Skip to main content
Loading video...

Tainted Grail: Kings of Ruin - Board Game Preview

Transcript 27:26

thank you hi everybody I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple the board game review show where I deal with reviews top tens and always give my honest humble opinion even if a lot of people might not necessarily agree with it so today I am looking at tainted Grail the kings of Ruin prototypes this is a preview as opposed to a review although as with all my preview videos I will give my honest thoughts about how I think this game is shaping up at the moment but of course this is due to launch on Kickstarter next week I'll put the date in the description and of course you know things can change you know production changes components change rules change so you know what I'm saying now is as of applying the Prototype so it's no secret as a little background that I do love tainted Grail the original one is down on my shelf downstairs I have the entire all-in Pledge for the previous one so I got tainted Grail I've got the uh what was it called the last night uh future like set in the future winter Wasteland campaign I literally a few weeks ago just finished the age of Legends prequel campaign that was in the box and they have not done red death and I'm not even sure I will ever not because I don't like it but it's just the game is pretty hard I'm not sure I want to play the expert campaign and get my you know get my rear end handed to me but I really love the narrative storyline of this with tainted Grill I like a good dark gritty tail I don't want like happy-go-lucky Zelda style story

narrative telling for the most part there are some exceptions but with these if we're going to go into like magic and sort of medieval stuff and that I want it to be gritty dark you know give me give me like not necessarily make me uncomfortable but I want things to be like not pleasant you know it's not just like oh everything's happy hunky dory it's like nah you're surviving the world's kind of gone the pot and you're trying to do the best you can and not everybody is out to give you a helping hand you know that kind of setting I really enjoy so the general plot of kings of Ruin is essentially this is set a little bit ahead of the events of Tainted Grail but I don't think it's quite as far as you know the future the last night where everything was all winter Wasteland but the idea is is that you play two characters who have journeyed to do your various trades like someone went hunting you went to go sell candles and as you got to a place called four maidens the weirdness sort of built up it got Misty the king's past like track that you were trying to get through is now blocked off and you're just trying to get home you know you're not trying to solve the riddle of the Mystic Arts or something you're just trying to get back to your family or break through your tribe or whatever so the story commences with you setting off and encountering stuff that obviously changes your destiny the whole idea of the king's a ruined tied to is that they were basically free like Heroes that spun up over time that tried to go find King Arthur because he's already like long gone but what happened is that these three Heroes went out and

effectively became Kings or ruined as they were named where they were Twisted they were sort of mutated and basically it didn't go well for them shall we say so the idea being that these three kings of ruined exist where are they you don't know you're not going out to find them but Destiny has a way of making you making them find you whether you like it or not so King to ruin is a standalone campaign expansion for the game so what that means is that you don't need to own any of the original tainted Grail in order to play this you might think you know what I'm just going to jump straight into this version and ignore the original one do I think you should that's really down to you I mean this is going to make references to you know people and ideas and things from the sort of technical universe that you might not necessarily understand if you haven't played the first lot but still you do not have to if you don't want to spend so much money you know with the first slot then you can just jump into this and I think the story explains it perfectly well you know what's going on you know what the weirdness is as you might pronounce it you know that everything's going to go on the pot and it'll tell you who King Arthur and all these various people are so you do not need to have that background it's just a nice bonus if you do so what this is is a 10 chapter campaign the original was 15 so I'm glad they've shortened it a little bit just to make it a little bit less daunting in terms of getting it done but you play through each chapter and each chapter is pretty lengthy I mean these two chapters I got in this prototype box were long to say the least I thought I was going to be able to get this done reasonably quick and then get

this preview done no it took me a while to get through these playing two-handed it really the you get plenty of story and plenty of stuff to do in these scenarios so it's not like 10 minutes and you're done no no you're going to be playing each chapter for a good few hours before you get it done but in each chapter you progress through the story you'll encounter side NPCs story elements you know continue with your personal story and you know fight monsters engage in Diplomat again counters and you essentially progress through the story as told by an exploration Journal so all these locations that you can go to I don't and and sort of like slight spoiler alert I'm not going to spoil too much in terms of plot but you're gonna see mechanics you're going to see artwork deal with it I mean otherwise why would you be watching this but you essentially have these cards on the board they represent locations and these locations will be you know next door to each other but they are two-sided so they're flipped with the clear side which essentially is oh yeah everything's nice but then there's also a weirdness side which is basically like everything's all Misty cloudy and it's you know just I think the best way to describe the weirdness is evil fog that sends you insane has nasty gribblies in it you know it's kind of something you might almost expect from a cthulian type storyline but your characters will take you know be on the location cards you'll move them around by spending action points of which you have a certain allowance based on your character board and as you go to these locations you'll

