Ranking and Roasting Board Game Boxes
Transcript
board game boxes drive me crazy they're either too big too small too ugly or too annoying so today I'm going to rank 50 board games by their boxes let's get into it we're doing a classic tier ranking starting at the bottom we've got collection ruined these are the worst of the worst boxes the games that you're embarrassed to have on your shelves then we've got depressed Sim if you've ever played The Sims you know that there's a little room TR C ER so if the Sim is in a room that's full of all these ugly things then it depresses them this is something I really notice in my wife if if she's in a place that she just finds ugly that it really bums her out and I get that with my board game shelves if it was full of games like this then I would be a depressed Sim then we've got shame of shelf we've all heard of a shelf of Shame well these games are the shame of the shelf that they're on then we've got but the game play is good these are the average boxes they're plain Bland uninspiring but the gameplay is good getting a bit better looking we've got you've won second prize in a beauty contest collect £10 these are the boxes that are almost beautiful but there's a couple of things wrong with them then we've got can I get a shelfie with you these are some beautiful boxes they're not quite perfect but they're almost there and finally we've got hang it in the lra these are the board game boxes works of art they're the Pinnacle of what you can achieve with a box and I
can assure you not many games fit into that category and before I start I just want to thank Pro for giving me the idea for this video in the comments of my collection video right let's get ranking starting with Katan this is not a goodlooking box the yellow and red color scheme I'm not a fan of this here you've okay the name of the game is Katan the name of studio is Katan that you've got Katan written twice on the side of your box that is not on I've barely touched this box I like this is like a new copy it's it's really worn already this I hate a number don't put numbers I don't know what that is it doesn't matter it shouldn't be on the side of my box I mean the art is fine I played the first ever German version of Katan and it had this really beautiful cover that they got rid of instantly and if you look at the first American cover it's like the worst imaginable Bo game cover you could ever think of so this is an improvement on that but yeah this is going in depress Sim mysterium I love this cover I think that is one of the nicest board game covers there is and then with this version this is a newer version they've ruined it with this horrible logo that it won a prize in 2016 the can asor that should never be on a box like this is my this is my board game and you ruined it with some advertising I don't need to be ad ad vertis to I already bought the
game I like this game and you're ruining it in my collection by putting that on the front that should be a sticker that goes on the cellophane or something that I can remove when I buy the game not permanently on the cover of the box if it wasn't for that logo this would be hang it in the louvra but as it is I'm going to have to downgrade it to can I get a shelfie with you like almost perfect but they had to ruin it Bonanza I mean this is one of the ugliest board games in existence and they're just not helping themselves with this I this where you're encroaching on the artwork of the box with just this color logo thing I hate that every single side of the box has this really ugly age thing and Play account that doesn't need to be on every side of the box you can put it on one or two the proper artwork is yellow you know with red writing but this is the way to have it up on a shelf and it's green and then this side like why do companies bother to have this like weird upside down writing on one side it's almost like to please people that have it up the other way but who has it up the other way that's not that's not how it goes to Bean or not to Bean pretty terrible tagline it's just I mean it's mostly it's not even the artwork itself I think it's something about just the the bright yellow but this this has to be collection ruined pandemic one of my favorite games I used to have have the original version of this which was
really ugly and this one came out I think I was like really impressed by how much better it looked some people thought that the old one looked better they were crazy I don't know this character art it's it's not fully doing it it almost looks like you know obviously it wasn't but it kind of looks like AI art that's how it's got this sort of softness to it Awards down here printed on the box no get rid of that I I don't mind the logo it feels a bit dated now there's a nice side to the box where it's it's just the name bit of artwork and like a not too annoying logo don't hate that I'd say this is second prize in a beauty contest collect £10 it's it's not perfect but I don't hate it Las Vegas Royale this is supposed to be a deluxe version of Las Vegas I think I actually prefer the original box art it's sort of like ooh it's luxury cuz it's in black with gold but there's just something so like 2D and basic about this art and the logo there's just so much empty space on this box you've got this horrific uh information like square that feels like the intern did it the the logo is you've got this the numbers why are there numbers on the box and then this is one of the worst things is this whole numbered thing this is something that Aaliyah did with a whole another line of games this idea that oh you're going to want to buy everyone in the line because they're numbered cuz if you've got one and four it's not going to look right on the Shelf I mean that is just ridiculous marketing tactic
