Let's chat about the new evergreen basic weaknesses! (ARKHAM TOWN HALL)
Transcript
Hello everybody and welcome to an Arkham Town Hall with me and Daniel where we are discussing the new chapter 2 basic weaknesses. Like all of our town halls, we don't have like a general specific thesis for this video. I just haven't really dived in deep into these uh basic weaknesses from the new set. I think what will be fun to do is we can kind of have them in pools. I'll make some like spaces for each of us to like put like scary uh like super scary, moderately scary, not scary, and we can kind of like go as put them in those boxes as we go. But this is the town hall. It's just open discussion, kind of checking out all of these weaknesses. I have them sorted by um four little areas. Enemies, asset, uh revelation, and then discard, and then revelation, and then double action to get rid of. So like sticky revelation and then uh this is a sticky thing here too.
That one's kind of sticky.
Yeah. Um so this Yeah. So sticky uh revelation asset and then we have the enemies here.
Can I start by telling which ones I've played with or seen?
Yeah, of course.
So obviously the re-reprints we can talk about at some point, but uh Okay. I've seen and played with the gold bug. I have seen and played with pursued. That's the first one there, I think. Um,
this one.
Yeah, that one. Also unaware for that matter.
Perfect.
Uh, Syndicate Obligations, Wounded, and Overconfidence. So, the only ones I haven't seen are the two enemies up there. Maybe I've seen the Is it the first guy, the lurker? The guy who has doom. Yeah,
I feel like I've seen him very briefly. He might have been in like a three scenario of uh you know, Brethren of Ash, but I don't think I've definitely not seen Miguel's weakness. Uh the one that comes up with Miguel and I've not seen um the other two that are sitting there. Lethal curiosity haven't seen and hemophilia. Hemophobia.
All right, so the ones of blood
I've seen this one. I've seen both of these guys. I've seen the gold bug. I saw this one once. I saw this one once. I've overconfident is the new weakness I get in every one of my decks,
which is very funny for me.
It has your name on it.
I've seen that one. I've seen this one. I don't think I've seen Hemophobia. Um, and I haven't seen Unaware yet. So, we actually have a pretty good spread. The only one that neither of us have seen is Hemophobia. Um,
how do you feel before we get into this? How do you feel about um these weaknesses generally? Do you think they're good basic weaknesses, especially compared to the original core?
Oh boy. I think they're kind of all over the place. Uh some of them are tougher than others, but that was true of the original bunch. I think uh but some of these are really really like game or deck defining, especially like Gold Bug. I think Amnesia, Paranoia were always that way. Um, and then a couple of the other ones are just kind of yikes, but that's okay. I think weaknesses should be hard.
Um, I can't speak about the enemy ones. I just haven't seen what they do. But I think they can be kind of mean, too. A student is mentioning that the lurker uh is annoying. You have to go rush after him and and his doom resets after every time the agenda goes, so that's annoying.
Yep. Um, overall I think like some of them I think some decks care about them more than others. Others they are I don't think you can ignore any of these. Uh maybe that's kind of my my experience like they're all impactful.
Mhm.
Could also be with the smaller card pool that you just you just can't uh ignore some of these kinds of things. Maybe even I would say that the maybe this is just me, but overzealous is kind of I don't want to say like the softest one, but it's because this card is the does whatever the scenario does just more. It doesn't really change your deck.
Yeah, it's like
Yeah, like soft isn't the word, but like uh dependable. Like it's like it's not it's not unexpected, right? Like it's you're going to know what it does in every scenario. It's not going to change what it does because it always will do the same thing that the scenario is already doing. And I totally get what you mean by that. Um I I think that the for me this basic weakness design is very interesting. Um because I actually think they tr they they they they explore new space but also still feeling vaguely familiar in ways that can be um totally fine and then also absolutely crushing. It's a very interesting thing. And I mean I think that uh and I'm not saying this in the fact that like oh um like someone's going to care more about like the like the the threecolor like solve like the like the hidden weaknesses from Carcosa, right? Like there's like everyone wants to move, right? Everyone wants to spend resources, right? Enemies are going to enter your location one way or another, fighter or not, right?
Um, like this one, like everyone's going to fail a skill test like eventually. This card is actually secretly kind of just like overzealous, right? Like this card is actually kind of like
sitting in the same more too, right?
Yeah,
it's it's rough.
Um, and like people are going to take damage. I mean, like this one's pretty basic because this is kind of just like the um the the direct damage ones, right? Like or like the hypochondria or like that kind of thing.
Um
and then like this one is a tough test. Like this like lethal curiosity is not lying. This card is it's a that's like a a mythos like a like a um Udmoth wrath of Udmar Doth style effect, right? Like this can be four damage.
Yeah. a four test is wild.
Yeah.
Uh because usually, you know, I don't know, like a scenario is not going to give you that much. And then as far as being a random weakness in some investigators, all right, if you have this in Dexter, you have the the juice to pass the test.
Yeah.
If you have it in someone else, maybe you're taking the damage. Maybe you don't have clues. It's a very punishing weakness, I think.
Yeah. Right now, a student is saying they have this in Joe right now. uh which is pretty spooky. However, with all that said, um I think that uh the meta for these weaknesses haven't hasn't settled yet where in terms of like uh the card pool, I mean, I think in current these are always going to be difficult, right? And I think that's good. Like weaknesses should have an impact when they're drawn. They shouldn't just be like whatever. Um, but uh when it comes to uh like chapter 2 once we start getting more options like they'll be able to be played around. Like even like the Nameless Lurker uh is a very spooky card if you are not playing around it. But it's one of those things again where you're like I haven't I have the Nameless Lurker in my deck. I haven't seen it yet. Let's try to stay in a central location so if he does spawn, he's going to be here or do what the do what chapter 2 is trying to tell you to do. Like chapter 2 is signposting for you as a player to split the [ __ ] up. Like be dependent on yourself. Like Lethal Curiosity is actually kind of doing the same thing. To me, this card is continuing to push the the design agenda of everyone needs to be able to fight. Everyone needs to be able to get clues, so do that. And I think that that's a very interesting thing to see pushed by these weakness cards. At least in my opinion.
