Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 33:30

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to look hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and we are doing a no run through review for nineveh-leer and the expansion thing velir um which uh the reason why we're doing uh a discussion or a review instead of a run-through just because i can't think of a very good way of actually recording this game um and it's not the most exciting game in the world but i will say from my perspective this is probably the best set collection game that i have played like i i really really like this game and it fits the same vein of a filler um but also keeping it it's like because i think i mean it's not quite as short as most fillers yeah uh i i would call it more complex than a typical filler but it's short enough that it kind of fits the category right right and like after like one play-through you're like oh i get it yeah okay i see how these work they're really like the rule book doesn't do this game any justice i remember the first time we played it we were like how the hell do you play this game it has to be more complex than this this rule book is all over the place uh it's really the heroes the amount of heroes that you have to be like and they all do something different so these things do the same but it's the heroes that really create a variety so that's probably yeah you're right it's not a filler it's definitely not a gateway but for me it it scratches that itch um because normal

set collection games to me are very blah um unless they're incorporated with other games right but yeah uh i very much like this one so uh let's start with just the base game and then we can jump into the expansion what do you guys think of the base game i don't care who starts fine fine if it's it's well as always it's more complex and more things to consider than is is my liking but you know it certainly fits in that i can see it as a really good middle ground or a simple version for more complex gamers taking a break between games yeah yeah that's true and in that sense of filler um yeah which would be by definition really of a filler yeah would be like i'm tired of playing v the lasada games can i take a break and then i jump to this one yeah yeah i can see that as as a scratch on the edge um but simple enough to pick up probably a lot more simple than the rule book which i never read and i picked it up well enough yeah it's it it really is a strange rule book i i wonder if there's like a language barrier that made it complex uh because who are the designers sergey leggette and i mean well the helmet is sergei legette and the hammer is jean claude van damme jean-marie minguez uh i don't know what the hammer or the helmet mean but but yeah like it's i i do think it's relatively straightforward at least because after a couple playthroughs and not having played it for a few months i was able to

come and be like and just teach you yeah and being like uh let me just remember what these are called and then like one or two kind of rule clarifications and then it's like oh we're good yeah um zach what do you think i think it's good i bought it because it's a lightweight game that i have most i don't want to say heavier games but mid-weight games this is a light game that doesn't take a lot of teaching um i've yet to play it at my house doesn't take any teaching then he tells others what they could play this game's good anyway let's play the hunger again um but yeah it's it's it's fine it's it's it's decent yeah yeah i think it's very strange because when this game came out it was like i know the diet well it's a dice tower it got a seal of excellence it's not like an essential i don't think but they were raving it up and z had that same concept of like this is a it's fine uh so i can see it kind of being that way where it's like i don't hear anyone talking bad about the game but yeah i think they this game was so hyped up that you're expecting a lot more moving pieces when in reality it's you have five coins in your hand play one down take a card to a set and that's really it like we were talking about oh do you play for heroes or um or do you just try and get the best set and whatever is available it's pretty balanced as far as you know obviously i've been focused on getting one or two factions filled out and you a lot more balanced in this game with the expansion that

definitely have uh became a lot more obvious right uh or uh optional i guess is the the word um because the expansion i'm thinking if you if you the base game i could see kind of getting dull after a couple playthroughs because there's not really a whole lot of options in terms of the end cards you're getting yeah and then the heroes while there's plenty you're not going to ever get a bunch of them yeah yeah so you're really getting the ones that correspond to the strategy you've already started and there's nothing you're going to pick that's going to really like jerk you in a different direction yeah for me i guess the fine middle of the road or you know but not stellar comes from the idea that it is simple enough with a layer of complexity that it hits a niche but it's not long enough or involved enough or strategic enough for it to be in that higher level of games that people really rave about sure and it's not simple and straightforward enough for people to play it once and instantly love it it's something you want to play through a few times and then go yeah okay i'm getting it yeah yeah no that's that's actually a very good point um because you're right in the in the fillers that we've played that i've enjoyed canvas cascadia uh uh calico um hell even vivid memories uh those are like kind of like brain burning puzzle games yeah and and they're probably the same length as this game but i would say those are you're more like

