Black Rose Wars: Duel - Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlock Dev and I are doing a discussion over black rose Wars dual Lex uh yeah so this is the the deluxe uh whatever copy so your box might not look like this yeah it's limited edition limited our get on level yeah only people who uh have money can get the the limited edition it's really what it is uh anyway so this is basically Black Rose Wars uh as a two-player game uh specifically designed for two players um because apparently no one likes the original Black Rose Wars at two I've never played it at two I actually am going to play the new one rebirth at two cuz a friend of mine he got the copy and he wants to see if it's any good at two um but when this was announced I was actually really excited because of that like black rose Warriors has always been a game that's really big on having a bunch of players bunch of different Mages different schools that you're you know you're comboing um you know vying for control on who's killing who mhm um and duel itself um I kind of have mixed feelings on it because the game comes with one school of magic which is like this Templar Crusader um School uh seems to really
focus on getting the undead templari out buffing them with abilities and kind of activating them a lot uh not a whole lot of direct interaction I mean there is like we were both using the same school yeah okay yeah in in Black Rose Wars duels you have one school gotcha that you pull from in regular black rose Wars which I know you've only played maybe a handful of times um there are there are a bunch of schools uh and one amazing thing black about Black Rose Wars is the sheer variety of schools you can so do you like pick your school at the beginning yeah so each M get your own personal school no well so in the original each Mage had a specialty of school um but that really just meant you know how we had these these personalized cards were shuffled into our deck had our picture on them um each Mage uh kind of has those shuffled into the school deck but they're all Universal any Mage can pull from any school at any given time okay so you know we have the study phase where we draw to from our deck mhm in the regular game you draw two from your deck and then you draw from uh two from any number of schools got that are available um but yeah in Black RS Wars there is one school that both players are sharing mhm and the game comes with just one school which again really big on summoning the undead templari giving them giving them like abilities like explosive bones and and Bone Shields and having them out on the board a lot MH
um I don't know if the if I'm not like vibing duel itself which is really interesting cuz I thought I would really like it cuz I love black rose Wars I think it's an awesome dual like something about duing Mages that theme is just super cool to me but so I'm wondering if it's just the system of black rose Wars Duel or if it was the school of magic that just wasn't that exciting it felt very basic yeah hey summon these they go and punch someone M hey deal three damage to someone right I yeah I I it's been a while since I played and I played it maybe once maybe twice at most the original black world it was Wars with you right um so I don't have a lot of reference to like how they compare um that's why I'm here yes so with this game am I able to bring in I'm able to say Swap this out with another school of magic yes so that is one thing that's amazing about this is it even says Beyond The Duel so duel the material in this box can be used to expand Black Rose Wars The Lex can be put into the regular game forgotten spells can get added Bartholomew and R the two Mages can be added and the rooms so everything from here is compatible with all black rose War stuff gotcha Black Rose war is in the Dual School of magic you may replace the Le School magic with any school of magic from the other products making sure to include in the game all the materials necessary due to the head-to-head challenge nature of this game some of the schools of magic that develop complex tactics may not be
impactful in a duel it should also be kept in mind that if a school of magic involves the use of additional rules they will need to be consulted of the core game rules and stuff and then forgotten spells the all the Forgotten because there's a ton of the Forgotten spells not just two the game just comes with two forgotten spells in the base game of this uh all of those can be added gotcha uh all the Mages from all the black can be added okay um and then all the rooms so these seven rooms besides the um uh I guess you may replace the seven rooms with so I guess you don't have to have the Black Rose Room mhm so yeah pretty much everything is backwards compatible and compatible like you can use all this stuff in the other stuff you can use that stuff in here yeah um so you can do the uh occult school you can do the Bic school you can do the destructive school you can do um I mean they have one that's basically cthulu school like any school but it still is just the one school right I'm not sure with the structure of game uh how I feel about the 1 V one yeah I um so yeah with the with this one we were running into you know we're we're drawing from the same decks essentially MH I'm getting a lot of cards that say oh hey it's a lot of templari manipulation you know summon a templari you know uh give him a buff activate the templari um lose a point uh activate the templari and it's
