Skip to main content
Loading video...

Detective: Season One - Discussion

Transcript 27:10

viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for detective of modern crime board games season one uh so with that tagline season one i'm very much hoping that they do more seasons right i love this game it is so much fun um like just the the in-depth writing the atmosphere that they give for each of the cases um like yeah you definitely go check out our discussion for whenever we did detective monochrome board game the first time but here we're going to be talking about season one so cat what did you think i really liked it i thought it was really enjoyable um i i i actually can't really remember what the first one was about now that i'm thinking about it it was about yep you're right because we just because i really actually liked the last two uh natural causes that one was about the yep that did not i had not opened up anything about that uh wow oh yeah the the the professor that's right yeah that one was okay uh yeah the other two really liked um stories were good um the clues could be better sometimes um yeah in how we get to them but i mean all in all it's it's just a lot of fun right i

think with it i think it's just these games in general they don't there's never a point where it's like definitive on like okay yes now we know you know who it is or what the weapon was i know um it's always our speculation and there's times at the end of the case when they do like the epilogue thing where it's like where it tells you the the story and you know it gives you the whole rundown and then you're like oh okay yeah now it's so obvious but throughout the game you're you always have an air of like uh i don't really know um because we don't we because you'll know how how in-depth the writers wanted to go right like and there might be some spoilers for the record of of this but uh before we get those in a nutshell this season one was fantastic yeah uh like cat said the first one was okay was was pretty good um but yeah the the second case and the third case were were extremely solid yeah second case is my favorite yeah uh i was actually going to ask which case was your favorite and i i would agree i think the second case was mine because it was just so different from the the the other ones yeah yeah uh but but yeah so season one was fantastic i really hope that they just continue to support this game over and over and over and it sounds like they are this is one of their high tier games where uh they're doing like a what they call it like a signature series where they have a specific person to write a case

and they've done one of those where they had rob davio who was one of the guys behind um i want to say pandemic legacy okay and things so he did one case so they're doing more and there's no another one coming out next year very cool that's the best thing about crime is that you can just do it over and over and over and over right but yeah so because there's a lot of crime out there and and there's a lot of stories you can make but yeah that's what i was saying it's like you never know how in depth they want to get so for like the third one where they uh or it was about the mafias the two mafia yeah really with you know jimmy and then troco yeah and it was like we were sitting there and we're like man okay all the cards are so many cards that are saying you that are proving that jimmy is innocent so this is where the spoilers i guess are coming in kind of and it's like you don't know if the writer really wants it to go one way and it's like oh oh okay so like it's going to make it seem like that it was it was jimmy's group and all the cards are saying that he's innocent so then you want to believe that he's innocent but then it's a hook and it's actually really them planning right so you don't know you don't never really know how the writing is going to be if it's going to go that in-depth or if you're going to be like oh okay well like how i said with the the the the wine i was like well was there a lipstick on one of them are they gonna call that like are they gonna are they gonna assume that she wears lipstick is it accurate to her picture like obviously she's wearing makeup yeah so you know is that gonna be something that they're like oh and it's an imprint of uh right and usually they will say stuff like that um and don't get me wrong these these

games are very in-depth especially with the ontario system where you get fingerprints you you probably if there was lipstick that probably would have been mentioned right um and it's like oh okay but then we we have the timing and so you do have to take a lot of things into account especially in one of these cases it mentioned you know the height and the build of someone yeah and you have to remember that stuff and mention the timing of a package and then the timing of the the murder and you have to take that stuff into account yeah where other games like sherlock holmes for example you don't yeah like not really but here you you very much and these games are so brain burning they definitely can be when they're like when they're like the very first one where you really have to have to pay attention with that one um yeah unfortunately i think the problem with the first one is we just took it in a totally different direction right just so completely left field right and then that's the other thing that with these games is they have so many different leads that you're like well which one should we go to you know for a fact especially with the truck the travel time yeah you have to be like okay well we have 24 hours but really it depends on how many times we're moving and luckily like the final case where you do have all the time 24 hours you're really in two locations you were in the field and then police station so you actually were able to manage and get a lot of cards uh where uh otherwise where it's like oh no we need to go to the campus into the headquarters into the police station and go back and forth

