Skip to main content
Loading video...

Knave 2nd Edition - Review from the solo perspective (solo RPG)

Transcript 30:17

hey everybody welcome back to the dungeon dive Daniel here I hope you're doing well and if you're not I hope you are soon okay on today's episode we are reviewing Nave second edition and Nave second edition is of course from Ben Milton the incredibly uh popular YouTuber on Quest beast and game designer with Nave this was insanely successful on Kickstarter so I know that a lot of people have copies in their hands now but in the in the kind of Pantheon of modern Indie RPGs there are kind of three pillars I think and three games that a lot of people talk about a lot and those are into the odd from Chris McDowel and Karen from yoai gal and right yoai gal yep yoi G and both of these I do have experience with we've taken a look at Karen on the channel before in a kind of a roundabout way with run Karen and also uh we deal in lead and um into the odd I haven't yet taken a look at but I do have experience with both of these I do not have any or I did not have any experience at all with a Nave first edition the only thing from band that I do have is maze rats and I thought maze rats was pretty cool it's a good collection of table that you can use and Nave is is is somewhat similar and I know that people like Nave a lot so we're going to be talking about it now this is the first video that I'm going to introduce something on and we'll probably return to this metric as

we talk more about uh RPG systems and that is the solo score uh as everybody knows or or new people to the channel as you will find out uh 99% of the games that I cover on the dungeon dive are from the solo perspective that's how I enjoy most of the games that I play and that's how I spend uh the vast majority of my time gaming is solo and that goes with board games and RPGs and so I'm developing a a a solo score now the solo score is not a grade uh it's not an A+ B+ don't think of it in terms of a grade don't think of of a low score as being a bad game it's a it's it's a spectrum and it's a scale on one end you have a one and those are games that I would never recommend for solo play those are games something like Fiasco games that rely 100% on their social interaction as mechanisms and to generate the fun of the game and then on the other end of the spectrum you have a 10 would be something like like Keralis or Thousand-Year vampire something that is designed specifically for solo play and I would not recommend those games for multiplayer or they're just not designed at all for multiplayer play so n on the on the on the solo score I'm giving it a a five out of 10 it's somewhere right in the middle uh Nave is not meant for solo play there isn't a chapter on how to facilitate solo play it's not an

official option or even really a consideration and hey you know what that's totally okay uh not all games need to have a a a a chapter dedicated to how to play solo but it is doable especially with an oracle so with an oracle I'm giving the solo score a 7 out of 10 if you wanted to play Nave uh solo and for an oracle I would recommend something a little more robust and I would recommend uh something like random realities from Caesar kakle uh we've taken a look at this before this is a fantastic Oracle with all kinds of information for generating anything that you would need or what you might want to take a look at is the little GM emulator from Gustavo Quello and we've taken a look at some of his games before uh little town and eldrich town and just recently caves and catacombs and this is a new little uh Oracle Zen that he uh that he put out and this is a copy I got a PDF from hi and uh this is a copy that I printed out and made myself and this is a really really cool Oracle speaking of oracles we are going to be taking a look at a bunch of oracles soon we'll be flipping through my Oracle book where I just have all kinds of different Oracles ranging from little simple one pagers to more complex things like the two that we just took a look at but I'm putting together a few more and coming up with some notes for some others so we can take a detailed look at all of these amazing oracles that are available to

help you facilitate solo play for games that are not specifically designed for solo play now Nave as a tool for using Nave as a tool for other games to generate uh things for your solo play I'm giving it an 8 out of 10 and that's because it is absolutely overflowing with awesome tables that can be used for generating just about everything you would want to any a kind of typical DND D style fantasy world there are so many tables as a matter of fact that I made my own PDF of just the tables of just the generating the the things that generate um ideas and encounters and content for a game and it was 52 pages of tables just overflowing with tables so Nave as a tool to help facilitate play with other games is very very valuable I'd say it's worth the price of the book just for all of the tools and we'll be taking a little bit of a deeper look at all of the tables as we do look through the book so Nave second edition again from from Ben Milton with art by Peter Mullen uh fans of Dungeon Crawl classics will of course recognize the art one thing I appreciate and it was also something that I appreciated in Karen and run Karen and we de in lead is when an RPG kind of lays out the the the the

