Underwater Cities - Board Game Review
Transcript
hey folks we've got a doozy of a detail review and it is underwater cities from Vladimir now black Masucci is the same bloke who did post our 28:49 if you've been paying attention to recent videos you all know that's one of the points salad games that super dry super mechanical for some reason I like don't ask me why that transformation happened with that particular game probably because it's very streamlined it gives you a lot of options but maybe it's mostly damn it I like dice placement anyway and more variety is good yes it's a complete drypoint salad but that's just something about its streamlined mechanics work take note publishers so when I heard that he was doing a heavier euro game for underwater cities as like oh okay more stuff from him this will be good hang on a minute heavier and then I started learning that it was like a good free our game it was pretty heavy quite brain Baroni was still gonna be relatively super dry you know mostly just mechanics it's like no you hit once food bowls are 2049 but I don't know if you're gonna hit it twice weird underwater cities you are building well literally underwater cities mean it's in the title come on and of course the objective is to have the most victory points of course and to accomplish this you are building cities and tunnels underwater and in these cities you get to build little buildings light labs and farms and desalination plants it's how you pronounce it the stuff that tastes so out of water and you're doing this by a very interesting mechanic of cards you
cut me I mean come on what cards you know that's nothing well hear me out here it's kind of card worker placement in a sense you have several slots on the board four or five slots per color green red and yellow the idea being that you will play a card on one of these slots to trigger a location action but if you can play a card at the same color as the action as the location that you're going to you get to trigger not only the location action but also the card action so you want to be as efficient as you can and get the most actions the most benefits and bonuses throughout the whole game in playing these cards you will do things like adjust turn order build cities produce resources make tunnels upgrade buildings you know collect more cards you know would you want more cards off the deck which are you know they're chopping change in three different phases of the game would you want some special cards that are you know you don't know which ones are going to appear each game and six of them a completely random out of a selection of in game scoring cards it's very much a hand management that tableau management building game yeah of course you're building like little city domes and little tunnels and little beat cities on this little player board map in front of you but when all things said and done themes not the strongest element of this game it's more the mechanics of those cards it is the bread and butter of this game you carry on through free errors you play a certain amount of rounds then have a bit of a scoring and production phase then another round same again run around same again and some end game scoring occurs it so it's you know it's on Rails and terms of the rounds you
know when it's going to end there's no surprise ending here but throughout that it's all about playing those cards and having that limitation of only four cards in your tableau in front of you play out a lot during the game of course you know does it can he can you do it twice you can lightning strike twice in this occasion let's look at it in more detail duration is depends on your perspective it's a weak point for me but not quite as bad as I've seen in other games it depends again on what your tolerance level is this is a long game full-stop fact end of discussion it's long the box has 40 minutes per snorkel okay prepare but I like the symbol users on it and okay 40 minutes per player is on average what you're gonna do actually this is pretty accurate yeah you will at best to be able to do 30 minutes of player if all of you know what you're doing and you don't have to check the RULES and you don't have to teach the game 30 minutes of player but like I say golden scenario but let's go back to the real world here and suggest that you're teaching new players or you have the occasional slowest one or you have to look up the rulebook every now and again or you might have to teach it or people just want to actually talk during the game and you are looking at about 40 to 45 minutes of player so you will play this solo and chances are it will take you about an hour and you know hour tops and then two players somewhere around
this 19 minute mark free player is easily looking around a two hour - in a bit mark - at a quarter two and a half tops and fruit for players huh for players thing would be anything from like two hours if you really are in that golden scenario - anything like three to three-and-a-half hours I have heard tales of people taking four hours plus with this game that's a bit extreme I'll admit longest I've had was freeing a bit hours with four players but there wasn't that many new players in there and I was already used to the game at that point so it's definitely long except that and as far as I can tell for - and free player it doesn't overstay its welcome it's it's decent enough it you know you're engaged between turns more than a bit later but you don't feel that there's too much downtime yes you gotta wait for your turn to get background but there's plenty enough for you to think about on your turn particularly as this is more of a tactical and strategic game again more on that later for players though you're engaged but for players is just that step too much this is a game that really needs to take three hours it doesn't need to be that long but it does well at a two to two-and-a-half hour mark so four players is very dependent on who you're playing the game with and I know you can say that about a lot of games but with this one especially you are looking at a two and a half plus our game with this and I feel that you don't get enough interaction with other players to warrant that length this is mostly a