and your 24 hours is actually really 10. and then even then it's like okay well let's look at this card oh that took three hours so now you really only have seven hours yeah they didn't do that here which was really good yeah like you only went back and forth so as you're playing you do have to take in time of your time management okay we have five leads we can do at in the field so let's spend the one hour go to the field and then do all these five you know and it's just you do this as a team to decide what does each person think is really the most like efficient way to actually play this game yeah um whether you're gonna say something i am um but i want to go back because i didn't get to say it because you went off on the time tangent um no the time is really important but i was just going to say how this game is really good at mimicking real life because um like how with the first one we uh kind of just went off on just a completely different direction that we went to but that happens in real life all the time where the cops see a lead right they misinterpret it and so they're chasing you know one thing when they should really be chasing the other and by the time that they do it's like oh well this guy got away with murder because sure because we thought it had something to do with whatever yeah because we went off way off on like gambling and then stuff like that and then we come to the final like questionnaire and then it's like one of the suspects we were like there's no way yeah we were like nope yeah because we we have we found someone we're like no

because these games always include like uh additional questions and things where it's like okay so that might not be part of the case but that might be extra points right and i really think that this game does a fantastic job about like whether the case is solved or failed uh and i love that because in sherlock it's based or meet those tales it's based off a score okay answer all these questions you get a score of zero to a hundred here it's like for for example uh the um the third one the last one we did yeah it was like we we solved it but we got six out of twelve points you know and the points are kind of more of just a status because we didn't see how well you did right but in sherlock holmes it's like okay here's five of the main questions but there's five additional ones that are really have nothing to do with the main case where you can hopefully scour they're your bonus points yeah uh and i think that this game kind of does away with that because the additional questions in here do pertain to the actual case yeah and i like that i really think that the red hair there aren't really any red herrings right uh whereas there are red herrings in the in the written ones so i would say that only red like the real heavy red herrings was in the um again spoilers is in the second game because oh you're right literally everyone and that one was very much a movie style it was a hoodie because everyone it's like oh they all could have everyone yeah everyone has a motive and that was that one was an interesting one because we

like had all this evidence like i took notes of the family you took notes of the guests and suspects so we both split like you know divide and conquer and then we go to the question and then i was like okay who do we think did it all right this person it's like oh you solved it yeah we were like oh i expected there would be like way more questions but nope it was just one person and that one had a very did such a good job with the like the the who done it feeling the theme the the the suspects um the atmosphere yeah the most the motives and then like you were like oh man like i don't know everyone seems to have a problem but this one seems to make the most sense based off of just information that wasn't directly told there's never a point here where it says on the bulletin like hey this person is really strong or something like for you to take note of you you it's all gossip it's all here yeah it's and that's why i wanted to talk to you know the staff first because it's like they're gonna spill the [ __ ] like they're absolutely gonna and the staff didn't tell us anything i know right i was like it's all fame like it's like man this family [ __ ] it wound up being family drama but like everyone had something to say at one point you little bigger yeah they had personalities yes and you're like i [ __ ] loved talking to him last because his was just such like uh yeah you're and then you you read into more about like the dad and you're like manny i'm glad you died in peace i would have killed you too so i think i think the and you probably agree with me in terms of the three cases it'd be favorite two then three

than one i do agree with that yeah yep yep even though three was really good it was still really good um because it you you had the atmosphere of the italian mob and then trying to go and then you were like oh yeah how could i not they were constantly throwing out words like bambino right and and grazie and and mountain uh me and more but yeah and so you with the third one you just had that back and forth and i think actually the third one probably had the most aha like yeah whenever especially whenever we got to like the very end where we i talked to one person at the very last minute and then we talked to and did one more final dive and it was like oh okay so that that confirms it and i think that that that error of like well i don't really know uh it is there but with all the cases they're written out so well that i think it over time if you're playing well of course and you and you take the time to really study that that gets alleviated throughout the game because at the end we were pretty much like yes this is the person who did it like uh which i i absolutely love the natural causes one the very first one it's i think if that was a regular case in the base game it would have been fine but it was so overshadowed by how well the the second the last two were yeah

yeah because we're sitting here in the and we're taught raven about this case two in case three yeah and we're like what the [ __ ] i and we forgot and there's always case one about oh was it okay so a guy would died and how yeah and yeah it just didn't didn't hold on to that like oh this was a really good story it almost felt like a filler yeah right uh but i very much enjoyed that there were three of them uh i think that their use of these these tokens was nice because in the base game you have different types of tokens and i just feel like that that's a little convoluted for this kind of game because it's like oh to do this we have to have this token and to do this we have this token whereas just in here you just had these yeah and these let you do more and i just like the simplicity of these instead of the different tokens yeah and getting uh getting like those yellow ones in the third game for example i feel like we would not have gotten those if we interrogated jimmy because i was like no i don't think that's and you agreed like i don't think that's necessary like we don't need to play hardball with him because we don't think he did it like we just did not think he did so he was probably able to actually give us favor right and be like okay yeah i know that you're not like you don't think i did it so i'm going to do you a cell yeah clear my name right and i mean those those yellow tokens were really cool because they actually represented kind of choices that you have