Yeah, the clue thing I think is tough though because the amount of clues you have in maybe like pushing the scenario forward. Like it's makes you play a little bit scared and maybe that's fine. It kind of the way that paranoia says don't hold on to resources. You just have to change the way you're playing. Um, and is kind of similar in that respect. Um, yeah, but usually you're like, I have the four clues to advance. Let's go. And you might say I don't know. We could we could hold off a little bit, but you can't do that forever.
No. But yeah, this one you can also like Yeah, like is the fighter the theory is that you could just like you'll probably fail by like two or three and you could just like take the damage, have the soak. I think there's like ways to play around it. We just haven't like they're still surprising. Like if Lethal Curiosity is in my deck and I forget about it as my random basic weakness when it shows up I'm like are you kidding me? Like
you have like this is this is my life is ruined which I think is we're still not used to these cards yet is a big part of that as well.
Yeah I think you hold back some skill cards for this in particular.
Um I think this is I think this is considered a scenario card. Mark does levelheaded work on this. I don't know.
I think it does.
I think so. I mean, it's a encounter card, but I know they changed kind of the definition of what scenario an encounter. Let's not get into it. Someone else can look it up in the meantime, but um I think the easiest one.
Someone put a grimoire somewhere, right? Someone digitized the grimoire.
Yeah.
I can't find it. I can't look it up. Can someone in chat look that up and link it to us? Because I would love to look that up.
I think the easiest one so far, and this is maybe just because I've been playing with you, is overconfident. Just seems like you have a little more control over
that. And taking one damage is not as bad as unaware.
Oh, it's on Arkham Build. It is. Yeah, it's just a little button at the top. Open the grimoire. I don't want the fantasy flight one. No, I want this one. Then we can look up scenario card. This doesn't help.
I'm looking too.
Okay, cool. I'll let you look.
Yeah. Okay. Okay. Um, yeah,
it says asset event, skill, investigator cards are generally referred to as player cards, while act agenda, enemy location, scenario, reference, story. Treachery cards are generally referred to as scenario cards. Enemy and treachery cards are also referred to as encounter cards. Okay, so it sounds like treachery cards should still be scenario cards. This is still a treachery. So, okay,
even though it's a player card, it's not a player card after it's drawn. That's the whole deny existence thing. All right. So, yeah, it's still good. I think levelheaded is fine here.
Okay, perfect. Perfect. Um, and yeah, like there's that counterplay to kind of work with that. Um, which is again I think is we're going to adapt to and I mean if you are playing chapter 2 um or legacy, this pool is going to just keep going because there's always going to be new basic weaknesses that they discover. I agree with you on overconfident though and I imagine you've seen that in how I play with it. Um, it's funny because I'm doing two runs right now, one with you and one with beard. And um, uh, both of the times that the only times that overconfident was actually removed, it was removed by the other player. Um, because so like that's the thing. I love overconfident because it is it's like my play style in a nutshell, right?
Oh, this trace put the primary exception to the above rules are weakness cards. card subtypes consider to be player cards when they're bearer's deck and either encounter cards or player cards while they so yeah no that is no then it's all good we're all good there
y
um but yeah no I I think overconfidence is definitely the softest one here but it also can potentially lead to some chip damage if you do ignore it kind of reminds me of nihilism but just like a softer version of nihilism but easier to trigger but it's still a softer effect
right and and you know we played legacy for the silus and Carson run failing tests was just not happening. But if you're playing, I don't know, with the Miguel deck only and your survivor who like fails tests to, you know, then trigger Daniel Jameson, like this might be more of a problem.
Mhm. I just think that one damage you can plan for
unaware after you fail a skill test is just I mean it's only once per round and only during your turn but whatever the encounter deck throws at you might be worse than one damage.
You're praying it's a [ __ ] enemy.
Like you are
this is what I was saying. This is kind of like overzealous in the sense that like on average this is going to give you two encounter cards because the the the mythos deck tends to lean uh slightly towards um treacheries. It's usually at like a six six like a 2/3 one/ird for like for that kind of design.
It's less than that. It's it's it basically hits 30% or so. It's not
even a third. And of course, this also can change. Like imagine this in Miscatonic Museum or in a more recent example, Longest Night, where there are no enemies in the encounter deck and they just hit like a freaking truck when they do show up. Um, which uh I think again I think Oh, sir, there you go.
You know what's funny? I just This is total nonsequitter, but you mentioned Matonic Museum. Isn't it hilarious that they came out with oops in that mythos pack?
Yeah. Yeah. No, they were just signposting the design decision there with the name of the card. Just oops. Did we do that? But like I think that I'm of the opinion that even though sometimes these weaknesses can be in unfair positions. I don't think it necessarily makes the weakness bad. I actually thinks it makes to me the weakness more engaging where we can have these like stories show up that come from these weakness cards. Cuz if you think about it, right? Like say you look at all these weaknesses, right? How many do we have here? Two, three. Um, so seven, we have 13, right? So right now,
doubles of amnesia and paranoia.
Yeah. So like, yeah, right now we have like a one in 15 chance, one in 13 of the unique weaknesses of getting this card. And then you also have to be in a situation where you're playing Hemlock Veil and roll that one out of 13, right? So like it becomes like the odds of it happening are not small. Like it can happen but like the fact is is that I think that it doesn't change like the how unhealthy this card is. I think that it's like I don't know. That's just like my thought on this is that I I kind of like that it can be these situations that it has because again there's all these other weaknesses in the same situation. you could just get like I don't know like wounded, right? And you just like clear it out, right? Or someone clears it out, which is also again admittedly very bad in longest night, right? Like hard scenarios weaknesses are generally just are hard harder, right?
