Stars of Akarios Review - Hyperflop
Transcript
hey everybody it's space the final cardboard here here is a list of all the other cardboard tiers and these are the seven continent Voyages of the Starship groomhaven if you didn't know what any of that really meant then don't worry I'll explain in just a little bit but if on the other hand it sounded tried and conceited then we've just taken the first step to understanding why stars of vicarious fundamentally does not work sort of this is stars of vicarious an ambitious box of space toys from first time designer Brendan mccaskill in it you will take on the role of Starship Pilots hurdling through solar systems doing what I imagine all Starship Pilots do leveling up their abilities and looking for character upgrades ambition is an old Tale in board games ours is a hobby of passion and we tend to reward it the bigger the idea the grander the vision the more back is on Kickstarter in this case nearly a cool million Canadian a lot of people were willing to put some serious Dosh to see This Promise delivered so then what is that promise well it's Gloom Haven but in space ah this sounds so cool it's like an idea Taylor Made For Me look I'm a simple man I'm nearly in my 40s I like tactical turn-based combat and I like space shocking I know I bet it's not like more people in my demographic in board games
but it's not just any tactical turn-based combat it's gloomhaven tactical turn-based combat aka the game myself in the lane all the way back in 2017 named as our number one game of all time and the highest ranked game on Board Game Geek and the precursor to the highest funding tabletop crowdfunding project of all time which me and Elaine designed a scenario for which isn't really biased but it's like something I thought you should know imagine having this Stones nay the moons to put your own spin on that well it turns out even the moon wasn't big enough for Brendan because here comes a Galaxy brain level idea what if we ship even more genres together and add seven continent another Smash Hit heavily criticized by a channel into the mix and let that be a thing and just like that we have the basis for a game of magnificent scope you'll fly through space engage in Starship fights explore mysterious worlds upgrade your characters discover puzzles if I got something like that when I was 12 it would be the best toy I ever had my very own personal space adventure and this is where you say Africa that does indeed sound very juicy but Brandon mccaskill is a first time designer and gloomhaven and seven continent are both very big popular games can he possibly succeed at combining them
no welcome to NPI space camp it's just it's just like regular space camp except you can't wear an astronaut suit there is no Planetarium and you have to learn board game rules to understand stars and vicarious first we must understand space and for that we will need a lot of time get it because space and time of the same thing never mind it's too high brow for you the framework of stars of vicarious rests in space exploration here you'll move your very big spaceship from count to card interacting with various places denoted by numbers that lead you to a big book of story there's three different types of things you will find when you interact with a number there could just be some story text with a choice that will result in either a penalty or a reward there could be a scenario with an exciting space battle where you'll pilot your Starship weaving through hexagons and peeling your enemies or World exploration where you land on a planet and once again explore a map composed out of cards but this time in a more elaborate way hey look at that space camp is over anyone got any questions you're there with your hand up yes the toilet sign the corridor to your right two doors down I'm just kidding space camp is far from over there's so many more rules to learn but don't worry we're gonna start by putting our best foot forward onto the very stable surface of the first element we're going to dissect
is space combat the game's strongest suit when you start a campaign you'll be asked to pick a pilot and a Starship almost any combination is valid here because each of them provides statistics relevant to mostly World exploration or space combat also they both have a mini that and I can't wait to show this to you docks onto your player board literally docks because to be able to dock the Starship you have to flip over your stats you will need them when you're docked and when you undock your ship to go into combat you can flip the stats back up again this little detail makes me so unreasonably excited but it's not just that because if there's one thing stars of vicarious gets right it's presentation or more to the point how presentation reinforces gameplay everything you can do in space combat is right here on your player board want to peel your lasers there's cards with diagrams that show you exactly where you'll shoot and what it'll do want to zip past an enemy fighter and do a hard 180 to bombard their engines look there's a card that displays this specific maneuver other upgrades include pilot abilities ship abilities co-pilot abilities and Tech each has limited and that use is tracked by cubes also tracked by cubes is your Hull your Shields oh and stress wow sound effect
I'm sad now it's too much like real life everything is right here at my finger FIB in what feels very much like a pilot's control panel I guess immersive is the word here but I like to think of it as magical instead the enemy is right in front of me I press the proton blast button and kablam I can see that Ronin Scout through my viewport drifting listlessly in space its lasers reduced to a mere whimper no one can hear because it's space you can't hear whimpers in space that's science mechanically everything's powered by dice each Turn You Will Roll four three-dimensional lock cubes that can then be placed on various abilities of your ship as long as the icons match movement results will generally power movement abilities fighting results will pew pew your pews and stress results in more stress predictably but also it's a wild result because on stress you can do anything just like how I wrote this video in practice it results into a tantalizing cat and mouse each turn predictably you will find yourself in space but the thing about space is that there are spaces in it and for something that is literally nothing it can be quite tricky to navigate let's say you are facing a ronin frigate a big hulking Mash of
