Philosophia: Floating World - Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for philosophia floating world uh which was a game that i had backed on kickstarter uh basically just off theme alone like i i am i wouldn't say obsessed but i really love feudal feudal japan eras and i was like sure that that art looks pretty amazing i'll buy this off of that and this is one of those very few times that whenever you kind of blindly um back or buy something that it it pans out this game is fantastic it's pretty good i i thoroughly enjoy it um because we were talking about innovation earlier today especially with deck building and this is one of the most innovative deck builders i've played uh there is so much that goes around that it it has an edge of darkness feel just because your deck is not dictated by just you basically solo building your own deck your opponents have so much actual control over what you are allowed to do and i think that's extremely fascinating because you want to build in a way that's obviously when you deck build your building in a in a in a way that makes it to where okay obviously this is going to pop off at some point but in this one i feel like you're kind of building for what you're going to end up giving your to your opponent right
what i was trying to do was trying to make your hand your deck so juicy that it made the decisions that much harder yeah i mean that's kind of what you're doing you you want to have as many of those search actions as you can so maybe you'll get two in your same hand and then it kind of messes with the decision making and stuff yeah because what you do is each card well not each card but most cards have a collection uh which is what your opponent collects no matter what and then the actions that you're available so whenever my thought was okay uh the locations were fantastic as well because it's like oh free move like i had a free move that i then started to go with the search ones because i was like okay i'll just go place the place like grand i was on the opposite side of japan the entire time so it wasn't gonna end up happening anyway uh but just having the free abilities to be able to uh kind of mitigate how you're going to build your deck is also why i went for kind of burning a little bit more like i burned three cards uh which doesn't sound like a lot but i mean those are actions that you're taking away from yourself as well as potential um uh resources you're gonna spend so i was trying to build in a way that no matter what i gave you you were gonna have a hard time right now disguising the crux of the system but at the same time it also kind of burned because i
i was limited on resources the entire game like i had to there were times where i had to take a certain hand because it gave me resources and i was like oh like it was getting it was getting pretty crooks down towards the end um brad what do you think of the game well if you know anything about me feudal japan is probably one of my least favorite themes in it um but this one i enjoyed because i you know like i i like deck building and this threw something new in it you know with with the opponent choosing the piles and all that stuff i don't know if i don't think i've ever seen anything like that before necessarily that i don't need that i mean i'm sure there's something out there but but uh having those decisions and you know the board is small so it kind of it has that hidden move not hidden movement but hidden location yeah aspect to it as well yeah um it it they were able to jam pack a bunch of decisions and game without blind you know kickstarters a lot of times are just this is the whole thing yeah this is all surface levels this was not bloat no like there seemed to be like you know the decks aren't oversized they they're you know uh the monster decks not punishing so if you just try for it for that one you just have to have the stuff it's not like you have to spend the stuff even if you fail yeah and stuff like that um yeah yeah there's just a lot of stuff i you know going into the stuff i like
that they have the your uh winning conditions are flat right here in front of you telling you how to win the game all the icons are on here pretty self-explanatory it was a quick learn really yeah yeah it was it was pretty simple it looks busy because the the rule book is a lot of tiny text and so you look at it and you're just like oh god but no it's it's very straightforward the icons immediately make sense um there's a couple things that i don't think are bad like i wouldn't necessarily call them negatives but i do think they're weird and one of them you mentioned the monster deck so it is nice that it's not punishing um for uh like because you have to you just blindly draw and you're like oh i happen to have the stuff for it so you kind of do prep you you shop for a little bit getting the the ingredients uh and then hopefully hopefully you have the time and the money to be able to kill it and but at the same time which is so that's a positive is that you just can't you just have to move there you draw and then it's like oh okay i killed it or i didn't and then you just put it to the bottom of the deck you keep playing what's weird is once you do that once you get lucky essentially and kill it then this deck becomes obsolete and they're so i mean i mean going forward the art for this game is just absolutely you know stunning like for for everything for it all the cards full full tarot size cards of art it's it's gorgeous um but it's like in the two-player game especially the
the deck this becomes completely useless shopping kind of becomes lame because oh i killed the monster i don't need any of those yeah cause i reset that store four or five times that game just to try to get icon like the icons to be able to do that stuff and everything yeah it feels a lot more mechanical about that and because you don't get anything for killing a monster except a token which is one of the victory conditions so that part feels more mechanical than thematic and i would have liked it if they there could have been a couple like there's a couple things i think i would have enjoyed potentially a little bit more and i think once again they went for simplicity over um complexity so one of the things is i feel like if they wanted to be punishing there's two ways one there could have been ways for you like you get to um like maybe maybe an action or maybe a uh card ability that lets you peek uh but i think what would have been nice is if you go out to fight and you're like you oh it's the cloud dragon and it's you know a yumi and a shuriken and a coin let's say you didn't have the yumi you did have to spend that yeah and because you you still did fight it but you just failed you don't because then that would allow you to still want to go shopping right you know what i'm saying um i don't know if that would actually be bad in practice like it might be annoying since it is random you spend your time to move down here and you're just like
