Skip to main content
Loading video...

TDG: Cody's Top Ten Game Mechanisms (October 2025)

Transcript 20:38

Hello ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the discriminating gamer. You know there's a fine line between the numerator Hello ladies and gentlemen and welcome to the discriminating gamer. You know there's a fine line between the numerator and the denominator and only a fraction of people will understand that. Today we're going to go ahead and take a look at my top 10 game mechanisms of all time. All right, ladies and gentlemen. So, we're going to go ahead and take a look at my top 10 game mechanisms. What do I enjoy the most? What kinds of uh uh mechanisms do I like to play? I've been thinking about this a lot. What do I enjoy the most? one of my favorite kinds of actual mechanisms to have in games.

And I was surprised just how many me different kinds of mechanisms there are and how many I really enjoy. Now, I'm going to have one honorable mentionment, one honorable mention here. I should point out I'm going to not just say the me mechanism. I'm going to tell you a few examples of games that have these mechanisms. So, uh my honorable mention is tile placement. I enjoy placing tiles on boards. I think it's fun and interesting. Uh, some examples of games here. Downfall of Pompei, where you're putting the tiles down as lava to eat people up. Isisle of Sky, a great kind of Scottish game kind of where you're building farmland. Uh, to sorro, a great game where you're kind of building paths along the seas there in Japan. Great. And then, of course, the all-time great tile placement game, Carcassona. Uh, that's a really, really fun game set in kind of medieval France. Fun tile placement games. All right. Now, my top 10 game mechanisms of all time. Number 10 is push your luck. I really like games where you have an option where you've gotten something, you've gained something, and you can hold, or you can go further and and take some big risks.

Uh, heat is great, right? You know, when you're playing the cards, you've got to decide how am I going to take those corners? Am I going to make it? How am I going to play the cards to to to make that the best the best possible solution I can? or am I going to keep playing in order to try to move as fast and as far as I can? Uh, Clank Clank Catacombs. I love Clank Catacombs. You're going into these dungeons and you are trying to find um, you know, treasure and loot, but there's a point where you got to get out or you'll get stuck and you won't you won't win. Uh, I really like that one. Uh, sniper elite is another good one. You've got this bag building mechanic. you're taking shots at guys and you're pulling the tokens out of the bag to try in order to hit those guys.

That is a lot of fun. Uh pusher luck is just great because there's some real tension there and you know you're taking big chances, but there's some potentially some big rewards. So that is my number 10 pusher luck. My number nine is pick up and deliver. I really enjoy pick up a deliver games and particularly a lot of the Pick Up and Deliver games that are built around fun and interesting themes. Some of my favorite Firefly the Board game, of course, it's based on the TV show. You're going around the verse. You're picking stuff up. You're doing jobs. You've got to go from one planet to another. A lot of fun. And then along that same line, we've got Star Wars Outer Rim. Kind of the same idea, but you're the bounty hunters. or the scum and villain that's going around the galaxy in order to uh do these very special missions. That one is a lot of fun. Zia, another great space pickup and deliver game where again you're moving around the galaxy picking up and delivering. And Merchants and Marauders, this is a great pirate themed pickup and deliver game where you're moving around the Caribbean, but you're also kind of wary of uh going to war and becoming a a marauder and a pirate and being hunted down. But those are all great examples of pick up and deliver games that I really enjoy. So that is my number nine pick up and deliver. My number eight is a game is a mechanism that I recently did a whole top 10 list on and that is my top 10 hidden movement games. I love games with hidden movement. Sniper Elite again, you

know, you're you're one person is trying to avoid running into the Germans and you got chances to take out Germans as well. Um, letters from White Chapel. You're Jack the Ripper and you're moving around while everyone else is trying to locate where you are and arrest you. White Hall Mystery, which is also kind of the the smaller version of Letters from White Chapel. And then, of course, one of my all-time favorite games, Fury of Dracula. Fury of Dracula is great. One of the used Dracula. The hunters are trying to find him somewhere in Europe. They don't know where he is. He's trying to mature vampires and gain points. Tremendous fun. And of course, Captain Sonar, which is kind of a team battleship game where you're trying to hunt down the other side's submarine. Lot of fun. So, that is my number eight, Hidden Movement. My number seven is a game that is a game mechanic uh mechanism that I have always enjoyed since I played the first game I'm going to mention here, hidden trader games.

Battlestar Galactica, the board game, is so much fun. It was a cooperative game where one or more of you is working against everyone else. Now, this game had a terrific IP. In fact, I've said this before and I'll say it again. I have never played a board game that so perfectly captured the the feelings and the emotion of its IP. That TV show was all about paranoia. Who is the Sylon? Who is the Sylon? And the game does the same thing. You are asking those same questions. You're making those same accusations that you do in the TV show. I love it. um Unfathomable, which is kind of a riff on Battlestar Galactica, but it's set kind of in a in a pleasure cruise, a cruise ship in 1912, and you're fighting Cthulhu monsters, and then one of you is actually a hybrid that wants the Cthulhu monsters to win.

A great hidden hidden trader mechanic there. And then of course, Secret Hitler, almost more of a party game where um some of you are fascists, some of you are um liberals and you don't know who's who. And then you've got Hitler in there, too. And you're trying, the liberals are desperately trying to figure out who their enemies are just through this voting mechanism. And it is great, great fun. So that is number seven, the hidden trader mechanism. My number six is take that. I love games where you can play dirty tricks on people, where you can throw monkey wrenches into other people's plans. You can do this in Star Wars Rebellion. You've got the mission cards where you are trying to, you know, do different things to your opponent. Um, one of the cool things here is, you know, a rebel can send someone out and then the Empire can send someone to capture them and encase them in carbonite, right? Um, so there's a lot of fun things. the rebels can do these like like sneaky raids and try to blow up uh Imperial installations and stuff like that. There's a lot of fun missions that that act in a take that way in Star Wars Rebellion. Really enjoy that. Um the DC Comics deck building game also has take that. You've got attack cards where you can attack other players when you play them and they can potentially can defend themselves with defense, but very often they don't have it and they can gain weakness cards. They have to maybe discard cards. There's all sorts of fun and interesting things in the DC comics deck building games that allow you to

play Take That. Um, also too, ancient civilizations of the Middle East or the Inner Sea. Both of these games are they have this veneer facade of civilization building games, but the reality is they're take that games. You are constantly playing cards having natural disasters occur in one empire, playing a card to have, you know, a revolt, a revolution in another empire. This is a really fun game where you are constantly uh trying to take out your opponents there. Great, great fun. So that is uh my number six. Take that. My number five is area control or area majority games. Games where you are trying to have specific parts locked down for you and your faction in order to gain points, in order to gain victory. U one of my absolute favorite games, Cordier.

Cordier is just fantastic. Now, this is an older game. I don't believe it's in print anymore. And it's a great game where you are trying to um fulfill petitions for the queen and you're putting out cubes and you got to get the the majority of cubes in those areas in order to make it work for you. It is great fun. I really like that. And then kind of a game in the same series, Dominire. Here, you're actually trying to dominate the city of Tempest and you're putting cubes in various places and the different districts of the city. If you own them, you get different powers and that lets you do other fun and interesting things. You also create kind of a card tableau that helps you gain power over the different cities. Tremendous, tremendous fun. Of course, one of the great area control games of all time, Ele. This came out in the '9s. I just played it, I think, last year for the first time.

This is a great game where you're trying to control areas of Spain. Um, you've got a great kind of tower you're putting your cubes in and you don't know where the king's going to move each time. Uh, great game, great uh, area control and area scoring game. Really like El Grande. And of course, probably the best area control game of all time, Twilight Struggle. Such a good game about the Cold War. And again, you're playing these cards to try to give you points or give you events that will allow you to to take take hold of different locations on the board and to dominate those locations. Again, I don't think I've ever played a game that make that consistently makes you make the best of bad decisions like every turn. Really a lot of fun. So, that is my number five. Area control area majority.