uh it felt very limiting I felt like I was top decking quite a bit like I'm like okay this is the cards we got like one like okay I get a bunch of hits um and then cool sometimes they get a good hand sometimes like okay it's all a bunch of templaria manipulation I have no templaria and you haven't summoned any yeah so I'm just going to eat [ __ ] right uh yeah or I'm drawing all the ones that just deal damage like like first turn of the of this game was oh deal you deal two damage to me I didn't die four I'm going to do it again yeah um so I dealt eight damage in one round and it's like I just happened to draw this mhm uh the quests I'm not a huge fan of I yeah they're both visible like you said before that they're personal I think I'd like that better uh yes I don't like competing and they're so broad that either one of us could go for them and again you said that was a turn order thing yeah because it's it's as soon as someone meets that then they can announce that they completed the quest but because turn order matters if I play three you know instant spells or combat spells before you do it's like oh okay because I got to go before you yeah then hey I did my three before you I'm going get my points mhm and they give you points they give you points I mean the Black Rose kind of deals damage um to you like there's like a penalty for completing them yeah but you you get points and really you're also preventing the Black Rose from getting points and I will say the Black Rose gets a little bit more involved in this um it almost
feels like the black rose in this is meant to replace a third player yeah just like an extra yeah cuz they have events like in the original game there was a deck of three different decks of events depending on the phases of the game game and it's like the black rose would be instigated and involved that way here it's like there's four turns in the game mhm and it's like okay black rose phase it does that so you know exactly what the Black Rose is going to do the entire game because the game's only four rounds so it's like okay well it's going to place instability it's going to convert damage it's going to place damage it's going to do this and that's that um here's my biggest thing of why I'm not really diging this and it kind of goes back to the fact that there's one school in original Black Rose it felt like okay you're this type of school you studied divination mhm like and I mean and nothing ever stops you from going like hey I'm going to play a bunch of divination and then go into destruction Nothing Stops you from you know developing a deck to get cool combos that's the beauty of black rose Wars It's freedom in that um but you could very much be like my Mage specializes in illusion I'm only going to pull from the illusion deck so it's a an illus Illusionist and if you pull from Transfiguration we have two completely different game styles on how we're competing right here I felt no different from you yeah it was the exact same it was the exact same it's like oh man no thrill I felt the whole M it felt very
yeah what's what's just uh you know just going through the motions yeah it's like oh oh I got the bolt spell that you also can cast yeah exactly I got the I summon a templari oh I I transformed your templari and made him attack you exactly there also wasn't really a whole lot of like cuz in original Black Rose Wars again you have defensive spells that you don't reveal they're kind of like they're trap cards MH so it's like I'm going to activate this and you place a token on it and it's like that's activated that was one of my two activations but you don't know what that is so you get to do that you activate my trap card oh okay cuz a lot of them can be like it definitely needs that because and again I think it's mainly a problem with the Lex school that's not what it's meant to do right but it's also a hindrance because it's like it's the one school mhm so like say if we swapped out the leg school and we did like illusion how would that go from what you know of the illusionary school the illusionary does a lot of traps a lot of like oh you went to attack me I'm not actually there um you can do like uh like teleportation um stuff there's uh it's it's a lot of like traps and conditional um spells mhm but they're not heavy attack yeah like this would be fun if we had completely different schools I guess I feel like would be better that would make sense to the duel yeah I wasn't yeah I was double-checking I'm like I'm like maybe I missed the setup but because the game only came with one school that's all they want mhm
like it'd be dumb if they were like hey actually each Mage can have their own school it's like but you only provided One MH so no the game is meant to be be one school I guess we're dueling Lex Mages is or the agreed is like we used this school before the battle or something right uh but it it becomes very like you just don't feel like an individual like nothing differentiated me from or to Bartholomew except I had one more hit point than you and you can hold one more card than me yes which I never built up enough of a hand but yeah but also at the same time some schools absolutely would not work divination for example uh does a lot of quest deck manipulation pulling a bunch of quest seeing the future and seeing the tops of decks and stuff gotta there are no Quest cards in this um and I really yeah hate the the face up Quest what I originally thought was like because they're the the board I actually really like like I like how very organized like it's like yeah so everything that you're keeping track of uh the board has punch outs in it to keep track of cubes and stuff mhm I like that but because because it's so segmented your side my side I thought the quests were tied to each of us like only I can do these only you can do that but that nothing in the rules that I found segmented it they're just there so at any point and that would also be dumb because one because some not all quests are created equal like if they were segmented like only I can do these and only you can do those M then if I did all three of these I would only get one