unsavory looking hexagons that will surely obliterate you if you do nothing about it well thankfully you have a weapon but the trick is that weapon will only do something if you can get the enemy into its firing Arc maybe you have a long shot something that can ignore the frigid's massive Shields and deal damage directly to its Hull a few lucky shots out of that might just take it out but uh oh it only fires in a straight line and uh oh it won't hit anything that's directly next to it and uh oh it won't hit anything that is too far away that is a lot of our outs to fulfill especially in a game where the way you are facing is part of the puzzle anytime you execute a movement maneuver you can only move along the pattern of the maneuver but it also takes into account where you were facing to begin with and rotating your ship is a luxury you can't always afford first it will Hoover up one of your four precious dice dice you could have used to unleash extra damage or fire at multiple targets second you can only rotate two hexes meaning that if there's an enemy directly behind you you're more likely to get in a better position by flying in a big loop which makes sense you're piloting a Starship not a dreidel as for shooting itself well it's pretty simple your attack will tell you the base damage that you are
dealing then you'll draw a card from your modify fire deck which could be say a plus two yay or a minus one Boo or in rare cases double damage that's your crit or you could miss entirely as you progress through the game and get abilities you will be able to modify your modifier deck take out a minus two for example that card is no longer in your deck for the rest of the campaign all ad cards with bonus effects and yes that is the gloomhaven part one for one it is however looser than its predecessor it isn't structured in a rigid manner there's no I go then you go anyone can activate any ability as long as it has Supply remaining you can spend dice at any point freely interchanging actions between players meaning if you're in a situation where you can't quite get that you're a gunship in your sights you can always ask your buddy to fly up to it first and hit it with its I don't know tractor beam now not only can you shoot it but also you were in its bottom Arc meaning you get advantage on your shots meaning you are a lot less likely to miss it's tactical crunchy and satisfying the fun part isn't shooting at spaceships it's figuring out how to get to the place where you can shoot at spaceships you're Korean and swerve and manage to outflank your opponent you put all your power into lasers direct here yes take that you run and Scout and then
you realize that you put your astronaut in front of three enemy Fighters and they will kick it once you and your friends have spent your full dice to power your ships it's the enemy's turn here they'll draw a card from a dedicated deck each type of spaceship having its own separate deck the card will say where they'll go and what they'll shoot and this is where it all goes wrong enemy behavior in this game is just a mess on multiple firing arcs there's a lot to be said about how clunky it feels to move these ships since facing matters and their movement is erratic and different each turn you have to adapt to unintuitive visual patterns figuring out which hexagon it is they end up in and since most of this map is literally empty space there's not enough visual Clues as you pivot the card to match to the ship's facing and then re-adapt for the next three enemies that all face in a different direction it just feels very nebulous talking of nebulous there will be times when enemy Fighters will do something stupid like fly into a nebula which damages their Shields and in games like gloomhaven where movement rules are much more defined and feels great because you're like haha I outwitted you take that you ooze here it feels unearned because you're not sure whether they flew into the nebula because they were meant to fly into the nebula or you flew them
into the nebula because you once again misunderstood how movement actually works because the movement rules are not very clear but that is just a quirk of the system the price you pay for gloomhaven in space except despite the inevitable comparisons by me every reviewer on the planet and pretty much what the game markets itself on I have to ask is this Gloom Haven in space because whilst it does Port over some of its systems in my opinion it ports over the uninteresting ones yes the modified decks character progression damage system are all recognizable to fans of gloomhaven are adapted nearly whole cloth and provide a good rigid structure but not the fun let's get back to enemy AI remember I mentioned that each ship type has its own separate deck of AI cards that implies that they have their own distinctive quirks and patterns of behavior and whilst I can't definitively state that that isn't true for example the Ronin frigid has a big area attack that the Ronin Scouts simply don't but these moves feel so circumstantial and in the margins they simply don't separate ship types enough to the point where the free defining features are how much Hull shield and attack they have the three things that are not on the AI cards the same can be said for player
