Skip to main content
Loading video...

We Could Not Finish Terraria: The Board Game

Transcript 33:33

I think Terraria the board game is bad. In fact, I'm confident enough to open the video with me saying so, which I have done. I think it's bad in a way where you can make an entertaining board game video just picking apart the kind of bad that it is, which is its own kind of blessing. The game is not enjoyable, but at least it's fun to talk about. So, let's If you're not familiar with Terraria, don't worry. You're not alone. Neither am I. I've done some due diligence and purchased the video game, tried it, and had some fun. It's nice. You wander around a procedurally generated world, gather resources, craft them into gear, dig underground, and slay beasties that harass you. The one thing I have learned about Terraria is that it has a really dedicated fan community. And one of their favorite things about Terraria is when people equate it to Minecraft. Apparently, they are entirely happy to have someone called the game 2D Minecraft. Now, I am no expert, but whilst these games fall into the same genre, there are obvious points of divergence. But listen, I am not going to quibble. If the fans are calling it 2D Minecraft, who am I to disagree? Terraria was published all the way back in 2011, and it feels like it.

Not in the sense that it is dated, but in the sense that it is an incredibly millennial coded game. One of the items in it is a pone hammer. Original PWN spelling for that extra authenticity. I hope you're getting a clear sense of what we're dealing with here. It's good. Pone is an aged word for 2011. But let's forget about that for a second because a decade and a half later, after gathering up a whopping 1.6 million pound sterling on Kickstarter and rocking an 8.0 Zero rating on BGG. We have Terraria the board game Pone Hammer included. Wow, that's a lot of money and a [clears throat] lot of rating. And here I am making a video about it without having completed one full play.

Wild. One does wonder where did it all go wrong and for whom? And also, are BGG ratings just meaningless? Never mind. Let's not get distracted. There's a lot to go over. Let me show you some brief rules. Terraria, the board game, is a cooperative deck building game. On your turn, you'll draw full cards, and play them to do whatever it is the card says. If a card has a green dot, that's an action. You can spend an action to move, dig soil, chop trees, open chests, attack enemies, and teleport goods and items to other players. Cards might also have other effects that are not actions. For example, a card might let your partner draw another card, or it might heal you. Crucially, you can perform these in any order. Each round in Terraria is split into a player phase, an enemy phase, and some cleanup steps.

During that player phase, players can perform actions in whatever order they like, including splitting up card effects. Meaning that if a card gives me an action and also lets me draw and discard a card, you could perform the action. wait for other players to do what they want to do and then do the draw and discard. I genuinely appreciate this freewheeling flow because it fits gracefully into the ethos of Terraria. There is no reason for you to do any specific thing in the video game. You progress how you like and whilst board games need more structure than that, this no holds barred approach to turns injects a bit of that looseness. But it also creates opportunities for tactical play because you can wait for more information before pulling the trigger on certain actions. Player hands then become a communal puzzle in a fluid way.

The game encourages teamwork and discussion, similar to our recent favorite, Daybreak. Nice. You'll begin Terraria on four starting tiles, all of which belong to the forest biome. But this is literally the tip of the iceberg. Each game there will be five biomes. Each free tiles wide and five tiles deep. Each biome offers different enemies, different loot, and different artwork. And hypothetically, if you were to explore all of it, this is the breadth and variety of space that Terraria lets you play in. It's huge, isn't it? Yes. But also, if you zoom in, you will notice that these tiles have the word foreshadowing printed on them. How strange. Some actions are slightly more involved than just spending the action point. Both mining and chopping wood converts that action point into mining and chopping points based on the tool you are holding. A starting copper pickaxe converts these at a 1:1 ratio, but later tools might jumble these numbers in funky ways. And again, there is a surprisingly open feeling system to how all of this works. Let's say I had a pickaxe that gave me four mining points.

If I only used up two mining points to mine this iron, I can still hold the other two virtual mining points until the end of the player phase, walking around doing actions on other cards until I decide to use it again, potentially topping it up with other mining actions. Finally, you can perform free actions, which there is a whole bunch of, but of note are things like placing robes, platforms, and crafting. That's right. Crafting is the focus of Terraria. So, naturally, it doesn't cost you an action to do it. You still need to gather the resources, but it's lovely to just be able to make the thing you've been working towards without additional steps. And there are so many things to craft. Look, A WHOLE MENU BOOK WITH tabs of the actual hundreds of weapons, gear, armor. There's even a tab for foreshadowing. And the armor, look, it's these perspects cards that you overlay over your character. And so you have a dress up mechanism. I think this is delightful. Ropes and platforms are placed on the map as traversal tools, and both are there to interact with the fall damage mechanism. Yes, this is a board game with a fall damage mechanism.

Unironically, I think this is the best because not only does it invoke absurd video game physics, but it also lets you do some nifty trickery with how and where you place these. And nifty trickery is the gateway to getting your players to feel clever. That's fun. In case it wasn't obvious, this rules overview also served as a showcase of all the things I liked about Terraria TBG. But I already told you, I think this board game is a stinky boy. And now a little disclaimer. The internet is rotting all our brains. Not just yours. Mine too. Everyone's. It flattened the difference between criticism and negativity in a way where it's way too easy to fall into a cycle of social media that feeds on the emotions critical work can create. What that means is I can't just do the same thing that movie critics did in the 80s. This film good, this film bad. I am about to be quite critical of this game and hopefully in an entertaining way, but I need to make sure that I look after your mental health as I do it. I'm not kidding. [snorts] NPI has never shied away from negative reviews. I believe they are a genuine benefit. But if I do a negative review, the algorithm will suggest other negative reviews or worst yet people who make negative slob. I know this happens because there's so many people that complain that we only ever do negative reviews. And when I see

those complaints, I am like, uh, do people even watch us that say this? They do but only a list of videos that was created by a machine. The machine thinks that if person watch this that person must eat more of that. So it just keeps recommending our negative videos creating an impression that that's all we do. So two things. First, if you want to watch more of us after this video, the end links will have a playlist of videos where we just really like a game. Second, I want you to understand that I'm about to be mean to this game, but that does not mean I am trying to be mean to the people that made this game.

I think they made a lot of bad decisions, and I will be critical of them, but I genuinely believe that this critique is beneficial. It deepens viewer perspectives on game design. It helps them pass and understand why they enjoy some games and not others. And I also hope that in some way it does help Paper Ford games. Just don't let videos like this become your diet in moderation. Okay. Okay. So, you know how I said Terraria TBG is a deck building game? Well, the deck building isn't really deck building. It fulfills the general remits of deck building. You build your deck, you play cards, you shuffle your discard, etc., etc. But I want you to think about what it means to be a deck building game in the year 2026. This genre is 18 years old. You could have grown a full adult human being in this amount of time. Video games from 2008 get full-on remakes because they look too dated. You can't just give us the bare bones of deck building and call it a day. You have to twist it somehow. Innovate on the genre.

But [clears throat] Terraria isn't interested in twisting anything. It just wants to simulate an entire video game in cardboard. So the way it uses deck building is to basically be a mechanical engine to drive its ideas. But that engine was never built to carry that kind of weight. It's trying to power a bus with potatoes. It might inch occasionally, but this is going to be the worst school trip you have ever been on. The result is a game that is intolerably slow and the deck building feels unsatisfying because the cards haven't been created to be fun cards. They've simply been created to propel this idea of a game that quote unquote feels like Terraria. Let's take a look at how this works in practice. A common trope of deck building is deck thinning.

the idea of permanently removing unwanted cards from your deck to make it more consistent. Terraria has free card shops. The guide cards are available at the beginning of the game and simply offer free types of upgrade cards, none of which enable deck thinning. By driving the game's levers forward, you'll eventually unlock the ability to purchase merchant cards. These are entirely unique with comparatively strong abilities and come at two costs, eight and 15 gold coins. And each of these brackets has exactly one card that enables deck thinning. Spring Clean costs eight gold and lets you remove one card from your deck, but then it also immediately removes itself, making it single use. Get rid costing almost double also does this but unlike spring clean it stays around letting you repeat this effect as many times as you like.