Yeah. I actually feel like all of these with maybe just the exception of OK based on how I've seen it, you just you can't let them sit around. Mhm.
There's unlike I think in chapter one where maybe it's also the deck power where it was pretty easy just to leave a couple and play and say me it'll work out.
Yeah,
I don't think that's the case. Like the movement one. I've been playing with that one recently. You if it shows up at the beginning of the scenario, you can't let that stay. Just it goes.
If it shows up in the middle of the scenario where you don't have the actions to get rid of it, it can be really bad.
Yep. And you have to figure out a way because you are starting to count how much damage you can actually take and how much you're actually going to move. But I think that's really good for the game to make you make tough decisions.
If it shows up at the very end, well, I mean, any weakness isn't so bad and probably you're okay, although maybe you've taken a bunch of damage at that point and then becomes uh kind of awful. But I like I like this one to some extent. it. I think it makes I wish it weren't as easy to make the choice of I need to get rid of it,
but I do like that they're all a bit painful.
Yeah. Yeah. No, for sure. I also do like that. Um, uh, there's also like I think there is counterplay like not so much in chapter 2, which I think is a is a good thing to discussion, but like I think I mean a lot of people are going to play be playing this game legacy, so they're going to keep getting stuff. They're going to like play digitally, so they're going to have access to everything, right? But like even if like you see these weaknesses like you can adjust, right? Like none of them to the level that you have to adjust for like doomed, right? But like even with like wounded, you're like you get that and you're like, "Okay, is there a way I can like mitigate damage as I upgrade or alternatively find movement tech that works around it in some way?" Like maybe I'm moving during other players turns, right?
I think that this provides interesting questions and not everyone's going to have access to it, but I think what that does is it further like defines the class. Like for example, I think that survivor and guardian have an easier time with wounded and that's actually a class strength, right? Likewise, survivor is going to have a worse time in unaware compared to the rogues who are going to have an easier time with unaware because I think that when a rogue is fully set up, they're less likely to fail their tests, right? But a survivor is going to get hit by this quite a bit more.
So wound's going to ding you anyways, even if it's not your turn, right?
Oh yeah, cuz it's each turn. It's each turn, not just your turn.
So, move during the mythos phase.
Yeah. Or the enemy phase, Luke Robinson.
Use that decoy trap to move around the map. There you go.
Yeah. Uh, wounded has to go quickly. Same for syndicate obligations.
Probably.
Probably. I think
you might get to a point where you're not spending resources anymore. Yeah, I think that like I would get rid of like for priority wounded is probably like a tier above, but they're pretty close to each other. Um, and then likewise, uh, this hits rogues more than it hits other classes, right? Like like this is probably like rogue and seeker because at like later in the scenario, a guardian isn't playing needing to spend resources as much. They already played their a million cost assets already, right? Like they're already set up. So, I think that there is some cool kind of like uh class strength weakness like and class weaknesses that can really pop here like how mystics are and seekers can deal with lethal curiosity pretty well, but like guardians, rogues, and survivors like they either have to tank or drop their clues that they spent a lot for, right?
for syndicate obligations. If you're playing I think if you get this as a random basic weakness just probably either you're getting rid of this or you can't play the talents because that's every time you spend a single resource or the ability, right?
Pink Floyd, yes, I found a button. I must have passed my investigate test. Thank you so much for the sub. Much appreciated. Um, a few other things uh from YouTube. I'm out of here was with a scenario that you could not resign from as well, which is very funny for the same sort of thing. And then dice gods going back to unaware. Uh the difference between that and overzealous the cards are split out. Overzealous gives you two cards all at once. Yeah, of course that's Yeah. No, definitely this gives you two at once, but it's kind of the same thing where this can end up giving you multiple encounter cards over multiple turns. Like I'm just imagining a scenario where I autofail a test against an enemy I wanted to kill and then suddenly I'm looking at a treachery that's like undealing me an additional horror due to and also that enemy has retaliate. Right. In that case I'd like rather have overzealous especially if it's a treachery that then next turn if I fail again I lose another um I have to draw another encounter card. So, it's like it's kind of that they're kind of like
cut from the same cloth, but they're coming from different shapes, which I think is very interesting.
And you still get that enemy. If you're discarding unaware, you still get the enemy.
Yep.
So, good luck with dealing with that problem, too. So, it it's tough, but you're right. You can get to a point where you're just not failing as much. I think with the chapter 2 card pool, just alone, this is tougher. I've just found myself failing more because you don't have the juice to uh consistently pass every single test.
But eventually it'll be okay.
Yeah, cuz like these are um this is the best time to talk about these weaknesses cuz these are the only weaknesses that are always here. They're always going to be in the current pool, right? Because these are the evergreen and the this the core set. Um,
oh, speaking of overzealous though, I just love, and it doesn't happen all times. We're not talking about this like a normal thing or evaluating the card this way, but whenever that top card already has surge, you're like,
"Yeah,
get it."
Yeah. You're like overzealous. You [ __ ] suck. No one likes you. You weak ass card. Yeah.
It actually happened to me and Pax the other day. We were playing uh Drown City and there's the one task that makes you draw the uh no the first card you draw during the mythos phase during the first mythos phase gains surge. Um and it's not just you it's every investigator and both of us drew a card that gained surge and we were like we got off scot-free.
Yeah.
Let's go. Yeah, that's great.
But there's nothing in Unaware that lets you get around that problem.
Yeah. Yeah. That would really cuz like uh correct me if I'm wrong, but if you draw a surge card into an enemy, that doesn't trigger the discard effect on unaware because it has to be the first card that you draw.
Mhm. That
that would be naughty. That would be like the game like pulling like a little sneaky trick on you.
Yeah,
that's really funny.
So, what do you think of the the reprints here? So, amnesia, paranoia over zealous. Do they feel like they did before?
Yeah. In my opinion, these are the three best weaknesses, basic weaknesses they've ever designed because they're the only ones that hit every class equally in theory, right? Like in theory, like seekers have higher like um highs, survivor have lower lows versus like also again rogues uh have high highs for the money and survivors again low for the money. But like in theory, every class wants cards. Every class wants resources. Um, every class doesn't want to draw encounter cards, right?
So, I think that like these are the best three reprints from like the original box that at least I could have thought I could think off the top of my head.
Yeah, I agree. I remember haunted being from the core and it was something that you just kind of
usually cruise through because
y
you weren't really using every stat.
Yeah. Here. Actually,
I'm glad that that didn't
I want to I'm going to pull up I want to see the I'm going to just have them I'll read them out here. Actually, I can just do this. I can do anything with the power of
OBS. So, let's kill Current.
Yeah. Go away current.
Let's look at the original core. Actually, let's look at revised core because that's actually the more accurate thing.
I don't think it had any more weaknesses, though.
I don't think so either. Keep scrolling. Okay, so those are all the signature ones. Okay,
so uh yeah, amnesia, paranoia, haunted, I agree, was kind of just benign. They kind of have one of these back for these two.
Um, which I think these are all right design. I think that um, don't get me started on the wording coming around it. Like I think the rules around it are a bit of it of a baggage, but I think like the design sentiment is okay. I think Stubborn Detective um was unfortunately a bit too swingy to be a basic weakness in my opinion. Uh, however, I do think that Mob Enforcer was actually really good. I think this guy was a very good basic weakness. because uh he's basically like a paranoia light for somebody at the table if you can't kill him, but if you can kill him, he was requiring two attacks, which I think is very healthy. And I think Silver Twilight Acolyte, uh I wouldn't have been upset if he came back as opposed to the Nameless Lurker. I I view them to be um obviously not the same level of threat, but I think they're very close to the same like identity for what they represent for the board state.
Yeah, I suspect it's gone just because they didn't want have to design around placing Doom on the current agenda to be
Yeah,
like a beneficial thing.
Yeah, I think so. I think you're 100 with that one. But I'm very glad that Paranoia and Amnesia were back. I think that these two are just like very stellar cards. I don't like that they zoomed in on Paranoia's art now now that I look at it. If I go back to the original
has a different frame, too, I think. Yes, it maybe does. Let's
slightly different.
Uh, the color has changed,
the lighting.
You can actually see the back now,
which is a very weird choice. That's okay.
Know he's like in front of a desk or something.
That's a That's a That's just a That's just an art thing to me. It makes it less about the amnesia and more about the scene, but that's okay. Um, so I've seen a lot of discourse about Nameless Lurker being bad for the game. What are your thoughts on that so far with Mr. Nameless Lurker? Well, like I said, I don't think I've really seen him. Um, I don't think it's bad. I I can see that they do have to kind of design like they can't have too many uh short agendas. like we're not going to see a an SX type thing. Uh because otherwise if you can't get to this guy, he's going to just keep collecting doom every time. But like you said, you know that this is in your deck. It's not like a treachery from the encounter deck that you don't have any plan for because you didn't play the scenario before. You're always playing with this guy in the back of your mind.
Um we don't really have a whole lot of good aloof tech yet.
It's not like the B cop situation that we used to have. Trying to think of all things that work. So, gorilla tactics is kind of the easiest one in chapter two,
but this guy gets way easier when you can just, you know, tap out B cop, too.
Yeah. And just kill him. Yeah. Just nuke him
because you still have to get to him, engage, and then fight and
or
Yeah, because Yeah. It's when the investigation phase ends, so it's not even like when the enemy phase ends, which I think might have been a nicer change to have it when the enemy phase ends,
right? Because then like you could just like last action engage take two to horror and that's your weakness. Right.
Well, right. Right. Cuz he wouldn't be ready. Yeah. Okay.
Yeah.
I mean, if you're Daniela, you still can kill him, right? Cuz he'll get doom and then you just fight and then he's gone.
You've taken two horror. But
yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. because I've only seen this guy um I think I had him in my Izzy deck on my first play of Brethren and um he never really impacted it too much, but that's because the maps are actually pretty small
in the core set. But like I can imagine this guy coming out in Edge of the Earth, right? Or Inmouth, right? Or as you said in Essex, which is Nightmare Scenario, right? That's a freaking uh Yeah, that's a freaking Wizard of the Order just hanging out at the back of a train.
And that's terrifying.
And and maybe that's the the biggest issue with this one is that it's potentially in locations you can never enter.
Yeah.
So maybe like connecting location would have been reasonable. Give him some other numbers maybe, but a connecting location. Give him a lof. And
yeah, connecting location empty if able. Yeah.
Yeah. Hunting dog. Yeah, that helps.
Yeah. It's just the
the scenario design. If you can't ever enter the location, you're staring at the guy uh up the forbidden peaks or something. And
he's just like looking at you with his two knives and you're like, I hate you. get down here, you son of a [ __ ] And he's like, nah uhuh. But then again, maybe they're gonna like also kind of take in tech that's like engage and animate a connecting location, right? like like stuff like that could be a way to circumvent these sort of things because I think what's kind of what could be healthy is if the designers pay attention to these cards in play testing and discourse and maybe they think, "Oh, what can we do to give them more options because this one's kind of sticky right now?" Right? And while it doesn't help in the ever, sorry, the the current environment because they're not evergreen, right? I think that's okay because then like again I do believe even though I I have to tell I have to take a little side step here. I do believe that every uh player will eventually play legacy.
