Farshore: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and today I'm doing a discussion over farshore which is the sea version or water version of everdell now when this was announced I was like really really like you you capped off your stuff with everdell and then you're like oh [ __ ] that's where we make our money we got to keep milking this like that horse I saw it move let's keep [ __ ] kicking it to get get more money out of it hence farore that was my initial thought and then I played it and then I played it some more and then I came to the realization boy you kept kicking that horse um farore is fine I actually I don't really have problems with the game I have weird feelings about the company and and here's a reason why and this is pure this could be pure speculation so don't I'm not like some tinfoil hat wearing guy I didn't dig into the company and you know Roo up some P I didn't look at you know 20 year old Twitter post or whatever um but from what I have gathered I think they did some weird production design and marketing design for this game because uh this copy that I have is the
retail copy and so I'm actually not even going to talk about the game right now because it what's surrounding the game and what's keeping me from being more positive about it is the fact that the retail Cofe and I never I usually never bring up price in a game like this but the retail copy of this is $100 and that blew my mind like I saw it in my local game store and I and I very rarely Buy Local it's normally oh I want to play a board game today and let's just go to the game store and just look around maybe buy one support the local game store every now and then but God damn you guys got to start competing uh and I was like oh they just that that was a misprint on the sticker there's no way this is $100 and then I looked up online and saw that it was for 80 and I was like no no like they're not selling farshore for $80 on their on their website and what I have heard is they meticulously planned that made the retail copy more expensive so that people would go to their website and buy it actually and I find that completely shady and I'm a business major overall my my college degree this is was years ago and doesn't matter at all but was in business so I understand why they would do that that makes perfect sense hey you idiots don't buy at retail don't go to the local game store those are dead come to our online store and buy it from us cuz it's
cheaper it's the same JC Penney concept of like or just a mentality of being like hey instead of a coupon we just lowered the prices to be what a coupon would reflect it that's a JC Penney business model that almost well not almost it pretty much tanked the company and then they had to go back and be like no now we have coupons don't you feel like you're saving something that's what it feels like so with that taken into consideration after playing farore what do I think of it it's it's everdell with a few tweaks albeit slightly better tweaks and you might be wondering what this is I just got done playing the solo variant but it's B basically everdell and but with a water pirate theme and I like the pirate theme I think it's neat I think the artwork is still absolutely gorgeous uh I mean I think what is it is it still Andrew I thought it was an um I'd have to go look at my everdell uh collector you know complete collection that I haven't played since I packed it all up um I want to say it's Andrew Bosley art but I could I could again be absolutely wrong um nope Jacqui Davis is the artist for this one boy am I just G to look like an idiot if the artist is okay nope Andrew Bosley was forever Dell uh jacqu
sha Davis which is not on the cover uh also did fantastic art it's so good like very immersive very Lively the actions you take are pretty much the exact same spots to get resources go places to go get contracts um but the the loop if you've played everill before then you're going to pretty much be able to jump into farshore and just kind of be like okay well what's different and they do have like in the quick rules on the back the like comparing far Shore to everdell even though that's kind of weird to me where it's like hey we already know you're going to be comparing it so here's the major differences so I figured it would be nice to actually go through these and and talk about the major differences so number one is setup you get one worker in Autumn one worker uh one worker goes on the ship so instead of having you know getting like one worker now two workers later and a worker later you basically will get you start out with two workers one worker is in your boat for whatever reason even though I I don't know why they have the worker in the boat you have the colored flag that shows who the so it's like anyway you have two workers you prepare for Autumn and spring you get a worker summer get one worker fall or Autumn you get another worker um I actually don't really like this uh
mainly because it feels very restrictive still and I'm not even saying like you can still get combos and stuff and you can still get enough resources to do what you want but it feels more restrictive when you're playing because you're so limited on the workers like you you have to go to certain spaces and it's like well I'm already out of workers and now I'm already out of resources so I guess I'm done which could like shorten the game of of farshore which could be a good thing but I always liked how everdell kind of ramped up and it was up to the players to it's like if you if you blow through your workers and your resources and you're not using the the like the system to make free stuff or you're not getting an engine going to where you can keep playing and keep eeking out each season I like that a lot more and that and so farore kind of has that but I feel like you run out of stuff way quicker so you're preparing for a season and you're like well I'm not really getting much anyway like cuz I'm not getting extra workers I'm getting one instead of two I don't know it it feels a little bit more restrictive on that so uh this one is the best one like I would say the best change that they made to farore is this one where it says duplicate cards get stacked so there are always eight different cards in view I think this is one the best change of farore has because in everdell you could have the librarian and the librarian and the whatever and the and you could just
have duplicate cards where it's like okay well no one wants these cards and they're just kind of staying there in Far short if you you know draw the exact same card wish I could find an example now um oh I did so the scrip dorm is out here in the bay if you you know as you're setting it up let's say oh someone takes the salemaker and then you draw the scrip torum it gets stacked on top of the scrip torum so a new card comes out and now you always have eight different cards this is a very very welcome change to farore because one it's going to allow for more people to be able to grab different cards unique cards that they wouldn't have seen otherwise and duplicate cards are just stupid if that's what's clogging up the bay but I also have a caveat to that put do that in everdell like if you already if you're playing everdell then uh you can just easily take this Rule and just apply it to that be like okay duplicate cards now get stacked in everdale boom problem solved I don't see any reason why that that why that would be an issue um so the cool the best thing about farshore can be applied to everdale next one the card deck has been rebuilt with many new ability okay well that's there your ship will advance by playing cards so the new thing is also these wind roses There's A and B effects um the a effects are referred to for
whether it's Unique common a critter or construction so the type uh of card and then the B is the symbol so everything but purple they have yeah blue green red and brown and these get shuffled and you place them face up so every time you play a card that is matching the face up of a or and or B you move your boat and your boat is essentially and this kind of I feel replicates or replaces the extra worker is every time you match that so let's play I let's say I play a unique whatever the B symbol is or whatever the that BR blue symbol is which I know they have titles um I just don't oh governance cool so I play unique governance building which is the blue script I I get to move my boat twice for that each time you match that you get to move your boat and your boat is a victory Point track uh another way you can score so if you have ways to move your boat you can potentially get up to 60 points but every time you match or or uh land on or cover or go over a place with a treasure map or a treasure token you get a treasure and treasures are wild resources or two points at the end of the game so another way you can get a bunch of points but also gives you some variability with the
resources um it this is fine like the dock thing is a fine uh system um might be a different strategy for you to go forward than just building your city you could highly focus on what the wind roses are and almost try and take cards that always match the two so you can ramp up there are a bunch of cards that give you like the uh salemaker is a green production card that moves your boat one space okay well it's green so it goes off when you play it then it'll go off two more times in Spring and Autumn so you're at least going to get some extra movement there um some unique locations that you can send workers to allow you to move your boat so it's good then the amount of treasure tokens that you get become very sparse towards the end as the points get higher but by the time you're getting up there anyway you're probably going to have all your workers so it evens out um again it's fine I personally would rather have an extra worker than a boat moving around a track but but it's it's all right it's good it's there um let's see treasure tokens can be used as replacements for any resource yep so when over the treasure tokens that's a thing that exists events are replaced by map titles they can M multiply together for Big Value so they should not be ignored okay so in everdell they had on the tree uh map tiles or not map tiles events and
the events were kind of uh extra ways for you to get victory points by meeting certain conditions they hey have this kind of uh you know this kind of card in your city or have this many um have this many of this type and you would go and you would be able to take that event card and that would that would be worth points now they have these contracts I think the events are a little bit more complicated and sometimes they're either completely forgotten or they are are difficult to do or rely on luck so it could be like oh lucky me I happen to get the the two cards that this event was um was looking for so I'm able to go and grab that I can see kind of why they would do away with that but the contracts I feel are just I feel they like they're kind of boring literally all they are is they're a they're a point multiplier and you need either four green or three of anything or two purple you know like so and what I mean by that is like hey for this four green one if you have four green cards in your city you go to the dunes to claim a contract okay now this is worth two points times any number of contracts that you get all right now you got three blue go there grab that that's one point but now it's three * two so these two are worth six then hey this is one of everything so you have one of every type of of of uh of card that's
two points so it's two four and five but now it's times three contracts so that's 15 points and you see how it ramps up um the bot that I actually just played against got 2 three four five 6 7 8 nine and then had six contracts for 54 points um or 50 yeah 54 um so like yeah they they ramp up really quick if you can get a bunch of them because it's the multiplier element uh again it's fine like the boat thing you can get a bunch of points for the if you go if you don't go for boats you can go for contracts and that's another way you can get a ton of points but they're just so simple like I thought the the events there were a ton of and that kind of made a little bit more exciting to try and get versus uh I'm naturally building my city I got those so I guess I'll go to the Dune three times with my three workers I have and just kind of get a bunch of points yay like I don't know it feels like you care less about what is in your city and you're just looking for symbols so I mean it it just depends on what you're looking for this is the contracts are a lot more simple uh they they like on first glance they're easy to make sense of how you get them and they could be rewarding if you're just wanting to be like hey man that's 54 points right there there you go that like again I
don't really care much one way or the other um occupied tokens are replaced by anchor tokens so this one is huge this is very very huge and this again makes farshore feel a little like not a little like a lot more restrictive so everdell had um basically constructions that lent themselves to allow you to play Critters for free like the libr like the library let you play The Librarian for free it felt thematic it felt like hey this makes sense that I have this specific Construction in my city therefore this specific Critter would want to you know occupy that work there live there whatever it might be so I can play this for free whether it's in the bay or whether it's in my thing and now it's occupy and you place a token on it a little bit fiddly with the with the Occupy tokens but now um now it just kind of makes sense that my city feels lived in in farore everyone is given three anchor tokens and these anchor tokens allow any Critter to kind of anchor to that location um really all you do is oh I have this unique Critter that's worth five mushrooms I have any construction in my city I have this Tangled raft this shitty ass raft I can spend one of my three Ang aners to play a critter for
free so it's not thematic but it is more streamlined and but you will never get more anchors there's nothing that is like hey gain an anchor you have three therefore you have three free cards to play um I it again it's fine but it's like I feel like you're missing a lot on the the theme of it it's like yeah okay maybe yeah the farshore thing no one pirates aren't tied to one location so sure the sculptor could just kind of show up and just drop anchor um at a Grove for example it's kind of whatever uh still feels very restrictive but in a pinch it could be really nice that you're like oh I really want to play this card okay I'm going use one of my three anchors uh to um to just play it for free because now I can do a bunch of other stuff and it might also get you more resources hey I play the unique Critter that's exactly what I needed for um uh for my wind roses that's going to put me up two which gets me a treasure thing and I needed one more resource to play this card next turn it it still does have that combo esque feel but you're kind of still restricted once you spend all of your anchors then now you got to start paying for resources where in the in everdell that felt like that the whole game the whole game was like
Hey I built these specific buildings uh they allow me to house these people so now I'm going to start looking for him to build out my city um simple still a little more simple still more streamlined because there's no fiddin you just have the three anchors the anchors are nice they're metal they look cool uh but it just like if you kind of like have three high value Critters in your hand and you spend all three of them to play for free and you're just like okay well I guess I'm done getting free cards whereas in all of everdell you had the potential of having free cards the entire game and sometimes you would play for that sometimes and if you just kind of took their far Shores duplicate Bay Area like with where duplicate cards stack you're going to start seeing a lot more cards so it's fine again then we go to yeah there are no more open red locations so in everdell again you had uh red locations and this was very fiddly and hardly ever used you had your red locations were were location were extra work replacement spots anyone can go to and you had these standies that were open or close signs um so you would plus put like a red location so hey this kooper for example um in everdell you would place the standy open closed with an open sign on top of it meaning that anyone can go
there and then anyone could go and then you would flip it to closed and they could use your city's location um I actually like this change in farshore that there's no open close what with the locations that you have in your city are available to you uh in everdell I guess it was like a lot more communal kind of thing like thematically but yeah it's I've I don't think I've ever went to someone else's location even though that could be nice you could be like oh man I really want one of that in my city okay well I'm going to use I think they were compensated for it in I think they may have gotten a coin which was a point in everdell I can't remember because again I've never went to someone else's location but if someone got something and you're like oh that allows me to get like you know two free resources yeah I'll send my worker over there you get a point or whatever it might have been and I get my resources that would be nice if you you couldn't get that like in here if I got the card that put it into my city no one else can touch it however I I much prefer it to where because I mean you take games like an Acron and it's like hey now I have extra worker placement stuff in my own you know City area yeah no one else can go there this is my engine this is what I need for my strategy you can't take that from me now hey if I want to go and get two treasure tokens then only I can do that no one else could just come in and be like yeah man okay haha I'm going to send my worker and get two treasure
tokens I know it's in your city and so but you don't get to use it uh yeah this is a much better change uh theoretically you could again put that into everdell just take that rule and be like no there is no open closed whatever is in my city is is in my city boom then no problem there but if you play by the rules then it's it's better in farore and then um yeah in general resources are slightly harder to get and cards are easier to get and more frequently used for purposes other than playing them into your city um yeah I guess so like going to the docks allows you to discard cards to gain resources uh cards you can be play can get you the shells the shells replace the coins um in the game like so the are basically victory points yeah I guess the one cool thing that they do have that they didn't really mention is they have these islands uh that are placed based off the number of players and in everdell it was those cards like those Forest cards there were like four of them that were put out and those were always just there the islands kind of do the same thing except they're limited based off number of players um and the islands are cool cuz they're very powerful but whenever you're done preparing for a season in summer they get flipped so they're no longer used uh
I actually kind of find that interesting um because that just means hey these really good opportunities for us are now gone uh so yeah this is this is a nice thing like yeah I guess the water washes them away or whatever theme it's supposed to be overall the question kind of comes down to do you if you don't own either which one do you get actually let's before I get answer that the question is if you own everdale should you also get farore and I would emphatically say no like there is zero reason to pay $100 for this game like because and there's actually it's not like the components are nice it's wooden pieces like it's what is it it's um I think it's beavers yeah they have crabs beavers puffins and ducks like I've always liked that they that the workers they're nice wooden the cardboard is good the card stocks good the art is amazing um like they do the same thing where like these mushrooms are spongy the seaweed is weird feeling they have these gems and the wood the components are nice however I mean metal anchors that that's not Kickstarter extra stuff it's hey this is what the comes with however I will also say that this game gave me
the worst board warpage I have ever ever experienced borderline unplayable where I actually have emailed the company hoping to get a replacement because it got warped so bad that I actually had to bow it to be able to fold it back up like it it would not just naturally close that's how bad it is the cards kind of getting get that weird curve and I expect that I play in a basement so but even then the shittiest production quality of games that I've played before have never been as bad as what this board gave me so for $100 or 80 if you go off their secret shop and really give them the real price of it um it's 100% not worth it I I don't think so like even though some slight tweaks that farore has and it's a it's a different theme the reason why that this isn't an expansion is because they already did their complete collection like if they never did that complete collection I don't think this is a separate game I think this is an expansion um but they stretched it out and tried to come up with enough differences to be able to make a different game and be like hey yeah we're going to capitalize off the everdell IP uh don't you like the art which I do I do love the art so then it's like okay well like if you don't have either if you don't have everdell
and you don't have farore which one should you get I would still say everdell because it does have the expandability and there's no doubt in my mind that they would that they're not going to make expansions to this why wouldn't they um they literally have like a whole map of their world which I was looking at the map and I could I I'm like what is farore where is it is that just the title is that cuz all the other locations are real locations on the map I was like is over here farore like like does it thematically tell you where you're at Rugged Coast north of everdell Valley so maybe I need to look for everdell Valley and place um and and see if it's on there but yeah like it's I mean you get your water stuff from the pearlbrook expansion I mean it's not quite like this but it's it's like I guess yeah four aquatic creatures um but yeah like everdale just has the sheer expandability too much I would still say like that complete collection I see so many things and hear so many people of who haven't played it since they got that thing it is too big and I I agree like I've tried to play and I'm just like uh that's just a lot of stuff even though it's organized very well this I mean yeah I would just say go get everell because if you want expansions let's say this is like everdell becomes your favorite game and you play it every single night then yeah you can be like
ooh now let's get this expansion you have options to pick from farore currently does not have that but yeah just something rubs me the wrong way about how this game came about and kind of the weird things that they did with retail stores and that could just be that could be my tin foil hat uh like maybe there was no malicious you know intent behind it but it's just kind of weird that it's like for $100 this game is not worth that at all I even have a hard time paying would pay paying 80 and for the record this is not my copy this is a friend's copy who let me borrow it for this review I did not shell that money because I don't give a [ __ ] about that like it's it's just no I don't think the changes are worth it I don't think this game is different enough from Bas everdale it has a better solo variant you can watch my solo variant discussion on that and that's the major difference uh and all the the the stuff that's better in this game you could actually apply into everdell so it's like well you made some differences that were better but I have everything for everdell so I'm just going to put those in that and there we go like problem solved H yeah it's just this this game just feels like as much of a c like and I thought Sean was the king of cash grabs this one just feels like oh [ __ ]
we accidentally stopped making content for everdell well what can we do to keep making money off of everdell um yeah so I mean it's still a good game that's the weird part like it's still everdale and that I mean it's still good still solid uh of a system but I feel like that is almost a redundant thing to say at this point because everell exists if this game came out first it'd get the same hype that everell got unfortunately it didn't and now it just feels weird um which brings me to on a scale of 1 to 10 what do I give farore and uh it's it's like it's weird because normally price doesn't get brought up at least I try not to take into consideration whenever I'm giving these rankings like whatever you know for what they're worth um CU I really like everdell and every expansion except pearlbrook which is a fine expansion every expansion after that has just slapped so I really like everdell it like cranked up into my top 10 and my top 100 at one point uh like I have ever Del at a nine I'm gonna give this one uh God this
[ __ ] uh I'll give it a seven it's still a good game but if I'm taking into consideration like the price and the weirdness that I've heard and read about with their weird ass [ __ ] over retail companies to push people towards their store and the warped board and some of the minor changes I don't really care for I could also take it down to a six which is still slightly above average but game itself like take out everything everel doesn't exist none of that exists this game is still $100 retail 80 if you get it from their store yeah I'd still give it a seven um but that that kind of comes with a lot of caveats which is very rare like these these types of reviews don't really come out where it's like uh or it's like man hm there's a lot of weird background you know [ __ ] that that comes with this review so it's like seven asteris oh what's the asteris mean if you don't know noell if you don't take into press consideration any any of that so uh yeah six with all the extra stuff considered seven by itself and that's it everyone that is my thoughts on farshore let me know what you think think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time upd it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that
subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and sub subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you