nobody in their right mind is going to buy all of them so then you're just ruining the way they look on the shelf for every single person that buys your game so yeah absolutely hate that there's really nothing about this to like so collection ruined I guess Lost Cities this is the updated version of this game it's got Vincent detrit artwork I think it's an improvement on what was before I really don't like this logo the way they got these sort of letters that I don't know they're like snakes or something it's not working for me this is a Parents Choice Gold Award I've never heard that I don't know what that is that shouldn't be on my box just stick it on the back it's fine there's loads of space I mean let's talk about publisher logos first of all don't ruin the cover of your box with a logo Cosmos logo I'm guessing it's from what like the 80s or something is one of the worst logos but just make it smaller like it doesn't need to be that big there's something about German Publishers they've all got terrible logos and they insist on emazing them everywhere uh We've also got with the sixth Expedition down here again that should be on the back of the box the other thing to talk about with lost cities is the size because this is how big it could be this is my Dutch version of Lost Cities and all that's in this box is this deck of cards I mean there's a board that you I would say you don't really need so this is in this
box it's it's not like the worst offender but it's really not doing itself any favors so we're going to go with while I like the artwork I think it's letting itself down in a bunch of other places so we're going to go with but the game play is good I just spotted this barcode that no barcodes okay that takes it down another ranking this is definitely shame of shelf with that barcode on the side okay we're back to something that I like the look of I think that Iberia is better looking than pandemic there's something about this character art I really like the whole color scheme I'm loving feels like it really evokes the era and the theme you know got the kind of diseases up here and you got the train down here there's some really nice World building with the cover I don't love that it says limiters collectors Edition because it's not even limited anymore they're now just this game is so good that they just released it as Iberia they took the pandemic name off it so I don't know what the new one looks like I imagine slightly better than this one the side of the box is nice there's nothing offensive about this at all so I'm going with hang it in the Lou the resistance I've had this one for over 10 years so it is looking a bit dated pretty worn I didn't hate the artwork it gives a feel I don't think it's high quality but it it gives a feel it was always a bit weird that it was like Don esdes the resistance because no other game does that and at the time it
was like who's Don esgd you're not Rina kitzia you're Don esgd this here putting your website underneath the name of your game that's ridiculous that should never be happening I don't want I mean maybe that's just indicative of the time period it's a nice size I I feel bad putting this right at the bottom I'd say depressed Sim with this one like I'm not ashamed of it but it could be so much better Dominion right I mean what category do you think this one deserves to go in look at this logo this is a second edition they had a chance to improve things what is going on with this logo like the stretching out the O's like was someone just having fun like oh yeah maybe if we stretch out like what is that depicting I have no idea the the artwork is like fine it's like sort of faded and but this gray that's just around the whole thing this like mled gray and the logo this the font and how it it doesn't like the S here doesn't quite fit on nicely oh this is so so bad this this is kind of a different thing like the there's just like a bit of the board game art just on the side of the box I mean yeah this this is collection ruined the minion's not actually in my collection I've just got it in case I might use it in a video at some point but if it was it would have ruined my collection a long time ago aul must be attractive
because it sold like 3 million copies right I I do like the tile artwork but this this font here is Algerian go into Microsoft Office and find the font Algerian and type the word as all and you will get this exact thing honestly you need to make a Papyrus sketch you know the SNL Ryan goling Papyrus sketch make it about Algerian and AO because like most games have like they put a lot of work into the logo I mean apart from Dominion but they're iconic they they they look different to anything else because an artist has actually put the effort in and this is just a font that you can get in Microsoft Word um but everything else I don't know it's nicely integrated I like on the side how they've got the information but it doesn't feel like it's sort of annoying like it it fades nicely in and even the logo is you know it's the company logo but it's kind of made to look like one of the tiles so it's not my favorite but I'm going to give this one can I get a shelfie with you it's it's a good-look box we can't deny that the cover of RA is beautiful there's no denying this Eno tool artwork I just love it but hear me out here I just feel like the rest of the Box isn't quite doing it first of all this is is not the deluxe version I can't close the Box properly like it requires so much work to to get it flat the bag of tiles flat so that I can
close the box I hate a box that you can't close like I would say my least favorite thing in board games is boxes that are too big and then my second least favorite thing are boxes that are trying to be like small and compact but then you can't fit it in and it like doesn't close prop but that is somehow maybe that's worse be I because you were so close to getting it right but you just didn't quite do your mask correctly um also the sides I'm not I so on my shelf I either have to have this I I think it part of the problem is just that it's a twetter name of a game which I think just kind of looks a bit rubbish so you've either got that or that and I just don't really like either of them and then these sides are just way too much going on like we don't need to know the name of the artist and the designer there you know you've got it on the front and then you've got the information and the logo and there's a bird and there's a snake and this other thing like I just feel like that's too much going on so the cover is hang it in the louvra but the rest of the box is just one tiar down it's can I get a shelfy with you I might get some hate for this but I don't think that Sagrada is that beautiful of a box I do like the stained glass bits but when I first got this game I was like why is it all gray I just didn't understand and then I think that year I happened to go to Barcelona and see the cigada familia in real life and I was
