Skip to main content
Loading video...

Why I Don't Like Tainted Grail | Unpopular Opinions

Transcript 26:56

how's it going everyone dylan here from all you can board and today i have a different kind of video that might be a little bit controversial but i'm hoping not too controversial because i'm trying to do this in a way that doesn't invoke a lot of you know argument or controversy or anything um because this is a brand new series something that we you know are going to be doing ongoing on the channel every so often whenever we encounter a game that we think fits the mold to talk about in this way um and it's going to be called something to do with unpopular opinions in in board gaming or something i don't even know what i'm going to call it but it's going to be if that's what it has to do with i'll figure out some title when i'm putting this on youtube uh you'll already know what it is by the time you're watching this um but basically what it is we're going to look at games that rank either very highly on the board game geek top you know board game list or rank unusually low in our in our opinion and we're going to talk about our alt our different opinion our unpopular opinion so basically we could take a game that is you know no i don't want to say universally left because it's not as though the board game geek list is the be-all end-all and and you know the final say but we're gonna take games that are either you know widely loved um and say why we don't personally like them or games that you know are widely panned or widely you know not not well known for instance and why we love them so much so we're going to try to do this ongoing on the channel um as we find games that we seem to have different opinions on and the first one that i wanted to do because i've had this opinion for a while and i've wanted to do a video to talk about it is of course as you can see here tainted grails so tainted grail is going to be the first one to talk about i've kind of given you the overview of what the series is going to be but before i dive into this the other thing i want to

mention is that in doing this obviously this is going to i'm 100 certain that there are people out there that absolutely love tainted grail and are gonna disagree with me my hope is that in doing these videos is that we can have some fun discussion in the comments about why you like a game that i don't or why i don't like a game you do or vice versa without it ever getting into like arguments or someone being mad because i have a different opinion the the world is full of different opinions when it comes to entertainment especially like video games and books and movies and tv shows it's never some there's never an instance where something comes out and it's just you know universally loved um even some of the most widely loved shows out there you know the seinfelds and the friends for instance um the movies the shawshank redemption things like that i know people who don't like them and that's okay i feel like no one should be criticized for their opinion um when it comes to things like this because everyone has different tastes everyone has different things they enjoy and don't enjoy and so what i'm kind of hoping this a long-winded way of saying that what i'm hoping with this series is that nothing ever spirals out of this series where it's going to be you know argumentative or combative or people are going to be angry about you know a game they love being talked about in a way of here's the flaws because many of the games i love have flaws and many of the games i love other people hate and that is totally fine i think that's like the most interesting thing about entertainment products in general is that we can have such different opinions we can talk about them so i'm hoping that that's what this allows for i don't want people to be arguing in the comments or like really vocally angry

that they that they're you know have a different opinion than me or other people that might agree with me or whatever the case may be let's just have some fun with this i respect the hell out of this game and i'm putting it on this list because i think it's an interesting one to talk about so all that disclaimer out of the way let's dive in i'm going to start talking about tainted grails and i think the very first place to start the best place to start is i'm going to tell you the things that i actually like about tainter grill because there's actually a ton of stuff i really like about change grail and i think it's important in the context of what i want to get at with this to understand that before i jump into the reasons that i'm putting this as my unpopular opinion as a game that i don't like that many people do so tons to like here like i said first of all the story and the lore i find to be super super engaging the the way that every character gets their own uh starting letter that you basically get to read that gives you a little bit of your backstory and sort of why you're setting out the way that you are um and the fact that this world is very it's like arthurian legend but it's really a dark version of it and there's a lot of like mystique and mystery and stuff going on like i don't want to get into the the nitty-gritty and the details because i figure i i feel like if you're going to jump into this game and try you the fresher you go in the better so i really don't want to spoil anything for anyone to really touch into anything so i'm only really giving you the bare bones overview here but it's just really really engaging and as you uncover parts of the world um and learn more of the lore and more of the story and what's going on with the characters and everything like that i found that that was unbelievably satisfying that's probably my favorite part of teenage girl and campaign games in general that's something that's usually important to me um there's a couple of key pillars i would say in campaign games as long as

