Suspects Runthrough
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked we are playing suspects uh we are doing chapter one the murder at alistair mana uh yep we play we're playing as claire harper she takes the stage you guys wonder who claire harper is sure she was born in 1910 she is an avid reader of agatha christie a world traveler and more british than five o'clock t wow how racist okay huh i thought it was four nope apparently five o'clock t is just really british like uh you said this is a french company uh it sounds like a frenchman and they still are holding a grudge aren't they killing montage yeah i'm guessing that's french but that's racist too sure oxford university admitted her after impello she's insane oh yeah admit her after implementing quotas for female students in 1927.
token she followed in her father's footsteps and graduated with the key to unlocking her dreams a degree in criminal law now claire harper investigates observes discovers and thwarts there's no mystery that is too twisted for her brilliant mind no case that's too hard for her to crack claire harper isn't just a detective she's a good detective said she's the very best she's pretty she's adequate she's not just a detective she's a detective who mixes drinks she's not just a detective she's a woman and we met our quota damn it yep we got it all right so uh quick caveat uh there are three mysteries in this box uh we are doing one of them this is the first ones of spoilers uh if you um are wanting to see how this plays but if you want to know our thoughts you can definitely check out the discussion where there might be slight spoilers alright so are we ready fort william scotland 21st december 1934 before heading to london for christmas i went on a short tour of scotland the day after a beautiful ramble through the highlands i got a call from inspector jameson of the fort william police i'm terribly sorry to disturb you but the tragedy has just occurred at alistar manor a lot of butt playing magic smells like [ __ ] and i don't like it his wife thinks she's a bat about that mary higgins lord edward alistair's young fiance was found dead of strangulation and bat marks then that
in claw marks a lot of you know the secret magic is in the butthole no it's in the prostate which is in your butt yeah but it's more specific you don't even know i don't you know fort william is a small town where everyone knows everything that happens so when i was informed that a young associate of justice cameron of the high court judiciary was visiting from edinburgh i decided to contact you we don't have many of these sorts of cases around here i think that your help would be quite welcome since i don't know how to just sit idly by accept this new challenge without blinking before going to the alistair estate i inquired around about mary higgins and lord edward allister the first intriguing fact there was a 40-year age difference between them how sexy brett that is like you dating a ten-year-old sick [ __ ] i did not and it was consensual well yeah but i'm not like oh my god all right go or at least or 90 or 90.
she could have been older 90 10 year olds lord edward was married twice before he met mary when mary higgins name was mentioned around fort william friendly and fresh were the words most frequently used to describe her but local gossips couldn't help but think that the 20 year old was just waiting to be married so she could get her hands on lord edward's fortune that's what they call it these days
after intriguing fact another intriguing fact is that mary's murder took place just a few days after another tragedy lord edward's disappearance he loved mountaineering and had gone on a climb upgulvane with his brother william but william allister returned from the expedition alone so the two people who owned this estate this manner uh she was found dead uh by being strangled and he's he's missing so that's interesting uh he just says oh go uh climbed up gold vane how you saw that g-u-l-v-a-i-n armed with this information i headed to aleister's estate which stands a few kilometers from fort william alone in the countryside when i drew up to the estate i marveled at its beauty a vast neo-gothic manner with a breathtaking view of the highlands thomas the butler came to greet me it was 3 30 pm hello miss harper inspector jameson told us you would be coming we had suffered a terrible tragedy but i am certain that with your expertise you will quickly discover who was behind this terrible crime you shall have free reign of the house to carry out your investigation i took the liberty of finding a map of the estate for you perhaps it will be of some use uh these are just crotch shots mr uh who's this guy was thomas so we take the map of the manor which is this hi map yeah
got it got it this is all there we are uh so there's the map of the mata um and then we draw a card number one ah okay so there's thomas this is thomas hi thomas okay uh miss mary arrived at the alistair estate just three years ago but i quickly became very fond of her i called to the fort william police immediately the body has already been taken by the police to the medical examiner's office at saint andrews hospital in fort william their phone number is in the great hall the entire alistar family is currently at the manor they're willing to cooperate with law enforcement please take this it will help you it will help you get to know the family better consult the family tree hi tree that's a lot of people wow that is a lot of people luckily we can't talk to most of them can i look at this real quick so uh we can question him about mary higgins and question him about the alistar family okay so cat well here william absolutely looks like a murderer first of all sorry what he looks like so yes what are you trying to say to me well here are here are questions uh who is the killer okay what is the motive uh what event or events led to the murderer to commit this heinous act the murderer used three objects or items
name them and in what order did the events leading up to the murder take place um i'm gonna say the crucifixion of jesus that's a start what happened after world war ii okay came after this yes i'm like okay well we're already uh nope nope this is 1934. yeah that's five years later oh no she was born in 1910 that's why i was thinking yeah murder and then d-day so okay so what are the questions we have we have them right here you don't have to write them down i [ __ ] need to write one more because i have a bullet point nice okay so just give me one more question i have what is
he said william so we can start looking around the place so we'll start talking to people so william his brother that he went hiking with uh and he disappeared oh he has a head wound uh-huh from being hit from the defensive world yeah yeah it is well that sounds like somebody to start with because the guys disappeared and he was the last one that we think anyone seen him and i'm sure his headwind is easily explainable like he got um yeah so the his new wife his new wife showed that i'm gonna shut this off this is gonna be a useless camera um so his new wife he showed up three years ago the butler was immediately smitten with she just showed up too she's just like well he probably brought her home i'm your wife um no that's not how i'm married that's not how that works uh does it say where she was found uh was found dead of strangulation i guess we can ask the butler where he found her body and then go there question him about mary higgins yeah yeah let's do that and then we'll talk to william what's the number 36 36.
okay bam mary was the daughter of mr williams friend lord edward met her on a trip to australia she was a delicate caring young woman who was very much in love with lord edward despite what you might hear about her she was in poor health too dr pearson our family doctor had been visiting her more than usual lately our gardener joseph raised the alarm this morning around 11 30. there's something there's something strange in the conservatory he told me when we got there we discovered miss mary's body she was sitting in her usual chair with her detective novel at her feet she was already dead there was nothing we could do cool well she's been sick and she strangled herself you know how sick people do the conservatory huh which is oh yeah right there you can also question him about the whole family if we want to uh that might be something just saying but i do think we need to talk to elder you know what it was a uh mercy killing um this is basically the plot of knives out oh my god got it no that wasn't a mercy feeling it was an accident that was an accident spoiler well who gives a [ __ ] you should watch it again come out with the second one they are and it's not going to be as good shut up nothing ever is well yeah we tried that with star wars too you see where that went conservatory conservatory so either we look at the place or we talk to the brother i don't know why you want to talk to the brother he's because he's totally on the up-and-up did you have a brother that you went hiking with i don't know we're talking
about oh i've never had a brother you know the one who owns this manner we should collect some evidence against him before we talk to him no i don't really uh oh god mary's dead yeah she's super dead you can't speak well i almost said you can't speak joseph also found the body but is joseph the gardener hmm yeah i found her yeah no oh the farmer joseph mengele interesting says he's from spain you know where was he from belgium no no where did he hide that's what i was trying to reference oh he well in argentina he hid in uh puerto rico uh he went he went all over the place went through italy the the same the brenner pass everyone loves that guy it's pretty cool it's pretty happening spa if you're a nancy i always like the uh locations fine i'm okay with that four oh and uh okay well here's here's something good uh to get five points we need to answer these questions in 30 cards up to 30 cards wow okay that means it's a lot longer yeah than the short one yeah then the demo you know uh okay so what's the first break point yeah oh the conservatory is pretty the conservatory is a peaceful place mary higgins used it as her reading room her armchair was placed to take advantage of the light filtering in through the south window while enjoying
the view of the botanical garden so we can examine the balcony that overlooks the park which might give us um i mean someone broke in to strangle her i would imagine right i mean unless this is like one of those sick [ __ ] who likes to prop up dead bodies and be like oh man possible she was moved yeah i don't know what she was discovered there so we can examine the balcony that overlooks the park we can take a closer look at the armchair um or we can examine the victim's detective novel yeah we'll read it why would we care about the novel well what if it's like what if it's how to kill is superman well if it's super meta and what she was reading in the case of around that is this case yeah how to strangle yourself and make it look like a murder favorite book exactly i'm sure no you're deathly ill uh examining the novel just because it's called out as a thing to look at yeah well there might be you know although with 30 there might be something in the ledger like there might be something in it she might be she might have been like oh but she was throwing up she's writing his name you might pick it up and something interesting might fall out yeah so it's like condoms
okay so the pages go from 17 to 30. it's all smudged when you try to flip it it's just like ew all right let's let's look at the book her husband's disgusting wasn't her husband's condom maybe that's why she got strangled novel a fascinating tale in which the detective in charge of the investigation gets lost in faulty reasoning and follows red herrings oh no in the end they never catch the murderer oh interesting it's a weird sherlock holmes novel i've never read that yeah i'd like to read this speaking of meta rip that card up let's keep it just in case that's funny i was wondering about that it's the disrespect for me i don't know i you know what gualam guano montang it's whatever i wanted to be because he just insulted me that's how you get them that was a meta clever jab all right now let's take a look at the actual thing we wanted to look at the balcony was that what we want to look at not the balcony sorry it was the i have the arm chair right here okay this is where mary uh was found dead after carefully examining the back of the chair you notice a mark it seems that something was pressed against the back of the chair the mark is approximately 10 inches long boner
it's a footprint wow so she uh man you know what they say i think it's a footprint feet is that another footprint it looks like a foot so it acts like well most likely he was wearing a shoe yeah he was like holding the chair and yeah pushed yeah so she was caught off guard he wasn't like plus smacking her around smacking her around the bedroom it does appear to be a men's footprint i don't know so we can rule out uh females wearing heights okay oh yeah because females don't commit murder from my experience women don't kill they've never killed they just bite off penises and throw out the window unless she was what was her name what was her name who did that that's it yeah yeah see that happened when i was alive so i knew about it it happened while i was alive too you were four yeah i was still alive you know you don't really know but were you living yeah it's like now i'm dead inside 28. i heard about that on the radio and the radio used to be all right something that sad people listened to because you didn't have tv oh when i left my phone you didn't listen to porn i had to listen to the radio and i was like yeah the listen no we pictures with the scoops that's right viewmaster we have the silent movies oh god do you rest your porn
