Kinghill: Discussion
Transcript
thank you some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and Zach and I are doing a discussion over King Hill uh this was a game that I you know at this point I don't remember why I backed it like it was back when they were back in place for one-on-one exactly and because I like work replacement games we like work replacement and I I really do enjoy 1v1 um when there's a lot of like back and forth head to head out thinking your opponent uh kind of stuff but like skirmish games for me anyway 1v1s are very tricky for me to actually enjoy right um because either it can come off its way to random or stuff like that it's like well you didn't beat me dice beat me or too slow yeah or too fast or there's exactly it's hard to get a good balance um so I had like kind of like freehand trying to end to to play this game and I was like okay you know what there might be some Merit here because this has been sitting on my shelf for quite some time since I got it I know at one point we attempted to play it and like I like pulled it out and I was like yeah I don't think so I don't want to play this but we finally got it done uh and it's it's kind of a mess yeah of of a game I think I mean obviously it was it was cheap to to buy so it's a low price point uh for what you get out of it there are there's a
lot of variety in terms of buildings uh units to buy and the fact that it is a worker placement battler I mean I battled the wrong wrong word but you essentially are trying to defeat your opponent's Castle uh and that sounds interesting but then you realize why isn't that more common right because it's it doesn't work right and it's so again in skirmish games and one especially one-on-ones like you can play games where someone doesn't attack and then someone plays a combo for defense and so you do one point of damage yeah so then you're going back and forth and it takes [ __ ] forever yeah or you do some damage and the other person then heals half that damage and the other person's just blowing out damage but the other person's all built on this healing effect and so where it was like I had all the damage but it would be like okay 80 damage and you're like okay I healed from 85 it's like and so that's where my I love your Realms by the way but in that instance it was like but that's where I find like scrimmers games are so hit or miss for me is I very I mean 1v1 1v1 uh sorry 1v1 games where I feel like it's just at the right pacing we really are out thinking your opponent um
then this one it combined two very interesting work placement with skirmishing in a 1v1 yeah like those three things I've never thought that um uh what's the chart where you put the bubbles and they hit touch and diagrams where those three should ever intersect because I I will say I think there is there's something here because like but it feels like there needed to be like refinement right because he he wanted it to be like I mean maybe he didn't want it to be tactile maybe he wanted to just be kind of just balls to the wall because you can get a [ __ ] ton of spells you can get a [ __ ] ton of resources you can have your army um you have the the force stuff right the randomized events that you can't really do anything about right uh the randomizing I mean because there's more action tiles in there so I mean in terms of replayability they got it here so actually that's probably one of my problems at this point with it is a little too much replayability yeah I think it's kind of it's a little much I mean on this table this table is large but the cards are so different from each other because there are so much variety I don't know what the cards do yeah I mean literally I kind of just kind of glanced like oh does it have this symbol no okay I'm just not going to care I don't even care about anymore yeah and I I mean I look at the inherently a problem with this game that's almost any any
card game there's a market that's like someone's not gonna be able to see [ __ ] right uh we've played multiple games where Brett's just kind of like I forgot all about those because they're over there uh yeah it's kind of one of those games but I mean I like the fact that you can build differently right you you get different builds that that's cool um but I almost would have rather just had I'd rather have one or the other because if one person gets an engine going then normally that's like oh cool he got an engine going that's how he's gonna win through victory points but in this game it's like oh I got my engine going quicker than you did now I'm gonna start just outright dealing damage right um because I got extra workers quicker than you which then allows me to get more resources than you which didn't allows me to go to one of the action tiles pay six of my 80 Stone to just flat out do three damage to you right and uh I mean he's you can snowball that into a bunch of stuff you can do that then you could do uh actions until you take the resources so then right I mean there's a uh there's a high high chance that this let me just double check that this could have been our cards right so it's like I'm gonna take all your resources so I'm just gonna do one attack and you have no stone left so you're gonna take six damage at the end and it's like okay right like all right let's just pack it up and that was the thing like because I went whole all spells and