um where it's like okay if we get to if we do this then we'll have we might have access to something else later otherwise that would move them into this new dialogue and i well it did and i thought that that was really cool versus just constantly relying on these it was an extra like ooh okay well let's get this it was a reward for doing certain things now what sees what this doesn't do it doesn't utilize the website as much and i know you don't mess with the website um yeah but here you essentially like it didn't it didn't do the questioning everything everything's card based and i understand that this is basically kind of like an intro to detective because i think the detective ones are way more in depth these were still very heavy but you feel and it gives you that satisfaction at the end which is great but the ones in the base game you have to use the internet you have to look up [ __ ] that you don't know anything about like the very first one which i'm not going to spoil anything for that but you're allowed to use your cell phone yeah you're allowed to use your cell phone uh you do have the questioning uh then you do have to actually match fingerprints and and dna and gather stuff uh here you you do put that stuff in but it's more of like a like i said an intro like oh hey here's kind of what you can do but there was never unless we missed it completely but there was never really any matching where it's like oh boom okay we found the gun and the bullet and you know putting the match in and they match and it tells us who has it there's none of that uh but i think this

does a pretty good job of kind of leading you into the base game i think that you could play this and you only you actually only need this which is great you can just buy this box by itself and then just be like okay now i'm going to now i understand how the game is going to work so now i can go play the bass game yeah um let's see one complaint that i have and it's mainly with it's kind of with all of them except sherlock funny enough is the and i understand it's thematic but because these games and i mentioned this actually in the meet those tales discussion because mythos tales has a timer just like this expect me to solve the case well it's not so much that it's the fact that since these are one time play if you are like we did on the very first one if you're going left when they want you to go right and you you run out of time and you're technically supposed to do the final report yeah you didn't really get to experience the story right and i think that was our problem with the first one is we didn't really get to experience the story too much because we ran out of time and it's like okay uh because moving locations cost time you don't know how long you know okay we're going to go to the police station to search the evidence room oh that took six hours right you know and i get i very much get that that's thematic and that does give you an error of like we need to really make

good decisions here but in terms of the meta owning the game it's it could be it could be a little upsetting whenever you're like man we didn't get any of that right all right i guess we'll learn the story and just read the epilogue right and especially when it's like [ __ ] we wouldn't have gotten that no matter what like that's such like to us it's a left field because we thought we were on the right track right and then to be like okay so we were supposed to put together that he was an art connoisseur oh so that means he's the art thief right right oh okay so that means that this person was blackmailing this person because of that i don't make those to me that's a kind of a leap that's something that you would see in like a tv show yeah and um i definitely do not uh think that way so yeah so i i think that i'm more the who done it kind of right or the uh i think it's really it comes down to the writer that makes you not feel that way i think the first one the first uh uh case was i don't i don't think it was badly written i just think that it didn't point you in the right direction as much to make you feel satisfied at the end uh whereas the second one and the third one very much did and i don't know if they're the same writer i i mean this book actually has some inside depth on honestly if i wrote it if i was able to solve like out of just my own intelligence like pick up on all those clues from

case one i would put that on my gravestone i would be like solved case one season one of detective just to let everyone know because it's that much of like a holy [ __ ] [ __ ] oh wow she did it but yeah so it's it's really the job of the writers for even you know chronicles of crime sherlock holmes all of these kinds of games to give you basically the air of free will we can go anywhere yeah but we should be going in the right direction to experience the story that i'm sure the writer wants us because it's hard work all this is hard work to make it all cohesive yeah uh so if you're like way on left field not even it's right then probably something in the writing made you believe something else like uh and and i think that's more prominent in case one where the the person the suspect we just never and had no we like we blew it up like no there's no way and i will say the one time the only thing that could have helped us if uh if we had just really like thought about it was i said oh like this kind of thing like the uh the bee whatever i was like this is perfect because they keep it in a lab and then i was like anyway it was stupid and there are times that we've played games like this where uh i think our friend josh made some he's like oh it's this guy yeah and we're like yeah right idiot and then we come to and i was like oh my god he was right uh