oh and oh i'm out imagine being really excited and finding like an old roll of film and you're like oh my god the treasure's on this and you develop it it's it's grandma and grandpa's porn reel okay so okay this family tree is going to be [ __ ] insane so let's start by not talking to any of them well that's the thing we only talked to like his side of the family workshop because which is the only exterior room that we can go to that we can examine do we not want to look out the window i mean we can it would just i i just don't know if that's gonna matter right now because we don't i mean even if it's like yeah someone can get in we don't know who um someone can certainly see that someone's reading unless well okay unless we can see you know maybe the workshop or something from there and that might give us someone who might have been able to look in the window and see if see if they saw anyone else in the room well we can certainly see the workshop from there or somebody would have known like oh i can see her she's always in at this time of day like this is when i can yeah yeah so this is a balcony so this is the second floor right well you can have a could assume that
that those are stairs and that no because it literally says ground floor well didn't it say look out the balcony yeah examine the balcony that overlooks the park i mean does the balcony have to be top level kind of would make sense well otherwise it's rarely on the ground floor yeah well wouldn't it just be called a porch probably well not 1934 so the balcony may be above this room or the room maybe two-story i don't know just so much of this looks these are stairs and then this is how you get from this how do you get from this uh room staircase of that roof to that staircase i don't [ __ ] know that was a wise kid you know reference beg your pardon yeah how does how do you get from this uh this building staircase to that building was that when they were trying to do the hive thought baby listen to me this is this is the same this is the same building this this lays this place on top of that so this staircase is that staircase i'm starting to see it we're looking for that secret tunnel ah why it's good you know so good anyway um and the only reason i'm pointing my ass drawn to the workshop is because it's the only exterior building with a number and it's in direct line of sight yeah maybe there's something on the balcony like a condom okay so we have uh camilla alistair looks to be
evil well because george and carolyn at this point we have no idea we could just do anything yeah until we start getting some yeah i mean joseph mason is the one who found the body okay let's go talk to him okay 28. all right well he looks like a criminal immediately that was easy the gardener of aleister manor looks you up and down also had been barking outside the conservatory for several minutes as soon as i realized something was wrong i called thomas it must have been around 11 30 this morning miss all right oslo oslo we go to oslo no i don't know who the hell that is well not not anyone's family uh i don't know i was listening he called the police no as soon as i really i called thomas thomas is a butler yep it must have been around 11 30 this morning okay uh let's see i don't know if we can finally young fiance was found dead of strangulation so thomas the butler came to greet me it was 3 30. so we got here at 3 30. is this 11 30 the uh the same day i'm guessing so about four hours later is when we showed up looks like well there's more to this by the way his thoughts on mary higgins so the the um the victim
a shy young woman edward allister the her missing uh uh husband her fiance stern but fair edmund allister uh edmond grandpa edmund aleister oh um cousin maybe cousin brother yeah probably a cousin to the clara hastings and andrew alice or alistair so you're probably uh or a nephew um yeah a young man with a passion for cars and tinkering an expensive hobby edith alistair uh is the niece in town i've heard she's a regular socialite it's her youth no doubt william allister the brother he likes to tell me about his exploits but i think he's jealous of lord edward's success and jonathan lloyd uh miss lloyd leads him around by the nose he asked me if i had any plants that would help him to sleep the hell is jonathan oh jonathan lloyd uh brother yeah because they're they're related so uh third brother okay edmund or brother-in-law actually yeah because there's elizabeth alistair so sister brother so two brothers and a sister um and then that's her husband jonathan lloyd is her husband and yes a brother-in-law i have i have a burning question about this family tree yep colin their son well someone died before before it was one year old
oh interesting and dash lines to three women oh so we don't know is that it's one of their children we don't know well definitely edwards well it's her child no he it said he was married twice before oh okay but we don't know whose child it is because it's going right below that lady isn't it like yeah but it's tied to him so it's their kid and he died um yeah he died before he was woman oh dashed is probably deceased yeah well they're grayed out as well if they're deceased okay yep but what's also interesting about this is both of his previous wives died at the age of 28. it kind of seems like they really like to kill their wives in his family uh okay so theory after looking at this uh edward is in charge of killing his wives and he had william as a cover-up he edward's not dead and he's not he is he's not necessarily missing he escaped and william's his alibi of like oh it was tragic grand we haven't talked to him so we don't know why he came back alone but um that doesn't really answer any of the literally any of the questions so yeah who did it yeah we still don't know uh somebody jumped the gun by eight years somebody jump the gun yeah edward's like hey you gotta wait eight years he's like i don't wanna [ __ ] wait eight years
i'm no god i'm not doing your chores for you well you get to live scot-free okay oh she and the child probably died in childbirth oh maybe 1805 same year okay okay yeah that's fair or he killed them both that's not out of the question yeah the only rooms that lead to the conservatory or the drawing room in the music room okay we can also go to a study edward alice or study or yeah uh what can we do with thomas we can question him about the family the rest of the family i mean if he's a butler he probably talks mad [ __ ] on the family yeah i mean before we go randomly speaking with people we've only got one person well two people he got the gardener he found the body and he told thomas yeah and the brother yeah so maybe we should just get an overview of the family first and then we'll have those notes when we talk to them yeah yeah i like that i like that idea the alistar family has seen its share of tragedy lord edward's first two wives died his only son was stillborn and edmund and edith's parents died young leaving the twins in dire straits luckily lord edward took them in all right interesting interesting so okay so he was still born so yeah and who was it his and his edmond and edis parents
who the hell are they oh oh clara and andrew oh they're both dead um died young leaving the twins in dire straits okay yeah so they are his niece and nephew so his thoughts on mary higgins she brought the smile back to lord edward's face all right so he was sad elizabeth alistair a strong woman she remains convinced that lord edward is still alive edmund alistair a young man full of energy and great gentleness i have a feeling he was quite fond of mary edith allister a confident young woman jane lloyd alistair a charming little girl oh their daughter uh the the sister's daughter and william alistair he wasn't as successful in business as edward what a loser could i have the two cards with family details oh these two yeah i just want to keep track and compare yeah real quick while you're
okay um so far we have no i don't even have a single person to blame well i mean we've got thirty guards before we get something true yeah it was clearly suicide yeah you know what that's gonna look out the window and see what we see yeah let's just go and do that we get we got the only idiots look out the window okay the balcony uh the door behind the curtain leads to the balcony overlooking the large park the snow that fell during the night has cloaked the property in a white blanket and gives the landscape an eerie stillness you open the glass door it was unlocked and despite the cold you step out onto the balcony the snow continues to fall gently you walk back and forth along the balcony looking down at the ground below you nose footprints in the snow okay um we take card9 and place it on top of the map of the manor boom all right some footbridge yep footprints that lead like you said from the workshop uh to the balcony which would make sense because he is the one who noticed something strange about the conservatory so there's 10 and 11 on here so 10 is probably the footprints 11 is probably still footprints yeah well let's look at 10.
yeah oh and maybe that's what this is maybe it's because he was walking through snow or mud or something that's how the footprint got there because also because this is like a felt and usually you can like make prints in that or he was like i'm gonna get away with this i believe something so 10 sure i haven't picked them yet oh okay the footprints stop right in front of the window with a direct view of the chair where mary's body was found the footprints are fairly fresh they were left after it stopped snowing as you recall the last flakes foul fell around 11 30 this morning the footprints are approximately 11 inches long which probably corresponds to a men's size 11. the other footprints were obviously left by a dog oh okay so how does that correlate to the size of the footprint on the chair it's an inch bigger yeah so what we can tell you it's not the butler because it has the purple lining um which doesn't uh it doesn't align to him purple one low okay well definitely his okay but but he's a gardener he did say 11 30 the time matches up and he's the one who found the body doesn't mean he's not out in the clear but those could be his footprints so far it tracks yeah look at 11 yeah for sure as you look more closely you notice faint footprints that are less visible because they are partially obscured by
the recently fallen snow from these footprints you can conclude that someone went into the workshop and then came back out snow and wind are not the allies of a detective such as yourself because they make it difficult to measure the footprints they're probably a men's size uh probably a men's size 6.5 about 10 inches long they are possibly women's shoes but you can't be certain will you hand me his thing again that matches his thing again purple no it definitely does not interesting but it doesn't match the chair it does match the butler okay what was the butler doing out walking around in the snow yeah he was supposed to be butlering why can't we question the butler about himself that's also true what do you think about yourself why should we do you think you're rather suspicious uh yeah so that's kind of so this ties to the the men's 6.5 ties to him i think honestly yeah the the gardner's probably clean um he's the the footprints coming into it is probably him going i swear the bout the balcony is just because you can get to it from outside and the footprints well it doesn't necessarily say in france or balconies on the ground actually oh okay uh these are the footprints number eleven because the pattern in the snow matches the pattern on the back of
the chair okay more so than you know they say it was a lady size ten so it could be a a woman's shoe but it's hard to tell okay uh should we go to because those could be wedges not heels and this is definitely the butler's footprints yeah the 6.5 so far okay heels back then we're very different than the heels now so sure uh should we go to his study see if if he was the husband was hiding anything with the or the workshop but what would be in the workshop well murder murder yeah rope because there are there were you need to find three three items oh yeah involved in the kill yeah let's go to the workshop 35 yeah definitely the gardener's area and the dog and there's royal that's all slow what's the dog look like oh no i just see a dog a dog bowl i guess no what does the dog bowl look like joseph mason's workshop is full of tools and accessories of all kinds so we can examine the shelves we can examine the workbench if you have not already done so you may take card 9 and place it on top oh okay which we already have so are you writing all that down like like shoe size and who our possible suspects are we'll probably remember everything yeah i mean we probably will i mean that's why well it's all written uh down already the shoe size and all that like because you could put men's 6.5 in a line and then put possible
people that this match is up to well who does it match up so far thomas smith that's the only one we have right now what do you think so what makes you say that because the purple lines match up something about the game so there's definitely a connection between those two yeah that's what these little colored marks are on the side well the shelves i can very visibly see rope um and the workbench has gloves on it well those are clear yeah do you think it merits a further examination or oh without a doubt because most likely it'll give us uh an item yeah so 46 is the shelves old rope this rope found in the workshop would make an ideal murder weapon and it has one as a brown line it goes from the top so i haven't seen one of those nope not yet but we do have that as an item and then yeah the workbench is 39.
oh there we go pair of gloves you find a pair of brown leather gloves and joseph mason's workshop okay so this is pretty neat green three different green lines one means the suspect's hands are bigger than the gloves the suspect's hands are the same size as the gloves or the suspect's hands are smaller well i bet you anything they're gonna match joseph yeah okay so his hands are bigger than the gloves oh they're probably not is i'm pretty sure they're gonna match joseph because he works there and yeah owns them yep so they're a match that still doesn't rule him out no but what's most likely going to happen is uh a pretty good suspect is going to be one that has the same size footprint and the one that can wear the gloves so which means we need to talk to more people talk to more people and the only other one that uh is not well how hold on how old are these um nephews edmond aleister is 21.
