Skip to main content
Loading video...

Most D&D campaigns end horribly. Here's how to avoid it.

Transcript 21:28

hey everybody this is me Lance mster Undead Viking here to have another conversation with you about an aspect of role playing that is well it's probably been spoken about to death it has been beaten to death so I'm going to go ahead and uh amble over to the dead horse and give it a couple of kicks myself so most campaigns role playing game campaigns they begin with a great idea they they begin with a lot of energy they begin with a goal and ultimately what happens is they die a long or sometimes abrupt boring end to attrition to boredom to people moving away to the inability to get uh people together at a specific times so on and so forth they do not begin a story have a middle and have an end it it it just doesn't happen and I think we accept that I think that when we go into any of our campaigns we really really want them to have something amazing to happen we want it to be that big long epic TV show or giant movie with three parts you whatever and especially and mostly I think on on the on the GM side of things we have a idea of what we want to do and and and in my opinion and this is maybe a video I could do at some point else um

the GM should not have that idea structured very well it should not be hammered into place it it it should be a piece of clay that maybe has a few indents into it as we begin the process but uh it will become more refined as time goes on um as the saying goes uh God loves it when we make plans and that's the same thing uh when we're talking about role playing games um I am lucky in the fact that I play with a group of people uh that I have known uh for most of my life I've known every single person that is in uh my well with the exception of one person who just recently joined but the vast majority of people that are in my D and group are people I've known longer than my wife uh and my wife and I have been together for nearly 20 years uh I met these people when I was in Middle School and I started playing D and D with them and I have continued on from that time we have played lots of campaigns and at the beginning we played them in a way that we just had no ultimate goal we had no uh uh where are we going with this type of situation we just started them rolled up our ad and D first first Char first level characters and somebody had a dungeon and we went into it we gained

experience and then we went on to the next dungeon we went on to the next dungeon and so forth and we just played and then things you know we didn't have a story we didn't have a you need to find the lost jewel of whatever you need to discover uh what happened to the ancient civilization of this you know nothing like that there was no this is the ultimate Evil and it has to be defeated because it's coming to destroy the world and and we just didn't do that and I think it wasn't until I don't know we were in our high school years where we started having um that idea there was one idea that was a complete McGuffin uh we had we started this campaign and um my friend Jason was running it and we had this uh call one of one of the members of our party had been asked to come home uh because his uncle the the baron of something or other uh had uh passed away and uh there was going to be the reading of the will and this Grand nephew of his that was one of our characters uh it wasn't me I don't I forget who it was uh was gifted um this chest this this huge chest that uh was just who knows what was in it we had no idea it was just this is yours and uh

the the contents within uh are for you and we tried everything we possibly could to open it um it was magically sealed we could we couldn't figure out how it was and so we started beginning this process of like we had heard tell of this magic item that can open anything and it's over there and so we began traveling uh and trying to discover what was in the chest um we never opened the chest uh we we played in that campaign for uh a couple of years and we never managed to open that chest it was always one thing that we couldn't get done there was always one aspect at one point it got stolen by demons and we had to go into hell uh to get it back um but along the way we never ever ever open that chest and and and it it was kind of like um the briefcase in Pulp Fiction uh before the briefcase in Pulp Fiction existed it was our malti Falcon let's put it that way and uh uh Jason has since admitted that he had no idea what was ever going to be in the chest it was just just it was just a thing it it was just it was like exactly that it was just a McGuffin it was a reason for us to travel it was a reason for us to go on adventures and that worked really well actually but ultimately it wasn't something that ever could have an end because we couldn't open it we couldn't discover what was in it we couldn't see what was going to happen um there was a really fantastic Adventure that my friend David ran that

