Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beast Games (season 2): Game Design Notes

Transcript 10:40

Hey, I'm Jamie from Stonemire Games and today I'm going to talk about my thoughts and favorite mechanisms essentially on the latest season of Beast Games. Um, I love reality TV or specifically I really I love reality competition shows and I enjoyed season two more than I enjoyed season one but I thought they evolved some nice things in season two of Beast Games. I also watched it around the time that I'm getting excited for season 50 of Survivor and uh Traitors season 4. So, I might cover those in the near future as well. Um, so yeah, I'm going to throw up a photo here. This is maybe a very mild spoiler from the show. It happens fairly early in Beast Game season 2. Um, that shows just just to have something on the screen while I talk a little bit. And I'll talk about this one first because I love Survivor. One of the neat twists in Beast Game season 2 is that there is a survivor uh crossover episode where they uh some of the contestants fly to an island in Fiji and realize that they are on one of the islands where they film Survivor. So for for a huge Survivor fan like me, it was really neat to see them on this island. No Survivor contestants show up here, but Jeff Propes is there and they do a series of Survivorike challenges and end up even having a tribal council where they vote someone out. Um, one of the things that that I think was notable about this episode, other than it being like great to see the Survivor format used for Beast Games for an episode, um, and actually I like the idea of doing crossovers like this in general between shows. I think that's a neat way to give a shout out to these

shows that are learning from each other. But one thing I really liked about it is that actually two things. One, Jeff has a very funny quip uh with uh with with Mr. Beast here where Mr. be comments how Jeff doesn't have to shout to get everyone's attention and Jeff has a nice quip about well like you don't you don't have to shout you could just say the words and people will listen to you. So I like that little quip. Jimmy did not heed it for the rest of the season. But the other thing that Jimmy did not heed for this show is that a a common thing in Beast Games is that each episode ends with a cliffhanger. Like you don't know who is going to be kicked out or you don't know who's going to win a challenge or something like that. And I have a feeling I mean one of the the core tenets of Survivor is that there is someone voted out at the end of every episode. It isn't left to a cliffhanger like you know who is going to be voted out. It's kind of the promise of the show when you sit down to watch an episode episode of Survivor that someone will be voted out at the end of the episode. And Beast Games doesn't do that. They wait oftentimes to the next the beginning of the next episode. Very like YouTube thing for Jimmy to do. But uh I really like that for the Survivor episode. It's almost as if Jeff said, "Okay, I'll do this episode, but you got to have someone vote it out at the end."

Like, you can't save it for the next episode. And it was kind of a reminder of how well that works because it come the episode comes to a nice close rather than a cliffhanger. Um, always leading to the next episode. And in this streaming era, it's so easy to just watch a few minutes of the next episode anyway. It it I I don't know why they do that. So, um, I kind of wish that would happen for Beast Game season 3, that there would be a conclusion, a clear conclusion to every episode. have that promise fulfilled at the end of the episode that uh that you ke kind of that you know was going to happen. Um and so I like that in the Survivor episode. Some other things though that I thought were clever or different at least in season 2 is that instead of having I think they started with like 2,000 people in season 1, in this season they started with 200 people. Uh and I liked in general how quickly that those 200 people were whittleled down to around two dozen people. And that way we could actually get to know the contestants fairly well rather than having this deluge of contestants that we don't really know until we get to the top 10.

Um, so I like that. Also, I thought it was interesting. I don't know if it really paid off, but it was interesting at the very least that a hundred of the people were considered physically strong people and a hundred of them were considered smart people um by various metrics of strength and intelligence. I don't know if this fully paid off throughout the season um but it did make me not long for, but uh I enjoyed some previous seasons of Survivor where they divided the the the uh the cast into different groups like that. And I thought it made some interesting decisions in Beast Games in terms of how people grouped up and how they approached challenges. But um and how they approached like their alliances as well. But and yet I think most of the challenge challenges or more of the challenges in beast games kind of swayed towards physicality and also swayed towards uh working as a team. And I thought the the people who grew up playing team sports had a little bit of an advantage there over the uh the at least, you know, the subjectively more intelligent people who were on the smart among the smarts people. So, I like the idea, but I don't know if it was as well balanced between those two groups as it could have been. Um, one major thing like in the first season of Beast Games, maybe the the biggest frustration for me was that there was a lot of self-elimination uh for reasons that I could not understand. like the the premise of many different

