Charterstone: Review (SPOILER-FREE)
Transcript
hey guys Dylan here from AO SCB and today I'm bringing you my final thoughts on charter stone which is of course a village building a legacy game from Stone mire games this was a very tough game to review I feel like it was a game that had me at odds with myself normally I come out of a game and I ain't know how my how I feel about it whether I liked it whether I thought it was just okay whether I disliked it I felt like there was different parts of me that had different impressions with charter stone and I've never really felt that way coming out of a game before it definitely has some flaws and some things that you know I think it you know stumbles on but it's hard did I had just how addictive the discovery element is and that's obviously super important for a legacy aim if you if you don't feel like you want to come back to to keep discovering the secrets that has and you're curious what's in the box there's really no point playing a legacy game so it does some good things great as some things okay it's just a very it's an anomaly for me and I'm gonna try to you know explain that a little bit better and really unearth what it is that I thought about this game so let's just jump right into it but right before we do that I'm just gonna remind you that this is a spoiler free review I'm not gonna be showing you we're really talking about specifically any elements that you unlock later that being said I might generally allude to something but I'm gonna try to be as vague as possible and and only do it for the purpose of trying to get my thoughts so without being you know too vague and you not understanding what I'm talking about and I ramble for you know a bunch of sentence doesn't really provide no value to you so I'll do my best but again don't worry you won't see something you
don't want to see the surprises will be yours to discover let's jump right in let's talk about an area that charter stone truly shines I almost have nothing bad to say about this and that's the artwork and the components the component quality is amazing okay like I've come to expect that from stone Meier games it's great the coins themselves the gold coins that you use as a currency throughout the game are stunning you know they're that hard metal they're just really well-built to get a whole ton of them I was super shocked when I open those up just how I'm great a component they are all the the wooden pieces for all the different resources in the game the the pumpkins the the grain and all that are all shaped differently they're all colored differently they all have their own you know distinct look and feel to them awesome quality there the board is super bright and super well-designed all the cards have different characters animated on them but you know the assistant and bet inventor card the assistant broker card all the characters you know they have the same similar stance but they also just have a very distinct characterization and feel to them that makes it really really fun to just unlock things and see whichever other characters are in because you're naming them all you feel an attachment to them the persona cards same thing all the costumes and all the persona cards are all distinct they're all some of them are really funny we know one obviously after you unlock a water persona cards by the end it kind of loses its luster a little bit all the
characters there's the six characters they never change across the persona cards see it's the same character with just a different costume on them with the same expression and everything that kind of wears thin after a while but I understand why they did it wasn't a huge complaint to me just something that after playing twelve sessions you're probably yeah I get it the buildings are the probably my favorite part to unlock every building that you unlock that you stick onto the board has its own look to it some of them are hilarious the names you tie into the design the buildings I'll spend a bunch of time just looking at the card and checking out the buildings rather than take planning on my next turns so I have no complaints over are working components I think that they are phenomenal this is one area that charter stone just absolutely sticks the landing so as I said charter stone is a super unique type of legacy game think of any worker placement game that you have in your collection or that you've played that you're really fond of and basically deconstruct that game take out all like the different mechanics and different ways to score points and break down to the bare bones that's kind of what chars own starts as and as you play the game over these twelve sessions you basically build the final version of the game and that's really what drew me back to charters from the most I wanted to see what my end board was gonna look like I wanted to see what new mechanics are coming and you know what different twists and turns were around the corner and hiding them in the Box it that is the best part in my opinion of charter stone ahead of most legacy games but especially here also because of the fact that you're sticking you know buildings into your specific charter everyone has
their own charter in the game and you know just on the map in general there is this sort of engine building aspect to charter something I found super intriguing and that's that you can choose what you build in your own charter and oftentimes you're incentivized to go to your charter and other players can even be penalized for having to go to your charter or they may have to pay you or whatever the case may be so that that all aspects of the game is very important and the fact that you can build a little engine there say I'm gonna build this building and then I you you find it you know a way to construct another building that works with that building in unison it kind of develops your strategy over the 12 to 12 sessions now this super exciting system unfortunately has some flaws that come along with it one of those is that you know because you're building this game out as you go the base game that you start with is notably less exciting than the one you get you know on session 10 session 11 we didn't see that as a huge huge issue for us but I feel like if you're playing you feels kind of slow and not what you expected stick stick it out because it's going to evolve it's going to get a little bit closer to what you're probably hoping for also I haven't mentioned this is a competitive legacy game not cooperative and I found that you know interesting it may be as well put it just because it's some nice filling a competitive game that wanted to be a cooperative game and what I mean by that is we played with two players and often times I wanted my opponent to unlock things to to get new elements and new game mechanics so it felt like when he unlocked something it wasn't you know he got points for he jumped ahead of me
