Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 196: Erin Escobedo on Meltwater

Transcript 1:00:25

It's ad break time. I'm proud to announce that the Beyond Solitire podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University Center for Learning through Games and Simulations. They just successfully funded their most recent game, Greg Luring Albbright's Keep the Faith, which is a light RPG about the growth of a religion. If you missed the campaign, do keep an eye out for a chance to late pledge in the coming weeks. Also, if you'd like to support Beyond Solitire, please head to patreon.com/beyondsolitire to help me keep the lights on. For now, though, enjoy the show. Hey gamers, this is Liz Davis from Beyond Solitire. And this week on the pod, I'm very, very happy to have special guest Aaron Esco. Uh she is the designer of Meltwater, which you may recognize as a previous Holland spiel production, but it is now coming out again uh through Capstone, and I'm very excited about it. Uh, so how you doing today, Erin? Oh, I'm doing about as you know, I'm doing about as well as a a transw woman in America can be right now. You know, like it's it's a bit of a like holding two thoughts in your head at once. Oh, my life's going well. I'm doing well. Oh god, the news.

You know, I'm having that exact same experience. I feel like, you know, I love my job. I took my dream job. I design games all day. And then I turn on the news or like look at social media and I'm like, "Oh [ __ ] It's Yeah. Yes. Yeah. Agreed. Confirmed. But let's not talk about that. Let's talk about the end of the world. Yeah. You know what? I like it. Um, also, you know, creation is resistance, right? We're here. But yes, for people who don't know anything about Meltwater, who might be listening to this episode, what is like a little brief primer on the game? So, Meltwater, uh, previously titled Meltwater: A Game of Tactical Starvation, uh, is a game for two players, uh, in which the setup is that it's the Cold War and the Cold War has gone hot. The nukes have launched and most of the world is uninhabitable. Uh the only patch of habitable land uh left is Antarctica, but of course nationalism survives down here too with the remnants of the US and the Soviets. And this war may consume us all. So, you know, cheery stuff. Uh I like to describe Meltwater as um I spent a couple years screaming into a paper bag until my lips bled and now I'm handing it to you.

Uh yeah, it is uh it is a lot of feelings that I have condensed down into the smallest package I could fit it into and put it in front of people so that maybe I could stop having nightmares. It hasn't stopped, but it was a good try. Uh but we could share them now, you know. Um yeah. No, at least I can make other people look at it. I just I think a lot about the uh are you familiar with the uh game designer David Furer? Uh old video game designer created Missile Command uh back in the 80s 1980 uh was also the creator of Tempest. Uh that one with like the cool vectors you go around 3D Space Invaders. But the one he's best known for is probably Missile Command. The one in which missiles are constantly raining from the sky and you're using a couple of missile imp placements, just little clusters of pixels to blow missiles out of the sky before they land and destroy six towns on the board. Uh he was often described that while working on this he suffered nightmares where he'd be up in the hills of San Francisco looking out over some of the cities along the coastline uh San Fran, San Louis Abyispo, others and w and know that he had about 45 minutes before the blast reached where he was standing and he'd have these nightmares every night.

And uh in that way uh meltwater is my version of that. It is my terror at large systems of national ideology of nationalism that seem to somehow override the logic of species, of survival, of kindness, of charity, of all of the good things we purport to have. And yet somehow if you designate like half of them red, half of them blue, issues of specieswide survival seem to just get put aside over and over again.

And I didn't start this game meaning to stumble on that. Like I originally made this game like because I was watching some videos of John Conway's Game of Life while depressed, watching the cool little patterns and was like, "Huh, I could do one of those." So I set out a little grid. I drew, you know, on some paper and I made this little system of pieces growing and dying. And then I started paying attention to the news. This was around uh 2016. And yeah, I was actually I actually I want to press I was going to ask you because it sounded like from your designer diaries and the previous discussions of Meltwater that it's sort of like a serendipitous event in your life that you just you got a prototype, you know, putting it in Antarctica was kind of a joke because the mapboard was white. You've just been watching a lot of like you've been playing a lot of Fallout. Yeah, I've been playing some Fallout back in the day. Uh I was, you know, and the board was white so little Antarctica. Although the more I started to think about it, the more it started to come together.

And as I started to focus more down on this model of like pushing someone to the edge and starving, well, I start looking into stuff uh just world events. This is around the same time that, you know, I start getting more politically aware. I can't remember how long this was after the Mike Brown shootings and the uh resultant protests, but watching the use of force against my own countrymen certainly changed a lot of how I suddenly saw the world and the way it structured around me and the ways in which people can be otherred and made and made so that their survival is a non-issue. And the more I thought about this, the more horrified I became and the worse the nightmares got, the worse the depression got. And uh and then I squeezed it all into some cardboard and monetized it.

Is that what we're supposed to do with our hobbies now? Okay. Oh, no. No. That's that's the thing. You find a good deep well of personal or uh local or worldwide trauma and you monetize that [ __ ] You squeeze that for every last dollar you can bring out of its blood. I'm kidding. But that that's sometimes what it does feel like when making things that scrape something a little closer to the bone than you meant it. That Yeah. So Meltwater has been around for a while now. So, the last interview I saw about this was with Danthro in 2020. Do you feel that the game is as emotionally raw for you now as it was when you made it? And like what has reemerged in the process of getting it prepared for publication through another publishing house? So, uh I've been less involved in this one than I wanted to, so it's less personal.