over half mine were destroyed two of your resources yeah but I was like I can do that but these other effects are probably slightly more to my you know advantage and what I'm actually trying to accomplish that is like I don't know the destroying your resources was going to be the best use of my right especially when I can just go explore and kind of generate them all back and I had spells too in terms of like but I I honestly I saw one and it was like I would deal three damage to you and it's yada right or plus two Castle endurance and I was like that's just annoying right that's just cheap to do so I'll put another complaint I do not like the fact that um your cards are already split with a cost but the inside of that cost is another split yeah four options on every single card it's two main options that's not the point of cards I like two options yeah and I like one that is better for more expense yeah so now I have a choice and I always know I have one that's cheaper and one that's not because otherwise realistically what you gave me so every time I draw a card I have always two cards in my hand yeah basically with one choice uh and again it just feels like it needs to be rained in yeah like more is not always best right uh because at first I was like I was thinking okay this could it's gonna be a game that like accelerates really quickly because you started out with two workers and then you can easily get more you diver I like the fact that you diversify them yep very simple to go and just get it oh I want to go this route I
want to get a sound and um and that the mining locations thematically makes sense you don't go there they produce more resources so right you go and it's like oh man there's like five extra Stone there I'm just gonna go and get eight stone right uh but then there comes kind of a point where it does kind of come to a halt eventually you're gonna you know you have to attack your opponent right which is why I did yeah it was like if it wasn't gonna be you it was like whenever it was gonna be you yeah you took the damage from the earthquake and then I would admit I took that damage it was gay mom yeah I was like oh because you started with less than I did right by one but I was like okay I get an extra attack I'm gonna go get more soldiers because there was one the enforcer I was gonna pick up she gives you an extra strength for a soldier yeah that you control I was gonna get her do the same catapult thing um or not catapult do the whatever that is yeah just flat three damage and then I was gonna attack yeah and I knew that but um it was like it wasn't and that's part of my problem is like we do this build that we do this build so it's turn six right so there's nine turns in the game nothing happens combat wise turn six and it's done yeah which some people might like I almost would have preferred if there was actually like a hard set attack face uh if not like every round like every I mean there's nine rounds at the end of ever at the end of the third Sixth and Ninth round there's one there's a battle so you actually you don't have to worry
about like are they uh like like you can actually build up an army right especially in this fantasy kind of setting it's not like a surprise Army just shows up right like you'd be like oh I [ __ ] see them they're about to Siege my castle all right like I can you can plan but without in a 1v1 game that's supposed to be head to head like hmm what is he gonna do okay I know like if you were able to be like I know the battle's coming up it's about to be the end of the third phase right I need more I need more you know buildings or I need more units and also things like okay don't just have spells that heal your Castle have somewhere out here so if you're not going for spells like you're not building Mages to go collect spells I can send a builder or the miner yeah in his you know the plus ability is increase your Castle Health by one yeah now you have encouraged someone saying I don't want Mages I don't want to touch magic yeah I want to do this whole other cool thing and but I still can start slowly healing maybe it's not but again you're not using magic that often it's not that many ways of getting it yeah here's one spot that can just slowly yeah it somewhat but imagine if we're going into round nine and I've hoarded a bunch of gems and spell cards and it's like okay well you're not gonna be able to attack me uh it's my turn I'm gonna play these spells and heal all the way back up right it's like oh okay right wow I'm glad we
wasted an hour like just for you this sandbag right like healing yeah I really don't enjoy stuff like that if you're gonna I mean the fact that they actually don't have a Healer unit uh that I mean that would have been much better like you said have a location that you can send a Healer to maybe heal your units right uh maybe heal your castle wall or I mean I'm sure it's in here but or a specific building right uh I mean I do like so living wall right there basically I think it adds your Castle's overall health oh yeah yeah and regenerates once per turn yep okay that's cool so as long as I can keep my defense High you have to really start hammering to get that thing going yeah yeah and I mean there are two different decks of buildings that the beginner cards do get cycled out at the end of the fifth round uh I mean honestly the best part about this game I think is the work replacement stuff oh yeah but that's because it's work Replacements and work replacement is the best anyway yeah it's the best mechanic out there hmm I don't know about that to me worker place was probably my favorite mechanic out there I certainly love like yeah probably I mean it's it's so much but they're usually hand in hand work replacement just kind of goes with everything right so I mean you have the
worker only the engine building where it's like that car base where you keep building up because I was thinking like I was like oh everdale because I love Tableau that is also work replacement yeah yep so yeah so like I said there there's something here like if someone were to tell me they like this game I wouldn't be shocked no uh I just think that the actual castle attack portion is it just doesn't really fit yeah uh especially when it can come down to you have you got certain cards not real I mean it is kind of a card game so I can't really put in too much stock but it's like oh like imagine if I got the living wall on top of my innate defense and then I had and it's like okay well you actually can't beat me right and then like you just flood with spells like spells like plague okay I'm just gonna start dealing three damage to your units like you can't stop right and then I'm gonna go with my assassin because my other plan was to get this house of the dagger which let's which upgrades that so it's like now if they have two Health left I can send my assassin there right to just start killing your units it's like okay you can't attack me and now you're never gonna have units because the Spells are just gonna chip damage them right and then they're gone right so I think what it kind of comes down to is we don't really seem to like the Spells I think the Spells kind of are my biggest complaint because they they add in a sandbag of healing right which is
dumb uh there's no counter spells I don't really like 1v1 like I do that's why I don't like key Forge key for just I do everything and watch you undo everything that I just did and we're going to repeat until somebody kill ourselves because we don't want to play anymore um I don't necessarily mind these nope um because two of them are gonna come out right and it's an even split of bad and good um right because we have one that was great yeah and one that and the early one was kind of bad but again because 1v1 there's so many spots that you can go mitigate that you'll really just yeah I mean now if this came out there's a little bit of difference if like you could breathe really fast like we build here right uh but and and then the the force tiles that come out are actually player dependent right we chose to mess with Force energy which will potentially bring some out because every time they're drawn right like they're face down but then if it's filled up then it gets revealed right I actually don't mind that yeah I don't mind the unique action tiles no you're not knowing what's coming out yeah yeah it's like oh that's because they're all pretty good yeah so it come for me I don't like the spell cards and I don't I'd much rather in the 1v1 work replacement game there'd be an attack phase I agree I mean so the spell cards I think just need to be reworked on their
own um I think they're a mixture of just too powerful but at the same like if you don't go Mages you're not going to get spells cards but if somebody does go heavily into Mages which again it's not bad to go into Mages um because again like that we saw at least two sacred pools so you can just start being magic crystals all right out your butt yeah and then it's not that big of a deal anymore and this is gonna be kind of weird so I don't I also don't think that the units are all created equal yeah in terms of how much they cost right like of course units need to be more powerful than other units like xanar the mighty is a six six but that's five golden three magic to hire that's nothing right in this game in one action potentially with my explore I drew four cards and it's like one two three oh look there's the five gold immediately in the Mage after turn two is three magic so you can get him and now he costs the magic to attack but it's only one magic so that's what I thought with this guy because that's where so it's five magic and two force that you paid but basically if you can get him because I think I had him on this turn I think so yeah because I got two more he pumps out any of level one or one Health Creature from the discard yes pop out now their abilities that as they pop come out but like this one was a three one and I could again pay magic to resurrect him every time exactly I've
been literally playing a magic game yeah that's the perfect creature for me yeah yeah and that's why it's like again there seems to be too much put in because in this game The Defender basically just has to sit here that's what you just [ __ ] your pants be like and maybe that's what throws me because like I didn't even hit your Griffin because it didn't make sense for me to attack your Griffin yeah yeah but you as the defender why can't you use it to defend it again what it should what it should be is kind of like magic the Gathering if you're having stuff like that where you that's that's like a magic combo right right there where you have a unit a really powerful unit that prevents right you know mobs or from dying cool in this game there shouldn't be two phases because there's a weird cast or no the castle phase makes sense right it's the it's the additional unit phase that's kind of dumb what it should be is you're you're attacking me right I choose who to defend right because like in Magic I'm attacking you right you use your people to block you and then what would make sense is instead of even doing the cast phase so whatever damage I do on top or that goes through you know you can never damage my castle on my attack yeah but any damage that goes through to yours you taking a castle thing oh like trampled right well so basically yeah whatever's left over because again if you don't kill my guys then that's when yeah they got through my units to attack my castle Yeah you have to make a choice then do I sacrifice everything for defense right now or do I take some Castle damage and
