Skip to main content
Loading video...

TIME Stories vs. Adventure Games (Going Analog: Episode 3)

Transcript 21:01

remember sliding your cursor around the screen click click clicking away looking for clues finding objects to stuff in your inventory and talking to everyone in sight for hints on what to do next point-and-click adventure games were prolific on PCs in the 90s so they took a backseat to shooters and strategy games over the next decade but the genre has recently made a big comeback newer games such as broken age or modern-day remakes like Grim Fandango remastered prove that point-and-click adventure games are seville and demand time stories is a modular board game you can even call it a board game system in which up to four players go on time-traveling adventures together looking for clues finding objects to stuff in their inventory and talking to everyone in type for hints on what to do next the core set of time stories has the board markers and tokens you need to play any adventure within this franchise but it comes with only one scenario asylum that takes place in 1920 Paris you must work together to prevent paradoxes in this timeline as well as others that you can purchase separately to preserve the greater good yes you are time cops here strong Limbert on top

you'll begin each mission of time stories at the base we lay out these cards and find out your team's objective by reading the back of each card you'll fully know your team's goals as you travel to nineteen twenty pairs you'll then wipe these cards and replace them with the first theme that you'll actually get to interact with so on each player's turn you'll take your token and decide which of these cards you like to visit are you interested in talking to the new nurse over here looking closer at this portrait or maybe you want to find out what's going on with this pretty girl you'll take that card turn it over reveal an additional story finding items to keep positive or negative encounters or unfortunately you'll maybe find nothing at all as you progress you're going to go visit different rooms and different locations each with their own set of cards to explore progress through the story solve the main objective and get back to the future before time runs out oh and if time does run out don't worry everyone can just try the scenario again using knowledge from previous experiences to make a more efficient run now let's see what the going analog review resync all right we're reviewing time stories which as we said in intro it's sort of like a point-and-click adventure so that's why we have two special guests well Anna you've been here before you reviewed level sono maker protocol in our pilot so I was special guest Tim Schafer who might know a thing or two about point-and-click adventure games I guess look them up you know if you see

I never get myself yeah so uh and then my old friend Michael we haven't been on the show yet I'm not but we're old EGM friends and then we have actually GM guys on the show we played through base stereo that came with a game that's called asylum and then you guys played that as well then we got caught up in and we all play together the next scenario which is sold separately the Marcie case and then today we played a little bit of a proxy of dragons we didn't quite beat it but we are on a time limit so yeah who'd like to start thank you okay I am I was looking in the context of adventure games and compared to that the whole time it was the thing I like about it was that it emphasized when I think one of the what are things is great about aventure games that don't people don't talk about that much which is playing them with someone else like because I met people think of adventure games like you solo experiences but I just remember playing text adventures with my dad and like he'd switch off when did you get stuck and the other one would sit down and play and so there actually these great multiplayer experiences and I think this had that exploration of a story and locations but we're all talking the whole time and talking about what we should do next and I think that's a fun way to explore a story to your point about the multiplayer experience in a Marcie case there was a scenario where there was a big red button and some of us wanted to press it and some of us did not it's like for everybody wanted to push it thank God a certain responsible somebody

it was a time captain at the time you're doing the same thing you're doing when you play adventure game where you're trying to second-guess a little bit the designer like what are they done to it so far well they always kind of baited us for these things that seemed like you know like to kind of Robo dope you in and that I don't know every red button isn't push me yeah and have felt like that to me exact I'll say it was right oh yeah we don't just say two of us were right I feel it's wrong I liken this to like a choose your own adventure book right you're just making choices that's if you look at it as a game game I'm a it's not a strong game per se but it's just a really cool experience like the stories there that art is fantastic every scenario we've open up the fact that the art is just top-notch super professional really slick layouts and there's it's just all professionally done so it's like adding a game later you know what one thing I wanted to say to counter that a little bit because I went in thinking it was kind of like an adventure game and the thing about adventure games is you have infinite time to just go anywhere you want and explore and things like that and here in this game because you have a time limit it is not quite as like oh I'm just going to see what all the content in the game is talk to everyone whatever like that's kind of how you're thinking of being in that in that space this one reminded me a lot more of something like D&D where you're you have a gog star DM like who's not actually here right now that is the game that is like all does the way the game is set up and this is this is the thing that I really like about it is that it's very clever and

how it sets itself up is essentially a DM and it has all this awesome story and surprises and things like that the thing that I really love is the way that it sets the atmosphere and even like the rules it introduces each scenario like so like you mentioned there's a set game set that has like a bunch of these tokens that are not even used in some in some of the scenarios that you get and then in others it's kind of exciting every time you open the rules like oh these things have meaning now and they work like this the time limit thing even though it takes away some of the chill thing people like about adventure games like oh they move at my pace you still had they're still relaxing and that you get all the time you want to think about it but in your actions dad's this holy mechanic which makes you give you something to talk about or on the table like should we or shouldn't we it's not just like let's flip over all the cards that girls are definitely really at stake of all the choices you make me go here versus here you go together because you only have so much time so I think it does add a whole new mechanic it is more stressful but I think that was what makes the choices Wow and I think what's interesting too is that each each scenario feels really different the art itself is different in each one and so they all look different like the fonts are different and I really feel like every time I play a new scenario it's almost like a different game like for instance we're playing this dragon the prophecy of dragons and you can actually it's more emphasis on equipping items like my characters and assassin and she can't she can only wear a leather vest and she can have a range

