Méthodologie: The Murder on the Links - Mystery and Intrigue
Transcript
You all committed the murder. Hi, it's Tarrant. And Stella here from Meeple University. Welcome to Methodology. This is newish game it's called Methodology the murder on the links. So, as you can see the art style as well you probably form uh thought about what the game's about. And that is actually true. It's murder or crime investigation. Yes, it's uh it's set in the Poirot Agatha Christie universe. Indeed. Um the game it it says on the front it's a social deduction card game. Um it's sort of a mix between light social deduction and light logic deduction. I think it's more logic deduction than That's Anyways, that's the sauce. We'll see if it's a leader, but we're going to talk about what the game's about first. Yes.
So, in the game each player begins by draw There's There's 18 cards in each of three decks, character, location, and object. And those are visible on these boards. So, this is the character board shows you the 18 characters. Uh and you'll lay out similar ones for the locations and the objects. I'll put it on the side for now. So, it's somewhere there. All right. And then each player begins the game with three cards of each type. So, that is three characters, three locations, and three objects. Yes. Um the way each round works is the the players will uh draw or the players will choose one or more depending on your player count. You choose more at a lower player count of these cards to play face down.
And then for each of the three boards, the locations, the characters, and the objects players will reveal the card that they played in that type. And whoever has the lowest numbered card based on this little flag number makes what's called an accusation. And this um and the card you play is going to end up being discarded. Uh but what you're doing is you're trying to fish out other cards of the same set. So, if I played one of these three here, these are the uh Baraldi case cards. If I'd made an accusation on that basis, anyone who had one of those cards still in hand would have to announce that would have to announce that they did.
And then in turn would have to announce which one they have. You have to tell the truth about having one, but you don't have to tell the truth about which one you have. Because you ultimately want to keep concealed from other players the cards that you still have in hand by the end of the game. Uh the player who made the accusation then get or the player who had played that card originally then gets one chance to tell one person they're lying. Uh if you are caught lying you lose a card, which is bad. If you try to catch someone lying and you fail, then you lose a card. So, those things um uh you've got to take a risk there potentially. And then all the cards of that type that were played come out of the game, so it uh reduces the amount of cards left in the pool.
And you go on to the next round. And this one so I can put it Oh, no, it's still on there. Yep. Uh yes, that one. So, the play continues in this way and at the end of the game you're aiming to whittle down your cards to a hand containing a location, a character, and an object. Cuz you can only score one of each at the end of the game. Um if you've been caught lying or you've failed to catch people lying you may have fewer than this cuz you may have lost some cards. So, you have these and one of the ways you'll score is you want to hang on to high scoring cards. So, cards will give you points and some of them combo if you combine them with specific other cards. It's a bit of a fantasy realms type of thing going on there.
So, that's one way you score points. But you also want to keep your cards concealed because the other way is that everyone gets a chance to at the end of the game to guess what cards you've got. And so, there's all these uh all these tokens here. Um each player has an icon, so I would be the uh footprint player. And I would be trying to guess what everyone else has. So, you know, I might think the handcuffs person is that and the key person is that. And you would go through and you would put these tokens on the board um trying to guess which characters people are. Whichever ca- whichever card has the most guesses for you. So, if I if I were the footprint player and everyone had worked out by deduction that I had an Eloise Renault and had put lots of footprints on there then I would lose that card and I wouldn't get to score it. So, that would come out.
And so, it's a key part of the game is uh making sure people it making sure it's not obvious what cards you have. Once it becomes obvious what card you might have You just discard it. and keep another one. Um but then you also get points for guessing things correctly. So, each of these tokens has your icon on the bottom and if uh if I had guessed correctly that the bowler hat player was Arthur Hastings, then I would get a point for that. So, you add up You can if it's a six-player game you'll have up to 15 guesses cuz there will be five players and three different things to guess for each. Uh so, you'll get a point for each of those. You get a point for the cards remaining in your hand that don't get destroyed by other players knowing what it is.
And the highest score wins. And that's the game. The rules is not that complex, but you kind of have to play it like the a few rounds or something or even the whole game to understand I feel what actually makes the game, what's the strategy, and how does that actually feel and work. Do you agree? Yeah, there's a number of things there that were certainly weren't intuitive um when we taught it to when we first taught it to a group of six and played it. Um it the strategies weren't intuitive. Um it wasn't clear when to when to lie or how obvious to to lie and what the end consequence of that was going to be. Um I found the biggest thing ultimately was was memory. I found you know, it it says it's a social deduction card game, but I found I got a lot more points through memory and through keeping track of what other players must have had left than I did out of trying to deceive people.
