Flamecraft - Board Game Review - All Staff Know Dracarys
Transcript
thank you hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences we'll get on with the show in just a minute but first a quick word for my sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kiander.co.uk kiander stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on audra's over 30 pound further discounts on bulk purchases and even five percent of your spending refunded bacteria's points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get five percent discount on your first order over 60 pounds so let's make gaps in your collection a thing of the past get down to kinder and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it so today I'm taking a look at flame grab the cutie little dragony game from cardboarding Academy and Lucky Duck games for family weight question mark wanna order but it's a worker placement game effectively where you grab your you have all these different shops that give you various resources like potions food diamonds and bread Etc and what you're doing is you go onto a shop with your dragon piece and you're playing Dragons you've got these different Little cutesy Dragons and more on your artwork and that later but you'll play Like Flint or uh fondue or loaf or patina or Bob yeah there are some weird discrepancies with these uh dragon names in here but essentially when you go to these shops you're
Gathering resources and you're placing dragons in order to trigger their abilities and get more rewards what you're essentially aiming to do is of course have the most victory points of course but you do the bulk of that by enchanting the various stores so you have to go and get the resources and Trigger the dragon effects but then what you'll have is a bunch of Enchantment cards which is essentially gather the Resources pay the cost and put enchantment on the shop which essentially makes it more lucrative in the future but that's essentially the gist of the game you have these shops as you fill each shop more shops come out and then you'll draw more dragons and you'll put layers out gather more resources do more enchantments and you'll be able to score a few extra points by gathering fancy dragons although I mean they look kind of similar to the normal Dragons I'm not quite sure why they're fancy and some of these may be great little scoring opportunities during the game and some will be in-game scoring opportunities but you just keep going on until the dragon deck or the enchantment deck Runs Out play another turn each and there you go count at the victory points and see who wins jakaris so we've started off with a pretty simplistic overview because that's one of the plus points of this game it is very very simple you know the rule book may look big but honestly a lot of that is Big Font some of it is just the appendices where it's talking about solo mode and different like FAQ characteristics but the actual rules themselves are in big text with a lot of picture representation and you know there you go set up and you're done and this is mainly just a component thing
there's not that many pages in here this is an easy game to pick up and play you could take this to a game Cafe and it wouldn't take long for people to get going the only slight negative on it is that I did mention about appendices at the back there are a few occasions I've played with some of these Dragon abilities and some of the combinations with them in the shops where you do need to go to the back of the book and just go right on now on Earth the spell fire Springs work with that then and then you read it and it usually 99 of the time has actually given me the answer I need it so it's a good comprehensive set of rules very easy to read I didn't find any glaring errors in it but yeah this is a nice straightforward game to learn to play it it's also relatively straightforward although where it says family weight I might be underestimating kids intelligence here but no no no me not you guys yeah maybe a little more than yeah I'm gonna flummoxed kids of it kids are gonna go oh look Little Dragons and yeah I get the red dragon and the Gold Dragon and look like a little uh Suzette Dragon little cutie and it certainly has the aesthetic appeal to appeal to kids but you've got dragons that bounce around all over the place and swap with other dragons and then gain multiple goods and then the enchantments require you to put them on specific shops and some of the shops have got special abilities and you've got companion abilities which are once per game things that you can trigger there's a fair amount going on in this game I mean more so than something like say takinoko you know so where people sort of go oh that's not particularly Gateway gamish well this certainly ain't Gateway game
this is a light game but I feel like kids might just take a game or two to get used to how some of these effects work but for the most part they should get into it eventually but yeah I mean non-gamers should be able to pick this up with relative ease and you know Gamers yeah not a problem I mean you can learn this in about five minutes and get started playing if you're used to this kind of thing component wise well uh you've seen all the cards you've seen all those but haven't got the PS to resistance yet wow okay um I mean I can practically wear this like a scarf I did it in the um unboxing video but yeah this is a play mat neoprene playmat of where you put the shops and the various cards and the score track gotta give props for production quality to give you something like this in there although if being long like this does make it a little bit interesting to find a table space for it also the stitching on here is kind of weird because on one side I can see the full shot picture but then on the other side the shop pictures are cut in half if you look in the rule book if it was a board it would have the full bit of the shop on there but on one side it just feels like the roofs have been locked off so I think I don't know if that was an error in this printing but curious to see if anybody else has had that issue and it is a little bit weird when you look at it also the font choice is kind of odd on here these these scores some of these numbers look very similar to each other so when you're counting up your victory points you're easily gonna mistake sixes for eights and the nines and it's just gonna be a little bit harder to read at a glance but all in all I can say it's