multiplayer solitaire game yes you can get blocked out locations for that is no different than any other worker placement game there is no card to interact with the other players you cannot go and destroy their base you can't go infiltrate their base or anything like that it's purely a case of who took the space or the objective before you did so for the most part it's multiplayer solitaire does it need to have that many players does it need to have that longer time length so it's not too bad I have played a lot worse the caves taking far too long don't why not but you know for the board it is it's just about enough engagement to not overstay its welcome well without four players anyway but ease of play this is a heavy game guys come on some people have tried to claim it's like mid wait I'm sorry games like viticulture are mid-weight and they're still fairly involved as a you know you have to play at least once or twice to get the hang of it but it's not too complex that's more mid white euro this is heavy I mean you know you've got to contemplate you know what cards you've got in your hand what cards are you know what spaces are available you know what resources you need the feeding of your people the you know the four cards in your tableau you know are some of them actions that need to be triggered there's a special card there don't want to grab it now before someone else does do I have the you know the objectives if you choose to play with them can I meet one of those how long
it's gonna take me to build a city so I can get points before the error finishes and if there's a lot to take in and thankfully the rulebook does a good job of helping you out with this this is a very good rulebook there are one or two ambiguous parts in it but nothing too bad you know nothing that you couldn't sort of figure out with a quick FAQ look or certainly we're just maybe a little bit common-sense now that I think about it but the rule books very well laid out it's logical it's in the right orders in terms of steps that you should learn it's fairly clear written and there's a lot of pictorial examples good pictorial examples not just a tiny little screenshot no proper examples of how things like construction works how the network what your network is made up of and trust me that takes a little bit to get your head round you know what's connected and what isn't but again there's pictorial examples that's a good set up diagram there's good diagrams for the cards basically you should be able to pick up this game with relative ease if you are used to this weight game already people compare this to terraforming Mars it's got similarities but I don't think they're quite the same game but certainly if you're used to a game of that way - no terraforming Mars type wait you're gonna get into this without too much trouble do not stick this in front of a new player though or even a next step game is way too much out there I mean if they were blown away by the likes of Paul Sartre 28:49 for example this will melt their brain it's just not gonna work yeah this is definitely a gamers game I wouldn't want to put anyone remotely ap in this game because oh my dad if somebody is if somebody
plays this game who would normally ap I will happily open the lot was it an air lock when it's underwater I don't know but either way I would just drown them outside before I'd let them play this game because it's not a game that you want to have your analysis process prone player here because there's a lot of options a lot of choices to make a lot of decision-making throughout and it's very tactical which means that a lot of the time you kind of have to think on the fly a bit ap players will kill in this game there's a nut for them at all but like I say good rule book heavy weight not for newbies not for the slow but it's because hey I expected this to be a lot harder to get into and I found that with the aid of that rule book wasn't actually too bad tactics and strategy now this is where this game starts to shine a bit more because this isn't a strategic game you can't really play this in a strategic kind of way you might think well you know this time I'm gonna munchkin on farms or I'm in a munchkin labs or I'm gonna go around and get those free metropolis or I'm gonna maybe just build a ton of tunnels building on the cities maybe I'll just stay in two or three cities and really build them up I don't know you can't really do that though because like terraforming Mars I know I make the comparisons but there are similarities you know terraforming Mars gets a little bit flat welcome me anyway everybody else seems to ignore this fact that it has a bit of luck involved doesn't matter if you draft the cards you're
still drawing from this giant deck of cards and you might have a corp that says oh I I get to bonuses and that when I make trees right I'm gonna make trees this game and you never see any tree cards it happens a lot so there's that element there it's the same here though you are drawing from a deck of cards you draw one every turn you can draw more cards with actions but again you are drawing from a deck of cards and you may find cards that are good for what you wanted to do and some another pretty rubbish and it's not like they give you a lot of choice on those cards they're either good or they're bad there's not really much middle ground here so you can't really do a strategy throughout you have to think tactically because you could be thinking right well let's see if I play that now and get that bonus which could be used to do that one finite draw another card or what's pretty sweet you know what maybe that can wait if I do that one first you know and see that action card in front of me of I will trigger it now good got the bonus do I really need it again can I be bothered to wait until the error finishes before I change it up okay maybe I will play this action card over here claim it and replace that card with that one it's done its job there's a lot of that you have to really be capable of thinking on the fly you need a plan you need a back-up plan and you need a back-up plan to the back-up plan because if people take your spot which frequently happens particularly in free before player you gonna need some other ideas and sometimes you will just get blocked out of a location for the round and you really want to go there and it's like well if that don't work what's the
