Crits & Tricks Review: Critical Thinking Required
Transcript
Hey there everybody. I'm Mike Delisio.
I'm Z Garcia.
I'm Chris Ye.
And today we're going to be talking about Crits and Tricks. This is a trick-taking game from designer Pete Whissinger and publisher Inside Up Games. And uh this is one that maybe has a little more theme going for it than some other trick-taking games. This is definitely going for a D&D type of a feel.
Sure.
Oh, yes, of course.
Yeah. Yeah. And so the aesthetics do that and uh just other little kind of D&D type tropes. You'll see when we talk about it and in the video, but uh let's head down to the table, show you how it plays, come back here, and let you know what we think. To set up crits and tricks, every player is going to choose a color amongst the available colors. They're going to take their kind of standard set of D&D dice and they're going to get a player screen. I'm going to fold it down for you because it also is a bit of a player aid. You're also going to need to set up the deck. So, this is the deck of mercenary cards. And in a game, you're only going to be playing with four of the six mercenaries. The bard always has to be in that mech mix, excuse me. And then you could choose any of the three others to go along with it. Once you've removed all the classes that don't belong to your particular game from the deck, you'd put it back into the main deck and you'd shuffle it up. Uh you're going to be putting a certain number of the cards into the deck depending upon player count. Crits and tricks is played over three rounds and each round is going to have a particular structure.
It's kind of laid out over here. The first thing you would do in the first round is to determine who's got the initiative for the first round, which means who leads out the first trick. So, everyone to determine that would roll their d20. Then, what you're going to do is you're going to summon your strength, which means that you're going to roll all of your dice behind your screen like so. Now, I'm going to put the screen down just again for the purposes of what we're doing here, but you would then have all of your dice laid out and be able to arrange them. Usually, you're going to want to go from your smallest die to your largest die. And there's a reason behind that. There's a tiebreaker that has a lot to do with that. So, after everyone has summoned their strength, then we form the party, which is we're going to be dealing eight of these mercenaries to each player. Let's assume this is a four-player game. And you would deal out eight cards to each player. So, after the eight cards were dealt out, you would also deal out four quest cards to each player. The way this is going to work is that you would look at your hand of quest cards. You would choose one to put behind your screen and then you would pass the others uh to your neighbor going left some rounds, right some rounds until you eventually end up with four different quests that you'd have behind your player screen.
From those four quests, you're actually going to choose three of them that you want to keep. So, let's say, for example, I wanted to get rid of this loud card. That would just be discarded. And now I'd have these three quests that are that I'm going for for this particular round. And now the trick taking would begin. You have eight cards, but there's only going to be six tricks that are played out each round. I could choose any of the cards that I have to play into this trick. Uh so let's say that I chose that I wanted to play with the rogue as the lead suit in this game or in this trick, I should say. Now, all of the different classes are going to have different winning conditions. So, when you play the rogue, the winner of the trick is actually going to be the player that has the die with the lowest value. The barbarian is the opposite. It's going to be the die with the highest value will win. The wizard is whatever value is equal or closest to five. And the bard has to match whatever the lead suit is and will have that winning condition. So the bard is a wild suit and if you lead with the bard, you have to state which of the other suits in play it is. So if you led with a bard, in our case, you'd have to either say this is a rogue, a barbarian, or a wizard. And the winning condition of that particular class would apply to that uh that trick. So let's say that the rogue went out and we're again it's the lowest value. You also are possibly,
well, not possibly, definitely looking at your quests and seeing if there's any way that you can turn one of these in because you do not get any loot strictly for winning tricks. You only are going to get loot for matching your personal quests that you've got and potentially being able to complete the end of the round quest that everyone is vying for. So, I've got a couple of good options here. If I want to win with a low uh die or win with a low number, I've got a d6 here that has a one and a d12 that's a one. Essentially, the d12 is better because if there's any tie breaks, the first tie break is which is the larger die. And if there's another tie break, then who played later into the trick? So, I could easily um have a strong showing by just leading out with that d12 with a one on it and then everyone else could follow. Now, that's not going to really do anything for me right here because none of these really help me.
