Skip to main content
Loading video...

Circadians Chaos Order Review: Asymmetric Excellence

Transcript 15:45

hello i'm ferrell this is talling we are board of it and today we're going to review circadian's chaos order a game with two designers one of which sam mcdonald you might have heard of for his work on the something of the west kingdom series a very popular series considering that i think several games in that trilogy are now in the top 100 games of all time the other designer zachary smith they believe this is his first board game design in which case nice job and what a game to kind of start off your design on or your design career on but if you're thinking or considering chaos order you want to get any thought of the west kingdom series out of your head because you wanna be thinking of games and if you enjoy them like root doon commet guy project yep set in the circadians universe chaos order is half euro half war game it's for two to five players it has six asymmetric factions euro style tracks combat and drama each asymmetric faction has their own way of winning but there's also a global win condition that anyone can achieve and we would like to stress that whilst it is definitely its own game a pithy way to describe it could be that it's the game scythe could be if it actually played like people think it does from the cover and just final note we were very kindly sent our copy by the designer

now in chaos order the factions are fighting over powerful relics that have landed on the planet represented by these chunky boys a player can win the game by controlling all the territories that have the remaining relics on them in the czech relics phase or they can win through their own personal win condition each faction has a private vp track and all get vp in different ways one gets a vp from each battle that they win whereas another has to upgrade their faction powers what's really interesting is that the vp tracks are all different lengths so one faction and he needs four vp to win whilst another needs 20. there'll be a maximum of 6 rounds and in each one a single relic is up for grabs the first thing you'll do in each round is set the prices for the actions of which there are five discovery build harvest recruit and move each player has a set of pricing tiles with different costs on them and each one gets to price one of the actions which means i can do the action for free but the other players have to pay them to do that action once that's done the actions are carried out from top to bottom the actions are pretty self-explanatory from their titles discovery is essentially research and will let you move your cubes up the various tracks to make your actions more powerful build will let you build the different structures each of which has a different purpose harvest provides resources recruit provides fighters and move lets you move

after the move phase you'll resolve combat anywhere where there are multiple factions on one space to do combat you will select your battle action from the combat will and then you also have the chance to use a tactic card to boost your action the player that has the most strength in the battle will win but you do also have the chance to wound your opponents soldiers and send them back to their base or you have the chance to block incoming wounds returning to the asymmetric factions a player will win the game if they get enough vp to reach the end of their vp track if no player does this the game will instead end at the conclusion of the sixth round or when a player controls all of the remaining relics on the board after the combat phase if we personally had to use one word to describe chaos order it would be interesting it's such an engaging game to deconstruct and experiment with particularly as it's such a smooth mix of euro actions and tactical combat one thing we really loved is it has this really rewarding way of letting the players combo the different systems to boost their actions from the very first action in the first round you should also know it can be a little bit fiddly as asymmetric games tend to be the actions and the goals are pretty straightforward but there's a lot of stuff to add on top this faction has special tokens that faction has different abilities and so on keeping all that in mind we'll call it right now this is a board

game that is going to divide people pretty evenly some people are going to love it some people are going to be pushed away almost immediately if you're the type of gamer or have a gaming group that loves root loves oath loves dune you love deep diving into it playing with different factions and just really getting the most out of it then you might as well consider this the next big thing in that space it's something you're going to want to get it's going to give you everything you want from those type of games but also it says unique enough that it also still deserves a place in your collection on the other hand a lot of the elements of this game are going to push people away and they're just going to bounce off the length the complexity the asymmetry and you know the inherent problems of fiddliness that comes with that and teaching people that moving on to the factions what we really like about the asymmetry in this game is it's the type where a faction will be based on an existing system within the game so they might break a rule or two or have a different focus but essentially everyone's doing the same actions in the same way this makes it a lot easier to teach new players because the actions that every other player is doing will still be relevant to them as opposed to being something unique and unintelligible a la route that said some of the factions do add on new mechanisms to the existing systems but those are potentially the most intriguing to players

it's worth noting that speaking of all the different factions they're all pretty unique and terrifically fun to play as i think what we really enjoy is the way their powers abilities their little special actions they really complement the different systems of the game and it is the kind of game the kind of asymmetric game where you're going to play against someone being a faction you haven't been before and you're just going to go i want to be that faction next time because they look pretty cool now it's worth noting that because these factions have different ways to score it is a game where you need to keep an eye on the other players and smack them down and know how to smack them down otherwise or i can see an issue with maybe more experienced players in a game where someone's being a new faction or just a new player that this experience player could kind of leap to an easy faction victory because people are too kind of inwardly focused on learning their new faction or being new to the game but i don't think it's too much of a problem because like four of the factions have gained victory points from combat in different ways so those are quite easy to understand how they gain the victory points and also how to stop them don't let them win a battle for example so the yeah it's not that big problem whilst discussing these win conditions we would also like to note that we do wish the rulebook did a little bit more to indicate that the

players should really be going after their faction win conditions as opposed to holding the relics because the game has a backstory about them and they're these giant tokens that dominate the board it does lead you to think that they should be everyone's focus and this inevitably leads to a game that is overly long and usually goes the distance it was only when we checked the bgg forums that we realized that players should really be winning with their faction win condition and most games should be ending in the fourth or fifth round we do feel like there could be a bit of an issue here with players neglecting their faction win condition in the first couple of games which makes it overly long creates a sub-optimal experience and could leave players disillusioned turning to the actions they're actually surprisingly simple and straightforward and in fact a lot of different aspects of the game are but where the complexity comes in is just that you have a lot of different systems coming together in interesting ways you have asymmetric factions which always adds obviously a layer of complexity and you do have a lot of symbology but a lot of the actions are actually rather interesting and even fun to do despite them being almost kind of basic euro actions or combat actions discover is particularly rewarding because it's an action that allows you to make actions better and all the time you're actually getting instant rewards as you do it so it's also rewarding as well as being fulfilling then you've got the build action and this is interesting because all anything

you want to build costs the same amount so it's not a problem of how much you have to kind of spend to build but what you do want to build the fact that each building does something different creates interesting options you know foundations are going to give you a kind of permanent unlockable ability that carries on for the rest of the game your outposts are going to let you move around the board easier your strongholds have a specific faction ability so it's kind of an interesting decision baseline but then when you mix in the asymmetric factions it becomes a really interesting one another one every time you are a new faction the pricing phase is also a very sharply designed mechanism it really creates an interesting decision space first of all what action do you price do you price the one that you want to do most of all do you price one that gives you an instant reward because you know those rewards energy ruby cards gonna come in handy second how high do you price because if you price really high you could basically just block other players from being able to take that action and that could interfere with their plans and annoy them but if they're not taking that action then they're not paying you energy so maybe it's better to price low and get as much energy from as many players as possible so you can then afford to do things later it's just a really interesting mechanism and at higher play accounts you get a really fascinating economy of energy flying between players it also makes things quite tense at

times because you can kind of be sitting there watching a player think about if they're going to do the action or not when deep down you're actually really counting on that energy to be able to do something later and my personal favorite thing to do is to price the harvest action as high as possible because at times it can mean that if players even take that action they're basically getting negative energy and then it kind of cracks their energy economy and their energy income i just find that really devilishly fun chaos order is just in general a really rewarding experience in the way that all of the best euros are there are so many things that you can upgrade and improve so you're constantly improving your faction and creating shortcuts with the way that you interact with the game what's particularly cool is that you can upgrade your faction abilities especially when they're pretty decent to begin with it also installs an arc in the game with everyone starting out slow and timid and then by round five everyone is zipping around the board and having 25 strength in each combat before we move on to final thoughts it's worth just taking time to talk about some other issues we have and we don't really mean issues it's just that these are things people probably would like to know and should know before they consider buying it first it's quite a long game and it's only going to increase at the higher play accounts i mean the box says 2-4 hours and for us a lot of this is directly

coming from the battle system before we get into it we'd like to say that we actually like the battle system i think it's excellent and a really nice distillation of several kind of systems i've seen in other games it's also sharp tactical exciting engaging and it really nicely kind of pulls in different mechanisms from this game you know pulls in the buildings it pulls in leaders some of your attributes and so on the problem comes almost before combat in the move phase because obviously this is quite a big decision how many troops are you going to move where are you going to move them to what leaders are you going to bring in and once you've thought all of that you get to the combat you resolve battles and first you've kind of got to count up your pre-battle strength so both players know where they stand going into the battle then you've got to look through all your tactic cards and you'll likely have a couple what values are you going to use what's best do they have any actions you can use to help you in this battle specifically then you've got to pick the section of your battle wheel which one are you going to use then you reveal and then you might have to roll dice and then you've got to count up the strength again and then maybe someone's faction ability comes into play and then you've got to count up wounds and then maybe there's some shields that block those wounds and as you can see that's not a small amount of things to do for a single battle and the problem is this blends with the

factions and the asymmetry because many of them are kind of enticed to keep battling and battle often because they get their unique brand of victory points that way by doing something via the combat it's just almost for us too involved for a game where combat's going to happen so often and higher play accounts it's it's not really something you know i'd want to experience let's say five players because i just think it would be a bit too much for me but that said i do think like a lot of this game this is going to be something because of the kind of tactility of baton strategy of setting yourself up around the board there are people who will really enjoy it and they won't mind at all and then there'll be other people who are just going to bounce right off it so final thoughts this is a really excellent game it's wonderfully designed but it's definitely going to be best for a certain type of person or gaming group but those people are going to have a great time with this it doesn't do anything particularly novel but it takes some of the best aspects from some other beloved games smushes them all together to create something really interesting and worth coming back to time and time again there are so many little touches and elements in this book so we would have loved to have deep dived into in this review but sadly we just don't have time if this has sounded like something you're in anyway interested in definitely go out and give it a go buy it make it the new game you're going to keep playing time and time again

but that was our review of circadians chaos order uh thank you for watching please subscribe if this was helpful to you in any way and just feel free to ask us anything you want to know about the game but we will see you next time thanks for watching

Progress saved