Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 22:29

Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and Dev and I are doing a discussion over React, the art of war. This is a onev1 style uh fighting game,

something that you and I are relatively familiar with. real well accustomed to.

We've uh we've it's either I mean we we have we dipped our toes a little bit. There's this one, there's war chest. Yeah. Yeah. Especially me. Uh War Chess, there's of course Exceed and Battle Con and you know, a lot of these kind of skirmish style games, Summoner Wars, which I know you don't care for, but um I'm drawn to these kinds of games. Yeah, I I really Well, funny enough, I say I'm drawn to them, but it's always hit or miss whether or not they're going to be good. But I always want to give them a shot. I guess Cloud Spire is kind of technically skirmish one v one is always within that same kind of a kind of wheelhouse.

Yeah. That gentleman's game,

right?

One man versus another

with only that width between them

that if you make one mistake, IT'S LIKE I'M THE DUMBEST.

I'm the dumbest.

It's like, do you mind if I walk that back? No.

It's like it was your own reaction. like you you set up the thing. So, it's like no. Um I know it always feels bad to be like no, I'm not going to let you walk that back. That benefits you greatly [snorts] when you played both your own cards. Um but this one I Well, so this guy uh and this team, Brother Ming, they have another game that I was interested in that I ended up backing that is also 1v one style game, but it uses marbles. So, you have like this this tray of marbles that come out and it's kind of like Candy Crush a little bit, you know, where you're trying to make patterns and that's how you trigger Yeah.

your stuff. It looked fun and gimmicky, but then I knew he made this one

and I was like, "Okay, cool." So, I bought it

and uh you know, without knowing anything about it and that was my downfall was I watched no gameplay and this was here's how you knew I should have done that first. So to learn this game so we could play it, I watched, you know, how to play and I watched the playthrough of it.

And while I was watching the playthrough, I was like, I don't think I'm going to like this game.

Okay.

And that that rang true, unfortunately.

Um, it's not the worst one. I think I'd probably rather Man, actually, I was going to say I'd probably rather play this over Exceed, but Exceed is faster.

Yeah. I I don't hate exceeded.

I don't like

am I do I like enough to buy it all myself? No.

Um I don't like top decking. So, you know, games where you win by top decking. I don't enjoy games like that. It's why I also don't play Magic anymore because it's like, man, I wish my deck would pop off. Oh, no. More land. That's cool. Uh just something about I like one v one v one games where you have [snorts] a good amount of information or they are short.

Yeah.

And uh this game is unfortunately not short enough to justify its simplicity.

I mean yeah certainly in our experience it it ran a little long. Yeah. Um

let's see here. A little different from the others. Quite a bit more of an expanded field. Yeah. Um because I mean this has the same amount of length as like our games of BattleCon.

Yeah.

Like averaged around an hour and that's what I've seen from every playthrough of this game. Averages around an hour. And if anyone says no, no, this game you could play it in 20 minutes. No, the designers can play it in 20 minutes. They know all the characters.

Yeah. They know every single character to a tea. And and and that probably is true. You could say that about any game though. I [ __ ] hate that argument of like, no, I can get this game played in an hour. Is it the only game you own, right? And is it the only game you play? Then yeah. But unfortunately, this is not the only game I own and it's not going to be [clears throat] a game I want to get that into. Hell, I mean, yeah, we could probably speed blitz games of BattleC. And we've definitely had

just make it full like intense uh like chess out like hit the timer and just like, okay, so you only get like a few seconds to think,

you play your and then that might be entertaining,

right? And we've definitely had games of Alakon that lasted 20 minutes. It's usually one of us getting blown out where it's like I'm just I'm I'm I'm mashing buttons. I'm panicking. Um you got a combo going on. You are uh you just having your way with me.

Um but I do enjoy games that have

I initially enjoy games that have a ton of asymmetry,

but this one I feel like just has the bones are there. It just doesn't have the staying power. It doesn't have the pizzazz.

Yeah.

It It just feels like Yes, the characters are asymmetric,

but almost in feel, not necessarily in wow, I'm playing a completely different game than you. Um like this character, it's not like root asymmetry or hell even battle asymmetry where it's like here's this whole gimmick.

Yeah, they do play a little bit different, but the game unfortunately is so simple that it it just doesn't it it's just not fun.