And I think yes, you are right there. There's not really very clear at the start until you start playing what the strategy is. You've got one of our friends doing something and kind of like accidentally revealed that he's got he's has all the transport cards or He had all three of these, which um cuz you start with three of those cards, but then having all three of it he couldn't play one of them because he would have had to have accused with it he would it it's kind of the worst draw you could get really because when you play one of those cards it's going to be the uh the max one. It's going to be the one that makes an accusation. You have to ask the question, does anyone else have this? And when everyone's when everyone says no That means then it means they're all in his hand.
Yeah, because it's a four-player game. I don't know how it works with less than Some some items come out, you know. All right, okay. So, I think we got one of the worst situations in that game. Oh, no. I was like He's the only one that has got this type of game when he accuse somebody and obviously he's got the lowest one. That That means he's accusing. Yeah, you're right. And that means that no one else has them. And everyone knows that he's got all three cards. Yeah. So, it becomes more apparent as you play it. And then you play again and then you Oh, yeah, so this is what happened. You shouldn't do that. You should do that. You try to score. It's not just about trying to score the highest point card, but or if somebody like you say earlier, if somebody knows what card you have you're better probably off trying to play that card next round. You can also accuse Oh, that's a lie. And then if you um I did that a few times and it turns out to be true and then I have to discard cards.
So, I ended up with only like two one cards or something like that at the end of the game at that one game. I'm like, oh god. I scored really bad. So, what's your what's your thoughts overall? It is um as I was saying, it's just one that you need to play again and it needs to probably be in the right group as well. It is a little bit of social deduction, but mainly puzzle deduction where and then memory where you need to as you say what what he said. When you need to think what people have. But there's also There's also the other layer is to have it like broken watch. You have the plus four with Hercule Poirot. Is that how you say it? Hercule Poirot. Hercule Poirot. Hercule. The Hercule. Poirot. Poirot. Poirot. Poirot's better.
Poirot. Yeah. You all committed the murder. Tarrant always does that. Yes. Based on a movie. Yes, and book. Does he always say that? No. It was just the answer He never said that. That was just the answer to that uh particular case. Okay. No spoiler. Oops. You were careful not saying what. I was very careful. Sorry. It's somewhere in the cloud. Uh yeah. So, I think it is I don't know. It's a very different game. It's a very different game. It's not not one out there, but that's on the good side. On the flip side, it's that unique that you kind of like trying to work out what is going on, what do you need to do.
As I say, best to I would highly recommend maybe play a like a sample round before you play the game and then know exactly what is going on. Or play the second game straight away. Beside that, it's That's a unique um it would be I don't know. I think it's it's it's actually plays pretty quick. Uh I wouldn't say it's like wow game, but it's also not a bad game as well. So, it's it's okay. Yeah, I'm probably a bit Yeah, I'm a I'm a bit less keen on it. I don't think I'd recommend it. Um it's everything felt kind of a lot of things felt out of my control. You know, there were there wasn't that who likes in control. I didn't feel there was that much room for strategy. I felt that you know, obviously what I wanted to try to do was um keep revealing the same card over and over and then hold one back that no one knew I had.
Because that way no one would guess it in the final round and I would get the points for it. But I had no control over whether that was going to be the case. If someone had happened to investigate if someone else had happened to investigate that type of card, I would have been forced to say I had one and then either lie or reveal it. And I just didn't find that a very interesting uh interesting decision to make. That's fair enough. And then ultimately you know, the information that was released was relatively you know, it was either I say I've got this and and people are being quite conservative and and not lying or they're just I don't know. It was it was a memory game with a little bit of is that person lying or not without any reason to think that they might be lying. So, it was just a straight guess of are you lying or not and how much can I remember for the end?
It's definitely a light lightish game where you just don't probably take things too seriously. It's definitely like far away from Eurogame, for example. Mhm. That's it. Yeah, that's it. I mean, we we played a we played a lot of cards and then have to remember 15 things. It was kind of It's where it was more memory than anything else. Definitely, if you do play, I would recommend uh when we played at six players and everyone was putting down these guest tokens, um it just became chaos and everyone forgot what uh forgot what they'd already put down and all this board. see if this is yours or not. It's It's flip It's not flipped. Yeah. So, take one of each, put them all on this board, then move to that board, then move to that board. Otherwise, you're going to get horribly confused. That's actually true. That is a good tip, Aaron. Yes.
The artwork, though, it is good. It is a really What is that style? Um It grabbed me. It kind of like a Titanic sort of you know, Titanic movie style? A little bit of a noir cartoon sort of thing. It's not fully noir, but and it's got the I don't know. My illustration style is I do like it, though. Yeah. Yep. There you go. So, have you played anything like this? Have you played this one? What do you think? Would you like it something like this? You know, as long as you play it lightly and you know, it's maybe it's your type of game, maybe you're not. It's up to you. And that's it. That's it. Thank you so much for watching, everybody. If you find it is useful somehow and would like to see more review videos from us, if you can please comment below, subscribe, and hit the like button.
I'm also on Instagram. Find me there as well. And hopefully we'll see you next time. Bye. Bye.