Skip to main content
Loading video...

Wargame Archaeology: War College Wargaming with Col. Sam Gardiner

Transcript 46:20

hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson for beond soliter and I have a very special guest uh this is retired Air Force Colonel Sam Gard how are you doing today Sam good AEL I'm super excited to have you on because the reason I want to talk to you is because you have had a long history in doing war games uh in a professional context so uh for for people who are getting to know you um how did you get into professional War gaming in career is that something that happened early uh or did you stumble on it later no I taught uh strategy at the national War college for about 10 years and early into that I discovered that war games were a best way to almost understand strategy so my class each class would be a mini war game and the students would be asked to play roles and then we would examine afterwards what what came out of that of that discussion is wargaming something that you discovered as a hobby first no no it just it's it's just like going in and say uh you know if uh if Iran has a nuclear weapon what do we do that's a war game to to the extent that examine the future Alternatives and the Strategic Dynamics uh that are involved in that

situation so it's just it's actually a what it is is an exch ion of adult learning you know adults don't learn when they're told things adult learns when they explore things so that was it sort of where my thinking came from and why it pushed me in that direction you know what you say that I'm not sure that children learn things from being told either so I feel that works for certainly adults show um so uh when you like came across the thought of doing this in your classroom is it something that other people were already doing or did you just instinctively figure it out trying to get your students to engage uh I think I moved in my own Direction uh I thought you know it worked and the students were excited about it and uh well that's it that's awesome I I like having this conversation because I feel like this is an indicator that like really anybody can war game and War gaming can spring up anywhere you know we have very complex rule sets on some of them and stuff now but um you know it could also just start with a good question so how uh how structured were your war games while you were in the classroom um you know sometimes you it sounds like you started with just a question but how complicated could they get well that before you do a war game

what you I think you have to understand is what the strategic dynamics of the situation are you don't just go off and do the Navy has had War Games up at Newport Rhode Island for U 50 years and they are very detailed and they just sort of said well let's have a war game and see what happens that's not the way I conducted it I you know it's the Strategic Dynamic is that if Iran has a nuclear weapon that's going to change relations in the Middle East how does it change and what does that mean so you're you're pushing a storyline that has to do with strategic situation and the Dynamics and in an any strategic situation I guess there are probably three or four Dynamics you need to understand and so that was once you sort of narrow in on those you push to to examine what the consequences are how do you pick like the most important things that you want to home in on in these games because I mean these situations are really complicated um so what what level of like um of closeness to the subject and focus can you get uh in these scenarios well that you know that what maybe Ukraine is a good

example there are we're at sort of a focal point of what the future is going to look like and there are a number of things it could do it could be uh the Donald Trump solution or Russia may not go along with that so just those are two alternative Futures you need to understand U and then talk about what the consequences of either of those are nice all right so we've kind of watched you as somebody who uses war games in you know in classroom context but it's also really clear um from some of the notes that you sent me before this interview that you took your wargaming and you applied it to um situations outside of the classroom so briefing ambassadors and working with organizations uh is that something that started after you'd beun teaching or did you bring something that you'd done professionally into your classroom no it sure came came after I did teaching and then uh I sort of had a reputation for doing war games and people would call me and ask me to get involved excellent so what are some of your favorite projects that you have worked on in that context oh well probably the one that I think was most significant was uh the Iran nuclear issue uh in over a period of oh three or

four years I may have done 10 or 15 or 20 different War Games examining that all that conse that situation and the consequence of it the thing about because I didn't work for anybody I could test different audiences with the Iran situation uh I did a did and described a game for the Atlantic was actually described in the magazine one month I did a game for uh the CNN in which they with the actual players examining what alternatives were by the time I had finished that couple of years I had some conclusions I wrote some papers as a result of those conclusions uh I was invited by the US ambassador to the UN to come to the an informal meeting of the security Council in which I briefed what the results of this of the games had shown uh and as part of that U I sat next to the Ambassador from Iran and looked him in the eye and said that if you respond in a wrong way you will be forced with regime change the consequence of this getting out of hand you need to

understand so it gave me an opportunity uh to talk about policy in ways that you couldn't do otherwise oh that's really interesting so when you told the Ambassador this how did he respond uh like an ambassador I mean he you know I they had known the reason the meeting was called was because they knew what I had been doing and uh so they were opening to listening and uh it was uh zachar was the Ambassador at the time who speaks very good English and he's very Western oriented so he knew what he was was seeing and what was involved so he he responded but but I presumably the message got back to Tran because you don't have a meeting of Security Council uh for the purposes of talking about your country and not report back home I mean fair enough so uh when you ran these games for like say CNN how um how did you structure the game differently for like different audiences so if you're playing it with students you might do it one way but how does it change for like a magazine or a news organization well the the uh game I did for CNN was actually with Prince of

