Spectral Review: The First Time We've Strongly Disagreed On A Game...Ever?
Transcript
hello and welcome to bit I'm Farrell this is tally and today we have a review of spectral by Ryan Courtney for you and this is a game that is probably going to be the most divisive Board ofit review in all of our years of reviewing board games I can't remember ever having such a difference of opinion and it's even weirder because we both really like every other game of Ryan Corney that we've played yeah spoiler but why don't you tell them what spectral is spectral is a competitive deduction game in which you'll be taking on the role of a team of treasure Hunters searching through a spooky Mansion and you need to avoid curses in order to seek out that treasure before we get into the review it's important to note that we were sent this as a review copy by the publisher by Wing games in spectral as we said in the intro you're doing competitive deductions so on your turn it's very simple you either place some treasure Hunters down or you pass you can place as many treasure Hunters as you want but generally you'll only want to put one if the space is empty when you put one down at the intersection of two cards you're allowed to then peek at one of the cards and you kind of fill out what it shows you on your chart chart here in this
booklet and these cards are going to give you indications of where curses or Treasures can be found because the cards don't show you what's on that space they show you what's on another space and there's four different types of cards one will'll show you where something is on a double diagonal because the way this grid works is that there's only one other card in the grid where you can move twice in a diagonal Manner and still be within the grid there's also a reflection so the card will show you where treasure recurses reflected so along this midline here so if this showed you treasure the treasure would actually be here and if it was a reflection then there's also as you can see here it's split into quadrants there's also a quadrant diagonal where it looks within the quadrant it's in and it tells you that the treasure on a diagonal and there's basically only going to be one diagonal that it can be in within the quadrant so that's where the treasure all the curs is final one's a bit trickier it basically divides the scri of Cards into an outer loop and an inner circle and it's saying that the treasure or the curse is two cards clockwise in whichever Circle that card is in so if the card's here the curse treasure will end up being here if card is here the curved treasure will
end up being here so that's a little bit highbrow complicated but essentially you're going to go to spaces the cards are going to tell you where treasure or curses are you're going to write it down and you're trying to as quickly as possible figure out where a lot of treasure is but also where the curses are because if you end the game next to a curse your players are wiped out so you get nothing if you end next to just treasure you get the treasure and if multiple players are next to treasure they divide it equally and what you eventually want to do is have a good idea of where some good treasure spots are that are free from curses and then you're going to start loading up on players because as I said you can put as many treasure Hunters down as you want but to knock your player out of that space and back to you the other player or yourself has to put down at least twice as much so once someone has kind of put a four down somewhere it's very difficult to knock them out with the limited numbers you have and at the end of the game the player who has the most treasure will win all in all spectral was something quite unlike anything I've played before it's quite Noel in the fact that you have this logic puzzle deduction game where you're looking at stuff and working out where things are but you also have a competitive element where eventually you're going to have to make decision on where you want to stand you want to probably end up knocking
other people away from spaces you want to go so you get more treasure then you just have this little competitive element it's something quite unique and very unsurprising actually that it came from Ryan courney there's a lot I personally really like about the game I really enjoy the deduction puzzle I like sitting there and kind of quietly working out where things are doodling on your little booklet figuring out what you can from information you've gathered and this is a game that definitely is rewarded by having repeat plays because you start to figure out the patterns and how things Interlink and you can really end up surprising yourselves by the amount of information you can deduce by not having gone to very many spaces however you also have to find people who who want to play it the whole time and it's been very hit or miss when we've introduced it to people obviously even between me and tally but there's just something about it that I think is really great for a kind of quiet cozy deduction game although on the other hand people who like interaction there's really not so much even though you're trying to knock other people out but you can also have some interesting moments of trying to read other players if you're playing a kind of higher player count game because at two players it's more straight deduction if you're playing four or five there's a lot of oh why are they going there it's the mid to late game does that mean something should I go there and you can kind of