two i' get four points you can get five yeah um with them not really being any harder uh to do so and another thing there's only these two Quest cards I mean they're double-sided so oh that's it yeah that's it so it's also very very minimalist there's only these boards um so there's only this turn order I mean it's again it's double-sided but it's either yeah it's either these four events or these four events for one game feels kind and that one school feel kind of lazy it really does it feel again it kind of feels like a cash grab like hey people are complaining about black R war is not being good at two here's a two-player thing it's really good if you have all the other content mhm but this yeah this alone would I would hate this yeah this is literally it two Mages and again all the Mages in the original one have special abilities mhm tied to them you don't have to do that but they all can be a little bit more unique mhm um so ol to Bartholomew or barthol Mouse barthus MH uh there's only those two nothing really different one extra hit point that that can be handy um only two forgotten spells mhm the seven so there's nothing like I like the the the
box is empty this is it yeah I don't remember how much I think it was like like 50 bucks yeah um so it's just kind of like a glorified expansion it really feels like hey I want everything for Black Rose Wars I don't give a [ __ ] about this uh I'm just I want to add this to my existing stuff which I have everything for Black Rose Wars so this is like oh hey great seven more seven more locations two more Mages another school and a few more I guess a new mod to fight with that's just kind of but here's the thing I would never I would never play this like I would much rather just deal with play Black Rose Wars yeah at it felt more significant at least that's from what I can remember and the I think like this is a game that I feel would be better with a group fight 100% because again here's the other thing when you're dealing damage there's actual thought into who you want to attack like do I want to divide and conquer and have a little bit of damage on everyone so when they die I get some points do want to hyper fixate on one positioning matters cuz the board's a lot bigger my problem with this is movement didn't matter because the cards the school has to accommodate for being able to go into the other game these weren't designed specifically for which I appreciate it'd be annoying if we just had this it's like oh can incorporate this but almost all of the cards had a range of two yeah well and then you're hitting anyone anyway literally anyone mhm but that won't matter that that actually matters in the other game because it's a lot
bigger so range matters yeah movement matters um and so it's like this might be a really badass school to hyperfixate in a massive board where you just kind of summon and buff up your own skeleton Templar Army and you send them out to just be like hey by the way yeah it has explosive bones I'm going to move it out there and I'm going to dis you know disarm it so it blows up in a room of three Mages M it's like you guys were all fighting and then this you know this [ __ ] kamakazi just blow yeah all of that is what makes it exciting and it's like hey this is my school I'm this old Templar Mage that you know his Spirit has stayed in that's my theme you're this other one who's all about nature or turning yourself into a different creature mhm um but this on its own oh God like no yeah yeah um cuz the first time that we played this I we we called it the wash because it's like you didn't do any of the Quest and you still didn't really do any of the quest I'm like I'm still like kind of bewildered how you shot so far ahead uh so the Black Rose Room got me six points killing you three times got me nine points that's 15 already yeah um and then I got two three four from that and then end game yeah yeah um so I mean it's there but it's like I didn't feel like I worked harder than you you
and one great thing about Black Rose Wars that's always been it hasn't it wasn't never a player elimination you die it's like okay you dealt you know you dealt six damage to me Keith did three Mason did two and then distributes points and then it's like okay you get three points Keith gets two Mason gets one um which is good because you might not have as many points as everyone so you kind of jump up there was a and it was always about who had the most points by the end of the game um you can I mean Quest give you points in in the original but again those are cards that you draw and you have specific goals you don't have to fight anyone like if your quests don't align to that you can go all quests and be like I'm going to get a bunch of points this way this on its own I think is literally just I mean if you're a completionist get this so you have more content for the much better version mhm this is I mean the the cover is [ __ ] sexy mhm but I don't know they also have this weird thing they have another game called Nova what is it Nova a this it's like some Renaissance game I keep seeing a bunch of their stuff that's like supposed to be cross compatible and I'm like what is this game why are they keep promoting it um and that's kind of what this is that's why it's like the Templar theme because that's kind of what the Nova adus their other game is gotcha so I don't know what why I mean why this was even made if they didn't provide any content for it and the way that they put the title is dual left well Lex is the school of magic so are
they going to make a dual something else yeah huh cuz you think it would just be called Black Rose Wars Duel but then they have Lex it's like no it's the that's the school of magic so that's it yeah well if they lets them make more content but make you spend more money on it I guess they'll just keep doing that they will and I'll get it so I can have stuff to put in the original in the original game um and I know this is kind of based off their new system of rebirth so the other big difference is in the original black the one you've played it was all the rooms had abilities okay but as you were casting spells like doing a [ __ ] ton of Destruction spells and stuff you were putting you still putting instability but as that filled up it destroyed the room so it lost the ability oh in in rebirth the theme is like the black rose is like trying to build itself back up so it kind of does the opposite like this does where it's like none of the abilities are here but as they as they as we put inst stability back into it it flips and now the ability is there gotcha it's different um I haven't played rebirth yet so I don't know if I'm going to like that more funny enough the first time I play rebirth is actually going to be as a two-player game yeah so I'll be able to directly compare that to this but I was like Devon hates this game it's not great I'm not vibing it it didn't feel zesty I I mean we just