weapon whereas I'm in some of the other scenarios there was no armor there was nothing really that was keeping you from like using a weapon so and we even have in this live shot we have currency and we actually yeah like I was shopping for a look at all the gold I have that I collected that I sadly did not to get I wish we could say wow how you nothing oh just what happened like I guess you run out of time before you can spend all your money so much go but uh yeah it's really cool because like in this particular scenario it it really does feel like an RPG whereas when we played the Marcie case it had like a different vibe to it just like the asylum also has a different vibe to it so I think it's like really amazing how they're able to make each scenario feel like a different game even though it is basically the same game with the same kind of component yeah it's a cool system and what's cool is inside the box and I set it down somewhere anyways this box has all these different spots you could save your game yeah very house video gaming things so if we're in a middle of a story and we're okay we don't want to lose our track track of what we're doing where are we gonna be at next time you can put everything away in certain spots so that you could continue exactly where you're at before which is very clever super smart when you guys would read choose your adventure books like you never would just read it once through one writer path and be done with it right like I used to like doggy er the book or put like a little paperclip so I'm like making every possible path and then you end up doing that in this game

because it's almost impossible I think to beat it on your first try you're going to run out of time so then you get totally yeah back to the present day they send you back with all the knowledge of what you first laid sarcastically they rate your performance Bob Bob yeah Bob is such a jerk all right so the we all agree this is a pretty cool experience right it reminds us of the adventure games choose your own adventure books RPGs but it's not maybe perfect what don't you like about the game we had I feel like we had a very uneven experiences like remember the very first time we played it we're I feel like really excited today we're having a lot of fun in the second session I felt like when we got really bogged down in combat but we were also playing it wrong so I want to blame the game for that but I just remember even after that we're playing it right there are certain areas I feel almost like with adventure games when the adventure game has had the sequences but there's a lot of combat a lot of action they can really climb down become really tedious and I never felt the game with those best weird a lot of like widows long-haul combat rooms we're just talking about I feel like this is just like kind of it's like the pacing is slowing down and it feels like just beating us up and I don't feel like I'm having a clever discussion about where to go next or all the things that I like about the game aren't happening so for me personally the combat was not the strongest part I loved so much about the adventure aspect of like the flipping the cards and finding out what the story is in the puzzle it's just there's like I almost

didn't like the game of it but that make sense like yeah the act of like moving the time and the combat and the fact that between you and me we like we would argue and argue but like discuss over like how these school things work like you roll it and you check like because the way the combat work is not like most dice rolling combat games where you just kind of like you take your attack and then you - your health it's not like that it's like this weird convoluted system and then when you when you get into like the different scenarios you get like these magic points and like all these other things and like some of some of the things have like hearts on them and some have other things you're like I just want it to be simpler like why does this have to be so confusing when the core game is so fun I don't want to fight I just want to explore it it's weird cuz it's not complicated like say a DM D or path we add it right we're like okay there's skill checks and there's armor class and there's bonuses and things like that it's sort of straightforward and not at the same time yeah I think it removes the I think you're right like the D&D systems like yet like you said you have to roll like against some of the skills and then you roll like for damage and things like that I feel like that gets into a territory where it can be really fun because if you're rolling dice all the time you're like ah Manas you know select a foul role or whatever it is whereas this is so it's convoluted in an unfunny and then when you actually do rolls to resolve your combat it's always disappointing for some reason or like I don't know it is that it's weird because

if it wants to be suitable for the reason you just brought up I was like not being too D&D but it's almost like in trying to be simple it's almost complicated in the way that they designed it I will say one other criticism is the fact that you lose that because you can't win and one run I don't think it's possible yeah and when you when you die or die when you retirement out you get rid of all the items that you've collected thus far and that is one of my least favorite yeah most of them like we get to keep one like you never suppose we have a special symbol like that is wondering like that is this way of the reason we're single knows yeah right but I really don't like backtracking like that that is really idea stew me and I and I think like that works against a lot of the charms of the games this reminds me of when I play a video game and I'm like really into the story like I'm just going to give an example of Bioshock right like when I play Bioshock I was so immersed in the story that I would literally walk around an area after all that I killed all the enemies and just look at everything because I just wanted to know like every bit of the story and if the game was getting too hard I'll just like move it down the easy because I don't want the combat and the mechanics to get in the way of me enjoying the experience the immersiveness and the story and I felt like when we were playing this I wanted to turn on easy mode like I just wanted to like you know what let's just put our time to 60 and then like let's not worry about like the time and let's just like