like oh that's why it's gray because this Cathedral is just like a a monument to is it Granite I don't know it just so gray but with like nice pretty stained glass windows so thematically the box is perfect but it's just kind of ugly like I don't want this like Stone gray box on my shelf and I just feel like somehow it doesn't mesh with the beautiful colors kind of like the cathedral itself um so yeah I don't know it's got I don't I I like the sides you know there's not too much info but I just I can't look past the gray so I'm going to give this but the game plays good code names my favorite game of all time I before I made this video last night I was talking to my wife about it and she was like I hate the way that codeen names looks you better mention that and I in sort of in my head I was feeling that code names isn't that ugly first of all I feel like cod names should win some awards for picking this size of box perfect for a party game and then loads of games have come since and copied this size so this box is something of a trend Setter but when you look at it it's got this horrible gradient I hate the kind of mled thing where it's just like ooh it's a bit worn the print on the font and on these things this whole like top secret word game that sucks and then the silhouette
yeah the artwork sucks and then the cge logo is just is one of the uglier logos and the way it just doesn't mesh with any of this like the color scheme or anything so yeah this it's not great is it I'm going to go with depressed Sim it's not going to put you in a good mood hanging out with this box this is a travel edition of Trailblazers a game that I recently got and I just love the packaging on this you know it it's in this little case that you can take out I assume it's waterproof but I just love that the case itself has got like the beautiful artwork on and then I really like the font that they've used the the color schemes great I mean it's got a carabiner if you want to take it with you it all fits nicely in here and it's just different you know it's not great for going on the shelf and kind of fitting in with your collection but it really does stand out it is a bit questionable this game being like in a travel Edition I mean it obviously small it fits in but it takes up a lot of table space it's not the kind of thing that you can play on a hike or on a picnic blanket or whatever like you need a a sizable table certainly no wind or any kind of weather conditions but you know I feel like that's somewhat by the by because you can still take it in this case you know to a hotel or something and yeah I just really like what they've done with it so I'm going to say hang it in the louvra this is Ticket to Ride Europe the first modern Bard game that I ever got and I feel like it holds up pretty well I it just got like a good cohesive
aesthetic to it I think like it's not going to blow you away but it's got like an old timey Vibe it's a bit you know washed out I suppose but I just like the way it all comes together I feel like days of Wonder really get their box is right and I really like the sides of the box like the way that you've got the trains run along here so you've got a good idea what the game's about you know but just the name of the game and then a very small company logo that just doesn't annoy too much that's what I think they're getting right and then I also do like where you've got like this is a character from the game well kind of I mean you don't play characters and this is another character from the game and so you can rotate the Box on your shelf and have whichever thing that you want I just I like it when Publishers give you options on how you're going to display it in your collection so I'm going to put this one at can I get a Shelf with you it's clearly not the most beautiful game ever but it really gives a sense of the game and it just looks like a really appealing package Star Realms is one of the smallest games in this video and it gets respect for having a tiny box I like I massively appreciate the small packaging but God this is one of the ugliest games in existence the font this logo like so every game should have on the smallest side the name of the game so that I can put it into my shelf so that all the depth of the game is in the back of the shelf and it's taking up the least amount of space on the Shelf possible so I can fit in loads of games and this just has this horrible logo or
a barcode and a bunch of legal text that is just rubbish and then the sides this is an advert for like the the app version of the game and then this is a bunch of awards that it's won like I hate every side of this box even the front I mean the artwork of this game is Just rubbish like these icons this I mean this has got to be one of the ugliest games that I own absolutely collection ruined and it it's a shame because it packs a lot of game into a tiny box but even with this tiny box that has such a small footprint on my shelf it manages to ruin the entire collection okay change of heart this is getting downgraded to second place in a beauty contest collect £10 there's no way that this is on a par with raah and aul this is on a par with pandemic Quinto is so ugly what I don't think you should make a game that is just all white it's starting to really collect dirt and then you've got a tagline the New Sensation from Quicks what if you don't know what quick is the font I hate but the fact that they've made this win red as if like the name means something it what that's why they they called it Quinto because it's got win in it but why the the to I honestly I have no idea the name it's it just looks so cheap and this looks like a a mass Market game from like the 80s or '90s and it's actually great but you'd never know uh this has got to be collection
