"Path of Civilization" First Impressions
Transcript
hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today in this episode I review a game that was highly anticipated for me last year around the convention season during Gen Con and Essen and this game is path of civilization a story of humankind this game is designed by Fabian gell art is uncredited because of the AI art which we'll discuss later published by Captain games this game plays one to5 players in about an hour to two his weight is a 2.75 out of five overall ranking right now is 3,875 with an average rating of 7.4 out of 10 this is a civilization themed game that offers a few mechanical similarities to some games that we'll talk about soon but mechanically makes this game interesting to me is first the simultaneous play without going into too many details there are multiple phases during this game where everyone is playing a turn at the same time basically what you're trying to do is play cards from your hand to your Tableau to either gain resources to spend on future cards to buy or to spend and place cubes onto different areas of the main uh Central Area to uh use these to buy certain cards to your Tau as well not action cards but things like wonders
and leaders Etc you can also Place cubes to an area where you can have military influence in majority uh there's a philosophy track as well and so a lot of these opportunities to play these resources occur simultaneously and the one ingenious thing about this simultaneous play is for example if you are competing to buy a certain Wonder card or a leader card card since there are simultaneous bids for these according to your own Tableau there is a priority system set in place that would allow you to either win or lose a c that you are bidding for in comparison to your opponent who is vying for that as well and that is baked into the card and the Tableau that you are given at the beginning of the game and so it makes those time is and situations where you are trying to get a card at the same time which may or may not occur depending on the player count how frequent that may occur but it makes it easy to break those ties and determine where you might go you can uh if you do lose buy another card and have a chance to uh take control of something else on the market which is nice and so I really like how they can streamline the tiebreaking situations and further speed up the game
play through many of the actions being simultaneous second thing is the escalation that this game mechanically goes through as you are progressing through the game this game is nine rounds Long and going back to the phase where you play cards to your Tableau you always have five cards in your hand but you only get to play four of them discarding the last card in your hand to a discard pile and so the game forces you to not only make a decision on where you can play these cards but also the decision of what card you want to get rid of and you will always buy one card later on during the round refilling your hand back up to five and so these action cards that you're buying are the same every single game you are buying these cards that give you the ability to to gain certain resources or combinations of resources whether to continue to buy certain cards that are better and better throughout the game or to be able to place cubes once again onto the uh Central area of the game and so there is a constant escalation and decisions to be made of what cards to keep what cards where to play these cards but also which card to discard in order to replenish your hand with with a hopefully better card that aligns with your strategy in
addition to that the Strategic focus of this game somewhat revolves around challenges and battles and every round it alternates in between a challenge and a battle the challenges often have objectives that are public for everyone to try to accomplish no one is battling for or challenging for the majority of the points if you happen to fulfill those requirements for example if you have enough blue cards in your hand you add them all up for a certain amount of points and there are often different objectives that you try to fulfill as well but the decisions that you're making to replenish your hand and to continue to buy cards are often linked to these challenges and they kind of steer you into a direction of the decisions that you're trying to solve each turn but then they alternate with the military battles and so you're always having to think about adding new military units to the military area of the board and being able to place a sufficient number of military points to hopefully gain enough benefit and the way that they handle it as well is that the Victor gets pretty much all the benefits that are listed the second place gets some of those benefits and third and fourth place and so on get a minor reward Ward as well and so it's not as punitive it's mostly opportunistic for those who are
participating heavily in the battle situations third the diversity of cards is pretty substantial in this game there are plenty of different Challenge and battle cards that you can mix and match and have a variety of them from game to game the amount of leader and wonder cards that you can purchase from as well are varied they are all separated into three different eras with different leaders and wonders that appear during those epics of time and so you don't get to see all of those from their particular decks you only draw three out of the 10 or 15 or so from each deck so the variety is felt every game and so there's a feeling of replayability there and then to culminate all of those the decisions that you're making each turn thinking about not only what cards you want to acquire every round but also which leaders and which wonders align with your particular strategy do you want to go and focus more on the challenges are there some challenges that you don't want to focus on do you want to really progress of the philosophy track as well and and so there are a lot of decisions that pull you each turn there aren't enough resources to allow you to do everything you are trying to find the best Solutions every turn with what you have to be able to get as many points as you
can when comparing this game to some other games that are released now the first game that I thought of and many people do as well is Seven Wonders both of them offer a civilization themed simultaneous play experience however the resource management is a little bit more complex in path of civilization compared to Seven Wonders but I will say that the experience in Seven Wonders does feel more interactive you are constantly eyeing your neighbors to the left and to the right to see what resources they have available which ones you may not have in order to exchange money to build the cards that you want and play them into your Tableau you are constantly looking at each of those players to see where their military might stand and whether that is something that you should pursue or not as well while the military aspect is very similar in both games there aren't a lot of opportunities to interact with your opponents in path of civilization other than the situations where you're trying to buy the same card at the same time or obviously when you are participating in battles with military and so if you're looking for more of an interactive experience then Seven Wonders has that in Greater quantity than in in my opinion than path of civilization next dun Imperium is
another game that I quickly wanted to compare mechanically they're very different and rules complexity as well Dune Imperium is a much heavier game than path of civilization however the way that combat is settled felt very similar in my first experience with path of civilization as it is in Dune Imperium you if you do win combat you gain a lot of rewards and those who are in second or third place acquire less and less resources but it's never a matter of someone who is at the very bottom taking a punitive brunt of not you know winning a victory you don't lose victory points you don't lose resources Etc it's only an opportunistic and positive interactive experience versus another game that will we'll talk about which is very negative when it comes to military another game that recently came out last year or at least was kickstarted was Millennia this is another civilization themed game that boasts a lot of track progression as does path to civilization there are lots of tracks in both games which not only allow you to progress and keep track of resources but also where your victory points are coming from in the game Millennia is a much more complex game than is path of civilization there's a little bit of bidding and that kind of interaction that you have trying to VI for certain
cards but for the most part mechanically they're very different and I think if you enjoy the tracking experience or progressing up tracks that you see in Millennia and or should say in path of civilization as well as tapestry is another game that comes to mind as well then if you want a more complex experience with track progression and a civilization themed experience then you would probably want to try out Millennia finally the highest or one of the highest rated civilization game games out there uh Through the Ages so Through the Ages is another card driven tblo building game it is a lot longer it's a lot more complex than path of civilization I should say that the weight and rules complexity of path of civilization Falls somewhere along the lines of Seven Wonders maybe a little bit heavier than that game but Through the Ages is a more punitive experience as well if you are not keeping up with your military and battles occur you know during certain phases of the game you will lose cards from your Tableau you will lose uh the ability to progress in this game and it's really hard to come back back from and so it offers a more I guess punitive interactive experience in Through the Ages and some people like that including me but empatha
civilization is a lot more friendly when it comes to Military and for points as well it's a lot more feasible to get points and keep them in path of civilization I went through the comments that people left on path of civilization on Board Game Geek and summarized them using AI technology and came up with the following points both in favor of as well as points of criticism towards path of civilization those who enjoyed this game thought that this game was very replayable it was quick it was easy to decipher on the table the iconography and what certain cards did it filled the gap for a lot of people in between uh complexity wise between seven wonders and Through the Ages is if you're you are looking for a civilization themed game a lot of people enjoyed obviously the simultaneous play and the constant nature of upgrading your cards in your hand and progressing Through the Ages and through the rounds a lot of people enjoyed that aspect it reminded them of a deck building type of experience and for some there were multiple paths to Victory where you can diversify but also focus in on a couple of different areas of the board whether it's philosophy or military or otherwise to gain the points that you would need to be
Victorious now some criticisms for the game first of all include the a AI generated art now in my opinion art is obviously subjective but when it comes to AI generated art there are arguments about the I guess veracity of using that in a published game whether it draws from already copyrighted or established sources and builds upon that whether that is legal or frowned upon or not that is something that I don't want to discuss or necessarily get in the middle of I feel like for me this review is mostly focused on the mechanical experience rather than the art I will say that the art on the cards and throughout the game did not necessarily affect me one way or the other it didn't affect me neg in a negative way is what I'm trying to say and so that is where I will leave that argument uh for some people the variety of cards was not variable enough and perhaps they were referring to the action cards they are the same from game to game and they're very reminiscent in the if you were to compare the resource cards that you get in age one in Seven Wonders they're going to be the same cards that you see in every single game there are some differences in what benefits you gain from purchasing certain cards but other than that it's
the variety is not focused on those action cards but in the other versions of cards in the game for some people The Limited player interaction was a downside to this game and if you bought a phys version of the game especially considering the AI component when it came to artwork which is where I feel like some of the revenue or cost of a game goes into the expense for this game for the weight that it provides was a little too steep for some one note on the solo play I thought it was fairly easy to run the otoma during the game they didn't take very big turns they would interact with the uh markets of cards that are available in the game and with the challenges as well in the military at certain points of the game and you would quickly do their action which would primarily be taking away certain cards from the board or placing their military marker at a certain spot to serve as a competitor for you when you do score your points but they don't score anything for military and I thought it was ingenious the way that they decided how to set up the difficulty from game to game there are four different categories of cards which tell the AI what to do
and when to to interact with the philosophy track with the military track and with the Wonders and leaders and the easier versions of these four different categories of cards had them interacting at less frequency versus the higher difficulty where the opponent would interact with these areas at a constant rate a more constant rate and at a higher rate as well and so with the really for example the difficulty with the philosophy deck of AI cards they would progress a lot farther through the track then perhaps you would be able to or the military they would consistently have a higher military threshold that you would need to meet if you wanted to beat them in Military and gain those rewards Etc and at the bottom of each of these cards were how many victory points that particular card would add to the score threshold that you're trying to beat and so in essence this is a beat your own score type of experience but it is variable and determined by which cards you decide to use at what difficulty there's a bronze silver and gold difficulty for each of of these four categories and so therefore there are 12 categories in total and so the combination of however you would like to arrange the difficulty for each of those aspects of the game
really do affect the score every time and creates a different threshold that feels variable every time you play so that was easy to run and felt unique as well so finally my concluding thoughts for p of civilization this game felt really fun to play from start to end it felt like the decisions that you're making mattered right from the get-go and you were making tough decisions from the start it was easy to learn especially if you've played games like seven wonders kind of had that similar feel for what you were trying to accomplish like I mentioned before the strategy in this game felt like you wanted to try to do everything and diversify as much as you could progress pressing up all of the tracks and buying all the cards that you could but you were limited by the resources that you gained every turn and so you had to pick and choose which areas you wanted to focus in while trying to do a little bit of everything at the same time and so I felt like I was pulled in different directions and it that felt good it felt good to try to figure out what I was trying to accomplish every turn keeping my eye on the battles and objectives that are alternating every round but also trying to progress up the main tracks that everyone was trying to move up as well and so I liked the diversification of strategic avenues that were included in this game the
variety felt pretty good to me as well not in the action cards obviously but in the Wonders and leaders they had cool you know neat actions that felt thematic to the characters as well and so I liked the variety that is inherent in the base game when it came to the balance of these different Avenues of strategy and what to pursue I felt like there was not too much influence that your own personal Tableau which represented a civilization had on where what paths you would like to take I think it was the the majority of where your points were coming from felt like following the challenges and battles as closely as you could to maximize the amount of points he had there and the minor components included the Wonders and leader cards that you were acquiring as well as the action cards that you acquire they give you some victory points there some of them had some endgame objectives that you could try to fulfill very similar to the guilds that you see in age3 of Seven Wonders and then there were some base points that you would get from the philosophy track as well which seemed important and substantial as well I felt like the military progression was not as lucrative when it came to points as it felt like in Seven Wonders I think those who do focus on on Military often do
pretty well in Seven Wonders it felt a little bit less lackluster or a little bit more lackluster in path of civilization but those rewards were enticing every round but that I guess punitive nature that is included in Seven Wonders where you do get negative points if you lose Wars in comparison to your neighbors when you are switching from age to age did have a somewhat of an impact there now I guess that's to say that I felt like the decisions that I was making while I did feel that tug and that push and pull in different directions of what I wanted to try to accomplish after I went through the entire game which I was enjoying from start to finish I felt like the the escalation of starting really small with your resources not being able to do much you know only having a few cards that you can purchase from but then having that ramp up just a few rounds later to give you more options of what to purchase and and where to allocate those resources for the Wonders and Etc I felt like the decisions and the Avenues that you took were roughly the same I I did mention that the military track didn't feel as Point heavy as some of the other experiences that you're trying to have in this game such as the objectives such as the philosophy track and the endgame
wonders and leaders that you could purchase throughout the middle to late portions of the game I felt like they were roughly equal and so it didn't really I felt like it didn't really matter at first what I did essentially I would look for the most efficient ways to gain resources I would try to you know put down as many resources as I could while following those public objectives and that was enough for me to beat the game on its easiest mode I think and so at the very least it's feasible to kind of follow the resources and make decisions there and so it there was a lot of handholding felt like to allow you to beat the game at its easiest mode and so I think I will say that my point differential from the AI wasn't as substantial as perhaps I felt like there probably is a lot of room to grow strategically in this game and a lot of efficiency questions that you're trying to decipher in each round as the solo game at least gets more difficult but also as you introduce more players to the game I I've only played this game solo and I would imagine if you play this game at four or five players then the decisions are a little bit more numerous in the amount of Wonders and leader leader cards that are available in each round the interaction
of choosing which cards to bid for and hopefully purchase based off of your own Tableau will obviously become a lot more contentious as you introduce more players who may be eyeing that card as well and so I can see that situation coming into play where you're trying to think about what your other opponents may be able to do or may be able to do easily and what cards they purchase and that can alter your decisions but I guess off of first blush it felt like it was pretty easy to just follow the resources uh pick up a card here to kind of give you an edge on an obje Ive or a battle and then use utilize those resources that are on that card to tell you where to focus your efforts in the next round and so despite that I think there is potential for this game to be a little bit deeper and more complex when it comes to strategy but the rules overhead is not too bad I agree with a lot of what people said that the iconography was pretty straightforward I tended to go back to the rule book or the glossery to look over and confirm some of those challenge cards and battles just to make sure that and some of the Wonder and leader cards just to make sure that I understood them correctly and so besides that it was pretty easy to know what you're doing phase bye turn by turn in the game which I appreciated if I were to choose this
game versus Seven Wonders I I think it would come down to time I think and if I wanted a more social and Interactive experience I feel like you can get that social experience better with seven wonders and am comparing Bas game to base game I have not really experienced the expansion material that seven wonders offers and so that opinion may change based off of that but if you're just comparing base game to base game path of civilization despite the simultaneous play does feel longer it feels a little bit more complex and especially as the game progresses I feel like those decisions become tougher and tougher versus with seven wonders the decision space is very simple at first and I think it ramps up a lot less than it does with path of civilization in my opinion I I know you can play Seven Wonders very competitively as you understand the deck itself and the age cards and which cards may be missing and comparing that to your Tableau and to what your neighbors are doing and trying to pursue as well I know strategically seven wers can be complex but if you're just kind of comparing them casually then Seven Wonders is less of a heads down type of experience and more of a heads up and a more interactive social experience that you can play casually a lot easier than I think you can with path to civilization but and of course path to
civilization rules wise does not compare to games like tapestry or Millennia or Through the Ages in is not as competitive I would say then compared to Through the Ages which is very competitive very skill oriented where if you don't play the game right you will have a bad time and it's obviously a longer game as well but um aside from the component issues and the art issues I thought path of civilization was a really fun game and I think if I did have more time to allocate with my game group who really enjoy Seven Wonders I think they enjoy it a lot more than I do but it's really quick to pull that out and play it in 20 to 30 minutes especially with players who have played it before and to play it at higher player counts up to seven it's a lot easier to do that in a bigger group with seven wonders and so that has its time in place but if I'm sitting down with three to four players maybe five and I have about an hour an hour and a half to play a civil Iz a themed game I think I would choose this game over seven wonders if I had more time rather than play Heaven wonders back to back I think I would choose this game over Millennia as well I think Millennia was a little bit too complex that and it's mostly track based and I personally have more of a uh a fun experience when I'm
building my own Tableau out rather than progressing up a track in comparison to other players but but a lot of people enjoy that and I think that's why I would prefer path of civilization compared to tapestry but something about tapestry just calls me back every time and despite the mechanical track progression there's a little bit of Tableau building and there's a puzzle that you get to solve with your your faction and and your Tableau the the city board that you have and the tapestry cards that come out and so so I I don't know it's hard to say it's it's neck and neck between tapestry and path of civilization but I really enjoyed my my experience with path to civilization and hope to have more of that in the future so those are my thoughts on path to civilization thank you for listening or watching and hope that you schedule an appointment with us real soon and hopefully catch you on the next one take care