Uh when we started this, I spoke with my uh developer at Capstone, Christopher High, and uh we set out the plan. And then um personal events happened. Uh my mother's breast cancer uh reemerged and uh became terminal. And so, uh there's been a lot of uh emotional dealings with that. And then my stepfather and my grandmother both passed, leaving her alone. We moved her in with us. So, it's been a rough few years. So, I decided that, you know, I'm happy with this game. Here are some changes I would like to propose. Here are some thoughts I've had about the game in the intervening years uh since, you know, when we had this meeting uh time. It's fake. Uh but we had this meeting. I gave him this outline and then kind of returned to deal with family stuff. Come back, put some input.

And so, there are parts of this game that are now very much Chris's. And cool. Uh this is a collaborative art form. I come from collaborative art forms. I studied theater. I worked in uh fe uh film and media fia. Great. Uh I worked in film and media for a while. So I'm very used to this idea of I there is no central artist. The artist takes part and then someone else takes part and it you get a greater hole out of it. But so this is a little less raw, but it still feels every time I look at it, it's like, oh, this this this still feels like I wouldn't say an accurate model, but an evocative model of multiple forces. Because while Meltwater is textually about uh nuclear apocalypse, I I didn't name it Meltwater uh in complete ignorance uh of say climate catastrophe. And in the intervening time, we've had other major disasters that uh put into question our relationships with our own governments and the ideas of our own nations and watching greater and greater disasters spiral out of control because it would require doing something that isn't self- serving first on a nationalist scale. And that just never seems to happen. It never seems to be important enough.

Yeah. And that still feels resonant. It still feels resonant that when I originally talked about the game in 2018 when I wrote those original essays for Holland Spiel, which by the way, please don't go back and read those. I feel a little embarrassed about them. They are I enjoyed them. They are from a time when I was trying to be a little more professional in my writing style and speaking style. And these days, I tend to be uh a little more direct in the ways I talk. It kind of to me reads like I was trying to write a high school essay again, but the the thoughts I had in there are still relevant. And I don't know, the uh when I touched on the fact that world hunger is still out there and still just as solvable a problem.

When I notice that our government is hoarding things like vaccine patents to get some sort of vague advantage. When I see all of these things, I just I am in shock at the larger systems moving above my head that control our lives and get to deem who is and who isn't a human who matters. Yeah, that didn't stop. No, it actually does pain me to think that perhaps Meltwater is more relevant now than when it was made. Yeah, maybe. But this is the world we live in in which great hyper objects and hypers systems uh that are so grandiose in their scale of global control like you know systems like capitalism, systems like nationalism, systems like poverty and conflict and I don't know patriarchy, cisexism, uh white supremacy, all of these things that are so big and No one person is controlling them and no one person is making them these decisions for them.

But somehow they persist. Somehow they act as if they have their own agency which is not aligned with human survival. Yes. And so here's a little toy where you can watch that in paper. So speaking of toys, you know, it's funny like you you've clearly got the knack for what I might want to ask you next. So you know you decided to express your feelings about all this through a game. Um, Meltwater is your only published game, but do you find that like making games is a way that you like to express yourself or like model things that you're feeling? And why games as opposed to another another art form? I feel like that's a very good question and I ask myself this sometimes because uh like with Mabel I have a lot of hope for the future and potential of game design as an expressive and illustrative medium. Uh especially tabletop design where you get to play with the bones of thing. Like we all understand that a game like a video game can connect to you emotionally, but it's connecting you with you in like things like cinematic language as often as it is mechanical context, whereas board games are just here is your mechanics, here is your mechanics and some words that we call them. And I don't know, it's it Mabel knows what she's doing when she's making her systems. She has an angle. She's a creator of pyic arguments

through her games of saying, "Here is my position. Here is why these systems work the way they do." Cole, another designer I admire greatly, is a historian. He is very detailed in his research and his applications. I'm not really either of those. I'm a horror writer at the end of the day. I'm just putting down something I find unquing, something that I can't dig out of my brain with a screwdriver if I tried and sharing that. And board games are the methodology I know. They're the methodology I have some familiarity with the language of. It's less that I chose board games because they are the best medium for expressing what I wanted to. Though I do think they are and that it is a great medium for something I wanted to express like Meltwater. But it's more like France Kofka's The Hunger Artist.

Why did you choose to starve yourself? Never found any food I liked. It's less that I chose board games for this as I didn't really know what else to do with it. It felt like the thing to do. See, the secret is I'm not actually that smart. Mabel's a genius. Mabel I is incredible and she talks me up. And who boy, I have a couple good thoughts like once every few years. That's still more thoughts that are good than a lot of people ever have. So, I wouldn't sell myself short. Um, but I think it's very interesting that you describe yourself as a horror writer because I do think that Meltwater is interesting in that it I guess involves players in horrific acts. I mean, it is a game of tactical starvation. But the other thing that's sort of an interesting catch from Rottwater, I think that's ahead of its time is this premise that well, y'all could just stop. Ah, yeah. the uh the forfeit condition which you know it is in there at the model is such that the radiation is only spreading is only continuing to spread because no one is taking steps to stop it catastro like the the radiation spreads as the game continues. It says in the rule book you stop the game you're everyone alive can try and stop the radiation but but what does that mean for you?

You didn't win. Aren't you supposed to want to win? Have you How many play tests of this game have you watched over the course of time? And like do people ever take that option? People take people take the concession option a lot and like Okay, I I want to drop the curtain here a little. Sure. I think it's a great I think it's a great part of the message. I was really again I kind of stumbled across it because I was looking for ways as Danthro noted in his original glowing review of Meltwater which I'm still humbled by. Uh he talks about the the fact that you know a someone more designerly I guess you would say would have put in a track to like oh once there's this imbalance or once there's this population difference the game is over. But like that's not how the logic goes.

That's that's not how the state sees. That's not how the game is played. Yeah. I don't want to get overly obsessed with present politics, but I do hear some of this too in the echoes of like, oh, let's own the libs. Haha. I want to hear, you know, the other side has to be upset and crying for me to feel happy. It's not enough to win. It's you have to make the other person lose. It's not enough to It's not enough to survive. You must overcome. And it's I feel like this is a narrative baked into our culture and a lot of cultures, but definitely ours that you have to position yourself hierarchically one over the other. I must predominate. you know, my ideology must predominate. My way of thinking, my way of asserting myself must predominate. And it's this never back down, never surrender mentality that was evoked by figures during the Cold War, such as uh Thomas Harsfield Power, who infamously said the line that kicked the whole game off. You know, why would you want to save Russian lives? The whole point is to kill the bastards. If there's two Americans and one Russian left at the end of the war, we win. That's an insane thing to say, but they gave missiles to the guy who says that genius. I don't know what I'm doing here.

Oh god. So, and but getting back to the point. So, behind the curtain, part of it is just that I didn't want to include a condition for someone OP for like to end the game when someone is getting wailed on. So, I just said I I used to play a lot of Magic back in the I used to play a lot of Warhammer and a certain point you concede because like yeah, you could play this out if you want to sit there for like the next 10 minutes on a foregone conclusion, but so I'm used to games where concession is a thing. I also play a lot of chess. I play a lot of two-player games where like, yeah, okay, this one's written. Let's let's let's wipe it and go to the next one. And so that was just a very natural thing to reach for me to go, why don't I just tell players it's okay to give up if you don't want to keep playing? Why do I have to hold their hand? I feel like a A lot of game design is not a lot, but there is a theory of game design that says you that sort of treats it as if you need to put guard rails around the player. Like you must guide the player to the optimal experience of the thing.

And I feel like it's it's a very it's a model that is primarily built on removing negative play experience, which is a very commodity focused thing. It's uh your first bite must be painless and smooth and easy like biting into a Twinkie. And it's like no, I'm okay with my players [ __ ] up and finding out to be a little crude. I I am okay with someone trying something and getting completely washed and then being giving them the nudge to say you don't actually have to make yourself miserable and play this out. But also, as Dan Thorough points out, you have to be the one to pull that trigger. You have to be the one to say I quit. And who boy people do not like saying I quit. There is there is an impulse to just not just say no I can win this and and as you try to win this the world burns. Yeah. No, our culture hates quitting. Actually, I think my toxic trait is that whenever I play like a one less heist game, I'm convinced that in real life I would know when enough was enough and that I would know when to stop. But I don't actually know if that's true.

Like, yeah, nobody in our society fully knows when to quit while they're ahead, right? No, we have to keep making the number go up. Don't you understand that if Elon doesn't get another 100,000 million that he'll break down and cry like a little baby? Do you want that? Do you want Elon to cry like a little baby? Do you want him to Do you want him to fall over sobbing on his shirt and throwing up and puking and pooping his diaper? Do you want that? Is that a thing you would like to be thinking about right now? I mean, kind of. Yeah. But I'd rather he's he's friends with the president. So, yes. But so leading kind of leading from this, you know, I'm I'm first I just I'm curious for people who are interested in Meltwater and they've played the previous version, what are some things that are different?

Um, and then it seems like it's I mean, has the game changed significantly or is it just kind of in smaller smaller increments? I would say it's the core of the game is still very intact. Uh so there are two basic camps of the changes. So I'm going to put them into like the minor changes and the major changes. It's mostly minor changes. The minor changes are mostly things like uh the move and transport actions from the old game have been collapsed into one. Uh it was it was annoyingly fiddly. Uh stockpiles no longer care if you're friendly to them in order to get the food. just if you're close enough to be a hex away from a stockpile, you're close enough to steal from it. It takes off a lot of those little like bookkeeping tracking things. Uh there's a change to instead of skipping starvation on the first turn, you skip the first doomsday card. Just little things that make the game tick along a little easier. There are two major changes. The first major change is a change to the setup. Uh the old game had these three different styles of setups where you kind of went back and forth and built your own board. I found like almost no one I talked to actually played that. they'd always just go with the pre-built setup. So, now there's two pre-built setups. Uh, one is the summer scenario. Uh, the idea being if the missiles launch in the summer while Antarctica is fully staffed by researchers, cool play out the normal game as you kind of recognize it from Holland with a couple little tweaks for balance. Uh, there's also a winter scenario where each player starts with way fewer pieces on the board and a lot more. And because most of the research stations on Antarctica are seasonally