he's around the same age as her maybe he's like my [ __ ] uncle's of perv like you need to be with me i'm an entertainer i got the cars i was having an affair with her were they actually married no no i guess they weren't yeah they were promised yeah betrothed yep so edmund is right on my list um maybe uh it could be edith maybe because maybe edmund was smitten because it did say he was smitten with her right edmund was the nephew no well the butler was too but edmund uh carson tinkering expensive hobby uh young man full of energy i have a feeling he was quite fond of mary yeah so he could have been they were maybe they were planning to elope and maybe eveth was like you're not gonna take my brother for me because they were they were left alone like their parents died so they only had each other and she's like you can't take him from me he's mine and they're [ __ ] siblings in town i've heard she's a regular socialite and oh edith a confident young woman so who are we talking to that okay or the brother yeah who we've been avoiding yeah and is the most suspicious of all of them um only in the missing of of edmund like i can't i can't think of a reason why he would just all of a sudden like kill i mean he could go on both kill edmond and mary
or then he's covering up yeah and we might find a discrepancy in this story there are also some guests apparently yeah the dance teacher and we already talked to the help so that dance teacher was given some uh kid lessons but her figuring got stolen yeah she had to take a break it was awful all right what are you guys feeling the brother the niece or the nephew brother okay all right 24. well i was walking alone in the forest when the tragedy occurred it was a short walk because i'm still recovering from the fall i took while hiking dr pearson comes to the manor regularly to see me his thoughts on edmund allister he got lucky with his business uh or edward alistair um edmund a bit too kind to be successful wait which one's the one edward is the one that's missing ed mend is the nephew okay edith the niece a young spendthrift who is too accustomed to luxury elizabeth alister a woman who is strong and takes the initiative that's the sister jonathan lloyd her husband thoroughly malleable completely under elizabeth's thumb camilla alistair still sprightly despite her advanced age that's i think it's their initial mom thomas smith and joseph mason so the excellent servants and cecilia purcell
uh the dance artist a pseudo-artist um i just got lines right yeah so all right his hands are the same size as the glove um and he has the size 11. okay so he has well no i'm sorry that's that's the wrong set of footprints yeah and so if he's size 11 he can't possibly be 6.5 uh but we can question them about his business we can question him about the hike and we can question him about mary higgins probably question him about the hike because he's the one yeah that's because he said he he did say he fell yeah so he said edward was on the hike yep all right edward and i have always loved the great outdoors yes i challenged him declined to climb uh gold vane together we were caught in a snowstorm we tied ourselves together and edward led the way after an hour edward fell into a cleft dragging me with him it all happened so fast he must have been poorly attached because i found myself alone on some kind of ledge no matter how many times i called out to him he never answered i was badly injured so i hiked back along our path alone and made my way to mcloyd's cabin i went back to the cleft the next day but found no sign of edward since i was injured i came back down the mountain to raise the alarm yeah they're in together he's covering we if we get three of those symbols we get to draw a card probably more information on his story we might get one if we talk to the doctor who sees him yeah because this is medical
and also she was sick so the doctor is gonna he's gonna be bound to know her oh that's true do you want to ask him about mary higgins i think he's red herring i think he is he's just a jealous bitter [ __ ] he just kind of sounds like a big old [ __ ] yeah he's like oh they didn't have to work for theirs but i did so [ __ ] them and i'm still not very good at one yeah i'm still not i say but just so tell me about your business business was it i don't i mean i haven't heard of it he's just like we just keep egging him poking that button or we can talk to the doctor because that's the person that we can no we can't no we can't never mind we're okay at least not right now so you don't want to talk to this guy anymore oh no we can't william i was just saying that we we got options got it i know but you're thinking that it's not probably worth much he might have some information though on my only my only thought is that's going somewhere yeah but he probably won't have any more the third uh caduceus caduceus that's productive symbol yeah draw card three if we find if we get three of them yeah uh yeah i mean he seems bitter about literally everyone but we can ask him what he thought about mary more information on her yeah because what if he he's like i thought she was really perky what if he was like he's only you know 20 years younger than me how old is he he's 57 so no it's still still uh almost 40 years
37 years to be exact yeah what's the number to ask him about mary uh 51 51 he's right here mary was a charming lively young woman much like yourself miss harper as he licks his lips she was the daughter of an australian friend she and edward met while he was visiting me in australia i'm the one who's going to have to tell my friend his daughter is dead and i don't know if i'll have the strength to do it william serves himself a large glass of whiskey before continuing she was devastated when i came back from the hike without edward uh she was truly in love with him william empties his glass in a single gulp i don't understand why she was attacked she had no property and we all knew that edward didn't want to marry her or include her in his will oh interesting good thing we talked interesting and we all knew that edward didn't want to marry her or why then why was he with her oh my god he's gay oh that would be interesting that would be or he's female or he's mary she's never experienced that one coming interesting then didn't did um huh that's that's weird so it kind of makes me think miss mary arrived at the alistar stage did she just show up and i'm here to
stay no i think it's more he brought her but why well we can't just take his word for it he's the brother he's on the up-and-up he's got a concussion listen to the man mary has two r's in it okay yep let's go to his uh study now okay yeah i'm i'm feeling study well bam a tidy room that is the seat of edward's empire there is no safe the master of the house must have had absolute confidence in his staff there are various maps and documents about the surrounding mountains on the desk so we can examine the letter or examine the maps and documents oh examine the maps and documents because if it's a map of gold vein he didn't fall into a crevice well we already know that he's still alive yeah in edward alistar's study find documents concerning his preparations for a hike in the great grampian mountains mm-hmm um okay so the gold vane climb up gold vein is gold okay so fort william 10 december 1934 so 11 days before this dear mr alistair the equipment required for your expedition will be delivered on the 14th again i would advise you not to go ahead with your plans your brother's choice of goal vein is most certainly extremely dangerous at this time of year going without a guide as he had suggested would be uh to my mind taking an
unconscionable risk you're sincerely peter mchillway so yeah so his brother wanted to go there without most likely if he uh if he had a rope they probably cut it now we have no we have no way of knowing that for sure but but we can assume that he actually got this equipment note that it was dangerous to go yeah yeah it's on his desk if it's if it's a tidy room then he probably had it all organized so what is the possibility they didn't go there but william said that they did when they when they didn't come back together oh yeah yeah i'm trying to find the time the timelines don't really i mean without actually having a map and pulling up all that uh which this isn't that kind of game what day is it today the 21st of december so you definitely have your equipment yep you got you got it a week before and he definitely had he he was appearing to make plans to go somewhere else well he was advised against well this one is the grampian mountains i wonder if i don't know anything about these i don't know if gold vane is just one of the mountains and the grampian are the range of mountains and this just one particular one in this mountain range that's how i would take it you can just look at it as like different areas yeah yeah and then because it even says golvane your brother's choice of gold vein is most certainly extremely dangerous at this time of year okay so it probably is uh
it's basically just yeah it's highlighting the fact that his brother made a very questionable suspicious decision yeah but i mean at the same time it's like he's a six-year-old man he can make his own decisions i mean i also like to go spelunking and not tell anybody what i'm gonna do that day yeah that's that's kind of where i'm at though is like it's not like he like was forced to go he's probably like ah i'm still okay so why is a really good interesting thing because my co-worker catherine just told me a story where she took a walk with her sister because her sister just had to know where she was going right because she lives in this area that they were walking um her sister had never been down this trail before and they got lost he could just be a [ __ ] idiot what happened his brother yeah when you when you yeah um it could just be a case of male pride where he was like we don't need a guide well oh well i mean well you might be onto something because didn't um someone say that uh edmund like likes to listen to williams exploits maybe william's just kind of a an idiot no he's like a thrill seeker he's a real don and he's like i i climb these mountains all the time we'll be fine and he's like okay well you do this a lot more than i do let's go and then he's like ah i didn't realize how dangerous this was yeah maybe yeah yeah but there's still whoever it was it's in here somewhere um still thinks that he's alive oh the sister elizabeth yeah alistair still thinks yeah she remains convinced that lord edward is still alive see that i mean very much could be yes but that
brings up that brings up a thought that might not have occurred to people so yeah that was that was supplanted for a reason sure and right i heard someone got lost in the crevice in the mountain because what could have happened is uh william if they both got injured let's say let's just say his story is he's on the up and up they both get injured he falls uh william doesn't and he he can't see him in the snowstorm he waits till it subsides and he doesn't see him again ed edward could have you know maybe he was unconscious he wakes up and then he crawls to safety succumbs to the elements or the snowstorm well yeah uh and i would assume or william knocked him out locked him up well we're assuming that williams we're not trying to find who killed out killed edward trying to figure out who killed mary true um we don't even know if edward's dead but but this is the perfect crafted story with his brother um who who could i mean i'm thinking edward didn't want to marry mary and he didn't want her in his will and he crafted this story and the situation to escape well it would just what like all of his responsibilities yeah the whole family in the manner and everything maybe they suck he's doing that maybe we should talk to more people and find out if they do well he was he was gregarious enough to take in the twins when their parents died yeah and maybe they suck maybe so yeah i'm not i'm not undermining it it just seems to be all right let's look at the letter there's