However, there are other things that you can do. So, um this enchantment says I'll get one and a half bucks if I win a trick where I used improvise. Well, what do they mean by improvise? All of the suits also have a crit ability. Okay, which means that this is not going to be played into the trick. you're going to be playing it outside of the trick essentially to trigger its ability. So in this case, I talked about improvise. That is the crit ability on the bard, which means roll your die up to two times. So if I'm able to do that and win a trick, that would get me some points. If I were going to do that, I probably wouldn't actually even play with that because it's already on a good uh it's already on a good value. So maybe instead what I do is I take this die and I uh apply improvise as a crit. Okay, that's why you have two extra cards. You can play up to two crit abilities per round. You can even play them on the same trick if you wanted to. So reroll your current die up to two times. One important thing to note is that anytime you are placing a die on a card, no matter what, for the first time, you can just roll it as a matter of course without using any abilities. That's just something you can do every trick. But let's say because I wanted to try to to win using improvise.
I use that. I roll this. That's once. That's not great. And that's twice. Also not great. But you have to kind of stick with it. I could if I wanted to do it again. use both my crits in the first round is or first trick. Is that smart? No. But I'm doing it. Five and three. All right. Well, there you go. Now, the other players would have to follow this suit if they can. So, if they have any rogues, they would have to play them, assign a value to them, and act accordingly. Let's say somehow I was able to win this trick. If I was able to win this trick, then I would collect all the cards from the trick and I would turn that in because I won a trick where I used improvise. I would go ahead and immediately take the one and a half loot and I'd put it in front of my player screen so that everyone knows how much loot you've got. Essentially, that's how the game is going to work. You're going to play through six tricks each round trying to get your personal quest completed. and at the end of the round trying to fulfill this. In this case, this one is win tricks equal to the value of one of your dice. So, let's say that I had played this and that was the die that I put in front of my screen because it's already been used. If I'm able to win three tricks, that would fulfill that. If I had this in front and I only won one trick, I would be able to fulfill it using this. You get the idea.
There are more of these that I'll show you in just a second. But really briefly, let's talk about the different crit values or the different crit abilities in the rogue. You can play that to skip yourself and go last in turn order. The barbarian, the rage ability allows you to uh adjust your die value plus one or minus one, two, or three. Actually, plus or minus one, two, or three to the minimum or maximum of what that die can do. The wizard transmute ability allows you to swap your die for one that you played previously. So maybe I uh played this, but I wanted to swap it with this one. I could do that if I played a wizard for its crit ability. The bard I showed you, is to roll it up to two times. The druid and the paladin, we haven't talked about those because they're not in this particular game we're showing. If you play with the druids, the second highest value would win and their credibility is the entangle where you force another player to reoll their current die. The Paladin is the highest value, but that match has to lead uh what the the the lead die size. It has to match what the lead die size was. So, if someone led with a three on their D8, you'd have to play a higher number on a d8 to be able to win in a paladin trick. And their crit value is that you would win ties this trick over the regular tie break that would be established. Okay. Um, so there's a bunch of different quests in here. You'll continue to do this three times and whoever has the most loot at
the end of three rounds will win crits and tricks. Let's head back up and let you know what we think. Okay. So, in the intro, I talked about the theme and um how do you how well do you think the game kind of actually evokes the theme beyond the aesthetics, beyond the fact that you're rolling like a standard uh D&D set of dice?
Yeah, I think the names on the little missions you're drafting certainly do some of that heavy lifting. I think it does a decent job honestly of of taking two things I don't normally associate trick taking and role playing DN I'm going to say D and D for the sake of
you know shorthand
uh and combining those things in not the most obvious way that I can think of cuz honestly the the trick taking in this game is sort of this weird means to an end sort of you know way trick take
as you were mentioning ear you know earlier we You played a hand and it was like you marveled again at like it's funny because the trick taking isn't even the point. You do it to achieve other things, you know, which you could have done with, I don't know, stacking wooden bits and be like, if I can put this large bit on top of the little one and it balances, I score this card. It's this weird thing, you know. Um, I think that's interesting. It's a clever idea. It's a It's a clever way to implement that.
Yeah.
Yeah. Some of those objective cards are a little bit more like extra thematic, which I think is is a nice touch, a nice little flourish of
uh you know, tying something some result with one of the dice like you know, with with the um the you know, one of them is called like dagger strike
or whatever. Yeah.
Yeah. and like you have to use your D4 on that particular one or like you know a big whiff where like roll the 20s cider into a trick and lose, you know, just those fun things that like
remind me of actual moments from role playing games,
but like you said, not done in the most obvious way
in that regard either. So, it's kind of a surprise both on the RPG D&D front and on the trick taking front.
Yeah. And I think it was smart. Uh, you know, the these quests, we're talking about the ways you score points. The ways the ways you score points is by grabbing loot, which is money, which is points. And the way you do that is not by winning tricks necessarily, right?