the dni the Director of National Intelligence was one of the players and you when you do something like that with those kinds of players you need to be relatively sophisticated and that one of the things that came out of that game was we got people who truly had a grasp of how much destruction would occur if we attacked Iranian nuclear facilities and then how long it would take for them to repair those facilities and after we did that uh one of the players said we may have to live with Iran with nuclear weapons you don't blow up the knowledge to produce a weapon so no matter how many times we blow that up they have the knowledge to produce a nuclear weapon Iran is a virtual nuclear power just as Sweden is a virtual nuclear power oh that's interesting all right let so um it sounds like your gaming about Iran was I guess relatively successful in that you got to do a lot of research people listened to what you had to say uh how do you make sure that people are going to listen in war games and also how do you um what happens if you miss a

perspective uh well but by doing it more than once you tend to search perspective the whether people missed the one of the other things is I wrote a paper for the century foundation in which I summarized all of it so uh it wasn't as if it were done and just laid out out for others to look at I wanted to tell people what I thought we were saying and I frankly that's been during the Bush Administration and we've lost it the the knowledge didn't hang around because we just read this last week that uh Biden asked what happens what would happen if we attack the Iranian nuclear facility oh so the things that you learned from that war game didn't necessarily get passed down to Future administrations yeah yeah ah all right so this also leads me to ask you know I asked about um missing perspectives because um we also kind of came to this prepared maybe to talk about your game about policy in Libya and uh and what happens if not everybody um is is heard so could you tell us about um the inter agency game uh that you did for for the dod yeah not too well because I don't

remember it very well it wasn't that profound but uh there are no let me use a different example let me use Ukraine this what's I've been working on a game on Ukraine and what becomes clear to me is that one of the negative outcome comes is it occurs if the United States doesn't continue to provide assistance to the government to fight that war could I go to the state department and say I want to do a game for you to show what happens if the United States doesn't provide assistance to Ukraine they can't do that you can't do that the administration wouldn't allow the state department to provide them a policy options so what has to happen is you have to go outside of the institutions and do enough so that you get people's attention but you do it where it's possible to really examine an alternative you know if H if the president found out that the state department was examining increased military aid to Ukraine maybe they'd be on today's list for people fired Fair all right so how are you um going about your work on your game and who are

you hoping is going to play it well I I'm starting this a little bit differently because it's so sensitive I I'm actually doing it on one onone with people uh I have some contacts from doing this before and I asked them to examine the key issues and so I'm I'm doing this by micr steps uh and I I think it probably at the end I will end up having to write something uh about what the conclusion is but then and you know that the thing of it um Trump is not very wise with respect to understanding second order consequences he can't do what happens if this happens he can say I want this to happen so that it's even harder to get to him uh if you tell him that that well what's coming out of of what I've been doing so far is that Russia is very likely to keep fighting and cause a humanitarian crisis in the humanitarian crisis at a time when Europe is just like the United States they have turned negative against refugees and displaced person so he has a weapon that he can

use against all of Europe not just to Ukraine which is the chaos of humanitarian disaster oh so when you are designing this game um how is the game structured like how many people is it for and what kinds of rules are you putting in place to kind of help people understand um the situation as you see it it starts out not very structure but as I've talked to people I find out what people don't know and what I have to put into sort of the background of the game and one of those is this change in Europe about uh refugees you know everybody was so open to Ukrainian in 2020 uh people assume that that's the case but it's not the case uh politicians in Poland Germany France the UK Etc are are developing negative attitudes about we don't want they're bad people they do crime is almost as if Trump is giving them a script to read from who knows old discover one day um but um so you also mentioned that you um have been doing a lot of one-on-one play

because you are concerned about having a game that's about sensitive issues um at what point do you think a game is too sensitive like how how gritty are you getting versus it's just a political issue that people have a lot of strong feelings about well I I'm at the stage right now where I've gone one-on-one to I send out parts of the game to maybe 50 people and of that 50 people all of whom are in Ukraine interest group uh I'll get back maybe two or three suggesting I shouldn't badmouth Trump that he's going to find a solution I mean is it badmouthing to ask questions I mean maybe this this world yeah no oh it is bad mouthing to say that you know that Trump will not have a political Solution that's going to be acceptable to Ukraine and Russia okay this actually leads me to a fresh question you talked about your one of your previous games um the game about or the Run uh being one that you conducted during the Bush Administration um so that means that you have successfully done policy work under conservative administrations in the past so how