uh the duties the game master duties the player duties what is expected of the people who are playing the game and there are a few things that I did like in this section and that is that the players guide the action so GMS let the players dictate the flow of the story don't over plan go with the flow roll up lots of random things give the players agency keep the game moving I think that's really important to keep in mind especially as uh solo players sometimes we can get bogged down in in looking things up and uh we can get bogged down during a game of like oh I have this perfect tool for that ah what was it where was this one chart I had in this book uh let me put the game down and I'm going to go to my shelves and dig through all of my zen and all of my all of my PDFs and all of my stacks of paper and find this one Perfect Tool when often we can just kind of go with the flow and keep the game moving that is really really important uh you can go and find your perfect Tools in between game sessions um another thing was using time as a resource I know time as a resource is something that is really important to Ben he has a whole video on the old timekeeping methods in original DND and how important that is to to uh to the game and using time as a resource time is a precious commodity to the adventurer especially when they are in precarious situations and so keeping uh using time as a resource is a very important element to this game as are uh

using as is using items as a resource items can be broken to do cool things you can lose items as you lose hit points you can use the ability to carry items as you take damage and so on so items and time are a very important element to a game of Nave uh character creation character creation is super simple and I like it it's a classless system although it does have careers and careers are used to give your characters a backstory and some uh some items and some gear to start off with so we have our typical Fantasy ability scores are stats we have strength dexterity Constitution intelligence wisdom and Charisma and each one of those is associated with an archetype It's associated with a common uh fantasy archetype so of course strength would be your fighter dexterity your Rogue Constitution your Adventurer intelligence your Mage wisdom a ranger and Charisma a cleric and your ability scores range from 0 to 10 and the ability scores are are basically the modifier that you add when you want to do a challenge and challenges are pretty simple in Nave you take a base score of 11 you add or subtract any modifiers to get a target number usually that Target number is 16 and you roll a D20 and you add any modifiers and you have to meet

or beat that score so with a Target value of 16 that means that a new character can have about a 25% to 40% chance of doing something heroic of of accomplishing the task that they set out to accomplish and that's because your characters will start with three points in their ability scores now you can either assign those points to make the character that you want to or you can roll randomly and I think this is really cool it's a really neat way to randomly roll up a character so each one of these stats corresponds to a number ranging from 1 to six you roll 3d6 and you assign one point to the numbers that are rolled so let's take a look here okay so five five and four so four we would go uh score one point in our intelligence which would be a Mage and then two points in our five so we are kind of we are a magic using Ranger really neat way to create a character everything else would start off at zero so you could make a really powerful Fighter by just giving your initial three points in strength or your initial three points points and intelligence if you wanted to be a powerful magic user but I really like this really I mean there is a character 444 hey uh we are a mage there we would have three points in intelligence or here we have four one and two so two would be a rogue and one would be a fighter and a mage a fighter Rogue Mage hey that's kind of like El in

a way at least El a very young a very young naive El or something like that but uh so yeah that's the way that you create characters that's pretty much it you start with a D6 maximum hit points so you don't have a lot of hit points uh we would have two hit points there all right however your items are also your hit points or your kind of like your wounds and you start with 10 item slots plus your charisma modifier or your Constitution modifier so my Constitution modifier is zero so right now I have a maximum of 10 item slots when my HP reaches zero then I start Crossing off my item slots from 10 up and any items that are in those slots those get lost those get uh either they're damaged uh you can think of your items as critical wounds as direct damage uh some damage will do direct damage and that bypasses your XP completely and just starts Crossing off your uh your item slots I think that's a pretty cool thing now we also have a couple of careers we get to choose two careers or we can roll uh let's roll randomly here and those will be D1 100 rolls d00 so let's uh our first career here is a 47 so a 47 that will give us a hunter and as a hunter I start with a ENT a bare skin and a bear trap all right and what is my second