did Mythic battles I'm like that was way better as a skirmish first fighting game yeah so like I kind of felt into that one but this one I'm like okay I got my one guy to do my one couple of spells the only like the complexity is like the order that they go off of right and it's still the one the one school we're both doing the same [ __ ] thing exactly yeah that was I think this game could have worked if they if they at least put in two schools and said each Mage picks one cuz like the diff I guess I should say the difference is each school and I I'd have to double check but I'm pretty sure every school has like two forms about it okay that was the difference was you picked so you start with those six I pick Knight I start with those six that was our diff but the problem is is like they these specifically did not feel different enough um whereas the other game I feel like they do but even then it's like I don't know I would I would have much rather just had it be like hey it's duel here's two schools like do the what what is it well like who who were the um enemies of the Templars think I thought there was like two factions you think yeah I am actually uh
yeah you could do like do an assassin school yeah like the the The Lex and then do the Assassin so one Knight one player picks I mean you could still do like all the other ones where it's two things so whoever play picks the Lex school to play they pick one of these as their starting hand and then it's like the assassin school I pick one of those so we do play completely different mhm um but again then we're still drawing from the same core deck so we're going to end up with same spells or yeah but it's like you're hyper you're focused on one so it's like instead of like in in this specifically it's like there is no core deck like this is assigned to you I if they did the different schools I have one so whenever we're drawing two from our deck and we draw two from our own School mhm so you're still focused on one which is what they seem to have wanted so it's like oric is the Assassin Mage uh Bartholomew is the Lex mage so it's like we get to see how those work but again I I kind of think that they they clearly didn't want to put in the effort to try and do that yeah yeah I just didn't I I can't imagine this was play test very much and it almost seems like this is dry I don't know this is extra content from like things that they were working on they're like ah we need to add a few more cards so we'll just do that and we'll package it as a as a separate game yeah I mean there wasn't all that much the the comp opponents are still really good this doesn't make me like black rose Wars any less um but I would never play this again and it sucks
cuz I also can't resell it yeah because I won all the stuff right uh yeah have the stuff yep player Aid's good that was nice um yeah yeah I'm uh I'm I'm I got I got I got nothing nothing I yeah felt felt very very tedious um with this one so on a scale of 1 to 10 Deon what are you giving Black Rose Wars dual uh well it's like black R Jews not like does not represent the original game yeah right
um like go a four that's yeah that's where I'm at too it's not great um and yeah I just I didn't have a lot of fun with it right yeah because I was like okay maybe the first game but I mean even the first game I felt the same way I was like okay at any given time we are always Within Reach of each other we can only attack each other or the summons but who cares the summons are there so it's like we're only hitting each other so it's like I punch you I cuz like very rarely do I ever do a physical action to actually punch someone yeah it's only like well they have like one hit point left I'm going to run him yeah and then knock them out and it's like okay I got that but here it's like I punch you I punch you I deal three damage yep you're going to move I don't need to I I I can I can hit you from any I this I'm going to charge this room up so I'm going to hang out here you right yeah that's pretty much it so I can use the Ability and and yeah it's like it it's just it's not not good uh so yeah if you again just just want more stuff for black Wars wars then get it um and then basically deconstruct and add it all to your original stuff then that's a thing yeah but I highly highly discourage getting it specifically to play duel yeah um there are a bunch a much better two 1 V one skirmish games uh if you want about dueling Mages I recommend Summoner Wars uh that is pretty much a way better
game than this and unfortunately I can't speak to Black Rose Wars itself being good at two I'm just going off of what Bor game Beek says that people say they wouldn't recommend it that twoo yeah um or another game that's about dueling Mages that I that we have played but uh we might have played oh we I know we played a specific rule wrong was that ion game oh yeah yeah so that one felt like it had potential it it really did I think there was they that I know we [ __ ] up a rule the one yeah the one where you just get to kept countering but that card was like a onetime use I remember that one specifically but that one it the problem with that is there's they're all boxed differently mhm so to get everything for it you can't just like get like a bundle for it and it's expensive yeah so I don't know anyway that's our thoughts on black Ros Wars Duel let know you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe wonderful what every time of day is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you