do how have you felt from Administration to Administration and um you know do you feel that more than just politics has changed yeah I it everybody is sensitive to not saying the country line uh people are afraid to do that and the commandant of the Coast Guard was fired yesterday because she did uh you feeling exercises or discussions about accepting people of different color different sexual orientation I mean it's not just sensitive in the in the sense that you shouldn't do it but you get fired if you do it the the evidence is so was that true under previous administrations where you were doing these games or do you think people used to be more open to different viewpoints used to be more open it was possible to have a part of the government that was examining Alternatives uh that wasn't in itself a threat but it appears now to be a threat would you say that that was true under Bush and under say like Clinton or I don't know who you were working under um it wasn't wasn't true under Bush

uh certainly to the extent that it is now interesting uh you also have like this long running interest in humanitarian issues so you're very concerned about humanitarian crisis in Ukraine um and am I correct in in my in Remembering you've also done a game about Syria yeah again not significant it's not in my top list of things I think it's significant just because I mean you know Syria is undergoing some changes right now as well I guess I just want to know like did things play out the way that your game did um and if you're doing a new one what would that look like yeah and then there's the the for that is the issue of chemical weapons uh you know if that were introduced it would change the situation interesting all right so you mentioned some of your games that you see as like more or less significant than others so let's talk about another one of your top games what's a very significant game that you that you want to talk about uh one of them has to do with nuclear weapons okay we haven't done well a adapting to the way the world has changed more people having nuclear weapons and then a major significant change is that the size of the nuclear

weapons now being produced by the United States and Russia are much smaller than what we knew when Nagasaki and Hiroshima were attacked Nagasaki and hoshima maybe a 40 or 50 kilot 10 weapon Russia has a weapon that is 0.5 kiloton in the in in the olden days if somebody one of the powers United States of Russia wanted to attack an air base it would do so with a weapon that was big now they have weapons that are small that would do the same damage to the air base so that the threshold of dis disaster has gone down it's possible we could see an exchange of nuclear weapons that wouldn't be as disastrous as we had thought about it in the past also it now is that Conventional Weapons can have the same impact the same damage can be exerted on that air base with Precision guided Conventional Weapons as would be with the nuclear weapon so that what happens is this whole notion of the role of nuclear weapons in the future comes unglued at a time when we

have not done that you know as far as United States policy is concerned were you know big shoot as far as the Europeans are concerned it's the big shoot now it may be possible to say Russia if you do this we're certainly going to bomb you bad with Conventional Weapons that changes the whole equation and it should change that we shouldn't fear nuclear weapons the way we did and I Bob Woodward's book is interesting from one respect it seemed that the the chairman and the president both thought of nuclear weapons only in terms of the large sizes that were used in hoshima Nagasaki because they were just terrified that over Korea that we might have some sort of a nuclear exchange uh that doesn't need to be the case anymore we got to think through this whole post Cold War post World War II role that nuclear weapons play in foreign policy and a military policy so if we're going to think that through what is that game look like who would you what roles would you give and what options would you give to help people figure that out well that's what's so interesting is I came to this conclusion by in my class at the

national War college and I when I had the students play the Russians at the end of doing that one of the students said real men don't need nuclear weapons what does that mean that means that that we could do whatever we want to do with Conventional Weapons and so why have this fearful threshold that's before us that has had such an impact on thinking about foreign relations and military power since the end of World War II I mean do you think it's better that people are really afraid of nuclear weapons though because it does kind of make people back off if people are less afraid of them then what no I think that that if you're less afraid of them the need the reason to use them diminish oh so they're like less of a less of a threat less of a blackmail less of a role in in I was I spent a tour at shape you know the head the military headquarters in for NATO and at that time almost any option no the only options we considered play games is if the Russians penetrated the inner German border was for us to

use nuclear weapons and larger nuclear weapons there need to be more options in that that was a dangerous player it still is a dangerous period we need to be able to think about how to stop Russian invasion with Conventional Weapons and not go to the extreme of nuclear weapons interesting so when you use games to do this um you know I mean I feel like the term game is something that we're just casually using uh have you seen like when you tell people oh let's play a war game to figure this out what is the general response to that and how much respect do people have for games as a way of talking about these issues issues and working on them I I'd be careful about even using that term in some audiences we need to think about alternative Futures and examine how we would respond to them rather than use the term war game to talk to somebody you never called a game at all no no depends on the audience sometimes it draws and sometimes it repels that's fair so when you first started doing these simulations say in your classroom um did you call them games from the get-go or was that something that came later no just walk in say okay you're now the Russian general staff here's the situation what would you do so at what point did you