next best thing you really need to get a move on with so there's definitely more tactics and strategy but it's engaging I mentioned with the duration that it's a long game but the fact that you have to think tactically means that you are engaged for the most part between turns you'll get times where you know you can't really think too far ahead because the game board state might change by the time it gets around to you and if four players that really does happen but you know you can at least be thinking right well that's good that's good right that's on their turn we're still good for that but just in case you might take that space I'm gonna keep this other one in mind you know but occasionally may just get background to your turn and suddenly it's like well you just screwed up my plan you screwed up my back-up plan so hmm give me a second quick you know and you've got to think of something else you got to be quick about it but it will keep you engaged you're not often gonna be sitting there going you know for players you probably will be but two to three players no not so much you're gonna be involved it's fun to play those card combos and you know the the main aspect of this game the card played with the tact with the location spaces and trying to match the colors is also the best part of this game you know trying to come up with cool combos trying to make the most of all these cards it's never satisfying to just go you know well there's a card I'll just do two resources from that location unless you're desperate for that location action it's much more fun to be able to go I could play that read over there and get this and listen and I'll play the other over here and get this and this
you know I always want to trigger as many bonuses as I can granted that doesn't always mean that I'm playing the best move because I might be trying to get too many bonuses when actually I just needed this one key thing you've got to chop and change and know when the big battles and when you know when to hold the win the folder but yeah it's engaging very tactical and I like it the card play in this is great fun just like the dice in pulsar were great fun the cards and this one a great fun certainly for me more entertaining than the draft in terrifying Mars and similar similar games like that I just think there's something about trying to create those combos that's more satisfying and just simply picking a card but you know strokes for folks so far looking good aesthetics this takes a little bit more of a nosedive well not not too far maybe shallow waters you know it certainly is pretty in terms of color you've got bright blue and a blue so you've got blues everywhere because it is underwater after all but you've also got the bright green yellow and red of the cards and on the board it is littered with iconography like a ton but thankfully there's text on the card so if you don't understand you like a dog refer you can always just read the text good I like it when games do that kudos but it's not entirely great component quality wise I think it looks nice I mean there's nothing much on here to go all this fantastic artwork is a pretty basic map of the world and your player board is just some basic like water effects now say it looks good and yeah I
work on the cards themselves again it looks nice it looks colorful and vibrant but the cards themselves are not the best quality they're quite thin and you're gonna be using these are lot yeah putting them on your tableau putting them on the locations picking them up shuffling around drawing them from a deck shuffling other decks there's a lot of card draw card manipulation the cards will wear and tear if you're not careful you really ought to sleeve these and it's gonna currently cost you about a tenner and premium sleeves in order to sleeve as many cards as are in this game and then find a way to store them and stack them on the board so they don't slide around everywhere it's it's all that but I do recommend you sleeve the cards in this game though I mean I'm already like collating together an order when I need to start getting some more sleeves for this until then I'm like no it's it's kind of worrisome on top of that you know the domes are okay they're just little plasticky domes but they look the part the tunnels are just a little bit cardboard chits and so does everything else resource chit chit when 2019 people can we not do baron in cardboard chits but you know they they look ok but there's nothing particularly special about them and there really isn't enough in the box I mean you're constantly having to change up ones to freeze and everything especially when you get to the third error of this game where production is so insane and off the charts that you're producing things a lot faster than you can physically use them and so there isn't enough compose in a box to favor three or four players it's pretty annoying at times and then
on top of that you've got that building that all beads these tiny little circle little circle disks or plastic disks and burn up they look nice except they're every small very small you have to put them on this little space next to the domes there's free spots for if you expand it and one of its own is fine but then you stack two in order to have an upgraded version and then you do this multiple times throughout the game and so one little nudge and suddenly these beads all over the place and then you're trying to stack them up again and because you've got the domes Neman else in the way you're basically having to play tweezers your fat fingers in order to get these beads to balance on top of these things anybody with OCD is gonna have a field day with these when they're slightly out of sync with each other yeah so it's okay I've certainly the colors and the art gets me more into this then the the whole butt component quality side I feel that a deluxe version would have been better maybe like just an upgrade in the component quality there's already people on Etsy doing different components for the chit's in that which okay it's kind of horrible looking plastic but again it looks better than the cardboard so it's kind of a hmm in the map region for aesthetics now the best thing with this game is that the thematic immersion is top-notch gorgeous and dripping wood thing yeah in your broth okay that was a lie yeah it's basically the whole pulsar 28:49