i guess like exhausted or like mentally exhausted by the end of it because you're like i just need this one pattern to go here and oh there it is thank god and then now it comes all together here i don't really think a whole lot there's not a focused goal to shoot for yeah there are a bunch of goals and you just have to balance right at any given moment yeah i think you kind of pick like in in the games we played tonight like i would just pick oh i'm gonna try this strategy this game right and see if it and see if it pans out and never once have i been like oh man those are the nine cards that are out wow there's there's a lot of options because in reality like you said yeah there's gonna be cards you specifically want but maybe it's because i've only played this as a three-player game but i've never been like so cutthroat where it's like i have to have this card otherwise it ruins my whole plan it's like ah i didn't get that orange i needed oh well i guess i'll get that purple that's left for me because you only gain yeah and maybe that's why people like it because it's not it's not that cutthroat yeah and i admit i i disagree with you a little bit i think that's the biggest fault in this game is that it's not cutthroat it's and i see i can see why someone is just like well who gives a [ __ ] why i'll just take whatever you know yeah it has a little bit of that quacks uh energy it's not nearly as random as quacks but there are points where if you don't get rolling at the beginning i mean you saw how i played both games

like you don't get started the right way at the beginning of the game you're just stuck with like the last card every single right and you just get yourself into a bad position which some of that could be mitigated by practicing the game some of that's just the randomness of the cards yeah it's yeah you could you i mean you can play this game very cutthroat there are times where um like during the uh oh well the phase between h1 and h2 the distinction cards like these which i'm glad they exist it's just kind of a nice goal gives you a little benefit but none of them are really broken um in fact i don't think any of them really i think they're all kind of balanced but if somebody gets three of those and the other two players yeah one well that's where it becomes cutthroat that's where you lean towards like this game could get wildly unbalanced very quickly that's true yeah if someone's getting yeah the the tiebreaker the extra five coins and then the three um it's i i i haven't played the game where someone got all three um hell in fact i think in the games we played tonight i think one person got two and then the rest were divvied out um but you're right uh but that's kind of i think where it gets cut through it is you look at what your opponents need and there were in the second game we played there was a time where it's like the the two mercenaries that i had i chose to go last and i saw oh okay well you put yours in blue okay well i wanted blue and red but i can't get that so i'll tie him on blue and then

i'll steal and then i'll get the red one yeah and so this game i think is polarizing that it can go both ways it's like ah i see that brett needs a fourth blue to get a hero there's one blue there i know for a fact i i mean you could you could retain and be like i know his highest coin value yeah so yeah it's got enough that you can play that way and that's the sort of games that i enjoy is when you can play offensive and defensive yeah but again there's enough complexity and there's enough variance that i don't think you can do that very effectively yeah um you can't truly hate draft unless you're willing to sink yourself but that's the thing i don't think you think yourself in this one because you gain something if you need a blue yeah yeah i might not need a blue for a hero but hey that was 10 points that was 10 points for me and you don't get 10 points and you don't get a hero the difference between 10 points and like 15 points or 20 points could be game breaking at the end yeah absolutely uh it's unlike um petrichor where everything was i don't gain anything i just [ __ ] everyone else over this one is because yeah any hero that anyone gets is good um yeah really i mean i can't think of a single one where it's like that one sucks uh so it's like yeah you do hate draft to stop someone from really trying to get a hero but you do only have so much control because the what's super random are the ends it's like if if a blue's going here here and