nice to get a neoprene mat in a game as a retail copy the artwork is beautiful artwork by Sandra tang and it's gorgeous it's a really nice cutesy artwork color full the dragon designs are all nice I mean it's you know if you've got some people that like My Little Pony fans or like that sort of Animation or whatever you've got lots of cool little nice like just things to make you go oh very good artwork especially on the shops I mean these shops are telling a story in every portrait so you know I play with a couple of friends who are like major sort of geek out girls when it comes to like cutesy artwork and it's like uh are you gonna take your turn third sorry she's too busy like staring at the cards and you know you got to admit they're very nice they're all unique there's a lot of them there's a decent amount of shops in here and you don't use them all every games you get a good amount of variety but the artwork Stella really like it where the game falls on components though is I think the kickstarter syndrome yes Kickstarter allows you to get three different upgrades to this game metal coins Miniatures and wooden tokens you can tell I think that hmm I feel like you could have put some of those in the game already some of them are completely unnecessary but a couple of them I think should have been mandatory from the get-go so first of all the miniature dragons each of these cost what like I think it was like about 50 odd Euro 40
50 odd Euro Essen to buy flamecraft retail and then it was about 20 something Euro a piece to buy each of the free upgrades so the deluxe version cost you about 90 to 100 euro depending on the offer at that time so 100 euro for this game that's asking a lot value-wise but the dragons you can he gets cool little wooden meeples with dragons and they're cool they've got like little designs on them in that and it's like yeah these are perfectly fine I don't need unpainted Miniatures to replace these for 20 odd pounds right especially when there's only six of them you know I'm perfectly happy with that don't worry about that the metal coins I mean yeah the coins in here are well cardboard garbage frankly they're not particularly interesting I I would substitute clay chips for these I've got the uh these Sinister Amazon but that's a sinister six but you know the cinder to the fish coin chest that I can use these coins are pretty basic and Blair but honestly you don't have that many coins in the game I mean if you're lucky you'll get about what five or six by the time the game ends so the fact that you're using cardboard coins is not a big deal to get up to spend money to get a pouch with metal coins in it there's enough ways to substitute the only upgrade I would definitely be tempted to get and that's only because I think these chits are kind of garbage is the wooden token resources because you get a lot of those resources and you do use a lot of them in the game there's multiple resources I mean there's six different types here but in the retail box all you get is this tiny little cardboard chip I feel like I'm gonna break this damn thing pretty thin pretty basic Design Graphic
artwork it's yeah this could have been a lot more interesting and I don't see why you couldn't have put the wooden tokens in the Box normally I mean honestly if you had these wooden meeples and you know some slightly you know some wooden coins maybe and these tokens were wooden they don't have to be huge make them this small but make them wooden or thicker cardboard at least then I'd be singing the Praises like 10 out of 10 for component quality in this game but as it is I'm not a fan of this cardboard here I find there's a chintzy and a little bit layer but I like these wooden meeples and the artwork is really good and the cardstock is a little on the flimsy side you might want to sleeve these because you are going to be doing a lot of uh playing and tucking and stuff like that so you might want to get yourself some mini Euro sleeve cards I think it's mini Euros that will fit these but just don't quite go find out on BGG but yeah I'd suggest maybe getting some sleeves so there's some aspects of component quality that are pretty stellar and some that aren't quite up to speed the Box quote one to five players 60 minutes it's gonna take you a bit longer than 60 minutes with a teach and five players and honestly five doesn't kill the game but I think it outstays its welcome by the time you get to the upper end of four players and certainly five players yeah five just feels like they just bowling it onto the box like with every other game in existence to make it sell more honestly just find another game if you're gonna do five players but that being said you played this with solo two free players this game is going to go in speedy speedy speedy fashion and four is not the longest game ever either it certainly has a bit of a good a game Arc as well because you start off with a few
starter shops you know some really basic ones that don't even have abilities but then eventually you're putting out all sorts of dragons on these various shops and some of them are bouncing around all over the place they're triggering multiple effects and you can come up with some fairly janky turns at times particularly if if you're using the companion cards as an optional variant where you've got a once per game ability that's pretty powerful do not do what we did in our first game of this where we decided to um read that rule wrong because most of the time you get these abilities you assume that they're once per turn once per round or once every now and again like you exhaust it in that oh dear we decided that this was not once per game we decided this was basically once per turn stop it you're so stupid whoops this created the most janky broken game of flamecraft you could possibly play once per game get that rule right but other than that like I say I'm not factoring that in as a deal breaker that was our fault or possibly my fault because I read the rules like that but the game goes along at a fairly Speedy pace and the rules being fairly straightforward and the graphic design being relatively straightforward other than the fonts used in certain places means that the game goes at a quick pace and you don't feel like you're waiting too long but again four players and definitely five I feel that you're kind of the downtime might just be a bit too long because it's difficult to necessarily plan out your whole turn particularly if you're after certain dragons because all it takes is for somebody to put a dragon on the spot you wanted or somebody to use