My number four is worker placement. I love games that have elements of worker placement. if they're a straight worker placement game or there, as I say, there's just elements of it. But I really, really enjoy that. There's some really fun games. One of my favorites is a fairly recent game uh from a few years ago, but this is Dune Imperium or Dune Imperium Uprising. This combines kind of a deck building system with a worker placement in order to gain the resources that you need in order to fulfill victory and to put troops out on the board for combat. I really like how it meshes these two systems. really a super fun uh worker placement game. A War of Whispers is another fun game here. You're actually taking on the roles of secret societies, manipulating kingdoms on a board, and you place your uh your workers, your agents in these different locations that give you powers that allow you to manipulate the board to get the outcomes that you want. The problem is everybody else is doing the same thing. And you find these secret alliances and secret rivalries that you didn't know you had at the beginning of the game. they reveal themselves over the course, but it's done through a worker placement system. Very fun game.

And recently, we played uh Builders of Balders's Gate, which was very fun. And there's a worker placement element here where there are different locations on the board that you can go to and do different things. And it's very difficult to get your guy back once they're placed. You have to kind of do a lot of different things to get it back. But if any other player goes to the place where you're at, you automatically get your guy back. So there's that tension of do I really want to go there and he's going to get his guy back? Then he's otherwise he'd have to waste a turn to get it back. So anyway, really fun system there. So I really enjoy worker worker placement games. Tremendous amount of fun and that's why worker placement is my number four. My number three is deck building. I love deck building games and I love deck building when it's when it's married to other systems like I just mentioned in Dune Imperium. I thought that was, you know, such a tremendous game. I love the DC Comics deck building game. I love the Legendary system of games. Um, Clank, I really like its inte deck building integration into Clank. And I really like it. Uh, I really like the deck building integration in Undaunted Normandy and the Undaunted series.

That's a great tactical war game where you're actually getting your cards and you're using your cards in order to move and to attack with your various units. I'm still in the middle of the stalling campaign with my wife. I really want to get that one finished. Uh it's so much fun. I love deck building uh in Dantto Normandy. Probably probably now my favorite straight card deck building game is the G.I. Joe deck building game. Uh the GI Joe deck building is great. You're going on missions. You've got to your cards have to have Joe's descend on the missions, but then you also have uh equipment that you're going to bring along with you, gear, um and and all sorts of other things that are going to aid you in these missions because on these missions, you actually roll dice, and you're trying to get the very best.

You're trying to get the most number of dice you can get yourself in the most advantageous position for those dice rolls. Tremendous fun. I love love love deck building. It's it's one of the absolute best uh mechanisms we have in gaming today and I love it. So that is uh number three, deck building. My number two is very basic, but it's kind of something I cut my teeth on playing board games when I was a teenager. This is dice combat. I love games that have some form of dice combat and that do it well. I'm thinking to myself, first of all, Axis and Allies, right? Because Access and Allies has this great system where you've got so many different kinds of units, infantry, artillery, armor, aircraft, and depending on what that unit is, that's what you have to roll. If you have three infantry, you're going to roll three die, but they only hit at a one. But the infantry may defend at a two. So if you're defending, they hit at a two or a one, right? You tanks, you know, you're going with five tanks, you're going to roll five die.

they're gonna, you know, hit it a three or defend it a two or whatever it is for that particular iteration. Um, but I really like that just these big massive beautiful dice combat fests with uh Axis and Allies. I've always loved those. More recently, Battle of Hoth, which is also a riff on Memoir 44. In these games, these they're commands and color games. Essentially, you roll the dieice and if the target of your die, say infantry or tanks or artillery, um if if the symbol you roll matches that unit that you're targeting, then they're going to lose figures because you're going with a number of figures and they lose figures from that unit. Um it's tremendous fun. The Battle of Hoth takes it to the Star Wars universe. Memoir 44 is World War II, but there's a lot of other Commands and Colors games uh besides those that just do an excellent excellent job with dice combat. Again, more recently, Burning Banners, a game I played for the first time last year that's got a great dice combat system where you're you're rolling dice, but then if you get hits, you have to confirm it. So, you roll dice again to try to confirm those hits or at least I think it's I think it's a seven and eight is an automatic hit. I think it's a five and a six have to be confirmed.