ruined okay so here's a small game that gets it right I mean just something about the color Choice with a fake artist goes to New York it just pops on the sh this is a newer version originally you couldn't get the Box open but now they've put the little divot so it's actually somewhat easy to get the Box open I mean you could question the size in that like you've got to really pack it in it's not as bad as some oink games for like getting everything back into the box you know I do I love the Oink aesthetic so they will do well in terms of boxes but there's one thing that really bugs me about oink games and that is that they don't put the name of the game on any of the sides of the box I'm not going to have it on my shelf like this nobody is doing that so then I'm either going to have it like this this this or this and the the name isn't there so then I guess I just have to know which game it is from the color um so yeah I hate that and really I think that's costing it a place in the top spot this has to be can I get a shelfie with you because you got to put the name on the side of the Box otherwise I don't know what game it is Lords of Vegas is one of my favorite games of all time but it is so ugly I'm so ashamed of this box like you've got the this is just word art like do people still do is word art still a thing like from Microsoft 98 uh with like a drop shadow this is so bad uh roll the dice and build Paradise
hate that there's a number on the front of my box get that get rid of that why are there just like random cards from the game more numbers more tag there's a different tagline here dust dice dollars that doesn't mean anything to me it's also just a really bad quality box and I mean I haven't even talked about this terrible artwork I know there's a new version coming out I mean the whole game is hideous they need to update everything about it so yeah collection ruined but brilliant game I just remembered something I hate about the resistance and that is that it's got adverts on the inside of the box like I have paid for this game please stop advertising to me like yeah oh okay you can't see it when the box is closed but I can see it I have to open the box every time I play the game I don't want to buy your other games some of which are probably not in print anymore because this is like 10 years ago now I hate that so much like you have sold me a game it's not an opportunity to advertise to me more and if you really have to then just put it in a little pamphlet that I can throw out as soon as I get the game so because of that collection ruined I feel like I should hate caraz on more than I do this I mean it's obviously got this very dated aesthetic but it's set in a dated time right over 12 million games sold I don't care don't put that on my box the artwork is weirdly like fuzzy as if they've like
blown up uh an image like it's almost like someone took over the company and like they didn't have the right files so they used an old JPEG and they had to like enlarge it beyond the resolution that it was capable of because you could just kind of see this it just doesn't look right you know like when you make an image too big c on the side like the shape of a Meo which I don't know I just the whole like getting oh we did meols and making everything a Meo I I kind of hate that but I do like the font I think it's and I I like the kind of iconic C thing here so I I don't I feel like PE other people will hate this but I don't think it's that bad so I'm going to stick this in but the game play is good this is my kind of cover trekking through history I just love the way that they've combined loads of the artwork from the game the color scheme just feels like a really iconic cover that it like really stands out to me the logo down here it just all comes together I like the way that it's kind of showing you a clock I I think they've updated this now and it looks worse to me but I don't know I I don't have that what I love about this one as well is that they have followed the actual L rule at least one of the sides should just have some nice artwork and the name of the game there's no logo there's no information Play Count nothing that every single box should have one of these sides if not
like three or four of them you know cuz you can you can have your rubbish side that I'm never going to show with your information I don't really get the having one that's just artwork I that is weird to me like I need to know the name of the game for it to be a ball game shelf but maybe some people are into it but I'm not I'm not marking it down for that this one is hang it in the louv it's a classic the Quest for alado has some really nice artwork this is the second edition they got the artwork redone by Vincent D TR and I do prefer this version I I love that cover I like the the logo choice I don't love that there's it's in English and French I don't know that just feels a bit weird to me I it's like a moneysaving thing I think artwork wise is on the verge of hang it in the louvra but the Ravensburger logo oh my God what a curse on board gamers across the world one of the biggest companies one of the worst logos just this bright blue that doesn't go with anything and just to rub it in on every single side of the Box Ravensburger logo oh Ravensburger logo in a different direction and here it is and it's not a triangle anymore it's taking up even more space as a square and a square oh and there's a barcode so you know you did a great job you recommissioned the artwork and made the game look better within but the box is just not cutting it so I'm going to say this one is can I get a shelfie with
you oh boy someone should study Queen game's obsession with yellow what it and it's just this color of yellow it has no place in any board game collection and yet every single queen games is in blazoned with that color this is Luxor just one of the many examples I I don't like I don't hate what they're trying to do with the cover but I just feel like uh it's just too it's too yellow don't love the logo this it was nominated for the SPI yarz great it didn't win it definitely shouldn't be that big let alone on the front cover Que games logo I it's not I don't know I don't hate it as much as others but they've got the SPI Yara is there again and really it's just that yellow it just there's something about it it just makes me want to go to sleep and it doesn't make it look like a fun game this is collection ruined all day and I feel like so many Queen games are like that and of course it's a great game it doesn't deserve it I've got mixed feelings about love letter I do like the bag it's like thematic it's a bit different different but on the Shelf there's it doesn't really stand out there's no name or anything like that and then the thing that I really hate is that the tokens fall out of the bag I've lost these tokens like in my ruck sack when I've taken it out so that gets it marked down I think it's a good look and I love that it's small so this one I think is second place in a beauty contest collect
