The Gardens Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm taking a look at the gardens which is a one to four player board game designed by brett gilbert and matthew dunstan this one takes around 30 to 45 minutes to play on average but before i get into my review on the gardens i just want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kianda.coduk who are my go-to online retailer in the uk and if you use my link in the show notes you can get five percent off your first order but let's get into the review on the gardens okay so the setup for the gardens is going to look somewhat like this where you have these three different rows of cards to draft from you've got three different decks here you've got the a deck the b deck and the c deck and the number of cards from each deck that are on display is going to depend or vary on the play account so in a three or four player game you're gonna have three or four cards respectively but in a two player game you're also going to have four cards because you actually draft twice the number of cards um so in a three or four player game you're gonna play over eight rounds and in a two player game you're gonna play over four rounds you've also got the main board here which is essentially a score track and you've got these variable objectives which are the criteria you're trying to aim for to gather points throughout the game and also each player is going to have their own individual player board that look like this and these are modulus you can actually change them around if you want to but i recommend just playing the basic way here where you've got these two boards up next to each other and you've got this default strip down the middle and on this strip you have three meeples one for each of those rows
so each player's turn is going to be rather simple where the start team player with the one with this kind of a bird token here is going to have first choice to draft any of these cards from either of these rows so let's just say for example here the first player wanted to choose these double trees here like this and because it's come from the b row it has to go in the middle row of your personal player board and also when you place these cards you have to build from the middle outwards so at the moment i can only place it here or here but as i build more cars i can start spreading out like so so let's just say i ended up placing this card like this and then i'm going to move the meeple from that row onto the card that i've just placed like so and that is going to be kind of the one of the unique mechanisms about the game and all of the different features on these cars you've got these trees you've got these lakes you've got fountains you've got these benches and you've also got these statues and roads all of those different features are going to score in a different way so you've got these four features that score at the end of the game and you've got three features that scored during the game so you can see here that the trees the ones i've just placed are going to score points based on how many i pass through um so let's have a look here so i place this um this tree like so i'm going to move it from that one to this one and that means i've now touched two two trees and that also counts from the one you started from um you are going to have a look on this little worm tile here and see how many trees i passed through ie two and that's going to give me three points so i'll be up three on
the score track and i believe there's four different types of these feature trees and you're only going to score for the one on the card that you've just placed and once the first player has finished placing the card moving their meeple and maybe getting points it's going to go to the next player to draft however when they draft they do not need to choose from the same row that you've just chosen from they can actually pick any from the display so let's just say the next player chose this one here and put it on their board and then the third player wanted to choose this one here like so and then it'll get back to the original player um however now the original player has already placed a card in the middle row or the b row then they are not allowed to choose another card from that row they're going to have to choose another one so each round you're going to place one card on each of the three rows so let's just say for example um they wanted to choose this one here and again because it's on the a row you're going to have to put on the a row here like so and again move the meeple from these the spot that it's already on onto the car that you've just placed i've touched one tree therefore that's going to get me another point so at the end of the game your playable is going to look something like this where every single spot has a card placed on it and then you're going to add the all the points you've got during the game to the end game scoring criteria but let's have a look at how all the different criteria score so we've already covered the trees and how they work by we know placing a card and then whatever you land on or pass through you're going to get a corresponding amount of points depending on the amount of trees of that type that
you've passed through the fountains here work in a very similar way but you get a point for every lake or fountain that you cross through you've also got the park benches here which will score you a point for every surrounding car that you have on your player board so when you place these cars you want to be making sure that you've already built a bit of infrastructure around it to get the most points out of that placement uh you've got these end game scoring ones here where you're going to score a number of points depending on the amount of different trees you have on each row so if you have all four different tree types or the featured tree types then you get 10 points but if you only have say two you're gonna get three points you've got these um lake scoring ones here which will score you five points if you have a whole column of matching lake like this but if you only have ever have two um out of the three then you're going to score two points rather than the five and you've got this one here which is going to score you a point for each connected road you have in your longest kind of sequence so i think i've done quite well here by having it one two three four five six 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 i believe so that's quite a good um achievement there and you've got this statue one here because you can see some of these cards have statues on and where you're going to score 10 points for every other player that you have more statues than so that one adds a little bit of player interaction into the mix and there are a bunch of other scoring tiles that you can choose to use these are slightly more advanced than the base ones and but not terribly more so now