he has a letter on his desk uh this is on november 12th uh 1934 uh from lloyd aha uh t j lloyd jonathan lloyd so this is dear edmund as your personal lawyer so the husband of elizabeth for several affairs i must insist it is for your peace of mind and for mary's future i understand your reluctance but your fears are unfounded please forgive me for being so straightforward but you can't honestly believe that a marriage could have any negative influence on mary's fate the fact that catherine and margaret both died shortly after your marriage to each of them is a pure coincidence you must understand that in the absence of an heir if anything should happen to you your estate would go to elizabeth william edmond and edith mary is not protected in any way if you don't want to marry at least agree to make a will we'll be able to talk about this in person next month sincerely yours j lloyd well there's motive to get the yeah no it's not though because mary doesn't get anything but they he may not have relayed that information well and especially as his attorney he wouldn't based off based off someone someone said it that jonathan is completely under elizabeth's thumb so there's no way he's not [ __ ] by elizabeth um and getting uh william said that yeah so there's no way elizabeth doesn't know that that mary doesn't get anything okay so we do have motive that okay edward
didn't want to marry mary because he's paranoid that because his last marriage yeah they would have still but they'd still be alive if we didn't get married um how old was mary 20. he could have had like eight good years with her or they killed her um maybe she was pregnant and then he does have an error and it doesn't go to them it goes to the air okay oh like maybe she was a little like a little uh like not very ladylike and they slept together and yeah she got pregnant and then one real taboo two yeah that's assuming that this is a christian family what year is this 1930 well it's not necessarily christian sure but look they're all related they're all family members they're trying to keep it pure elizabeth wanted to be with edward they're they're once again [ __ ] siblings what is this what is this movie from some pink yeah movie sucks yeah okay okay so the one thing that i would say that contradicts your theory that he wanted out is uh butler says she brought a smile back to lord edward's face oh interesting yeah i don't think that he wanted to escape his life but i also said that women don't murder people and unless he would escape and then she could we would
be free to run off we should probably care about her yeah we should probably go talk to elizabeth because that will also give us a chance to test the gloves and the footprints um because i wonder if what if they're all in on it it's possible well who would it go to elizabeth william edmund and edith why oh because they're the brothers they're the siblings because william elizabeth and edmund and edith are the the kids the kids to oh because they have another brother and they died and then they died and then they came in so they would be here they're pretty much who's the oldest between them elizabeth is 50. william is 57 uh okay i was gonna say andrew maybe they killed andrew as well but uh he was 37 so if it's going in line of succession it would be william would get the he would get the uh estate it would it would be divided by among all of them i'm sure that that's what's implied no we need to find the will and find out yeah did he have a will and he was being implored he was being implored to write a will yeah if you don't want to marry at least agree to make a will so he didn't have one i guess now i yeah we know of yet yeah he could be floating around in the absence of an heir if anything should happen to you your estate would go to elizabeth jonathan probably told elizabeth this she probably told william and william's like hey i can get rid of him
but why would he do that because he gets a share if it all goes if it's split between them they get the money and the this massive manner they get some instead of nothing so if he's a lawyer and he and it's not that he was like i don't think jonathan didn't i think he's just uh he's an innocent idiot who happens to be pussy-whipped by his wife these are really good theories um maybe we should talk to the mom of all these the mom's like ah elizabeth has always been a little murderer killed the dogs it's like oh my okay so she's gonna be able to talk to them if we can but she also seems removed from she's she's the only one left alive um but it looks like that george alistair their dad um remarried uh to carolyn mcgovern so how many children did she sire on this church oh actually no george alistair and carolyn mcgovern those are all their kids um based off this uh at the top there they were they're linked it's very faint but it's up at the top they were married but the kids are from oh my god i hate these charts so much yeah yeah i see what you mean so it was previous marriage no kids yep okay so maybe so why is she questionable why is she even here she's probably she lives there the old bag that still hangs around that's true why is she still around that's suspicious enough she has a
number she's clearly sucking the life out of the family that's how she's still she's trying to kill them all one by one yeah and then she gets it all she gets the law 92 she was born in 1842 yeah or we can talk to jonathan lloyd he's the lawyer i don't know if we would be able to question him about the letter right we're allowed to question him about whatever we want you could ask yeah i don't know i definitely think having elizabeth would be able to have us at least yeah put her in the footprint kind of category if she was around we're fairly certain she doesn't have men's size 11 shoes yeah but she could have women size 6.5 well that's meant 6.5 which is the 10 inch but it also states the they are possibly women's shoes but you can't be certain true so and those were the smaller ones mm-hmm okay yeah the ones that actually fit the footprint on the back oh yeah these are the ones based off the the footprint outline match that got you so i think i think this is just going to keep us a trail i mean it's those are the gardeners shoes he's the one who ran to the bottom oh they also fit william as it turns out these two have the exact same marks ah so yep we think that that is not worth anything nice cool i'm cool yeah no one's looking um they're gonna back up now and watch it
again what are we doing um we also have all these uh locations we can go to but you can't really there's no really reason to search any of the locations quite yet so let's focus on people okay um i yeah i i guess elizabeth or i'm thinking elizabeth that they're the only ones with a motive that we can at least pinpoint right now sure yeah it seemed devious pull her card does she look like a stone cold she looks like a vampire jesus christ that's true i don't need the manor because i'll live forever i left alone for fort william early this morning and didn't come back until early this afternoon i feel sorry for the poor child of course but i dread having to tell edward the fort william police seem overwhelmed i hope you won't have come here for nothing miss okay her thoughts on mary egwin wow what on mary higgins edward uh edward's new play thing she didn't deserve to die like this um edward allister he's still alive but he's a fighter edmund allister too nice to be a real alistair edith alistair strong and determined the exact opposite of her twin william allister edward has always been superior to him in everything especially [ __ ] me i don't understand why he's the one who came back from that expedition jane lloyd alistair my daughter i adopted her 10 years ago jonathan lloyd he's a family lawyer oh
and he's also my husband camilla alistair she's lost her marbles and thomas smith and jason joseph mason they serve us well well the they do fit her footprints okay and her handprints her hands are too small though that doesn't mean that she didn't wear them yeah it should imply that but and she doesn't have a little brown mark coming out of the bottom yeah no one does nothing does so far um i mean no jay simpson proved that just because the gloves don't poop he was acquitted that means he's innocent i quit it and hit it you know what i mean acquitted means he was not found guilty which also means he's innocent no one has ever found it 100 they're only i'm on team oj yep that's what we call him we're the oj oj uh the simpsonites i'm sorry you said we yeah there's a lot of us there's sent for simpson what can i say there's you and there's o.j uh who is the other lady who killed the kid the prosecutor another part of the defendant the defendant is what i meant to say yeah the yeah the defense attorney doesn't care they just want to make sure that they were on team oj the fence was on like which is the right side of things so let's just get that straight brett all right it is straight
anyway okay i don't think she did it we've also haven't asked william about the hike have we yeah we did yeah he said oh no you have all the william cards yeah but it's a william carter okay sorry yeah i've been trying to keep all the cards for the people next to them oh okay that's why the butlers are still here i'm trying to keep over there she seems to favor edward yeah so i can't also said one of the twins was a [ __ ] [ __ ] either or she is completely convinced he's still alive because she knows he's dead and she's deterring suspicion if she thinks he's still alive what makes her think that maybe because he's her favorite she was like he's i mean his older brother she's probably like i you know because she's mad that william came back yeah i mean i get it but i mean it's she doesn't seem too tied to her husband so he's a family lawyer oh he's also my oh and he's also my dick that's all he's good for no yeah because edward's not around because if she would want the inheritance then she would want him declared dead right so she'd be the quickest one to be oh nope he died once again we're not trying to solve his murder i think we are getting hung up oh my god that card was right about red hairs
no it's all related it is definitely related but i think this is going to be like a edward came back and murdered her subplot kind of thing well shhh is she the mastermind between either his murder or hers it would be the perfect alibi to say oh i didn't kill my wife i was lost it would so yes i yes but but let's i think it's one of the i think it's the uh the niece i think it's either let's go talk to them then let's go why do you think so because i'm going off of that the fact that edward took them in edmond was smitten with mary and maybe they had a thing going on and edith was like no you're not taking my only the only person i've had to bond with because i had no one else growing up he took them in when was it 10 years ago 10 days ago no it wasn't 10 days father said it didn't he um uh let's see oh nope that's us being told um that was being that was raising the alarm no so he says here luckily lord edward took the man doesn't give a time frame doesn't give a time okay oh well it'd be when they died oh so they died in oh okay so they died in 19
what said they died young their parents does it say parents yeah right edmund and eva's parents died young because you can't just take kids from parents who were alive i mean not in this country clara hastings alistair died at 50 and andrew alistar died at 37. that's young for him but not for her not necessarily i agree um but they died in 1917 or he died in 1917 she died in 1930 they're 21 years old right now they were born in 1913 so when their dad died he was four they were four good he was four years old when their dad died they were four yeah by the time she died their mom um they were like 18.