10 I've had a lot to say about Zu vardis the anthropo animals are not doing it for me but I do really like the art of Quai Moria he's one of my favorite artists in board games and so it's it's sort of like oh why couldn't you have just commissioned him to do something different the thing that I want to talk about today is the fact that in my collection video people were like why is Zu Aris upside down because I wasn't given an option I wanted to have the box like this way up and the text is the wrong way up and the Lo like so if I that is how you should have a box so that you can read the text like that which puts the company logo upside down and this Ibis upside down and there's no option on the other side because they wasted this side with all this information that I don't want I don't need that if I have it like this then I can get around it but nobody has it this way up I swear if you do let me know in the comments but so zaris it's going to be but the game play is good this is the second edition of fugitive the first one had quite a nice box but this is even smaller I mean you just can't I can't get over this flap you know magnetic Flaps in board game boxes are amazing and then the fact that it's got this like cut off thing oh yeah that's just that's winning it so many awards the original version didn't have it does have the name written on the
smallest side but I kind of wish it was like a thicker font or something you can't really see it but aside from that I love the artwork from Ryan goldsbury I love the size so small even smaller than the first edition so fugitive is hang it in the louvra I've just got this new version of through the desert I used to have the big Fantasy Flight version which comes in like a ticket to ride size box so the fact that allplay have put it in this size box I was at first really impressed with I like the new look of it it's like not too offensive on the side here I I don't really like this whole logo thing this is verging into Ravensburger territories you really don't need to be doing that but the issue with through the desert is that in the same Kickstarter they released this expansion and it comes in you know one of these like Tatty boxes that you're obviously not meant to keep it in so it's meant to go in here except I can barely fit the base game stuff in here I tried putting this stuff in here the Box won't clothes you know and that is just so annoying when you've sold them at the same time it's different if you know the expansion comes 2 years later this isn't a box it has to fit into this box and it doesn't so that is depressed SIM for me despite how good it looks there's nothing more depressing than not being able to fit your own game into a box we're not talking about sleeves or anything that where you've like brought it upon yourself this is like how the game was
made and it doesn't go in the Box A Game of Thrones board game I've had this one for years I still really like the way it looks I feel like old school Fantasy Flight they had a real era of making Nic looking boxes you know they pack a lot into it's not like well some of them were definitely weren't using up all the space things like Mission red planet but something like Game of Thrones there's a lot in here and this is bulging because I've got sleeves and geek boxes and expansions in here so I can't blame Fantasy Flight I like their logo I like that it's small like on the side of the box it just doesn't it doesn't take up much space and it just kind of feel like it fits another thing I really like is that on each side you've got a different character so there's like the hound and uh I think that's Jon Snow um I like the art on the front the logos feels a bit dated now but I I'm going to say if this was new and fresh and not faded hang it in the louv dead of winter is one of my favorite boxes of all time it's just something like the logo really captures the feel of the game I love the artwork from Fernand Suarez I think probably my favorite art in a game because of just how like the characters come alive I feel like very few games Focus so well on their characters I really like the way they've just like made it seem like this is a game about characters which it so is um and then the sides of the Box you know there's there's one little logo that I feel like it's been nicely integrated and then you know the name of the game kind of wish there was some
maybe some characters on the side but obviously they've got the zombies instead so it does kind of work so yeah this is hang it in the louv I I love this one this is the new version of no thanks and the thing that I hate about it the most is how much bigger it is than the original version this is an older version that I have look what is this like four times the size I mean I actually prefer the new look but on the side of the Box there's just so much going on if anything's going to depress a Sim it's you try and get a new copy of a game and it's four times the size of an old one so depress Sim very few games look as nice as the crypto like I feel like it doesn't really look like a party game so it's almost letting itself down in that respect but it's just got such a nice aesthetic like this cover just comes together in such a great way they almost mess it up like this side of the box that's useless to me this uh I don't love this is crazy it's got like warning choke cooking Hazard it's got the contents on the side put that on the back that's wild but it does save itself with this one this is the one that you have on display so I think this one has to be hang it in the L it's just too nice waterful park was in my collection video and I couldn't get the box closed again it just there's something about the way this insert is designed that all the stuff just falls out when you try and hold it uppr right and any game