here chances are i'm not stopping you from getting one blue unless i just get really lucky but at that point you're not gaining anything right for me to be like oh to really stop brett from getting a hero i'm gonna try and beat him out on every everything yeah i mean you could do it once or twice but you can't do it throughout the whole game like i realized at the end of age one when i chose to make that one to tie you in this faction so that neither of us got that benefit um i didn't do it for that reason i did it for the points right but it also blocked us blocked you from gaining something right and that was an added benefit yeah but but it wasn't a strategy it was a added bonus yeah i'm not and i'm not super thrilled about the the tiebreaker rules for the distinction cards that if you tie no one gets it i i do like the fact that the gems are a thing like it's very simple as a tie breaker you don't have to do anything weird and i like the fact that you trade yeah unless you get of course the six but then that means if you keep losing out on ties well then chances you're not going to eventually yeah um but i would much rather have the distinction cards be like oh okay yeah i have oh man i have five oh he just put five down okay i'm gonna try to uh i'm gonna try and tie him so i can swap the gems so i can win this that would add a little bit layer of strategy and it does in the expansion we'll get to that right uh but yes yeah yeah you are right but other than that then that would just kind of be annoying that would slow this game down to a screeching halt if someone's sitting here trying to okay what kind of coins does he have i know

he has a 19 where's he going to put the 19 like that would just be super annoying yeah um it is light enough that that that could be done but it really does if you're playing with someone like that play a different game you're going to lose because they're playing that way no you're going to win because you didn't sit down for an hour and a half playing this game with someone like that because that would draw this game out so long yes um so really in terms of like keeping coins mental it's probably like i would only ever keep track of your highest be like okay i know you have a 23. where are you most likely to go and that's what i was doing in the expansion because i was worried that uh someone was going to take this one that i desperately needed i was like i was trying to win out on the first one so i can go to it and grab it but then i'm like then i lost it and i'm like [ __ ] okay no one's gonna steal no one and then you took me over and i'm like you know i did that for my benefit wasn't even considering what would right be a disservice to you and it wasn't the best card for me anyway like milner wasn't uh so so i i think yeah this game could be more cutthroat you could hate draft a little bit more but it's not so much hate draft that it like seven wonders can have right um because it to me hate drafting is like hate drafting is when you text you you stop someone from getting something to no benefit of your own right like you benefit because they don't get something right sure i mean i get people can view that as oh that's my gain from stopping you

from gaining something uh but for me in this one me stopping you from getting a red or or any color it's still good for you it's still points and it's still a path that you can now aim for to try and even out a set but uh but yeah i mean that's really the base game do you guys think any of the heroes are busted these these ones don't count they're the expansion i didn't really focus on the heroes much when i when i happened to get one i just looked around real quickly and made a quick decision i haven't played enough to to really understand how they all feel most of them are straightforward the colored uh ones for the actual sets um are pretty straightforward it's the neutral ones with the special abilities yeah uh which even then but no i think it's good yeah i think they're just more powerful versions of what you can always get yeah most people might say the brothers the five brothers because they ramp up so quick literally getting two jumps you from 13 to 40 points yeah which is huge like i got 81 points off them alone um mainly because of the expansion allowing me to do that but that's one of those things where oh you took a brother yeah you took a brother okay that's who we're taking yeah which is not great i've never enjoyed games like where it's like oh you did something now i have to play it completely i have to play you know goalie yeah you know to i don't

want that brother but to stop you from getting 20 37. 27 points i guess i'll take one and it becomes a wash so maybe the brothers i don't like so much but every everyone else uh i think is i think it's pretty straightforward or cool in their abilities yeah yeah the the extra powerful ones you have to give up something yes and that ended up costing me without even realizing yeah oh yeah yeah the first game where the ability to get any more ever yeah yeah uh all right so they still so pretty well um so the expansion thing velir i'm very curious um because you were the one who brought it up uh you're like oh there's an expansion and that's been sitting on my shelf forever uh would you go out and get the expansion absolutely not really you don't you don't like the expansion it adds way too much to the game um so that's part of the issue is you could play this game with people who are there just to have fun you can play it with people who are gonna min max everything and i play with both types of people and certain games work for both types of people there's a lot of lightweight games that work for both groups this game i cannot see working or at least being enjoyable because the entire time it's going to be like oh you're sitting there you have ap the entire time yeah there's that just adds i feel like too many levels of depth for you to

think 40 moves ahead in my opinion okay because you can get to the point even like with the card that i had um you can start getting to the point where you're you're trying to figure out who's gonna go second and who's gonna go third and am i gonna win on one two or three and what are they going to get on one two and three and it's just it it loses that level of lightweight game there's some randomness in the game and but that's enjoyable because it's low it's it's a short game and low impact overall yeah with adding that it just for me it's just it's too much sure and i don't think it's like heavily complex i think it just just adds a lot of stuff there's too much going on it takes because nidovelir becomes one of those games and there's a few that are out there where man that would be a good top ten that'd be a hard one to do but there's games out there where it's no you're no longer playing the game you're playing against other people like chess for example is now i'm playing against you yeah uh this is so simple that it's now complex because i'm because we're in the same mindset probably target i've never played target before i've heard it's more yeah i understand there's like three things to do in this entire game but it's now very difficult because you and i are so on on sync i think nina velir the base game can become that where it becomes more about reading people on their cards what strategies they tend to go for what heroes they might get it's not so strategy heavy but it could start heading towards that the expansion

you're right takes that away you are now no longer able to play the player and you ask the question about the heroes i do think there are some cards especially towards late game that if you set your cards up in a certain way they are overpowered i don't think heavily yeah i think i think they are not completely balanced i think there's some that are fairly weak that come out and maybe that's you're talking about you're talking about the uh like the the base game heroes yeah i'm trying to figure out which ones you think because i think i think the base game heroes are pretty balanced yeah even with the brothers i think they're fairly balanced because i played a game where i focused on that in the first game that i played and i did okay yeah actually the first you won you won that game i got second did you get second in the game with me you another zack yeah oh i thought you won yeah um uh yeah because well yeah the brothers are interesting because either you go for them early which now gives everyone the opportunity to steal it from you or you can try to go late but then you have less chances of trying to actually get gain any points from it uh the ex yeah the expansion definitely lets you ramp like i got one brother and i think in one turn i got two brothers like like three total yeah just from the way that oh cause you got a card that lets you get enough yeah i got a card that let me um yeah actually i know what it was it was i got a brother as a regular that's that's who i picked and then the next turn or a few turns after was the the artifact that let you recruit a

hero and then i recruited the guy who gave me his clones places clones that gave me a set that gave me another brother um and then we still had enough time left for me to finish another set which gave me my third brother but even with adding are they mercenaries what are their mercenaries and artifacts yeah at the beginning of the game with the base game you can start planning out like okay somebody's gonna get a set i'm gonna get a set at this point in the game when that comes in it just it's completely awash you have no idea who's gonna get a set and when and it's gonna go by the the lead player then if you have that then it's gonna change things it just yeah it's a little bit too too much yeah especially for a game where you're you're randomly betting on tokens that you don't know what people are going to flip over you can't i don't think you're randomly betting on you're not random but you don't know i'm saying you don't know what someone's going to flip over at any given moment you're trying to get yeah you do have to guess but when you get to this area of having another level of complexity added on the randomness of getting those cards randomness being the token values yeah i think that's the point where it pushes it too far especially with the mercenaries and then yeah that pushing you into a situation where you don't know if you're going to get the majority in something because you have two that could be red but maybe you want to go for another thing and it's just oh right yeah because of the the split the split mercenary where it's like like in the in the first game that we played tonight was just the base game it was like you and i going back and forth on the warriors and it's just kind of

okay who happens to i'm saying that i loaded up on warriors and i'm just like this is right this is not gonna be readable by anyone as far as what i'm gonna do yeah that's that's actually a very good point because yeah it's like you can try and uh in the base game like hope that okay i can beat him in this bid and that and this is the final bid i beat him there boom i have more warriors that means in the distinction i'm gonna get the benefit or if it's h2 i'm gonna get to add my greatest value coin right you're right the mercenaries it's just like well he has four over there so he could beat me but he can just go for a set or you could yeah or something you can just different yeah uh so then the mercenaries just completely out of yeah you're right it's like well i have no idea what he's doing so then it becomes well i guess i'll start taking mercenaries i don't want them because they're blue and red and i can't make a set with either of those colors yeah but i don't want you to have it because you also have the artifact that gives you points for each mercenary so right because the the game we played with the expansion i was thinking man zack's probably gonna win just straight from that that card because i don't want mercenaries yeah like i want these cards because i want to make my sets and those mercenaries suck for me yeah so all right i guess we'll just see how balanced it was um which it ended up being like balance between you two i think like four points difference yeah wow um

but hmm you make a good point because i was gonna go into this i like the expansion like i i like the artifacts and i like the uh mercenaries but if you but i don't know if i like it in this game i think you make good videos of all the things they could have done with this game as far as an expansion which i also i don't think an expansion was necessary that quickly the game just came out like i feel like another player came out like three years ago really they were showing it at gen con i'll look it up i feel like one yeah i'll look it up real quick um which maybe it was older than that i don't know i think it was i thought it was is it 20 20 or 20 it's 20. okay so two years ago uh and the expansion came out the same year oh weird yeah it was out of print for a while the boat this game was uh relatively hard to get i think especially the expansion yeah now it's a little bit more available so maybe that's why i felt like oh man just came out with an expansion well no it came out with it apparently there's so many things they could have done to expand on the game i would have been fine with more heroes like more heroes or another class yeah or i mean there's there's tons and tons of things they could have done looking at the past exceptions of other games but brett what do you think of the expansion um i agree with both of you uh well i'm actually agreeing with zach i i was coming in being like this expansion's great well i agree with you then you like the expansion no i mean what i think me personally no no because well that's the agreement is it adds a

layer of complexity and it adds a new set of options when i'm already right on the edge of overwhelmed trying to to get so i wouldn't i wouldn't want to throw in the base game immediately personally yeah um but if you enjoy it and then you get a little bit tired of the base and you want that extra layer it's there to be had yeah and in that sense i would say it's essential for people who reach that level and want to move on right and so what they have done as an expansion i think is really great whether or not you particularly want it is the question sure yeah yeah and and for me you know if i reach that level when i reach that level i'll go yes i would really like to incorporate all of these changing elements and things like that so in that sense i agree with both of you that no i don't particularly want it and it isn't uh it isn't necessary on the other hand what it adds is a whole different level of thinking instead of just creating more of the same yeah that's true yeah that's a very good point and you actually hit the nail on the head because they stay on the front don't play this expensive this expansion sucks just give us money this expansion can be confusing because behind its very simple rules has hidden a multitude of new strategies we recommend that you take the time to familiarize yourself with the base game before embarking on the thing valeer adventure starting directly with expansion added to the base game could spoil the experience lack of experience could make your choices difficult and or random and it would result in a lack of strategy in order to

counter what your partners do which is very very true i actually like the fact that they say that because most expansions don't and then you're blindsided by what the [ __ ] is going on you know i say that on the box no you buy it and then they tell you no they don't don't attempt to play this game too yep we don't accept except returns that's true yeah they they don't uh say it on the box but i think which is why people watch play-throughs and exactly this is like this one right now so yeah in terms of an expansion it i i like the fact that you said it doesn't give you more the same because that's what i was thinking oh add another class well then you're just adding another class and um i would've been fine with more heroes and they could have done that but yeah they really did throw a monkey wrench in the game by adding artifacts and mercenaries like maybe you have to choose this or this yes or you may not have a choice because it does come down to and this is probably better in with more players where oh i really want that artifact or ooh i really don't want zach to have that artifact but [ __ ] if i go there then that's going to allow him to get that that class which is going to allow him to finish a set i could i would almost bet money that and i could be wrong but the designers of this game i feel like well i don't want the fourth player to feel left out just getting the last card so we're going to put these in so that they have more options but