start referring to what you were doing and designing as games I don't know I said probably more now than at the time I again I went that way of teaching because it adults respond respond to it right so say I'm gonna do a game I'm gonna say I'm gonna teach a seminar every week in which adults respond to the way the seminar is conducted and seem to learn and are intrigued and want to learn more about the subject right so this is definitely pedagogi first it's really interesting to talk to you talk to you about this because my first encounters with um professional wargaming are through people who have connections to hobby War gaming so you know I've played vula rink's coin games you know he was at the CIA or you know I have I speak pretty frequently with Sebastian Bay who is at Georgetown and he's running all those war games so for you like how has how have things developed and changed I guess since the start of you discovering that this works pedagogically to now where people pretty much seem to treat it as a normal thing let me react you said uh pedology that pedagogy yeah yeah you know in fact what I would call it Andrei which is

adult the Italian for adult as opposed to child the the difference is that uh I think that between yeah I I haven't really thought much about this but I think that that that the that the the professional stuff doesn't grasp the Strategic implications the way you need to for adults who are interested in policy you you can grasp that uh lots of Blue Chips overwhelm little red chips but the strategy of what's behind that and which is very complex uh you don't get to in a in a professional war game interesting so uh just in your own life do you play games for fun as well or is gaming something that's for classroom only no I didn't play for fun no I played for understanding I mean that's fair I I was I've never I never did games sort of been this Evolution gotcha so you you never like an Avalon hill guy or like interesting so how does it I mean did you encounter people who were and did they understand what she were doing

and have ideas about it not very much no I mean there there seems to be I would assert that there is a population that does that and populations that worry about real policy issues are not one and the same they're two different populations interesting in my perspective they I do think they've done some more com combining but it's very interesting to like hear about it like this all right so um another thing I kind of want to talk about is that you know you you've talked a bit about wargaming sensitive issues and about humanitarian issues uh but I think you also really really see this kind of game as a way to build consensus so uh could you say more about that and give some examples of how you've done that throughout your career I did uh a couple games a different times in Nepal Nepal is a a country that has been dominated by uh Communists for many years it has had King but the king went away and they reverted to dictatorship and the US Embassy in catmandu was having troubles internally because they didn't agree how to react they started with they knew coming up

was going to be the king was going to go and there was going to be an assembly that takes over and so the question is what should US policy be in life of this change and policy towards Nepal is essentially humanitarian Aid you know do we bring food do we do education and what is it we want to do to support us policy in light of what the government is about and there was a terrible disagreement going on within the country team about what to do uh and so these two war games we did by the time we finished they ended up agreeing that the the purpose should be next generational in other words okay people are starving that's bad things are going bad but if US policy is going to have leverage it is in terms of having a generation after this one that can move in the direction ction of more democratic Le more democratic institutions so it was a way of of coming to consensus and it seems it worked I talked to somebody who was more recently in the embassy and that's still their focus they second generational focus of US policy to the

extent that we can do anything it's still limited but I did uh that comes to mind one of the first games I did when uh I retired was I did a strategy game for the Ford motor company and they wanted they were asking the question what happens what should our future strategy be with respect to the building of Auto plants and construction of cars in Asia it was a big movement after Nixon to move well commercial interest in Asia and of the game the conclusion was fairly clear that the players came to saying that if we do this in a few years China will take over and will be selling Goods to us so it is a mistake to try to go there and have them build parch factories it's going to backfire and we will be the subject of that consequence uh and it was culturally so antithetical to the way Ford Motor Company thought you know we go where we can buy parts cheapest that they were unable to come to grips with it it was almost as if it was it was a knowledge that they couldn't handle about the future because

it would require them to change about the present and they were unable to do that you know that's probably true can talk even about Ukraine and the United States policy now you know we probably need to provide more Aid more military aid to Ukraine but that's almost Beyond The Pale there's almost nobody who would stand up and say not it's not a question of keeping what we provide to Ukraine keeping that level but it's a question of increasing the levels not many people sign up to that interesting all right so I want to Circle back around this but one thing that I've noticed as you talk about war game and I think it's important because um you know when you think War you just think conflict kinetic conflict especially in in the Hobby World um but when you talk about a war game you're talking about Aid you're talking about policies about cars you're talking about um you know a lot of things that don't necessarily have to to do with actual fighting so to you like what is the scope of what a war game could include it's a the scope is situation of conflicting interest and objectives and ways to achieve objectives so it didn't could be

