Fathom Review: Treasure or Trouble Below?
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassel.
And I'm Camila.
Today we're taking a look at a game called Fathom. This I'm a sucker for anything that has water on the front cover. Yep.
And in this game you are you are sending out ships of apparently different centuries. I was a little confused on the theming of this. You are marine biologists who are fighting for an esteemed spot on this island because their marine biologist is retiring and you are going to different areas of the island and different expeditions trying to complete goals and be the best marine biologist to win the sustained position. Did you pick that up?
Yes, I knew all that from this very themed game. Well, you are going out in the ocean and that part's there. Camille's gonna show you how to play. We'll be right back. At its core, Fathom is going to be a tile laying, pattern building game with some deep sea exploration and thematics thrown in here. It's going to come with four different expeditions or scenarios, if you will, in the box. And to kind of complete your setup, you're going to choose one of these to play through. In this one here, I am set up for the expedition one Leviathan Falls. and you'll just consult the rulebook for the specific scenario-based setup and to get and as well as the scenario-based scoring objectives which will be out there. It's going to have different components and um again just bring a little bit of flavor to the specific scenario that you're playing. You're going to play over six rounds in which you're going to be taking different tiles and exploring your own personal board, trying to maximize your scoring as you build out the patterns. Each player is going to have their own board like this over here as I am set up with the red player. And then there's going to be a shared sonar board over here as well. For a round, each player can consult their individual dashboard, which is where you're going to track where you're at in the round, as there's a couple different phases that you're going to go through. So, the first thing you're going to do is take your first pawn for the first phase here, which is the ship phase. And everyone gets to move their ship one space. Now, ships are going to follow the circular spaces.
So perhaps I would want to take my ship and move him to right here in the very middle spot. The next thing you're going to do is everyone is going to change their bags or switch their bags, pass them one player on the left. So the bags are going to rotate around even though they are player color dependent. You will be drawing from other people's bags. So let's say in this round I've gotten my bag back. I'm back to the red bag here. The next thing you're going to do is you're going to draw three of the tiles or chips here from the bag. You can keep up to two of these to place on your board and and the rest are going to go onto the main board out here, whatever you don't keep. So, you'll see this on your own player dashboard here because you draw three. You get to choose individually for each one what to do with it. Each of these are going to have two sides. You have the dark side, which is undiscovered, and the light side, which is discovered. The first time it comes out of the bag and is placed out, it always goes on its undiscovered side.
Uh these are also because we're in the ship phase here need to be placed next to the ship. So let's say for the first one I decide to keep it. So I'm going to place it right here. And let's say that I want to keep the second one as well. So I would also keep put it here next to my ship. And then for this last one, I have to put it on the board. So I would look over here and find which quadrant is mine. I am playing as the red player. So I would place it on an empty space in this red section. Each player is going to do this with their three pawns. And then the last thing we do to wrap up this uh ship phase here is reveal a tile that is underneath our ship. So that is now discovered. That wraps up this first ship phase which is played simultaneously. And now we're going to go into the sonar phase in which we're going to go in player order. The first thing we're going to do is we are going to fill in any of these spots on our section of the board here that are um don't have tiles in them here with some of these bonus tiles. So, we would do something like that. Then the second thing is everyone is going to pick up their little sections here and in player order we will claim a section of this board. At the end of this phase, everything does have to be evenly distributed. So, whoever goes last doesn't really have a choice of play of a placement, but the first player has a lot of choice. They can go on any of these lines on the sonar board. And specifically, what you're looking for is tiles that you want or maybe some of these bonus tiles, something like that.
Let's say that I really know that I want to go into bonus tiles this turn. Um, and I like the look of this one. So, I'm going to place it right here. The second player, the blue player can now either place it here or here depending on what they want. And let's say they want to do it right there. So then the white player has no choice here. And again, at the end, this is evenly distributed amongst the players. So that finishes finishes up this sonar phase. We go into the last phase of the round, which is the submersible phase. And this is going to relate to your little token or pawn over here on your board who is going to follow the vertices. Now, the submersible gets four actions, which again are going to be tracked on your individual board right here as you take the four actions. And there are five actions that he I'm sorry, four actions that he can take. He can repeat actions, take them in any order, anything like that. So, one action he can do is he can move up to four vertices. Again, the vertices are going to be these little triangles. And he, let's say that he wants to come over here. So, he'll go one, two, three, four right there and end his movement right there. That would have been one action. So, I would track I've done one action. Uh, another thing that he can do is take a tile from his sonar uh section over here and place it adjacent to where he is. So, again, I'm playing as the red player, so he could take one of these, for example. Maybe he would take this one and place it right there. But let's say that he did not do that because another action that he can do is take all of the bonus tiles that are in his section and claim them to use
later on. Um, this is a one-time use that can be used immediately or any time before the end of the game. In this case, it means you can move a tile on your board to an adjacent space. So, it gives you some flexibility to kind of maximize that scoring. And then the final thing that he can do is he can discover one of these tokens that is next to him. So, for example, let's say that he wants to spend two actions in order to discover this and this. That's going to be important because at the end of the game, only discovered tiles are going to get to score. The final thing we do to wrap up the round is readjust the turn order. The first person goes to the last and everybody moves up. We have now completed a round. We would go to the next round, reset our pawns, and start once again with our ship phase. Once you do this six times, all players are going to look at their board and remove any tokens that are not turned on, any undiscovered tokens. So, in this case, I would remove all of these, and they would not get to contribute towards scoring. And then from there, you're just going to go through the scoring. The four main species are always going to score the same, and that's why it's on this that is used every game. The coral, for example, which are going to be this one here, they want to be in groups together of the same color. And based on that grouping size is how much they're going to score. The fish want to be in school.
So if you have a group of at least six fish together, they will score nine points. The crustaceians are going to want to be adjacent to coral. And the sea cucumber is just going to be depending on the players. Whoever has the most gets 12 points. Second most gets seven and and so on. And then of course depending on the expedition that you're playing, you might have more um scoring opportunities and creatures as well, which which the Leviathan Wilds, I'm sorry, Leviathan Falls comes with two of those as well, which are special tokens and special scoring for this specific scenario. That is going to be it though. every all the players are going to score up all the tokens on their board depending on their scoring abilities and the highest points will win
the I like the theme of the game like I said at the beginning I thought it was a little weird that the ships were
different eras in a sail ship and I'm in a
and in fact I think there's two is this like a deluxe version was two ships for each
yes they give you uh extra copies there's there's extra of a couple of the components I think that's just because why waste the cardboard, you know, if they had the extra space. And so you have double of the ships and then you have double of the round tracker or something like that.
So, two things with the rules I want to mention. The first one is
um I I think the rules could have been clearer on, hey, play with box one
for your first game.
Yeah.
Because I sat there going, oh, we'll open the boxes later, right? And then the rule started explaining it and I said, "Oh, box one is just
the basic game." Not really because you could use any box,
right? You can start anywhere. It's definitely the most basic of them. But I do wish that there was a version, an expedition or something included in the base rules. Like don't make me go here and then over there and then come back to the base rules when I'm trying to learn it. I think that one of them should have just been in the base rules or it said go to expedition one, something like that. very very clear on what to do
and it's not a hard game to understand. Um, and it it works pretty well. But that's the other thing about the rules is
have fun teaching this if you're the teacher in your group because everyone as soon as they get their bag they're going to think it's a bag building game. They're like, "Oh, this is my bag. Am I throwing more tiles in?" No.
Not only you not throwing more tiles in, it ain't your bag,
right? No.
It's your bag for all of one minute and then you pass it.
And it's kind of a weird disconnect because the stuff is in your color,
right? But it's not your color. You're just trying to get and color doesn't even matter for most of the tiles. It only matters for a few of them,
right?
It's fine. It's
It's a little wrap your head around.
This is not how the game works. And once you get it, it's really easy,
right?
It would almost be like if you had a deck of cards you passed around and you drew from them.
It's almost like, well, what's the point of the colors then? And you're like to balance the number of tokens.
There is quality color matters and stuff. Yeah.
At its core, this is a game that is like many, many others where put stuff on a board and how it's put on the board is how you score.
Correct. Yeah. Patterns.
But what makes Fathom different is how you get them.
Um, moving the ship around leads to some really interesting decisions because that ship is where the tiles that you draft can go. Mhm.
But then also that little radar thing which isn't as it's not really radar. It's I'm I'm taking control of a certain quarter and also deciding the first person
what the quarters will be for everybody else.
Kind of setting that pattern.
It's interesting. I like it a lot.
It is that was that was really intriguing. I kind of always looked forward to that spot of like okay where am I going to put these tokens out if I do it over there? Because then if I do that and I'm choosing my my section first. So, if I put it there, then I can get both of those tokens. And so, it was a really interesting balance of when you're going to keep something, why you're going to keep it, leaving spots purposely open on that that shared board so that those bonus tokens come out. A lot of subtly interesting decisions.
And you have the two ships, your main ship and then your little um submersible
which I don't know like that one's moving around. Your other ship's kind of almost warping from space to space, wherever you want it to go. But where each of them is matters. Um, the game itself, it's it's a little odd on how the game is taught and in the rules because I believe the game says some things you shouldn't do simultaneous.
Yes, correct.
But honestly, unless you're playing with a really really hyperfocused person who cares, oh, who has the biggest group of coral? I'm trying to figure out this game could be sped up so much by almost everything could be done simultaneously. I think the only part you don't do simultaneous in the rule book it says is that middle section and in that middle section is you can't do you can't do that simultaneous because that's when you're divvying up the board other than that the first phase and the last phase are both simultaneous which is fantastic
I guess but what I'm saying is people can they can get caught up well I'm not going to do my actions and put out coral
because you have a group there or whatever and if you're going to do this I'll do this and I'm like just don't don't play with
don't even look at other people's boards
but it does make the game go quickly. Although it does also open the door for people cheating, and I don't mean deliberately, but accidentally making mistakes and
no one catching them. But I don't care. I'll take that over
timewise. It makes the game so much faster. And
I'm glad that you have more than one reference card, but um now you have one for two players. That's better. But still give everyone a reference card. Yeah.
How hard is this to do at this point?
Yeah. Everyone has the ones that go on the side of their board, but you don't have the scoring ones. And that's like, yeah, it was so close. So close.
It's better than most because you can put it between the two players on each side of the table, unless you're sitting at a
a card table, then have fun. But
I just don't get it. I really don't understand it. It's not that hard to print out more cards.
And and this is one thing that I thought was interesting, especially the multiple times I've t taught the game. So I'm interested to know what you thought of the actual player board that shows the different phases. I think it's fantastic that it shows the phases, but it's one of the few times I'm gonna say like it was a little bit much.
Oh.
Where it's like, oh, I make one decision and another like I have three tokens I have to make a decision on, so therefore I have three spots I'm supposed to go down.
I it's it's therefore thematic flare. I think
I think so. And and kudos. I would rather you air on that side. Yes. You know, give me too many spots that I'm not going to use. And and I will say the final phase where you have the four actions your submersible can do. That is helpful because if you do one and then you take it back or something like that, it's good for sequencing to kind of keep track. But I used it maybe like twice in the game. We all just got
taking the tiles part. I'm like I'll do these three. Hang on. I'll take one now. I will take two.
Yeah.
And the bonus tiles are nice. Uh that's one of my complaints about the game. I think there is in the first game of this I played I feel like I won because of luck
because it was a close game.
Okay.
And I just guessed that
the underwater token.
Oh,
and it was worth four points and not minus two or whatever. That's a big swing and I definitely won by that little. That being said, if that bothers you and it didn't bother me a lot. It was just like a small thing. the box two.
They're they're not as different. They're all worthwhile getting. So, it doesn't matter. But I the bonus tokens
I thought some of them are clearly better than others.
And I would like to see a variant possibly of them being face up.
Oh,
when you're sonaring.
Okay. Interesting.
Because then that would affect where I go because I might go there's a bonus tile there. I don't know if I want to take it or not because it might be great, it might not. But if I knew what it was, I might take it more.
And unless you go hard into that strategy, which I don't think it'd be a winning strategy because the points are kind of low. Um, unless you go hard into it, you're probably not going to explore all four of them. So, it really does come down to luck. If I got, you know, the the high scoring,
right? Well, if you do find the good one first, and this is again box one, then you're done. It's a really good luck thing. Yes, you can find the bonus tokens that let you look for them,
but that also has to let come out. And so, right, I could see that it does it does have that feel of of fishing, right, where you're like, let's cast right here and see what happens.
I want to be clear, though, that's very minor for me.
I like this game. I think it does a lot of interesting things. I think this genre of putting stuff on the board and scoring, I'm I'm really over it. Um, but this brought me back in because I like the sonar. I liked the movement of the boats, and that felt unique and different. And the theme, I'm a sucker for this theme, so count that in. know that if it's a C theme, I'm going to like a little better. So, this is 7.5. Very enjoyable game. Good components, easy to play, and fast.
Nice. I'm really similar. I'm at an eight on this. I was charmed. I I went in with pretty low expectations. Picked it up because I was going snorkeling one weekend and so needed a box of, you know, ocean themed games to take with me and took it, taught it uh from the rule book, really easy teach, and was just charmed the more and more I played. Um, I enjoy the variability between the four boxes that I think that they do stand unique in how they play and the goals of them, but it's not like you're learning a whole new game either. I don't think it increases the weight of the game, and I think that's a hard thing to do as a designer. So, I was really impressed with the four different boxes. I'd love to see additional boxes. Um, and I think it's a a good balance of simultaneous play to keep the turns quick and keep the game moving, but interaction on that main sonar board, sonar board, uh, you know, divvying it out that it kept it feeling like a group game and not multiplayer solitire. So, for me, it's an eight.
Well, there you go, folks. That is Fathom. Check it out. I'm Tom.
And I'm Camila.
And we're going Well, she's going snorkeling. I'm I'm gonna go I'll stay in the boat. Hey folks, thanks for watching another one of our videos. If you like our videos, if you like our channel, you would love to game with us at one of our conventions. Check out Dice Tower Cruise, Dice Tower East, and Dice Tower West. Fantastic conventions where we play games with wonderful people, a humongous library, and lots of other events and stuff. Also, don't forget to check out our channel, like and subscribe. I'm Tom Bassel.