have these almost gambling deduction reading the person experiences where you're almost betting on how well you're reading the person rather than what you know or you're using limited information in combination with what someone else is doing and it just creates some really novel and interesting situations to work out so what I will say for this game is it is very novel and we haven't really played anything like this before I do think the whole writing your notes down using the pencil having a little secret book is a very fun and cool experience however for me I'm less of a fan of the game than Farrell because I do find the randomness of where you first place your treasure Hunters just a little bit frustrating obviously you're trying to deduce where the curses and the treasure is but there's absolutely no way of knowing where it is from the beginning so those first placements and those first cards that you look at they could be anything and you have absolutely no way of even guessing what they are and the thing is you can't take any action and you can't do anything about that if you do discovered later down the line that there is a curse there or there's no treasure there for example so I think the lack of being able to do anything about those first placements kind of renders much of the game a little bit pointless for me personally I do think it's also a game that is a bit difficult to teach and explain because there is
hidden information so throughout the game of course if people have questions then you can't really help them without revealing information so it is a little bit difficult in that first game and I think you just have to play it in order to be able to understand really what you're trying to do and then reveal at the end but that said it is a very quick game to play I think most of games have lasted I don't know 15 to 25 minutes so the fact that it is kind of random in the beginning and and difficult to teach maybe in the first game it's not the end of the world you know I'm still happy to have a game of it it of it it is quite fun to try and figure out where those things are but yeah it's just not going to be a favorite of mine because it is just too frustrating to me that you can't do anything about the hidden information that you eventually find out spectral is a particularly hard one for us to come to a conclusion on because we both feel very differently uh I think it's going to be a very much love a hate game I do get your points that there's inherent Randomness where you put people down originally but it doesn't really bother me because you kind of have to throw them out there to discover where to go but there is also an argument that one of the tiebreakers is who who has kind of lost the most people to curses and if it's due to starting turn Randomness then that can be a little bit it's quite annoying
annoying but I mean that hasn't really happened I would say yeah that's true but there's the potential for it I think it's great for people if you like what I said in you can say my segment where I'm talking about the coziness of the deduction the the fun and joy and kind of just comforting satisfaction of doodling and figuring out uh I really enjoy that element of it but why don't you tell them why they wouldn't like it if you find it frustrating that there is that Randomness in the beginning you know what I don't even find that you know too bad it's just that you can't do anything about it I would like some kind of mechanism where once you do uncover some information then you could actually take an action on it that might make me feel better about it but if that sort of thing would bother you as it does me then this is not going to be the game for you what I would say is it is quite a nice one to play with family or like non board game of friends because it's don't know about that they went down pretty badly when we try well I think it's just something novel right and if people are line with your taste it's a nice small box it's very transportable we took it on holiday with us uh so those are some kind of good quality points about it and I don't think it's a sort of game like I don't I don't hate it uh I'm happy to play it if you've never said that to my uh reactions sometimes when we're playing it um but yeah if you know you have some
people in your life that may be more align with uh Farrell's opinions then I don't think it's something you know that you're going to absolutely hate but yeah for me if you align with me then I wouldn't get it yes so obviously a clear conclusion for that one but I think it it's disc certainly something unique and it's something definitely if you can try it somewhere without buying it I definitely think it's worth doing that uh there's a lot to like about it and in fact something we haven't mentioned so far is that there's additional cards you can put in to make the puzzle more complex basically so there's the easiest way to say would be almost like three mini expansions because these types of cars do certain things like actually they cancel where that card puts the treasure yeah so actually it stays on that card or the curse stays on that card uh and it makes the puzzle more complex and intriguing so that's something that's quite interesting as well in terms of replayability and you also Shuffle these up so it's a new puzzle every time but yeah I mean you just have to pick who you align with more I guess exactly yeah so but very interesting and something that I would like to play more I just need to find someone who is in t to play with I'll play yeah I I think I'm scared too you get angry so that was our review of spectral if it was helpful and you're not subscribed please consider subscribing
it would really help us if you have any questions about it please ask us down below and most importantly just thanks for watching we really appreciate it and see you next time bye