and I didn't even care it wasn't I wasn't even worried about the square I was just like what'd you get what'd you get what'd you get I wanted to see what he unlocked and what do you unlock you game whirring Justine got me more more engrossed in it and that that is a good thing that is a positive but at the same time it takes away this from this competition so if you're a really competitive person you're coming into this thinking oh cool competitive legacy game I never really felt like the competition would had enough weight to it so keep that in mind when you're looking to get into this one another weird issue we had is that because there's there's no set order to the way you unlock things so it's not like pandemic legacy where you know it's been planned out what you unlock in May or June or the general month frame or whatever in this game you know there's a sometimes a drastically different order you can unlock things depending which buildings you construct it and so on so we actually had aware you know I won't mention the components themselves of the game mechanics but we actually had it we're in game 11 the second last game we unlocked or game 10 we unlock a really major mechanic added new new cards and a new system and everything and because of how late that got added in and the two remaining games we played as part of the campaign we never even really experienced it so it was cool we we added them in and that was it we never really did anything with it that was disappointing because it was pretty a pretty cool mechanic oh I know we both look to each other and said man that would have been really cool till Mach 4 sessions ago you know and I suspect that could have been because we were playing with two players and which is another thing I'll mention is that we did the entire campaign with two it plays up to six and I have a pretty good feeling that this is one that you know they
would hope that you would play with five or six or four even I feel like playing with more players would probably up the competition a little bit more ever be more people to compete with more points going around the games would be a little bit longer and you'd be unlocking things faster so maybe that would the unlocking sure I said wouldn't be as much of an issue I feel like this might have been a game made to have those higher player accounts the problem is is that they want they really incentivize you to come back with the same group and it obviously it's harder to you know constantly meet with five people overall I had a lot of fun with chars and that's obviously a really important trait for a board game like this especially one that demands you to play over 12 sessions to get the full experience I never was dreading coming back to it I always wanted to come back and to see what else I was going to unlock I just think that that desire to unlock things and see more of what the game had to offer was greater than you know the actual gameplay I was experiencing a couple examples of that is you know the reputation track which is in the corner of the board you start off with that there and it's you know you compete there with whoever has the most tokens and whoever has the most look at ten points and seven and so on I found that that was sort of a dull area of the game for me and it might have been because the player count we were at you know there was only one other person I'm competing with on here for reputation compared to if there was five people jostling for position but I just felt like it was never something I actually pursued like I'm gonna you know go hard into reputation this game I would just get reputation while I was doing other things and I wouldn't really care if I didn't win because the point
differential between me and my opponent wasn't that big of a deal usually wasn't the deciding factor in a game likewise the progress track which is your timer for the game there's some interesting elements on it but you know the rewards you get from moving the progress track our reputation which I already didn't find too exciting and then the income marker which in our experience I won't get into what the income does but in our experience once we uncovered what it what it does and have that becoming element of the game that was super late in the campaign so really we wouldn't most of the entire most of our sessions not really utilizing the income and so the progress track was really just the timer and nothing else there was opportunities there for it to be more I just personally never really experienced that so I it felt at the progress of the reputation tracks of the board were just so underutilized and and there's so much untapped potential there now a big draw of charter stone one of the things that you know they really wanted want you to understand is that after your 12 sessions it's unlike other legacy games where you just you're done and you know you put on the Shelf you never open it again except to admire your work it becomes a fully functional worker placement game now on paper that sounds amazing that's such a great concept you spend the game on walking everything you go through this very unique one-time campaign and then you build to your own board game essentially as you go like I I think that that is a genius concept and a great design idea the only thing I'll say is the next in execution when the campaign was over this wasn't exactly a game that I realized had been drawing me back in because of how great
the gameplay was I could I could sit down and have a good time with it and I honestly think that people who maybe don't play worker placement games as often or you're wanting to introduce to that concept this might be your finished bore but honestly be a great way to do that because some of the concepts are just more simplified than then you know a game like champions of Midgard or you know bigger more feast road and you write like bigger worker placement games this might be a better entry way into that genre the very last thing we'll touch on is just that even though this is a legacy game and there is a story that goes throughout it it's not a it's not a very deep story and and you know who though I won't spoil anything but I found that it by the end it just sort of there wasn't this amazing climax it sort of just fizzled near the end I was still invested and it was still fun to watch a play out I just wasn't no it wasn't anywhere near as invested as you know I wasn't a playpen Demick legacy season one for instance I'm gonna end off by echoing what I said at the beginning of the review and that's that this is a very difficult game to review I have many competing thoughts here you know it's a fun game and I enjoyed my time with it and I constantly wanted to see all the secrets and everything and had to uncover but on the other hand that was the main thing drawing me back and more so than the actual gameplay and the things I was doing you know turn-by-turn which I think is a bit of a problem if you play this with four or five people you might have a vastly different experience than we did and the game you finish off with you might want to keep coming back to it that group now that it's finished and each try different charters and everything so I think that this is still a game
definitely worth checking out I just think that if you're coming in expecting a game akin to you know pandemic legacy or betrayal likes your Clank legacy you're gonna leave a little disappointed because I don't think it quite hits that tier but that doesn't mean it's not a good game in its own right thank you so much for watching if you enjoyed this video we have a ton more on our youtube channel if you thought this gave you a lot of good information or it helped you make your decision give it a like subscribe to us on youtube if you want to see more you can head over to our website at all you can board comm for a ton more content as well thank you so much for watching that we will see you in the next one you