try to live for another day to do the attack against him next time yeah because my wild Griffin it's like he has a regenerate too so it's like right okay like like it I could be like oh okay you're attacking with a three or I'm gonna use him to defend your whatever that's called right because it's gonna hit him for four at the end of The Run he's gonna heal two right but there's none of that yeah I just go okay because again attack your girlfriend unless I want you to just kill it outright yeah it's like all right you dealt you know five damage to my castle oh time to also add insult to injury and kill all my units right it's like cool cool I'm glad they existed right um and that was my thing that was what that's what throws me a little bit with this game yeah it's I I do think that this game like could warrant a second edition or a second reprint like fine tune it fix your damn rule book because that is atrocious um like basically like it's legible like you can read through it and then but then if anyone has any questions you don't know right like it's just like I don't know is there a handle everything spells I don't know right so what's uh like so if I go if I use the Ability like to do that can I do this I don't know like because it's just not in here this is an all over the place rule book um that is just because it's Kickstarter and people don't ever want to actually
put in the time we ever paid people who write I call it more technical documents for your rules and that's where I think board games needs to go back to so Kickstarter has lots of great things about it one of the things Kickstarter needs to now as a community we need to push past this okay you can Kickstart everything that you like hire someone whose job is to exclusively review and write Rule books yeah well a lot of companies do Paul Grogan retire direct rule books I'm sure there are others I just know there are others but I mean innately that is a blessing and a curse of board gaming is that if they don't then your game is unplayable right therefore no one is buying your game or playing your game so and I mean the board game Community is generally extremely positive but there are a lot of people who throw a fit about Kickstarter stuff so it's like word spreads like if he comes out for another game or a second edition I'm guaranteed people are going to be like is there how are you working on that rule book uh but I I think honestly there is something here it's like keep like a work replacement stuff is fine get rid of some stuff fine-tune other stuff the battle which is what you towed it as a 1v1 game make the battle actually back and forth interactive some decisions so one person who attacks first isn't gonna basically win the game right
um and and you're you're kind of onto something this this game I mean I'd say it's Innovative I don't know a single work replacement 1v1 battle game than this one no uh so because I even like the Caravans that come in just extra hell hey yeah what do we go offering me um so so yeah I mean that's pretty much what I got for uh for King Hill I don't think they're Heroes were much of anything yeah I mean mine did one time thing yeah I mean I even got them upgraded and didn't even [ __ ] matter yeah it's like oh cool there's also one in here that would that would have been really upset because there's time of Heroes your hero abilities are upgraded I've been really annoyed if I got the ancestral tomb and then that pops out right like oh all right time to replace it right uh yeah you got you got anything anything else no all right on a scale of one to ten what would you give King Hill six that's where I'm at two yeah I think it is slightly it's slightly above slightly above average it's Innovative to us I mean again like we said I don't really want to play it again um but I would if if they went on Kickstarter again with the second edition I would check it out like I
would I would be like hmm did he take feedback yeah like it to see if there were any changes because like I said this game is there's something here it's just it it reeks of Kickstarter it reached a first time designer trying something because in terms of art not bad I actually really like the board yeah there is some weird stuff on the board uh in terms of I mean they actually put text he didn't try to make it language independent right you know which sometimes can be really funky but there's some weird stuff like on the on the actual print it shows the icon of where you get an extra peasant but because you cover it up right you'll never see it you'll never see it so um these things I guess just show where the units go one other thing that is kind of odd and I don't really like it I don't like the two cards get cycled in a row of five basically for a lot of cards that could be detrimental to a build it's like you have one turn to do it and because you start with so little workers it's like well I'm never getting that yeah because it already takes a worker to build this building and so round one you're just you're never buying building something yeah I think oh I hired someone because I went there and then happened to get an Explorer right uh but but yeah I would I would get rid of the two it either increased the market to six cards or keep it at five and just have the the last card which you could theoretically just house rule right um so yeah there's there's some stuff here
Peter Merrick uh just we can go do a second edition fine tune the hell out of this game uh and you might have a really unique Innovative game that could spark something like lost ruins of our neck or Doom Imperium with work replacement deck building right there's no I'm not saying a work replacement 1v1 game can't work nope uh it theoretically makes sense you use workers to build up your Castle to find another per like another Army yeah got it make the combat more like magic the Gathering uh which to me is the best kind of 1v1 card game right that's why it's been around for a while for 30 years 93 only in 30 years interesting only it feels like in terms of in terms of those games though like that yeah it's I I'm I'm amazed because it came out 93 which is when I was born got it so yeah six out of tens from us uh that's our thoughts on King Hills let us know some of you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you