especially when they've put thought into the insert there's ways to store the stuff but they haven't put enough thought in so this happens that is just totally unforgivable I hate that so much and yet you know the look is fine like it's a really weird depiction of the game you know waterfall Park is a negotiation game there's sort of money and Deals going on this doesn't give that at all it's just like this bright colorful thing so I don't really feel like it matches the game but obviously it's not like horrific to look at and then the the Box they they've almost got it right like the fact that it's just the name no logos or anything but I actually feel like the new rule is that it's not it's not just the logo but there needs to be a bit of a Vibe of the game behind it can't just be like a plain color the fact that the Box won't close is the the biggest problem and this one is going on shame of shelf because if it's taking up that much space on its shelf then of course it's the shame of the Shelf this is castles of burgundy specialist Edition this is the answer to the fact that everyone thinks that castles of burgundy one of the ugliest games ever especially the inside of the game I I think the original cover sort of okay on like a carcasson level they made a special edition and they didn't exactly get it perfect you know the art the front cover art is fine the fact that it's like special edition I don't know that's just feels a bit weird like just give me the name of the game but the box is ridiculous absolute least favorite trend
of modern times with boxes is this whole like fat box thing going on the fact that it's like the there's just a certain ratio that it should be it should be wide and long with a bit of thickness these like super thick ones that take up so much space on your shelf I hate I just hate them like and and they just look like what is this what like why is it just a tiny logo in the middle and then nothing else like this is supposed to be a special edition and this is how it looks on my shelf that is insane to me and then that's the other side those are your two options like you've commissioned so much nice artwork in this game that you know the whole point of a special edition is that you redid All the artwork of a really ugly game so where is that artwork on the sides of the box that are going to be on my shelf you know not to mention the fact that it's just totally over blown size cramming in so much stuff um I don't know with this one like you know on one hand it looks nice in but it looks nice but it's just too big you know I honestly think this is shame of shelf like I'm embarrassed to have a game of this size for you know for what it is inside not going to talk about foundations of Rome today but foundations of Rome on a similar level but there's just something about the side here that's just really bugging me this is great heat pedal to the metal I love the like the speed thing going on there's just something about the the art
style of this cover that just really brings the game Al life I love the like the Flames like I I really feel like the difference a lot of the times between a great cover and a weak one is they put enough effort into the logo but also the integration you know it's not just about okay you've got one good bit of art that you've just put on the cover but how does the logo fit in with that how does the company logo and the name of the designers fit in and this just has been been properly brought together and that's the difference on the side I don't really need the designer names I don't mind you know this logo nice and in the corner doesn't get in the way all of the sides are the same which is maybe a bit dull but for me and it's thicker than I'd like but it's because it's storing the cards UPR right and making like a really organized system inside with the insert so I I can't hate it too much for that hang it in the louvra with this one yeah this is burgle Brothers although you wouldn't know from a lot of the sides of the Box you have to like turn it to this side to see the name of the game I love the creativity it's made to look like the building that you're heisting and you use it in the game you know you've got the helip pad on the top so this you end up at the top of this heliad so I do appreciate that and I think when I got it I I loved it more than I do now they just
the fact that it's always sat on my shelf either just showing a helipad what game is that or this which is just terrible um you you know nobody's going to have it on its shelf like this and I don't love I never love a game where you can kind of see the the bit sticking out where it doesn't look like it's closed properly even though that is intentional the the artwork inside I love and I I love the theme thing but for me I'm giv this one second place in a beauty contest collect 1010 it's it's it's close but it's not quite right you know points for size for sure but it doesn't come together I'm really torn with Forbidden Desert because I know everyone hates tins and I used to really hate tins but I don't know I've I've kind of maybe I I wouldn't say grown to love them but I've grown to not hate them they're just kind of different they stand out I think the the main issue I have with tins is is the the fact that they fall open so it depends how they're kind of constructed inside how much is in there but also something about the tightness and then if you can Dent them you know that is that is one of the major fls but I do like the way this is embossed I like the art on the Forbidden series and I really like the font that they use I don't love the sides here though like the logo I didn't know this gray again just really generic information and it's exactly the same on every side so I don't have option how like how am I displaying that so it looks nice in my collection so yeah I
don't know I think I think this one is veering into shame of shelf and I think all tin haters out there will probably agree with me just one is an incredible party game but God it could come in a better box I don't know I mean it's sold a lot of copies it's done really well so is there something about this that speaks oh this must be a good party game cuz I just don't see it but I also don't know how I would Market this game I love the box size code names you know but on my shelf this is how it looks with the world's tiniest logo just down this end you know company logo what is going on like why can't I just have like a big just one written here that is that is what the side of the Box should be it just looks so weird on my shelf and then the color palette is just this beige thing with these flexs I don't know there's just very little to like about this um I think it's it's got to be depressed Sim it it it's buming me out I love the aesthetic of the Sherlock Holmes Consulting detectiv Series this whole draw thing you know there's question marks i' I've never had it fall out you know because I I suppose I do keep them up like this this it's just something it's it's like well constructed it's really sturdy box so it doesn't fall apart like other ones I love the like shiny embossed uh magnifying glass I love the the font choice on the sides may be like a bit boring but you know I like that you can line them up and they kind of