the purple dragon and start bouncing them around to completely mess up your turn the enchantment cards you know they're all pretty generic they just get you points or various awards for playing them but there's a bit of a luck element to the game where the enchantments will come out on the mat and they'll basically you know be available but you just might have that situation where you're one short of a particular ingredient but somebody else just conveniently has it in front of them and by turn order they just happen to get it before you it's you know this is definitely not a game you're playing to play like skillfully or like a proper strategic hero this is pretty much a tactical you know fun Charming little game that's pretty light it's gonna have a decent amount of luck but not so much luck that it's just roll the die and see what happens you do make choices in the game and they do matter the game filters a little bit in its variety though I like the fact that there's a lot of shops and there certainly is a lot of shops this variety isn't a problem you have a few starter shops but you'll get maybe another six or seven out to forget the exact number and you know there's a lot of different shops to have so that's all well and good but the dragon types are a little bit kind of stoic yeah they are the color is what ability it has there's no other variation with them and some dragons are definitely more useful than others the bulk of your points in this game are going to come from enchantments that's just the way it is so you're going to be needing Goods in order to facilitate these so naturally the two dragons that give you Goods which are these two so two of one good or three different these ones are really
good to have and most of the time these are the ones that are being triggered the one that allows you to give a good away for two points it's nice if you've got spares but other than that it's essentially just two points every now and again this doesn't get triggered very much I mean I try to trigger it a fair amount but then I'm just hurting myself the more I gift the purple one gets triggered way too much of this comes out involved because basically it gets triggered so that it can bring back the dragons that give you Goods so basically these three might as well be identical this literally might as well just be a clone of these two for how it gets used the two though that basically revolve around Dragon cards the yellow one drawing cards and the red one placing them these feel a little underpowered compared to the other ones these don't get triggered anywhere near as often as others because if you're playing this Dragon to draw a dragon you're just rinsing and repeating itself I've just played this so that I can draw another Dragon well then why don't I just find another way to draw a dragon or why don't I just get some goods and do an enchantment which has a reward of ghetto Dragon so I might as well just do that instead and the red one place a dragon in town that's good if you have a hand of a ton of dragons but if you don't that's not exactly a massive deal and frankly placing a dragon just gets you a little cheaper reward every now and again like maybe a point or two or a coin or you know a good it's not exactly a massive deal to place the dragon down it's better to trigger the dragon abilities that's what is more good for and some of the shops I mean some of the
shops are fine but there's a few that I just find a little bit like a little too powerful I mean you know fire a dragon from your hand and then gift it to a player for Five Points that's pretty powerful to get five points on there these ones which let you get to you know you gift Goods to other players for points again goods are good to have and keep uh gaining Goods is always going to be a better one than that but there's one in here I can't seem to find it at the moment oh here we go yeah the dragon alley and leave two coins to gain rewards which are pretty sizable rewards I mean two dragons two a fancy dragon and two points or five points you know that's pretty good oh and visit another shop so you lose two points but you gain you know some decent Awards or five points on top so you're gaining three but then you get to go to another shop and do basically another turn this is a pretty popular place to visit but then you just get a few that don't get visited very much and so I feel like maybe the balance is a little bit off with some of them but again it's not a deal breaker for the game it's just one of those niggles I found mainly I don't like it for the fact that these two dragons just seem kind of weak like these are definitely bottom tier dragons the green one's kind of mid-tier and then these three are like triggering all the time everybody wants Goods because everybody wants enchantments you know enchantments are the way to get points frankly you know you might get a particular setup with shots that gives you points for some other weird you know contrived way of doing it but that's going to be few and far between you really do need to get these the fancy dragons are a nice way of scoring points