abilities all of them are accessible to you at all times you don't have to create plans and setups you just have to push the button and fly or shoot or spin like the dreidel meaning that the turn to turn puzzle isn't how do I maximize my abilities and actions it isn't Dynamic and shifting it's just how do I shoot and I could use up one of my abilities but again that's not Dynamic I'll just use another shooting ability or the default shooting ability I have the need for shoot and I need to move so that I can shoot not what to shoot with not what weapon to save up for a harder enemy just shoot and that's a fine puzzle but not sustainable over there's like 150 scenarios in this game not all of them are combat scenarios and you won't encounter all of them but you know that James Bond intro where he walks sideways along the shot and then turns to the camera and then goes kablam exciting right well play that clip on repeat for a hundred times see how you feel about it then and you know what that's okay I did maybe say this isn't gloomhaven for a reason because that's not all this game is it is gloomhaven within the seventh continent Adventure framework so judging that alone would be foolhardy neither element was ever going to be the game's strong suit because the development for
each of the progenitus took years and years those over carriers does not have enough time to be stronger than either all it has to do is be competent at each of them more to the point at the beginning of this video I told you that this game does not work and so far all I've shown you is a game that isn't as interesting as it could or should be but I did not show you a non-functioning game and my argument is that it isn't functioning and I still stand by that because once again stars of vicarious is meant to be a holistic experience a melding of Adventure and tactical fighting and it is precisely this joint that holds the two together that buckles under pressure and collapses everything but before I can tell you why I have to show you the other side of this game and now you're like oh no it's back to space camp we're gonna have to learn rules again just so he can tell us that this isn't as good as seventh continent and well it isn't but that's not the point the point is it's really really quite rubbish the basic gist is that this is a Choose Your Own Adventure Style game but instead of being just a book everything is displayed on cards you examine the artwork find a prompt that looks interesting and then read that prompt in the book this could lead to a bit of flavor maybe a puzzle if you're lucky or Advance the plot in some way leading you
to another destination I do have a record of not liking this card based exploration Choose Your Own Adventure Style game a genre that despite its popularity only has a couple of entries probably because it's really hard to make one of these so much effort has to go into ah writing puzzle creation and a 10 system to hold it all together stars of vicarious technically does have all of these but just the faintest width of each so it can passes functional here's where it gets really weird because the explorative side of stars of vicarious can be then further divided into three different types of exploration one being the overarching space exploration where you'll fly a Starship and interact with numbers in the book and that'll lead to scenarios some of which could be space combat and others could be World exploration which can then further be subdivided into two different types that follow the same rules but have a different purpose and scope let's briefly dip into the space part I say briefly because it's dull and pointless I'm not being hyperbolic because you're not exploring as such you're just pushing this mini of the sparrow that has the stability of a piano going down a flight of stairs across cards to get to the next mission it does provide opportunity for random events or sometimes side missions not part of the main plot but I feel like this could have been done without the
need for me to tear down components and set up new ones each time I Advance the story The Hitch here is that anytime the sparrow moves or explores or does anything it has to spend one Supply and if you run out of Supply then you start taking penalties for future scenarios giving you the impression that there is a resource management situation going on here I've played through half of this gigantic campaign and not once did I feel the sting for the lack of Supply making this whole thing feel like a weak wet slap the world exploration has more rules for example you have energy that you spend each time that's the thing that lets you do things and if you run out of energy you start taking damage to health and if you run out of Health you could technically fail a scenario you also have four dice that you roll each round just like in space combat but here you roll them when you assign them to an action how many dice you need to assign is displayed on the cards themselves when you choose what to explore and it asks you to then roll certain results to succeed you can assign more dice than the minimum displayed on the action to ensure that you succeed but doing that means you might not have enough time to explore everything the adventure has to offer before your energy runs out problem is most of your dice meaning
actions will be eaten by just moving from card to card forcing you to roll and move but the only potential downfall here is that you might roll stress which will add to stress which once again in no weld exploration scenario has felt like an actual penalty so these dies here are just a restriction on how much you can do in a turn and how many turns you have is restricted by energy a mechanism that is important in what I will dub as little world exploration but perfectly resettable in Big World exploration all of these mechanisms can be summarized as faf an elaboration just so these cards can exist rather than any meaningful gameplay you also have stats that sometimes add to the total result required when the visual prompt specifically displays that particular stat and each pilot has their own Suite with future Pilots you unlock offering a bigger total towards their statistics that is sort of the rules and none of them work I mean once again make mechanically they provide a structure that the game rests on so that it can be functional but just like with space exploration you'll wonder why you're doing any of it because it's not interesting and without spoiling too much the game offers you shortcuts so that you can circumvent the rewards that you get out of it but then it still forces you to engage with these systems anyway let me explain the difference