The problem here is that the game understands that deck building has to have a deck thinning mechanism but has no idea what to do with it. If Terraria is a chill game so too then Terraria the board game attempts to create an atmosphere of just doing things. But because it is a deck building game, it needs to give you deck thinning. Otherwise, the size and inconsistency of your deck becomes intolerable. But it also cannot give you deck thinning as a reliable tool. Because when you average out the difficulty curve, this game is much too easy. A constant supply of deck thinning will create monstrous decks that will reliably circumn every challenge the game poses. Thus, you have two cards that can perform deck thinning. One that works exactly once and another that will work every time you draw it, but only for one player.

Meaning, in a four-player game, one player can craft the deck they want, trimming it to a lean, mean do everything machine, whereas other players will have to satisfy themselves with the few instances of deck thinning they'll get as rewards for completing objectives. In the late stages of the game, you will unlock an NPC, which is basically just a permanent new assistance rule for the game that will allow you to thin your deck. You can do it once every round for free, and then once more by paying money, which at this point is only useful for fulfilling certain objectives. So, twice per round

He's snorting.

There we go.

We're done.

Okay. Okay, that's good.

You can do it once every round for free and then once more by paying money, which at this point is only useful for fulfilling certain objectives, so twice per round. This is a stark contrast. For a large portion of the game, deck thinning is table scraps. The game tosses to starving mouths. But then, right at the very end, EBENEZER WAKES UP A NEW MAN and lavishes us Pavos with a goose. It comes far too late for it to have any meaning. And this 180 twist feels more like a design cheat rather than design leverage. Deck thinning is a problem that many deck building games have to reckon with. It's a powerful tool that if mismanaged can make any system trivial, but it is also a core tenant of the genre, and how you handle it is a telltale sign of the strength of the design. Terraria's answer is to basically bypass this issue with a shortcut, curtail availability, and call it a day rather than leverage this problem into a creative solution. So far, I've described two of the card shops, and the third one isn't exactly a shop. It is a pile of unique reward cards tiered into five levels. You'll receive random cards from here as a prize for winning combat, opening chests, or completing objectives. Now, you have a system that neglects the ability for you to curate your deck, but also stuffs random cards into it, meaning your deck is just whatever the game throws at you, which then

eliminates the core appeal of deck building. Contrasted to an excellent game like Slay the Spire and its board game adaptation and the gulf is so vast. One system is synonymous for being moorish because every play is another chance at crafting some monstrosity that is unique and quirky and made by you. Another based on a game about crafting uses deck building in a system that actively does not want you to craft your deck. And in case you were wondering, yes, the reward cards have exactly one more card that will let you thin your deck. It's in the highest reward tier, meaning you will have a small chance to access this deck thinning tool at the end of the game, which is obviously where deck thinning is strongest. The game has various status effects, fire, ice, and poison. Ice is a particularly pernicious one because if you get iced, you will draw one less card for the next two rounds. But that's okay because you've trimmed your deck to only include effective cards. Oh, a loot card in our game gave me the ability to ignore all three status effects once if I had it in my hand or forever if I kept it in my special ready slot, which can always store one card between rounds. I want you to understand what a card like that does to a game. At the bottom of the entire world is the underworld layer, where lava and the most dangerous beasts

roam the land. Even getting there is a significant investment of actions. But your reward is hell stone, the resource that will let you craft the best gear. Risk reward, right? Not only do you have to have specialist tools to mine hell stone, but you will also suffer the effects of fire, which makes you lose two health immediately. Having a card like that in your arsenal undermines this entire system. Suddenly, it doesn't matter that you take fire. It doesn't matter that you can't thin your deck. You just have to have this one card forever ready and that's it. There's nothing else you need to worry about. In summary, the deck building in Terraria is a superficial engine to invoke the DiCaprio pointing at the TV meme. It's just like Terraria, but it doesn't innovate or leverage deck building tropes to complement the themes and motifs of Terraria. When the game does give you powerful tools, they completely undermine the game's challenges, rendering them inert. There is no design here. It's just things stacked on top of other things. It functions, but only as a tower of blocks. chuck anything at it and it immediately collapses under its own weight. I am so very consciously aware that there will be some person maybe even the people who made this game saying to me that I don't get it because that's what Terraria is. It's not a game about tension. You just do things. But

if they're allowed to build towers made out of blocks that are just there to be demolished, by divine right, I am allowed to build a straw man. I cannot emphasize how stark a shift happens between the start of Terraria the board game and the end of Terraria the board game. The rules are the same, but experientially I am playing two different things. The beginning of Terraria relies on both efficiency and luck in a way that makes you feel you're maybe actually trapped in the wilderness and whether you make it out alive or not is far from a foregone conclusion. This is less dorky video game and more bare grills. It's giving naked and afraid, but you're actually naked and afraid. The way the game achieves this is by constantly spawning slimes in your starting area and giving you a combat system that is basically a dice roll off with some unfavorably stacked D4s.

Imagine you've just begun the game. There's wood to chop, resources to mine, treasure chests to open. But first, we need to clean up the area because otherwise the slimes will just keep hitting us. Instead, we attack first. To make an attack, you're going to use your sword and the enemy is going to use its defense stat, which at the beginning of the game is a variable amount of D4s. It's a D4 roll off. Sounds easy, but remember, it's dice. Literally, anything can happen. Worse yet, if they do roll high on defense, they will use that dice to attack you back and then you will have to roll your own defense d4. In summary, if you miss, you are probably getting hit. But then also, if the slime is alive at the end of your turn, you are getting hit again. Naturally, you can make multiple attacks, but that costs an action point, which you probably don't have anymore since you spent your actions walking to the slime.

And if you do have an action point and you miss again because dice, you will get hit even more. The penalty for death isn't particularly massive. You lose any consumables you had and some money, which isn't great, but entirely livable. Uh-huh. The actual penalty is spawning you back in the starting zone, which I mean, this map is small now, but imagine the full map at the end of the game. That could be a real bummer. Finally, you have to advance the threat marker. This is the only way you lose Terraria. Advancing the threat marker to 10. It advances by one every time you die and [clears throat] also every couple of rounds. However, if you're fighting a boss, the fret marker advances by two. To cut the rules short, what all of this means is that fret is cumulative. And whilst there are ways to lower it, early game deaths can spiral the situation out of control and end your session before it even got off the ground. So far, you've spent two, maybe 3 hours, depending how much of looking up rules you needed to do, on a tight rope of efficiency where you need to roll dice well to have a chance at winning. Now that that part is over, welcome to Terraria, baby. The rest of the game is here, and it is long and boring. The icing on the goo is that there exists the slime king, an early game boss that spawns as soon as you dispatch five slimes. Meaning that

fighting slimes is just bad all around. You might die and even if you don't die, you'll summon the boss and then you'll still probably die but with a worse penalty because remember fighting boss means the threat advances more. You are not ready for this. So if not fight, then flight. Enter the magic of houses. Once you scrge up enough resources, you can construct your first abode. And here's a trick you can do. Once you construct your shed, you can start digging underneath it. And because the wood of the house is made out of some sort of a slime repellent material, they cannot enter the house. So, if you create a narrow tunnel underneath, you have access to the more lucrative underground world and the slimes can't get to you. Here is where I have to give it to Terraria, the board game. Even though this hour-ong early game Escapade is directly cribed from like the first 2 minutes of the video game, it feels like a magic trick. It's not something the game advertises. You have to put this idea together yourself. You do get a bonus for building your first house, so you're certainly incentivized to do it.