explore them which involves going to a journal and reading from the various passages as directed and this will progress a story and give you side encounters and have you gain keywords which you tick off a save sheet that you know means that when you encounter someone else later on it'll say do you have you know you know false rumors part two or something if so read this verse and you just carry on in that simplistic manner now compared to the first one the story yeah it's great I mean the first thing to grow had a fantastic story and that was like one of my favorite things about it the gritty storyline but this was really good quality writing really good setting great world building this is no different I mean I went through the first scenario and I was already hooked into the story it's like and even more so I think than the original because one minor flaw of the original was that the characters you had felt very kind of similar in a sense like story wise but you know you didn't feel too differentiated with them and there were some kind of obscure ones here though I think they've kind of like improved it on some respect you get to play in this prototype there's going to be four characters I only had two Elgin the crack Candle Maker and gerdwin the cell sword or I basically call her a Huntress because she's got a giant crossbow but these two felt very different from each other not just in the way I wanted to operate them I mean gerdwin blatantly was kind of like a combat fighter-ish character and Elgin is blatantly slightly better at the whole diplomacy thing but normally I used to play this game solo I'm now getting more into that

mindset of playing two-handed for a couple of reasons we'll get on to that later but I played both and I felt that they were very distinct each character essentially has their own combat and diplomacy deck much like the original tainted Grail but with these cards in the original they kind of just felt very generic attacks with some exceptions depending on the character here though it felt much more specific to who you were playing like for example Gerwin runs around with a crossbow so some of her cards are just defend intimidate charge like you would expect but then there's ones like uh you know a silver bolt and hunting bolt and poison bolts and stuff like that it's like okay and you can even get look cards that are basically like improved crossbow in that so it felt more akin to what her deck was on elgin's side same thing you get to make candles so you've got ancient candle poison candle candle stick smash you know he wanders around with this great big like star for the candle coming out of it it's like really cool but the idea that you actually are playing cards that fit with what your character is just makes it more appealing for my thematic standpoint I mean mechanically it's the same thing but it's nice that it's not just simply attack block defend it's nice that it it relates to the character and makes you more immersed and attached to said character as before you get skill cards if you level them map and instead of having a card you've now got a tile with a cube slot in it that you basically slot next to the skill in question and it does the job for you so you know all well and good there but yeah I mean

these two characters felt really good there the benefits were very useful benefits but I didn't feel that their negatives were so debilitating either specific especially in the age of Legends campaign I mean some of the negative effects your characters had were just crippling it's nice that these are more of a annoyance rather than oh my God they hurt every five seconds you know when I'm with these people now models awaken Realms yeah we know what the Reagan Realms are like models and they still look gorgeous I mean I've got a few Sun Drop samples here now there were some casualties because they were basically encased in bubble wrap sellotape so they were damaged in transit which is why my gerdwin is basically just a plank of wood Because the actual character fell off but you know when they send you the fulfilled Kickstarter it will be packed packaged better I feel like I'm gonna break this damn thing we all know about this dude chloridine yeah this is a brilliant looking model I mean I don't care about the scale size or anything that people were moaning about this is a guy encased in play armor with a massive cloak on The Chariot being pulled by two barted horses I mean that is just phenomenal as a model and instead of men here is what you have before you now have way stones and uh this segues nicely into one of the next like really cool things I want to mention about this new set they are upgrading the first tainted Grill to what is essentially 2.0 so you can get an upgrade pack if you've already got the original or if you just buy tainted ground now it'll have those