between Little World exploration and Big World exploration which I'm not displaying here because visually is effectively the same thing it's just bigger but also I want to avoid spoilers it is also a contrivement because it's just a quest Hub you might encounter some characters or if you're lucky discover a side mission and when I say Quest Hub I am being generous it's more like a quest Fork if Forks were sad and only had two teeth the rest is filled with tiny poorly written vignettes most characters don't even have names just adjectives a tall person a short person a curious person a sad person um descriptors maybe I should write my reviews like that from now on a good game a bad game a tall game a little game done that's four games reviewed no complaints I'm not allowed to elaborate I am being mean but mostly because when I start exploring these worlds I'm so curious as to what I'll find here I mean the whole purpose of having these cards not just shortcutting through all of it mechanically is to give you a sense of wonder you're finding things and that should be interesting instead all I got was credits because that's the reward for like 90 of them the other 10 can be upgrades for your ship or even new pilots and new ships but I already get
enough of that stuff from just like the general shops or random space exploration events or just progressing through the main plot whenever they announce a new actor to take on the role of the doctor in Doctor Who the British kids show that's way too popular for its own good my father-in-law always says the same thing I'm glad there's a new person to take on the role and they look exciting but it won't matter at all if the stories aren't good ah finally we get to talk about the writing no scenario design Little World exploration uses the same rules as Big World exploration but it's self-contained vignettes a dip into some flavor and excuse me but I would rather dip stale bread into vinegar than play one of these again don't mean that as an acquired taste I mean they're disgusting not in an offensive way just I didn't like them but but we'll get to the often spot a little bit later the just mechanically so frustrating each one has its own spin but the only spin I feel here is my head turning and twisting trying to figure out who approved these never have I played a board game with such an acute sense that there is an invisible dungeon master masterminding all of this who designed an RPG session solely to have fun for themselves without a thought about the
other four people at the table and whether they're having fun they're not they'd rather be scrolling through Twitter than indulge this nonsensical Adventure again not being hyperbolic there is a little world exploration scenario where you could reach a fail State between the ranges of turn 18 or turn free what determines that some die rolls independent of anything else that you are doing roll a die see if the scenario ends I mean that's good isn't it that's normal gonna take this opportunity talking about scenario design to dip back into space combat and my setting realization that this game might just be half baked as early as my fifth scenario I got a big clue that someone didn't think this through when I played a space combat mission where my best bet at succeeding in a scenario that technically had no fail state was to do nothing that's right just fly away and hope that the cards come up right I'm trimming away some details here but that is the gist of it oh and the bugs there's more bugs in this game than an Adrian Tchaikovsky book when om games got in touch with me to see if we wanted a review copy of stars of a carriers they did warn me that they were working on ironing out some arrows so I was primed for a game that wasn't a hundred percent cohesive but I was not ready for this it goes without saying that the rule book isn't great but it's what they print it on the cards that's the real
culprit some cards show effects that don't correspond to their effects as explained in the rulebook for example this card shows you that you can perform one of the two basic movement Maneuvers whereas the rulebook says that this card's effect is choosing either of the two basic movement Maneuvers and this is not the only card that does this this copilot has one name on the front a different name on the back of course if you try to find that other name on another card's front it has the other name on the back which one is which is impossible to determine that's just a couple of the examples of the Myriad of misprints that I found and by the time I got to the scenario that is the same paragraph printed four times in a row all I could say was well of course it is to the credit of the designer they are actively answering rules questions on BGG and with a can-do attitude you can put together the big picture I'm mentioning this less to be like oh ho ho look at all these bugs although dude look at them but to display the whole cloth of this game which is that there is only half the cloth the ambition of stars of vicarious is the melding of two gigantic genres the reality of stars of a carriers is that the design team got a good start with space combat and then my guess didn't have time to develop the rest of it I think that's why I'm so
disappointed because if it didn't feel so Half Baked I think this would have the potential to be a truly memorable experience whilst I did complain that a lot of this exploration could have been abstracted that argument ignores what the exploration adds a sense of a universe filled with characters locations and surprises and it is but notice I didn't say cool characters or interesting locations or unexpected surprises those were the adjectives I would have liked to have seen also as a side note whenever we review a campaign game we get comments saying oh it's just the reviewers blitzing through it and then they get burned out on the game and don't like it please I've done this reviewing log for a while now give me some credit I know what I'm doing I really took care to try and enjoy stars of Aquarius I was excited for it what frustrates me is how close this game feels how inspired its ideas are it's on the verge of not just working but being one of the most interesting designs out there I wanted to take these ideas from gloomhaven and seven continent and use them as antimatter fuel to hyperspace punch into new unexplored territories instead it uses them to prop itself up and trundle over the finish line of a three-legged race that other competitors have long finished and now have gone to get lunch leaving stars of a carriers alone behind and very tired blending two