Yeah. I mean yeah like what was it to touch on your simplicity what will you clarify that the decks

the decks are there are only four cards and

now there might be a different combination like some some characters have two intentions and two reactions. Um the the big variety between the characters are their innate intentions or their innate reactions. Like some characters, both of the characters we just played, the tattooist and the sculptor, they

um but their masterpiece things are both passives, kind of like pop off abilities,

right?

But there are other characters who actually have an intention or reaction. Like I know the calligrapher, she has a reaction where she can kind of like, you know, kind of do the the sculptor blow up like, hey, I'm just gonna now be able to all my ink deals damage, stuff like that.

So it bait

eat it. So I think that was originally whenever I had, you know, actually done research on the game. And that's also not necessarily the game's fault. That's my own fault for not doing research ahead of time. Um, but once I had heard, oh, the decks are four cards.

Yeah.

So, it's just you're just shuffling a 30 card deck with four of the same cards in it.

That's not all that exciting.

I mean, it works,

but it gets very tedious.

Yeah. I mean, it's also reducing, you know, the amount of randomness that, you know,

um, but yeah, but one thing like in the game's favor [clears throat] I did like

[snorts]

um is that I mean eventually like as we're playing through one round, we do kind of learn each other's characters pretty quickly and kind of understand our whole kit,

right?

Pretty quick. Yeah, it I mean I would definitely say if someone is trying to get into a game like this, uh this is not a terrible starting spot because again you're not going to be overwhelmed by either the the multitude of steps that Battle has or you know even exceed you have your staple cards that every deck has, but then there's like probably 20 or so cards that are unique to that fighter.

And there was no like, you know, hinge rules that we just kind of had to stumble upon. Everything was pretty well explained all

everything's clean. I initially whenever you're reading the cards you're like what is this weird wording where it's as if the character is explaining hey I do this like I do this from here and you're like that's odd but then it kind of just is intuitive

right

which is kind of cool.

Um

and yeah it doesn't overwhelm you with keywords. It doesn't have a lot of stuff that bogs you down on I bring in a summon. It has summoning sickness. Um,

one thing I do really like is the fact that every player's draw phase, both players draw. So, you always have a chance to be able to draw into something. If you're out of cards, Yeah. that's a hindrance, but in just by the time it gets back to you, you're going to have two cards.

Yeah.

So, you almost kind of always have at least two cards. It still has the RNG element. Uh where because with the reaction and the intentions, it's like sometimes you could still get hosed if you don't draw any intentions. You are limited by what your innate intentions are, which might just be nothing.

But then if you only draw intentions, then you just can't react to anything,

right? But then you get a big fat turn.

I mean, you survive.

Yeah. you get you also get a single like okay boom I'mma pop this one intention down pop this one intention down um I think the game shines when the react system is actually going off

uh but then that's going to boil down to for anyone who plays Magic if you like the stack rule right

you know last in first out

and that can be it is interesting to build a game around that I'm curious what you think of the re like the react system

yeah it takes some getting used to, but it's not too bad. I mean, once you're like planning, it's like I what I mean, cuz the game's so straightforward. I I mean, it's like, okay, I see you have two cards. It's like I see what you've been doing. I know you can dodge out of the way, so I'm like I want to kind of milk out

what effects you have. So, like, I'll lead off with kind of like a [ __ ] intention.

Um, uh, see if you spawn out a few other You waste a few, try and get out of the way, and then I hit it with the primary. uh down the line. Anyway, but yeah, it's um

yeah,

interesting.

It boils down again to if you like the stack rule and for the so like

in this game um that's something to take into consideration because if you are wanting to do something, I'm going to attack I'm going to attack an adjacent zone. Okay, that's what I'm intending to do. Do you react? Uh yes, I'm going to move. Okay, I guess you will just do that. Even if you

do that

even if you have a lot of reactions in your own hand, which is a nice thing. You can react to your own thing

and you're trying to combo.

Um there are some moments where you have to play backwards.

Be like, "Okay, first I need to play my attack card. You know, I need to play whatever. I'm going to play my tattooist. She can move one space and then you're not going to react. Okay, I'm gonna play this react card that lets me attack.

And then it's like, okay, well, I'm not attacking. And then you pass and then, oh, now I'm going to play all my move cards so I can move move and then do my attack.

It's just it's weird. Um, and again, this is perfectly fine until where it bleeds into this game is overstayed its welcome and now it's annoying.

Right now we're just kind of dancing back and forth. I have my minefield. You have your soldiers. Yeah, [clears throat] and that's like I mean, hell, that's even the stack rule is perfectly fine. I have no issues with it until a game of Commander lasts an hour and I'm like, just [ __ ] someone just lose, please. Like, I'm so over it. And that yeah, that's just more of a a personal thing that I've definitely noticed, especially with these kinds of games where if it's now a competitive game and I'm not invested the whole because I just played like a three-hour Euro game just the other day. No issues with it whatsoever. So length of the game is not necessarily a problem. It's am I invested the whole time and this game just did not have enough to keep me invested

to justify the systems that it's bringing. Um, I brought up before we started recording, I brought up Unmatched, which is a game that I specifically remember. You might not remember it all that much, but I specifically remember us not caring for it at the time. And my same issues were like the deck's too random, yada yada yada. And then I picked it all up again a few years later. I have everything for it. And it's [clears throat] it's a [ __ ] blast. because yeah, the deck is random still, but you might, you know, if you're being attacked, you might not have any defense cards, but you have a lot of versatile cards in it. So, chances are you're going to draw into some. And even then, even if you get your ass beat, that that game does last 30 minutes, right?

So,

and it is it does feel asymmetric. So, there's [clears throat] other games of this type that balance its randomness with its length of game,

right? Um, [snorts] I I mean I'm just overall like so I mean that's the basically the the system. The masterpiece. What do you think of the masterpiece thing?

The masterp I mean for our characters was fairly just like oh okay you kind of get a freebie um like power up like I just got to [ __ ] out a big buddy anywhere I wanted.

Right.

Um and then you got to what? Power up all your rabbits and bring them back.

Pretty much. I got to bring them all back and then I got to put the tattoo on them.

Yeah. So, I mean,

but um

Yeah, I guess just kind of like a timer thing. Another thing to kind of think about, but [clears throat]

did you need to stress about it? Not terribly.

No, I mean

I it it almost it feels like it's a afterthought

of like, oh, well, all these games they usually have a like a super like a uh you know, their ultimate is up. Yeah. I got to add that in this game, but how can I make it different

rather it just being like a

cuz they're all artist themed. So like, oh, you're building your masterpiece.

It's a definitely a cute twist on the idea of a super.

Uh and and the masterpiece also tracks your health. Uh so, and that's the weird thing is this game only lasts until you get hit three times. But the problem that I noticed with that is in my mind I'm thinking, okay, I don't want this game to last that long. Three hits and then the game's over.

Well, because you have such limited health, you are very reserved. It's like, I don't want to get hit. I only have three health, so I'm going to play defensive. Everyone's playing that way,

right?

Whereas if you have 20 health, ah, [ __ ] it. We can trade. You know, I'll be a little bit more aggressive. You don't you can't really do that in here unless you really do have kind of a combo which you can absolutely combo off. I mean uh like you know if I don't have a way to move my rabbits out and you do the explosion thing then boom boom you hit both of them that's two damage.

Yeah. I mean that's really all you can do is kind of gamble um with how many cards they have in their hand. It's like they have none. It's like okay I can go all in.

Um they got a handful of cards like I'm not going to touch them. But like with you I'm like you had a handful of cards like I dodge swap. I'm going to do all this. But then that kind of boils down to all right. Well, that's not necessarily fun in a fighting game where it's like I'm just That'd be like if you and I were actually squaring off and we're just waiting for the first person to throw the first. It's like and we do that for 20 minutes.

Everyone around like hit someone already.

Someone comes up, hits me with a bottle and it's like kicking you.

Yeah.

Yeah. So, it's it's like it it this game feels like it wants to be a quick game. Mhm.

Like a quick, fast, snappy game, but then puts a lot of rails, you know, barriers in your way to not really make it that way.

Um I mean, and I know they have the timer system, so it that also is like, man, I'm running low on cards. I better start trying to. But I mean, it's a 30 card deck. You don't necessarily if you don't have ways to draw yourself, you're drawing one card every turn, right? So it it takes a bit to deck out and it's not like there's a mill out person.

Yeah. It's like your main components are what's in front of you.

Yeah.

What you have to to kind of run off of.

So it's a weird situation because it's like I I definitely see what you're saying. I like that there's I like and don't like that there's four cards

cuz it it does reduce the RNG while still being there a little bit because it's a deck. What are you going to do?

Right.

Um

but I also find it just way too simplistic to be that enjoyable. The fun for this game feels like, oh, I'm gonna see how all the characters play and then you immediately see how they play. Okay, there's not really a whole lot of depth here anymore.

It's kind of like Sea of Thieves, you know, where it's like everything's surface, you know, the video game Sea of Thieves. You're like, man, this is beautiful. Like, and then you realize it's all surface level. You dive into the ocean and realize it's an empty empty.

You have a horror panic attack.

Yeah. Oh, dude. God. Yeah. That game is like, man, this is the best water I've ever seen in a video game. And then I remember on the beta for that game, I jumped off the mast of the ship during a storm and you know that green kind and I was like I need to get out of here. Like I I'm I'm having a meltdown.

It's where we play raft. It's like get me out of the water.

So I don't know. This game's not bad.

Yeah.

It's just overstays a little bit. A little too long.

Little too long.

Little movie chess chess checkery in a way.

Yeah. And it's unfortunately, I think, in a genre that I can point to better games. You know, if you want a chessy style game, I mean, if you want a grid-based, you know, 1v one game, I would highly I I think Summoner Wars is an absolute blast. Um,

but if you want a fe a kind of a chess style game, War Chest,

yeah,

has that. And then if you want a asymmetric skirmish style game, I mean, I don't personally like Exceed, but a lot of people do. exceed or unmatched.

And then if you want a really sweaty game, Battleground.

So there's just a ton in this game. [clears throat] You know what's the novelty

of this game?

And yeah, the big thing is the react system

and it it it's a good idea. I think it's it's like, man, that is different even though it's literally pulled from magic. But I think I realized, oh wait, in a fighting game, I would like to do what I want to do.

Um, but that's that's kind of it. I mean, yeah.

So, you got anything else?

Nope.

All right. Oh, and then I mean, one thing that is cool I should mention is I because I I don't see this enough in in these kinds of games. For all the characters, they have a play style card.

Mhm. you know, with all their well, it says their components, but it also says the play style. And I think that's very nice for it to tell you, hey, here's kind of how this character works,

right?

Um, use

what you should be setting up, what you need to try for. [clears throat]

This card, uh, you know, use this card to get your, you know, I'm just using tattoos cuz that's who I played recently. Use this card to get your tattoos out of harm's way. You want to put tattoos tokens on them so that all the tattoos can kind of be variable. It's not just the blue one that can only do the blue tattoo,

stuff like that. So, I mean, it is very nice for people who are not familiar with this and they just pick, "Oh, I want to play the DJ." And he's like, "Complexity 5 or difficulty five," which again, I don't really see what the difference is between difficulty and complexity. Those seem like synonyms to me or like, "Okay, like cuz I don't even know how I'd begin to explain that to someone. Okay, this character is pretty difficult to play. It's a four out of five, but he's also complex. Yeah.

Yeah, I got that.

And complex.

Sure, someone's going to be in the comments. You [ __ ] idiot. Difficulty means that Webster's Americ says like [ __ ] kill yourself. Uh, so, but I do want to give credit where credit's due. I like how it tells you what the play style

what the play style is.

Um, yeah. So,

on a scale of 1 to 10, what would you give React?

Better than every game you mentioned.

One of them. Um,

uh, I'll give it a six.

A six.

Six.5. Slightly above average. You loved it.

It was my favorite thing. [snorts]

You gave the Lands of Evershade a five. No kidding. You gave

I think I gave it like close a 10 when I first played it, right? until it was like, "Oh, this is all AI."

I love when I sometimes remember what scores you give and then I'm like, "Devon, you gave this game you bitched about a like a seven."

I give it I usually give him a safe bet. It's like I mean it's above average.

What if I told you this game was $200?

Mhm.

It was not $200. I think it was a hundred though.

Yeah.

Um I'm I mean to be fair, I'm actually not that far off. I'm going to get I'm going to give it a five. I think it's it's serviceable in certain areas but lacks in others. So that kind of meets it right in the middle. Um while the characters that I have played and seen played they are technically different from one another. They are not at least wholly asymmetric enough like enough for for me to to [snorts] enjoy. Um so yeah I will put this right at a five. Um oh dude [clears throat] we forgot to read the the lore book with all the characters backtories [clears throat]

and um I mean I've mainly been picking the characters that are barefoot.

Mhm.

Um cuz that and then of course with the massive anime Milkies.

Oh, they're all teenagers. No. Okay. Well, [cough] never mind. [clears throat] So, you got anything else?

That's it.

All right. Well, that's our thoughts on React. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe. Having a wonderful whatever day it is for you.

Progress saved