challenges and episodes was like, "Okay, there's 50 people and by the end of this challenge, you need 20 of you need to have chosen to leave this game for the remaining 30 to continue in this game." Um, and it just I I I never understood like it it to me that wasn't entertaining to watch. It didn't make me root for anyone in particular. In fact, it made me slightly root for the people who decided to leave, but they were then gone, so you couldn't root for them anymore. Um, and really like the whole idea of these people have gone through a lot to get on the show and then just asking them to leave so others can stay. I did not like that. And so I thought one big improvement in season two is that um there were more interesting choices throughout the season whenever there was something even close to a self- elimination like you could and oftentimes it wasn't even an elimination involved but some many times it was where like if you take this money um or if you do this thing oftentimes also resulted in money or some sort of a reward. You have to leave um but uh but but other people get to stay. And there's one exception to this, one one game that was an exception to this, but for the most part, that's how it was structured. And I thought that was a much more interesting format to watch where we got to watch people make difficult choices and weigh the value proposition of staying in the game and trying to win more money or trying to win the eventual $5 million versus taking like $100,000 now when there are 75 people left. I thought that sort of like that to me asks a really good

question to the audience of what would you do in this situation? Would you take the guaranteed $100,000 or would you stay in the game for longer even though you have a lower chance of getting a lot more money? I think that's an interesting decision. I actually think this is one of the things the show does really well or did really well in season two. It led to a number of decision points where I turned to Megan or she turned to me and we said, "What would you do in this situation?" I think that's a good sign of a great reality competition show when you wonder what would you do if you were in these people's shoes. Um, two other quick things that I liked about it, uh, in season two, and again, I'm staying away from from spoilers here, but one nice hook or change in season two is that uh, in season 1, near the very end of the season, there was a coin introduced where if someone flipped that coin um, or chose to flip that coin, they could end up doubling the $5 million pot into $10 million and uh if the coin flips on the other side, I think that person was would would have been eliminated. This coin came up in season two as well, but it was introduced much earlier in the game. It was someone won this coin and it created a really interesting dynamic. Uh do you do you uh that person had the choice to keep the coin or give it away to someone else? Um they could have done that at any time.

And also it made it it meant that there was a pretty big incentive to keep that person on the show so that the coin was in play. And meanwhile Jimmy shows up every now and then and tries to bribe that person into giving him the coin so he doesn't have to spend $5 million if the coin flip turns up heads at the end of at the end of the season. Thought that added a really great dynamic to the show that I would like to see in the future that could work in other shows as well. And finally, my favorite challenge in the show. I'll take down this image to not confuse you because it isn't this challenge, but there is a tower building challenge that I thought was could have even been a better mix of uh strength and smarts. It ended up being more about uh strength, but it was a tower building challenge where you had to build a tower out of these giant kind of foam blocks with a number of people. A number of people could help. Um and you just had to be the fastest person to reach something that was really high up. So, you had to build a physical tower that went up probably five stories. It was really tall. Maybe maybe I'm overestimating there, but it a very tall tower out of these big blocks. And the one reason I'm not bringing this like as the best challenge of all time is that every block could only have one block underneath it. So, they couldn't like build a nice big base and build up from there. I think that would have been a little bit more interesting if they could have done that. Instead, they it meant that there had to be a lot of physicality involved because you were not just strategically choosing which block to go up there, but you needed someone at the top of the tower, there could only be one person up there to physically like pull the blocks up there and then pull themselves on top of that

block and then pull up the next block. Um, so whereas if you if you if they had a lot more flexibility as to how they could build that tower, it could have worked out, I think, in a more interesting way. But overall, I thought that was a really interesting challenge to watch. Like visually, it was fun to watch them build this tower. Uh, it was a flexible and creative challenge in terms of how they built the tower, how long the person stayed up there, when they chose to like try to grab the thing at the top. Just a really interesting challenge to to build a tower like that to get to something that's really high up and with not too many rules involved either. Um, so yeah, I really like that challenge. Overall, I thought season two was a really solid improvement over season 1 and I look forward to seeing the the show continue to grow and evolve in season 3. I'd love to hear your thoughts if you watched season two or season 1. Um, and let me know what maybe what your favorite challenge was, your favorite improvement, and if there's anything that different that you'd like to see happen in season 3 of Beast.

Thanks.

Progress saved