Evenfall - Board Game Review - UNLIMITED POWER!!
Transcript
hi everyone I'm Luke heor and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences we'll get on with the show in just a minute but first a quick word for my sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solu head down to my new sponsor Kender Kender stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on orders over £30 further discounts on bulk purchases and even 5% of your spending refunded back to you as points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get 5% discount on your first order over £60 so let's make gaps in your collection a ft of the past get down to Kender and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy enjoy the rest of the video get on with it talk about the game that was popular among many and yet i' barely even heard of it yeah evenfall this was a game that literally when I was talking about my anticipated games for Essen people were going like oh finally a top 10 that doesn't have even fall on it and it's like what's even fall and I just completely missed this one I think I must have like glossed past it when I was looking through like the tabletop together tool maybe heard the title maybe saw the cover maybe something about it must have made me go ah whatever and just sort of skipped by it but finally I decided you know what while I was at Essen I grabbed a demo of it had a chat with a designer very nice chat you know even switched the uh English and German decks around so I could get into a demo when loads of people were camping it in the morning check out my Vlog where I talk a bit
that about that in more detail but you we we I basically got to sit down have a demo with three other players and now I I grabbed a copy and decided that I would do this one for review this isn't a review copy this is literally me going hm okay I want to buy this and see what's what it ticks and see if it handles well with lower player accounts how well the solo mode works Etc and I'm seeing a lot of people give a lot of praise to this one uh but of course when I see a lot of people giving praise the kudin in me thinks something must be up well question is is there or is actually Justified even for is essentially an engine builder card game you play as witches and elders and mages and D whatever the theme doesn't really make a difference here but what you're essentially doing over three rounds is that you are utilizing this deck full of multi-use cards in order to score the most victory points by playing different locations out but by also putting ritual cards on those locations to trigger like special abilities or bonuses but also playing Specialists to get special abilities as the game goes on but then also council members in order to get game end abilities or round end scor ring it's there's a lot of different things that you can do with these cards but it's one of those types of games where basically each round you do as many things as you can from the available actions until everybody passes so you've got to micromanage your resources like leads and uh potions Etc you've got to utilize an element of worker placement with your witches and your slightly more restricted elders and basically it's a casol be as efficient
as possible get as much as you can done with the resources and cards you have and try not to pass too early so that you're basically wasting your time but the cards that you've got to play come in various multi-use guises so for example specialists can be played either as a special ability that goes throughout the game or it can be slid underneath your board in order to be a could be a special ability it could be a round end scoring it could be a game end scoring you know they've got two different uses but then also you have the rituals essentially the rituals of power whatever which you place on these locations of power they call everything power in this game everything's got a power thing but these places of power you can Harvest to get some more resources if they're on the top of your board I.E your inner sorry your Outer Circle which is essentially the top here but then these rituals whoop where did that ritual go there we go these rituals can be placed on these locations so like so they'll score the victory points if you can get them into your Outer Circle which is the bottom part of your board but they might have more action spaces for you to use your various witches and Elders on in order to trigger more bonuses once you get to the end of the round there is a battle phase which takes place on these three two or three locations depending on player count and basically these have got action spaces for witches but there's also these are the ways that you actually get these places of power and at the end of the round you essentially do a scythe bidding phase where you secretly bid how much Mana you're going to spend from
what You' collected compare it sorry add it to the witches that you've already got at the location and everybody gets prizes based on how much power they contributed but the winner gets a power Stone which effectively can dou double the point value of something in their Inner Circle so you win some repeat these three rounds and at the end of the game have a guess of course card-based engine builder games are not something that is uh somewhat uncommon in the world of board gaming a lot of people were trying to say oh this was a bit like race for the Galaxy but honestly no it's not really race for the Galaxy has the simultaneous phase thing where you're selecting what phases are going to happen and then you play the cards there's only so many actions you can do and stuff and it's like nah this game isn't race for the Galaxy I compare it to that I'd instead compare it to something like empires of the north because empires of the north is another one of those or even Imperial settlers you know that whole family of games where you play cards in front of you they have special abilities you have restrict you know limited resources and you try to do as much as you can until you're forced to pass and end the round this is essentially the same sort of deal but I also want to compare it to a game I've still got on my shelf and I've not played in ages called elisium This is a little Hidden Gem from a while ago that nobody really talks about anymore but in elisium you had cards that you collected and they went above your board for certain reasons but then you wanted to try and get them below your board for scoring well this kind of works in a similar fashion because a location that's at the top of your board allows you to harvest it for resources but then if you can get it to the bottom end your board the out the outer to the Inner