And to the person who when I said that before they were like they can't play legacy everything's going out of print. [ __ ] when they rotate out of current that's legacy. People are just going to be building their own legacy format. Sorry, that just has always been a thorn in my side. I'm very bitter about that comment. But um
I can just add to that and say, are you saying that people who don't happen to own Dream Eaters aren't playing Legacy right now?
Yeah. Exactly. Right. Exactly. Um but like the thing is that I think if they give like a few solutions and explore that that color pie, I think that Nameless Lurker might become a little bit softer and they can kind of adapt to it, right? Maybe they um like with guardian with the lethal curiosity if they just really embrace damage healing because like say for example um like this card is in your deck as a guardian they gave you an event that is heals you like three damage and moves you right like that solves this weakness right so like there is there there are tools I think to deal with them it's just like
uh Arkham players generally don't like to adapt and the game sometimes will ask you to adapt and you'll be better for it if you do. And I think that's the case with some of these weaknesses.
Maybe we'll get a reprint of your favorite Nathaniel Cho card. Get over here.
Yeah. Or Relentless.
Not that one, please.
Yeah.
Well, that would help with for Guardians anyways with Nameless Slurer. How about the other one, though?
I I'd be down for a functional reprint of Get Over here that costs one. I'd be down for that. What's the other enemy? I honestly have not seen this guy or thought much about him.
No, not much.
Yeah, he's just a the classic 234.
Just counting.
Just counting.
Uh, honestly, this guy seems uh so like the tough part about Bloodrinker is that if you draw them when you have enemies, it's going to be a problem. But I think that's the case for a lot of um these kind of basic enemies, right? But this guy honestly is pretty pretty chill.
Yeah. Yeah, it seems great. Seems like I drew him from the encounter deck.
Yep.
I mean, this is another question I think we've talked about before. You have uh should weaknesses be tougher than a random encounter card or are they on par or they should be should they be easier?
That's a great question. Do you know what I would do to this guy? What I think this guy needs? I think this guy would benefit greatly from elusive.
How about some flavor text?
No.
Empty spot.
No, I like to I like to paint my own story.
Fair enough. Elusive would be interesting. Yeah.
So, Dice God says, "To answer your question, signature should be stronger. Random basic weakness should be we uh not stronger." So, do you say the That's a great question. Dice gods. Do you think it's like they should be weaker than regular enemies or on par with regular enemies? Cuz I think they should be on par with a regular enemy like just like a a enemy that you find in the encounter deck but not like weaker than them but not necessarily stronger for like the basics.
Yeah. They should be like a a mid enemy. Yeah.
Not something that not like your two twos. Like that would be a really silly uh encount or weakness, right? um because I want to meaningfully interact with it and not just say that my guardian with an extra bullet can can solve it,
right? It should be draining something from someone.
Um yeah, I think the signatures they're a little different because they should interact with what the investigator is doing rather than thinking about maybe just like what the standard difficulty of an encounter card is. Yeah, 100%.
They could be easier, but easier in the sense that they're what they should be doing is taking away something from the play style that they think your investigator is doing. Uh, so they can be tougher because of that, but they might not be as tough for other reasons because they kind of know what your investigator is doing.
Yeah, I like that. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Cuz like Yeah. Signature weaknesses should always be about countering the investigator, not the table, right? and random basic weaknesses in theory are just kind of like their design philosophy is counter the table, right?
And I think that that works a lot better for just like a generically strength enemy.
That's my take. I mean, I think I would I you can usually get through most of all of these uh cards, right? Easier than an encounter card.
Uh sorry, harder than a regular encounter card. That's why overzealous is what it is because it is two encounter cards. Yep. Yep. Yeah. And like the in theory this bloodrinker is two actions, right? Like that's where like the theory of this guy comes and like same with Nameless Lurker when you catch up to him. Big caveat is that he's also engage and like kill, right? Like that's like the the theory for these guys. Um gold bug is taking away your accessory slot. So in theory, if it made you sacrifice something, it's like that's two actions. It's like it's like two actions of punishment there. The thing about that amnesia and paranoia is that they can't really measure that as much. Like you could say discarding seven cards is losing seven actions, but maybe you just got those passively during the upkeep phase. Maybe you had a card that drew stuff like you drew like multiple cards for one. Um but like the general idea that the philosophy you see is that a basic weaknesses is two actions. And I think that's also why um is that's why I think that um signature weaknesses that are just two actions are like my least favorite signature weaknesses because they feel like basic weaknesses because that's what we're kind of like taught for these uh these cards here,
right? Yeah. I mean, yes. Like so Silus is, you know, the one that we're both playing through is truly annoying, right? You can't let siren call sit around,
but it's not
engaging to just spend two actions to get rid of it. It's probably someone else doing it, too.
Yeah, I would have loved if it was like after you spent resources for a skill,
like put a thing on this and when there's like three things on it, get rid of it. I think like that would at least like it would feel more engaging and less like a
thing to just like press press a button to solve, you know?
Yeah. make it torturous chords or something like that.