you've got ones here where the statues want to be um or not adjacent to the statues so you want to have them isolated on their own i know each column of fountains that you have you're going to get more points you've got ones here where you want to have the you score points for your biggest cluster of focal trees and regardless if it's a rows or columns you've got ones like this where you want to have the pathways connecting to park benches and so on and you get the gist so there's quite a lot of modularity there if you want to kind of tweak the rules slightly there is a further advanced variant that you can choose to play with where you have these illustrations already on your player boards and then during the setup of the game you're going to put these cards on the matching spots and that is going to add some more interaction to the game where if you are the first player to place your card on that spot then you are either going to get victory points depending on the orientation that card is flipped or you can get an end game or in-game bonus so they'll do things such as this one here where you can either get 10 points if it's facing that way or at the end of the game choose one type of focal tree and score two points for every tree of this type in your garden or you've got the opera house here which will give you 10 points or at the end of the game score 10 points for every complete loop in your pathways so just little tweaks on the rules here just to add a little bit more depth okay so let's get into my thoughts on the gardens so you could probably tell there from the little play through that this is certainly tailored towards a lighter you know more introductory level gamer which of course is absolutely fine um but the thing that drew me into this game the thing that
sold it to me and made me back on kickstarter was this meeple movement system you know i've never seen this used before i think it's a very novel mechanism and i certainly feel like it's got a lot of potential you know this idea of placing a car down and then moving or physically moving a meeple from one row to another spot on that row and depending on what you pass through is going to get you points that kind of adds a bit of legacy to the game where your previous decisions are going to affect future decisions and that again that is the thing that really did sell me on this one now i will admit that i think that this mechanism has a ton of potential but i do feel like this game has almost hamstrung itself by being so light because all these features score in pretty much the same way they're not terribly interesting in the way they work you know you're going to score points based on how many trees you pass through or how many you know lakes or fountains you pass through it's like there's not much variation in what they do and how they score and how that mechanism is actually exploited to make it feel different now that being said i do think that the idea of building your tableau out adds a bit more weight to the way that that meeple movement system works because you know again because you have to start from the middle and build outwards as you go you can send that sometimes end up building cards right next to each other which means that you know if i if last round my meep was here and then i place this card i'm only going to move one spot which is going to somewhat limit my potential to score points on that round however if i end up building like a cluster of the same features here and then i end up kind of going back and forth you know going back here and then
back here and then back here and then back here then you're probably going to end up scoring more and more of those multipliers by placing you know the same feature down so there is a good balancing between the two and how you are going to keep dragging that muffle back and forth throughout the throughout the rows that adds a little bit more depth to the game which i did appreciate now i must admit that i did find the drafting system a bit too restrictive especially at the three or four player account where you're essentially just drafting one card per row and quite often there is nothing you're interested in in that row there might just be a bunch of lakes and you've not really focused on lakes and um you're not going to add or you're not going to end up scoring many points for them at all and there's nothing really much you can do about that now i do understand why they have kept the pool so tight because it adds more kind of consequence and more tension to each of the drafts because you need to prioritize things accordingly um you know if you really wanted this road here because it's going to connect a bunch of your roads then you're going to do that and you're going to fall behind on the other ones but that's that being said i do feel like they would have been better if there was a few more options there to actually get more potential of scoring from the tiles because a lot of the time i felt like i just had you know a choice there that no matter what i choose is going to be crap so that was a bit frustrating at times for me personally i do think there's a good mix of in-game and end game points and it's nice that you do have some variation there too just to tweak the gameplay and to change the end game and in-game objectives and how all the different features score so again just add a little bit of life into the game and it's kind of a good balance