Sometimes it's by losing tricks. Sometimes it's by playing a particular die and, you know, losing or winning, you know, like losing with a d20 is harder than winning with a d4, right? And so things along those lines. Um, I think it was smart that they with these quests have a kind of a basic set that will work with no matter what uh classes you're playing with, but then they have ones that are specific to each class and make sure that those are in there so that if you're playing with the rogues, you have some quests that are specific to the rogues, things along those lines. And I think that's purely done for thematic reasons.
Yeah.
Um, which I appreciate. Um, and we've talked a bit about this um, kind of slightly different odd approach to tricktaking. Um, and it it certainly is. I have played other missionbased tricktaking games, right? There are some that are very very well known, primarily the cooperative game, The Crew, right? Um, this is kind of taking that general concept of tricks are a means to an end. you're trying to kind of do particular things and puts it in a different context. But one thing I think it does is it does make this stand out from a sea of trick takers. For sure.
Absolutely. Yeah. Yeah.
I think it definitely does that very well. Um to the point that to to to the extent that I think this might not appeal to people that just like trick- taking games.
I think it is too esoteric to be like, "Oh, you like trick- taking games? Tricks and crits or whatever it's called." It's also a terrible name. Um,
I don't mind the name.
I think it's so like it's I I get it. It's cute. I will flip these things. I think tricks and crits. I'll probably say tricks and crits more than crits and tricks, but that's not neither here nor there. Uh, it is weird. It is It is weird. It is. And and and with that weirdness, I think come some negatives for me. The idea that it is
a game that is very slow because you have to be pedantic in the way you handle things. It is a game that is going to not appeal to a lot of people that like trick- taking games or the people that really love Dn D might really not like this because of the pedantic nature of the trick taking.
Uh it's very lucky. It's wildly lucky. There's all these things, you know, that are,
I think, going to make the audience for this game
smaller than I suspected, you know, while just sort of familiarly the passing familiarity with like, oh, cute.
DND meets strict taking. All right. Then you get in there, you realize this is much weirder than I thought this approach would be. Which on the one hand, you're like, "Oh, I commend you for not taking the easy way out." You know what I mean? M on the other hand is like I I hope this finds an audience.
I I really have a lot of fun with it, but I think every player at the table is going to have a moment where they kind of lock up for a second and they go, "Okay, hold on. I can play my 12 because it's at an 11, so I have a good chance of winning. I I see what they have, but I also have these powers. I can use up to two of them per turn." Like everyone's going to have a few moments like that per round where they kind of have to like hold on guys sorry I got to look at my missions my my quests again and and okay I actually want to lose with my 12sided die so this might be a good opportunity to do that on the inverse of that when people kind of get into a flow it's so cool to see the weird things that happen and someone's just like ah I don't have very good odds but I'm going to roll into this one instead of using my pre-rolled numbers I'm just going to see what happens and when they nail it It's amazing. The elation is like high
and sometimes also the guilt of like that really should have been someone else's
but I just like I snuck right in there. So I don't know. It's it's it's chaotic. But I compare it to another dice based trick taking game called Mino Dice or Mythical Dice.
And that thing is just purely chaotic. And this one has the right amount of control that I like comparatively. Mixing the dice with the cards leads to a bunch of clever play moments. Yeah, I think you need to know kind of what you're getting into going into the game. And and so when you talk about tricktaking as a genre, there's kind of different axes that things tend to balance on. You've got control versus chaos. This is pretty heavily weighted towards chaos. There is enough control I think that you don't feel that it's completely random. But [clears throat] I don't think that this design is afraid of being a bit look the fact that you can literally reroll every die every You can basically have a random die roll every trick.
Sure.
It's built into the design.
Well, and the the cycle of like it's not about playing a hand.
Yes. It's about achieving these very short bursts of things like,
yeah,
this card says win two tricks in a row and I score that sucker. That's as far as I'm planning, man. That's it.
Yeah.
I'm I'm going to try to win one and then I got this other thing to seal the deal with the second punch. That's all I got.
Yeah.
When that once that plan is done, I'll figure out a new plan.
Yeah.
You got to be okay with that. the inverse of that, which is why I'm a little concerned, is that
it then doesn't play rollicking.
You know what I mean? You're kind of alluding to that, but it doesn't I haven't experienced that feeling of like
the the some trick taking games get into that sort of flow state of like chucking cards, blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah
and that gets you going with trick taking. I don't think you're going to have that. This this is not that game. Okay. Yeah. There will be the the moments of like, hold on, pivot. Do I roll? Do I not roll? Wait, which one? Oh, wait, wait, wait. Let me modify that with a special ability on a thing. There's too much of that for it to get into that sort of flow state. I think
that's one of the other access points I was going to mention. So, I'm glad you did. Yeah, there this certain certain trick taking games,
you can have a full-blown conversation around the table. You're playing cards. Boom, boom, boom. Oh, yeah. I'm going to play that. Boom, boom, boom. And that can be a fantastic experience. This is not that. It is very much not that. This is very much going to be because
with all of the randomness and the chaos, you still have this idea of
you're you're drafting your own goals, right?
You're having to think about, we haven't even talked about the fact that whatever suit or class of of card you lead with, there's going to be a different win condition for the trick.
Mhm.
So, you have that going on as well. sometimes highest value, sometimes lowest value, sometimes closest to five, sometimes this, sometimes. So, you've got that. You've got every card that can be played either as a card into a trick or used for its crit ability. That's the crit in in the crits and tricks. And so, yes, this is a game that that is not I I I don't think that it's going to necessarily be a game I would recommend to all people who like tricktakers at all.
Um, it has a lot going on. there's a fair bit of randomness for what you're doing. Um, but I keep coming back to the fact that I'm just kind of charmed by this design. I mean, I really am. I I just Nothing feels like this. And it's hard to say that in tricktaking games. Nothing quite feels like this. Um, I will think that it may get some comparisons to another recent trick-T game called Origin Story.
Same designer Pete Whistinger.
There you go. And that's why I brought that up. That's the other axis designed by Pete or not.
Yes. Because this has some of those sensibilities.
I agree.
Right. And so I do think fans of Origin Story should 100% check this out. At least play it. And I think the same goes if you played this and like this, you should check out Origin Story because you'll see I think some of the designers kind of trick-T sensibilities. This kind of going for big swings. uh Thinky. They're Thinky both games,
but they can pull off some very satisfying feeling things. This one, I think, is more chaotic in some ways than
than Origin Story.
Origin Story. Yeah, I agree. And that might be, you know, the push and pull with Jamie Stegmire. Who knows?
Yeah, maybe. Right. Yeah. Um I do like Origin Story as a game better than this game, but you can definitely see the the shared DNA, the shared thought, you know, um
logic there. I think it's there's a few trick- taking game designers out there that have made their name as trickt taking game designers and I think
he's definitely on his way.
Mhm.
You know what I mean? Because
with just two games, and he might have done more, I don't know. But with just these two already, I feel like if you showed me a trick taking game that was this outside the box,
I'd be like, "This feels like one of his games." You know? I think that's great.
A pretty distinct voice in Yeah. I think that's cool. That's very interesting. Um, yeah.
So, I guess the last thing I want to bring up before we go to final thoughts is the production. This is the retail edition of the game that this was also part of a Kickstarter project. You can get add-ons and metal coins and all that stuff and and all of that is great. Um, but just as the retail edition is coming with PVC cards, um, which you know, I think these are PC.
I think they're I think they're just regular card stock. Sorry, the maybe the upgraded are PVC, but these are nice quality cards. Okay,
you said the other one, the fancy edition, which you have seen and played with.
I think these are PVC, sir.
Uh, these are definitely not PVC. No, they're not.
Oh, they're really good quality. We're learning in real time. Maybe the other ones are plastic.
They they are know that for sure. Yeah.
And they you said that it is uh, you know, has a kind of like a nicer little display for your dice and what have you.
Yeah. Yeah. But I think the quality of this is is quite nice. I mean, the dice are standard.
There's something really fun about using, like you said, a standard set of DND dice,
right,
in in this, you know what I mean? And other games have attempted to do that, you know, not trick, but that the idea of using a a standard set to simulate D&D in some other kind of game. This is a take that game, but you roll these dice. This is a worker placement, but there's a dungeon crawler, but the dice represent your people, and when you fight, you roll the dieice, and when you sneak, you roll the dieice, and you're looking for a low number. We've seen that kind of thing. This is neat. It It implements that really, really well. I think it does that well. Um, obviously, I've mentioned a couple of issues I have with the game, and I do like the other game you guys mentioned from the designer more, but I think it's cool, too. I think I like it a little less than you guys. So, I'm going to go ahead and give you my final thoughts here. Um, this is one I can definitely I guess my recommend who is this for would be do you feel like you've seen everything there is to see in trick taking then try this try origin story try those really really weird ones you know um because they're not just taking trick taking and adding esoteric rules to trick taking then taking a core of trick taking and adding all this other stuff on the outside that isn't normally associated with that kind of game And I think that is a less destructive way of enhancing what trick taking can become than the inverse of that which is just sort of drilling in deeper and chewing away more and more of something until it becomes like I don't know just
it's it's this like it just eventually becomes like keyword soup to describe a trick taking game. This is different from that. I'm going to give it a seven out of 10. I like it, but it is definitely an acquired taste and it is definitely not one that's going to hit the table all the time when I'm just in the mood to play a trick taking game. This is not that game.
I'm uh I'll I'll go next. Uh I I like this one a lot. I think that Pete Whistinger, the the designer, I think his sensibilities really speak to me. Uh I know that he does development work on other Trick Takers, too, and those ones from like Game Head. Uh no loose ends. He's worked on Trick to the Future. I like when he touches a game. Uh, and so, yeah, this is this is one that does speak to me. I'm giving this one an eight. I think it's a lot of fun. I especially love that it really breaks convention uh of this style of game a lot to the point that I almost would recommend this to people who don't really love tricktaking because it is also so out there that yes, you have to follow suit and like those little types of things. But I think that even the goal of the game, completing those quests is so different from like bid and see how many tricks you think you'll win. Uh or uh you know, don't collect the heart suits or like they're they're so different that I think people who enjoy a little bit more of just kind of a rockus game
will enjoy that moment. They'll enjoy rolling that 20sided die. Um, I I think that they'll enjoy just kind of the zany parts of this and the trick taking is kind of this like delivery mechanism. It's the utensil. Uh, but if you do like trick taking and if you like weird ones, check this out because I think that the the um the the design is so smart. Higher sided dice break ties. Sometimes you want low. So a one on a 20sided die with the lead the correct lead suit is the best. And in many other cases, it's the worst.
We just, you know, we just play like I alluded to. And it's that feeling of like you play a card and then you play a card and then I'm like, "Yes, I win. Great. I take the trick." And then you both in you both cash in like, "Cool, you win that. Here's three points and one point." And I'm like, "Oh, oh, okay. You both just made out like bandits cuz I took that trick, right?"
It has that blood rage Loki strategy thing going on
a little bit. Yeah. One of the
Yeah. Yeah. You're winning. Oh, I sacrificed myself. 14 points.
Yeah. Like, oh yeah, I was supposed to lose on a tie. Ha.
Mhm.
How would you know that? But then when it fires off, you're like, well, I'm going to remember that. Next time you see someone lead off something too strong, you're like, that might be bait. I don't know. It's weird.
And you may have passed that quest on and just forgotten about it and been like, "Darn it, I did. I passed him that quest." You know what I mean? That kind of a thing.
Yeah. So, yeah, it's an eight for me. I think it's the ziness pays off very nicely, but the scoring is kind of wacky and Yeah. So, it's good. And I'm right there. I'm I'm I'm also at an eight. I I I think that this creates a very singular experience. And it's not always the experience I'm going to want when I want to play a trick taker, but I don't think there's another game that will give me this distinct experience, if that makes sense.
So, it's getting a lot of points for its uniqueness within the space that is increasingly becoming crowded. It doesn't feel like novelty for novelty's sake. This really does feel like its own design and it's kind of a mad professor type of a design. It's like wacky things going on and it all absolutely works. I feel like it's a very nice thematic connection in a genre where you don't find a whole lot of uh theme that really has impact. I think it does have impact here. Um, and I if it was a little bit less random, a little bit less kind of chaotic, I would feel more comfortable recommending it to more people. But that's why I'm coming at an eight. I think it's a really really good design, but I don't think it has enough enough of a kind of a a wide appeal. I I would struggle to know comfortable whether I would recommend this to you or not across the board. Um, unless I knew you very well as a gamer. So, uh, an eight, but a a very, very, I think, impressive design.
Agreed. And a ton of fun.
Yep. All right. Well, there you go. That was Crits and Tricks. As Chris says, touched by Pete Whistinger. Um, and uh, that's going to do it for us. Until next time, I'm Mike Delisio.
I'm Z Garcia.
I'm Chris Ye.
And I'm coming in with a sneak attack like a rogue.
Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh, check out our channel, Dice Tower. We have all kinds of things. We review games, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.