Circle it will then score points and you're able to use your elders for work of placement on those actions rather than witches that normally have to go to the other locations where you battle so there's an element of Alisia an element of like the Imperial settlers Universe combine the two and you effectively get even full I don't get it production wise the game is fine I mean it's not the cheapest game in the world but it does give you some half decent quality components I mean you've got wooden resources you've got some cool screen printed uh chunky wooden meeples I mean these are pretty cool you know the elders and the witches having their hats on and stuff no actual faces I mean you don't really see any faces you just sort of see the clothing thereit which is quite a nice touch uh you've got your player boards which you have to use the what's it called double-sided sticky tape in all to stick down but no big deal I mean they function nicely and they're pretty sturdy mainly really you're getting the artwork for the price point though the artwork in this is really really nice I mean look at that the cover I must Adit I glossed past it when I went past in tabletop together I'm surprised I did because that cover is beautiful I really like the look at that cover you know everything else like the rule book here these various boards even all the cards the cards have got some really wonderful artwork on it and if you don't know the artist U Martin motet I believe you will find that that name also features in revive revive is a game where his artwork is barely on show because no matter how good the art is in revive there's not a lot of it and the game kind of looks Bland when it's on the
table come on Fanboys admit it but here the artwork is on show it's on all the cards it's on all the locations it's on your player boards the rule book you know this artwork is there to be scen I mean I especially love it on these uh Battlegrounds you know the the central mountains there you've got this kind of yellow Autumn I really like that look you know it's just it's a really cool look for this game it fits the theme that it's going for and let to say not the cheapest game of the round but it nothing in here feels tacky the multiuse card thing is something I enjoy in board games and here it's no exception I like it here as well although it's only in some respects the artifacts and rituals that you put down on the cards are kind of note they give you an action space or some cool ability so they're not exactly really multi-use the multi-use aspect comes from the specialist cards of which there's two uses for each you either have the special ability as a specialist or you put it underneath your board as a council member but what I do like is a there's a lot of them so there's a good amount of variety the abilities are pretty varied but another aspect I like is that you can't have more than one of them in your coven you can't duplicate but the bottom abilities for the council members are different between the two copies so yes the ongoing ability is the same but the bottom bit is different so there's quite a lot of variety in some of the end game like and round end and sort of ability things you get from Council Members which means that in this game there is quite a lot of different strategies that can formulate based on the cards you get now it is difficult to formulate a strategy from the get-go because you get your initial set of
cards and there's only so much you do in the first round the first round is quite quick round two and three is where the real meat lies and where a lot of more stuff is happening but your first round is mainly kind of setting up what you're good at to begin with and there's only so many things that you can kind of decide at that point but you know it is good that there are a lot of different varieties of ways to play I have tried multiple different paths I've gone battle focused I've gone ritual focused I've gone Harvest focused I've gone coven track focused you know I've gone you know I've done you know or you know other thing focused you know there there's a lot of different ways that you can play and it's good to have that for an engine builder the problem Choice even the player boards have got asymmetric Powers you can play your first game with just basic symmetrical sides but then you have got four different player boards with asymmetrical sides on them and you can basic each one has a very different style of play I haven't yet noticed any to be completely unbalanced yet although I've heard reports that maybe the blue star is a little bit powerful at times but honestly I just find these quite entertaining to play and honestly if you're playing with Gamers you could probably just switch to using the like you know asymmetrical side off the GetGo and it will do a decent job so combine that with the rest of the cards that you've got for strategies in that even though the deck of cards is only so big I mean that's not a bad size for the deck of cards and you only see so many of them in the game I mean you draw typically six every round and you might draw a few more You' not seen a lot of the deck yourself during the game so