Yeah. Yeah, that'd be cool. That'd be cool. But like you can see the theory and like what Dice God is saying is that dice god is is an expert at the the pedantic part of this where I was not talking about in practice. It's like in theory, right? Like in in theory the design theory there was like oh this is going to go on the location they want to go to. It's very rarely on the location they never want to go back to, right? That was like like the theory that comes with it. So, it's like in the design theory is that this is like a location you want to get clues at and then you can just someone can pick it up and kill it, right? Like in theory, it's like you walk to it and just like draw to. Oh, no. I'm not Don't worry. It's I'm not here to to say it's bad to think that way, but it's just like it's it's like one of those um one of those things for like the the interesting thing and how the fact is like the reality of it is often not how the design wants it to go, right? Like so like to echo what Dice gods is saying, it is ultimately more move actions plus the engage and the kill, right? So, like that is the thing where I think that ultimately if I look at all of these cards, um, Nameless Lurker is probably the one that's breaking this rule the most, which is probably why, at least in the communications I've seen in the online discussions, is that this card is the one that people are generally the least happy with because I do think it is breaking the math for what um, basic weaknesses should be, right? Because in theory, I see the
theory. This is just a move and engage to a location you need to get to. Like an engage and a kill to location you need to get to anyway. But in practice, that's not often how it turns out.
Yeah. And how often so even paranoia and amnesia, right? We talked about those being there's some highends and lowends. I think for those two cards, since they're in your deck, you can kind of plan around I don't stockpile uh resources. don't stockpile carts, so these don't hit me as hard. Um, but how much beyond, as you're saying, split up or say in a central location, can you really mitigate the worst possible outcomes for nameless lurker?
Yeah. Yeah.
And the difference there is that the scenarios are all different, right? Your deck for amnesia and paranoia, those are always the same. I can have a plan there, but if you're at the one end of uh I don't know, the Great Lift, right, in in D City, I can't get back there. That's just not how that scenario works.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I think that you're right. This probably would have been just like cleaner if it was connecting location empty if able.
Yeah.
Yeah. or like honestly nearest location without investigators, right?
Mhm.
Yeah. Like
works too.
Yeah. I think that there's I think that this guy might have slipped through the crack slightly, right? I mean, this guy also probably would have been fine if he was just came in with a doom, right? And then the text doesn't have to change and then it's just like, oh, we got an ancient evils, right? Like, and that sucks to have an ancient evils in your deck, but like maybe you could go kill it. But with this guy, because he's a recurring ancient evils, like that can be pretty pretty bad. Yeah, too many things. It's also like the gold bug where I mean, I still don't know how I feel about it, right? Cuz this one it takes up your accessory slot. It gives you the minus one health insanity, and it shuffles back if you want to get rid of that. It's like there's three problems here
and maybe it could just be two.
Uh my thought on gold bug is just like tank it. Like I think if I get gold bug I just like I give up my accessory slot.
Yep.
I think that's just like the the you're just like, "All right, you got me game. I rolled this." And that's probably not like healthy, but I mean like there is the option that you can pay the 3xP tax for it, right? So, like it's not like completely dead, but I don't know. I I do like targeted uh slots when they're not the main slot because the accessory is literally like the slot you use for the [ __ ] up thing you want to do, right?
Yeah.
Like that's generally what the accessory slot is used for. Let's actually see. I'm actually curious. Let's look at the chapter 2 accessories. There's a good number. Strangely, there's none in guardian, I think.
That's crazy. Uh, slot is accessory
and none in seeker.
Well, that's crazy. I mean, if there were two classes. Hey, Anonymous just gifted a sub again. Thank you so much for that. Much appreciated. Um, that is kind of funny because if I had to point to the classes that I would consider to be the not accessory class, it would be like honestly survivor and guardian. So, not seeing a secret one here is kind of crazy.
Yeah. In the original core, you got police badge and disc of insomnia at least. Yeah.
So,
but like Yeah, definitely Rogue and Mystic. I view them as like they really like their accessory slot. So like they feel it a bit more. Um Oh man.
Wow. If you roll this in Marie, that's really bad.
Yep.
Yeah. Yeah. Cuz it's like if you have the blood stone for Moro, your signature for Moro this to move stuff around
and you don't really want to lose the health and sanity I think on her. You'd love to have a full eight. Yeah.
That's a tough one.
Yeah.
I wonder why they didn't just let you do the double action discard on it like the the ones in Hemlock Veil.
Yeah, it is interesting to kind of like see. I mean, like I don't know. I don't know. It is. It is interesting
because it's an insult, right? You you shuffle it back in, you draw it again in three turns, you're like, "Well, I I don't know." You know, I mean, you probably shouldn't. It's like,
yeah,
I want to say it's the wrong choice all the time, but it's probably not the right choice. And then I don't know, there's just something that kind of bugs me about that.
Kind of gold bugs you about that.
There it is. I I do wonder if it was like a uh if it was just uh let's say it's like put gold bug into put in your thread area, lose that second sentence. You get minus one health and minus one sanity and you can shuffle it into as an action. So you actually could play like something else into the slot to get rid of it. I think that would be fine. I think that would be fine.
What's uh Dendro say is also you can't lead play without doing the taking the damage.
Let's find out. Let's kill this uh slot and this set thing that we got down here. And then let's
clearly a two-handed uh weakness is worse. So I need to give you a way to get rid of it. But it's an easy discard, right?
Yeah. It cannot leave play while it has no damage on it.
Okay.
I So I think Yeah. I don't know. I think like Denderphosis is what I would consider to be a bad weakness from its design u for the slot stuff. Like I would love it if um Gold Bug had the the hemlock thing of
choose to
Yeah. You just take a horror. Yeah. To shuffle it back in. I think that's actually very healthy design um for a weakness. Uh it gives the player some control because as I always say, when players have a choice, they usually make the wrong one, right? Mhm.
Um, and I think that that would be it would I think it would make it more debilitating, especially if they make it take one health and one damage, like one horror and one damage.
Oh, that would be fun.
And then you can shuffle it back in. I think I think that would lead to a more kind of like engaging sort of things. But yeah, like you can't because of the recursion, you can't reliably keep an accessory in play. Um, unless you do the tax and then you just eat the health insanity, which I guess is okay, but you know, it's like in uh indebted where 3xP solves your weakness. This doesn't solve it, right? But at least it's accessible to everyone. Relic Hunter being neutral. Yeah.
