KeyForge Review - My Favourite Collectible Card Game
Transcript
where do I even begin to talk about keyboard I could start with the fact that unlike in other collectible card games in this one you don't get to build your deck you open a pack get out 36 surprises and for better or for worse that's your lot of course I could launch this video with a mention that all decks in keywords are procedurally generated with the almighty algorithm or bless you who hears or responsible not only for your decks composition but also the artwork on the back of the cards and its name ending up with such utter gibberish as this surely pretentious god of Bharath on YJ just drown of the empathic Lake off okay I deserve this one champion Lazlo of no pun included or I could start with a fact that every single deck and keyboard and it has already sold in millions every single deck in ki Fateh is 100% FDA certified you need that means that when you buy your deck it will be your deck alternatively I could start with a fact actually that that's that's all the beginnings dear viewers I used up all of my beginnings or that means that this video will have none in key port like in
other collectible card games you will be pitching your deck against your opponent's deck but unlike in other collectible card games instead of trying to reach oh I don't know let's just come up with a random goal like reducing your opponent's life total to 0 you will instead be trying to forge three keys each of your decks will be composed of free houses that the algorithm chose for you there are a total of nine houses available in keywords although any given set will only have seven of the nine houses some reason I feel this really burning desire to do a Voyager reference no idea why the houses are your first exposure to keep witches theme which I like to label as delightful nonsense you're mighty alkanes trying to forge keys in the planet glued from bits that's called a crucible for some reason and all that really means is that you'll get to pilot a team composed of green little men robot librarians and noble Roman Dino dudes or if you're lucky you'll get to open a pack with my favorite house this actually has this without a faction entirely composed of rude people just yelling at each other or as we call it in England the House of Commons key Forge lets you know immediately that it doesn't take itself too seriously but it's not dark to the point where it's not interesting either it straddles that fine line of being ludicrous but appealing because I just want to play
with these cards yes give me a Draco prank oh and I could curl this cow fine all day long and sometimes it even borrows characters from the Marvel Universe like The Incredible Knob who brings along all his best catchphrases it's napping time who let the nap out and my favorite you can't handle the knob this decks called courier Harley's act Akane I told you complete utter gibberish but just because Keef which is very daft it doesn't mean it's also not smart designed by dr. Richard I created Magic the Gathering Garfield himself it puts some very clever spins on the card battle formula as mentioned before you win a game of key Forge by forging free keys to forge a key you need to collect six or more amber and retain them until the start of your next turn because that's the only time you can forge a key you can get amber by playing certain cards by activating various abilities on the cards that you've played but predominantly by reaping you can reap as long as it's your turn and your creatures are not exhausted and they belong to the active house and that's where things get very clever remember Lance mana cast costs will forget about all of that because in key food you can play any card that you like and there's many of them as you want as long as they belong to the active house let's say they it's my turn and I've chosen house broad nur I could play mine up my other knob and
my mega knob this is great I now have free not although do note that I can only put creatures to my left or my right flank this is important for a number of reasons but in this case my knobs say that it's creatures cannot reap now alternatively I could fight my opponent's creatures but to do that my creatures have to be unexhausted and they come into play exhausted so I have to wait until the end of my turn to do that talking of the end of my time this is when I draw my cards as well because my drawer limit is by default 6 and I played free knobs I'll draw 3 cards cool I've got a full grip I've got my knobs I am ready to do things and my opponent did indeed play some knobs that I would really like to get rid of but to do anything with house prop nur including attacking or reaping I would first have to activate house probe na but the problem here is that I no longer have a single brockner card in my hand and if I activate house brockner I can only play house proper cards this is a puzzle that never fails to delight I could make plans for many turns ahead figuring out what I'll play and what I'll activate but Keith's which is a dynamic field I'm not just building my board presence I'm responding to what my opponent does and keep getting surprised by new draws that's interesting let's talk about tempo which is a concept invented by Magic the Gathering theorists although arguably applies to
all card games of this type imagine it as a tug row with someone always having a strength advantage and now imagine that tug rope has your board presence as in how many cards you've played to your board or more accurately how good those cards are had giving you the leverage to push you towards winning the game if you have tempo you are not fighting back you're comfortable and give push your advantage if you don't have it your focus isn't so much winning but clawing that advantage back in most card games tempo is binary you either have it or you don't in key Forge you have three fresh holds every card game is a race to the finish line be the first to do something and you win tempo is defined by that race but because forging a key is generally a point of no return this race is split into three laps so you could do something like fight over your opponent's supply of amber potentially stealing it and taking it for yourself or capturing it and putting it on one of your creatures which is great up until that moment where the creature dies and then your opponent gets all of that amber back or you could alternatively realize that you're in a losing battle and opt to let them Forge a key whilst you work towards dismantling their advantage I realize I'm going a touch too deep for a regular review and making it sound like a crunchy competitive experience rather than just the silly good time honestly to have a blast with key Forge you don't