implementations in the idea is is that it's introducing quality of life improvements to make the game a little bit easier a bit less grindy because as much as I love the original tinted Grail it wasn't perfect it was very grindy I had to house rule a lot of it in order to make it more bearable to make it more you know streamlined also just to make it a lot easier to play because I played it solo with just one character and when you played Solo in the original tainted Grail you were just asking to get whipped in everything it made it very hard difficulty wise now one other big contenders for that was the men hears you had to put them on locations in order to open up the map they were very like you know grindy you needed to get a ton of resources to activate them they ticked down there's a little timer before they ran out they were a bit of a pain so a lot of people house ruled them now you have way stones these are much better yes you still have to put them out in order to like go around the map but they now go on corners of the map so they open up more locations like that you are visiting but they don't cost as many resources to put up and if you don't have the resources you can instead do what's basically a blood price sacrifice which is where you contribute your health to getting them up now granted that hurts you don't want to do that far too often but it's great that if you think one magic shot from getting this one up and uh do I have to go grind some magic no you know what I got some spare health and then I get one of these up it can be

a lifesaver trust me on this because I ended up in that situation but far less grindy much better if they don't tick down so once they're on the board you either drain them yourself or like very rarely does a game effect drain the way Stone and I think that's where the Guardians come in these monsters that roam around the place no longer are they automatic encounters which used to do my head in it's a case that you just can't explore the location while the guardian is there and you have to manually challenge it much better because I hated the fact that they were basically Auto encounters and rock hard these Guardians are now killable in fact to be honest I dare say you actually have to kill them in this one if you want to progress further in the act because they just get in your way otherwise but it's just a nice better way of doing it so other like quality of life improvements I've noticed uh the food requirement you used to have to eat every day you had to find a food and it was it healed you and reduced your Terror rating but you had to keep finding food again grinding you get where I'm going with this here now if you want to heal you have to eat food but you don't have to eat food at the end of the day you can just simply say I'm not eating food you don't heal but no other debilitating effects it's like instead of eating a nice cooked meal or rations you're just foraging for berries in the bushes or something and uh small fries oh all right cottage cheese it makes thematic sense and it's again less grindy I can get a bunch of food and decide when and where I need it you know

am I at Max Health already you know what I don't really need to eat any food then it's like oh I took a bit of a hit from the hunting that deer a second ago you know what oh yeah I'll just eat a bit of food now it's ah these little improvements they sound minor but they go a long way so a lot of the rest of this expansion is kind of as it was before in the sense that you can upgrade your cards and your diplomacy and your combat deck oops sorry sorry Claude but you also have like secret cards that you get during the game so a story art might say right get a secret get it and it has some cool effect you can get items they're now separated into item decks A and B I don't know if that's going to happen in the main game that might have just been for the Prototype and of course you've got the quest cards that tell you what to do and encounter cards with all the various monsters and they're all rubber banded at the moment because let's face it the images should give you enough information but you know all of that stuff kind of Remains the Same and I do wish that maybe they tweaked a couple of aspects you know the main one is that the items a lot of the time don't feel that great I want an item that's really cool that really does a lot for me and a lot of these items you kind of feel well that's kind of meh I wanted them just to be a little bit more powerful and a little bit more useful but on top of that uh the other thing I wanted to mention is these um random events when you go through the chapter as you have the main quest cards and you sometimes have to put these random events on top of the deck because it's basically a timer but they're weather effects so good weather you get

to try travel easier but most of the time they're bad and it could be that you immediately find a blue encounter a green encounter you you know lose Health when you travel you traveling costs more there's more bad in here and then good and I just think they're just a bit too punishing you know I mean if you shuffle them up and deal like three or four at random and you just happen to deal out all bad events you've just made your chapters so much harder than if you got lucky and dealt out a bunch of good ones I get that it's thematic to have ever changing weather but I don't know this is one of those things where in the original game I actually house ruled these out I dealt the random events as a timer but I didn't actually follow the instructions on these it'd be nice if these changed a little bit before the next Kickstarter filled because like I say it's just one of those little Jabs that you get that's just one step too far because difficulty wise I mentioned that the original was hard you know you pretty much wanted to play it in story mode it will beat you to your knees and keep you there permanently if you let it here it's still hard but I do think they've worked on the difficulty rating a bit I didn't feel like this one was like kicking my teeth in every five seconds you have a lot of encounters yes but they felt beatable with your starting decks and with a couple of upgrades it wasn't quite so punishing now it's still not easy I mean if you've got two characters you know you could you basically pull your resources together which can be quite handy you have a lot more action points to spend in a turn but what you'll pretty much have is like one character who's good at