argument pulsar 28:49 was plenty old Spacey it kind of looked it but theme wise who gave a monkey's it really just had nothing to do with the theme this is pretty much the same deal really I mean you could feed your people with bread wheat or kelp what does it matter depending on what setting you choose yeah you got the little domes that look like underwater domes but aside from that you kind of half the time forget you're actually underwater you know because you're building labs you're building farms you're building like the desalination plants so you pronounce it but at the end of the day it could just be a subway network of tunnels for all it matters it could be a subterranean network you're building you could easily change this from underwater to some other type of underground or in space type setting and the card play really has nothing to do with what's your turn but building underwater seas like why am I playing colors on colors and creating combos to build resources to build up great cities how's that work you know there is no traumatic time with this game this is bone dry and for the most part doesn't matter too much I mean like I said I like to post our 2849 despite the fact that has no theme theme does not instantly make the game good it just makes me come back more often for it because I want to get immersed in that theme here the setting is cool I mean I like the whole idea of building an underwater city Network I don't know at many games that do that and I feel like it's something that could be explored more no pun intended but yeah it's like whatever I've got cards
I've got resources and care once called kelp or antimatter or whatever it's like I'm playing cards and doing cool stuff with that the fact that we're underwater in a city pho matically is pretty much just lobbed it lobbed across the ocean and never to be seen again so do not go into this game thinking you're gonna get a thematic gyro ain't gonna happen this is bone dry but again that doesn't kill the game for me longevity longevity hit and miss with this one you've got all the cards and you've got three separate decks one for each era now you're going through a lot of these cards each game but not all of them so there will be new ones you'll see from time to time but you will also notice that some of them are just derivatives of each other you know this one gets these two resources this one gets these two resources this one gets you points based on how many connected cities you have this one gets you points based on how many connected tunnels you have yeah there are variations but they're not exactly the most unique cards in the world they certainly get more powerful much more interesting as you go into later arrows and you know if you were to expand this game which I'm sure they'll probably do at some point I think there's already an expansion in the worst of my not bad to to my knowledge you there will be a chance to add more cards more cards great more variety I'll be more up for that the special cards that you can go after are a bit more better on that regard because the level one and twos use them all but they're shuffled together and you don't end up with many during a game I mean we played one game and I think we drew two of those max and you know there's a lot
of them in there so you could end up with some pretty unique special cards I just wish there was more than like one or two ways in the game to actually draw a special card it's like so hard to get there special cards that it's kind of like do I really want it and the end game scoring ones you pick six out of a bunch and the rest go back in the box now these aren't the most interesting cards I mean one scores you for this resource one scores you for that resource one scores you've a number of cities one scores you per number of this they're pretty generic but again six randomized every game you've got a slight advanced variant to add some objective cards so if you meet the criteria you instantly get this they're cool they're randomized you only put three out it's a really easy addition there's no reason not to play with them to be perfectly frank but again you are limited replay value eyes by the number of cards in the game the locations don't change there's no chopping and changing of those things I mean that could do that an expansion but my god your brain would burn like crazy if you started mixing those up bit like um tea or tea whoo I can't actually does the same thing and yeah burns your brain and that one in this one it would just go to eleven but it's really down to those currents you're not gonna get through minigames before you seen pretty much all the cards in action with maybe the exception of some of the ear or two and three ones because ade those rounds of shorter but be you're probably doing more stuff with card you've already got but you know there's enough cards to keep you engaged for a while it's not like you're gonna be going oh yeah seeing it seen it see it you know you're not gonna memorize these