oh and then oh i just bought the you know shuriken and i just lost it another thing they could have done with it is to keep that deck relevant yeah is to have like like those icons on there so like to beat them you may get a symbol yeah you know and then you just like so like you're still or you get like a passive ability some sort of ability something benefit for that card that keeps you wanting to go back and fight them you know because that's the easiest one in my opinion that's the easiest one to complete yeah of the of the four things yeah i mean you just go you just buy stuff have time and money and just dive in see what happens yeah that's the first thing we both got exactly and yeah once you do it this is like oh okay i guess that's that yeah you have to kind of go out to a monster spot and do it and spend an action but it's just an action you just have to draw it and be like oh great i have a katana and uh yep and okay i guess that's dead and don't need these anymore uh which is a shame because i like looking at these the the art is just so like the variety for it and they have like the the artist of who drew this like the traditional japanese art it's so fantastic that it would have been cool if those monsters yeah gave you something like like the locations these location cards that have the continuous effect yeah if these all had a continuous effect now one thing two player game versus six players games yeah those spots are going to be taken up a lot of time and
you're not going to be yeah you know because we stayed in those spots for a little bit until we were able to beat them so that's to block people out yeah you know in a two-player game we could just sit there because we weren't really yeah the spots weren't contested that's true yeah i think that's probably what it is in a four or five yeah a multiplayer game um which is on the back of this board i don't believe there is um i'd have to look at the i don't want to flip the board well they're only showing the two-player game on the so uh yeah we've only ever played this at two which once again it's which brings me to the next thing that's unique about this game it's entirely simultaneous yeah uh what do you think of that um i would not have liked it at all except for having this up here having the person be able to be like yeah and then they go down the tracks right next time because that almost becomes a strategy too it's like you know if i know for a fact you're going for that deal i'll be like yeah i'm gonna go for it too and then you'll be like oh nope that's i'm trumping you and then yeah the next choice yeah it's so frustrating because it's like i need that and it's like nope i have the initiative it's like so as much as i dislike real time games yeah having that and be able to you know keep it plus there's no down time in the game obviously there's no down time because you're except for when we're shuffling you're waiting on me to make it right i'm just like all right i know i'm not drawing any cards i guess we'll shuffle back but but uh as far as the real time stuff of all that
buying and doing the actions and stuff this part is what saved it for me yeah from not liking it because if that wasn't there it would be first come first of all oh no i'm gonna grab that and come faster than you and i would it's a card right then i would not like it at all but no i i completely i completely agree it's kind of like it it and it doesn't slow the game down it's not like oh we have to do this whole ordeal to try and decide who who breaks a tie it's that's the rising sun idea that's like an honor thing where it's like i'm higher than you i get to i get priority right and then okay now next time i'll get priority but there's also ways to mitigate that there's you know item cards that allow you to uh to go off the top of that which is interesting um because everything so that was that was my one weird thing it's not bad it is simple and in a multiplayer game i'd have to see the other side of the board because i can't remember is if there's more monster spots if there's more monster spots um but yeah this is this is a one to three player game so in a three player game someone is uh is trying to get in and fight it uh or i mean that's the double-edged sword if we're trying to fight and then the three-player game or even this one's like i don't feel like fighting i'm not gonna worry about the item deck i'm just going to go search i'm going to go run around and keep building and yeah and fine yep and find your location and then be like great okay now i only need two of those which is huge because getting four of them it's not like you need to find the location and get and get three you you have the objectives
it's almost like you know a game we played earlier wasn't tested as much yeah it's like they really put the time in on this one and the focus that is on like the board can be minimal yeah because the focus is on the cards yeah you know something they put a lot of work in this game you could tell i mean there's not besides the art it's very obvious that they put effort into it but yeah right but i'm just meaning just like like that all that all the game is here except for you're kind of just big moving around and stuff on that that's why the board's so it's really just an organizer honestly right right um like there's a little bit of deduction for because there's ways that you can just start revealing locations which is good for you and for the other players and it's like whenever you move down here and then you were because you were in um osaka yeah and then you were kind of like because you could have came down here you're like can i go around and i'm like yeah the only reason you can well the only reason i didn't go down there is because i was wanting to find a place where i could build a i would build a shrine shrine and you would already built one down there yeah so i was like well i don't need to go there because that's where i keep that shine there i'm like man because when you ask that i'm like oh absolutely because i happen to get both of mine you're you're uh what was it thule yeah you you got tuli and kiroshima and i'm like man each time we've played this my secret location has been right where i started yeah because they also have a few variants they have the teapot variant in the multiplayer game which is you give it to the person who least wants it and that person turns it left or right and that's how you rotate the
cards because in that two-player game we're only handing each other our cards but it determines the the draft order very small variant yeah um the variant for the unique players is of course the special abilities which are a little bit different little bits different starting items and then your player board which gives you kind of a little bit more of a goal uh like whenever i with the mountain and river of the kiso road uh each time i buy a snow i get a coin so all the variants to play this game this game is just so clean yeah like there's no weirdness now there is actually a negative i do have which is and there's ways to mitigate it which makes it less of like a i really don't like it and more of just an annoyance is the wisdom deck which is because you need certain wisdom icons to do certain actions which are victory conditions like the like the building the shinto shrines is oh i need shinto cards okay there's one there and okay you got it first so then you take it and then none come out and or one it's like oh nope this is the first one and that one's there and it's like why can't i just take that well that's why i was curious because with them both being on the table i was like surely yeah that's like that's why i was looking i was like is there like a money thing there or you know or you have to nope it's essentially it's another way you would have to build you would have to build to where you can study multiple times because you can only hold four wisdom cards so you so you okay i'm gonna study twice i'm gonna take that
one and then take the shinto shrine or if you pay to wipe it out and put new ones out right see if you get lucky right which is why having these free location actions were awesome because it's like okay you took the shrine i wanted great okay well i'll save my time and not do that action because i got a free one to clean it and hope i get lucky that's probably one of the only besides the monster deck being really just all about kind of luck um that was the only one that really kind of affected it because it was like man i just can't get a freaking shrine so i can't build because two of those winning conditions rely on getting those icons um the chia uh one or the chow one go to getting those true deals um but once again those are all icons but it kind of reminds me of tang garden where it has the icons and then the full art but uh this is just a lot better in every way it's just yeah like i was thinking at first oh having to pass cards around um i'm like i don't know if i would want to play this with more people but it would be pretty chaotic trying to do everything all at once it's it works really well with simultaneous play at two but i don't know how like imagine that at four like you'd have to you'd consciously unite you would always be on that so then it's like at that point might as well just do the turn by turn yeah uh because there's no there's no funkiness of three people trying to go for one card it's like i'm ahead of you so i get to take it i go to the bottom oh now we gotta
repel and [ __ ] and then it's all now yeah it becomes all weird i almost think that this would just be better with two yeah this engine or three but two most likely just because uh if there's the same amount of locations which i think there are on the other side no there's uh four more or five yeah there's more of these yeah there's six more locations i get taken out and a one to three player game gotcha i was just curious because i was like they're gonna get discovered so fast i mean if that's one of the winning conditions you have two people get it and then there's you have four four five six people on the board yeah you know finding that yeah there's seven more finding somebody's location would be easier it's a little higher but maybe not because that's assuming that someone's gonna run wild with the search cards and that's not the case because now that's more people trying to draft for those as well as because the biggest thing is not so much hey here's you know six cards divide them into piles which i love um it's also oh thank you for your six nope you're not gonna search uh well so discard that one but there were times whenever you were like handing me and it's like i don't want you to search because i knew you were right there i was like i can't allow him to search but then you'd get the ones that let you use your entire hand right but i was like but then you get to organize and it's like okay he could search but he doesn't get any movement so i'll make him make that decision does he want to move or does he want to search it's it's brilliant it's such a unique way of deck building
in a gorgeous game in a very simplistic but deep strategy which is what i love like you don't have to make your game complex to give it a lot of like layers that's why i was saying the cards are the focus like you know they do a lot with these cards even more than what that because you have to make the decisions on the cards and how you use the cards everything's cards yeah and that's the all your actions are dictated like you have some freedom with your player board but then as you start completing more objectives it becomes harder for you to do it so like it's like if you don't do the monster one and you cover up your shop and you're like oh i need to try and kill a monster but i haven't uh i haven't like gotten any items crap now i need to start buy cards that let me shop it's so good so question like so this one was always covering up this that is always covered always no matter what okay because it has the action yeah that was like i think that's just to be an icon for your uh secret secret location gotcha um there is yeah in in the future you can like your your decoy you can move it uh around um but that's also the okay if you find it they get that token which since i found it it makes it it makes my player board actions a lot harder so right um so if you're actually building two search and you happen to find it well now you're going to have a limited time on trying to do the other actions yeah because it was close like it was
all you needed was one way to just move there and search and you would have found it and then uh the tiebreaker is um highest on the influence track which would have been me in this case because there's no type tying there you had so much money i know it's so much money it's like i was just trying to find something that would help you know and i did buy some things yeah you know that were search things and everything they're in here yeah i just yeah i mean you know as well as i do it comes down you gotta burn through you gotta get rid of those cards uh because when you because you bought like two search cards and i was like well his deck is still pretty big he's not not going to get to those for a while uh so i was pretty lucky in that regard it's it's so good like and i just think the art enhances i cannot talk up this art enough and what's also great is if you're not moving a lot but you can shop i'll just get two coins to get a boat okay and then now i'm gonna fly a ship all the way you know ship all the way down there and search there why not it's like oh hey i found it and then you go till the end of the round because you can tie it's it's so good i think uh the the monsters i just wish did more because i mean they're so neat they just i mean really this this the monsters almost feel like tacked on it almost feels like they really just wanted to showcase the art and they're like well how can we put this in the game okay we'll just make
some random random items and then they'll be useless after afterwards because you don't attack each other you don't ever fight more monsters uh i don't know it's just it's weird it that that part is is extremely weird i'd be curious what they do in the previous version of this game the what was that their date to the wise yeah like like if it's just the same same setup different stuff and if they have it something that does something similar to that that's nice i think that's greek mythology right so you know i would just be curious like how uh how they change it's the same game just with different theme put on it yeah different stuff or yeah we'll have to check that out it came out two years prior it was 2019 i believe okay so that one so and i never heard of them i i just oh okay yeah this is fuel japan i'll just pick this up uh and it just worked out when we were first learning the game and i was like reading about oh you hand your opponent your cards i was like do you share cards like i thought it was initially like i hand you six you take one and put in your own disco pile and i'm like i was very hesitant when you were talking about all that because but it's it worked out it's like i don't want people to build my deck i don't want to steal cards from someone else yeah but it wasn't like that at all stacking my huge yeah you feel wealthy i mean as a ronin that's just kind of who you are yeah and the miniatures they they are what they are they're serviceable yeah they're kind of there i mean i'll take
these these could be painted there's only six of them but other than that i i don't really have a whole lot yeah uh all right on a scale of one to ten what would you what would you give this and actually you have 45 minutes to 120 minutes that simultaneous worked pretty well in a two-player game you haven't tried it with more so it would be interesting to see if it's clean or if it's a clunky mess uh it depends what you're playing with that's also true yeah um i liked it for sure um going into it i wasn't sure like i said it had been a good game to get me to like it because i don't like the theme right um and uh it's a good innovative deck builder but a lot of new things to the table um i want to really see what the solo variant plays like i'm not taking that into account with this obviously right but um i would probably give it a good solid eight eight good solid eight cool yeah yeah yeah that's that's a good that's a good score i am gonna go higher than i'm gonna give it a nine um i think for game play i would give it an eight i'd agree with you but the art i love the theme and the art is fantastic so that's gonna bump up that's what i was going to say if if it if it was a different like if it was some sort of other theme like maybe maybe mythology like it's it would be a nine if i like the theme yeah that's that's it yeah cause they did it wasn't like some weird like yeah like you said they give it to a bunch of different artists and have them do their interpretation because i looked up at least for the monsters it
says like their names udogawa kuniyoshi um and he's on here actually quite a bit but i was like oh is that an actual artist and yeah it was one of the artists from this time period so i think they put a lot of effort into it the the wisdom cards with the with the quotes and then also like the the ones with the text on them that just tell you like lore i think they really put their their heart and soul into making sure this game wasn't um some pasted on piece of [ __ ] so i gotta give them props for that and it's a solid innovative deck builder because like we said earlier deck builders aren't something that are my go-to especially pure ones because it's like you just i feel like you go through the motions and this one every single time i was handing cards to you and i was because i was excited to see what i was getting from you it was like oh you're constantly thinking and making decisions for other players and once you get yours then you're once again thinking and making decisions to try and quickly just go through a streamlined game that if this game was like two hours i think it would overstay its welcome yeah but at about an hour it it's so solid well something else really quick on these cards when we were getting these location cards i like that they because a lot of times in deck builders their currency cards or their actions you get to do both you get to collect on those cards and they have an action so you have to pay attention to both both of them yeah because it's like ooh i need more time but ah that action is not great i don't want to burn any more cards like a game we played prior you know it was like you either spin it
for the money or you take the action yeah this is you collect and do so that was another thing it just makes the cards that much more of a focus again yeah exactly all right so that's our thoughts on philosophia floating world let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you