staffed, only skeleton crews are kept aboard through the winter. So if the missiles launched, then it's much more a game of going out, grabbing refugees, trying to build the force before you take it to the enemy's doorstep, whereas the summer scenario is much more of an okay, let's dance. Uh the other major change, and this is one that uh was very much Christopher High's suggestion after many play tests, which thank you very much, Chris, for all of that work you put into the game. I really do feel like this is a collaborative effort now, and all that work, this game would not be the same without him. He's done some changes to the radiation model and to make it a little clearer and a little easier to resolve both the radiation distribution and the like starving phase making it easier to be like okay there's a dirty hex because we kept running into problems where like people would you know skip over like miss that oh this hex has a minus one and that guy should have died and while in the hollen spiel version I was very okay with that I kind of wanted people to have to look and see and perceive like this invisible projection of radiation the same way like you have to be able to see the invisible lines of capture in chess in order to not make a blunder. I was very okay with players making that blunder, but the capstone version it's much easier. The rad the the old dirty chits that used to the little minus one chits that came with the uh hollen bill edition now those are sort of we have these this new system of radiation. It's a little hard to explain without having the rule book in front of me, but the changes are a little more dynamic, a

little more expressive, and also a little cleaner on the board. Uh, so those are the major ones. I was originally going to try and do a little bit of rebalancing in the card distribution to try and match Antarctica's actual occurrence, but then life intervened, so it's the same. It's the same old deck of cards. That's really interesting. So, just a random theming question in your mind because this is about the United States and Russia on Antarctica after destroying everybody else. Uh, like what's happening in the rest of the world outside of Antarctica? Ashes. Everything's gone. Death, loss, and shadows on the wall. Are you familiar with uh Neil Shrew's book On the Beach? uh 1954 novel made into a movie afterwards about people on Antarctica waiting in the months the last few months before the radiation from a war between uh Europe and America reaches them and ends all human life.

That sounds like a great slash awful read. So I should definitely look into that. Really interesting uh very interesting delivery style uh really evocative. also written in the 1930 194 1940s50s by a male author. So, you know, you know, I guess, uh, like not horrible, just, you know, casual mis, you know, casual, oh, who aren't you a pretty little thing misogyny in places, but still great read otherwise. Yeah. I mean, yeah, you know, old sci-fi writers, if you if you've read Azimov, you know, uh but uh do they deserve rights? Uh leave a question down in the down in the YouTube and boost this video's algorithm or whatever it is we do here. Uh so this also leads me to um some other questions. So thinking about just like the sort of destruction, this idea that people can kind of stop whenever they want, but they never do.

Wanting to lower guard rails on games. Um, you know, I'm not I'm not the best game historian ever, but it seems to me just from my own entry into the hobby that Meltwater is a little bit ahead of its time and that, you know, I feel like now we're having lots of discussions about do games really need victory conditions or um like Zoe Ared's work is so interesting because it makes games about um you know, you could cooperate or maybe not and like what choices are you going to make? I I still need to play Veloci Rapture. That is on my list to play. Uh, one of the other problems is that the I used to have a much more regular board game group back when I first made Meltwater and the pandemic sort of killed that and it never quite recovered. But still need to get that one to the table at some point because that one's really fascinating. The most just party at the end of the world, nothing you do will matter except in the ways you decide it matters games.

Although my favorite of that is definitely uh either well two of Mabel's obviously either endurance or but then she came back both excellent games about what do you mean victory? Yeah. What does victory mean to you? And you know this is straying into sort of that RPG space a little bit. You know that you know very feely sort of games. But I am interested in sort of that overlap, the place where these nice cold systems can touch you in the same ways that something like a storytelling game or an RPG can. This is sort of the space I'm really interested in. The space where the space where you're playing with knives and you can kind of get cut. Yeah. I was actually going to ask about I guess what do you see your game preferences as kind of like in the vein of art games since you mentioned Brenda Romero as an early inspiration for Meltwater as well. Brenda Romero was an early inspiration although I I do think you know there's a lot of criticism of train that is very valid. Uh but Meltwater is very inspired by instead I'm going to say this wrong because I cannot speak Gaelic. Uh Shoken Le uh or Shoken Le or something like that. Uh peace be with you in Irish uh was another one of her games that was deeply inspiring on me and I've never played it. I've never gotten to play it. It was specifically designed so only people of Irish descent can play it. I am like distantly Irish but I've never been at like one of these events. So the rule book is not widely available. I had never played it, but I wa I saw the pieces and the message they told and

that like hit me. The fact that I could just look at this board from 20 feet, see a picture and see like two, three pictures of the play and know exactly what was happening and why it made my heart sink through my guts. So, that's what I wanted out of Meltwater. I wanted players to have that. The thing I think I'm happiest about with Meltwater is if you go to the BGG uh images gallery for it, the game sort of just tells you about itself. You see what the game is about in photos, just this pitiful little movement in a sea of oncoming end when you are playing board games. So, it's you sounds like I totally didn't answer the question though.

designers. Uh, I'm super comes down when it comes down to it, like Cole and Mabel. Cole and Mabel are my favorites. I will sing their praises up and down, especially Mabel. But, you know, I'm very biased. Mabel is like a sister to me. Like, I think she's the the most brilliant person working in game design today. And then there's Cole. Like, you you've seen what Cole makes, right? Like Jesus, my guy, do you sleep? No, he I don't think he does actually. Like I I cannot imagine making games that detailed, that intricate that fast all the time. Like Like I have I have fighting games to play. Like I have hobbies. I have a house to clean. I have a wife to take care of.

