Dynasty League Baseball Review: Take Me Out to the Flowchart
Transcript
I am a board gamer. I like to call myself an omnigamer because I like to play all sorts of games from all different genres. But I discovered when playing board games that there are certain subsets where people get really into those games and it's harder for me to delve into those styles of games. Heavy war games, incredibly strong economic simulation games and in a subcategory that's existed for probably 50 years, baseball games. Now, this here, the one I'm taking a look at, Dynasty League Baseball powered by Pursue the Pennant and they proudly proclaim themselves here they made the hobby games the 100 best, which is a book that I have both read and own. Um and it's here written by a lot of uh different baseball players saying this is uh the most realistic baseball game ever made.
Now, I like baseball statistics a lot. Baseball's my favorite sport. I love the idea of baseball statistics. I am in no means in the top tier of statisticians, you know that know that by the time we're done with this video um or even remotely close, but I still like it. So, I am willing to delve into these games. I know that Status Pro is probably the king in this genre, but this one intrigued me and I played these complicated games before, so I gave this one a whirl. Whoa! So, I'm going to complain about the rules a little bit here because I want to talk and show you here this rule book. This is the official rule book and how to play guide. Okay, great. So, I go in here and it's talking about here spring train learning the fundamentals.
Oh, okay. And so, they're going to explain some basic stuff here, there's ratings and things. And so they show you these two sample cards. And the game comes with a lot of cards. And you're going to be basically playing a pitcher against a batter. And you're going to be rolling three 10-sided dice, which is going to give you a number from zero to a thousand. And so when you roll these, you look at the colors, red, white, and blue. So if I roll these dice like this, I have 741. So on here, 741, I'm going to look here. Well, the batter the go only goes up to 500. So 741, I'm going to go on here. And then it'll be like deep drive, question mark, foul, question mark, and pink.
Well, I just told you the basic parts of the game. And then and talking about rules again, they talk a little bit about this and suddenly they talk about rolling and reading the dice. Great, I'm with them. And then suddenly they talk about weather and how that happens. And a meeting at home plate, which I don't just
It's not something you need to know in a baseball game right away. And then how to play ball. Okay, so we're back to what you roll the dice and you'll do this. And then you'll talk about sometimes it's versus left or right. Do the base runners advance? And I'm telling you these rules are nigh impenetrable. And I'm someone who understands the rules of baseball, but they jump all over the place. They act like you've played this game before. There's a ton of joining a league and stuff and I'm like, but what does everything mean? Well, here's the thing. A lot of it is done in this giant book here. So in this giant book, it's going to you're going to look up different things. They have a whole chart of bizarre things, things that happen once in a very blue moon. But hey, there's a chance the batter fouls the ball straight down on his foot and he gets injured.
But more likely, there's a chance that an error happens. And then depending on what position they are, the error may or may not happen. And then we have a range here, and that may or may not affect what things are happening. And this is looks very complicated, but in case you thought it wasn't complicated, they also come with these stadiums, which are going to change some of the stats of the game. And as I mentioned earlier, we have multiple sheets of weather that you're going to play with, and these will sometimes check things. And then if you want, here's the ballpark information. Now, they do have some stats here to keep track of a baseball game, but everything else is on the card. So, this is my complaint about this game.
You roll the dice. I know which card to look at, the pitcher or the batter. That part is pretty simple. You roll the dice, and I have a whole bunch of I mean, I have a ton of pitchers here. So, let me find a a batter so we can compare these to each other. Wow, so many pitchers in this game.
Here we go. So, we have a batter, Raphiel Marchan, against Michael Soroka. And I apologize to either of these players if I said their name incorrectly. And they have a lot of stats here on the card. And so, when I open the book, and I look at this information here, it shows you these cards. It just shows a picture of the card. It doesn't tell you what all that stuff means. Now, some of it I can figure out, but there's question marks after a lot of things. Now, I get for example here, I hit the batter. But, in outfield range, well, what does that mean? And the book, if you search through it, if you're reading through, eventually you'll be able to figure some things out. It doesn't help when they're like, "New!"
What do you mean new? Oh, you mean new to this set of rules, but I never played this before. And I have to just go through and look and say, "Okay, here's an off base. Here's magenta. Here's bunting. Okay, here's foul. So, then I need to check the foul territory rating in the ballpark charts and roll two dice to see if there's a foul. Deep drive, {question mark} I need to use the bat section. Okay, so I'm going to pull up this section here. I'm looking under this section and going through and here's the steel attempt. And every single thing that can happen in baseball is somehow on these cards and in these books. But getting there is such a difficult thing.
And at the end of the day, I'm not making any strategic decisions. I am rolling these dice and seeing which of these thousand different events happen. Now, it's not a thousand, it's more like 40 different possible events. But when I do with these events, if I come here, infield range, I then have to check the range on the infield on the thing and I have to look that up and see what happens. And is there a deep drive? And a distance hit? And there's just so many things just to see if I hit the ball. But does that make the game bad? Well, let's talk about it.
I feel like there should be that meme going on here where the numbers are going by and the person's just like, "Rocket science." You know, with all that stuff going around in the background. Because that's how this game made me feel. And part of it Well, I shouldn't say part of it. A lot of it is honestly that terrible, no good, rotten, bad rulebook. I'm sorry. This game is is complex game. That's fine. I'm not arguing against the game being complex. And I like the but that rule book is written very clearly for people who've already played this game before. Yes, I know I'm going to roll the red, white, and blue die and get a three-digit number. And if it's below 500, I look at one card. If it's above 500, I look at the other card. But then what do I do?
And it's just scattered all throughout the rule books. It could be so easily laid out there that it says, "If you roll this, go to page six." On page six, here is how the this whatever this symbol means. Here's how errors work. Here is how range works. Here is how bunting works, etc. And so if it was laid out very clearly, it would be so much easier instead of me having to look through a book, going to another chart, looking at this chart, trying to figure out where to go. That is mind-bogglingly bad. If you want more people to play this, then that rule book should clearly lay it out. And I I know that, you know, whenever I I talk about rule books, like there's someone who goes, "It's not as complicated as that. It's not that big." I don't think it is that complicated necessarily, but the rule book is no help at all.
Now, once you get through all that. So, let's say that you did have all these nice charts, which you should. The charts should be much easier to read, much simpler. It's really hard for me to justify the amount of effort that has gone into this. When I was a kid, I played a game called I think it was called Status Pro Baseball, where I spun a spinner. And you had these and each of the different baseball players had a a a pie chart and they had home runs and walks and balls and all sorts of, you know, all different things were on this chart. And you would spin it. And it that spinning there was out of 1,000, just like this is. And this where it ended, something happened. I spun the spinner and I was done. Sometimes the spinner might land on something and you might need to spin a different spinner piece, but very basic. This is not that way. This you're rolling three dice, you then go to another chart, possibly two other charts, you roll on those charts, you compare, you see if the if there's anyone on base, do they advance, you might have to roll on another chart.
But it all leads to the same thing. Why do I need to do all this when I could just have a baseball simulator, I plug in my players, and I press a button, and I see what happens? And I think that's where it comes down here. What choices am I making in this game besides building my team? And that's fine. I mean, baseball a lot of baseball games are that way where you pick your team, and then you see what happens. But why does it have to be this complex? I roll this, and and I think part of the the the different the difficulty of it being complex is when I open this and I pull out a random player. So here I have
[snorts]
Matt Bowman from 2024. He throws right. His endurance is 120. Pick off hold 1C plus plus four. Range B, error 100. And I'm looking at all these stats on here. And I can see some of his stats. He had five home runs, 13 walks, 24 strike outs, 26 hits. And ERA of 4.4. So he's not not you know, he's not a particularly amazing pitcher here. I can kind of tell that. But when I look at his card, I don't see it. There's all these different things and the different runs here, and I'm sure that statistically in a computer program wrote these out, but I can't glance at his card and go, "Ooh, those are good stats." It's like a code that I have to break and figure out. So maybe ultimate baseball players will love this game, and obviously there's people who really do like it.
But I just can't recommend it to people. Who am I recommending it to? Baseball fans? You're going to have to like get through this code. And again, I I just don't see why this can't be computerized to some degree where I put it in and it tells me what happens. Why is it fun for me to go look at a chart to roll in a chart to figure out what chart to go to when I can just put it in and see what happens in an app or something. And I'm not saying and I know people are so opposed to apps and computers. Oh, it just, you know, what's wrong with rolling dice and looking up charts? Well, the same reason I don't use my hand to multiply 37,424 * 19.8621, I use a calculator cuz it's easier. And I think the same thing can be said here. Now that being said, I have played other baseball games, you can find reviews of them, that were 60% as complex as this and I liked them.
And I liked them despite the fact that I know that there's almost nobody I can play them with cuz almost nobody I know wants to play this with me. But I'm willing to go out there and play it. But this one is a bridge too far. Part of it is the rulebook. Part of it is the fact that the players have been reduced to just a bunch of numbers that I have a hard time deciphering to whether they're good or not. And the third part is is that at the end of the day, I'm not sure all this extra numbers and complexity really changed how I feel about the game of baseball. And well, I can just go back and roll a die and if I get a 70 plus, I get a hit, you know, or something that I I I don't know how this complexity makes the game better. But that your mileage may vary. I'm sure someone's going to watch this who really likes this, but for most of my audience, the the fans of this who are like, why is Tom holding a FedEx box? I'm like, no, this is the actual box of the game.
I don't think I would recommend it for most of you because it's just too much. If you're in love with baseball and more [clears throat] than human beings, then this might be for you, but for the rest of us, I think we might pass. A five out of 10 for me and that's only because I love baseball. I'm Tom Vasel and you're watching The Dice Tower.
Hey everybody, thanks for watching this video. If you like this review or whatever you just watched, wasn't it amazing? Uh check out our channel, Dice Tower. Uh we have all kinds of things we review, game, we do top 10s, we play games live. It's all about board games, but especially the people who play them. Check out Dice Tower YouTube channel.