Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 17:46

hey gamers this is liz davidson from beyond solitaire and today i'm going to be reviewing merv heart of the silk road this is a euro game designed by fabio lopiano with art by ian o'toole which as you can see is beautiful and is published by osprey games so here is merv all set up for a solo game and as you can see this thing is a liquor this is a beautiful example of iano tool art and it's one of the main selling points of the game for me i just want to point out like even where the cards sit there's a little color coding to help you place everything just so and there's just something about that that really pleases me but as you can probably tell from the look of it this is a i took like a mid-weight euro game that takes a little bit of time to learn but then once you've got going it is fine so here you were in the city of merv the idea is to try to score the highest on the score track going all around the board and i'm gonna briefly talk you through some of the ways to do that without hopefully getting too bogged down in technicalities essentially what's gonna happen is this game takes place across three years one two three and each year has four turns in it so there are 12 turns in the game the first turns are going to feel really quick and later turns are going to take a bit longer because there's just going to be more that you're able to do and a lot more to be looking at and thinking about so in a solo game what's going to happen is you've got three players but only one is human one is you so you've got you you have the corrupted magistrate and then you have the high court here so what's going to happen is you're going to play your turn just the way any human would uh the corrupted

magistrate is gonna play according to some very cheap unfair rules because they are in fact the corrupt magistrate they're gonna have a whole turn and then the high courtier is also used in a two-player game and all they do is buy for turn order to be annoying and place buildings and as in a two-player game the way the high quarter is going to work is basically one person will choose the space that the high quarter goes on and the other will choose the actual building and there's a way for you and the corrupt magistrate to do that essentially what will happen on a turn is that each player is going to choose a spot somewhere along this row or this one or this one depending on which turn it is so turn one everyone's along here turn two everybody places along here turn three turn four and then you'll have a new year and then once you've placed your meeple then what you're going to do is you're going to choose a place to either build a building or activate somebody else's buildings so let's say that i want to go on the mosque track which is over here i would put a building right here on this spot i would get a blue cube because i landed on a blue place so there's cubes that are different currencies in the game so you get tan purple orange and blue so take a blue cube and then i would have a choice of what to do so on your turn once you've placed a building or activated a building according to your choice then there are three options you can gain favor and that's something that you do down here basically it allows you to score at the end of each year for wherever you're putting your meeples but

you have to have favor in order for the meeples that you place down here in different areas of court to actually score so you need to have courtly favor so that you can place meeples in these different areas and then get bonus scores for them at the end of each year if you don't want to gain favor another option is to place a soldier so if you want to place a soldier that means putting one of your meeples right here on this spot so let's say that for some reason i wanted to place a soldier here basically what that would mean is that my building was protected in case of a mongol attack so basically what happens is that in the second and third years as you can see down here you get some mongol invasions and basically they come in and they destroy parts of the city and if you have unprotected buildings then you lose them and then that part of your engine and part of your research generation dies off which you don't want if you don't want to place a soldier then your last choice is to take the action associated with the building spot that you just activated so in this case i'd be able to take an action with the mosque and if i had let's say a blue cube i could pay that blue cube to move and start advancing on this mosque track so i could decide that i'm gonna take this camel pay that cue but i never actually picked up and i would actually get to keep the camel which has a use that i'll describe momentarily so there are several different action types you can take based on the building but because your opponents are in here jockeying with you that's going to create some problems because they're also going to be aiming for different actions and giving you trouble but essentially you can do the mosque track you can take a wall action where you take one of these walls you pay a resource cost for it and then you place

it along the size of the city in order to protect your buildings or the buildings of others and that protection by the way gains you influence which is just another track up here and the influence track is crucial because it allows you to collect more types of spices and collecting spices is a way to get points so you want to make sure that your influence is doing well so what's interesting is that you get a little bit of influence to protect yourself but you actually get a little extra influence if you protect the buildings of someone else so there's a bit of a semi-cooperative thing going on here other things this board will let you do are place courtiers down here so that you can score later which is pretty key you can build a trading post which means that you can come over here and basically place your disks to create safer routes out into the desert that allow you to acquire common and less common goods so this is just a resource generator over here and as you can see the symbols will match so you know what buildings let you do what this is the library you want to collect scrolls because scrolls allow you to pick up breakthroughs that give you special bonuses throughout the game some of which are extremely valuable such as letting you trade a cube as any color or basically other things that make it easier to score easier to gain advantage you can also come over here and collect goods cards and you want to be sure that you have some options here because once you take cinnamon for example if you can only trade one sort of good based on your influence track well guess what you can't pick up anything but cinnamon until you get a little further up in your influence the other thing that you can do with all those resources you're collecting by the way is uh come