Like he must sleep at his desk. All love to you, Cole, man. You're incredible. But anyways, uh, but yeah, those are the RD designers that immediately come to mind. I haven't really been as like hand on the space as I used to be. So, if there's new ones that have come up since that like I really should know about, like, well, damn, I should really know about them, shouldn't I? Well, I also wanted to know, so it sounds to me too, though, like, okay, so we we like RD board games. I'm with you on this, but you also talk a lot about video games. like within this conversation, you mentioned a couple of video games. You were like Fallout at the time you did this. And I did want to ask you about fighting games at this point. You just mentioned them. So what um to what extent are you interested in video games and board games interconnected or do you see them as kind of separate

spheres? It's one of those things where it's they're different mediums. They are they both have similar principles and they both have like video games sort of it depends like I feel like trying to define what video games are is so much more nebulous right now that has had much larger an explosion of possibility space than board games has. So I think there are board that there are video games that are very close on the vin diagram to what board games are doing. things like, you know, things like XCOM or this War of Mine or uh or even just digital implementations of board games like Root Digital, which is excellent.

Uh but then there's the other side which is completely disinterested in the ways board games tell stories with these mechanical tensions of push and pull and victory and loss that are still beautiful and gorgeous. I'm a huge fan of the visual novel genre myself. My favorites being uh the work of Worst Girls Games. Uh AVB Max Schwarz uh created We Know the Devil and Heaven Will Be Mine. If you haven't played them, why are you spending money on my games? Go buy those on Steam and play them. Uh excellent, beautiful stories about being trans and queer in fantastical, magical, realist settings that just changed me as a person. And I wish I could capture something like that in the mechanical language I know how to speak in. But it's very much a creature of a different language. So video games is a spectrum as is anything we try to categorize. You know, uh borders, gender concept, many concepts are entirely fluid. And trying to say, well, are these two the same things?

Like I don't know if they're close to each other on that giant spectrum of concepts. Yeah. But uh for me though, the ones that feel the most like that gaming game sort of thing or I'm a huge fighting game fan. I I just like them. They are a beautiful little weird little language you can speak with another person that is constantly evolving and constantly growing and I love that. My favorite games are two-player conversations. The sort of thing where there's a tension between you and another person. You're trying to figure them out. Meltwater's a little like that. trying to figure out what their priorities are in response to radiation. Fighting games are very much that because you have to figure it out within human reaction times, within a temporally locked space where you don't have time to sit there and go, "Well, I know you could do this. I know you could do this. I know you could do this." Where you could sit there and work it out and just be a total prick.

But in fighting games, it's okay. Here's the situation. What? It's great. It's amazing. It has changed the way I really consume and enjoy this sort of gaming, especially because fighting games are so difficult to master possibly difficult. Like I love a game that I'm going to be play still playing and learning and figuring out in like 30 years. That's that's that's excellent. That's what I want. Not so much into these little short like shorter squippier experiences unless they are very narrative. This is super interesting to me because I mean I don't I don't hate fighting games but I find them stressful and I I don't always understand the appeal. So I want to know like what is your favorite like fighting game series and what makes it special.

So I I have an answer for that but I think here is the answer that is going to change this and it is completely independent of the game I play. And the thing is is that what makes fighting games beautiful and what sort of exists in them that has parallels in other spaces but never quite a onetoone is the fighting game community and specifically that it is a it disresembles other gaming communities in a very specific way and that is the deeply endless nature of it. There is. Imagine if the bosses in Dark Souls could go study up and be harder through things other than just getting more hit points or doing more damage. Imagine the Dark Souls boss could figure you out the way you're figuring it out. That's fighting games. It's incredible. That is the appeal to me. Is not the oh, this game is the perfect mech. I have my favorite. It's guilty exert. Uh, it's an amazing fighting game. Go play it. It's usually like $10 on Steam, but also it's a game for freaks and weirdos, and it's incredibly hard, incredibly dense. One of the most mechanically bottomless games you'll ever play in your life. And that's part of the appeal is you you don't have to know all of it. It's not like a board game. It's not you don't have to internalize all these rules.

Pick up the control. You know how to move left, right, press a button, do that. Learn the next thing when you need to. It creates this constant evolving process of learning that is itself reciprocal with the people you are learning with. so that you are constantly developing and growing around each other, learning these weird little private languages. So like one thing I'll come to is that okay so my friend Daisy we play a lot of Guilty Gear together. Uh she plays a character named Millia Rage. Very fastmoving whippy little character. Goes around the screen, knocks you down, sets something up awful on top of you for you to stand up into horrible hate her evil character. and I play the honest, totally fair character, Axel Low, a very slow British gentleman who just happens to hit you from across the screen with this big metal chain he's holding. Uh, and so the dynamics of that fight between me and between my character and Millia are interesting, but the dynamics between me and Daisy are unique in a way that is different from any other given Axel and Millia. In part because fighting games are too fast to do because they ask so much of you so constantly and you cannot physically physiologically you cannot focus on everything. You must develop you must choose places to develop yourself. You must choose what part of the infinite skill set you want to be working on. And this creates uniqueness. It creates intricacies. It creates dialects. There are places where you can always be optimizing and doing something better.