like you know two of three or you know if you're lucky all three are really really solid then it makes for a really good campaign game one of those for sure is the story and i think tainter grail nails that i i really really enjoy it's not going to be for everyone it has a bit of a um you know it's dark in the sense of like a dark souls type vibe like dark souls is not the same type of story it's not arthurian legend if you're not familiar dark souls is a video game a very difficult one i'll make i'll be making some comparisons to in this um but it's it's got that same sort of like dark over like brooding sense to the story into the lore and to everything going on if you're not a fan of that if you don't like things to be that dark and that great like there's some imagery and some stuff that's talked about that is not going to be pleasant for everyone to read um i don't think it ever gets too you know too dark at least that we didn't for me but for some it may but as long as that's not something that you know you're is a big sticking point for you i personally think the story in the lord is fantastic in in tint grail um the exploration this kind of ties into that being able to traverse this land you get you get a map to start and you get to traverse the land kind of following the guideline that this map is laid out for you but the map is not 100 accurate because maps you know back in this type of day wouldn't be so it's more of a guideline and you're exploring different areas getting to flip them over and read you know the information of the area and all the options you have out of those options you can choose multiple paths like you really really feel like you're exploring and in a game like this and in campaign games in general that's one of the main things that draws me is i get i like to explore and unlock things and find out more and and feel like you're slowly building the building like you're placing the

building blocks of the world as you go and because of the way that tainted grail functions with these miner which are basically these statues that you have to light and when you light a statue every all the areas around it are now accessible to you so you really have to explore and with purpose to basically unlock more you can't just decide i'm going to just go over to this corner there's things you have to do to unlock that you have to make it part of your mission it's important to like really focus on where you want to go and things like that but it's just really satisfying the exploration is something i really really loved about tantra girl and was the thing i was most excited to come back to it for to say you know what other areas have we not explored we haven't gone to this corner of the map i loved it i think it was done really really well um the timed and interesting events against something i'm not going to touch on too much because i want to spoil anything but there are events that you'll come across that are you know there's some that are character specific if you have a certain character um there and you're playing them thematically or you know leveling them up according to like the way that they've been built in their backstory um you may have more success in certain areas based on having that character present there's timed events in the sense that like you might go to an area and uncover something and now you have a certain amount of days to carry out that new like side mission that that quest before that runs out now that is that one character's focus everyone else may be doing other things and this person has a very narrow focus i have to accomplish accomplish this in x amount of time and other people might come in to help and you know it might help everyone if that conclusion is reached um very very cool all those things are very very neat and i like that they've been it adds to the exploration when you start uncovering

things like that um i mentioned the character specific trigger triggers uh the rewards for playing your character thematically i know i touched on that briefly but i just want to stress like it's really really interesting to read the backstory of your character see which stats you start with and then sort of decide i'm going to embody this character and and the decisions that he or she would make and be rewarded for that and there's times where i made decisions saying well based on my character's stats and based on you know what i know about my character he would probably make this decision and i was rewarded for doing that as if i almost like found the solution to a puzzle in a way and that was really cool and again anything that makes you feel rewarded just makes you want to keep coming back to it so that was great as well um and tons of character progression options you know i would say the character progression is not perfect in this game by any means um in fact there's many ways in which it falls much short but there's tons of options and you don't have to build your character in the way that it's sort of like i don't want to say destined just to to go in the beginning but like you're nudged in a certain direction with a character based on the stats you start with and things like that you don't have to follow that you can and you can choose the ability card to start adding to your character as you go which stats you level and win which cards you add to your diplomacy deck and your clear combat deck there's a lot of options so if you like the idea of progressing your character seeing it build and kind of customize it so that your version of this character is slightly different than someone else's you'll still feel that and and it is it is really satisfying so like i said that's a lot of stuff there's a lot of stuff to like in this game that's the one i want to stress a lot is that this isn't a video of me saying hey i hate tainter grail i'm

going to tell you why i would say that more than anything i'm just disappointed by tainted grail so now let's let's jump into the reasons that i'm doing tantra girl is the first one in this series so disappointment is the biggest thing for me because for so many of these positives um i find that there are mechanics and systems in tainted grail that deliberately make it hard to enjoy the things that tainter grail does so well and that is what i find so frustrating is that it's like the game is deciding deciding at times it is going to try to be less fun and one of the main examples i'm going to use here and i know this has been talked about in comments of different forms uh all over um and it seems you know there's it's a it's a divisive topic because there's people on both sides is when it comes to the grindiness and the you know having to light menieres and all the resources you need to gather to do that so what else say about that without getting too much into the details of it is that basically like i said your lighting is veneers and the veneers are going to allow you to explore more terrain around them but the menieres do not stay lit so depending on how many players you're playing with there's a basic timer that starts and after x amount of days in game those veneers will basically go out and you'll remove it from the map and everything that's surrounding that maneuver that is not lip like touching another lit veneer is basically not accessible anymore those those areas of the map come off and you have to to get them back you're gonna have to re-light them in here to be able to explore those areas again so you really if you're not done checking out certain areas if you're not done

with exploring certain ones or you know accomplishing what you need you're constantly having to worry and think about the meniere's when they're running out and lighting them again and if it was just as simple as going there and using an action or you know using multiple actions to be able to do it that would be one thing but there's a lot of resources to gather and in the beginning stages of the game it's the earliest stages i would say you know in the first several chapters it can take a lot of resource gathering and like going out of your way to gather the right resources to light maneuver so you basically stop doing the story you stop exploring and you stop doing the things that are you know for me anyways are really drawing me into the world and the things that i was playing and wanting to do you stop doing all that to start grinding resources to basically allow you to do those things you want to do which i understand that the game obviously was supposed to be this you know very grim world it thematically fits the world that you're constantly struggling constantly grinding so like from a thematic standpoint it nails that but the problem is is that when you sacrifice enjoyment fun for thematics in a board game where you're often gathering multiple people together and if you're in your if you're adults if you're in your 30s sometimes it can be hard to gather people together you might have you know you might have you know you're doing a full group of four and you can meet once a month and if you meet once a month because you really want to just like learn more about the story and like i want to like you know explore this corner of the map we haven't been been at yet and all of a sudden you're spending you know half an hour or 45 minutes doing multiple of everyone's turns just gathering resources so you can keep this

maneuver lit it just seems like it's preventing you from doing the things that you sat down at the table to do in the first place and if that's not fun and there's there's this barrier to get to the fun stuff i have to wonder why it's even there you know would the game have lost anything um besides some the thematics with the the grimness of the world if the miners stay permanently lit and i know that there's there's other things in mechanics it's not as simple as just saying that but just imagine for a second that the miniers stay permanently lit when you light one the world just continues to expand and open up for you and you just constantly can explore at your heart's content or whatever there can still be you know the world can still be dangerous and grim and difficult based on the encounters based on the exploration the results of the exploration but why do we need to be grinding constantly in a way that prevents us from doing the most interesting things about the game that is what gets me the most potent to grail is that it just seems like it's intentionally making it difficult to experience the most fun parts of it and for sure you could house rule different things to make that the case there is uh it's either called like an easy mode or a story mode or something that's in the rule book saying hey you can make this slightly easier by the meniere's staying lit longer but it just seems weird that the normal version of the game is is that focused on we want you to be grinding and barely able to do the fun things that to me is is is bizarre and not something i enjoyed with tainted girl and pretty much the number one reason that i i had such a hard time coming back to tainted grail um and you know i i've heard people make

comparisons to you know things like um dark souls at the video game i mentioned earlier because dark souls is a game that is excruciatingly hard at times and i remember playing that game playing dark souls 2 and at times thinking this is so infuriatingly difficult why am i even playing um but the thing that dark souls has that tainter grill doesn't in that regard is that dark souls does have this moment where you accomplish what you're set out to do um and you feel the sense of reward and accomplishment usually you unlock a shortcut that now makes it so you can skip a bunch of uh areas that you were struggling through so you don't have to do that anymore so you've made your life easier you made exploring the world easier there is a tangible reward that makes you feel like you've taken a step forward that you and you never have to take a step back and you're playing by yourself in tainted grail you're playing with four people that have all dedicated their time to or you and three other people if you're playing with a full group you don't have to full group but usually that's why i like to experience campaign games because they like to bring in as many people as i can have make a night out of it um so that's how i enjoy them so if you're playing with four players that way you've all dedicated your time so you've set aside time for this you may only have like three hours to do that as soon as you start having to like struggle and hit the wall over and over and over again it just it it's a little bit different than when you're playing by yourself and more so than that there isn't that that tangible reward in the same way yes you are rewarded with different you know with now more areas of the map or more resources when you get through certain you know are gathering all this stuff in the grinding phase but

you don't they would be it would be the same as dark souls if when you lit a meniere and it stayed lit that would feel like the same or works you're like hey we fought and we fought and we fought to get this maneuver led to open up this corner of the map and we did and now it's open to us and now we can explore we can check out the story and everything but yet you always feel the anxiety of that veneer is going to go out so we can explore for this day but then we're going to start gathering resources for when it goes out so we can't explore anymore and you're just like i want to explore that's what i want to do and the game is telling me you can't and that to me is the breakdown if the game has something that is super fun and i say i want to do it and the game says well you can't right now because you got to do this other thing that's less fun and it does that multiple times that to me is the breakdown that's where i don't agree with that design choice and i think that you know it's just unfortunate because there is so much exciting stuff that i'm just wanting to experience more often and i can't okay and i mentioned uh combat and diplomacy events and the first thing i want to point out is that i actually think that the combat system in the diplomacy system is super unique into into grail you know it's very easy for campaign games to sort of see what's already been done by things like dungeons and dragons or gloomhaven and different campaign games out there and just find a variation on that whether it's using dice whether it's using cards i find i found that change grails was very very different i hadn't played anything quite like that um you know the way it does combat in another game you're laying out sort of this like tableau of cards that's on in a sequence and you're matching up symbols and abilities will come into play with adding cubes to cards depending how many cubes which is damage is added to the monster you're fighting um it'll trigger different abilities