when he gave us uh the map of this town that we started in um there was this one building in the town and everything else was specific this is the Smith um this is the tower you know this is the general goods store so on and so forth but then there was this one large building and it was kind of darkened in and it just said unknown and that was it and this was a uh a building that the doors were sealed to kind of like the chest and we couldn't get it open um uh and we always wonder was in that and once we achieved and there was this Sage this wizard that lived in the town that would give us quests and we'd go out and do those and we' come back and eventually we had gained enough levels that he said I think you're powerful enough now and he called upon everybody in the town and said we will finally open this ancient evil and we're going to go inside and we're going to defeat it and then uh we all grouped outside and the Mage wizard whatever Sage cast some big giant spell and something happened but none of the doors open and uh everybody went home dejectedly and that evening the sage called us to his Tower and he said in actuality he had opened it but the evil

that was so great he knew what the evil was it was so great that was within that if the people had gone in they would just have been slaughtered but he had been waiting for us to achieve the level that we were and to have the power that we had so we could go into that dungeon and and defeat this ancient evil and it was kind of lovecraftian and and what have you but eventually we went down into the dungeon and we defeated it and that was the end of the campaign I always liked that idea it was it was it was really well so go ahead and steal that if you want I I I really enjoyed that but that kind of set the bar at that point now ever since that and when we moved on uh to Second Edition and Third Edition and 3.5 and maybe the half a blip that we played forth and we played Pathfinder and and we played Mech Warrior and we've played uh traveler and we' played you know we've played tons of different role playing games uh we've always had a premise a campaign the beginning middle end and and and there was a set point that was ended and for the most part we've achieved that we've reached an end um some of those endings went well uh some of the endings we fail uh and and the world came to an end there's several that have have happened like that um and then some of them still just petered out they just didn't end and I don't know what the solution is to that I don't

know how to make make sure you have an amazing ending I do think that you have to do a few things um if you play for an extended period of time there are going to be marvelous villains that your players are going to hate um and as the game master you need to make sure that those villains are put in place so they can finally meet their Just Desserts and those Just Desserts need to come at the hands of the players and then as an addendum to that if there is a very very specific villain that a very very specific player despises for whatever reason you need to make sure that that person is the one that finishes that thing that that villain off couple of couple of uh stories I want to say about this there was a campaign we ran where I had this general of this Army of this of this of this Kingdom that was overrun and destroyed due to a you usurper and the and the the head general of that usurper was someone that my character hated hated him hated him because he was always just a little bit too powerful he was always just a little bit too big um and and I could never have a situation where

I was able to to to take him out I mean he was he was basically he was my commander when I was just a lowly sergeant in in in the Kingdom's Army and and he despised me and I despised him but I had to follow his orders and then he was a traitor uh to the kingdom that caused the kingdom and its downfall which which ended up with you know thousands of people dying and I swore Revenge um the final session of that campaign uh a very very structured very this has to be just these two people battling was between my my my character and this other General these two generals there was a battle going around all around us but these two generals met on the battlefield and I finally my character finally got his his revenge and and was able was able to finally you know plunge you know his giant axe uh into this this this this man's face and and and and his life it was a very satisfying very cathartic moment um another thing is that I had a campaign where uh same exact situation kind of two arch enemies battling left and right so on and so forth and the villain still died but the person that hated that villain to no end

did not get the final shot like their fighting and a an another player like uh shot an arrow at him or cast a magic Missile or something and actually knocked off the last few hit points and that is a situation where in my opinion yes the villain died but there was no cathartic release for that player and my opinion that thing oh I a magic Missile and I do 11 points of damage oh well the guy's got nine hit points as the GM in that situation you have to say wait he had 15 hit points and and then let the person that hates him uh do the final hit you know do things like that to to you know remember you can adjust those things you don't have to be that structured um give the player that needs what they need for that moment give them that moment um so that's the first thing I think if there's villains that that the players despise uh they need to have that happen if there is uh unresolved Mysteries they need to be solved at that moment if there are unresolved um like good aligned or whatever aligned NPCs that are on your side they need to be a part of that and those stories need to come come together as well at the end whether it is like familial stories um stories between lovers you know things like that you need to have all those