out here and fulfill contracts which are also really nice because they are a way to score points scrolls they use to fulfill a contract by the way also still allow you get breakthroughs so it's totally worth spending your scrolls to fulfill these so essentially what you're looking at is a whole lot of interlocking actions that people are going to compete to take because for example you need to place meeples here in order to score you need to think about where you might want to invest in order decide where you want to place your meeples because you're going to have limited favor your influence impacts what you can collect over here and therefore what you can score for down here the mosque gives you some all-around bonuses that are really handy and you're gonna always need to be producing resources which means you need buildings down here and you need to be able to trade along these trade routes and you can do things like spin camels that you collected out of the game to do this without creating trading posts but in the long run that's less efficient so you want to make sure you're coming out here and doing what you need to do and so back to the middle because that's the trigger for all of these different actions you're coming here and you're activating buildings and i'm not looking at any rules of particular right now but let's say that a meeple is here and a maple is here basically what's going to happen is that they're going to place buildings along here and then you're going to figure out who's actually the first player in the next round so if you go by default it's going to be yellow blue and then red will go first because it's just the most advanced along the row or column who is going to be first however because yellow

gets to choose that first it's possible that they would do something like pay to camels we're just going to borrow these camels from over here they would put camels down for each spot they wanted to advance and then you get sort of like a camel consolation prize as you get forced back in the line so because really wanting a certain action is going to make you want to go first you might want to collect some camels and force your way up and that's something that both of the ai players in this game are going to do they're going to want to go first and it breathes some of that multiplayer feeling back into the solo game so another thing that's kind of interesting about this game is that the more buildings of your color you have along a row or column the more you're going to get out of each turn so you can do something like place a building right here maybe with the intention of taking another mask action but i'm also going to get a tan cube a purple cube and a blue one because i'm activating all my stuff there's also kind of fun stuff going on in the center where you can actually place a camel to take one of the bonuses in the center of the city so you're going to want to spatially plan out your moves the other thing is interesting about this game though is that you can actually activate other people's buildings as well but they get one of the resources that is on their buildings for doing that so you don't want to do it too often because you're just giving free stuff to your enemy and not building any of your own board presence yourself so again this is one of those games where you only have so many turns you're going

to feel like there's so much that you want to do it's going to make you a little bit crazy especially because your opponents will be blocking you off at every turn even in solo and you will just want to get so much more every turn than you actually can especially early on so this is one of those games that i played very badly the first few times and i got a bit better because i had a sense of how all these interlocking mechanisms were going to fit the other thing that's very cool is that this game does have a solo mode that's run by these simple cards the rule book is going to give you further direction in terms of deciding what the priority is going to be for the crowd to magistrate how to make decisions for him but you're also going to have these cards and what's interesting is that there are six cards in the deck there are four turns per year but at the end of the year after you've pulled these cards where he's gonna try to take certain kinds of actions so a library action he'll go up to purchase some goods he's going to make a bid on the favor track or he's going to build caravan routes what makes this interesting is that after he's taken these four actions during the year you actually shuffle these four cards in the discard and put them back on top of the deck so instead of being able to sort of predict oh he's gonna do something different this turn that might not be in his interest you essentially accidentally develop a strategy for the ai every game because what happens is that um they keep playing the same actions again and again which kind of represents a player focusing on what they want the most and then of course if the if the ai can't take an action then it will keep digging through its deck until it can