But if you realize you can dig underneath and avoid many of the game's early dangers, it makes you feel smart. Nice. The biggest advantage of not having to fight slimes is that you delay the summoning of King Slime, letting you find more resources to craft into better gear. The boss will summon itself eventually. There's a second timer, but by then you're hopefully better prepared. And once again, because fights in this game are silly dice rolloffs, it could really swing either way. Bad luck can end your session early, but if you do survive with threat to spare, well, that's kind of the terminus of danger. First of all, there are no more bosses. Well, that's a lie. There are five more bosses, but none of them have mandatory spawning conditions. You can summon and defeat them for special gear, and defeating the wall of flesh will win you the game instantly, but there is no need to do any of it because spawning a boss is just purposely making the game more difficult. The way you win Terraria is by either defeating the wall of flesh or completing an objective chain. These are a set of 10 tasks grouped into four categories: fighting, mining, crafting, and exploring. You can and should prioritize one of them, but doing other sets gives you rewards, like setting back the threat meter, so double dipping is not a waste of time. Bosses don't help with that, unless your chosen objective chain is fighting. In other

cases, they actively hinder this progress by accelerating the clock. and whatever gear they do deposit for defeating them is not worth the risk. Additionally, this combat system is simple to a fault. And by fault, I mean it does not account for progression in the game. The thing about dice is that the more dice you roll, the more probability becomes a bell curve. What this means is that the more you gear up, the more you can predict outcomes. Even if the enemy is equally matched, knowing the odds gives you an edge. And even if you miss, because the enemy only ever retaliates with one die, the retaliation mechanism becomes a trivial nuisance rather than a die or do affair. The result of all of this is a game with a mismatch tone. First, you claw for survival, and then you dle as every mechanism the game has painstakingly introduced to you is now undermined by every advancement that you've made. And it would be fine if it just quietly wrapped itself up. But no, no, no.

Remember, there's a whole objective line to complete. For example, if you are mining, which is what we regrettedly chose to focus on in our game, to complete the mining chain, you will want to mine six hellstone. This can only be found on the lowest rung of the world, the underground. And each tile could feature anywhere between zero and two hellstone. Meaning that the tone of this is explore new tile, move on to it, maybe fight a monster in a tedious roll off, hopefully minor hellstone, move again, fight minor hellstone. This one has no hell stone, but a fight. So, let's do that. Now, the monsters have responded. Let's fight again. At this stage, the fights are not exciting. They are still just dice rolloffs with the blades dulled. None of this is anything.

It is again just mechanism upon mechanism to make you do things. To reach this point, you know, two-player game, we have minusing out lunch breaks and dog walks spent 7 hours playing. I'd also argue that most people don't play games for 7 hours without breaks. So, actually, let's check the break time back in. Let's be normal, real people, okay? 9 hours. 9 hours to get here and the game is now telling me, "Why don't you wander around drawing cards and rolling dice?" Dear viewer, we quit there and then. We couldn't realistically justify spending more time with Terraria, the board game, because frankly, we desperately needed to be doing anything else. The question I want to answer right now is, how did we get here? How do you end up with a game that takes 9 hours from start to not even finish? And this isn't a campaign. There is no save system. This is just a single session of Terraria the board game. Like you were here for Twilight Imperium or 1817, but you're not. You're playing a regular deck building game with rolled ahead to resolve fights. To answer this, we must return to the Pone Hammer because believe it or not, it is the key. In the video game, the pone hammer is an item you get for defeating the wall of flesh. In the board game, however, there is no sense to have such a reward because defeating the wall of flesh is it. In what world does it make sense to hand out a reward for a game that has literally finished?