those loose ends tie up and can it be a little hack KN at the end to like get everything all together in one spot and and and get it done at the same time sure but the campaign's over you need to get those things done so I think between that the story lines of the players having a good summation and also like the Mysteries being solved and the the mysteries of the NPCs being solved I think those are the things that you need to take care of uh to make make it make it worthwhile to make people excited about but I just finished a campaign this past weekend uh as a player and now I get to go on and start my own campaign here probably in March and I when this campaign started it was a little over two years ago I started this guy um you probably can't read it real well my my chicken scratches of a handwriting this is Odin forgehammer um he this is and again this is Ed and D so like if those stats and stuff that you just saw don't make sense don't worry this is the version that we make ourselves and we've been playing ourselves and this is like probably like the 12th version of these rules um but this was Odin Odin forgehammer um he started off as uh uh the last remaining uh dwarf of Clan for ch um the rest had been put to the sword by the evil empire and he and the other

compatriots we all hated the Empire and we worked against um the the the Empire trying to bring their end we actually called our adventuring party Empire's end and and we we worked against it uh and try and and rallied against it had some other sub quests and other sub villains that we ran into but in the end we raised an army uh that Army went and attacked the last Bastion of power that the Empire had much like the Death Star and the emperor inside and we uh snuck in while the while a battle raged outside We snuck in through an old Smugglers uh uh tunnel uh that we discovered got into the palace had a ton of successive battles where all of the evil people that we hated the entire campaign um you know were kind enough to be present so we we could we could put the swords to them and then eventually met the emperor in his throne room by himself and we fought three massively powerful um like creations of his like you know that uh that had multiple different powers um we we had a huge battle and then uh we defeated him and then we and then we we left and we thought that was going to be the kind of the

ending however we had uh made a PCT with well actually I should say somebody that we worked with had made a PCT with some tribes of Orcs that we didn't really like but they they fought in the battle with us um we didn't like them because of some of their things that they did as far as um uh being uh slavers uh they they also um had some other aspects as far as uh they had claimed certain like you know territories when we told them they couldn't and basically we didn't have an army to remove them or whatever but then I remember as we left we were all like oh that's it and we kind of came out and we had the head of the emperor and the the the head orc of these tribes this this this uh orc King by the name of usar um basically came out and said we've done it we've slayed it but then goated and Odin my character despised usra car uh to to just despised him his clan forgehammer had fought his or his orc tribe of the North many times it was a tenuous Alliance and usar in being played by by the game master uh you know poked and poked and poked and poked until finally Odin had no had no he's and he just

called to his Dwarven Army you know death to the Orcs and uh and and uzer car uh and and and Odin met on the battlefield and and Odin uh it came close uh but um there was you know there was other people that the other players had to take care of but Odin was able to uh slam his Warhammer uh into oar's face uh and and defeat him and uh and it was it made for the perfect like ending after the ending of The Campaign it was really epic and it was really fun and uh I congratulate my my fellow players in my group and I also congratulate Craig uh as the person who is running the campaign uh to make that happen most campaigns don't end that way they don't get set up that way um it is something that really I mean you can read books on you can watch videos like this on it um but uh it is it's a difficult thing to pull off and ultimately it's one of those things where you're only going to really get it if one you kind of pull the strings you behind behind behind the curtains to make it happen and two just through practice just through play um to to so you get to that point and trust me my campaigns don't always end really well um you know it's almost like kind of a relief in a few of my campaigns where like the entire party was just killed off and well that was that you know no

nothing I can do now you know and it was like so you just had to you know let the dice fall where they may kind of thing but work at it make it you know you've you if you're watching this video I'm going to guess that you've seen tons of movies you've read tons of books you've read lots of graphic novels tons of TV shows you've seen good endings and Bad Endings learn from those and just do what you can to know what your players want so you can give them what they want and you can also have an epic ending to your campaign so there you go uh thanks for letting me talk about this this was just like something that popped into my brain since the campaign ended this last weekend uh if you have campaigns that ended really horribly I'd love to hear hear those stories if you have campaigns that ended epically I want to hear those if you have a campaign that ended eh I'd love to hear that as well so leave those in the comments I try to respond to every single one um thank you for the time to took you to watch this video uh hit the old like subscribe Bell whatever it is that you do I'd really appreciate that if you would and until next time uh this is me Undead Viking telling you to have yourself a great day all right byebye

Progress saved