And you just eat the uh health insanity. boxes.
Yeah.
Are we sorting things?
Yeah, we're going to sort things. It's a good way to kind of end this uh end the discussion here. Let's copy this because we are getting close to an hour.
Okay.
All right. So, what we're going to do is I'll get this text tool and we'll put like super scary. So scary. Want to die.
Yeah.
Not uh moderately scary. I can stand it. And then not scary. Give it to me every time. I think that's three good boxes to put these in. Oh, Daniel's smooing.
Uh,
yeah, you want to say we could treat this like a a graph. You could put it kind of like between them. Kind of like, you know, like
Let me think about Yeah, I'm just like doing a first sort.
Okay.
Um,
uh, I think this is moderately scary.
I think these are kind of like right here for me.
Those are kind of like fives. I'm always happy with an overconfident. I think this one's also kind of in there.
I need to figure out what to do with these. Okay.
Yeah, that's what this middle thing is here. Astute said it perfectly. I'll contemplate death but won't commit to it. Okay. I feel like it's tough because these are also kind of like I feel like I have a lot in this like 2.5 area.
Yep. First time each round. Investigator location takes a damage. Take one horror. That's probably fine.
I think this card is super scary. I think Lethal Curiosity is the one that I'm putting up here.
Yeah, I think so, too.
Okay.
These kind of depend.
I'm going to make some I'm going to make some uh some big plays here. I'm going to put these ones up here and for very reasons because I think they're all very similar. Um I think this guy is scary. I think gold bug after the talk about is kind of up here for me.
I think I'm going to round down and then round these two up. I think I'm going to go like this. Okay. It's It's somewhere in here. We can pretend that there's a some some idea. But
yeah, I can I I'll do that because I think this is we're unaware. I think these two are kind of here for me.
Yeah.
Okay. We can let ourselves have the 2.5.
Okay.
Okay.
Uh I think we ended up with pretty similar
pretty similar. Yeah. Uh big difference is I have the pursued up in the middle one. Um mostly because to me this this I I can I can smell this card from here. People are not going to get rid of this card and they're going to take three horror from it.
Like
um I've been playing a Tommy deck with this and I I find it to be okay. I think he's got a lot of soak. Maybe that's probably why I'm I'm okay with it.
Yeah. Yeah. It's like it's like it's this reminds me a lot of nihilism where or like that one card the um the one where you discard a card at random at the start of your turns.
Yeah. Obsessive.
Obsessive. Yeah. Where uh it does nothing. Like you read it and you're like, "Oh, this is fine. I can keep this around." And then suddenly you're like, "Holy, did I discard five cards to this?"
Like did I like take three horror from this? Like I don't think it's bad, but like I think that it could it's it's going to be people are going to take more horror than they think. So that's why I rounded like I have it kind of like here, but I'm rounding up. Um I think these three are pretty Yeah, pretty easy for the not scaries.
Oh, Orzel should not be at the bottom of this. This is somewhere else in here.
Oh, we're doing Oh, are we doing it like one of those like Oh, these are fun.
Yeah. Uh I will say that pursued this is kind of an interesting discussion we haven't had about these. Um my I think you agree with this too. So, if you play this game such that you're just like waiting around and drawing all of your fun stuff in the deck and then playing it all and then you you know you do finish the scenario um on time and you get all your XP and everything um you're going to run into your weaknesses more often because you're doing the deck draw and looping and the worse your weakness is, the worse it is. But something like pursued isn't as bad if you just say by the time this shows up either I'm getting rid of it or we should just speed up the scenario. Like why are we waiting around? The fewer enemies that we draw then this is just isn't a problem anymore.
Yeah. Yeah, for sure. I do love this card with uh swarming though. Oh god, that that
But I think I think that's so engaging how like a a campaign can change the the the scariness of a weakness, right? Where like even then it can trick people to be like I've played pursued but like five scenarios and I agree this one is on the lower side, right? Like I don't disagree with your rating at all. Right.
Yeah. But like they get used to us and then suddenly it's like they're playing dream eaters and a swarm of spiders appears and they're like I'm taking I'm taking a rotting remains. Like I think that's kind of fun.
Yeah, that that's bad. And elusive as mentioning is would be really scary with it. But that's like when you say I have to get rid of it and then you do.
Yeah. Yeah. I agree. I agree. Um, but I think you can kind of like unlike unaware, well, I mean actually unaware is sort of similar in that you can just stop failing skill tests, but uh
I think I'm going to go like this. I love this. This guys, just so everyone knows, there's going to be so many videos with like this.
I don't know what the what these kind of graphs are called, but I love this has just awoken something in me. uh enemies entering your location isn't really a thing you can prevent from happening. Uh in contrast to titaphobia or hypochondria,
um I mean that's true for the ones that you draw from the encounter deck, but there's still not that many of them. Uh it like the the bad end is bad, but if less than one out of three encounter draws is an enemy and maybe even look at what the encounter deck has by that point, right? If most of the enemies are gone, this isn't going to happen anymore. And that's something you can control a little bit.
And if not, the two actions to get rid of is good. I think the problem with unaware is that there's no you can't make this go away.
Yep. Yep. And I think that even like again like my higher rating is because I feel like people are going to let let it let it sit. And I think Daniel's right. The proper assessment is look at the scenario where you are in the scenario and then if you can't if you can't win the scenario in like three rounds, get rid of it. Right.
Right.
Yeah. Or ask Carson to do it because he has the actions lying around.
He sure does. He's like, "What do I do with these actions anymore?"
Yeah.
Get rid of overconfident.
Yeah. I don't know. Something like this. It's a It's kind of a scatter scatter plot per se.