But no one has ever reached that I do everything optimal. And they had to choose where they were doing that with their own frail human body, human muscle memory, human reaction times. And that massive combination of all these factors creates this pressure force on people that extrudes them into these wonderful, beautiful, unique shapes. And then having conversations between these shape, there's nothing else like it. I chess doesn't do this. if only because like like chess has a similar thing where people develop their own styles but like the the depth to which you have to go before you're doing your own thing and leaving your and feeling your own fingerprints are way further down the line after years of studying books and opening whereas even at every level there are these little parts of enjoyment where like again my friend Daisy her character her character has this uh super attack this called chroing rose where when she's zooming across the screen she leaves these little flowers that explode and it's actually not a really strong attack. But she has spent so much time perfecting all the little advantages she can get off of this. It is hers. It is hers in a way that someone else picking up the game, they might know what she's doing, but they don't have it the way she does. They haven't put the time, the memory, the muscle memory. So much of it is muscle memory. So much that cannot happen up here. It's too fast. You have to learn how to put it in your veins, your bones, your reactions. I'm a little passionate about this. You might be able to tell.

No, I love this. So, it actually makes me wonder though. Okay, this is not I'm not asking this in an adversarial way. It just sounds like it. Why do you like to figure people out by fighting them? Why does I mean like Meltwater, too? It's brutal. Like, you talk about figuring other people out. What is it that you figure out about somebody in an instinctive aggressive situation that you wouldn't otherwise? I just feel like this answer will be very interesting to me. So, I feel

like this is a this is a hard one to wrap your brain around because I don't know why. I just have always used that. That is how I connect to other people. Like, at the end of the day, I'm kind of a a weird dog. uh kind of shy, stays in the corner a lot. Uh having a structure with which to connect with people has always been helpful. And for some reason, the adversarial tension of a competitive experience, I don't know, it it allows you to be in contact with something different about a person. like it's something that isn't part of like their persona, their public face, the version of you that they have decided.

You see, it's there's an intimacy to it. It's there's a little bit of a thrill in just getting to know the contours of someone else's brain. Even if it's over something trivial that doesn't apply. It's not like, oh, I fought you and now I know that you are a coward and a fool, but you are a good man. No, no, it's not like that. It's just it is very much like what I have learned from fighting Daisy is how she is going to respond when I try and shoot her out of the air with a metal chain, which is not going to apply to a lot of other parts of our life. But like aren't a lot of the best things in life just learning to appreciate the textures of something, the taste of a food, the smell of perfume, the particulars of the skin of a lover. So many things are just you they don't need a bigger reason. The delight is just in appreciating this specific texture, taste, experience of another person, of another person's interior world, something we don't normally have access to because we are isolated in these incrossable voids of meaning to use a phrase from Derida.

You know, the idea that, okay, okay, going off on a tangent, but like let's say I want to tell you about a tree, and I'm totally stealing this example from a video essaist named uh Ian Danskin in Newendo Studios, but say I want to tell you about a tree that I had in my backyard, and I want to tell you about this tree. So, I can tell you things like, okay, uh, the leaves were like round and waxy and had a pointed tip and the bark was rough and came off in your hand in little chunks and smelled of dirt and the tree was taller than the light than the electric lines near my house. But all of these things are contextual. All of these words I can what I cannot do, no matter how much I tell you these words, is take the image of my tree and put it in your head. I can't. All I can do is use words to try and conjure an approximation of that in your head. But that void of meaning can never be crossed. You are creating your own tree out of your own subjective experiences of words like bark and pointed and waxy and how tall power lines are and what kinds of pointed leaves there are. All these things are from your context and I can never take my context and give it to you. But the thrilling parts are when you can almost almost get close to that, almost feel like you're touching something of another person that doesn't come across that void usually.

And that's the coolest [ __ ] Like that's people contain infinities inside of them. Every single person on the street is containing some unknowable, unquantifiable, infinite depth that we will never see. But occasionally, if you find the right angle and the right just way of doing it, you can come close enough to get a little glimpse of that bit of infinity you don't get to see. All right, this to another question about fighting games. So, how often do you try out new fighting games versus like go back to ones where you have already developed mastery? And how does that impact your communicative experience with other players?

Well, uh I'll I'll answer your question with a question. You ever learn another language? Yes. You ever take French? Uh maybe I had to test a reading exam for that crap in grad school. Yeah, sorry. Some people choose to pursue multilingualism, some people choose to pursue monilingualism. Some people find it frustrating that they can never reach the depth of their second language that they do in their first. And some find it an interesting challenge. For myself, I tend to stick very close to my favorite series, Guilty Gear. Like, if I'm booting up something in the middle of the night, I just want to play something. It's Guilty Gear. I'm going to play Guilty Gear. not going to take the time to grind out uh my combos in King of Fighters or Tekken right now, but I do want to explore those spaces in the same way I want to explore languages because well, there are things that you just can't say quite the same way in one language as another. know like it's like the the problem of translation like P I'm told reads completely different in English than in French because P wrote so that the language of the French sounds pretty and it doesn't like there are there are ways and constructions in French or in German or in Spanish that are completely different unique beautiful that you're not going to just get if you stick to one language but also the multiclassing is never going to give you the depth in the second language unless you were lucky enough to grow up in a truly bang languual or triilingual or whatever environment. So, you have to make that call for yourself. I I like dabbling.