Well, I did mention that the board game also has the pone hammer, but there is no way to obtain it, nor does it actually do anything aside from being foil. It is then here to simply say, "Look, we know you should get a pone hammer when you defeat the wall of flesh." And because that's what happens in the video game, this is what will happen here too, even if it makes no sense. This then reveals the game's entire design philosophy. Everything is sacrificed at the altar of being just like the video game. There is a surviile devotion to the source material which guides the shape of the game like a fickle deity. If in each Terraria playthrough there are five biomes, so too in the board game. If it has the surface, underground, cavern, and underworld layers, so too in the board game. If the cavern layer is twice as large, well, we'll double it here as well. But wait, we also need to make each biome distinct. Each have its own enemies loot. Also, this is a game about digging down, so we need to make each tile full of traversible spaces. Once you factor all that in, you create a play area that is absurdly large and filled with meaningless interaction points. There are 15 spaces between the surface and underworld layers. So, hypothetically, if you were trundling to complete your last mining objective and accidentally rolled some bad dice and died, then how many turns till you get back? And that is assuming a straight path down. The game knows this. And to

circumvent that, it gives you teleportation pylons that still cost four action points to activate, which is probably half the action points you have in a round during endgame. There is so much space and so little of you. A vast map filled with nominally different things, but only in the sense that one stat might be slightly different than another. Movement in this game takes so much time, especially horizontally. There is no reason to go from here to here, not unless an objective dictates it. So all this space feels wasted. I keep wondering what this game would look like if it was abstracted. If there were only one column in a biome instead of three. If movement cost an action to move between tiles rather than squares. How many hours of play time would that shave off?

Two, three, six? Honestly, I think that's feasible. I think that if Terraria wanted to, it could have been a two threehour game and it would have been way more exciting for it. This has been on my career bucket list for some time now. To review a game I've not even finished. If you want to discount everything I say because of that, that's okay with me. That's valid. You should do that if you feel like it. Follow your gut. One of the most frequent questions we get asked is how many times we've played something which listen I get the desire to know that I'm not an animal. Our hobby values depth and let me tell you this game is so deep you literally have to dig for hours to reach the bottom. But Terraria will not offer me anything that is going to change how I feel about it. It will not change my perspective or opinion if I play it more. I won't learn anything here. This is a game that measures movement in squares, but then has separate rules for measuring attack range with a range ruler. Why does that make sense? If I keep playing it, I will just keep finding more things like that that don't make any sense to me, and I'll just hate it more. And at the end of the day, the deck building just isn't that interesting. The game is just too long, and it does not justify its length. I think it's important here to remember the many things that the game does right. Its approach to fluid turns is

inspired and its adherence to the source material is evident. I think folks who love Terraria and don't have a lot of experience with board games will be smitten with the absurd amounts of references and similarities. There is a comfort and joy in it. I just don't want those same people to think that this is what board gaming is. that when you sit down for a session, you have to call in sick the next day because you've sat in a room for the entire day and didn't look after yourself. I cannot imagine asking any of my friends to try this. Elaine agreed to play it because it's her job. I dare not ask her for a second playthrough. It could severely impact our relationship. And I'm only half joking. I don't know how it would convince people to sit down for a 9-hour deck building game. Forget the rule book that needs a massive rewrite. Forget the weird tone changes. Forget the we can get it down to six hours because we're experienced. It's just a non-starter. It doesn't make sense. This was a game with promise and it was undone by one cardinal mistake. It wanted to be video game call on the board game and it ended up as merge. Well, what a note to end on. When I told our viewers on Discord that this was going to be a negative review, many folks suggested that we could end the video with footage of our dogs to counterbalance things. So, here's never before seen footage of Sydney as a puppy. Of course, if you'd

like to join our Discord, you know what's happening here. A plug for our Patreon. Listen, we're not like most other board game review channels. We don't make money off of sponsored playthroughs or Kickstarter previews. We don't even accept review copies. You might appreciate that kind of work and well, we rely on viewers like yourself supporting us. And as promised, here's a playlist of our main channel videos where we just talk about games we really like. See you soon.

Progress saved