leaving them in dire straits luckily lord edward took the man so it had to have been quick because they wouldn't last four-year-olds last longer on the street what was her death what was her death day or her birthday her uh her year the year that she died 1930 four years before this so and they're 21 now so he's only had them for four years if he got them whenever right when they were when they were put into dire streets so about 18 17 edmond and edith's parents died young so they were four years old when the dad died edmond could have taken them in because he was his brother and the wife was like i don't [ __ ] want him i'm just a woman i don't make money 17 when she died so what do we know about mary she's quiet and shy no she's oh [ __ ] hoe no what mary yeah they said that she was flirtatious and friendly so here's what people are saying about her thank you i want to smile back to lord edward lord edward's face kashish a and uh william has nothing to say about her elizabeth says edward's new play thing she didn't deserve to die like this okay can't ask her about anything oh makes it sound like edward is a bit of a womanizer she was reading she she was shy she was quiet
um wouldn't get along with edith i don't think because edith is like the tough strong woman the one who has why don't we talk to edith well young spendthrift who is too accustomed to luxury yeah uh in town i heard she's a regular socialite it's her youth no doubt yep so they're opposites and a confident young woman yep so they are the complete opposite the butler literally said that mary was known like around town as being like a flirt no that's edith edith is a known socialite who is too accustomed to luxury yeah so she has a financial she has the clearest financial motive yeah yeah because if she loses well why should we lose it though why would she lose it oh because she was sick they knew that she no well i don't know i don't know why she would have motive to kill her to get her out of the way when like nothing's being threatened clearly her relationship with her brother this is a sick crimson peak [ __ ] let's let's keep talking to people okay all right i'm going to edmond okay and look how [ __ ] hot he is he seems completely devastated his twin sister is trying her best to calm him down i was working on my car when i heard oslo oh oslo is the dog but joseph got there first and found mary's body i went through the front of the manor to get to the conservatory but it was too late
okay these are those are not his shoes also not his shoe size what size huh he doesn't have hands no he's a freak he does have the size uh for gloves but the gloves might also not mean anything i mean would you wear gloves to strangle someone with rope yeah rope burn if i wasn't sure i was gonna well they were sneaking up behind but here's the other thing the rope no because it was behind and that'd be kind of weird to try and strangle her um okay his thoughts on mary higgins and angel in the flesh edith alistair i'd do anything for her william alistair seems like a nice enough fellow and elizabeth alistair is hard on jonathan and jane so her husband and their daughter she seems nervous and has asked thomas at least three times if there is a letter for her asked her husband we can question him about mary higgins and we can question him about edward allister mary mary should we cut up our cards anytime soon oh yeah we probably should or not worry about it she was an angel in the flesh uh oh uh yeah she was the sweetest most generous person i'd ever met edward seems particularly emotional when he mentions young mary higgins from the first time i met her i knew she was special edmund pauses for a few moments before continuing calmly can we change the subject it's too difficult for me to talk about it it's too soon
you don't know what to think is edmund really that fragile did her death affect him as much as he seems to let on yes he's the fragile one we've established this yeah well he was in love with her yeah yeah he's the one who's actually upset that's true yeah so we have one two three four five six seven eight nine ten eleven all right one two how many cards do you have in front of you uh six six sixteen twenty two 23. so we have seven more cards before we can even try to answer them well before we start losing points yeah uh do we want a question about edward as well it's the [ __ ] dance teacher it's some stupid thing yeah we probably should talk to the guests um but yeah ask him about over because that is going to be important if we're trying to establish more motive like if there is something [ __ ] going on uncle edward uh wasn't good enough for mary i shouldn't say such truthful things because he's always been there for me and either since our parents died and i know that eden and i have shall we say relatively indulgent lifestyles but i'm not upset about his death your astonishment causes him to react don't look so shocked miss harper i'm quite sure he's dead edith jonathan william and i were together the night before last we all had a little to drink and william told us that it was impossible for edward to have survived the storm and the fall i remember that thomas was serving our drinks and although he didn't say anything he seemed very upset by the news wait a minute wait a minute
edmund all right time for a time frame thing again all right we were drinking the night before last so the 19th i was walking alone in the forest when the tragedy occurred what i don't know i've always loved the great outdoors we were caught in a snowstorm yes i challenged them to climb it together we were caught in a stone storm we tied ourselves together and ever led the way did that letter say when i think after an hour dragging me with him it all happened so fast he must have been poorly attached because i found myself alone back home made my way to my closet went back to the cleft the next day but found no side of edward you know i think kevin's on to something everyone thinks that the uh the old woman camilla is insane uh i bet you money she's seen something she's probably some [ __ ] catatonic old lady who was looking out the window at one particular time and she's like i saw that one that's in every mystery story it can't be in this one this is the one you need they like to do typical like tropes like they did that with you know the other one the other one yeah but they put one on the spoiler oh i still think we should talk to her i mean we got some time i mean she's so close to the [ __ ] grave as well maybe
she can talk to mary all right sitting in her wheelchair the mischievous looking old lady sizes you up well we know it was her where did we see wheel marks mr yellow wheelchair yeah sitting in her wheelchair my dear miss harper you're not suggesting that in my age i've decided to embark on a career in crime you can't be serious my child i played chess with edith all morning it was a long game that we began a few days ago we had trouble concentrating because of miss purcell's piano playing you can hear anything in this house even though i've asked edward time again to have that problem fixed we can question her about the alistar family and question her about mary higgins question about the family the whole [ __ ] family miss harper uh rest assured you won't get a more honest answer than mine i might as well be completely frank with you apart from elizabeth our entire family lives on edward's dime that's why i have a hard time understanding why someone would want to hurt miss mary higgins so her thoughts on mary a lovely dunce edward an overconfident gambler edmund bland fearful and unable to take the slightest initiative without his twin support edith allister strong and determined the exact opposite of her brother william a failure who returned from australia broke and he brought mary with him in his luggage his version of his hike with edward doesn't convince anyone
jane lloyd the daughter of elizabeth is noisy jonathan has no personality the butler and the gardener excellent servant and cecilia purcell a simple entertainer this he's the dance teacher a failure who returned from australia broke and he brought mary with him in his luggage i thought that i guess it doesn't i guess this doesn't disprove that but edward met mary in australia visiting william oh so that could still be true that could still be true but and and then yeah he came home from his visit and then william came back a failure but with mary so william doesn't live in australia or he did but now he's back right he's yeah he was funny he was there for business or for oh and his business failed a failed yeah venture interesting edward is the so based off what everyone is saying edmund definitely we can rule edmond out there's no way because he like idolized mary and is a coward unless she rejected him then that's why and a fit of rage but i mean no maybe no that'd be very out of character but i mean like also stranger things also yeah well it'd be very out of character for like what he presents anyway if he's smart enough to
you know the music room is interesting because she's saying you know well well not so much for that but she's saying you can hear everything in this house so you'd hear someone struggling you know kicking or whatever trying to get out of the chair you would hear commotion yeah especially if we're looking at this picture there's a vase that got knocked over so the music room would be the perfect cover to cover up any type of noise who'd you say she was playing playing the piano someone was playing um yeah miss purcell's piano playing that's purcell let's go talk to miss purcell i want to go to a location the music room okay well i'm because we're talking to too many people i think we're not narrowing down we're just getting more leads yeah um okay also related to it and it led us to the music room that's fine but now let's go to the music room all right the music room the music room the music yeah the but i'm gonna question her about mary higgins though i'll keep that one uh the butler wants to might as well just keep them all together mary was an innocent young thing a fountain of youth that edward drank from without restraint she was refreshingly candid docile and entertaining i can understand how a man as unimaginative as edward could find her to his liking every conversation with her was indescribably boring in banal but i think that even at your age you understand that eloquences the eloquence is not the first quality a man looks for in a woman isn't that right miss harper
edward wasn't the one who appreciated mary's charm and youth edmond was enamored of this young woman it was obvious but he never dared admit it to her he's far too awkward and indecisive to take the initiative yeah definitely ruling edmond out and if they i swear to god if it's edmund i'm gonna throw the biggest fit because everything is pointing away from edmond i know almost a little too suspicious you know at that point everyone keeps reminding us how weak and will we willless and you know pussy-footed edmond is how big big of a [ __ ] he is he doesn't but that can't be because everyone who works on cars is the toughest guy around that's true so that that's weird well everyone who drives a big massive pickup truck i mean they're just so cool no they're just late they're kissing just
all right music room the music room which is also connected to the conservatory which is interesting because if you're gonna go somewhere to read in the conservatory yeah why go somewhere that would be right next to somewhere this is gonna be loud and obnoxious unless the music was good people don't mind music some people just don't mind noise in general i think this will disprove you also she liked the music room is a large room that faces west it is separated from the conservatory by a door the large windows are hung with beautiful curtains that are tied back with braided ropes a large harp and a cello are on display but without a doubt the magnificent grand piano is the most beautiful object in this room we can examine the curtain tie backs also might be a murder weapon and uh oh i wonder if that i wonder if this is that rope well oh it's not actually rope it was from that but we can also play a few notes on the piano okay let's examine the rope because we got that right there yeah it'll probably it may connect would you look at that the curtain no it actually doesn't the curtain tie back this tie back is a perfect match for the curtains in the music room where you found it however i don't know if you would know it
and then play a few notes on the piano you sit down uh in front of the piano and um mechanically play a few notes recalling the music lessons you took as a child except for a few notes that sound out of tune you haven't really lost your touch drawn by the music young jane approaches you and declares you're as bad as miss purcell was this morning oh dad out of the mouths of babes you prepare to answer when you finally decide that all of this is not helping your investigation or is it she wasn't playing everyone thought it was her playing no miss purcell was this morning oh but she's just a bad piano player yeah she's she's a dance teacher she's an entertainer she's like i'm a dancer how many cards do we have we have yeah count all yours i'll count everything else we have one two three four five six seven eight nine ten eleven twelve thirteen fourteen fifteen i have fourteen and there's this one four errors so you have fourteen so fifty so thirty right at exactly thirty okay we can always change these so let's go ahead and um yes [ __ ] guess i have no idea all right cat go ahead and write down because i'm not gonna mark on this okay um so uh you can just do one two three four how are you doing okay who was the killer who do we think is the killer definitely the female twin edith
have we talked to edith we have not okay so we don't know if anything matches let's look at our suspects it's not it's obviously unless camilla can get out of her chair and uh because the footprints that we have based off of this is yeah after careful exam in the back you know some mark it seems like someone something was pressed against the back of the chair the mark is approximately 10 inches long and this matches the same what if what if camilla rolled up behind her threw the rope over but it doesn't mean that she can't move her legs she can't walk on them no i will i'll burn this [ __ ] game if it's camilla so we know it's not her the butler doesn't match the footprints in the snow um the gardener and edmund both match gloves and footprints but we know it's not gloves because we we're knowing it's not because this is also old rope the fact the curtain tie back makes actually more sense because it's readily available and then right right over yarn yeah bra in the other room uh the fact that you can hear everything in this and since music was playing this morning yeah um that uh if she was playing well and we're assuming the timelines match up if she was playing it wouldn't be her someone would have had to walk through it's most likely not the 10 year old
girl i think it's edith i think william is the most obvious one but i think he was more in he cared more about killing edward not killing mary because so far everyone seemed to like mary yeah the only person here who wouldn't like mary is edith so let's write down ethan edith um because even elizabeth i think if she if she favored edward the most um she probably wouldn't kill mary yeah those are the two okay that i'm thinking well actually does uh does the footprint match um elizabeth can i see elizabeth's card again it uh it does okay so we don't know about technically we also don't know about edith's shoe size what is the motive i want to say jealousy if it's edith if it's edith then it'd be jealousy yeah because if um if jonathan has told elizabeth hey by the way if edward dies mary gets nothing edith wouldn't know that um so that would also be a motive they're used to living this luxurious lifestyle and um maybe there's sorry to interrupt you but i i think i
think i like where you're going with this but i bet there are two separate crimes that edward is probably dead or it was an attempted murder because uh i had such a good train of thought and i just lost it so i'm gonna keep going thank you for interrupting [ __ ] i'll get back to you i'll get back to it i'm gonna put my glasses back but at the same time edith wouldn't even edmond wouldn't want edward dead because he's the one they it the mom said everyone lives off his dime yeah like so uh i'm gonna go with the motive is um