much as a human player might have preferred actions and then have to revert to plan b or even c depending on what else other people hogged up on the board so that's a bird's eye view of merv this is one of those games that takes a while to teach it takes some practice to learn but i wanted to give the best just overview possible instead of trying to hit every single point so now that you've got a sense of interlocking mechanisms what the game generally looks like and what your general goals are let's have some final thoughts so now for some final thoughts i do think there's a lot to appreciate about mirv i think that the interlocking mechanisms and how hard it is to get what you want done while competing with space for other players is very puzzly and i think it's satisfying for players who like that in fact the solo mode was fine but i suspect this game may actually be better multiplayer because of the more thoughtful competition for space and resources between sentient players so the solomon's perfectly good um it works just fine but this game is clearly meant to be a fairly confrontational euro game and i think that having a person to have a confrontation with is great especially since it's thanksgiving week and this is the perfect time for confrontations with your family and friends there's no question that the graphic design is beautiful ianotul's art is just stunning he's done it again there's no surprise there and i love how games with iano tool art um have a really beautiful blending of form and function so the art is gorgeous

but it also tells you how to play the game visually which i think is really helpful so all of that said merv is a solid totally decent euro game and i think that people who like games like this will also like merv that said i don't want to recommend it any higher than that for a couple of reasons the first is that a lot of the mechanisms in merv didn't feel fresh they were put together nicely and everything in the game worked but there are other euro games that just get my heart pumping a lot faster like i'd rather play tricarion again any day and i think that's partially because even though everything works together fine in this game i don't really feel like it's pushing the envelope of euro games it just feels like another euro game in a different flavor for people who like them a little bit crunchy so if you're just looking for that this is gonna fit the bill if you're looking for like the next life-changing euro then probably not murph the other thing that i think detracted from this one for me a little bit though is that i don't think that the theme and the mechanisms were fully married to each other in the way that i really really like and i think that's where my sense of distance from this game comes from so the theme of merv i think could have been really exciting i really like the idea of a middle eastern theme i know that they hired a cultural consultant for this game the art is spot on in terms of like making me recall my own travel to the middle east so i had high hopes for this however it actually just ended up feeling kind of sterile like you really could have

pasted any theme onto this game and it would have been fine and i think that's kind of a waste i also think the way the theme was set up generally is a little bit off so basically the idea of merv is that you know this is during the time city of prosperity you're traders you're trying to make a bunch of money you're trying to be really successful and the mongols are kind of on the horizon about to invade so a couple times during the game you just have like a casual mongol invasion you only really think about it in terms of like your economic prosperity and not really in terms of the fact that you just got your soldier killed that you put out there but the other thing that's funny is it's like you're just fiddling while merv's about to burn um this is this lovely idyllic time before the city gets totally wrecked and never fully recovers and i find that just sort of an odd choice like you're sitting here having fun and dancing along on the precipice of something terrible but there's no awareness of that in the actual gameplay um the invasions just feel remarkably chill for an invasion by an enemy army and to add to that i could tell that they were trying to kind of make the goods really cool like um they're peaches and that city was known for like the high quality of its peaches you know they're little touches of theme that are cool except that they don't really come out in the gameplay i really didn't feel like i was doing anything except pushing cubes and a cube pusher has its place but given a theme like this an art like this i just felt that it was wasted

especially because there aren't enough games with great representation of the middle east of mosques of all kinds of things that this game could have done but instead really you could have just set this in medieval europe and it would have been the same game so i think the reason i don't get as excited when i play mirv is that it is functionally fine but i looked at the theme i got excited about the possibilities that theme and then the game really didn't deliver and even in euros i like to really feel like i'm doing something that is aligned with the theme of the game i find that that makes it easier to learn merv's kind of a beast to learn but i think it's because it's so abstracted and i think it's equally difficult to teach for that reason because you can't just say oh you know so for example liz boaz notoriously crunchy as a euro game i find that one a lot easier to learn and teach because everything in the game links to something real historically that has to do with the theme and that's not really true in merv so it's still a good game if i had to give it a rating and i'm trying to stop doing that in here i'd give it like a solid 7 out of 10. it's fine and if you love euros and you're looking for a fresh one i think you'll enjoy it but i also think there were some missed opportunities here both in terms of pushing the envelope mechanism wise and in terms of really embracing the theme and making it something more than a visual flight of fancy and you know for me as a gamer that's

something that really matters so totally decent euro if you're looking for one it's fine uh but i wouldn't say more than that thanks for watching and happy gaming so you

Progress saved