do a full run and not have to worry about losing all your items or like having to go through this whole hallway of like enemies again the ending of all of our sessions has been kind of messy because I feel like we did one game we just got killed another game we did had another experience third game we go we either solved it or we got so close that we're like you know we would just we would just solve this in like one move if we were to do it again so we kind of pledges again yeah I remember exactly but I feel like that at least happened once and I feel like that's a big tuning problem because if you if you have that experience we're like okay we've done it twice and lost but now we know exactly what to do Batman we get to the end and you just nail it you feel like everything was working but if it was right you get to the end then you have this long combat thing and one of your guys dies and you run out of time are you really gonna set it all up again and do it again because you know what's gonna happen yeah yeah I feel like it gets a little messy in the end but yeah I feel like what this game needs is some sort of like continued mechanic or save point or checkpoint yeah like in a video game to where like like you were just describing like do all these things we know we're supposed to go where no we're supposed to not talk to this person let's just start the scenario from that section and move on yeah and the other thing is we're time travelers that should be theoretically possible before they've thought of that in a put that mark on something there's a check points in a way right yeah that was like a check point you got to keep that card yeah kinda wish it was on everything yeah I like that yeah it's tough for me because I really like the game but I feel like it's like a video game company with the DLC where it's like well give you this really cool

experience that's really short but you can spend a lot of money and we'll give you some other even cooler scenarios at a much lower price but to me 30 bucks is quite pricey for one of these even though this is a lot of content it just it seems like a game or like like you just said earlier you have to like chip in with your friend because I just can't justify spending this much money on a game you guys didn't ship in pretty good valuable although although I am I got some money now as you learn from this game our most valuable resources time yeah and that is what we given you we're going to go to our conclusions now and then everyone's going to get grab a d20 boy and that's how many words you get to say as your final conclusion oh you so stressful if you get stressed at every you might roll one my roll wrong one we did roll on roll to 2009 we got eight 17 boy they're doing keep talking all right so write down on your past paper that many words and we'll have to pay for both as a favor oops

who had the most here have 1713 I have nine right what were your final I'm sorriest in 17 words we clever system great presentation exploration and now covering mysteries is fun combat tedious wish it were a nap oh good check gorgeous art cool system variety and expansions recommended if you're willing to spend and this is right out of where you draw an emoticon for that is having upwards what's nice does that spend time and I'm honest Montagna all right who's next I'm against dropping a token down in this crash okay I guess I'm to give eight some nine okay I Sayed a fun game that could use less game okay but extra words you know it burns like really because if you give one of those discrete so you can say with you and so what I mean no oh no what is this me I change homeward Jetta okay immerse is beautiful intriguing mysteries ruinous item loss in the combat alright so I'm going to count to three and on three edges we're gonna vote okay so where is it if two thumbs up once on a Papa to to Jesus you so I think we should be excluded because we're getting developers and we don't pass judgment on yeah are you gonna magical world well I know for the show

it's way too late if it's unanimous that we all love it it gets a platinum award from the going analog show it hasn't happened yet this means you love it this means you like it and thumbs down means you're just completely ambivalent you just like man to even you don't like it alright no on three give us your vote one two three mozzie oh don't change your vote based on this because I am I game developer is really nice and I don't want to give my real any gaming that's made as a miracle I literally like the system I just want like my personal feeling you're like yeah like what I do I want to finish this or go want to go play one of these games I feel like I spent a lot of time being very very frustrated with this game even though I like really wanted to love it there were times when I was just like come on games come on let us enjoy you for you we want to let you in my wrist yeah I do admire very much it's not that's why I wanted to say I there was there's stuff I liked about it but I was very fresh in a lot no we appreciate your honesty and that was good and it's I think it's all fair everything we've said you know what we're talking about here it's also all right cool cool thanks very much for your time and let's check out some letters from Shaun Beatty

we're back with another terrific edition of ask Shawn baby alright the first question here comes from Cassandra e she says how do you prevent friends from fighting over favorite colors then parenthetically she says the Kings can be more common as I get older not as much when I was younger uh okay when my daughter is upset about a problem like this what I like to do that I'd put over one shoulder and then I pat on the back until and milk squirts out her face and I think maybe that's something you could use with your stupid-ass friends who fuss about colors we've got one here from Dan H he says you get to be passive-aggressive for a bit thanks Dan H what would you like to tell our I mean your friends start or stop doing to make boardgame sessions more fun for everyone it's a great question I'd love for people to be smarter click whatever that's a magic fantasy world one thing they could fit I hate [ __ ] that run around taking candid pictures of everybody and putting them on Facebook like like you're playing a board game like you're never gonna look more bored or unhappy or here's the back of my head while I'm throwing some dice tell everyone on the [ __ ] Internet that's what I did today they're gonna think that's cool but you could be like hey everybody smile the camera you're like yeah we're playing Pirates of Underdark can like whatever you're having a nice time with your friends maybe you're a bunch of nerds but like its happy you're spreading some positive energy if they're looking at the side of my head while I'm reading a rule book that I want people to think I spent my

day like that it's the [ __ ] Facebook like a picture me surfing here's the picture me making that with him duck that's the thing I'm into and people look at it like that the guy with some [ __ ] interesting hobbies remember playing pirates the underdogs are like you know life

Progress saved