anything you we could could war game what's for dinner tomorrow night that could turn into a war depending on the options um so I guess this leads me to ask I mean it seems like the moment to ask right you mentioned in multiple contexts right that you're very interested in consensus building and it seems that the results of your games often lean towards we should Aid other countries in the world so um I guess my thought is what is your hope for what people will hear from this and what do you think the consequences of giving all that Aid of doing all those things will be for the state of the United States and the world now you know I hadn't thought about that but in part of your question is the notion that we have a role not just telling people what to do in the world but helping them understand what ought to be done which is much better and adults don't like to be told how to how to see the world but if you can help them understand how to see the world it would be a major step forward in foreign policy yeah and even within our country you know like we're not in a place I think where our consensus building as a society is very good um um how as somebody who has done a lot

of consensus building would you say that could work on that oh yeah and in fact that people probably forget I know it's not mentioned very often but uh during one of the presidential elections uh high school friend of mine did a series of War games about nuclear weapons that was called the day after and these were apparently essentially to make people fearful of nuclear weap weapons and that we had to be careful uh I don't know that it had much of an impact uh but it's you can see how that would even be possible there no there's no reason why campaign couldn't conduct a series of simulations that examine future policies as opposed to having one person say them and then everybody supposed to get in line yeah it sounds like um this Al you know it speaks to me as a former teacher and obviously you too since this is how you instinctively teach um but you know I think it's even though it seems like an obvious question to us like why is it important that people should get to go their own way towards their conclusions instead of you know being told an answer even if you think that's the answer they're going to arrive at yeah people don't want to be told

adults want to learn adults want to understand and as purveyors of democracy that fits right in doesn't it I mean I would say so yes uh as as a student I would also have really I think enjoyed your class so it sounds like what you did as a teacher is very instinctive right you're looking for what is going to make your students respond and what's going to really teach them something so a lot of teachers do listen to this podcast so if you had advice for somebody who wants to go into their classroom and start doing a version of wargaming um how can they structure it so that if they're not just ready to ask a question like they can get started with something really simple should the United States provide military aid to Ukraine just ask yeah that's it so then what do you just have the students research it and come back and argue about it yes and then what that does two things one of them is it helps them understand the complexity and it also gets them interested in the subject interesting so I guess in another question I have for you is you know you've had kind of a long teaching career um am I correct in assuming that you taught both before and after uh the internet was readily available in classrooms yes yes yes so the other thing that's kind of interesting when

you say that right is you know I feel like information is now available to us at lightning speed but maybe in a less reliable way um uh you know how do you um how have you seen I guess the research that students do in response to these kinds of questions change in its speed and in its depth um before and after the introduction of computer searches I I don't know that I could say anything about how people's research has changed I do know that it's easier to form a group to examine an issue in a gaming like way that it was when the internet didn't exist I mean that that's more the that path is easier which is what I've been doing on Ukraine yeah have you been using Zoom uh no no I just did even more simple than that for example I sent out a an email Friday in which I sort of outlined the issues uh no Zoom interesting okay so um you know not all of us have access to a classroom setting anymore where we have people who are going to push us but I think that what you were asking your students to do is good for everybody to try to do in some kind of in some kind of way so how

do we take some of the lessons that you learned from wargaming and asking questions in your classes and apply them to our own discussions as we try to develop informed opinions and Achieve consensus with other people I I have to say I hadn't really thought about about extending it the way I think you're sort of implying but I could see a sixth grade class doing a Year's worth of wargaming you know where where in fact you don't tell them or gaming because somebody's parents is going to object but you're doing that Andre GOI the adult learning methodology in which you raise the major question that needs to be answered and having them investigate it and then discuss Alternatives of what they've Le interesting all right so then just a couple of like kind of chilled out questions for the end of the interview one um so you're not a hobby gamer so I won't ask you what games you've been playing but I will ask um what have you been reading recently that you thought was really good and that you would recommend oh it's almost embarrassing my day it takes about two hours of looking at the Ukrainian War SC I send out a Blog every day on what's happening in Ukraine and

once I do that my life gets pretty filled up so not too much reading no I just you know there's rest of the day that has to be taken care of fair enough although that actually ISS perfectly into the next question which is if people want to follow your work and they want to get involved and they want to know what you're putting out there um how do they get get in touch with you it sounds like you've got a Blog so how do we how do we get to it just send me an email address and I'll add you to the blog and what's your email where should they send it amguard aol.com samard at AOL.com gotcha all right uh Sam thank you so much for coming on and talking to us about this I feel like it's fun to talk to you as somebody who's really like been part of a lot of highle policy discussions but also as a teacher my pleasure uh all right everybody out there um so you heard Sam if you want to follow his blog send him your email and he'll he'll add you uh and I can be found anywhere online as Beyond Solitaire so find me literally anywhere I'm terminally online so please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming

Progress saved