that the monster now reacts with so you're having to say i could do three damage but that means that on their turn this is the ability that's going to trigger if i only do two damage it actually triggers this ability so there's this puzzle element that at times you you know you can find yourself just in thought trying to think things out but i did find it engaging i did find it interesting and i did find it fun the problem that i have with combat diplomacy is that sometimes the combat is this like really thinky puzzle and it is really time consuming and and it's fun for the person who's engaged in combat but sometimes only one person at the table is engaged in combat which means the other three people on that person's turn are watching the combat unfold and not to say it can't be interesting early on in the early chapters watching other people's combat was great and because we're going to benefit by that player getting more resources as well so it was fun as you get later into the game and everyone's you know again dedicating time wine to play and everything wanting to have their turn someone having a big session of combat and everyone else just happened to be stuck around watching um loses its luster a little bit as heyo put it and you can for sure have combat where you have multiple people engaged but there are going to be several instances where there's people at the table not engaged in combat you're gonna have them you know using it as a bathroom break or grabbing some food or whatever and it just it feels like almost this like disconnect in the game suddenly everything that was we're all coordinating and collaborating and talking and suddenly all of a sudden one person's doing the other three are checking their phones and waiting waiting for this person to finish their combat so that was the one problem and i don't even know that there's a way to solve that i just think based on how combat was done here that is just something that's gonna happen and obviously every campaign of

every board game someone else's turn is going on and and you're watching i just found that the this is a more extreme example because it lasts pretty long or can last pretty long um and that can you know slow things down bog down the session a little bit um and there are instances in in combat um where as you unlock new cards and basically as you start customizing your deck you can have certain cards that you know hey if i draw these two cards in this order if i just happen to draw these cards it's gonna really make combat go a lot better or i'm gonna you know it's harder for me to lose or i never lose if i draw this card and you can start just like really your the session can start to become about when i get into combat i just want to keep getting through my deck until i get the cards i need to win and so it becomes this thing where it's like you're powerful these cards are powerful enough that you just want to draw them to win the combat session and you're just basically whether it's through mulligans whether it's through you know using cards just for the sake of using them to be able to draw new cards or just playing cards that specifically allow you to get through your deck and thin it out to get the cards you need you're basically just playing for these specific cards and when you draw them it's like oh i drew it i win now and that's exciting the first time when you it's the first time you have a brand new card and less exciting uh every subsequent time so uh i still really like the combat i still really like the diplomacy events i just found that again those are kind of the minor issues that really bog it down so um those are those are really the main issues and i know that it's like hey those only sound like it's like you have these couple issues or these three issues whatever the case may be the

problem is is it all comes back to the fun that i'm having playing to integral a campaign game is different than sitting down to play a single session of a board game i could have someone over to play a session of lost ruins of our knack and someone could have a really bad game they just you know do bad deck build and they drop they just have a really bad playing session and you can still have fun with law students barnack and it's not going to take you you know you're not dedicating it's not like you this is our once a month meeting for it or whatever the case may be it might have been this is the game we played this time we're going to play a different game next time or maybe maybe we're playing a couple games that night generally for us whenever i i've hosted campaign sessions for gloomhaven for tainted grail any of the games in the future i'm going to play pandemic legacy um you know it's a dedicated thing we are getting together to play this game we have set aside at least three hours maybe it's on a weekend we have a longer period of time we had to work everyone's scheduled together to get everyone together we're looking to have fun like that that to me i want to have fun i want to collaborate i want to talk with people i want to uncover story i want to feel like i'm playing dungeons and dragons but i'm doing it with a tabletop board game experience and with the uniqueness that that brings to it and there's just too many barriers for me in tainted grail to get me to that level of satisfaction i would sit down for a session with gloomhaven and gloomhaven has its own issues with story and narrative but again those pillars i talked about combat and collaboration and you know working together in a dungeon diving game um gloomhaven has a very very strong pillar