I also just find this question interesting in the context of, you know, you're a board gamer as well. So, you know, um so many people play a board game maybe a couple times and then they get another. It's a very commodity mindset like like I it is one of those things that frustrates me just specifically the fact that there are so many many many games and some of them are beautiful unique inventive revelations and some of them are like I'm not going to like talk down say anything is bad. I'm not like there's good art and bad art and there's high art and low art, but there is art that's trying and art that's doing the same things in the the same formulas in the same order. And I'm not into those as much. And I feel like our hobby is very much built towards these first bite experiences in a way that I think a lot of things are in our culture, movies, media, books, they're designed for that quick one, one hit of dopamine and done sort of experience.

And like I'm not saying that's bad, evil, the sin rotting our civilization or whatever, but like you know, you kind of got to stretch your diet with the things that are a bit have that meat to them. You can't really just get that in a singular brush. That's part of the reason why I've actually kind of been slimming down my own collection a lot just cuz I don't want to buy something I'm not going to put some heart into. And that like but at the same time that like worries me cuz I'm putting out a board game. I'm making it. I would like you to buy it so that I can have money and pay off my advance and Capstone Games doesn't have to come repossess my kneecaps. Like uh that's why they're called Capstone, you know. Yeah. But but like it does sort of I feel a way about the fact that I'm kind of part of this commodity culture. I'm asking you to buy my game.

Are are you listener going to play my game more than once or twice? And like if If you are, why are you buying it? Like, buy it. Please, please buy it. I would love money. But you get it. I do. I do very much, and maybe this is a mindset I very much come from from growing up uh, you know, without a lot of uh, stretch budget, let's say, for nicities. So, you know, I'm very into the things that you can make last for a while, but now I'm starting to feel like we have this glut of stuff and no one takes the time to really explore. But it's also a hard genre to do that in because board gaming uniquely tends to require more people. Like, you have to have other physical humans seated in the room with you usually unless you're playing on like a tabletop simulator or something, and I I never do. I I'm old. I have never been able to like get past the interface issues. And board games are something you kind of I feel like I at least have to do in person and without the abil. But I can't do them at You can't do them at will. You need another human being. This is why I make two-player games really cuz Oh, this is why I do solo gaming. Yeah, I I'm big in two-player games.

Like I never I never got really big into solo gaming except for Mabels because I I get into Mabels because they're Mabels and I I wanted to know what she's doing and she's fascinating. But for me, gaming was always a social exercise. Even video games, like I don't tend to play a lot of video games where I'm playing alone by myself in the dark, unless if I am, they're usually visual novels. They're usually something I'm just going to for a narrative experience. Ever since I was young, like video games were me going over to my the kid next door's house to watch him to switch off hand off the controller or watch him play Super Metroid or something. It was never about like it was never this personal thing. It was always a community thing for me. That's one of the reasons I love fighting games is that fighting games are by definition a genre that are best with other people as a means of communicating with others.

But now and more I am finding the solo games that are okay. You're talking with the designer and those are pretty good. That's super interesting. So what is your I mean you've had a very busy last couple of years as we mentioned and some difficulties that kind of kept you back from the work of design. But what does your design life currently look like and does it match what you want it to look like? Well, I'm honestly okay if Meltwater is the only game I ever release. Not that that's necessarily my plan, but I've taken a different outlook on things in the past few years.

Like, I made a thing that I feel is really powerful and said a thing I wanted to say and here it is. Please enjoy. But maybe if I have something else I want to say like that, I will create something else. I actually have several that I'm cooking on. I'm not going to talk about them because actually talking about your projects is the death of them. That's that that keeps you from getting them done. You can get to know about it when I finish it. But I also don't feel this compulsion to keep making more stuff just to make stuff. That's that sort of consumerist weird feeling like I don't need to just throw more I don't need to cut down more trees if I don't have something to say with it. But maybe I will. Uh right now all right I will give a little bit of a hint. One of the games I'm working on uh probably will come out through Holland as will any future games I make. Um working on a game that is about uh using chess to try and process the grief of a death of a loved one. uh one about homoerotic sword duels and one about uh running away from your family because uh they see you as the devil and want to kill you and maybe you are but maybe you still want to live.

Are there any sorts that aren't homoerotic? I mean I guess straight people do it sometimes. You got it. couldn't be me. But this honestly all sounds really good. And I guess my thought I guess my other question for you too is it's so and I I asked this as a way to kind of ground myself, right? Like I'm somebody who was going to be a high school teacher forever except that I got like the job offer of a lifetime and grabbed it. But now I make games for a living. It's my hobby. It's my job. But I can't stop now. Um, does the act of just working on the projects satisfy you? And how do you maintain that mental space instead of trying to push yourself to be successful the way that other people try to measure it? Well, so I have an advantage there, which is that um my wife is the bread winner. Uh, I I I'm the housewife. I I I clean. I I I don't have to make the money and so that gives me the space to not have to my I will not while I would like uh to have some nice dinners if you uh all kindly buy meltwater and also again I would like to maintain possession of my kneecaps. So please help me earn out that advance. Uh but I don't I don't know once I left the once

I left a career once I so I went into housewifeing back in 2016 in part because uh the job I had been working at a media uh company called Pulp Gamer that used to create content for Mayfair games. That company unfortunately went under when Mayfair was bought out and at the time my wife's kidney condition worsened and she needed a transplant. So, I left work to help take care of her through the operation and then I helped care for uh another friend and then I helped uh I'm helping care for my mom now. So, that's that's the focus of my life right now. Making games is a nice thing. It is a way to put out there what I want to put out there to I don't know take whatever thorn is stuck inside me and see if I can stick it inside someone else too.