look a bit like books ah I don't know I think I stick with my guns I think hang it in the Lou I think this is a work of art and especially when they're together there's just something really nice about them I like the vibe of Cascadia this landscape it I don't know it feels like caring or soothing or something and it and it evokes the game I feel like the artwork's a bit generic I mean maybe that's cuz we see best soell everywhere but it's not I don't like it I just feel like there's games with covers that I prefer it just feels a bit easy oh we stick a deer in front of a mountain and the font with this like whole faded out thing that feels lazy that feels like I feel like that's just a font in Microsoft Word and you've just spaced out the things a bit I didn't I'm not vibing with that massively and on the side with these two logos don't give me two logos you know neither of them are like nicely integrated or anything so solid art but I I was going to go can I have a shelfie but the more I talk about it I'm talking myself into second prize in a beauty contest collect 1010 I it it's in the background of my shop but when I look up close I don't know I don't know if it's all that also from my backdrop is Parks I mean this is one of the best looking covers in board games and I I do really like the font and this kind of whole like gold thing at the top it just it gels really nicely I mean the
the art in this game generally is just amazing but there's no side of the box with just Parks written on it I mean like this way you've got a tiny little Parks down there and I I guess that's cuz they're like really pushing the artwork in this game but if it's on my shelf I need like like it just doesn't fit in if it doesn't have like a proper logo I'm going to go can I get a shelfie with you like artwork wise brilliant but box wise it could do better I've talked a lot about the artwork in libertalia WIS of Gale Crest the cover it just doesn't evoke the game this is not a game of expiration this is a game of backstabbing Pirates and this isn't doing it this box is covered in logo okay so we got the info there there this is the 239th game from 2,500 games I don't care don't tell me this information what it's part of the first printing like really I like how many people care that they've got a copy from the first printing this isn't Hemingway this is a board game that is just going to vanish and be reprinted with different artwork in 10 years logo logo here on the side of the box every side of the box has got three different info One logo another logo both doing the same thing then we've got the otama factory every single
side of the box is like that it's bright and colorful it's it's not hideous but it's just annoying and it there's just no side of the box that I want to display on my shelf so this is shame of shelf like can do better skull is beautiful yeah like amazing weird artwork in this game and just perfectly shown on the front box I like the logo I like the color they did a pink version I'm Not So keen on this cover is hang it in the louvra but the thing that bugs me is there's only one side of the box with the name of the game on and it's got a barcode on it like what what is going on just you don't need a barcode on the side but just put it on this side with all the crap on it or put it on the back but you put it there this is the only way that I can have it on my shelf and there's a barcode on my shelf like that is just totally unforgivable if it wasn't for that it'd be at the top but as it is can I get a shelfie with you but disappointed whilst I'm getting that shelfie fantasy Realms is never going to win any awards for looking nice I don't know what it is about printing techniques but this is just really worn it's such an uninspired look and it's not like covered in logos actually information is sort of fairly well integrated here like kind of hidden there is one side that is just so I don't hate that there is a side that has like choking hazard not sure that needs to be on the side of the box it's it's
really just the art bringing this one down I I think just looking at it bums me out this is depressing I used to kind of like the aesthetic of detective but it really is just a picture of a road with a blue filter on it I don't know they I feel like they're somehow getting away with it but this version here with this Game of the Year Edition it's like wow so you won loads of awards why is why does that have to be my problem why is it like on the front of my box so that it's ruining my collection what I do appreciate here that I you don't see done very often is that on the side of the box is the portal games logo and they've changed the look of it the colors of it to fit the aesthetic of the game you know normally the portal games logo is like a bright red so it would just really stand out that is good that is Modesty I really appreciate that and they do have a side of the box that is just no logos just the name of the game but it's just kind of got like a really boring background to it so it doesn't look that nice but it doesn't you know ruin the collection either so I think with this one it's somewhere in the middle but the game plays good but the Box could be better the only thing I like about Clank is the logo I feel like they got that right they commissioned someone good for the logo and then the rest of the art they did on the cheap nothing about this cover that works these two company logos they just stand out so much and then this a game by Paul Denon has just so clearly been put on right at the last minute like there's