yeah decent amount of variety around the game itself is actually not that complicated either the rules are not particularly huge I mean there's not a lot of rules in this book that there is a lot of pictorial examples there so it looks like a lot of pages but there's a lot of examples it's written clearly I didn't have a problem understanding anything in this book it's pretty well written and well done and the game overview and icons on the back of the book is really the only reference age you need but on top of that you do have a little reference Aid each that tells you every single action including important cost you need to know free action that you can do and then it gives you the most important like iconography on here this is about as good a reference AG you need and thankfully somebody actually knows how to do a half decent reference aid but yeah if you're a gamer you'll pick up this pretty quickly don't recommend it for casuals though and light Gamers I think are going to struggle a bit more but a midweight gamer a heavy gamer for sure is going to pick this up without too much trouble the fear I have with lighter Gamers is that they'll look at all the options of the cards and what they can do and maybe just get a little bit overwhelmed but I expected this to be quite fiddly a little bit clunky and honestly I couldn't really think of anything in this game that was fiddly or clunky everything kind of everything just kind of made sense the game also comes with a solo mode and the designer was adamant that it couldn't be a Beaty own score AI well it's not it's actually an automa it's an AI opponent and essentially what you do is you do everything you normally do in a multiplayer game for 99% the most part but essentially the deck of cards acts as the AI so you flip a card off the top
of the deck and its Victory point value is how much you move around this track and this track dictates whether it plays a card to its area you know it has its own player board and such whether it gets VP whether it levels up its own coven track you know it does its own thing as the automa and to keep it simple most of the stuff it does just gets it victory points but it does mean that you do actually have an AI opponent and a pretty tough one at that yeah um four levels of difficulty and you should be able to beat this on the easiest difficulty although it's still going to be you know a bit of a challenge on the second hardest difficulty on the second easiest difficulty this thing will give you a run for your money or kick your butt you know it's pretty difficult I can't imagine what anybody would want to play on the two hardest difficulties cuz they just seem like the the difficulty would just run away with itself and completely cream you and also some of that is down to a bit of luck because there's a lot of times when you'll play a card off the top of the deck and the VP values on here range from somewhere like one to four with a lot of the cards and so you know you flip a card off the top of the deck and it gives it a specialist well was that specialist work one VP or 4 VP it's entirely luck based because the AI doesn't use resources so the AI solo mode works and I do enjoy myself playing it because I get to do what I enjoy from the normal game without too much of a speed or time issue but you have to accept that the game is slightly random in how well the AI does it's not so much based on what you do other than the fact
that it will keep going until you pass it just can be a case that the AI just sometimes gets a little bit luckier than you do wait my cheating unit malfunction interaction is pretty Bare Bones in this game now on the plus side the interaction is all positive so basically if anything happens it typically gives opponents something good so I'm going to copy your ritual that's okay you get a victory point for it I'm going to get a bunch of victory points off this yeah but everybody else gets a book okay I'm going to do this you get something else there's no kind of I punch you in the face type card in this so that's a good thing but still the interaction is barely there cuz other than that and just going up against an opponent for these battles there really isn't that much interaction in here which kind of makes the whole idea of playing this with more players a little bit mute you know playing this solo great playing this two player fine you know I played it two player the other night in fact and it worked quite well but I just can't really see much reason you would play this with three and especially not four four it drags on way too long the AP potential in this game is quite high with the different effects and the fact that you draw a bunch of new cards at the start of the round which means you don't get time to kind of prepare what it is you're going to do with those cards and playing this with four players is quite a drag yeah to the point where I don't think I want to bring this out with four unless I really really trust the people I'm playing with it's not a game that I think is designed for multiplayer one or two players is your sweet spot here three if you must four if you're
desperate but you're probably thinking but you got those batt surely they're interactive uh not really because the battles are a little bit on the me side all the battles are is simply you compare how many witches you've got on these spaces and then you secretly do the bid with Manor like in Scythe with the combat values and then depending on how much you bid in there you all get value you all get stuff you get resources you level up tracks or victory points but everybody gets a prize so you're not actually doing much against the opponent apart from the fact that the overall winner gets one of those power stones to double the VP on one of their rituals which are good but not essential I mean you can get points by other things in this game if you're not going battle Focus then fine who cares whether you get a power stone or not there's no good having a power Stone if you've got a bunch of one Victory Point rituals in your area because one to two would be do it's not worth it it's really only worth getting the power Stones if you've got something like a three or four Victory Point ritual you want to double that that's a lot better but that's all it is you know you basically get one extra thing compared to people if I want to bid eight power I can do so if you only want to bid four then go ahead if I only want to bid six great if you want to bid eight then go right ahead I can't actually stop you these don't really feel like battles per se but even then this whole like aspect of the end of the round it's quick it doesn't take very long but it just feels a little bit me for the most part it's just the fact that I'm spending manner to convert them into Goods so having this whole secret thing and to be honest I mean most of the time like 90% of the