things it's not that bad but certainly eventually you're gonna get to a point where you need an expansion to this game not necessary to add more mechanics I think doesn't that mechanics in this game as it is you know it's and for what it has it's not the not entirely streamline but it's fairly smooth flowing I don't want loads more mechanics in this game just give me an expansion adds more cards to every era and special decks you do that you could make a nice cheap expansion and you would increase the longevity of this like crazy why is that so difficult why does everything have to be a DES I mean I guarantee I'm putting bets on it now next expansion to this there's gonna be a new mechanic new board or something okay fair enough more complication but alright let's put it in they'll be more cards great love it and they'll try to add a fifth player because somebody out there was moaning that they couldn't play this game four and a half million hours with five players bet is gonna happen if we don't want it I don't want a fifth player just take it out of the game right now but yeah and if you're a solo player like me there is a solo mode so that will keep you engaged as well nothing special about it it's just one or two tweaks from the two-player rules go in try and get the most points and I think build a minimum at cities but again it's cool you get to do the card combo play the game is mostly not we play a solitaire anyway so brain solo is not a bad deal I've had a good time with this solo it's been good fun so there's enough to keep you engaged as enough to keep you like for the price which is a bit of a high price point I'll admit I think most of the time you find this kind of in the fifty-pound category probably more so 45 to 55 I've seen it
usually retail quite a bit you know for a bunch of cards and some you know kits and a few little domes in that I think it could've been priced a little lower or if you're gonna make me pain that much then you know I'll charge me another 5 10 pounds and upgrade some of those components majorly yeah but like I say for what you get it's a pretty good deal underwater cities well definitely an interesting game this one because bowls are 28:49 completely took me by surprise I was like I love this game and I don't understand why here I don't love it but I do like it I find this engaging and enjoyable a lot because it's tactical and I think that pulsar had that as well I mean you could strategize saying I'm gonna munchkin is a munchkin Napper again you had to react to the dice so it made it very tactical as well that was kind of more 5050 this one definitely leans more to the tactical side in a strategic side but for me that's a good thing that's the kind of gyro I like more I liked having to react on the fly to what's going on and but to both so 2849 is simpler to play it is easier is more streamlined and I like the dice better in that then I do the cards in here but I think the card playing here is good fun certainly like I say some people have compared this to terraforming Mars I don't quite get the comparison entirely I mean both have card combo combo play and one is about terraforming a planet landscape
this one's basically about terraforming an underwater landscape so I guess there are similarities but one is all about card drafting and this one's more about card combo worker placement tableau play I don't know what you would call it really and certainly if you were gonna put the two side-by-side and say which one you want to play out of underwater seas and terraforming Mars I would burn terraforming Mars on the spot and play underwater seas without a second for you cut me deep Shrek you cut me real deep just now because you know the luqman the luck aspect is prominent in both so if you're a little bit of post to luck you're gonna find it in terraforming Mars and in underwater cities so you know you're gonna have to pull up with that but I don't think it's too much luck that completely swings the game in someone's favor and you can mitigate it to an extent and like I say a little bit of randomness is not like the end of all your roads you know not every euro has to be some zero percent luck boring monstrosity or something it can have a little bit of randomness in there mathematically like I say it could be a bit more pleasing but you know a few sleeves on the cards and maybe I'll upgrade the components over time depending on the price point a lot cheaper thing in the world but it's something that could be done and again more expansions add more cards it could keep it fresh in my mind so overall I think underwater cities is a pretty solid game it's just definitely one of my favorites I've been playing for 2019 is it technically the 2018 game or 2019 game it's probably the 2018 game I don't know it was released to Essen but barely s and it didn't get a proper retail release till this year so I'll have to check what the BoardGameGeek
says about it but so far definitely an entertaining game you know this is definitely putting a Vladamir Suchi on the map for me you know we've already had pulsar now we got underwater what else is he gonna come out with I will certainly be interested when I hear about it I'll just know to expect hmm an interesting mechanic and reasonable components and the subtle theme you know that is a bit of a - I wish this did have morphine because building this underwater city network could have it's just ripe for a rich formatic euro with this theme setting on it but unfortunately this one isn't going to give you that so a theme is a big thing for you like it is for me it's gonna be a negative but I say stick with it I think the tactical card play element of this game outweighs the fact that there is no theme in here and like I say I know there's a lot of games where I rag on them saying although there's no theme in this it's a little bit there but it's the fact that if the theme is non-existent for me the mechanics have to work extra hard to bring me in this game does that the card play mechanic brings me in no matter the fact that there's no theme so definitely if you're a fan of heavy euros this is one you should definitely check out for me it's not quite up there at the levels of Pulsar so I think I would give this a solid 8 8 10 it's a very good game definitely one I'm gonna hang on to in the collection I will certainly be like oh can we play a bit of underwater cities you know providing we cap the player count it free unless everybody knows the game I mean that is the thing with solo it's good fun with - it's good
fun but free it's even better for it's just a bit too long unless everybody really knows what they're doing and you must have that golden setup for four player to be worth it given that again it is multiplayer solitaire which is a problem for me as well but eight ten solid gang I look forward to the next one from this publisher and this designer so that's it for me see you on the next detail review and remember doesn't matter if I send you out into the water to drown it's nothing personal and it's only a game take care and I'll see you next time you