so i mean these games are a lot of fun but if you are one of those people that that wants to be here for the story and you don't get it like you like you you don't get to experience it and that can be a little disheartening yeah luckily though if you fail you're like oh man where did you miss it and you read the epilogue then at least it tells you the whole story that's always yeah you do so get it it's not just like oh i guess you'll never know yeah it's like but how would you come to this conclusion like what did we miss yeah went wrong like kind of like what sherlock holmes is sherlock holmes doesn't give you a time limit which is probably one of the benefits to that is if you decide as players when you want to quit um but you do know you do have a timer it's just more like well we've taken 70 leads yeah and sherlock did three you have a consequence so we have negative 800 points but yeah there's because you want to get a good score yeah uh but other than that i think that these this this season one box is fantastic uh i love these these pictures um because i tried to organize them based on how they were connected yeah like okay so this is the guy this is his son that's his boyfriend i guess that's the godfather no that was the i don't know who that was no i think that was yeah that was one of the the the sports guy uh but then that's the murderer then there's his wife so they're connected somehow then i kept these three so that's his wife so they're connected somehow i don't know how they would be no i don't know how they're connected but yeah so those are always fun these i mean this is one of those games that you can really get a cork board or a whiteboard

wheel it in and then take notes because i mean you have what four or five pages of notes yeah that's that's and that's one of my favorite things about these games is i do like taking notes and um and just drawing silly things is unfortunately part of that and going and going back and you have all the information in a digestible way uh but i also love this card system where you can sit there and be like okay so where'd we go oh we talked to him right here and then you can go back and and read and make sure we didn't like with these we can like compare the the the articles or something like that all right so on a scale of one to ten what would you rate each each case each case i will say i'll just give it a plain jane five for case one okay it gives you a nice little like introduction gives you a little taste yes uh gives yeah i mean essentially it does it just gives you a little little snacky snack about what you're gonna get um to me it just wasn't that interesting i'm sure to other people that they're like well but that's just that's just not me uh case number two i'm gonna give a dang old nine nine um because how freaking fun yeah was that because everyone had a reason to kill that guy he was a piece of [ __ ] i remember writing it down i was like deserved to die like yeah in in case two you had the it was it was more unique because it was like hey there's no locations yeah every card takes an hour like yeah and it's i'm like i'm like oh no locations and i then i read the i'm like oh you're in

one location the whole time yeah and because i was thinking about this while i was making my coffee upstairs um i was like it was not an act of like if he was gonna die that night it was when and by who yeah like he was going to die that night someone was gonna kill him yeah um so i think that one was just a really good it really put me in that movie mindset of yeah of like watching knives out um watching these fake like the family bicker the staff is just like oh my [ __ ] god i'm putting together like because i remember when we first put two and two together that um the conservator was his child right and they were like what yeah oh my god oh man and then like we never thought that she had a motive and i was like okay so she just has a gun what cares yeah i was just like oh yeah she just wants to protect herself yeah so that one to me just like um just really set the mood with the thunderstorm like it's a dark stormy night you can't get out like you have there's no cell service yeah yeah i thought that one was really awesome and then for case three i'll give it i'll give it an eight because it was still really cool there was a lot to put together that we had like those like aha moments like you said um and really solid because at one point we were like oh man they could be trying to flip it on us and be like be like oh my god this is a whole like this is a setup for a setup like yeah kind of thing at some point you're sitting like i was sitting there and i'm like no the writer's not that good like there's no way they did the double setup where it's like ah you thought it was them but it really wasn't it's like no there's no way

that'll be in the heist episode yeah right yeah so yeah so five nine eight i completely agree i i would give those uh those same scores to to the same cases uh five or the first one's not bad um it's just even whenever we did read it's like oh okay like right cool that was that right uh and then case two uh yeah everything you said i mirror and in case three uh was also really good but yeah yeah so these were awesome so overall like the whole thing i'd probably give it like an eight like the whole the whole the whole season i know technically you would just average that out and that would be tiny it'd be a 7.5 but i'm not bumping it pretty much an eight yeah pretty well i i still i mean but i still very much enjoy the process of case one instead of i just didn't care for the story as much right so that's our thoughts on detective monochrome board games season one ignaci and portal games keep making this these seasons these cases i i just love these i want them to support this for quite some time please do a heist episode like i mean because that's the thing is chronicles of crime just really they're about to release three expansions uh on top of what they already have sherlock holmes has four boxes with 10 cases each so that's 40 cases um and i think at this point since they made the website it probably i mean all their videos it's

not like they're embedding into the website it's a link it's a it's a youtube link and i i know actually how to make that myself so it's probably not that difficult uh it's difficult to probably make the website but now they can just put it all in here uh there i i didn't get to review the dig deeper with rob davio but that one was really good too so their signature series i loved i keep making seasons making expansions they have an la crimes thing they even have free cases so they can just keep supporting this uh as as uh as life goes on so you have anything else no cool so that's our thoughts and detective of monochrome board game season one let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved