Journeys in Middle-Earth: Discussion
Transcript
viewer discretion is advised everyone welcome to the discussion for Lord of the Rings journeys in mill earth fantasy flights newest game that is after riven essentially the way it was advertised to me was it was kind of like a mansions of madness like lor the rings yeah so uh so yeah oh yeah I guess I guess yeah there is there is none of that you you don't yeah you barely pick up any items along the way so here are the criticisms that I've heard from this cuz I don't think this has really had like glowing reviews let's see BoardGameGeek that makes sense though yeah BoardGameGeek has it at a yeah that's a one I mean and it's just been out so it could be I mean yeah well 8.4 but in all honesty that could just be people just like it's a turnkey of the floor of the Rings but a lot of Christmas Christmas was I've heard is that it's just very slow-paced and like not a lot happens which in our experience yeah there's really not a whole lot going on because like because you don't find items throughout the thing and you don't have a whole lot of search interactions right yeah yes so
most of your experience is you just moving and then just flipping cards from your deck and be like all right I got a success yeah and then you're just reading stuff which sometimes you'd be like alright she'll turn her back on oh my god you're like two cards oh yeah exactly so uh so I mean there's there's a little bit too to unravel here do you think that the Lord of the Rings theme is like is coming out yeah I mean it's they did stuff where I mean you're you're like yeah the named characters that everyone's gonna know I mean unless you're like excessive book readers and maybe these other people are actually in there I've only read fellowship in two towers but the named characters that most people are going to know are Aragorn Legolas and Bill oh those are those are the three three characters and then the rest are like Baron or Ellen uh and then someone else
he was the third useless whatever his last name is oh no Ghibli Ghibli he's also in here Aragorn alehna bearer for Gimli Legolas and bill bill oh so so I mean there's there's still some main characters and I mean you get some references of like Weathertop and stuff but this is just kind of one who's this so far reminds me of the off-brand lore the Rings video games like there was one that I remember for the Xbox called called Lord of the Rings of Third Age and you were some other ragtag group that was like behind the fellowship like the fellow sure was good because I remember there was a scene where it was like it was in that on the bridge of cousin doom where Gandalf is fighting and like all the other fellowship guys like ran off and you actually fight with Gandalf but you're just [ __ ] nobodies yeah they're there I mean I the game was the game was fun but there was a yeah yeah yeah I mean yeah you're the B team who's doing all the work so I mean as of right now and I should caveat this with we haven't finished the main campaign so right so I mean if you're like well it gets better later on that's fine and I mean this is one of those games that I'm gonna go ahead and say I do want to keep playing right just to see where the story goes because of right now is very
slow-paced I mean Holly look the first chapter I will say this though we played the first chapter twice and it was different yeah totally different like as soon as we pulled out the first note I like that's not the one we got laughs yeah yeah and there was one he was like a hunter going after a bear cub yeah instead of a guy lost fans yeah yeah so so that was that was really neat like there was just a little bit different stuff to go and there were some similar things like you had to find tracks and that was all the same and then and like I remember it verbatim like oh the Goblin pairs back yeah so there was a lot of stuff that was still similar that the I mean it's gonna be like mansions where you can play the same scenario in the overarching thing is going to be the same but there might be a little bit different things to do oh yeah like you I feel like they're just riding off of the oh the Lord of the Rings yeah for sure cuz that's what got me excited by anything like I liked the first one better the first chapter this one like almost immediately I was like okay I'll run over and go kill that guy right right after that I was like oh boy so I'm just gonna be stuck right here in this corner right getting my ass beat yeah it was it was like it was like a battle map that just it doesn't work with two people no yeah and you yeah and your your support and I'm I mean I have a really great bow it's literally called
great bow but I mean it does like I almost want hit everything if I draw draw right yeah so I'm a good fighter but at the same time like I can't take hits for [ __ ] so it's like the first one that's like okay well we can cover enough ground and do stuff but then in the battle ones it's like we can't do enough to do this and I don't know if we just played this one wrong or or white but almost like maybe used to be more supposed to lose but that doesn't feel right no I think if we were so because it was really like I was like okay ten hits there you go I dropped him and he's like oh good sup cuz they're wonderful them too we're just gonna have to find him again so that makes me think like oh we weren't supposed to lose it's just a setback yeah like we had that we had to retreat and then go camp and didn't follow them cuz I left so we're just being punished for the exam right I mean it is pretty cool that things will change depending on how well you do because in I mean in the rules that says regardless if you pass or fail in the chapter it will continue on so I don't know how many options how many branches that this campaign goes right but yeah you're right it does sound because that's seemingly what kind of fantasy flight does they have three things they have lower the Rings Star Wars and yeah like they really they lost a lot of licenses fantasy flight like years ago was like in its heyday and Battlestar
Galactica I had Warhammer and had talisman and had all these other branches and then now it just seems like okay so you make these big box games and literally there is almost nothing in this [ __ ] box you'll know how much this game cost probably a hundred dollars now I will say like four terms of content that you get it's not worth $100 like at all the artwork is fine I like the artwork the minions are okay they all kind of look the same so it's I mean it's Inc it they're just they're just I mean there are there minis like they're nothing to be like wow they're not like hate or Kingdom death monster minis him you never really expect that from a fantasy flight anyway but what you are probably paying for while how they can get away with this Center lower price point is you're paying for the yeah like ending work that went into the app and the app is really really good like everyone praises their fantasy flight or their fantasy flight their mansions the madness at which is also really good atmospheric they have the soundtrack they have the voiceover yeah the soundtrack the sound effects the voiceover the muse and the music and it helps you do organization and the app is awesome like second edition man blows first-edition out of the water but with this one it does even more it tracks XP it tracks lore that you gain it tracks the items that you have it
tracks upgrades for your characters it has a map and one of the greatest things that I saw was because if you look at the battle map this is boring to look at but the app actually had it in 3d terrain yeah and I thought that was awesome like that was so cool just to sit there and like it took okay so place pushes here and then they just and whenever you place them it popped him up and actually had a design of them yeah it'd be nice if it actually had like well there'd be no way the track really where the the enemies move but it was just neat like I thought was really cool how it tracks threat it literally like you don't have to have a marker and be like okay so thread hit this like at all it calculates almost everything for you so so the app is really how they're getting away with justifying this at $100 and that's I mean that's okay because I know for a fact that they're gonna add expansions like there it's Fantasy Flight they're probably gonna have like 10 expansions just like they did for mates the madness and Arkham and Eldridge or and they're just gonna over bloat this thing maybe not over bloat it but they're gonna just keep adding more and more campaigns to it so yeah so things that I like about about the game I actually really like the deck system
yeah how this works like it gives you a little bit occasion like you could look through and be like okay I have one two three four five I have five successes and then I have a bunch of other cards that if I have a bunch of inspiration that just gives me even more even more options to succeed and the fact that every round you get to shuffle your discard pile and at least Scout to you those are successes but I'll pick this one to go down here to get a little ability and put this at the bottom or oh I drew a weakness okay I'll put the weakness at the bottom so you get some mitigation versus I'd rather have this than dice yeah even though it's still random I feel like you have a little bit more control and I'm not gonna get as mad if I could even easily at least you know for a fact you will get successes versus die rolls where it's like well I keep failing yeah yeah exactly or yeah so so I really like I really like this and what I also really like it and it goes kind of back to the app is the upgrade system like you gain XP based off what you do and then you can spend that for your classes like abilities like okay I'll spend 3 XP to get whatever Martin was called something useless to get yeah quick snare that's
our dog Oh to get quick snare for 3 XP and now whenever with I when I strike with the skill I had stun so I don't know what do you think just in general what do you tell mean about in the things I'm talking about okay in the upgrades yeah i defending i'm personally never a big fan of XP spending on paper because i don't know why it just be like in the video games sometimes even barely then so you don't i don't like light making your character better some well i like i like that part that sometimes just move on from it yeah yeah um but it just always feel like i slows down important because everything is slowed down when you're doing a board game versus a computer on a console but I mean yeah as far as the deck like I agree that it's better than dice it is still random so I mean there there's sometimes we even just like oh like oh my mics - well I'm probably not like unless the card just happened to be that way which I don't know right yeah I mean I I agree but at least you know because you could look through your discard pile and be like and I know I have five successes in my deck okay they're all fun in the discard pile so I know I'm not gonna be succeeding it gives you at least some of that knowledge right yeah the fear and the end the damage that works just like Arkham damage and and
mental health yeah first yeah so that I mean really they just kind of took this in hopping in yeah for the most part made some changes but it just seems it's a little bit less atmospheric is because even talking to people like hey would you help me get my chickens it's like all right I was like oh yeah I mean even then there was actually kind of a place that was immersion braking where we were hunting these these orcs and and trying to track them down and I went fishing Oh like the fact that that was an option it's just like okay this isn't really like immersive right Rafe and I got an item I got extra rations so that's just stuff that we have now but it's like why why is that even really an option to to do because I can't think of really anything like that in any of the Arkham games right like it did just not seem to make sense cuz there are stuff like Oh like oh we need to look at that bookshelf or you find this but it makes them cuz you're investigating right to go fishing it's like yeah I guess cuz you're trying to survive at the same time if you want to go deeper into it yeah but yeah he would think that it would be like oh well you were walking on the things and then use your [ __ ] whatever do you think that so mansions in this mansions are scenario-based like it's not a campaign so each scenario is completely different and this is
campaign do you think they actually hurt themselves by making this into a campaign because they could have easily just done different Lord of the Rings like scenarios like instead of an overarching campaign because if here's the thing if this doesn't pan out I mean no one's gonna buy her stuff I mean they might just know I mean that's probably you know I'm actually wrong people are going to buy it it's just because in Florida they've got enough fanboys to know I mean I think I would like it more if it was scenario-based like I like that it's going it's short like the first chapter wasn't very long second almost 40 minutes but I like that they're kind of short I just do I would I wouldn't mind playing probably one hour two hours right to have like I'm just a big scenario because I I do like Lord of the Rings like yeah it does make me want to watch the movie Siri but um I don't know I don't know it just really depends on how the campaign is but I do i I mean it's just I feel like we've had a lot of campaigns lately and I just say yeah it's like okay so I mean and that's why they're doing the discussion like I'm not going to continue recording this we'll just play we might do a final discussion afterwards to talk about the campaign right but yeah it I just wanted to get some videos up just because a lot
of people are probably wondering if this is worth $200 as of right now I must say no it's not worth $300 for the app is impressive but unfortunately the game so far is is not like amazing right so you have a really really stellar app for kind of a lackluster game so far that like if I if this was mentioned second edition and it had the upgraded app like this one does then it'd be it in deep perfection but so far it's like okay well I mean really all we do is find an orc captain so but they keep alluding to bigger things right there's more evil at work so I mean they have a lot I mean Lord of the Rings it's such a vast you know world and universe that they have a lot of material to go on so I don't I don't think that it's not gonna get better and expansions could also make it really good like you can have boss it's like it we can go into the mines of moria and actually have a Balrog boss and stuff like that Oh mine yeah but so they have a lot of options and I mean I love lowering so much on this I'll just still buy it oh yeah I mean it's scale of one to ten so far I mean so far I'm gonna just pick it right at five just to keep state average yeah just just cuz I mean
I'm not the one who's in the app I love the narration in the 3d aspect is cool and I'm looking at it but and I think it is fun and helpful it's just go it goes here yeah yeah you'll have to cause to be reading or stuff like that I mean you are constantly reading but it's through the app and it's just interact it's more fine it just keeps it streamlined yeah yeah so that's helpful um but yeah as of right now like that second chapter really just kind of caught me off guard and I was like wow this is I'm I just I got right yeah like immediately I was like I was like there's no [ __ ] point for me doing anything I was like I'm gonna suck if I move out if I stay you know they're gonna think of is like if we just be aligned and cut that like we would have had as many people yeah maybe if I had actually just moved to the fire pit and shot shot at him and get pierced then that would have done away with his armor yeah so they're probably more ways that we could have beaten him but it was just scenario like you'd like there were just too many people and you can't fight ya really so yeah so yeah i mean um I'm gonna give it a 6.5 yeah I'm gonna happen because I'm the story still has me intrigued like I'm not completely like rode off or checked out like obviously it the app is
stellar I really I like the XP system I like the lower base because I mean I think with my great bow for example like if I spent the whatever 30 to lure it would go to a merc word Mirkwood great bow which would be five hits that would give me cleave and cleave it's like each enemy in the group suffers the full amount of hits instead of just one so like if I attack if I have a merc with bow and I attack them and I did seven damage and do seven damage to all of them so yeah the upgrade system I think is really neat yeah and for the range so six point five still still intrigued but that is our thoughts on Lord the Rings journeys in middle-earth let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day the speeds hey everyone thanks so much for watching this and if you liked this video and click the subscribe button below to enjoy any video that I put out and right next to that subscribe button is a little Bell click that so you get notified of whenever I actually upload these videos if you want to support the channel you can definitely visit my patreon page the link is in the description below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day of this for you