combat one character is good at diplomacy and so when you get into the respective encounters one character is going to be lagging behind a bit while the other does a lot of leg work but it's certainly easier than playing solo now with solo mode there is a secret card in the deck called self-reliant it wasn't in the original game but what it essentially does it gives you an extra action point around and it means you draw an extra card in combat or diplomacy and have one more hand size I'm not convinced that that's enough to make solo mode easy well not like solo mode doable I mean for example yeah you wouldn't counter slightly less punishing creatures for being on your own but eventually you are going to fight the bad stuff but with these characters if I've got two of them together I've got six seven action points between them like 14 action points if you go by yourself you've got about seven or eight that's a lot less stuff you get to do in a turn and at most you might get one extra random event on the top of the deck that's it it it's not balanced enough in my opinion to go into this true solo but to be honest it's not that difficult to Pilot two characters it just means that you're combat and diplomacy encounters are a little bit longer because you've got obviously two hand sizes to kind of micromanage and discuss between the well if there's two of you you're discussing it if it's just by yourself you're kind of working out what's the best way to use the cards together to to beat the adversary so I'm hoping that they tweak that a little bit but story mode has clearly gone through

some revisions I mean this is just a prototype rule book so it's all paper and that and the rules are easy enough I found the rulebook very easy to understand but previously story mode was pretty much like one adjustment here though you've got more starting items you get a standard a random standing item there is apparently a secret card that wasn't in the demo set that makes the encounters less difficult I want to know what that card is please because that could be like the quintessential reason why I play story mode um you then prepare the setup of the encounter deck so there was one less character you place one more random event on top of the deck that's pretty handy waystones actually cost less to put up that's really cool and you get to advance slightly easier and stuff so there's a lot more adjustments for story mode and honestly I just think play story mode story mode is still fun it's not like your cake walk over everything it's still all going to beat you down if you're not careful and it's not like you can just Waltz through any encounter you find it's still going to be you know reasonably hard but I think story mode is just a bit more enjoyable because at the end of the day my favorite aspect of the whole game is this and this is still top-notch quality writing material so why not let me enjoy this aspect a bit more but you can decide what you want to do if you want to play this in hardcore mode which is also in the book then seriously what kind of masochist are you but you know fair enough that's exactly what you want to do now one of the biggest issues I had with the original was the emphasis on combat you have

combat and diplomacy so you can go up against you know lots of different ideas but there was more combat than diplomacy by a long shot we're sending somebody into negotiate hey have you tried to make a diplomacy focused character in the original tainted Grail without any combat backup you are going to get absolutely roasted by the game it really does not give you enough reasons to go diplomatic as a character if you go full combat then fantastic you're gonna like be able to get through a chunk of the game yes you might do bad at a few little diplomacy encounters but they never really debilitated you that much even if you failed them so it's like what the hell really here I'm hoping that they balance the aspects a bit more and they're on the right track not quite there yet because there was definitely more diplomatic Encounters in here but more importantly for key parts of the story there were Alternatives so you could fight something but if you went a slightly different route or even on the same actual bit depending what you did you could choose to fight it or do the Diplomatic option perfect more of that please I want the choice make it fomatic make it reasonable as to why I would do either or but if I've got a diplomacy focused character and I think you know what I'm gonna be better off dealing with this guy by diplomacy I don't want to be screwed because I'm told I have to fight him and there's no other way more of that please but

there is still more combat in the game generally at least from these two scenarios I found I had to kill a bunch of stuff for food there was a bunch of Guardians obviously I had to kill occasionally I have to fight a diplomacy encounter but there was still more combat and I felt like given that you now have the choice of doing combat and diplomacy in some aspects if you focus on combat chances are you are still going to do better than if you focus on diplomacy but if you're playing two-handed you can have one combat person and one diplomacy person and kind of balance the two out but yeah I just want to see just that little bit of an extra push on the diplomacy factor it's not you still have fun with the card system going through combat or diplomacy it's fun either way but maybe just a little bit more emphasis or just a little bit more balance but of course this was from two scenarios it might have tweaked quite a bit now this next bit that's new is a little spoiler but as again if you're watching this video you're getting a little spoiler not necessarily in plot I'm not going to say where it ends up but uh you're probably thinking wearing fgf fight this big dude well at some point in this scenarios you come across a boss basically these the idea you come across one of them as the boss the kings of Ruin and the idea is is that it gives you the option to fight it or be diplomatic as I mentioned before which is really cool but they work slightly differently in that it's a huge model depending where you fight it will have implications but when you do decide to fight or be diplomatic with it certain events can happen during the encounter which means that the adversary has its own collection of like mini