between the two you know do you really want to focus on you know getting all the same trees in the same rows to exploit this meeple system or are you going to take a more balanced strategy and get all the different types in a row and they're of course going to conflict with each other because you've only got so much space in your in your or in your actual board and of course you are restricted by the car drafts in the first place so you're always having to adjust on the fly to see how you're gonna get the most points from each of these different tiles now that being said i do feel like these towels are not terribly interesting or creative i mean if you're familiar with these style of games then you're probably aware that there's a lot of games of this type out there um you know are you just placing things on your board and scoring points based on public objectives or public tiles and this one doesn't really do anything new and even at times it feels like the turns are not terribly eventful you know you place the car down you might get a point for a tray it's like you know big work it doesn't feel it doesn't feel like you're achieving much at times if you're crossing through four trees at a time sometimes it feels a bit more rewarding when you're getting a big chunk of ten points but generally it's a bit bitter you're getting a few points here a few points there um yeah you can get some more you know bigger chunks of points at the end of the game if you end up building a big network of roads or something but i must admit it did feel a bit incremental and it doesn't feel like you pull off those big incredible satisfying tones and that also applies to the extra tiles these are i think they're written in the book as advanced tiles and i will say that they don't really feel advanced
they are very slightly more complex than the base game ones or the you know the recommended starting setup so again they all still feel a bit predictable and a bit you get feels like they've been done 100 times before there are a few ones that are a bit more interesting i yeah quite like this one here where you have to have a balanced kind of number of feature trees on each side of your centerpiece so that adds a bit more long-term strategy and has a bit more attention to keep the things balanced but generally speaking they're all just again minor tweaks on the original ones i think one thing that works in this game's advantage is how quick it takes to play you know you are looking at 30 minutes on average maybe slightly more than that at the full play account but not much more and you know all the turns are snappy they're quick the rules are digestible you can get it explained in a few minutes and everyone's going to pretty much know what to do so it doesn't now stay as welcome and it feels like quite a breezy quick experience the player interaction mainly does come through the competition for the cards you want and how you're going to prioritize your draft um however i did mention that the statue feature does add some just interaction into the game because you want to be having more statues than your opponent so it is nice they made that a little bit of effort to add a bit more competition to the game um but generally speaking you're gonna be focusing on your own board and just reacting to what's available to you i don't feel this has that level of hate drafting or anything like that you're just going to be working on your own puzzle and if that affects other people then so be it it's not really something
you're going to be directly looking to do the game does scale pretty well and i have to say i think the game works best at one or two players now the reason i say that is because at two players you actually have two cards per row per round which means you have some contingency plans if people draft cards that you wanted before you get the chance to so again you can have a bit more of a bigger picture in your mind and can tailor your strategy more towards the public objectives and that also applies to the solo mode where say you have a lake in each of the rows you can maybe look at doing that for your turn you're building a whole column of lakes and scoring the corresponding amount of points where you know in the three or four player rounds if people snatch that card you're pretty much just left at their mercy and have to deal with what's left i think the game is wonderfully produced particularly when it comes to the visual um design it has a unique look and i can't really think of any other game that uses this look this kind of like old school brochure advertising poster visuals that really works for the game and i must admit it was actually one of these selling points to me yeah especially when everything is said and done and your board is finished it has a very nice look to it now the cardstock is of a good quality these are linen finished cards and they are of a good size that it's good that they're not too big because it doesn't take up too much room but smaller might have been a little bit fiddly so i think they've chosen the exact right card size here um the main board itself is dual layer where you can slot in these scoring tiles and they're not going to move anywhere which is quite nice and but everything else is just just just well finished nice nicely
polished and i've certainly got no quibbles at all with the way the game has been produced and made okay so let's get into some final thoughts on the gardens so i must admit that i was left a little bit wanting from this game for me it felt like it was a bit too simple um and that's not because the game is too light i'm certainly not against light games at all in fact i like a lot of light games but i do feel like this one has a glass ceiling on what it does and how it works i was completely enamored with the way the game looks and really intrigued about this meeple movement system i would have loved to have seen this exploited to a higher standard and i still think there's a lot of potential here to how this could be used but in reality this is just very simple stuff now i also feel like this puzzly style game mixed with the variable objectives has been done better through other designs that are very slightly more complex or more advanced than this one i'm talking games such as cartographers or the isle of skye i just think those games are just more enjoyable they have a more of a visceral attention to them and there's just something about them that just i extract more enjoyment from now i do appreciate that this is tailored towards a more introductory level gamer um but even that being said i do feel like if you're teaching this to someone who's not played many games at all then even then they are going to move on quickly from it because there's only so much you can get from this in my opinion and that even applies
to the additional kind of um modules and stuff you could add in to add a bit more complexity to it it just feels like it's been done before and you know although there's nothing glaringly wrong with it i just feel like it's a bit flat line for me and it feels like i've played this game before 10 times so unfortunately despite how gorgeous it is i'd love to see this artwork used again because it looks wonderful um i just feel like there's not much here for you know for you to spend too much time on and i don't think it's ultimately worth your time or attention when you could be playing some of these other games i mentioned so sadly not a recommendation from me that is the gardens