Canvas Reflections Review - Beyond The Base Game
Transcript
we just make boxes here hello I'm Luke Hector and this is the broken me pole a showed toot of the boarding card games and you're watching Beyond the base game this is where I talk about expansions to board games specifically because many other people can't be bothered this is for two expansions to Canvas I'm going to do two videos both should be pretty small one for Reflections and one for finishing touches which is the L one to come out so canvas you would have already seen my review and the rating I gave it this comes in a very similar box quite a big in fact I would dare say probably too big we'll get on that a little bit later but this one claims to add a new game board gold ribbons new type of scoring and reversible transparent cards they call mirror cards now canvas as you might already know is super light super fluffy you basically pick a card from a row draft it and you make a colorful art piece with three of these transparent sleeve cards and create an art piece and try and meet the criteria of scoring cards so the first thing you're going to notice yeah big board remember that lovely little play map from the from the original set this lovely thing sorry it's got to leave us I'm afraid yep we now have a bigger board I don't know how I kind of feel about that I mean could we have not had a playm as well but to have a board that I've got to flatten that has for the life of me I don't know why it has free holes in it that you can punch out is that meant to be easier to pick up the cards I'm not entirely sure but it's kind of weird why it's there
but yeah I don't know would have liked the little playmap but that being said this now has storage for all the ribbons it has storage for the different car scoring cards tells you how much the ribbons are worth and of course it has room for the transparent cards themselves and basically what does this expansion add other than just a bigger board well because you've got more cards and you've got a bit more Choice instead of only having five slots to pick from you now effectively have columns so same thing applies where you've got to put inspiration tokens on you know the columns as you go past and you do start with more but you've got to put one per per row on here so it is quite a lot more inspiration tokens you could be spending but essentially you are now picking from eight cards rather than only five so it gives you a little bit more option in that regard and of course you have a few more scoring cards so there are some specific ones here that are dedicated to this expansion but then there are also a couple that are just you know unique with the previous game and it just gives you more variety in how the game can score and you have gold ribbons which match certain point generating things on these transparent sleeves they're three points each if you get one you get one happy days but wait there's more so what is the real difference here well you have these mirror cards here and all of these in the new deck are mirror cards you mix and match these with the previous 70 that you had in the original box and basically you fill the Box up as much as it can go and put the rest away so you are going to get a bit of variety in the game now but basically these function exactly like the typical cards except now as well as what it has on one side
if you turn it the other way it has the mirrored image of what it is and hopefully I'll have photos to show you but for example here I had a gold ribbon in the very center is green and a triangle on the burgundy uh Swatch here but as soon as I turn it around it's now red and it's on this side so mirroring swapping these around essentially gives you like the opposite color swatches but keeps the symbols the same so what this now does is that it opens up a little bit of extra choice and variety when you're constructing your art piece because previously you had to choose three out of five cards and that was all you kind of had it was fixed in that position but now you could have a bunch of cards where you'll have like a mixture from both expansions sorry for the expansion in the base game and you'll be like right well I can do this one on there there hang on a minute if I turn this around ah great that means that lines up hang on turn this one around there okay and turn up that one there we go oh cool so it already opens up a lot more choice and these are a cool addition to the game and frankly very easy to teach with I mean you can play this with non- Gamers without much trouble to be honest I mean if they got the original game I can't quite see why they wouldn't get it with this stuff thrown in I mean all you've got to explain to them is this is a type of card that you can turn over whoop you do did that really take much extra brain power but it does open up a bit more depth and a bit more Choice here and that's most of what the game really gives you there's not much else I mean the rule book is l literally like about four pages total including front and back there really is nothing here
there's an overview of the icons it tells you the rules changes which frankly is mainly just how you draft the cards that's pretty much the only difference and it just mentions a couple of differences if you were playing the one and two player variant from before which again is very minor and I wasn't necessarily playing those variants anyway the only minor other thing on here is the Masterpiece variant which frankly not the biggest fan of really I mean this is is you know it's two it effectively gives you a way to have two winners now I could see people maybe young families doing this you know when you've got your kids playing this and they want to have a little bit of an extra incentive to make a pretty pitcher I am totally down with that I can't see Gamers taking this up essentially you have the best in show award which is basically whoever got the most points is the winner so you just give them this little token and say you won well done the Masterpiece variant and I will quote from the sheet here I am not joking here each player displays one of their paintings and explains its meaning as a group discuss the artwork presented and award the Masterpiece ribbon to the player with the best painting the painter of the Masterpiece and the winner of Best show share the victory right okay I mean I get this works with kids this is not something I ever use nor will I bother it's just a weird little gimmick it's not worth it but I can see why some people would but it's a variant it's not part of the game it's just something I'm not going to bother with I mean I'm not even going to bother with this token because you just don't need it whoever won the game won the