I use Morris. Yeah. Sorry. I was like, these cards are I was looking at yours for my assessment, but no, we're pretty Yeah, like Yeah, look at then I think like we have both syndicate and like wounded
in the middle here. Um, which again like you can just kind of like let it be and then suddenly it's like I let this be for too long. Yeah. And then on our top end it's again very similar.
Yeah.
Cool. That was fun. I like that.
Yeah, I did too. I did too. H um I definitely do see overall here a trend of meaner basic weaknesses though. I think these basic weaknesses are meaner than they were in chapter 1 and especially for the starter decks, right? Like could you imagine like if we look at the rogue one in comparison, right? Do you guys even know what the rogue one is? I do cuz I got it every scenario and I [ __ ] loved it.
Reckless.
Yeah, reckless. Like just in comparison to the two, right? It's kind of crazy. This one is just like commit this to a car, a test, pass a test that you're already up a million on. What's the penalty? I lose two resources. Compared to this one, which in theory fits the rogue play style very well, which is just like I don't fail. I mean, they already have the strongest card ever that's pushing you towards that archetype.
Mhm.
Mr. Marcus Sangstack, right?
Yep. like they already don't want to fail. So, it's kind of like fitting with the same idea, but it's now like adding such a punctuation to the fail, which this one was just lose two resources, which is
this could have had a negative one icon, right?
Yeah. Oh, yeah. It could have 100%. I think Yeah, I think like -2 probably would have been like honestly probably still fine for anyone except the rogues. So, minus one is like a good balance for as a basic. All right. Bye, Marcus. Yeah. All right, chat. Any other last questions or anything you want to ask about these basic weaknesses before we close the town hall meeting? They probably did a design with the Texas icon subtraction and the test didn't fit. Good call. That's actually a good call there.
Could be.
Yeah, honestly, I think they should have just they could have just codified it in the rules. They have the power. Well, I mean, icons on weaknesses should just always be negative. They could just say that.
Isn't that always the case? Like the one from uh the dream parasite. I think those are all they all work that way.
Yeah.
Uh better or worse overall than the older cores. I personally think uh nonbias like because I love the original core set. I think that these are better overall including the starter decks.
I I think they're better. I I do think there were some pretty swingy ones there, too. But I think these are better probably for the game with a couple of
Yeah,
but we we'll see. Like I think they could have standed to like I love Amnesia. It's tough.
Um and maybe it's just because I'm used to it now and it just hits hard. I don't know exactly about like these four how they're going to impact uh deck building and gameplay as much. I don't know how even it is.
Mhm.
What these are going to do over as as far as design goes. Like I think this is a like just it's a rough rough weakness, but you learn to live with it because like I said, all it does is affect your deck and that's pretty even.
Yeah.
Um in terms of you have agency over that. And I think like Lethal Curiosity because it's so specific about what it does can be really rough. Now it has to do something different. Um, and Lameless Lurker maybe is too scenario dependent.
Yeah. Yeah. Uh, common for a basic three health enemy weakness, even if pretty weak, is by far more dangerous than the same stat enemy from the Mythos deck, just cuz it's an extra can and get out of hand that spawns at a bad time. Yeah. But that's also true if there's no enemies that spawn, right? Like it's the opposite. So, it's like very swingy. Um, and in even in the situation, a twoight enemy is pretty solvable by anybody at the table for that one extra damage to match the three. I think that they can show up at a wrong time and we mentioned that here. But honestly, I would take this guy over every weakness here except for probably overconfident or hemophobia depending on like that. Like
to me, I'd always roll over confident.
Mhm.
And then like I would want bloodrinker after that.
Maybe hemophobia if I was a survivor or guardian. I think with Blood Drinker also, there's just so much in the chapter 2 stuff that says an enemy. Yeah, okay, we can proc some stuff off of that. Like a Dianiela or all the traps or Trish's evade. Like it's not I mean there's a four of eight, but it's not you're not without tools with all the investigators.
Mhm. Miguel actually would love to have this guy in his deck.
Mhm.
Yeah, I think that's the kind of thing I Yeah, there's I think that generally like drawing enemies is not the worst thing in chapter 2, which is kind of funny. I think there are more tools. This [ __ ] triggers my trapping and I'm sorry, my glassing and I'm like, "Thank you, brother. Now you die."
All right.
Well, I suppose the nameless lurker also can uh trigger glassing, but that's probably not how that
If it happens, you'll feel like a baller, man. Leave it on a victory location you're the farthest from
and then just be like, "All right, we'll get this eventually. I'll draw the Nameless Lurker as we hang out over here." That would be such a [ __ ] baller play. Like, if I could grade an Arkham, like an Arkham playthrough, that would be like like 20 points, like 20 percentage points of your score
compared to someone else who didn't do it. Yeah.
Amazing style points. Yep. Yep. I'm with you there. Honestly, that seems like a great little uh a little challenge where there's like a I rate like you rate you have judges rate your Arkham game and you get like style points if you flex on the game in various ways in exciting ways, not just crushing it. Cyclopian Hammer gets no style points.
No.
No. Doing it with a [ __ ] trench knife. Now we're talking.
Yeah, there it is. Do I get some points for uh on the lamb being relevant in my recent playthrough?
Yeah, that would get points. that would get points.
Justin's like, "It was in your hand. You didn't commit it to a skill test already?"
All right, everybody. Uh, thanks for watching. I hope you enjoyed this town hall. Uh, if you want to see more town halls in the future for various topics, please let me know down in the comments. And if you have any questions for Danielle or I, we do read the comments and we do respond. So, definitely throw them towards us. What is the basic weakness uh from the chapter 2 pool that scares you the most? And why is it probably Gold Bug or Nameless Lurker? Cuz that's the answer I'll probably hear the most from you. Thanks for watching. Have a good one.