ultimately it's also true in my opinion there's usually one or two things that you want out of each section i mean there's consolation prizes but those are consolation prizes a lot of time you want the one or two cards that you need to complete a set or something along those lines or you want one of those cards so if you're in third or fourth place it's not really gonna make much of a difference that doesn't sting any less but yeah that line of thought doesn't really work for for what that's doing overall especially because card gets discarded right yeah it doesn't stay over but it does become bidding becomes a lot more important important yeah because because these are so good like the artifacts are insanely good but the ones that are really good are super detrimental like hey you can't get heroes anymore yeah but that's 24 points which i would argue i would never grab that because heroes are going to be way more valuable in terms of like until the very i mean this is literally 21 points just these two alone and that that the crown was oh yeah you just can't get heroes anymore it's like well i don't really want that but if you can get a few heroes on top of that and then grab the artifact before age one ends okay yeah i could probably go h2 without getting heroes yeah so it it's an expansion that is definitely not essential i would never recommend getting this expansion along with the base game like i always bring this one up because it's probably

the number one expansion is prelude to terraforming mars yeah i would never never play that game without it i would never teach that game without it here yeah thing of velir is i'm keeping it i like it but no it's no i'm not teaching work your way up to it yeah yeah it's like okay do you get it okay let's play a few more games now this ads are the facts and i really think you really have to like the game yes yeah this at least has to be an eight on your scale no i would agree if you're gonna go for the expansion uh i would agree the mercenaries yeah they are another beast in terms of strategy um because i like the way they're handled i do too um you have to wait to commit yeah but you wait until the critical moment to commit to them instead of using them immediately and then god i wish i'd done something different right and i also like the fact that how they're organized you don't place them immediately you have to wait and it's like i have the most hmm well i could go you know i'm gonna go last because i might want to you know build out oh well they have crap he has three he could finish he can actually finish two sets by placing those who's he gonna grab you know um but it uh it's it's accurate to say that it does completely flip nivelier on its head uh so that's really yeah that's a it's a polarizing expansion one of the few that i've played and i wasn't expecting that of a tiny box yeah it uh it did bring in some interesting things

but it doesn't ruin the game like other zach and i played the expansion to tech canoe and it made the game worse like i was like i because we played tech henry by itself and and he liked it and i i like it and then we played the expansion we're like this expansion sucks it for me thank you very didn't do that but i probably wouldn't want to play it all the time all right um but with that on a scale of 1 to 10 what would you what would you guys give knit of the lear and the expansion let me start with you um i give nittleville here seven seven and think of the layer six six yeah still slightly maybe 5.5 okay we're on that still still very slightly above average right um i'm gonna go seven both on both yeah yeah um it doesn't hit me the same way it does you but i totally get the category of people who would just go crazy yeah yeah set collection is a genre of games that they're always just so blah for me yeah uh the only time i ever like like five tribes i like set collection than that um but that's one fifth of something that's in the rest of that game yeah uh this is a set collection game with and it's not necessarily it's not auction is it bidding i guess it's bidding right silent bidding silent bidding yeah and even that it's it's it's usually i

think i'm more taken by this game because it's two genres that i'm like i take or leave it but they work really well for me yeah um so i'm gonna give nina valeer i'm gonna give it an eight uh and the expansion man zack you did make a good point you're not wrong but i think it comes down to the types of games that you and i kind of like think uh but i'm gonna give the expansion the seven i do think it muddies the purity of nitivelir um a little bit more than especially what a lot of people are gonna expect if they're like ooh it doesn't make it a little bit more stretchy oh oh my god i don't know how to strategize anymore yeah yeah so expansion will be a seven near the value base by itself will be an eight and that's our thoughts on nintendo and thankfully let us know what you think of the game in its expansion in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved