Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top Ten of 2016 (Retrospective) - The Broken Meeple

Transcript 52:46

2016 hitting this for a lot of things but certainly for in my case for movies particularly we've had absolute belters we've had absolute garbage and we've had completely overrated hey guys welcome to another broken people top ten and this one has been requested by you the viewers I was tended to do this for a while but I wasn't certain if anybody really

wanted it so I asked question after I did my top ten of 2017 video whether people wanted me to go back and look at a kind of retrospective look at all her years and the world I mean put it this way the response was staggering there was a lot of responses saying do it do it do it people wanted this to happen so I'm going one step further than what you asked firstly today I am looking at my retrospective top 10 of 2016 but I'm gonna go further than that I'm gonna go to 2015 I'm gonna go to 2014 and I'm gonna go to 2013 basically I'm gonna start from the beginning you know when my blog first came about when the broken me ball was first formed the 2013 was the first top ten I ever did so I'm gonna do that one and 14 and 15 and 16 all in those years I have done top tens so what's changed since then well you're gonna find out in the next several videos I do on this subject and we're gonna start today with 2016 we're gonna go 2016 15 14 frame will do a countdown essentially so the reason I wanted to do this is because I don't get to play every single game that has been released in a year but come on who does even the diced carrot can't manage it and so some games don't come by me during the actual gear and I might not necessarily see them until halfway into the next year or even further than that it just depends

on who has the game whether I get here whether people wanted to know about the game or not and just down to time I can't play every single game for a year it's hard enough to do what I do now and even then I'm trying to sort of tone it down a little bit after January to try and see if I can hit my work-life balance back into focus so with 2016 I had a look and I've got all the lists already in this black book my lovely little black book of top tens and it's interesting to see how much things have changed since those previous years some aren't terribly different but 2016 in particular and I would say probably 2015 14 yeah actually I think 2013 is probably the only year that hasn't changed a huge amount but the other three years have changed quite a bit and it just comes with board game experience I've just been introduced to new games I've been introduced to stuff that came out in those year so I thought oh wow this let me by why didn't I get to play this one there's all sorts of reasons so 16 has definitely changed quite a bit and that's what I'm going through today I'm gonna tell you my top 10 of 2016 I will mention if the game was on last month last year's if it was on the previous list and I'll mention at the end when games have dropped off this list and some honorable mentions as well so basically we're gonna find out what's changed in a kind of a year's time really with this so that's it let's get our move on

now here's a quick caveat I am sticking to board game geeks dating system for games there may be the occasional one that will be like oh come on that came out like December 230 if I can't call that 2016 game but I don't think any of those are gonna be on this list but if BoardGameGeek says it came out in that year I'm going with it okay so that's the caveat but this one was one I've only recently been accustomed to and that is flam Rouge fan Rouge a cycling racing game not one that I expected to go mad for because I mean cycling's not the most entertaining theme in the world but I do like a good simple racing game and this one just slipped me completely by for 2016 I never even heard of it even this year when I'm sorry this year 2017 I'm already getting into that when I did finally play out I was like this was last year wasn't it I barely even knew it was there so I played it and found out it's actually a good entertaining cycling racing game gateway level perfectly simple the expansion ups are even more were allowing up to six players and a so mode so it doesn't complicate the game unnecessarily it just gives you more of the good stuff and some more player options but the premise is very simple you have a custom-built track and you can follow the cards they give you or just create your own you start off at the beginning you have two riders and very much like those kind of Tour de France and you know des there's very long endurance cycling races you see on TV you essentially play a card each

round simultaneously turns a very quick and you move your riders hoping to take advantage of other players slipstream because if you can get your rider so it's certain trying to amass you know if you can get your rider so it's behind another one just a little bit of a gap you'll close the gap because you've got lack of air resistance but if you're at the front of the pack you'll get exhaustion because you're the one that's having to put more effort into your cycling but the timing aspect is what really works with this you know do you stay at the back of the pack yo or do you got it for the front and stay at the front how long do you keep slipstreaming before you feel eyes I've got to break away from the pack and gun it for the finish line did you slow yourself down too much that it doesn't matter how fast you go you won't catch them up you know did you tire yourself out too much on the hills you know there's all sorts of these cool orbits you got to think about but the gameplay is very simple rules can be taught in less than five minutes and you're away and now you can have up to six players you can have those like computer players solo players it's a great racing game definitely one that's sitting well in my collection I enjoy not for everyone not everybody's into that whole timing aspect or really cares that much about cycling but it's won my heart over so in number 10 for 2016 flam Bruges

my number 9 yes I've talked about this one quite a bit including my underrated games list I didn't get a chance to play this one to a great extent during 16 so I didn't feel right to put it on a list but I got more plays of it at the start 2017 and I thought oh yeah this is definitely got merit this is probably my well excluding one other we'll get on to that in another list but you know it's definitely one of my favorite bag building games and that is this jumbo thing right here which is automobiles automobiles is a bag building racing game yeah so far I'm starting with the racing theme here but you know much like where the other games like all the arms and stuff that people sort of praise about more this one instead has you racing your cars around a track and there's multiple tracks now I've got the racing season expansion for this very good expansion done the review on it I think and basically you draw the cubes at this bag and the cubes represent the different gears of your car different aspects like the acceleration that brakes the steering handling that kind of thing and even the engine for example and your idea is that you're balancing out your bag to get round the track and 'obviously finish first but you know do you go for the high gears do you go for a particular like yo do you soup up your engine do you work more on the handling and the steering it's really cool how it works and it takes back building and gives it a good theme this is my problem with a lot of the other bank building games that are out there I mean I put all the ons on my overrated list as well as I

think it's okay it's just tracks trash tracks it's just a standard euro game we've barely any fee here are you at least have the racing aspect there's more to it than just simply pulling cubes out of bags and that's what gets me more with this one with racing season you've now got driver special powers you've got multiple tracks whether you've got two players or five players you've got a track for it and even better is the campaigns of Grand Prix free race mode that you can do with it which as you do one whole race as normal but then you get sponsors to help you with other races and your bag remains the same from race to race we including all the cubes you've bought and all the way that you look you know it you know the waste cubes so your car might have done well in the first race but it might be battered to high heaven by the time you start the second one it's a cool system and allows you to make you know get two or three games of this out of the way and you could do it in one night even it doesn't take that long to play as long as you never come across AP players so definitely a solid one I enjoy the expansions made it better automobiles I deserved number nine for win number eight I'm actually noticing that the last two games were I think this will be the only two games but I talked about automobiles on my underrated games list this is another one I talked about on my underrated games list and I barely had a chance to play it by the time I need you know we

entered 2017 it was hard but this one is definitely worth oh my top ten and that is probably one of my favorite negotiation games I've got at the moment subject to a few and that is new Angelis new Angelis is not for everybody not everybody goes mad for negotiation games and I can see why but this is a solid negotiation game if you're willing to play it for three hours it's a long game it's a very thinking involved because it's set in a net run at universe you are playing as the corporation's like jinteki and Weyland and all the ones that you know from the neck Runner LCG if you're into that universe and with this you are making deals to say you know I will better the city by doing this I will get rid of these crime I'll get rid of crime I'll get rid of these power outages I will cure the disease do you know all these things but you've all got your own secret agenda all of you want money at the end of the day you are greedy corporations and the whole aspect of saving your city is just a byproduct of making yourself richer so everybody is negotiating with each other about what deals they want to pass what counteroffers they want to make whether somebody else can make counteroffers for them even though at the end of the day you just want money and you have a personal rival that you're trying to have more money man in order to win the game you can have a joint victory and that fact that you have you know pretty decent components even if the plastic mean orange is kind of weird and you know gorgeous artwork as usual and the

traitor mechanic where one of you is a liberalist I think it's called and you are actively trying to make the city tank during the game and you win if that happens so it's four to six players and it's definitely best with six works well at five not best at four I don't want to bring this out until unless I've got five or six players because then you've got all the corporations and the Liveris and it just is a blast it will take you a long time three hours I'm not kidding here it's a long negotiation game but it never feels like three hours you are engaged the entire time if you're involved in the offer or not doesn't matter you're interested in what's going down you're looking at what people are doing you're trying to figure out who that liberalist is so that you don't help out the traitor but you're always engaged it's fun it's frantic it is brain burning you need to take a nap after you've played this but it is a solid negotiating game and one if you are a fan of the genre number eight new Angelis underrated

whenever seven is another new entry I've had already I've had four new games on this list since my last 2016 list that is how much you know it's changed from new games I've managed to play and this one I have given so much buzz with regards to its rule book because it's rule book is fantastic it's allowed me to play this medium weight euro game in next to no time where the solo or not it's brilliant and that is Manhattan Project energy Empire based off the original Manhattan Project but not a direct sequel in this one you're not building nuclear bombs you're instead building factories and you're trying to protect the environment to an extent you want to have the most victory points of money by the end of the game but in doing so you're building power plants in order to power all your various activities and escapades and infrastructures but you also need to keep an eye on the environment and not pollute it too much because it will be worth negative points to you if not if it goes too far it's a great balancing act between how much you want the pollution to you know decimate your landscape and how much you don't you've got you know the UN track that you level up in order to get more points which everybody can do and it's kind of a tank race for that but on top of this you're building buildings you're collecting these custom dice to generate power of return and the great thing that this is that it's a simple worker placement mechanic of put your workers on the more workers empower that you put with each thing is mold that other people have to spend to go to your spot so yes you can

sort of block other players but you've got to put more meeples down in order to do that people can still go to your spot if they want to it's not just full-out block but eventually you've got to take your meeples off the board and generate power for the next round when I say round your next round of Meatballs because there's no round per se it's all different timings of when people take their meatballs on and off and I love that because too many worker placement games are quite stringent in round one do this to do that take your guys back round two to the lip take your beetles off do that you know it's very linear this is fluid very fluid because green might take their players back you know they meatballs back now I might not take him back for another two turns and blue might have to take him on and off constantly because they don't have many meeples but they have a lot of dykes you know it it's really cool how you've got to look at what is you need to do versus when you think the best time is to do it do I wait for someone to get off my space with their meeples before I say meatballs workers you know before I go there or do I spend the workers to go there now because I need it now there's a lot of decisions there's a lot of paths to victory and it's very thematic it scales pretty well from one to five players can take a bit long with five I'm not the biggest fan of playing it with five four is okay if you don't have analysis process pity pool but for work free is brilliant two is great and even a solo mode great it's a solid game definitely deserving of this top ten

number seven Manhattan Project energy Empire when number six is the first game that was on my original list and it was high on my original list it is actually come down four places since the last time mainly because it's a bit of a nightmare to get to the table and that is kind of killing it slightly for me it's a fantastic game I love it when I can play it but it's like a free for our game and you can only play it two players it's a bit of a pain to get to the table and that's why it's dropping but there is no denying that if you want Star Wars in the Box you get Star Wars rebellion it's a fantastic two-player game and the rise of the Empire expansion improved one of the main problems with the old game which was the combat mechanism was a bit destroy it before now you have the tactic cards and it works great on top of that you can throw in some rogue one elements if you are a fan of that movie yeah I was all right with it but it could have been better but the game itself is solid it's rich in theme you've got great miniatures great artwork good cards it's just a great 2 player game that's asymmetrical we know one is trying to figure out where the rebel base kind of doing a deduction game whereas the other one is doing hit-and-run tactics and survival it's such a cool formatic experience and the main reason it has dropped from two to six is

because it's just hard to get to the table this is a three to four hour game at the best of times particularly if you're teaching it if two of you know this game inside that you might be able to do it in over two hours but to do it in any less than that something's iffy I can't see this being that short a game ever for me and that's what's hurting it because I have to teach it a lot which means it's gonna be a long game and I don't have opportunities where I can play a two-player game for that length of time because I go to beat group game nights it's it's hurting it but when I do get to play it I love it it is definitely worthy there's tab ten even if I have to accept that timeline and the accessibility of it does let it down a little bit so yeah you know still solid still love it just wish I could play it more often Star Wars rebellion Star Wars in the box number six

number five is this rate going to be one of my top picks for gateway games I mean there's so many good gateway games out there and I've got a whole series called the starting tile on fruit punch lunch that basically goes into different gateway games other than the usual Catan Carcassonne and you know taking the ride in what have you but this one why did I not play this last year I saw it I saw reviews I just didn't go for it I didn't know if I would like it as much it looked a bit too cutesy even though I do like cutesy themes now and again but wow this is just a fantastic gateway game there's no other way to put it and if this one dream whom yes dream home I'm not joking here this is not a wind-up dream home is a fantastic gateway game it's simple to play but has interesting decisions to make because you are choosing a column of cards of this board some rooms and some are various things that help you like the roofs and helpers and tools and such and you're basically cutting out this big house board you know great component quality in here and you're trying to set the rooms up in various ways that you can make bigger rooms for more points you know get certain combinations in there for like you know extra points like I need a sandy the bathroom the kitchen and a bedroom to make it functional great bonus points and the base game alone is already good fun you know simple can be done in 30 minutes 45 minutes tops even with up to 4 players the expansion I've

got for this though has really elevated it I mean it would be probably a bit lower down this list if I didn't have the expansion I think it's called 1 5 6 on each Street it's got a weird name but oh well and all it did was free things it added two more players so I can now play this with up to 6 players and it takes no more than an hour to play with six players fantastic I've got a simple game and I can teach in 5 to 10 minutes and get everyone playing and we can finish it in an hour perfect it also added two very simple modules the blueprints which is basically another way of getting endgame scoring and the friends which are basically you know during the game if you get certain rune con nation's next to each other on floors you get the card that gives you one two or three points depending on the difficulty of it that's literally it very simple additions you've got new cards with the five and six player count but you know they're more cards it's just a bit more variety but even just those blueprints and the friends they're so easy to teach I throwed them into every game I teach doesn't matter if they're brand new to games I will throw them in because they're very simple here's two cards that start a game you can score one of them aim for one go for it they're easy you know the friends get those colors in the right in you know and on the floor doesn't have to be that order but just get them on that floor get a few bonus points great but then when you add that to everything else in this game like the yeah the functionality bonuses the roof bonuses the the helpers that give you bonus points the points for just having the rooms in general the deck or tokens

there's so many ways this score it's almost like a cutesy point salad but unlike the point salads we've seen like all the Stefan fields and pulsar and all that lot this has a good theme you know everything that you do and it makes sense you've got to build from the ground up you know functionality bonuses are like what you would expect a house to be kitted as and everyone can just get into that theme and laugh about it because everyone's looking at each other's houses going I'm not gonna live in yours mate seriously what I've got no bathroom or anything what are you supposed to do in there and then there's a house that's got a game room a couple of play rooms and you know a garage gym or something and it's just like yeah I've got all the fun stuff in here granted I can't live here ever I can't cook my own food or anything but I've got my games room I'm happy that's all I need in my house there's just a lot of good things to say about this game and like I say we'd be interesting to maybe get a little bit of extra meat in there eventually just for if I want to play it more with like gamers but I've even managed to get my parents to like this and that's a very tricky thing to do so stream home I look forward to more expansions it's soon it seems to hint in the rule book that there's gonna be more cards coming out can't wait please give me more variety don't make it too complicated just give me more card and I'll be happy but I've raved on that mat enough dream home check it out if you like any sort of gateway level cutesy theme game definitely worth my number five okay we're into the top four

and this is gonna be the last new debut yeah a lot of new games have featured into this top ten in 2016 that's how much it's changed since last time a lot but this is the highest new entry and the main reason it didn't feature the last time is because I just didn't get to play it enough because I had only one play of it it was a Essen and it wasn't a very good demo seriously publishers get people to learn the rules to the game they're demoing seriously infuriates me when people who are there the demo games don't know how to play the games are there the demo seriously now the difficult thing did a range but I digress it's just me but this one I played one game of it in a four it's okay but I'm seeing potential but this hasn't wowed me yet we had to mess around with rules we couldn't finish the game it was a good demo but I needed more then I finally thought you know what I'll get my own copy and we'll see what it's like you know when it came out on the UK release I decided I want a review copy I want to check it out I'm so glad I did this is I hope it's right beyond my head this is a great game this is inish again not for everybody and the artwork is a little polarizing the Sun but there's this kind of trilogy of games that's going around that you know you've got like Cyclades you've got Kemet everyone sort of thinks that this is like a third in a trilogy of manner goes sort of dudes on the map type game in us bones they have a point there I like Cyclades

it's a very good game you need a specific set of expansions to play it well otherwise it's a bit yeah chem it I'm alright with but again I find that some of the powers that you can get her a bit unbalanced there's a lot to think about with those texts and it's a little bit too in-your-face I still like it I still think it's a cool game but you know it's kind of on par with Cyclades this is my pick of the free though finish you will have a mixture of dudes on the map with drafting you draft these great looking you know big Tarot sized cards with special abilities during your term you'll have a phase where you draft the cards and then you play the cards in order to trigger actions on the map to move guys around populate with more Klansmen to fight other players and bring out more of the map and the map tiles look gorgeous I think Oh where'd they all that likes off any shuriken zit look it looks like if you threw it hard enough you literally would take someone's head off or at least embed in the neck and cut lethal weapons but they look great and there's two aspects of this that really seemed to me first the multiple victory conditions you can win the game by one of three ways you only have to meet one but as soon as you meet it you have to announce you're gonna win which gives every other player the chance to whale on you until that time comes so you have to time it right to the point when you are at your strongest and they're at their weakness or you time it so it's near the end of a round when you announce it so that when people haven't got enough of a chance or

enough cards to come at you you've got different cards that you draw from a separate deck which are like more powerful ones you know so they're all unique lots of different things can happen but even the normal drafting phase is interesting you've got I think it's 17 cards so there's always one left over and you have four each and you you see them every round but you'll get them at different times and you'll think well this random kind of need that card I want back to come round I'm gonna take it when I can and unlike other drafting games normally you pick one card pass them on and then you may never see those cards again here you will should you should see them come back round but in addition what you've already drafted you're stuck with you can't then take it back here it's different you draft one card pass the other free around but then you take the card who just drafted and the free that your opponent gives you look at all four and then pick two of them so you actually could just stick with the one you just drafted and add another one to it but you might actually look at the new set of cards and go you know what I don't want that original current now I want to try this strategy this round so you can leave it in the cards that you're about to pass on take two different ones and pass it on it's a neat little twist and I'd like to see that in more drafting games because currently I cannot think of one that does that correct me if I'm wrong in the comments cuz I'd like to play that game if there is because I think that's a neat little twist a chance to change your mind midway through a drafting phase it's a

very entertaining game and its main flaws is that with four players it can go long you know it says sixty minutes on the box yeah with two players maybe but with four players you're looking at a good two our experience here it's a lengthy game and woe betide if you play this with anybody with analysis paralysis tendencies because they will sit there and a drafting phase and you will just want to rip the cards are not caring and get a move on because they're taking so long the twos between two to three cards it happens to all of us but yeah avoid the analysis process player to this certainly you want to play it a couple of times to get used to the tactics and strategy because it may not become apparent to you in your first game and this definitely rewards multiple players but yeah I think liking it it's not my favorite style of artwork but I can't deny it's good artwork it took talent to make this and they do look very colorful on them in the cards and the map tiles look gorgeous so this is solid and I hear there's an expansion coming out later this year for it so hopefully they'll be the case just give me more cards more cards more map tiles more variety don't add too many extra mechanics I just want more the good stuff in ish highest debut for the retrospective 2016 list at number four

my final three have remained in this list since the last time it was made did they move up or down you'd like to see well right now this one stayed level it was number three last time it's number three this time and it is the great Arkham Horror the living card game yeah why am i holding up a rule book well that's cuz I don't have the boxes anymore because this is a living card game and most people do not keep the original box I instead have this great box from I believe they call themselves optical laser I'll see if I can get a picture in a description Napper this is a giant cover box this is just the lid but I've got one of these and you can get it for all the Arkham horror games they do several they've done a vault that I've used for my eldritch horror and Arkham Hall ones but this is a box which I use for the LCG ones so this is just the lid and below it I can't get it right now is a bit too heavy but it contains all of my LCG encounter cards and it will do for the next several cycles and then I have a symbol ring binder with all of the cards to date all arranged nicely in there and for me to deck build but our Campari LCD is kind of like a direct rival to the Lord of the Rings living card game they function in a similar way they're both cooperative they both allow for one two three or four players and the idea is is that you're playing against an encounter deck the scenario is laid out with the plot in the storyline and different objectives each time and the idea is is that your construct your deck with the

investigator of particular factions and types and you'll go into each scenario you know going for the storyline fighting off baddies investigating weird you know mumbo-jumbo style you know Cthulhu Mythos tales and things you should not know and you'll attempt to complete the scenario but this is still great fun because each scenario feels very different in terms of certain mechanics there's always a quirk to a particular scenario that separates out from others I mean one time you might be scouting around a three or four storey building so that you've got to constantly go through the locations and a certain whay another time you have the locations in one big conveyor belt and you're basically moving along a train carriage as the backend of the train carriage is getting sucked off into a pool or somewhere there's some great variation with these scenarios and they don't all hit home I mean some of the cycle PACs have been better than others but some of the scenarios when they do good stuff it's fantastic stuff do I like it more than our Lord of the Rings card game no I still prefer the Lord of the Rings LCG but they're great I mean if you like one of the other I can see why this is still a solid thematic game and I mean I imagine I've actually been playing with like the last couple of days so I've got my I got here my mark Harrigan deck the soldier he's teaming up with a we got a Safina Ross Sol connemara named the painter not just and I'm going through the the cycle packs for the path to

kakuzu campaign now that deals with the king in yellow which is probably one of my favorites of the Cthulhu Mythos tales this whole aspect of a a play that comes and gets performed in theaters it's all weird but everyone who sees it goes completely man and people die in all sorts of weird creepy stuff happens it's one of my favorites and so far enjoying that as well the Dunwich legacy was a great cycle you know enjoyed that one even if it did get a little bit fiddly at the end and it's just solid from manic if you want a story driven style LCG this is definitely one of the ones you should be considering Eve you know unless you're not a fan of the Cthulhu Mythos in which case maybe you can skip it but it's definitely a solid one very fanatic very you know not too difficult to get going you just might either rules reference from time to time but it's even easier to construct your deck because it levels up as you go through the campaign so you buy Eckler cards with more experience points but most games require you to build like a 50 card deck and that's quite tricky to think of 50 to 60 cards to make a deck with here decks are usually around only 30 cards and you can only have two copies max of a particular card so suddenly it's a lot easier to construct a deck in this one I find then other LC so if you're one of the people like me for example who doesn't get a giant kick out of constructing decks it's an easier time to do it here and of course like me you could just do what a lot of other

people do and go on to you've got I think it's called Arkham DB and and for long the range you've got rings DB and I mean all right you know Android netrunner and all the other lcg's do a similar thing they've got like a website that has people submitting their decklist - you don't wanna make your own deck then do what I do go online find someone credible who's done a decent-looking deck of your favorite character take their idea tweet maybe one or two things to your you know your personal preference and there you go it's not a bad thing at the end of the day I want to get through those the campaign and enjoy the story and I do with this one Arkham Horror LCG solid number three and it stayed there great game my number two has actually climbed since the last time it was previously number four now it's climbed slightly to take the place of what was Star Wars rebellion and that is another Cthulhu game but wow this was such a good reprint of this game it's unreal definitely one that deserves a place in the Hall of Fame when it comes to Cthulhu games I can barely lift a with one hand out oh god this is heavy mansions of madness second edition this is pretty an absolutely brilliant game mansions of madness the original one was very clunky it could be broken easily had to have a DM running it and it was

alright but it was definitely a bit of a mmm fashioned of hand everybody care you know that can go away so when this one came out and said it was going to be driven I was sold because I'm always about getting apps into games and this is possibly XCOM you got a few others I think and first Marsh's none I think this is the best app integration we've had for a board game today absolutely perfect it handles a lot of bookkeeping it handles the combat it drives the story provides musical you know it even provides narrative descriptions of what you're doing combat so when you say I'll attack this monster with a bladed weapon it tells you that you you know you slide in under its feet and try and carve its leg out as you go through or so you know it gives you something you could pitch in your head as a cinematic moment the map tiles you know I laid out on the screen and you're laying out in front of you and miniatures and yeah the miniatures could have been a bit better not just in terms of quality but also just not have those fiddly bases that you put the snacks in that was a bit of a misstep but oh well big deal but this is heavy because I've got everything for it I have the the ones are the ones that upgraded it from first to second edition you know those scenarios I've got the expanded beyond the threshold and streets of Arkham I did a review on that recently and I'm gonna continue getting stuff for it because it's just so much fun it's heavy but I mean most of the weight is just the map tiles I've got I think half of this box is just map tiles and in fact

yeah enough it's so much content because I have two boxes I can't physically fit it all in one box anymore so this contains all the map tiles and all the miniatures and this contains the cards and the sonars and rulebook sheets there's so much content you've got the DLC that you can get on the on the app itself so you can download in a few quid buy another scenario the scenarios will feel very different automatic they're atmospheric it's just fantastic this was a top ten in my top 100 and deservedly so and I mostly if not always only play it solo I tried this with four or five players but it really doesn't work it takes far too long with too many players deciding what they want to do now free maybe I could do if you knew what you were doing - it actually works quite well - players can have good fun with this but personally I'm happy just to sit in this solo enjoy a good atmospheric horror game with free investigators that I control and yeah you definitely want free little top tip for you if you play this with only two investigators you kind of unbalancing some of the scenarios to just completely hose down you want to control free if not four at a time to get the most balanced solo experience but yes I digress love it fantastic it was number four last time it's number two this time it has gone up in my appreciation levels just love this

game this is hands-down the best Cthulhu game I think to date my number one hasn't changed most of you probably cooked this it was number one last time it's number one this time I must admit I came close I came close to thinking oh good mansions that madness possibly beat this one but still loved the game still loved to play it I own so much from it and the recent expansion actually brought it higher in the sense of my appreciation which is probably why it just edged out mansions but my god it was close this is the small box I have for it this oh my word I am gonna get hernia oh if we were wondering like oh my god he's throwing these games around trust me not by choice these things are heavy but you know I I try to keep my games and good Nick but sometimes you will get the occasional dead you just can't help these things sigh you called it I know it's polarizing to some I know this has been one of the most divisive games that you can get for you know the ones that have been majorly hyped but I just love it it just seems to me do I want to go full aggressive I can do it do I want to go

just build up resources and build up a ton of economy I can do so do I want to go out and find encounters I can do so depending on what factions and boards you get the start it will tailor your strategy but I can choose what I want to do there's a lot of variation in each game I've now got the slightly expansions for seven factions so you've got lots the different ones to choose from and any issues I had with the base game we're fixed with this because now you've got the airships which allow you more ways to transport around the map and even more variety in how the game plays out on top of that they're fantastic miniatures but it also gave you the resolution tiles so people fought no it just gets the six stars no just ends boring which is a fair criticism to make it's probably the minor issue I had to the game but now the resolution tiles give a different ending every single game with a end in 20 turns flat will it end after the fifth star and then after a short explosion from the fact will it be a kinder Hill style experience you know there's lots of different ways the game can end now and now you have variable endgame conditions on top of all your bearable starting positions and starting resources in that it's a solid game wonderfully produced I love the minis I love the realistic resources granted this is a Kickstarter edition so it does have all the fancy upgrades I would still happily play this game if it was just the retail version because it's still that solid of a game and I just get a kick out of it it's one that is supremely heavy it's got a

custom insert and everything annoyingly I have to keep some stuff in this box because unfortunately it wasn't intelligent enough to go by the legendary box when it came out that supposedly holds this and this with the insert and the next expansion coming up which by the way sounds amazing a legacy style campaign for life oh yes light but yeah if I find another copy of the legendary box I'm getting it and if anybody has a spare copy of the legendary box in the UK please get in touch because I would like it but yeah I still love sorry it's not for everyone and I can see why some people wouldn't like it not everybody went on mad on the hype for this and to be fair I didn't sign up to the hype for this I don't think it deserved all that hype it got cuz they got a sick amount of hype yeah hype destroys games in my opinion well certainly in my opinion of some of them and you know but it's still from my mind a solid game that I just love to play again another top 10 in my you know top 10 list in my top 100 you know I mean it was in my top 10 but love it to bits such a fantastic game not for everyone perfectly understand that we don't like it that's totally fine I can see why you know some of the criticisms that some people have made I kind of valid you know I may not necessarily agree with them as such but I can see yeah I mean from where you're coming from I see why you don't like it but I love it in it I'm gonna keep this a long time I love it love the expansions can't wait for the new one it was number one last time it is number one this time so that is

the be retrospective tapped of 2016 and this was quite enjoyable to do actually to go back and look at previous lists to see oh my god my tastes have changed you know I've played more games and now when I come to think of it these are better than those and there's not two more reasons why games have gone up and down on the list so this was a really enjoyable list to do it I'm glad that you the viewers wanted me to do this because you know I got a kick out doing it and I can't wait to get stuck into 2015 and 14 and 13 for you guys because for the most part they've changed quite dramatically as well from when I originally did those top tens and it's gonna be interesting to talk about what is that changed so I just want to end with this a little bit quickly by mentioning the last list I did in order from 10 you know from 1 to 10 I'll go down size number one yeah that was an easy one Star Wars a billion number two so it's dropped a bit free Arkham Horror dlc G stayed where it is now here's where things change of it mansions amman the second edition was number four that rose two places as you're aware now it really gets different quadropple us was my number five dropped off the list that was still a top 100 game for me it's a great city building gateway game whatever actually wears oh yeah down there it's a solid game still enjoy it but literally this would probably be like I suppose an 11 or 12 you know it's there's just a lot

of really good games that are just slightly better in core jobless there's no major reason it's falling off the list it's just that was actually more good games in 2016 I might have given original credit for numbers where we world 5 was cooked up there six words Imhotep yes Imhotep still on my shelf still enjoy it wasn't on my top 100 it's starting to drift a bit because of its dried theme in that but it's a solid gateway game very cutthroat in your face but it's a neat design it's got good variability and even if it has dropped for me a little bit I still really enjoy it preferably with two to three players but works ok it for a very solid game you know there's not much bad I can say about it it's just ball better games I've played for 2000 thing really again number seven yeah this one has dropped a bit for me even though it's still in my a legendary vault above me the giant case and that is a legendary encounters Firefly I love the Firefly universe I think the series is one of the best TV series I've ever watched as a game it's drifted a bit it probably would maybe make my top 15 I'm not sure cuz it's fun the mechanics of it are fine but there's only so much variation even when you're playing two different episodes and one big polarizing factor about it it's just the artwork is so horrible it really is the artwork is just dire so dire yeah I don't know why they greenlit some of that artwork it's just so bad there's

like a couple of good pieces in it but other than that it's hard to bring out a game when it looks that bad and that's why it's fallen off the list for the other starters but it's drifting a bit for me certainly I much prefer to play Marvel than injury I'd much prefer to play alien legendary definitely and then even the predator legendary so Firefly is just kind of fallen by the wayside for me and let's see what we have eight was pissed Odin yeah this one's starting to drop off it might fall off my top 100 because it was only you saw barely on there beforehand and this was basically Viking Tetris you know the theme is kind of there but it's a bit of a disconnect to have - oh if I put my bread horizontally it feeds more people than if I put it vertically what and oK we've gone out and done these actions and why am i putting coins and armaments and that in Tetris style like shapes and knights it fur matically it's a bit of a disconnect even though there is some of it there it's not completely drawing abstract but this one is starting to fall a bit not because I don't enjoy it I still think it's an enjoyable game but it's such a bugbear to learn and teach this state you've got four wheeler 60 different action spaces and things that you can do which great great variety of options now teach the thing it's ridiculous you've got new people dread playing this with anybody who doesn't know the game because you've got the teet all those spaces and it's just well Mina's all get-out and the fact

that I haven't played it for the wall is gonna be a problem because now I'm gonna have to relearn it myself and I mean psyche I'll learn all those spaces again it's it's a fun game and I do like it but out of those sort of early Rosenberg style games it's falling down rapidly just because it's just such a bugbear to get to the table and learn and teach it's fun but it's convoluted and it's very convoluted so you know solid but would possibly make a top 15 maybe 15 odd or something but yet that whole thing of being difficult to learn and teach is what's bringing it down a bit the game itself is sound and very enjoyable though and number nine last time was not alone not alone I digress but not alone is a solid card game where you know several people are trying to obey the alien as it's trying to hunt them down it's a sort of all versus one card game where you're trying to psych your opponent out you know the agent is trying to figure out where are they gonna go this round where do I want to put my counters and hunt down and the survivors are trying to evade you wait does he agent think I'm gonna go can I fool them and go over here instead but no he's I'm gonna tree knows I'm gonna trigger diability knows I want to go there so maybe I'll go there but maybe he knows I know that so maybe he's double bluffing me it's it's one of

those cool sort of I in your hit style card games very quick very tough it is tough for the survivors to win that game unless they get very lucky with some of the survival cards that you can draw or the agent is kind of ineffectual but you know it's a decent solid game and literally the only reason it's not on the list is because some better games have come out and it was number nine last year so there's only so much there li-huei room oh yeah top 15 game for me I think not alone it is a solid one and I'm looking forward to getting some of the expansions to it because unfortunately I'm still waiting for them to get released I think I missed out on them at conventions or they weren't on sale yet I don't know but certainly in the UK I have not seen a tell of the not alone expansions yet and I want them and then finally number 10 was Ken Aguilar yes right behind me can I can I go work an Agora whatever and it's a solid gateway game still have it still love teaching it has a few thing key aspects that do throw off some new players so it's not the very first thing I teach a lot of people but it is still gateway level I think it's the Gateway for many people it's such beautiful artwork very simple like push your luck style game play multiple ways to score it's just one of those Zen charming games that just makes you go ahh you know it's like tacky no Cohen Tokaido it's in that kind of Zen feel in fact this must have been on my top 10 Zen games it must have been go watch that top 10 actually so I don't think that's getting as much love as the other ones but it's an interesting list and so it's

a solid game it's just like I say it was number 10 last year so all I needed was one extra game that was bearing in it to push it off of this that's pretty much the deal just more bear games top 15 yeah probably I think it would make the top 15 you know it's a solid game and I really enjoyed to bring it out as a nice nice light touch for starting an evening or bridging a gap which is ending an evening on a light note so yeah it's a solid game so yeah that's it really I mean you know there's certainly a lot of others are considered you know vinyasa 2016 almost made the list mystic Vail was another contender let's see I wrote that down twice for some reason hi find was another consideration the party game and other than that I think that's it I think I mentioned all the others so I'm gonna wrap this one up because the lights are starting to go out on some of these the batteries really don't last long and I've been recording a other videos today so it's getting a little bit dark so I'm gonna end this one on a high note 2016 better games came out than I originally gave it credit for because it's just a testament to how much the list changed there were more good games than I originally thought so fair enough to 2016 I think the 2016 was a better year than 2017 for me game wise and you will see when I do the other list that there's gonna be some pretty big changes there as well I'm looking forward to talking about some great games when it comes to other 2015 lists until then take care and

regardless of what games you like they're still only games so I'll see you on the next top ten thank you guys for suggesting this idea to me hope you enjoyed it and I hope you'll enjoy the next free in this retrospective series take care everyone you

you

Progress saved