genres together means you're balancing two very heavy things on a tight rope if both are meant to be the star of the show if both want to stay on the Rope then both have to be as strong as each other stars of vicarius is far from getting that balance right you'd think it would just topple immediately but instead it just drifts aimlessly into the vast nothing when I say stars of vicarious doesn't work I don't mean mechanically everything in here eventually rube Goldbergs itself if you apply enough elbow grease but the promise of stars of vicarious was never mechanisms it was an experience and that experience is nowhere to be found when I was learning to write in University there was one piece of advice that was consistent between all lecturers Read Bad Books if you don't read bad books you'll never learn how to write well because you won't be able to avoid the pitfalls of others so this then is my final recommendation don't get Stars over carriers unless you are interested in designing in this space and need to learn what not to do or you sew into board games that you don't mind buying a disaster for let's call it academic research reasons just don't buy it now this wouldn't be the first campaign game that ended up as a mess it can stand proudly together with C4 gen 7 discover lands unknown all can be found in bargain bins for 15 and
right now stars of vicarious is a hundred and seventy plus another 70 if you want the Miniatures for the enemy spaceships which is a fair price it is aesthetically very nicely produced and there is a lot of stuff in here so for research purposes one day this will hopefully be a bargain but for now the only Merit it manages to achieve is that it made me bored of space something I thought was genuinely impossible and that is that now let's talk about why this game made me a little angry in a special new MPI credit segment we're tentatively titling politics and board games whenever we touch on more sensitive subjects we always get comments from people saying leave politics out of board games well I want all the people who've ever left that comment to line up and say it again because not a great show here for stars of vicarious okay I'm obviously being facetious in a way I'm glad that stones are vicarious is getting political if any board game setting deserves it surely space sci-fi would be it right I mean talk about a rich history of complicated subjects from Aliens commentary and corporate dismissal of the working class to Dunes tackling of environmental issues to more recent novels like her Katie Martins a memory called Empire and it's dissection of
Imperial sublimation or Adrian Tchaikovsky novels and all the spider politics or and politics or sometimes shrimp politics even when sci-fi isn't trying to be political it ends up being it anywhere and the people writing it know that here is an excerpt from the acknowledgment section of a John scalzi book who is self-admittedly a Rockefeller Republican as a second side note I will also note that the title of this book The collapsing Empire was not intended as a commentary on the current state of the United States the United Kingdom or of Western civilization in general I thought it up years ago it just happened to look like commentary because let's face it 2016 was a historically 40 year and I can only hope that 2017 is going to be better because if it's not it really is time to head to the bunkers with our barrels of beans and rice don't worry John everything is Peachy now this is so very clearly someone who says they had no political intentions but recognizes that despite that his book is political anyway because sci-fi creates Rich complex worlds and without politics those worlds feel empty so what are stars of vicarious do well in my short time with this story I got treated to such wonderful ideas like military essentialism and if we don't fund the
military then very bad things will happen descent is the worst and anyone who organizes against depression are just thugs statues on the other hand are very important even when they are built for very bad people The Establishment literally The Establishment is great but is murdered in too much red tape and some other ideas that borders slightly too close on real world conspiracy theories propagated by creeps once again I think I'd just rather scroll through Twitter it is probably somehow less harmful to my mental well-being I'm not even sure how much of it is intentional because so much of stars of vicarious feels like it's just cobbled pieces from Star Wars or Star Trek or Starship Troopers but not the verhoven Starship Troopers the Heinlein Starship Troopers and there's this line of both siding things that feels roped in as a defense mechanism when the game very clearly shows you the cards in its sleeves because the rest of the world building and the characterization is non-existent so this po-faced political drivel is the only thing that stands out so congratulations stars of vicarius you brought politics into your board game and despite that it's still utterly Barren hey you might be saying that was a very mean review and you're right it was if you didn't enjoy that I left a very positive video for you to watch if on the other hand you did enjoy a little
bit of deserved meanness then here's a playlist of all the bad games we've ever reviewed and if you really really enjoyed all of it then we have a patreon and and you can always support an open included by donating to that Patron and ensuring that we keep making videos we've got an exciting one coming up next very very soon