Ierusalem: Anno Domini | Review
Transcript
thank you hey Gamers this is beyond Solitaire and today I'm publishing a very special review of Jerusalem on odominee from devere games because I have guests I have got Jason Perez from shelf stories and what's up shop hey Jason yo my peoples what's up and I've got a difficult man to catch on video Dan Thoreau of space Biff how you doing Dan oh it's so early you've already recorded two podcasts Dan what do you got catch up over here I am not a morning person I went to bed at like three so what we're gonna wake up another moment and I'm
all right so here's a very quick overview of Jerusalem on domini this is a game designed by Carmen Jimenez and it is about getting as close as possible to Jesus at the Last Supper this is a game for one to four players there's special rules for one and two and I'm gonna keep this brief because um this description will be appearing on a podcast as well so I'm gonna try to keep this as cross media as possible but I have the game set up and there is a main player board with five action spaces so there is a space where you can send your followers out to various locations on the board there are locations where you can pick up materials such as fish bread and Stones there's also a market where you can get more cards in the middle of the board you have the last upper setup with a bunch of followers who are surrounding Jesus and trying to get up as close to him as possible and you also have the apostles who will be called to the Last Supper throughout the game and you will also score by getting close to them so if your own supply of followers and what you're going to be doing throughout the game is bringing stuff to dinner that will get you close to the table and then placing yourself close to the tables that you score off of your proximity to Jesus and to the apostles in the solo mode you're going to play against a little bot named Barabbas and Barabbas is going to cause the Sanhedrin track to advance bringing on the end of the game and also some events that are negative for you and great for your AI opponent in order to take advantage of any of these spots in the game you're going to have a deck of cards and you're going to play those cards one at a time so essentially every time you play a card it'll give you a location where you can go take an action and you will also have
some possible follower actions at the bottom of the card that you can carry out you're going to want to play cards in certain patterns in order to gain rewards and call the apostles to the last supper and you're also going to want to make sure that you're taking your actions in the most advantageous possible order because again having a lot of resources is great but the real point is to get your followers out of your player areas this is a warehouse I've of course messed everything up in shot but you have a warehouse that's full of your followers and they need to go to dinner and sit in the best place as possible you're going to need to get them there by moving them off of your board putting them in various locations and then moving them from the locations to dinner while also collecting the resources that they're going to need to pay up for the best possible seat in addition there are offerings that you can collect that take up room in your Warehouse that could be spent on resources but you might want points at the end instead and you're also going to have a chance to score by collecting Parables which will give you points on their own and are also part of set collection in the game so despite its religious theme this game is very much a Euro where you're managing resources managing storage space managing a spatial puzzle at the last supper table managing a card order puzzle in terms of calling the apostles and you're also doing a bit of set collection by listening to some Parables meanwhile Barabbas is going to interfere with you at least in the solo mode of the game so that is the quickest of quick overviews let's go ahead and go to our discussion because I have Jason Perez and Dan throw on here and I know that's
what you want to hear all right we are back with some final thoughts all right gentlemen how do we feel about Jerusalem on the domini I'm just gonna say I really wish that I liked this more than I did well let's let's pause there right because the reason why the three of us are together we've convened the panel right uh we're bringing a much different perspective than many many reviewers out there ever all of us in some way have a religious scholarly background yes uh so let's just kind of go down the road and say it I am a master of theological studies from the University of Notre Dame that was a previous life I thought I was gonna be a priest I did not gonna be a priest I'm still a Protestant Catholic um and I taught I did teach um this stuff for a couple of years uh my life has gone in a much different direction doing Psychotherapy now but I mean it's I'm it's still very important uh in my life to you know and I still get very excited when something like this comes along and takes it takes a stab at um a religious or like you know something in the religious historical Realms like I think this would lean towards a little bit of more of the historical realm uh with some Faith stuff so this is exciting to me and I bring a very of a perspective to it Dan you have a background right yeah so I grew up uh Mormon so that's that's the religious tradition that I come from which of course has its own perspective on this time period and Jesus and all of that um I pursued a doctorate in late Antiquity and early Christianity and um so I teach at the college level
um EFC Thomas Aquinas on your website for crying out loud yeah I love this stuff and you know when this game came out I was super excited and there are some things I really love about it to be honest and I want to get into that because I don't want to be a downer uh it does some really cool stuff including theologically and historically which you know I think is super neat that a game like this is able to come out on the market uh I I understand it was a little bit of a risk uh yes for them to publish and so I think it's cool that they they took that leap and I'm excited that it's out there but I do have some reservations uh you can already read my review so I won't necessarily go into everything that bugged me but I would love to discuss it with both of you because of your background so Liz tell us about your background yes so an atheist at 14 and I still am one however I took Latin as a way to like answer my confirmation class questions that were never answered and then I became obsessed and now I have a PhD in ancient Christianity from Yale because I never do anything by half ever um I'm now a high school Latin teacher from that background and I'm currently teaching summer New Testament so my little summer school babies and so we just read about the you know who's the greatest and Jesus let us sit at your right and left hands and you know we've just done it so um I I think that my assessments are going to be similar to y'alls but like of course with differences that are key to us
which is that I'm so glad that somebody took this theme on I'm so glad that this game is something that was considered marketable and that exists because I think that's great uh but I also just as a historian of this period as somebody who's interested in theology wish that some things had been different yeah I mean so I think the easiest part is to take on the mechanical stuff and uh Dan your review like your take on the mechanical stuff was like Euro Euro Euro Euro I'd wish actual uh Euro stuff so like um as Liz went over in her overview I think the the thing to understand about this game is that there's a core flow right you start uh with your followers and your cards in your hand you play one card a turn and that one card enables you to move your follower to it to uh somewhere usually the lands right so your follower is going to go from your board to the lane and then your father's gonna go with another action you get to take your follower from the land Gathering stuff Gathering offerings to the last time so it's this triangle movement that you are trying to coordinate and there's a bunch of followers that you have to coordinate and the one of the victory conditions like all your followers out there and um so I felt like just on a purely mechanical level um I my sensibility when it comes to euros isn't as kind of high like a guitar it might be a little bit much for me in my group so I appreciated that the core flow was easy to understand it easy to execute and had some interesting
decisions in there so just as a baseline Euro experience I kind of I liked what it was doing what'd you think Dan you know what I liked about it especially is the way that you plan these cards and you have to you're taking all these considerations I love it when every action that you take you're thinking not about what is it doing right now you're thinking about what is it doing now what is it doing in the medium term what is it doing in the long term and the cards do a great job of that because you're playing the cards and yeah you're you're moving out your piece in order to you know get fish or whatever it is that you need to do but you're also putting out these cards to gather the symbols on the cards in order to do what the game calls uh visit an apostle where you're you're getting the Apostle to come out and go hang out with Jesus at the Last Supper Hey Thomas the last supper's happening what are you doing over there let's go yeah let's let's get over to the last supper together and depending on the Apostle he's going to trigger some sort of bonus maybe Thomas is going to be like hey you can come to the last supper with me yeah um maybe you hang out with Judas and he's like hey I just had a windfall of money so have some of this money
and it uses some of that symbolism that's kind of uh you know that is quite lovely and and so I I liked the mechanics on the whole even if I found them a little bit dry you know I'm I'm willing to make an allowance especially because the Euro game is so dominant in the way that we think about board games the way that many board games are produced um so even though I didn't love the mechanics I I think they're very functional and I think they did a good job of uh getting everybody to the table and letting you play without too much overhead so that was a good part uh Liz how did the process of gameplay strike you
these days so you know it wasn't it didn't like thrill me but it wasn't bad like this is a very playable Euro if somebody said hey it's game night do you want to play this um I would be like yeah yeah absolutely let's play like I kind of like the puzzly aspect of placing the friendly followers like in different configurations around the table um I enjoyed again like you said like the kind of the emphasis on forward thinking that it's not just oh I want some fish it's oh I need to play this I need to go here I need to get these fish I need to use them to do this and I also need to keep track of my of my warehouse to make sure that I'm getting at people out of it to make room for the stuff that's going to go in it uh maybe I want this mahani card uh you know there's a lot to think about and so even though you're only playing one card ostensibly it's very simple you do get to do a lot and I I personally value that in games I love ease of taking your turn complexity of decisions like which turn to take if that makes sense yes does that very well yeah and so I think mechanically it is from yeah it's good to really good depending on how you personally you know have experience of euros and you know where you're at with that so then um and then and then also pointed this out in his uh with peace so mechanically you know solid doesn't blow the doors off functional whatever where the game starts to kind of buckle a little bit so I mentioned that flow right the you know you look at the personal space to the lands they got the resources and then
you get to the Last Supper and that last supper space that's the that's the the key right it's it draws all the attention that's what the Jesus figure is I forgot to take that Jesus figure uh and like that's where you're you're putting your pieces and so it's doing a lot of work mechanically and it's doing a lot of work thematically there yes and so and maybe this is uh this is this might be a thematic thing but it's also a mechanical Insight too in terms of like it's very ah lockstep like you go there you make your offering and if that's it generally you're there and it's like one Apostle let you kind of move things around it's like a one-form trade that felt very stately yeah very like you know uh the Jesus the the kind of Jesus that emerges in this game is about the kind of the royal Jesus which isn't the Jesus that I associate with this Theory like the Last Supper so I've just taught my students about the Messianic secret right like talking about disciples managing to make it through the entire Gospel of Mark and have no freaking clue who Jesus really is even after they figure out that he's the Messiah the Transfiguration and then the first person to really get it is a Roman Centurion who just watched him die like it's amazing uh as a storyline um so I will just I'm just gonna lay it out the reason this game drove me crazy is because the concept is so good because it's so real to the New Testament and it's so human I want to be closer to Jesus I want to be the best disciple Lord Lord which of us is the greatest Lord Lord can I sit at your right hand can I sit at your left hand I
will take on the cup that you're gonna drink from like these people don't know what they're promising and they so earnestly want to be something special in Jesus's eyes even before they fully who he is even before they really understand the consequences of that right there's something about that that's so touching I think in the New Testament especially like when the other disciples get mad after James and John like ask to beat the favorite because they also want to like there's something so human about it and I feel like this game misses the point because the point is that you're not actually supposed to ask that you're supposed to have the Insight that the first will be last and that the one who will be the greatest will be the servant of all and like the that entire spiritual point that Jesus kind of makes to his disciples who are silly in their depictions of not getting it right it's almost like the game enshrines the wrong part where you're supposed to just keep blundering towards a material Excellence when that's not the offering point it's about the quality of your offering like if he brings rocks you're in the corner and if you bring fish you're close to the middle and and it's like that that's not yeah but if you give all that you have you could be the Widow with the one coin I'm just saying yeah yeah you're right and like so and I I felt very Regal very stately because like that's what is that's what it would be like a Royal Court right or like a medieval Court Daniel you tell me more so like the better you're offering the closer you are to the you know the the site right the the the reason why you're there and you know from what I know
about the time period from what I know about you know the gatherings in the Middle East and everything like it wasn't like stately like it was a Knife Fight to get in there and it's like Whoever has the sharpest elbows and whoever can kind of uh you know muscle in there uh and and get the favor and all that kind of stuff and I almost wanted the middle to work out more like a a Catan Vibe or something where it's like I'm trading it's more Dynamic you know yeah I'm bringing my three fish you're sitting over there okay I'm gonna give you my three fish I'm gonna give you the seat and then we have to make kind of Trades that way uh and it's it it just felt so like there's this resource flow and I'm going along with the flow and then the resource flow kind of gets into that middle area and it's like oh whoa this is falling a little flat for me I don't want you what you think uh you know I I agree with you completely so I I'm sitting here with Jesus there and uh you sitting with Jesus look at him and uh and as you can see I'm very close to Jesus which means I have seven points yes and and on the screen Liz has you know she's next closest to me I don't know how your Zoom header uh panned out but that means Liz has six points and Jason you're way out in the building out there my rocks are just not gonna do it your rocks didn't do it so you got five points and the game does these this weird thing where first of all it's Pokey okay like like did anyone else's lands like always fill up and no one else could get in
there like like at bottlenecks really easily so the game becomes slow which I think is a bit of a turn off because here I am I'm like okay this game is accessible for newcomers and then I have newcomers come and we're playing like this two and a half hour game that's not heavy so it doesn't have that appeal to keep our attention but then also it's slow and in the midst of that happening suddenly we have this weird headspace where okay well I've put down Judas and sitting next to Judas is like minus five points someone else is sitting next to Jesus which is plus seven points somebody I play a thing that lets us switch places which is a net of 12 points and guess what I am now thinking about in the most Euro of terms like all of these traded sums of points which I I actually I don't know if this is The Game's fault I kind of think it isn't I I think the hero model might be at odds yes correctly yeah with you know it's inherently just so transactional and so mathematical and what I look for in a way you know these days if you ask me my my religious beliefs that's going to be a I'm gonna I'm gonna dump trauma on you right but the things that I love about this you know the reason that I went to school for it the reason I teach it is all because of this component of the the humans struggling to reach out and graze fingers with the Divine and this game is Just not that and I want it to be so badly I don't want to be sitting there and quibbling over sums you know the idea of
going out and Gathering fish to take to the feast is great but the idea that Jesus is Jesus has people at the door like now you don't get to sit next to Jesus until you bring the two fish and the two loaves I just find it so at odds and we've seen a few games that have done a wonderful job of of treating religious belief recently that I feel like this kind of ends up being anti-belief you know I play this and even though like I said I've got a lot of religious stuff I'm working through all the time I can still read the gospels and I love it yes as an atheist yes yeah it's and these stories even though I look at it and I see historical Jesus rather than you know the hypostatic Jesus I still look at it and I love what it's trying to do I love the different jesuses I love them all in their own way and this game instead of showing me you know the Messianic secret or Jesus the king or you know Jesus the weird alien from John you know all of those jesuses are so cool and then I play this Jesus and I get Euro Jesus and it's just it's
I wouldn't necessarily say it's like Euros I think it's like the more modern crunchy multiple Solitaire Euro you know uh I think there is a older breed of your own having worked with Puerto Rico uh I mean work with um some other like kind of the older designs it's much more interactive much more above the table and that's I think are what I want I wanted a more above the table experience uh and the the they give you that in the multiplayer the three and four player with like the favor tokens but I think I agree with you Dan I think I use those things two or three times a game that felt very kind of tacked on yeah and um so there wasn't a lot of reason to interact like I'm fighting myself and I'm not finding myself in that interesting religious way of like I'm fighting my sin no I'm fighting my warehouse capacity and nowhere in the gospels is their warehouse capacity ever yeah I also do want to point out that this like again like most of my issues of this game were thematically game if it had been another theme somehow I don't know how it will do it but I might have felt better about it but thematically like as you mentioned like so it's not just the resources in the warehouse it's stuff like Parables as a resource that made me like like a little Parable card it kind of made me crazy like oh you can go listen to a parable right here before last supper I thought Barabbas as the solo AI but like in cahoots with the Sanhedrin was very weird um there was just a lot that really that I struggled with and I think it might be an issue of being too close to the subject matter in a way like because I've spent so much time pouring over the
New Testament in so much detail those kinds of connections drawn made me nuts because I just don't really think that the Sanhedrin and Barabbas were going to be Pals yeah that like the Barabbas is politicking to be at the that's what the rulebook actually says like the the Barabbas isn't no he's in just like this guy that's like shows up like he wants to be you know he he thinks he knows the way uh the politics are gonna go you think because one person is always released that's kind of a tradition so it's like I want a politic 1000 to be that one I don't want you to be yeah which historically I just want to point out that's that is a unique uh into the gospels for what I can tell but possible story yes this is the annual thing foreign so I mean I guess like mechanically that ex the the player experience you know irrespective of the religious theme mechanically the the my biggest issue with the center and the center just felt like it felt very Euro it felt very like okay I'm I'm gathering the resources and like I like to have a feeling a little bit more of a feeling of a climax like because that's what an engine build it gives you an edge buildings that pop at the end of like okay boom and the pop here is I get to add five points instead of six or whatever like you know I'm doing now I've made my I progressed myself on the arithmetic and that it didn't it landed with a little bit of a thud at least in the middle yeah and then you add beyond that the Thematic stuff of I kind of wanted the middle to be more thematically resonant too so
that's that's kind of where I'm active wise one of the things that really stood out to me is how often in the process of play um people at the table so I you know I'm sitting there and my players are having very different reactions because I'm sitting going wow this is kind of super sessionist like yes please continue with that one yeah for the peoples okay so so uh super session ism is this idea that the old the Hebrew Bible and all of this this Jewish religion exists solely to point to Jesus in the Christian religion the idea that it's the Old Testament exists to create the New Testament um and and in Christianity this is something we struggle a lot with and it's it's a bit of a bug bear of mine because I teach this sort of stuff so when students come in we like to point out you know when Jesus is reading um the when he's quoting these sections from the Hebrew Bible he's if you're not being generous he's misquoting them in many cases and if you are being generous he's reinterpreting them um and this is pretty common almost every time Jesus brings up something from the Hebrew Bible you can look at it in an original context and be like oh he's kind of changing the meaning here um very common you might have as both of you certainly know Christians consider like the book of Isaiah to be the Fifth Gospel and the book of Isaiah is not talking about Jesus and its original context it just isn't and you really
have to stretch it to get it there um I'm not saying that to smash anyone's beliefs or anything like that I'm saying that because this game leans into that because rather than for instance the only time Jewish people really make themselves known is the Sanhedrin um like playing this game as far as I can tell you know historically you would be a Jewish Community right out in the desert yes and they don't have any identity um you're not an essene you know you're not a zealot you're not you know you're not some hasmonian restorationist you're not one of the five or six major sects that would be here yeah you're just sort of this featureless thing which couldn't which can give the impression that you're basically just a proto-christian um the Romans are absent so there's no to speak and use a modern term there's no secular investment in the crucifixion of Jesus there's no political reason to crucify him there's purely a religious self-motivated region and the people who hold that reason are Jewish yes um which unfortunately I think can lean into something a little bit frightening especially right now when we're seeing this Resurgence of Christian nationalism that personally I think every Christian should be invested in pushing back on yes I mean I'm literally teaching New Testament right now and I had to have an uncomfortable conversation with a student who just asked and I the things you can't judge them for asking it said why were the Pharisees so against God's will what like and you know of course I'm
like whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa several steps back like we had to have the conversation about you know actually Paul never stops identifying as a Pharisee Jesus's teachings were closest to Fair State teachings of any other Jewish sect at the time um and you know Jesus doesn't stop being Jewish like you know we really explicitly hit that multiple times in class but getting that presupposition out of our cultural understanding of what's happening in the New Testament is so hard that even after having this explicit discussions with students about it they still fall into the old tracks They cannot help it because the way their society is built you have to break it down and so yeah I do think that seeing the Sanhedrin especially this way you know it does you're right like imply that Jesus's only enemies are Jewish enemies well Jesus is Judaism like Jesus appears as very much like an icon like a Christian icon looking thing in this game instead of as a Jewish dude From Galilee who's like live in a Galilee life and it it's uncomfortable I've read the designer diary and I think there were a couple design Diaries and I think the person is coming at it from a devotional context like this is a devotion for for them yeah and that you know when you go when we kind of from my perspective like you're there's the Bible uh and I'm gonna you know kind of enter into the Bible and then whatever my personal positions are and that's kind of what's going to be expressed and
there's a whole bunch of Christians that feel that way and you know well we're we're all historical people and we all see the context and we all see that there were motivations behind why the gospels uh emphasize the role of the Jews and de-emphasize the role of the Romans they wanted to stay alive they didn't want to write into Roman propaganda so it's like okay let's uh soft pedal let's make pilate look like a really great guy or really you know but there was no historical evidence any such thing um to the point also no evidence that his wife was like an astrology girl who like had dreams that so there was all these motivations why the gospels are written the way they were written but if you are coming at it from that kind of like devotional uh you know this is a very heartfelt game for the designer like I mean they they really wanted to express something about their own spirituality uh with this game and there is a very valid um way of worshiping Jesus that's so directly like okay here's we're gonna connect over here and it's almost like she wants to be in the last supper right and like this is what I would have done I would have like scoured for you know offerings and tried to get as close to Jesus as possible so like that's a it's a valid way to approach it but the planting it into this context of let's just call it we haven't said the word yet anti-Semitism you know like supersessionism is anti-Semitism yeah and seeing that you know the followers of Jesus to proto-christians is anti-Semitic and I'm we are not accusing anybody of anything but like in terms of participating in tropes unknowingly this
is my kind of brush up against that a little bit too close for comfort especially for us who have this mindset of the historical background absolutely and I'm so grateful you said it that way Jason because I I I'm certainly not accusing the designer of of being anti-semitic um I but you know one of the things when I teach a class on the New Testament or on the letters of Paul is we are just so careful I mean one of the first things we look at is the way the Pharisees become the good guys of acts right they're they're the bad guys of the gospels in many cases but then you move into acts and suddenly they're the good guys uh they're the ones pushing the church forward this early Christian Movement and that and and the reason we do that is not to say Pharisees good or Pharisees bad we we do that to say history complicated and that the writer is complicated for perspective shift at shifting yeah yeah one that we're looking at different perspectives written by different people and that we're looking at a large organization you know all that sort of thing that we want to complicate we want to add some turbulence to those Waters um and what I was saying is that I'm sitting at this table and I'm going there's a disconnect because I as a historical guy who teach College I'm sitting there and going wow this is kind of super sessionist and everyone else at the table is saying things that I think are insightful in a different way that I can't reach because I'm I'm just I'm too close just like Liz said and what I mean is for instance when you upgrade that um that little tile by I think you've
given us favors and you take it off and you're like oh I finally get more storage space and you get one more space on your storage and every time we've done that everyone at the table has like burst out laughing because it is just so piddly to get like one more and so they're going well this is ridiculous I've listened to two Parables I've sat at the the feet of my lord for hear her and says dispense wisdom you get an extra ability to catching fish great yeah and the same goes with The Parables we were playing with a friend of ours named Caroline and she had this absolutely wonderful point where when we finally earned the first Parable in our game she was going oh well what do we do do we like do we tell the parable she was thinking the game would now suddenly break the fourth wall and become devotional um like like what are we doing or does the parable let you move closer to Jesus because you're understanding him better like do you slide to the front of a row but instead of being intermeshed in kind of these interesting ways or playing with what the game could be it just slips right back into Europe multi-solitare euroland we're so it's like well you get some points and it's just such a disappointment to have that happen uh and I really appreciate having played with people who didn't get it yeah a higher degree in Christianity because they were pointing these things out to me that are very insightful as we play that they were that approaching this as Christians approaching this as people who were yearning for a devotional game
because it presents itself that way right and not getting it or getting a version that is very locked into a certain kind of Devotion to Jesus which is very valid but that for a historical person's perspective because just has some difficulties I would say it that way yeah and I wanted the knife fight I won a knife fight and a glass supper personally so I actually feel like this is a good spot to kind of use towards you to this which is just a quick discussion of maybe what this game could have been and what we would have liked to see like I think that what you're saying about elbows is right I would like to see more human foibles um come to the fore and like the foolishness of trying to get closer to Jesus who you know by his own declarations values the least of these little ones and the prostitutes and the tax collectors and like the little kids like Jesus gave I mean you know even though I'm an atheist and I don't think about this in a devotional context right if you really are reading the gospels it's very clear that Jesus's generosity with himself and with his time is very much at the Forefront and he gives that self in that time to people who you wouldn't think deserved it or who had earned it in any way at all other than to think that he was something special and maybe not even that because some people hadn't I'm going to answer a question say more elbows uh I have to drop because I have something going on yeah please YouTube continue I can't wait to hear what you have to say so thank you thanks Jason thank you absolutely laughs
but um Dan do you have any thoughts on that uh you know I I just just to say that I agree I would I the best part of the game and I really do like this part of the game is that Central you know here's Jesus here's the here's the upper room let's go try to sit close to him I think as a scoring mechanism and as a as a shared incentive space to use a mechanical term I like that um I wish more of the game had fed into it I love Jason's idea about throwing elbows I like your idea too you know how cool would it be if you're playing this game and then Jesus doesn't show up because he's out helping somebody and in a way that's kind of a life lesson right you're like oh here we are we're gonna we're gonna bribe the door you know bouncer to get a really good spot and then Jesus comes in at the last minute and he said he pushes an apostle out of the corner and he sits at the corner of the table and he's like sorry I was you know I was healing a leper you know yeah yeah I I don't want I you know as a Critic I try to avoid talking about what the game that I didn't play yes but I just see so much potential in this game and there and there are glimmers of it um I I think that the the designer I see glimmers of her intentions that I really like um I like the energy of the game I even like the way that it's sort of human in that it emphasizes like you're out there picking stones and catching fish you
know you as the player are so preoccupied with the mundane that in a way you miss the Divine in front of you yes and I like that in a way I wish it had leaned into that because the irony of the game is that you pursue the mundane straight into the divine yes so what what are your thoughts Liz no I see the thing is that that is such a beautiful interpretive point if I felt the game was doing it deliberately yeah yeah yeah in that the mundane shouldn't you know being distracted by the Stones and the fish should and the coins shouldn't lead you to Jesus right that's the distraction that's Mammon right and instead it leads you straight to Jesus so sorry go ahead no I mean that's that's kind of exactly where it goes it's it's almost like we're still not getting the Messianic secret like it's a very markian game in the sense that in the sense that we are in the roles of disciples who are just slouching blindly you know towards the table and we don't really know what we're doing or why we're doing it we just know that we really want to do it that we really want to get close and we're like raiding each other on our closeness and in the end missed the point like maybe you know in a in a funny way right like it's it's the game puts us on Rails to mimic all of the people of the New Testament who also miss the point and like there is a professional in that like and and I do think I do think she's
doing that a little bit deliberately in that um like it's so hard to read it into intent but I I do think that she is positioning the mundane as us being distracted I really do I just think that the way it connects to the end of the game is Just like I think it would have been cool if like at the end of the game it was like you know flip a card psych oh whoever had the lowest score won you know or yeah something that's a surprise Jesus is all about surprises like that's actually something I very much deliberately teach my students pair like my least favorite thing about youth group as a kid was when people tried to tell me the Bible was basic instructions before leaving Earth like none of this is basic the entire point of the the Kingdom on earth right is that things that you don't expect happen the son who goes and spends his inheritance gets a big welcome back and the older brother has to look on angrily even though he did everything right the people who start halfway through the day get the same wages as the people who started in the morning like I wanted to see a little bit more of that topsy-turvy world emerge at the end of the game do you know what I mean absolutely I do uh I I you know one of the reasons that speaking as somebody who was raised with a very particular version of Jesus so Jesus who came to America right and uh but one of the reasons I love the gospels is because Jesus is just so Dynamic uh he's such a surprise you know even in this game so this is kind of Jesus as King right Jesus's ruler here he has he's got his Nimbus he's huge he's like the size of
eight people we have we have this Royal Jesus and and he kind of is the king I expect right he's the the whole idea with Matthew is you know Jesus says King but then you don't get the king you expected you don't get the Conquering Hero you don't get the restoration of the House of David you you get a you get a God who will feed you in a different way and you know is that a retrojection of people trying to explain his why their Messiah was killed sure but let's set aside that stuff and let's just look at what what the text is is trying to teach us that this is an unexpected God this is not a God who ripped himself off the cross and wiped out his enemies this is this is God who died and this game just kind of presents Jesus as King in a very King way yeah and it's also sad because this is supposed to be God who is about to die yeah he knows it and you know Gethsemane hasn't happened yet in this game and so kingly Jesus is even more of a weird note here for me because this should be a Jesus who's feeling insecure because he knows one of his friends is about to sell him out and a Jesus who's about to go meekly to his fate but also beg for a reprieve because he's human enough to want to not go up on that cross and do this like I don't know there's a there's an insecurity in that Jesus that I personally find very affecting
right and it's not in this game and like of course it's a game it's a Euro game like if there's only so much it can do I don't want to place expectations on it right that it just really could never have fulfilled but at the same time like I feel like it presenting itself in its way raises these questions right and brings this discussion out in a really natural way and like maybe that's the perk of the game in a way like the fact that it sparked this conversation and probably similar ones yeah sorry and to agree with you completely the the version of this game I want would be so heretical yeah like I picture a version of this game because I find it super weird that you know that Judas is bad right so so so Judas is negative points always he always gives you money and I find that kind of weird that yes you know that that you basically use Judas as a bartering chip you know to put in front of people make them lose points and I think it would have been fascinating for example if you didn't know who the traitor was uh who would betray Jesus no of course Jesus knows but Jesus says someone's going to betray me and you're going oh which is who who among these is going to betray Jesus and maybe it's a surprise maybe maybe the game lets you through studying The Parables deduce the various scoring quantities of the Apostles that like understanding the you know it gives you great sight like you don't know these Apostles have hidden scoring amounts and it's only by learning you know what Jesus is teaching
that you see into people's Souls you know however you want to put it yeah but but here's the thing then it then the game might have the possibility that oh maybe Peter's the traitor and then everyone's mad and so I totally acknowledge that the version of the game I want uh might be impossible yeah um but I wanted to do something like that you know I yeah I want The Parables to mean something more than points I I want the favors we're doing each other to be acts of Charity that do something Beyond just unlocking cargo space you know I wanted I want it to reach out and touch me and it kind of didn't yes I like your personal Jesus there um but I yes I you know I think that this game like all media of any kind about the Divine especially I think about Jesus right I mean i i in some ways I think it there's a profundity in the fact that it will never be enough that we're always going to want more like there's a reason that people wrote infancy gospels and apocryphal actually Apostles we want more more more what was Jesus like as a kid what was Jesus like as a person um you know how do we get closer we want to get close we want to be the people in Mark who are on the boat and not the ones who are on the shore when Jesus is preaching away from the masses and like that desire for closeness and the fact that we will never get it as literary and analysts or as people of faith if that's what you are like I mean you know
I think that the game accidentally winds up being something profound in that way regardless of his intentions because of that mystery at the heart of everything yeah I agree so do I have wibbles with the way this game went about things yes but I think I come down I'm glad it exists I'm glad that it's trying because the other thing is that like frankly nobody tries this so how is it going to be a perfect first try um you know yeah and you know what to to your point I hope that uh the designer um Carmen Garcia Jimenez I hope she I hope she tries again I know that she has so on her uh profile she mentioned something about she wants to create devotional games she wants to spread the word of Jesus I don't remember how she puts it but I hope she does I hope she Contin I hope she continues to take her her personal devotion and try to and and I recognize it's scary in part because of what we're doing right now right right but I hope she keeps giving it um I hope she keeps sharing herself not just because she's religious I hope that many people are trying to share their vision of of history or personal interest or whatever it is and I hope she continues to share her devotion um because I think especially once she steps away from Jesus directly yes I I think a lot of the problems sort of dissolve
um Jesus is so big let's say there's a reason that my doctorate is in the ancient Christianity program and not the New Testament program which is the other one I thought about applying for it so it's too big the smaller subset of text is actually the part that's too big but um said yeah I think that we come down the same time I think Jason you know although he had to go and handle the kids because he's a good person and a good parent um I am neither um so I think uh you know I think we would all agree we want more games like this in the world because it's not it's not that the game is perfect and we certainly could quibble with it all day if we wanted to but it's what it's trying to do that I think is Meaningful especially in a world of games that aren't always trying to do something but you and I are the types of people who are always looking for the one that is yeah I I agree I'm grateful that it's here you know and it's such a it's such a sea change that this game is marketable you know I think it's like the the new atheist movement of the early 2000s and just kind of being like Oh it's fun to slam religion you know like and I'm glad we've reached a point where we can we can acknowledge that you know what it's okay for somebody to have these devotional thoughts and want to express them without net unnecessarily slamming them because I I do want this uh I'm right you know despite having a
lot of reservations and I've shared them and I'm sure you're sick of my reservations but I am grateful I played this game yes I'm also grateful yeah I'm glad to have played it yes and you know what I think that in a world full of games where I can't say that that's saying something yeah so I think that we'll cut it off here but I hope we do this again like I hope there are more devotional games for us to get together and talk about frankly yeah but um for now everybody out there this is gonna be on the Beyond Solitaire Channel if you're watching us uh it's also gonna be a podcast on One Stop Co-op shop so Jason will run it over there um but Jason can be found at once up Co-op shop or it's shelf stories I'm Liz Davidson Beyond Solitaire and the Dan where can you be found spacemith.com spacebiff.com plays the finest written board game reviews in the business and uh so thank you so much everybody who joined us on this conversation you're free to continue in the comments so please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming foreign