right now our best our best motive is edith's jealousy yeah with her with her brother yeah like hey he might he seems maybe maybe they got an argument and it's like oh hey you usually listen to me all the time and now because mary's around so we'll go with jealousy what events led the murderer to commit this heinous act jealousy um you said an argument well edmund's edmund's infatuation with mary mm-hmm uh and yeah is concerned about taking his brother away yeah her brother yep so that's what we'll go with uh edmonds infatuation with mary no there's gotta be more to it there probably is but we haven't talked to edith so this is our first one if you know one the one through thirty guys the murderer use three objects or items name them what'd you put that is his stick shift anyway yep the murderer used three objects or items named them uh gloves the curtain tie i don't think the gloves are part of it may not be but it's all we got right now well it's objects the piano piano oh to cover up yes cover up the noise um the snow
the gloves may or may not be but yeah and she used them both and the old rope and the chair leverage like if she's okay if you want to like if she's pressing against it that's definitely gonna give her more torque to uh so i put the chair i don't know i don't think the gloves have anything to do with it i wouldn't i wouldn't have thought of that but you say it yeah it's justifiable right in what order did the events leading up to the murder take place nice okay so there's the hike yep where one of them disappears edmund edward edward disappears yep that obviously is important yeah because him missing leads to edith if we're assuming it's either take an action against mary um the only thing that i can think of is they don't know that they assume mary mary mary mary what if you know what the the financial motive is back if mary's pregnant yeah and that would have been an important event leading up to the murder we don't know that if we could talk to the doctor oh my god she's pregnant with
edmund's baby no edmund uh never had the the urge courage to she unfortunately committed a crime against oh yeah we're going that route huh it's possible um yeah because i can't i can't imagine the lawyer did it i can't imagine the dance person did it lawyers don't commit crimes no they're always 100 faithful to everything they do uh just like uh the defender the defendant for okay oh my god um yeah i i also want to go check out the drawing room because that also was connected to the conservatory they do their drawings so we don't know enough about the events to even guess well we can i mean i mean why bother really yeah i don't know move on okay i mean because we don't i mean we might get we might get uh we might get 20 points we might be somewhere on the ball yeah okay so now all the questions that's all the questions there's five god this one's rough this one's hard this is a big boy uh this is a big boy i was in there i'm like only three in the base game okay because i thought they were gonna be like the demo we did nope the demo was hard i should have known uh okay guys we knew we knew when it was five questions and 30 cards yeah we knew they're like yeah you're
not gonna get it what's the next threshold uh 31-45 so the next 15 cards okay nice uh drawing room go sure so forth and be drawing oh this was the chess game that uh that camilla was saying she was uh playing with edith just off the conservatory the drawing room has a magnificent hardwood floor in the southwest corner of the room there is a chess table a game is in progress a small cart with a tea set on it is placed next to the table oh my god mary was ill because she was slowly getting poisoned with arsenic over time no that doesn't happen in real life huh that doesn't happen in real life oh okay well this isn't real life well no somebody didn't somebody asked about like herbs earlier uh i think that was your [ __ ] imagination i'm not having a meltdown you're having a meltdown i do not maybe the doctor here read read that maybe it's in there so mary was reading while someone was playing piano yeah it seems like it could be distracting but see that's what i thought but cats like some people like to listen to music and read and you know what they say all the time it's true say what and that's why you are the way you are all right uh why am i oh i'll leave that up to you to decide i'm going to check out the chess game
probably a beautiful wooden table probably dating from the 17th century there's a game in progress and black is about to lose with just one move white will have black and checkmate what's more white could probably have won at least five moves ago one chair faces the white playing piece while there is no chair facing the black oh because uh carmilla's camilla's playing as black she says she was playing with edith yep all morning and so okay so edith was white it's not edith edith was edith was distracting camilla camilla if she could have won five turns ago she would have been continuing the game long enough keeping her there while someone else went in and did it what a weird thing to put down there though they're about to lose but they could have won if you had seen the board five moves earlier yeah well i think in chess can't you like pick up on that like if you're a grand master address you there's like it's like i'm gonna move my pawn here oh the winsenberg strategy it's like oh my god you freak like why are you like this i hate chess just makes me so mad we should play it sometime no i'll play onitamo with you that's that's more fun for me it is close okay the fact that they mentioned that okay so so it's a conspiracy one okay well yeah um especially if the door is open based off this picture if the door is open actually it's easier here because
there's nothing covering it white it white can't see into the into the room uh but um camilla could have so keeping her focus on the game and she would know when it was over she would know when the deed was done and it was quiet again but that also implies that maybe the piano player was in on it too because they would need to be causing a rock us why would she be be playing piano if she's actually not a piano she's an entertainer maybe well jane the daughter was like you're as bad as she was maybe she was trying to entertain the ten-year-old maybe so someone else is involved um elizabeth oh my god maybe it was edmond maybe he's so distraught and didn't want to talk about it because he loved her but he did whatever eva told him to do because he's so bitch-whipped he's so like you're gonna [ __ ] do this because he did everything he would do it he said i would do anything for my sister he did and maybe she wanted him to kill mary because she's like hey edward's gone we're gonna lose everything um or mary rejected him no i i don't think so i don't think that that is a thing did edward go missing before she before she died right oh yeah at least a couple of days concerned at least a couple of days i guess yeah okay okay at least two days so edith kept the mom distracted because they were playing a game
edmund would have snuck in and done it maybe that's why he's so distraught because he did love mary but he loves his sister more and maybe maybe that's why he did it from behind because he didn't couldn't look at her it was a very personal thing to strangle someone i don't know i mean i know it was rough i know i've heard it gets easier by the way he doesn't have the shoe size though but he doesn't have the shoes the shoes i think the shoes i think the snow's a red herring too well the footprint on the back of the chair oh you're right that's what we're assuming [ __ ] are we sure where does that snow print that's off edward what yeah you're right they don't match no the gloves didn't matter yeah not edmond okay i'm gonna check the uh the examine the cart would be on the cards she could convince william to do it but that's not the same footprint he has a matching footprint i see the wheelchair lady yeah and her footprint can you want to see her glove print she's going to do it yes oh she doesn't she charges we have squat down and grab her leg nope it's just like yeah she's like she has a little little baby foot
so here's the thing the thing is that is the size that matches the footprint on the back of the chair that's based off the yeah that's what i'm the the the footprint looks very similar and their description isn't it yeah the the footprint in here looks different but this also says it's faint which happened earlier which means it happened earlier now that now we're now we're starting to theorize that the killer was inside the house the whole time yes but that somebody was outside during the snow the guy who got it no no the guy it was the guy who found her no the gardener was late later he had larger footprints so but but that doesn't that say it's six and a half if you look more closely you notice faint footprints that are less visible because they are partially obscured by the recently fallen snow from these footprints you can conclude that someone went into the workshop and then came back out snow and wind are not the allies of a detective such because they make it difficult to measure the footprints they're probably a men's size 6.5 about 10 inches long they are possibly women's shoes but you can't be certain but that matches the footprint yes on the back of the chair so that size we think is the killer yes that's what i've been going with so if we don't think that they got the rope do we still think that they got the gloves they might have or they may have scouted out
that area make sure the gardener wasn't around maybe and went ahead of time and then came back um and that's why they're faint it's like oh okay and then the snow came came in later and covered it up um yeah so maybe the i still think the footprints are no because it matches the [ __ ] thing the fact that footprints are in the snow may not be important the fact that they match size is why we keep that card so whoever whoever matches that shoe size is involved they were involved by being outside at the right elizabeth yeah which i can't remember what if she if she matched she does yep she does the gloves don't but what are her thoughts on them either strong and determine the exact opposite of her twin and then edmond too nice to be a real alistar oh my god i don't know yeah okay you want to give up i have an idea you said you have an idea let's give up um okay floor plan floor plan floor plan the study she doesn't know about the letter what's a porter's room where the porter is what's the porter there's a guy with it's a title it's like a job
thing i'm not sure oh there are steps here there are the stairs that lead up cool how the hell is the did they also lead down how the hell is the the mom getting up there she's not a wheelchair camila how is she getting to the drawing room yeah there's a drawing room upstairs it looks like it then she's always upstairs yes she's never come down completely leave her up there oh she do go into town raise hell yeah go to the dance club racing kids and downhill contests well let's talk to edith we just talked to her and she's like i did it i mean and she's also super hot as well as a vampire just like every day at 11 am i was playing chess in the drawing room with camilla i'm obviously shocked miss harper as you can imagine oh i guess just like every day yep at 11 am her thoughts on mary higgins beautiful young and naive everything uncle edward could want in a woman edward alistair an old skin flint i don't wish him dead but i'm not heartbroken that he has disappeared you cold [ __ ] he's the one the reason why you're not poor edmund he'd be lost without me since our parents died i've taken care of him he's as gentle as a lamb william alistair i don't know him very well but he seems like a loser who is jealous of his brother's fortune fair enough elizabeth certainly smarter and stronger than her brothers her only flaws that she's a woman otherwise she'd
be the head of the family jonathan lloyd weak and submissive camilla the most sensible woman in the family we play chess every morning and thomas smith and the servants the household who are they wow who are they she's the only one who didn't say oh they're great same footprint yep but she wasn't outside at the time but she could have gone outside earlier collected the stuff collected the gloves maybe so footprint was a magic glove was not a match so edith and elizabeth may be in it together yeah which means that elizabeth is the one who did it yep but edith may be the mastermind maybe if that's the thing maybe it comes down to i'm the i'm the strong one i'm the smart one i'm the one who should run the household you know i'll get my weak [ __ ] loser brother take him on this trip that's why she has her her lawyer husband like that's why she's looking for a letter to get rid of any motive this letter this leather that states hey by the way if you die you know mary gets nothing and the goat falls on the family maybe having this is evidence that would lead to and elizabeth is just like yeah um maybe mary was like gonna financially ruin them like since she's a little younger maybe she was like more frivolous with the money and
wasting it everybody said she was really nice yeah nobody has a bad thing to say about her i'm also really nice but i'm bad with money too so yeah maybe elizabeth was the the head strong one that was like i can take over beautiful young naive um shy young woman i mean if so she's devious because she's got everybody thinking that she's got everybody saying hey she's was just great an angel uh let's see yeah her footprint matches the back yep um god if edith plays we have okay so it can't be edith because we know she was flinches playing chess and we have multiple reports stating that she was there at 11 every day so that would be something that people would know oh hey if she missed it as well yep um wow i'm trying to find another location to go to that makes sense the great hall you have to walk through the great hall to be able to um to get to the conservatory and the music room and the drawing room true so maybe there's footprints in the great hall maybe someone saw her maybe they dropped something have we looked at
everything in these rooms yet yeah yeah i've looked at every for all the locations i've looked at that book again and the book states fascinating tale in which the detective in charge of the investigation gets lost in faulty reasoning and follows red herrings in the end they never catch the murderer yep that sounds about right all right great hall they wrote a book about us we're writing the book right now oh look at that the great hall is the heart of the manor uh it leads to all of the main rooms this is also where the phone was recently installed you call dr stewart the medical examiner at st andrews hospital in fort william after a cursory examination i can confirm that the cause of death is strangulation the killer attacked the victim from behind the violence of the injury shows that it took a certain amount of strength to commit the crime the victim was wearing a scarf which prevents me from determining the murder weapon with any certainty but i would guess that it was a rope or a shoelace or something like that if you suspect anything you can show it to me and i can confirm whether or not it is a murder weapon there's the brown ah so the old rope is not the murder weapon but the new rope is also not the murderer
porter can we change our old answers now uh well yeah we can now we know yeah i don't know what a porter is yeah you can look in the room and find out yep i'm just gonna also look it up um because google's a thing well it would be common knowledge back then so where would they hide a murder weapon then well what if it's commonplace so they wouldn't have to hide it a person employed to carry luggage and other other loads especially in a railroad station airport and hotel yes of course very familiar with boarders at least this is available now where we can confirm what the weapon is so the porter's room might be where they were hiding the stuff after the fact since now we don't have a weapon true all right 41.
porter's room okay a small room used only by the servants it is filled with a variety of keys and accessories this is also where the family's mail is received as you enter you cross paths with thomas who is carrying a letter on the tray oh this is an urgent letter for elizabeth alistair i was going to give it to her may i give it to you miss harper whoo we have some options there's a box of sleeping pills on a small table there is a label with j lloyd's name on it jonathan lloyd okay we have an option we can open elizabeth's leather or we can personally deliver the letter to elizabeth oh clearly we should open it she seems awfully worried about this letter for what it's worth just before i forget uh gardner says that jonathan lloyd asked him if he had plans that would help him sleep that's what i was looking for oh okay that's what i can't sleep is because he did it because he killed her he's a sleep murderer oh my oh my god i would hate this game forever no because he then he wouldn't want to sleep like the second time i'm just done with those um the scarf was immersed was what strangled her that makes perfect sense we hammered my glasses i can't see for [ __ ] i can't see without my glasses
me either yeah okay do we open the letter or do we personally deliver it absolutely open it let's see let's act like we're personally delivering it and then open it in forever yeah i found this letter it fell open on the way i didn't cut it open oh my eye is itchy it's because i have no [ __ ] clue who did it ah that's also why my eyes aged okay um all right uh fort william uh the 21st of december so the same day okay same day of what is when this was delivered i don't know which is why it hasn't been given yet dear mrs aleister i'm afraid i'm the bearer of unfortunate news a few minutes after you left my office i received a telegram from the man i assigned to search for your brother he reported that he had discovered a body near the spot that william indicated this body is a perfect match to edward's description i'm on my way there right now to confirm it i don't want to give you any false hope my colleague is a professional if he tells me that edward allister is dead i am inclined to believe him i am most sincerely sorry for your loss but she doesn't know that yet but she sent someone to investigate confirm more like it make sure that somebody finds his body more like it i don't know i don't know who did it this is a rough one
and we removed card uh 43 from the uh oh something that would have happened if we get delivered the living brother card gone we can still deliver it to her but it's 49. she's probably pissed that we open it so and i thought about that i was like the fact that we can personally give it to her made me think that she might not be in on it but that's also just you know common courtesy it's also a red herring as we found there are some of those uh yeah so that's an option we're opening it was the red herring and we just well if we deliver it now it'll probably direct us to that card unless no this is 489 i know but i bet 49 says if you have not already discarded um yeah i mean she's basically pissed that we opened it i would be too so um oh yeah she basically leaves because we lose her card ah or no if we didn't already talk to her we would have not been able to okay okay interesting so she sent someone to investigate whether or not he was actually dead so she was either concerned about it or wanting to confirm well you'd want to find your brother either way he actually became lost or was intentionally yes yeah on their trek so i think this is
what i was trying to say earlier where there's there's uh one initial crime and then a crime going on i think it's just a crime of maybe jealousy is what we're talking about yeah those bugs are driving me crazy right um but how many cars you have also i think they killed uh someone killed edward for inheritance or slash power so we came here for one crime and we found another yeah 22 14 so 38 okay all right we still got so we started seven cards that we can look through um i does the footprint did did the footprint match it did match yes and but we know it can't it couldn't have been her because she wouldn't have gotten up and then just strangle someone 30 minutes later why 30 minutes later because she plays a lot chess with uh oh no it was found at uh yeah it was 11 30 wasn't it just like every day at 11. that's when she plays chess the body was found at 11 30. yes yeah but she could have gotten up and gotten stuff out of the garden out of the workshop that's what i'm saying it's like it's really suspicious the body was found at 11 30 meaning that edith wouldn't have had time to leave go get something and go strangle someone in the in the conservatory like almost right next door yeah yeah without that person being like what if it was the [ __ ] 10 year old who was playing she's like
hanging on i'm so silly i'm wearing my friend's shoes and kicking against it stealing shapes from the garden well we still have a murder weapon anymore no we do not it's the scarf it has to if she was wearing a scarf and its strangulation makes sense but that implies that somewhere in this deck is the scarf yes so it's somewhere in a location it's on her body we did examine her body it doesn't have to be on her body but it can be with her stuff because they have to take everything off the body yeah to examine her wouldn't just be like so wild and crazy if we talk to the guests like to cecilia what could we what do we think we could possibly gain from talking to her where she was at who she was playing for she was playing she was there in the morning she could have seen someone walk through the music room see it would be easy for elizabeth to say jane go ask cecilia to play piano and entertain you yeah you little idiot yeah i want to talk to you me as your mother you so edmund was out of the way and i'm thinking that's intentional edward yeah edward was out of the way and i'm thinking that was intentional it was all set up so that she would be alone because otherwise they couldn't guarantee that mary would be alone and it may or may not have been with the
intention of killing him but it was definitely to get him out of the way for a few days yeah and i don't think he was willingly leaving the family which points to william pushing him off over the cliff yeah that's fine but unfortunately we're not trying to figure out why edward's dead no but why that happens would have implications of who was involved and how all this she was killed later days yeah at least two days so it's like but why she gets nothing that's the thing is like she gets nothing out of it she doesn't get that manner she's like so so she knows stuff she's been blackmailing people or she's pregnant and producing an heir that would be the only thing i could think of that would give anyone a motive but the only person who would know that is the doctor which we can't talk to oh we already have we called him on the phone yeah um what's his name pearson yeah all right we can technically talk to him because i just saw the card we can talk to him if we get three of those symbols yeah that's true we knew that so we just need to look in more places and talk to more people and places are going to be better all right let's go talk to the [ __ ] dance person no i was thinking more locations just because that's that's that's going to give us more clues than talking to people the only other place is the ballroom and the library that's all library is always cool yeah
let's do the library that's what i'm feeling that's where a lot of people get killed a superb library filled with wealth of lovely volumes there's a desk next to the door that leads to the drawing room at the far end of the library a small fire is burning slowly in the fireplace i bet you man that's where the scarf's at serious black is in there serious black is hanging out there so you look at the fireplace yep oh piano string oh when you examine the fireplace you discover a string encased in a very hard material the string is partially burned you examine the string even more closely you discover tiny traces of brown leather at both ends gloves oh my god you gotta be [ __ ] my [ __ ] do i have to that is the murder weapon piano string piano oh my god what was this a professional hit which is why she was not playing well because the piano was missing at least one string it's not because she's bad at it but we know for a fact she was playing yes and the fact that she was the fact that it was missing at least one string and she was still playing implicates her she can't she couldn't have been playing and go kill someone implicates her not on the murder but in the conspiracy surrounding it oh oh i don't i don't think so okay um because i think give me all the people who have the brown the brown thing uh we said we know the brown thing the not the brown thing the green all the people that i can match footprints and um well you're looking for the people with
matching footprints right no it's actually gl or both it's gloves and footprints all right then because if it says yeah discover tiny traces of brown leather at both ends um yeah the pair of gloves brown leather gloves yeah do you want camilla i think i know all the ones that match and the gloves don't have to match perfectly it just has to be just right or too big
well uh no otherwise this game would be totally [ __ ] oh oh i you're right otherwise it'd be like oh anyone can do it yeah i guess i can put on gloves that are bigger you can yeah but or small yeah exactly but that for for game mechanics it would be way too wide open so there there'd be no point putting that on right so edmund has it um suspect's hands are smaller than the gloves but she was playing chess so it's not edith william can do it and of course joseph mason i don't think he did it because he's he he's the gardener there is gloves yes he's like wow um any and his feet are too big uh yes and he's a size 11 and he is not he's not a size 11 and he's always the other one no he's not he's not the other one either oh really yeah so it can't be edmund is there really william because it also says the size is approximately 10 inches oh sorry there's one more if we think the butler might have duded it his hands are too big the suspect's hands are bigger than the gloves okay that means the gloves are too small um and he also is not the same i mean he's the size of the the small one but he's a butler he could have just i don't think the help is involved
um yeah everyone says no the nice are the ones you got to watch out for uh did you hand me oh she's right here she see eleven but she's also a suspect's hands are smaller than the gloves yeah but that doesn't mean i mean if cat's right that doesn't mean if they're smaller she could still fit in the gloves well so clearly in my mind this is trying to lead us to the one person who did it all yeah but we're already thinking two or three people at least are involved the two people that are left based off of shoe size but they do have to have this hand and foot you would think um but we've we've literally checked everyone except except the piano player yeah also though i i do think that the game is taking in into account that we're smart enough to understand that if i have small hands and i have a pair of big gloves i can still use the gloves yeah i see it both ways right yeah so i'm not counting this um as as an option um i was just matching just because i was the only person left uh she did not match the footprints but she did match the gloves so if that's right then if we're matching the footprint on the back you'd have to consider you'd if you had consider i don't think it was william i think it's elizabeth um i think we thought that yeah yes but the um william seems too obvious he seems to be
the one that's going to be like oh i [ __ ] hated that one but he has no reason to kill mary he has a reason to kill his brother and he might have and he might have um elizabeth does have a reason um yeah she doesn't match or she matches the footprints and it's like oh you need considerable strength to be able to do this that's why your foot is against the thing she would know about the music room um she would know about uh playing chess she's the only one who would probably know the layout of everything and elizabeth allister is strong elizabeth alistair is a strong woman we've taken that to mean willed but yeah they're all saying certainly smarter and stronger than her brother yeah i think she's the killer maybe she was waiting to get that letter to um to confirm uh edward's death so that it's like maybe maybe jonathan didn't tell her hey mary sorry that's what i said earlier which was like she wasn't truly wondering she was sending someone out to confirm like hey you need to find his body like yeah so i can now kill mary and then get get the get all the stuff there we go and if edith is like oh man if she wasn't a woman she'd be able to uh she'd be the head of the house and she's like you're damn right okay what other locations i mean of course i mean so at least william and elizabeth were in on it together or she convinced william to bump off
edmond or edward yeah i think a lot of people are involved but i think the person who actually did it is elizabeth where's the oh we can also examine the desk let's just do that while we're at it sheet of paper you find some of dr pearson's letterhead on the desk using the old detective trick of rubbing a pencil in between your butt crack rubbing a pencil over the paper you make a few words appear kill mary you may uh okay dr timothy pearson general practitioner fort william patient mary higg herbal tea months rest she was pregnant she was pregnant she was pregnant yep and that's the second one and that's how she got edith involved to to to make sure there wasn't an error interesting well also the letter that the lawyer said he says i'm you know i've been your i'm the family lawyer and i'm your lawyer in many affairs and maybe that's one of them maybe that's why oh but that also would make sense because edward was suspect or not suspicious uh superstitious about both of his wives dying after their marriage and one of them did die after um so maybe he was just really like i don't want to marry you just because i don't want you to die or maybe he didn't know she was pregnant he was going through a lot of trauma you know yeah yep so there's two of our three
uh yeah if they have an air because it specifically states in that letter without you having an heir the house all goes to them and who's first i should i should tally how many times you've yawned this entire this entire time i've been in a few times i have been out of the house all day me too working getting a new job yes i'm allowed to yawn no you're not i am i am if anything should happen to you your estate would go to elizabeth william edmond and edith elizabeth is named first but i'm sure they're all equal okay i really want to figure out what the third one is you may draw this card if you collected three cadecius symbols i just want to know what the other one is because we have two of them now that's probably in a location and we're like oh you know what it probably is it's probably um jonathan lloyd um okay because he was asking for like medical herbs well that's true so i'm more just curious if uh what was it was whenever we see 32 yeah um big green thing at the bottom it's about his uh marriage oh okay yeah let's just do it why the [ __ ] not jonathan lloyd i was resting alone in my room when miss higgins was found i'll have to deal with that in addition to edward's eventual estate
um his thoughts yeah mary higgins a nice girl elizabeth we've been married for more than 20 years everything is going swimmingly um jane lloyd elizabeth adopted her 10 years ago a charming little girl edward a wealthy entrepreneur the only thing that hasn't been a success is his love life william allister he came back from australia broke with mary the daughter of one of his friends if i'm not mistaken and camilla she's not in her right mind but i think she likes me and we can question him about how those two go together right we can question him about his marriage which would be 26. are we just gonna go through everything now no no i just wanted to get the third one oh elizabeth took me as her husband 22 years ago since then we've lived in perfect harmony elizabeth and i sleep in separate rooms because i'm prone to insomnia elizabeth went to town to order sleeping pills for me because i seem to have misplaced my pill box last night i had a really bad night maybe my sleeping pills have been delivered to the porters room i'll have to check my one and only regret is that i couldn't give elizabeth a child but she adopted little jane she's a lovely child with a real passion for dance in fact her teacher cecilia purcell came especially from edinburgh to teach her and we got the third one which allows us to look at timothy pearson the alistair family doctor came to the manor as soon as news of mary's death reached forge william miss harper if i agreed to break doctor doctor patient confidentiality it's with the alistair family's consent ms higgins has been my patient since she arrived in scotland i hadn't haven't had a chance
to speak with my medical examiner colleague dr stewart yet you can call him from the great hall so we can question him about mary higgins we can question him about edward alistar and we can question about the rest of the alistar family or we're probably right about 45 at this point yeah probably 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 um 26 28 32 34 36 38 40 42 43 here we counted everything right yep so we can actually do a couple more before we count the one i did yep so we can do two more i think we should just spend them here and then answer and then see if we're right or wrong so do you want a question about mary higgins no i think all he's gonna say is she's pregnant but i would confirm or he's just have i mean we don't have confirmation we have a very strong submission i didn't have time to speak with the medical examiner but i'm sure he will tell you the same thing i'm about to tell you yep mary higgins was pregnant that's why i've been out to the alistar manor so often recently mary's last appointment was three days ago we spent a good part of the morning in the library trying to be as discreet as possible mary even asked me to keep my voice to a whisper it was almost comical i do understand her concern however she didn't want to tell edward about her pregnancy too soon she said she didn't want to give him a false sense of hope after what happened to colin and catherine i beg you to act the utmost discretion miss harper this
information is highly confidential that's right and then a question about the rest of the alistar family or question them about edward alastair i don't think we need to question him about my virginity would he call that out specifically yeah um because the rest of them is just going to be a bunch of general info that there might be some important little tips but edward is more targeted and i don't know why we i don't know why we would talk to about edward so that makes me want to talk to him about it all right let's just do it why not look at a book but yep edward was in great shape the last time i saw him he wanted me to examine him to make sure he was up to his brother williams challenge from a physical point of view i thought he was fit to hike up golvain as planned however i told him to be careful and made him agree to turn around at the slightest sign of weakness i also took the opportunity to examine william he is in exceptional physical shape and seem perfectly capable of managing any problems that might have arisen during the hike he was injured on the hike but he seems to be recovering quickly does he also seem to be physically capable of mirror mirror all right you're right that was pointless so let's answer the questions okay who was the killer the actual killer yep elizabeth elizabeth alistair yes god if if we're wrong i will be upset what is the motive to get the manner yeah right to not lose
okay what events led to the murderer to commit this heinous act okay so her pregnancy william convinced um edward to go on a hike and then bumped him off sure um but the main the main reason for that would be to make sure that elizabeth elizabeth that mary is mary is alone and vulnerable well yeah he's a target um so well i think it was an accident i do think oh oh and if we're if we're going with a financial motive it may have been an accident but if we're going to the financial motive then that would guarantee that they would actually have control of their portion well yeah obviously now you could just go try to find another way yeah it's true we're tired of them trying to trying to come up with an error we're just gonna get rid of him yeah okay so the events uh the the pregnancy um brings it was critical yeah and then edward's disappearance or edward's death would anyone else have known about mary's pregnancy they were being very discreet probably the lawyer the you you said it earlier that camilla said that everything carries and mary's not familiar with the house life oh yeah so she was yeah she's literally overheard over here okay okay all right uh the murderer used three objects or items name them the piano wire piano string gloves the armchair and the
gloves okay those are the three and in what order did the events leading up to the murder take place i don't know what that means yeah like that seems very vague um because it makes me think we think we know the story so yeah we'll see if we're right we'll see if there are any surprises all right okay so nice that this recently it's actually folded what if it's like mary's alive what this is for case number three all right over the who is the killer oh you're right over the course of your investigation you identified uh tons of people you you identified is every reason to believe that several suspects who would have had an interest marry oh oh okay all right it's it's laid out weird it goes like this oh over the course of your investigation you identified several suspects who would have had an interest in seeing edward alistar gone elizabeth alistair william allister edmund allister um edith allister and even jonathan lloyd they all could have uh benefited from the inheritance left by edward but what about mary who would have had something to gain from her untimely demise there was every reason to believe that mary higgins murder would not benefit anyone and yet one person was convinced otherwise oh my god that person is edith alistair moreover as we shall explain there is a wealth of evidence to prove her guilt okay we technically got it right it was
our first guess the motive for this crime is the most classic motive of all money edith and edmund's parents left her and her brother in a dire financial situation since they lost their parents edward had provided for edith and her brother this did not keep edith from spending her money lavishly but this probably wasn't enough for her she saw an opportunity to gain her financial independence she had nothing to gain from mary's death in itself but she would most certainly benefit from the death of edward and his future heir wow okay what events led the murderer to commit this heinous act for edith to inherit uh part of edward's fortune two conditions had to be met firstly edward would have to die but he would also need to die without a direct heir if edward were to have a child the child would inherit his father's entire fortune when edith learned he was to have an heir she had to find a way to get rid of it um if she was to succeed in her plans two events push edith to take action a conversation with william although she was no she has no proof if edith is convinced that lord edward is dead she became certain of this following a conversation with william william did state that it seemed impossible to him that edward could have survived his fall however edward's death was not enough as there was a matter of the future heir thus the second event that prompted edith to act her discovery of mary's pregnancy it was not so much mary who had who was the target of the attack as it was the child she was carrying it was clear that all the members of the family that married would not receive a share of the inheritance in the event of edward's death but this would most certainly not
be the case for his unborn child edith learned that mary was pregnant during one of her daily chess games in the drawing room the drawing room is just off the library and the walls in this house are paper thin either edith must have slipped away while her aunt camilla dozed off uh to spy on dr pearson and mary who were trying to be discreet um okay oh maybe there was something in the tea that caused her to fall asleep to carry out their plan the murderer obviously needed the sleeping pills because he said that his stuff won't mention to carry out her plan the murderer obviously needed the murder weapon a piano string glove so as not to damage her hands and a sleeping pill thus she could commit the crime on her own and make sure to have an alibi on camilla's statement in what order um did events leading up to the murder take place three days ago while playing chess with camilla and camilla had dylan again edith heard the whispers of dr pearson mary from the nearby library either discovered that mary was pregnant but kept it to herself on the eve of the murder her conversation with william persuaded edith that edward was dead aware that she had to act quickly if she wanted to hold on to her share of the inheritance she spent the next day hatching her plan at the end of the day she stole jonathan's sleeping pills this explains why he had a bad night and was looking for his sleeping pills the morning of the murder either took one of the defective piano strings that the piano tuner had thrown away after he had finished with the piano before her chess game with camilla edith went to the workshop to get the gloves she would
use to keep from hurting herself with the piano string once mary was settled in the conservatory reading her novel edith put sleeping pills sleeping pills in camilla's cup of tea and waited for her to fall asleep she then slipped out to the conservatory and strangled mary with the piano string protecting her hands with the gloves the gloves left traces of brown leather on the piano string edith threw the murder weapon into the fire and as the snow began to fall she went to return the gloves back to the workshop edith should have made the tea disappear but she probably wouldn't have drawn attention to herself by clearing the dishes when this was usually thomas's job there are several pieces of evidence that point to edith the footprints leading to the workshop and the mark of the armchair are a match of edith's shoe size also the gloves are too big for edith's hands but they but anyone can wear gloves that are too big can't they did did william murder edward this issue no doubt troubled you throughout your investigation however there is nothing here that indicates whether it was a murder or a terrible accident it's a mystery that william allister will certainly take to his grave oh that's funny and can white really mate in just one move like the chess game uh it's possible rook to f7 checkmate that's funny all right so whenever we score do we score based off of um our final guesses are yeah uh each level i would yeah if your final score is correct yeah so if it's wrong you score zero points so did we get anything right
um we we know that we got um three four and uh i'm counting one right because we did say edith well our final our final answer was elizabeth yeah so it would be wrong then uh i'd say we got three out of five right okay so we got the motive yeah because we said money yeah uh motive the events and uh well the murder weapons we didn't get because we didn't say the um sleeping pills oh sorry uh because we said the chair although i will say that's entirely misleading because it says object slash items this is an object yeah so like the fact it should have just said items instead of being vague about that yeah um so we would have gotten a point yeah either smiles sweetly as you at you as you accuse her of murder you and she both know that your theory won't hold up in court the case will be dropped um if we got uh well at that point at three points we would have had to get all of them right but uh between 15 and 24 eth was eventually charged and wasn't able to avoid prison her brother edmund devastated by the event left scotland a few months later to start a new life in the united states and i'm sure it went well for him and that is suspects everyone i hope you enjoyed uh click the i to go to the discussion
other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you