just no effort for that font or anything for it to go it's really bad quality as well like it's really worn down this game uh none of the sides of the Box are at all attractive save for the logo it's a really like poor quality box that you just know that you could rip with like absolutely no effort at all I honestly think this one deserves collection ruined yeah valara breaks two Cardinal rules first of all the smallest side doesn't have the name of the game on it has all this pointless information that could be on the back this like how am I having it in this shelf it's it's forcing this whole like bookshelf thing but that is taking up way too much space to hold it vertically and then even then there's not the name of the game like like the proper way it's like this tiny little thing just so that it matches the rest of their games like this and then it's got this drawer that just falls out way too easily which means if you don't have the tokens in baggies like I've actually had them cuz there's this big hole here so the tokens just like fall out into your bag nice artwork and I I actually really like the logo of this one nice small box but absolutely ruined by just like a couple of things so this is so close to ruining my collection but as it is it's just depressing me yeah depressing on a time it is different you know not many games are this kind of long and thin I don't know if I love that I tend to like sort of specifically
square or rectangular boxes things that don't mesh with other games in my collection kind of frustrate me at times but it is to fit in you know a really nice playmat that kind of brings the game to life so maybe I'll let it off it does have a magnetic clasp what I like here is that the logos have been made to fit the aesthetic of the game they're not just like thrown on there in their usual style so I appreciate that I like the logo the beige is a bit dull and then when you have it on your shelf it kind of looks like this it doesn't really stand out that much but I'm saying second place in a beauty contest collect 1010 like it's got a nice aesthetic this game but I don't know if the Box fully sells it I want to do these together this is Watergate and match of the century cuz they're clearly from the same line of games don't like the font the covers I just feel like there's not enough going on like you can see like a little glimpse of Richard Nixon and a little sort of scense of Chess but you know make sure that you can see our logos and it's funny because this one is Capstone games bright red thing standing out this one they've actually this is the Frosted games logo it actually fades in it's usually blue but it kind of fits in with the aesthetic so that's kind of weird that one come has done the right thing and the other not um but when I really hate it is when you put them together in your collection and it doesn't match now the info matches and even just the Capstone games
logo doesn't match it's way bigger and even brighter on this one that's ridiculous like don't have a line of games if there's not going to be any continuity and like I'm picking on these guys honestly there's loads of games in my collection that do this exact thing is just crazy like what did you just lose the files or something you can't just repeat the same thing again like it's your line of game so I'm sure that you can have I can't provide the Contin I like it just doesn't make any sense to me like it's so easy you know to have consistency although please look back through my old videos I'm sure there's no consistency but when you've got it on a shelf for the rest of your life because your games are that good there needs to be some consistency in your logos I mean this is clearly depressing me but I don't I don't know if it's that bad I I'm I'm going to say this is shame of shelf you know if this is happening on your shelf you're embarrassed about it it's it's buming you out like people are coming around your house and they're going why why don't they match John like what's wrong with your board game collection well I don't know what to tell you like I'm doing my best I had people in the comments in my collection video worried that I hadn't noticed that secret Hitler sticks out of my shelf I've noticed I absolutely hate it I just I just want to talk about every single game that sticks
out but this is way too long for a board game like you're just trying to get attention and I guess in a way I've given it to you but this is the wrong kind of attention I hate that they made this game this long and I hate that the cover doesn't have the name of the game on it that's ridiculous don't act like that that's bad behavior you know nice aesthetic it's very different you aside from the fact it's way too long it is you know relatively modest although could be smaller this has to be shame of shelf because it's embarrassing the rest of its shelf it's making it look bad by sticking out like that on a bookcase that has got so much depth you couldn't ask for a bookcase with more depth I don't know how deep a calex is but there's no way that this fits on a calex without having to like go through the back and then you've got to have it away from the wall that's just like no just stop it okay and I'm not having your game like this games aren't meant to be kept horizontally so take your punishment and do better next time this is deception murder in Hong Kong it's actually the expansion box and that's my first problem is that the original game was even bigger than this and this is a social deduction party game thing they shouldn't come in boxes this big okay so this is too big of an ego for a game of that style but I do like the vibe I do like the artwork I mean so many logos how many companies worked on this game
there's a dice tower seal of approval and then a dice tower award from 2015 I'm going to make a a a a maybe promise here which is as far as I know there is no actual L logo cuz there isn't really an actual L logo on any box in existence and nobody's offered it but I really don't want it to be on boxes like if someone said can I put it on the back of a box cuz you recommended this game I'll say yes but if they say can I put it on the front of a box I'm really going to try and say no because I don't agree with it regardless of the channel I just think it's it's damaging the look of our game so maybe I'll stick to that I'll let you know on the side here we've got a perfect side of a box there's no logos there's no dice tower logos there's just the name of the game and a nice bit of artwork so that is winning at points I think this is second prize in a beauty contest collect 1010 so that is the final ranking and I feel like I might have been too generous because there's more games in the top tier than any other tier but let me know which games you think I got in the wrong tier and if you've got games that you think ruin your collection or should be hung in the louvra then let me know and if you got ideas for more videos like this let me know in the comments if you like this video please subscribe to the channel to see more videos like it I'm John perkus thanks for watching