game that's good enough for me I'm not going to sit there trying to have a you know big massive discussion about whether my uh you know my giant uh let's see flip this over yeah lost giant which is effectively a giraffe looking at a signpost is somehow meaningful and some way it's just not something I'm going to do but as I say I digress it's a minor thing whatever and that's pretty much of the expansion is it is just that but there are one or two things to bear in mind here first of all you are going to have storage issues yeah remember when I hinted that in the first base uh base game video where I said that you had this big box and you know you were pretty much at the mercy of this box there wasn't much other room well um you only have a thin box this time and you have to put in this board which when folded down is quite a bulky board this takes up most of the space that is in this box and it will certainly take up a majority of the space in here granted there is a little size difference like not very not very much you know there's a tiny little bit of extra gir in the base box but it won't be enough to hold everything and certainly bear in mind there's another expansion I've got to look at yet you're not going to get everything into one box so how do they deal with this well they essentially introduce this little gimmick where essentially if I put the box here and then I put the Box here it makes a panoramic picture now I'm not going to deny that looks brilliant it looks lovely and gorgeous and bear in mind
there's going to be a third one here to continue the picture however there is a point a line that you must draw where having a gimmick becomes non-practical this is not a game that is super heavy and needs a bucket load of storage I mean if you put these three together you know with the other expansion to come it takes up about the same amount of room if not more than a typical box whe so I mean here's a g here's like a Lera one up here well two of them are as wide or maybe just slightly wider than one the s box so you're effectively using up half a calic shelf to store all three of these eventually and all that is in the other box is just more sleeves a board and a few extra tokens could we have not just had like a bigger box to begin with and not gone with this whole gimmick of I can hang it up on my wall and make it look pretty and stuff and thought more about the Practical applications where somebody might actually want to store everything in one box and have it all together and now they selling it you're sell it it's annoying having to store multiple boxes for this when essentially you're going to use everything because frankly there's no reason you would separate out the expansion in this it's so simple and light that you're just going to mix it all together and teach it to a brand new new gamer anyway but now I've got to get it out of two separate boxes and that's just annoying I don't like that and bear in mind like I said I keep reiterating this there's a
third box to deal with so you're going to have three boxes to open this is just a stupid idea I get it it looks pretty yes it's lovely and gorgeous and it's going to look amazing if you hang them up on your wall but I'm not hanging these games up on my wall I'm putting them on a shelf and I'm playing with them you know you just because you could doesn't mean that you should they didn't St to think of they should but the expansion is still solid it's an auto include once you've got these cards out and this board and the mirror cards you're not going to separate them out so it is easy to factor in it's just a painter store and it's also not the cheapest thing in the world again you paid 40 quid nearly for the original canvas you're paying a good 30 odd pound for these you know expansions as well is canvas really going to be game that you're going to spend nearly £100 on to get the EXP to get the canvas game this and the next expansion it's a tall order I do admit it's not the best value for money other than the fact that it does look gorgeous although to be honest I think I would have probably liked to playm B rather than the like a f do board because I think the playmat looks better or at least feels better remember K of GA that thing had like a little bamboo type board thing that you rolled out that was really nice would have been great if it had something similar and this you know you could have scaled it down a tiny bit you don't need all the space here for scoring cards and storing ribbons we could do what we like with that you just needed something to hold the display of cards that would have been enough and
maybe just a couple of little scoring bits and still to this day there is no score pad no score pad they still haven't put a score pad in here you're charging me like 30 plus 35 quid for this sort of thing can you not just put in a score pad I know there's not a ton to add up but it doesn't hurt it does not hurt but those things aside it's still a cool expansion so those blemishes aside I'm giving it an 8 out of 10 it's a good solid expansion from a gameplay perspective there is more Choice there are more scoring cards there is more variety I think the mirror cards are a great way to add a little bit of extra depth to the game without making it overly complex so it does the job ticks the boxes it just suffers a few blemishes from being an irritating storage solution and kind of removing redundant Co components from the old set which I now have to store somewhere I'm not going to Chuck them away but I got to put them somewhere and just you know putting in weird little variants like this but all in all still good 8 out of 10 so will finishing touches be as good we have to wait and see so that's it for me on this episode of the broken me if you like what you see then please thumb it up on YouTube and thumb it up on Board Game Geek when it goes live on the official page check out the canas review by all means i' be questioning why you didn't go to that one first but also check out the finishing touches review when I go into that one that will be another shortage video I hope by all means let me know your comments below do you agree or disagree with what I'm saying how have you stored all this canvas stuff once you got it going I'd be very interested know did you somehow get it into one box did you use all
three do you actually hang them up on your wall be interested to see if anyone actually does that but you that should be an interesting thing to see until next time regardless of whether you consider my uh juvenile mishap a masterpiece or not it's still only a game so bye for now