need to think about things like tempo or board presence you can just play a card it has an effect it has some restrictions they're simple but clever and you never have to worry about having an e card in your deck that you can never play because you haven't played 15 lines yet and my gosh is it forgiving if you really like your deck but it's a bed bunk and your friend keeps beating you there's even a handicap system that you can adjust however you like you don't have to use it if you don't want to but isn't it great to have a competitive guard game that offers depth and complexity but it's also just aimed at having a chill time with your body and lets you make it your own this is all I want a card game to be nothing more nothing less of course some people get a real thrill out of building a deck and that's fine that just means Keith wood isn't for you and probably never will be but now let's talk about the caffeine in the room this is where Keith which is real brilliance lies no it's not that clever an innovative use of algorithms but the fact that it understands that actually algorithms are pretty stupid every time social media CEOs and tech John's try to convince us that they're amazing I can't help but wince because my Twitter still thinks that I'm into love island there's nothing wrong with love island if you like it but I'm still not sure I know what it is what it does what I wear it with earlier in 2018 we reviewed discover lands unknown Fantasy
Flight Games second foray into procedurally generated games and it was a misunderstanding and a disaster on the scale of cats no not the movie I mean actual cats why would you keep a miniature lion in your house that will eat your face as soon as you die whose idea was that looking back it's clear that discovers real fault was its over reliance on technology I'm not saying that computers can't make up I just don't expect it to make any sense thankfully if your tech doesn't up being gibberish part of the fun of Keith which for me is untangling it into something beautiful let's take a look at my Megan off deck again yes I realize I'm a bit obsessed not only is it oppressively crammed with big dumb things from house prop nah but the rest of it is designed to let me draw lots of big dumb things or avoid big dumb things and let me tell you I am big dumb here for it from a strategy perspective this is questionable the typical flow of a collectible card game is to establish some sort of a board presence and then use that board presence to gain an advantage normally via attacking key foods flip stuff on its head by saying actually you can attack but all that does is clear your opponent's board to win you have to get amber to get amber you have to reap and to reap you have to not fight but then my deck is crammed full of things that don't actually let me reap playing a key for tech is the equivalent of owning a windmill when you're allergic to wheat
here's the thing about windmills you can mill anything it don't have to be wheat it could be buckwheat Bucks Fizz could be shoes as Gandalf once said all we have to decide is what to do the windmills given to us yes I do have a deck full of big stupid creatures that don't actually win me the game but if I keep deploying them and if I keep fighting with them then I'll kill anything that my opponent has on their side of the table and if they can't win then they come win actually scratch that I'm pretty sure this deck is terrible no human being would have ever designed this this is basically the village idiot who keeps bringing his inventions to the tavern for everyone to see except in key for this village idiot is the norm it's like a secret cinema version of Futurama where everything is absurd and stupid but I never want to get off of this ride and I get it some people find immense joy out of building the deck and out of competing with it magic is a thrill and some of my best moments in games have been at a magic tournament when people ask me what magic was I frequently described it as an evil combination of chess and poker and I still think that's probably the most apt analogy imagine reading your opponent's so well that you know the exact composition of their hand without even looking at it and you know the exact next move they will make you are in the zone you are neo every card they play
leads them further into your trap and every card you play dismantles the foundations of their reality imagine how good that feels but if I have to be honest I have to admit that that moment is incredibly rare and fleeting so frequently we talk about magic as an addiction the urge to open yet another pack and hopefully find a shiny tchotchke you've been after for so long and if you ask me I think the actually addictive part of magic is chasing that dream of a perfect game in 2002 mark rosewater the current lead developer of magic whose IMDB profile lists him having written two episodes of Roseanne penned an article called Timmy Johnny and spike coining free player archetypes that the development team constantly straw
please I guess in 2002 only men played magic to summarize Timmy is someone who likes to play big cards he was the first person in the NAP fan club spike is a typical tournament player it's all about efficient plays and efficient wins but here's Johnny and Johnny to quote mark rosewater is the creative gamer to whom magic is a form of self-expression Johnny likes to win but he wants to win with style it's very important to Johnny that he win on his own terms as such it's important to Johnny that he's using his own deck playing magic is an opportunity for Johnny to show off his creativity many have argued that magic by now is an outdated game with outdated mechanisms playing lands to generate mana is clunky and so on I would probably agree with that but what I think is really clunky about magic is this constant need to affirm all three player archetypes every set filled with cards that want to please everyone but nobody can agree what it is they actually want out of it it's like having you dinner at the all-you-can-eat world cuisine diner you can have sushi pizza and kebabs on the same plate but honestly you wish you didn't because nobody knew how to cook it ki fudge is for Johnny's sure you don't get to actually build your deck but you have ownership of your deck your weird stupid impossible deck it's like nothing else
in this world you're adopted a stray scruffy looking dog that barks at her own tail but you love her because she's yours and when you win you win because you figured your deck out but just before I inevitably recommend ki forge I would like to talk about something that I don't have to win talking about regular board games I have a bit of news for you believe it or not I am NOT your dad shocking I know but Chao speakers I'm not your dad doesn't mean we can't talk about addiction a little bit look you're a grown person unless you're not do what you like buy what you want but despite what I said earlier in the random hack model is still addictive and yes absolutely the only reason the package games like that is to abuse that addictive quality to make more money before wealth collide the first set of key fudge I would have argued that out of all of the collectible car games I've played it's the least reliant on it you buy your deck you milk it for fun until it's dry and then maybe get another one but with the introduction of cards like anomalies rare trinkets you don't get in every pack the push to buy more becomes more evident I'm sure you don't need me to tell you this but as someone who has an addictive personality myself and very aware that it could all devolve into I'll just buy another pack so there you go key Forge is fantastic and I hope it sticks around for many years to come a
struggle all known magic collectible card games face but if you have an addictive personality consider this PSA an opportunity to ask yourself this question do I really need this