as well but it's luck of the draw you get to start off with one but then when you draw them during a game you might get a fancy dragon that doesn't score for you in the right way at all or you know anyway okay if I can get one that says get me a bunch of points if I have the most food that's an easy one to achieve but then you get the ones where it's like have unique dragons in hand and uh you know pay a ton of goods to get some points uh what else you got to gain points for every starter Dragon that's not on yeah for every shop that doesn't have its starter Dragon on it that takes a lot more effort than just simply have the most food yeah so it's again luck of the drawers to whether you actually earn decent amount of points from these but if you can draw a bunch of them it's definitely one way to go and very quickly the touch on the solo mode in the game the solo mode is basically the same as multiplayer there's a couple of pages in the book with some challenges and all the two you know to get various unlocks your views are very specified set of shops and Dragons to begin with and then you can unlock more but it plays out pretty much like the multiplayer you have your turn you flip a dragon off the deck and see where it goes you go clockwise round put it somewhere it can go and then if you've got one of two other markers of the same color it goes on the shop and much like in the multiplayer game when you go to a shop you gift a good to another player if they're there so the solo mode is basically just multiplayer with one to minor changes on the steps other than that though it is a way to play flamecraft in about 30 to 40 minutes because it is pretty quick when you're doing it so honestly the solo mode works with the caveat I think the
scoring is a bit broken and the scoring in this is insane you know it wants you to get 75 points before you can even get an achievement and that's assuming you meet the achievement so that's just to qualify to even check that you get the achievement and even below it is shopkeeper 75 to 89 is flame keeper 90 plus is master of flame we only barely got that high in scoring when we played the broken version of the game with the companion abilities okay and you don't use companions in the solo mode broken or otherwise so I don't know how you're supposed to get 75 points in this game but believe me it's nothing that happens very often so these achievements are not easy to attain and I don't want to have to keep playing this game over and over and over again to find some fluky situation where I just happen to get 75 points because a lot of it is going to come down to what shops come out and whether these things get in your way and you know what fancy dragons you draw there is a decent amount of luck in the game so to have a really tough point total to achieve kind of goes against it really and makes it not that enjoyable if you know it's going to be a massive uphill struggle You Know Nothing Jon Snow so flamecraft is charming it's a Charming light game there's not a huge amount wrong with it I mean a couple of things I think were you know probably should be balanced a little bit better it will serve as kids fine once they've had a game or two to get used to some of the Dragon abilities in there but Gamers will be able to pick it up easily it's a good rule book it's very easy to follow easy to teach the artwork is beautiful
the components could be better though I don't like these tiny little like cardboard chits and horror money as an excuse to basically say buy our Deluxe upgrades the game itself I think is worth it for 40 euros or 40 pound or whatever the retail price might be I think for that kind of money you're getting a very good package for that but for a hundred Euro no way no way would I tell anybody to go buy this for a hundred pound with all the deluxe upgrades I mean that is too much money for a game that is like a 60 Minute light you know fairly lucky Affairs like no no no you do not need the Miniatures you do not need the metal coins just substitute your own coins like everybody can do these days and potentially if you must have an upgrade get the upgraded tokens because to be honest if I hang on to this game I'm probably gonna get those wooden tokens because I don't want to play with these horrible little cardboard chits all the time that many wooden tokens would actually bling this game out quite nice a bit I can forgive the weird artwork sort of misalignment on the map that's not a massive deal it doesn't break my game but everything else in here is pretty good the rule book and reference AIDS and that it's a decent well packaged Charming game just not something that blows my mind a lot of people are talking very highly of it going like oh this is one of the best of the year and I was like yes this was totally worth the hundred bucks I paid for it not sure I mean don't quote me if that hundred bucks isn't right I feel it would have cost you 100 euro s and maybe you got it on Game Fan for cheaper but then you got Factor shipping in that's another thing you know I don't think the
game is worth a hundred Euro no way but it is worth 40. I think 40 would have been a good price for this if you buy this just retail and you don't care too much about the component front I think it's a good solid package not not one that blows my mind but one that's good and I can recommend I'm giving it a 7 out of 10. it's good not great I don't think it's a mind-blowing but it's got enough charm to it enough good quality to it and you know enough uh appeal for a lot of Gamers both you know both light and heavy Gamers that they will get something out of this so 7 out of ten good give it a try but just don't maybe not Splash out too much money on it if you can help it so that's it for me on this episode of the broken meatball I'm Luke Hector and if you like what you see then I'd love you to do a few things for me thumb it up on YouTube as well as Board Game Geek when you see the post on there means a great deal for the algorithm but also consider subscribing to the channel but get your comments down below what do you think of flamecraft is this a game that you love did you spend all that money on the deluxe improvements was it worth it you know is this one that your kids are easily doing perhaps I've underestimated kids intelligence or are you like heavy Gamers and you like this for its charm and its feel I'd certainly like to know your thoughts until next time you can check out more content on the channel including the review I did for Starship captains and also the review I did for lacrimosa take care and remember as always regardless of which Dragon you wanted your personal little bit they're so cute it's still only a game bye for now jakaris