time I can predict exactly what the opponents are going to bid on this thing so it's not like the secret bidding thing is overly necessary either it just I don't know this this feels like it needed a little bit more to it it it's streamlined and it's smooth but it also feels just a tiny bit unnecessary I don't think you really really needed it well I like War but I wouldn't say I love it even fall is overall a pretty solid engine builder game I mean we've seen these card games before but the fact that it utilizes an element out of alium which is a long since forgoten game by most and combines it with the likeness of something like the Imperial set univers to creat something a bit more a bit more unique shall we say in this field is a pretty impressive feat I like the way it looks the you know the theme is tacked on like crazy but the artwork is decent and certainly makes it pop on the table to an extent you know particularly with the uh Specialists I think they look really really good but the you know the variety in the strategies that you can do with just essentially one deck of cards and a few locations is pretty impressive the variety in the game having four asymmetrical abilities and an AI mode that does work I mean the AI mode is not amazing amazing I think the difficulty curve is a little bit High especially with the randomness that the AI can get points but I much rather have this than beat your own score and the fact that the designer actually put in the effort to make one is you know impressive in itself if anything's letting us down though it's the fact that you know one phase of the round is is pretty mute and
not that interesting which thankfully is not the real meat of this game but it's still just something that you can kind of like me whatever you know not saying you ignore it but it just doesn't feel that satisfying when it's there but also the player count scaling is a little bit of an issue I wish that this maybe had a little bit more interaction that was not just simply oh you get a point if I do this I wish there was actually reasons I wanted to care what the opponents do because for the most part you don't you race to maybe grab a location before someone else can but and maybe a worker spot and there's not that many worker spots and even then it's not likely you're going to lose like you know get knocked out so really the only thing you're doing with the opponents from a competitive side is trying to see if you can win one of those power stones on the battle phase that's kind of it really there just doesn't seem a reason to play this with three or four players which restricts this down to a solo and two-player only game and I don't get two-player games to the table often which means I'm practically only playing this solo and that hurts for me not to say that you know I don't want to play it solo I think playing it solo is pretty fun I mean it's is it as good as empires of the north for that purpose though empires of the north has got more variety with all the different factions and it's certainly maybe a little bit even more streamlined but you know Empire of North is still a really really great game it's probably not quite as high rating as it was you know back in the day but you know which one of the two do I prefer i' probably still say I prefer empires of the north slightly but
um I probably do prefer empires of the north but even for is still pretty solid I'm given it overall if Empire of North is going to be a nine at this stage for me I think even for deserves a pretty respectable eight out of 10 it's a great game not quite distinction level but I do enjoy a lot of stuff in this with the cards with what you're doing in the game and the amount of variety I just wish that maybe this phase was done a bit more interesting and do wish that maybe the AI wasn't quite so dependent on a little bit of a luck element for how well it does and of course the fact that I don't really want to bring this out with three or four players and especially don't want to bring this out with four players does limit my ability to get this game out if you are constantly going to play this two-player then this is going to be a Sure Fire hit for you but for someone like me who needs more of a multiplayer experience a lot of the time with the occasional solo mode thing this Still Remains a great game just not quite an excellent one but honestly still praise to it I enjoyed it and I think a lot of people are going to as well so that's it for me on this episode of the broken me if you like what you see then please thumb it up on YouTube and thumb it up on Board Game Geek when it goes live on that website let's get the thumbs in and get it into the hot reviews section then for getet to check out more reviews that I have done I've got Essen reviews coming out of my ears for this month you know I've already done several and there's more to come besides obviously let me know your comments do you like you know do you like even for do you hate it what would you compare it to in terms of engine builders do you remember Elisa did you enjoy it let me know your thoughts I'll be glad enough to read them so take care
and remember regardless of what your Witch is getting up to at night it's still only a game so bye for now
everyone