in that entire setup and in that regard i just had so much fun playing gloomhaven we would get together and even when we lost a scenario two times we had to try the same scenario three times to finally beat it it just felt fulfilling it felt like we were having fun collaborating learning and it was just a really really good experience and i found found that there was moments like that like you know little brief moments in tantra grill where i was like this is exactly why we're getting together this was amazing oh that what you just pulled off was so good or what you just uncovered is amazing like there's those moments and but they're few and far between or they're not as often as i think they should be and really if there's any point in playing a campaign game where it just starts to drag for a long period of time and you're thinking well this is getting kind of boring like i think you have a that's a problem that's worth discussion discussing and i wonder how i from a thematic standpoint like i said i understand why there's this grindiness and why it's you know this really wanting to make you feel like you're just like constantly against the odds but if someone had to have realized hey that's going to make it very hard to enjoy certain parts of these mechanics or people are going to want to go experience our story and they're going to have to pause doing that to go grind this out and to me that just doesn't sound fun and you can make comparisons to like rpg games where you have to grind levels to beat a boss some people love that and that's why you know i'm not saying that this is a universal complaint like this is just an issue for me but again with what is sometimes demanded of a guy in his 30s

you know wanting to get friends together to play a campaign game the sessions just didn't quite hit the mark for me in what i would hope they would um and that's just a really important thing for me so that is why it's on this list and the reason i should have mentioned this at the beginning of the video but i think tainter grail is is somewhere it's in the top 100 on board game geek it's it's like in the 70s or 60s i'll put it up on the screen what it's currently at i haven't looked specifically at it i should have looked before i started this video um but it's it's pretty high up and it's astonishing to me that it's that high up because i understand tons of people like it but to think that when i think that this is in the top 100 board games of all time on that list that is just that boggles my mind because it's so nor even near i haven't played obviously there's way more games on bgg than how many i've played but if i had played like 500 games right um and was making a list like i can guarantee you tangent girl's not on the top 100. so the fact that out of all the thousands of games that are on there that universally that's where it's in place it's just surprising to me and i'm not saying it's wrong i it's again if maybe that there's that many people i might just be in the minority with it not hitting me in the right ways and the majority love the the way you have to fight to earn to light these maneuvers and then explore the map like i've really enjoyed that and i think that's great if you have and if please if that's the case if you're like everything you said you don't like is the reason i play tainted grail tell me in the comments because i completely respect that and those the kind of discussions i'd love to have because i love to hear what it is about those things that give you the opposite effect that it gives me so please let me know in the comments don't think i'm

attacking your opinion on the game i'm telling you what mine is and i am absolutely interested to hear why you have a different one or why you agree with me or why you like it or don't like it for completely different reasons let me know um the very last thing i touch on is there is the um two expansions here um i did play through the uh last night i think is the one i played last night solo to see how much different a solo experience was tainted with integral compared to four players whether it was better or worse i thought it was actually it was a little bit better i guess not having everyone else at the table and no one having to less stoppage no one watching each other's combat and you know just feeling like you're moving a little bit quicker at a quicker pace even when you're having to do the grinding there's less grindiness in last night in terms of the meniere's i won't again spoil everything but there's a little bit of a new system with it way less grindiness you have way more opportunity for exploration so it does correct some things um i wonder if that was because they realized that was an issue or whether that was the intent from the beginning but whatever the case may be it is i thought it was actually an improvement um maybe maybe not from a story perspective i did like the original lore and story of the of the first one but from a mechanics and gameplay perspective i actually thought the last night was an improvement i haven't played age of legends yet again because not being a huge fan of tainted grail um it's just not in my top priority list when i have so many games that i'm getting to but that being said that that's those are all my thoughts on it um let me know in the comments i would love to hear why you agree disagree like let's have a good discussion again like i said at the beginning i'll stress this is not about you know getting into arguments getting into big you know name calling matches

or anything i know people sometimes have very strong opinions on what they like and dislike but i think you can have strong opinions and thoughts and still respect everyone else's and that's what i'm hoping we can get out of this because i respect everyone who loves tainted grail um i just wanted to do this series because i think it opens up really cool possibilities for healthy discussion and debate and everything in the comments or just about different games in general not everything has to be liked by everyone or disliked by everyone and sometimes that just for me that's just the most interesting discussions they have some of the most fun conversations i've had with carlo um is even just the ones who are poking fun at the fact that you know like i think beast rhoden is a better game than agricola or something like that like those are the type of things that i think we can have fun even when we disagree so even though i don't like tainted grail and it's a game that i don't necessarily want to come back to if you do love it and you want you want them to make sequels and you want to keep playing with people let me know about it in the comments i'd love to hear about it we can talk about it and it'd be super super cool to hear about those stories so thank you so much for watching if you don't want to miss any of our content don't forget to subscribe to the channel you get notifications whenever we post a new video otherwise once again thanks for watching and we'll see you next time

you

Progress saved