But, it is just great. It's just excellent. I really, really love the dice combat system there as well. So, that is my number two, dice combat. All right, ladies and gentlemen, my number one favorite mechanism in games. I got to tell you, dice combat nearly took the top spot, but the more I thought about it, the more I thought I really, really like games that do this. And this is negotiation. I love to negotiate with people in games because whenever you negotiate, you know, I may get something from this, but I'm also helping somebody else get closer to victory. And am I getting a better end of this deal or are they? And that's something I always think about negotiation games. What are some of my favorite negotiation games? Moonrakers. Moonrakers is fantastic. Moonrakers is great. It's a deck building game.

Another great deck building game, but you've got to fulfill these contracts. And unfortunately for most of the contracts, you just aren't powerful to do it enough to do it by yourself. You don't have the cards to do it by yourself. So you have to get into an agreement with somebody else in order to do it. The problem is there are potential rewards. You have to decide who gets the re rewards. There's also risk and you have to decide who gets the risk. And you can totally make whatever deals you want to make over the course of the game. I absolutely absolutely absolutely loved Moonrakers as a negotiation game. Katan Katan is simple. Katan is a very fun, interesting gateway game. I just played a game of Katan the other night and I I had a ball and I love the negotiation in that game. It's the same thing. Do I want to trade with somebody if they're on the cusp of victory or closer to victory than I am, but I really need, you know, this this this wool or this wood or what have you? And so there's that tension there, which I really love.

Twilight Imperium. Twilight Imperium is a great negotiation game. It is a great negotiation game, you know, just from the point of view of, hey, don't attack me. Let's be friends and maybe we can we can work on something here. Hey, come on. why don't you you help me with that trade agreement and I can help you here with this problem. It's kind of a uh in a lot of ways it's kind of a less structured negotiation, but it's very fun and it's very in universe and it plays into one of the great strengths of the game which is Twilight Imperium has this wonderful roleplaying aspect to it and the negotiation really gets into the weeds with that. I love Twilight Imperium and the negotiation is a big big part of that. Um, and then also of course a Game of Thrones, the board game which is based on diplomacy.

Both of these games are awesome because no one is strong enough to win on their own. You have form alliances, but as soon as someone starts getting out in front looking like they're going to win, people are going to turn on them and break the alliances. Tremendous fun. Actually, diplomacy is the great friend losing game of all time. Tremendous fun. I always We played diplomacy a ton back in the day. All right, ladies and gentlemen, my number one game mechanism of all time, negotiation. Well, ladies and gentlemen, what do you think? What are your favorite all-time uh game mechanisms? What game mechanisms do you look for when you're looking into a game? What do you want to play? What do you find yourself favoring? I'm I'm very interested to know what your opinions are on game mechanisms because I just shared you shared with you mine. You can return the favor now. Please, please, please leave a comment here on YouTube, on Board Game Geek, on our Facebook page or on U uh X uh whatever it's called these days. Please, please, please uh like this video and subscribe to the channel if you haven't already. That really, really helps us out. And then also too, if you do like what we do on this channel, I would humbly ask you to click on my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where we talk about history, military history, books on history. I post some of my lectures on there. We have a lot of fun. It would mean the world to me if you would subscribe to that channel as well. And if you really do like what we do here on the discriminating gamer, I would humbly ask you to click on the super thanks button and leave a tip. My wife thinks it's

really weird that during rainstorms I just stare at the window. I think it would be less weird if she would just let me in. Please somebody help me on my feet again. And I don't know where I'm going. And I don't know where I've been. Please somebody help me on this ground. It's a long time and I'll be dying. Once a year I wind up in the van. I know that I love to fight, but I don't ever win. It's my life.

Go there.

And then once you're directed, you can go in. How am I going to get my planet back, though?

You're not.

Progress saved