collection of combat cards that go into your sequence that you're building during around and they'll have effects where it hits you back or you know messes you up in some way these feel very epic I mean they take quite a while to get through these encounters these are like you could spend half your session trying to get through one of these boss encounters what depends how long your session is I suppose that's relative but they're not short by any means and they're certainly not easy I mean if you're not prepared for these it's gonna hurt but I'll like the idea that it does make the boss feel a little bit different it's not just another adversary who's Rock Solid and you don't necessarily have to take down all its life you might be able to just get up to a point and then a story aspect you know changes things for you so I just thought that was a really good refreshing change and given that the whole idea is that you have three of these things running around the three kings of Ruin I'm interested to see what they're going to do with the other two I mean this was just the first encounter with this one okay and okay spoiler alert you don't kill it on your first outing that's kind of expected really but I get to fight this thing again but then I've also got the two other kings and they're very different in feel I mean this is like clearly some Warrior thing but there's a priest and I forget what the other one was like a magic user but you know three of those different boss encounters different stages you know stage one stage two and that they're gonna be pretty fun and I'm excited to see what they'll be even if they might kick my ass big monster so that's a pretty length free overview of all the stuff I

remember from the two scenarios I played but you know final thoughts are very positive I mean I already like tainted Grill I've already made that clear okay so it's not like I was going to jump into this and go I hate it but I hate it my precious but what I'm seeing here is an evolution of the original system it's taking tainted Grail ironing out some of those issues and giving me a new and improved version and I'll be interested to see what the 2.0 upgrade pack does for the original set because maybe it'll make me go back and play the other tated Grail campaigns again I mean there's plenty of story here there's different characters for me to play and different arcs to go down so it won't be the same as when I played it before by the time I get around and playing them while I've forgotten half the plot anyway because of memory but if it's got the quality of life improvements that this set has that's going to make the experience a lot better and I'll be curious to see what they do with that but you know with this if you're just talking this Standalone you don't necessarily need to get get it Sun Drop I mean yes these models look fantastic in Sun Drop I'm not going to deny it but it's an extra cost and even though awaken Realms do a pretty good job of pricing their kickstarters quite well actually to be honest I mean the upcoming prices I've seen on the preview page are pretty good value I must say it's still quite inexpensive like Prospect for a game in general and of course adding Sun Drop does add even more cost but you're gonna get four characters a bunch of cards all over the place I mean this is just a token amount in the Prototype there's going to be a lot more cards a lot more

tokens a lot more figures and Miniatures and stuff and it's just going to be a big grandiose narrative game but I'm really in I'm really excited to see how this goes because if they can iron out a few of those little wrinkles I mentioned already that still haven't quite been solved yet but then keep all the rest and evolve the rest of the system then I basically have another campaign that's going to be more fun to play than it was before and it's just going to be the same great system that I know I enjoyed so is it a complete revolutionary new game no it's more of the same but with improvements but that's not a bad thing because the original was already great this is hopefully gonna be greater so that's it for me if you like what you see please remember you can thumb up the video you can subscribe to the channel or the patreon to help me out with review copies as I'm a small Creator but also mainly just get your comments down below what do you think of the original tainted Grill does this one sound good do the quality of life improvements take your fancy are you gonna jump straight into this one and ignore the first one what's your experiences what's your outlook let me know I'd be interested to hear so until next time you can check out more content on the show including my top 100 which yes has halted a little bit because I've had a lot of content to do but don't worry I'll be getting back to it but you can also check out other previews for other Kickstarter projects I've been doing recently I'm Luke Hector you've been watching the broken people and remember regardless of whether you want to make candles or go hunt deer it's still only a game bye for now

Progress saved