career here uh 92 a squire a torch armor polish and a trun it so those would be all of the things I start with and then I believe you also start with uh a little bit of gold uh your armor class so your armor class always starts at 11 plus your armor points and you get one point of armor for every piece of armor that your character is wearing up to seven so if you had some chest armor and a helmet you would get two and then you would add those together for 13 would be your armor class and 13 that would be your target number that enemies have to roll to hit you uh pretty simple I do like that system there all characters start at level one as you gain experience and in this game gold is experience treasure is experience you all of the characters level up at the same rate and you go from a level one wretch all the way up to a level 10 a Nave and when you level up you get to add three uh one point to three different um ability scores so that's how you level up is just your ability scores go up so that would mean that your modify that you get to uh modify your dice rolls for doing challenges and so on and you become better at all of the things that you want your hero to be better at I love the character system in this it's very simple if your character dies you can literally have a new character up and ready to go in just a

few seconds but there is some flexibility especially in this D 100 careers and just a simple way that you can assign a single point to an attribute in order to become um more like that archetypical character that the attribute corresponds to so after the character section we get into our section on checks I've kind of got over that before you start with a base 11 and then you add modifiers to make the target number and then you roll a D20 and you add any modifiers and you're trying to meet or beat that particular Target number to accomplish the thing that you want to accomplish and after the checks we move into the fun stuff we move into generating things for travel and for encounters and for all of the random tables so traveling is pretty interesting in this game you have uh six different watches six different periods three in the morning 3 in the afternoon it basically takes one watch to move a hex that's about six miles if you move more than three hex's without resting you start taking direct damage so direct damage bypass passes your hit points it's kind of a forced March you start taking fatigue damage and your ability to to hold items goes down one watch equals about 4 hours like I said it takes about one watch or it takes one watch to fully explore a hex you do a wisdom check in order to prevent uh to stop yourself from getting lost it takes one watch to forge for 1d6 rations so

think of watches as your actions and you take those turn but you do also have to rest when you at at the end of the day you will roll your hazard die so this is where this game starts to get into kind of this solo play if you wanted to uh you could roll a D6 at the end of each day and a five you have a sign so the players find a sign and then you can turn to page 10 here and here are D1 100 signs so what would we find here um a four we find a blade marks on something maybe some blade marks on a tree are those natural blade marks or are they made by some kind of Smith weapon uh maybe they look like claw marks so there's some kind of wearwolf or something out in the forest uh we have different locations that you can roll on while you are traveling uh maybe we come across a 49 we come across a a lake and in the middle of a lake is a is a water mill so a flooded Watermill maybe it's not a lake maybe it's a a large body of shallow water with a water mill or a a some kind of Mill a water um what did I say yeah Water Mill and what are the traits here 11 um and it's burning down oh that's kind of ironic right is that ironic I don't know sometimes irony confuses me but uh so in the middle of this field of water uh there is uh this this shallow Pond is a Watermill and the Watermill is on fire and maybe some people are standing around scooping up buckets of water trying to put this

water mill out of uh uh trying to put the the fire out and you come along as a Wandering hero and you L lend a hand in order to help them do that but as you're traveling you can have an encounter you can become fatigued you can have depletion where your things that are perishable uh start to to uh deplete uh you can have a travel shift and travel shifts are things that just happened and this is a really cool way to roll up random charts as well or random um random occurrences I should say random events so we might have an eight um a ball lightning so we see ball lightning and maybe we can fuse it for some kind of UFO or something or a 21 uh there is some kind of disaster sometimes the tables will reference other tables so disaster on page 31 here all right what kind of disaster did we come across while we were traveling 21 um a dream plague what the heck is a dream plague I don't know that would be something that we would want to uh to look into too maybe that could be a quest or something to figure out what a dream plague is so again the charts are very very handy for traveling we have signs locations structures and place traits and then we get into delving so this is our dungeon diving here and again we have a hazard chart from an encounter fatigue burn a delve shift a sign and no no encounter when you're a dungeon crawling every action takes about 10 minutes so things are kind of

shrunken down a little more more focused and when you are dungeon diving of course you do have shifts here so we are in the middle of a dungeon and the shift is an eight I've rolled an eight I think three times in this video um the ceiling moves oh no the maybe the ceiling starts dropping maybe it is a trap um a six man this thing is like hitting z00 a lot isn't it um a blessing we come across a blessing so we find something good in the dungeon a 69 and what is 69 is the passages open and we can come across rooms so we can stumble upon different rooms as 64 64 is a managerie uh room details room themes different dungeon themes different trap effects different hazards different mechanisms all kinds of cool things to encounter in a dungeon and then we get into the encounter section here we have a 2d6 chart to roll up what the thing is doing what the people are doing what the moners doing how do they react to you anywhere from they want to kill the PCS to they ask to join the PC's party with a seven right in the middle being ignore the PCS what are they doing when we come across them well we have this D100 chart of of um activities they could be cooking preaching going on a mission uh murdering selling celebrating so all kinds of different things and then that leads into the combat section combat again is pretty simple you have a target

number number based on 11 plus either the Monsters level or the PC's Armor class and that becomes the target level you roll a D20 add modifiers and and meet or beat that there are things called Maneuvers and Maneuvers are things like stunning blinding climbing restraining uh those are things that don't cause damage but add to the Tactical or the Strategic elements of the combat and when you do a Critical Strike and that's when your your uh combat role is 21 or higher you get to also perform a free maneuver in that round of combat so that's kind of cool it adds a little bit of a narrative to the combat the spells all right the magic system here is really really cool so I don't use magic a lot in the games that I play I prefer to I prefer to have magic going on in the background or maybe uh going up against opponents who are magical I personally don't like keeping track of spells for characters so that's why I tend to avoid magic but this game has a random chart of D100 spells but you can also generate new spells and this is so much fun I love this so you have a spell formula and you roll a D12 to determine the spell formula so let's roll that here all right this is a nine so we have nine it's the Wizard's name the effect and the element Okay so Let's uh create this

spell here so the Wizard's name we have a D100 of course this is very vancy in here dying Earth style spells here so we have 64 okay so this is um pero pero effect let's go to our effect table so this is peros 48 pero identifying and element pero identifying 100 Wood okay so uh this maybe this uh Magic user is a a a wood a a a carpenter and so he has developed a magic spell to help him identify the wood of any kind of structure that he wants or something like that but we have different so you have element on form effect and form Wizard's name and quality and effect so we have qualities effects and elements and forms different types of mutations different delusions disasters and a whole chart on Magic schools really fun to come up with all kinds of magical abilities I think having access to these random magic tables might allow me or give me the um give me a reason to include more magic in my solo games we also have a whole bunch of charts on Relic magic so those are items that cause magic so those can be from different domains a whole bunch of different symbols icons um a whole

bunch of things for different types of alchemy for different potions textures tastes colors and ingredients so if you like mixing potions there's a lot of stuff for you to do in this game um equipment is is relatively easy again you can have up to seven pieces of armor to help uh bolster your armor class and those are Shields helmets gambin mail shirts breast plates arm plate and leg plate and all of those have the same cost so item itemization is relatively simple in Nave uh all of the you know all of the swords are kind of the same they're either one-handed or two-handed but then it's up to the player to come up with the details about their weapon we also have a cost of living uh chart from being destitute which is 90 coins per month all the way up to royalty which is 600,000 coins per month we have a D100 chart for tools for miscellaneous items for books clothing Fabrics decorations Treasures materials weapons and item traits and then we get into our section about buildings and warfare so this is kind of large scale battles now this is the only part where I think the books uh the organization is a little odd because we have buildings and then Warfare but the charts that follow Warfare seem to have more to do with buildings I think maybe I would have moved Warfare to uh after the subsequent charts here which include your City themes your City events your street details all of your building details we have our in name one

and two our food traits and our different food factions faction traits missions and rewards maybe um maybe Warfare should have gone right here missions and rewards this is really this is the part where I wish that this game had a little bit more uh a little bit more in terms of generating and that's generating quests and generating plots it doesn't have a lot of things to help you to help The Soloist get going once you get going the book is overflowing with helpful charts but getting going um takes a little bit of an effort and so that's why I do give this game a five it's kind of right in the middle of that but if you take something like either of the two um emulators we looked at the little GM emulator or the random realities you should be able to get going pretty quickly and come up with a plot and come up with some uh some quests to get your game going and then we also have down downtime and downtime you can actually earn XP in downtime by gambling because since gold is XP the more gold you gain the more XP you gain because you can pay to get trained and you can also recruit different uh helpers different henchman we have different types of art we have different archetypes of people you can recruit such as the salty Mariner or the gentleman thief or the hardboiled sleuth or a swash buckler a classy cortison or a melon collie Queen and then we have a whole bunch of charts for NPCs uh male

names female names surnames one and two personalities NPC details professions goals assets liabilities relationships and mannerisms and then we get into our section on monsters so we have a D100 monster chart here we have an example bestiary and we have a way to generate our uh some of our beasts some of our monsters monsters have your typical stats like they would in any kind of basic fantasy you have armor class hit points level the number of attacks how fast or how far they move the morale and the number appearing when you want to generate things we have you can generate animals different organs different monster traits and Powers sense sounds tactics and weaknesses very cool coming up with random monsters is super fun a lot like coming up with different spells and then we have a gameplay example and finally the last section here is a section that I really like and this is designer's commentary and Ben has gone in here and addressed kind of the major points of this game and why he chose to do with them what he did for instance I really like this uh this commentary on random tables and Ben says much much is often made of whether a game's rules are good but in my view the actual content of a game the situations locations events NPCs often has a bigger impact impact on the experience than mechanics I totally agree with that uh mechanisms

are kind of a di Diamond dozen mechanisms come and go we can choose and pick mechanisms that we like it's easy to find mechanisms it's hard to find that meaty stuff and for me when I pick up a RPG I like a lot of random tables and that is one of the first things I look at is how easy is it for me as a solo player to generate the things that I need on the Fly while I am playing and some books really fail on that and I don't typically like those kinds of RPGs whereas if I picked this up in a store not knowing anything about it and I started flipping through this and I saw all of these tables I would think yes this is a game that I can use even just as a tool for generating things for my solo game so I really appreciate Ben's focus on random tables and then he also in each of the major topics he gives his inspiration so the inspiration for his random tables uh was the perilous Wilds by Jason loots and Augmented Reality by Paul Gallagher I am familiar with the perilous Wilds I am not familiar with a augmented reality so that gives me something to research now and each one of these lists his inspiration and so if you're looking for more inspiration if you're looking for more games to to research this is a fantastic section it's kind of like an appendix in for the things that been for the the systems the game that been used to inspire him in the creation of Nave and Nave second

edition so yeah overall I think this is a pretty great book it's nice and small it's compact it's very well made it's it's The Binding is nice the stitching is nice the art is nice all of the tables are nice I would just say if you're looking for something solo that you can play just with the one book this is not the game this is not that game this doesn't have solo rules it doesn't have a built-in Oracle it doesn't have a chapter on how to facilitate solo play so just know if you're looking to go into Nave second edition solo that while it can be a fantastic tool to generate things maybe for other games you will need a little help from an emulator to get your game going and to help handle some of the GM duties so all right you guys well I hope you enjoyed this review of Nave second edition we will talk to you later bye-bye

Progress saved