Skip to main content
Loading video...

Catacombs: Black Box Expansion First Look & Review

Transcript 7:07

hey everyone this is jack from the cardboard held and as many of you know i am a huge fan of catacombs the dexterity bass dungeon delve one versus all game in which either the hero players are cooperatively trying to make it to the end of the catacombs triumphantly defeating the catacombs lord or as the player controlling the baddies you are trying to inflict as much disc-based suffering onto your friends as possible so being the big fan that i am i was of course really excited to get the opportunity to check out this sexy little monolith the new catacombs black box expansion which is actually up on kickstarter right now as of this review going live and so we're going to take a look at what this box has in store for your catacombs man that is really sexy the black box expansion is by design a sort of summary and reflection on the history of the catacombs franchise from the box art paying homage to the original look of the game to the alternate monster cards giving the discs you already have fresh new abilities pulled from throughout the many expansions catacombs has had to date and there are new things here from a brand new double-sided play mat featuring the lair of the two cool new catacombs lords to a new set of monsters rooms and a few more odds and ends to me the most impressive new features are what's kept me coming back to

catacombs again and again clever physical aspects of this dexterity game that convey complex thematic ideas anchoring is a new attribute where a disc can be firmly held down during another player's turn stoically holding the line while soaking up damage in a game where positioning can be key and manipulating your opponent's pieces to give you better angles or make it harder for them this mechanic alone introduces so many interesting possibilities where there's the transmogrify shot where you can transform one of your opponent's pieces into an ice worm limiting their capabilities for the duration of the room group rush calls all of your team's units to arms and the hook shot lets you shoot a token and move within a radius of where it lands all of these are strategically interesting thematically compelling and the new monsters in particular the devastatingly strong quagmirage and enchanter lieutenant pieces make for great new options during gameplay but if i were to point at the single thing that i like most here it's the deca monster cards that can be used in place of their og's for every pre-existing third ed monster to date throughout catacombs history even just since the release of third edition there have been so many innovations and creative ideas that are now worked retroactively back into the game take my dog cerberus for example vanilla serb would move punch and shoot a couple arrows serb point 0 now moves and then in order of his choice shoots ice lightning and

fire shots not only giving real strategic flexibility but painting such a better image of what's going on with each of these dog heads and as someone who owns every little drop of catacombs there is to have this fresh coat of paint and sort of consolidated design philosophy for all the monsters is so great to have but that's what also leads to the greatest weakness of this expansion like i said earlier the catacombs black box is both a summary and reflection of all things catacombs to date but it doesn't serve as a particularly great expansion if you don't have those things to reflect not only are there no new heroes in here but if you don't have any of the other expansions you miss out on a ton of the monsters that are being replaced let alone some of the components referred to by the new cards that lightning that cerberus shoots not only does cerber rely on you having the lightning token from the icebox expansion but the reference in the black box manual even tells you that the description of how lightning shots or any of the other expansion shots work are to be found in that expansion's manual sure you can always look up a manual pdf online and you can always shoot a fire token and pretend it's the lightning blast or web shot or whatever that's just not the same though fortunately all of the monsters and catacombs lords that are new as of this expansion which are really good have everything they need to play right out of the box so as a die hard

catacombs fan this is a great expansion to to bring some new things in that are the type of things i look for in new catacombs content as well as breathe some new life into the bananas amount of catacombs stuff that i already have it's great so i'm getting a lot of utility out of this but because it doesn't have the legs to stand on its own really it is nowhere near the top on my recommendations of first expansions to go to for catacombs if you just want to flush out your content caverns of sawth is fantastic or if you want to kind of add a new dimension to catacombs then wyverns of walmere is really fascinating and just a a fun addition to the game this on the other hand i mean sure if you feel really compelled about the new mechanics that are in it then yeah do what you want and there are a couple other things i didn't even mention that are fantastic about this like some of the monsters now give you boosts or bonuses if you slay them throughout the game no longer is it just gold but you might slay a mage enemy and get a random spell from the deck for the heroes or an item or heal a little bit not only is this a great avenue for more thematic elements to be wedged in there but it also makes sense from a mechanical perspective too because as monsters get more complex

with these new replacement monster cards well they tend to be a little bit more powerful and those struggling heroes are going to need something to kind of see them through it just makes it more dynamic and interesting as a whole so as an expansion for a die hard like me i love it and i know there are a ton of people out there just like me who are looking for this kind of capstone to the catacombs collection so far and i have no problems recommending it to you and for any fledgling catacombs fans out there well it's a good thing there's a lot of catacombs content out there for you after you pick up the base game and that is our review thank you so much for watching i've been jack for the cardboard herald if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via writing podcasts and video here on our channel and website cardboardherald.com our content is audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard herald

Progress saved