But if I've done that, I've already succeeded. So anything else is gravy. You know, again, maybe I'll make another one or maybe I'll just keep cleaning the floors and making food and be happy that y'all liked the one I made. Honestly, I dig it. All right, so I've had you for just coming up in an hour, so I'm going to ask you a couple of just softy questions. And so this one I normally just ask like what is a board game that you've played recently that you're really enjoying? Um but I mean a piece of media, a board game, a fighting game, a book. What have you been consuming lately that has brought you some joy? Uh well, so uh a book. Well, I just happen to have Aunt Mabel Holland's Cardboard Ghosts. You know, it's it's great. I love Mabel. Although she does like brag on me a little in here and it's very embarrassing and oh my god could you I love you sis uh uh hide my face. Uh aside from that uh see other things I've really enjoyed like okay this this isn't original Root.

I played Root recently. Root's still really good. It's still Root. Uh like what do you want me to say? It's Root. Thanks for keeping my lights on. Uh uh fighting games obviously. Like I'm going to go out and say it. play Guilty Gear. Uh, Guilty Gear XR, Guilty Gear Strive, Guilty Gear Accent Core PlusR, all of them, the various members of the series, they all have cord solid names. It's okay. Just search Guilty Gear. They're all great games. They're all amazing. They all tend to go on sale. And if you ever really want to get into fighting games, it's easier than you think. It's all about just finding a group of people to do it with. Uh, and if you'd like a place to start, I'd like to recommend uh a friend of mine, uh, twitch.tvpattheflip. TV/pattheflip p a t h e f l li l i p. He is an educator. He is a instructor and he is a great person who helps people get into fighting games and Guilty Gear in specific and has written a lot of instructional content, a lot of inspirational content, a lot of talking about why we fight and why we enjoy these games. And he's a really excellent writer, Patrick Miller. Uh, just go check out his work if you ever want to understand what the big deal with these fighting game things is and why it's more interesting than just two people mashing buttons at each other. It's it's a great time. I highly recommend checking out some of his writing or some of his video essays or some of his talks. He's great. Uh, and that's brought me a lot of joy recently. And uh, God, I recently saw The Substance that also brought me a lot of joy. God,

excellent horror movie. Fantastic analysis of the madness of being a woman in a society that treats you like a consumable product. Just kino kino. Absolute kino. Go see the substance. I keep thinking about watching it, but I'm very worried the body horror is going to be like too much. Oh, it's so body horror. It's so body like Okay, body horror. Body horror is my thing. I love body horror, but yeah, you have to kind of be into that. You kind of have to want to watch, you know, the gross skin and the blood and the sewing and the needles and the Yeah. You know, I'm a big baby, but I kind of feel like artist like so many people have talked this movie up. I'm like, "Okay, am I just going to like make my boyfriend sit with me and just have to turn it off occasionally?" I mean, that's that's just I really love specifically that kind of horror that just digs something very real out of you, something that hurts. you know, movies like The Substance, Hereditary, uh, The Platform, uh, just incredible movies. Uh, horror, that's the other thing. Horror movies. Just go check out some good, uh, some really good social horror movies. This is interesting. So, for me, like the I I love horror movies like The Witch.

Oh, yeah. Fantastic. Love that one. Excellent. So, do you have any other recommendations along those lines? like ones that are like not necessarily body horror, but they're deeply like creepy and kind of about a little bit more than just a scary situation. Like the substance sounds interesting, right? Because it's about something more as opposed to just stabby stabby or something gross. Well, have you ever seen uh I Saw the TV glow? No. Excellent film. Uh incredible. Uh hit me in a really deep place. Totally recommend that one. Definitely go see it with a trans friend if you can. Okay, sounds okay. Leaving it there. Okay. All right. I will I will phone a friend and and and arrange movie time.

Fantastic. Um and then I Okay, I think I already know the answer to this question, but I have to ask. Um where do you like to be found online if people want to follow your work? Please don't. I have no interest in being followed online. Thank you. You can check me out on my BG page. You can uh see what the publisher posts, but like I don't use social media. I I I mean I have I I have them, but they're just they're just for me. So uh uh enjoy if enjoy my game. Don't follow me on social media. Uh given that I really appreciate you taking the time to come on here. Um, I'm very very grateful that you consented to do an interview and I've really really enjoyed getting to talk to you. Thank you very much. It was delight being here. All right everybody, I can be found everywhere online is beyond solitire and in fact terminally online.

So you can bother me about this interview. Um, all right everybody out there. Um, please like, subscribe, comment, ask questions and most of all happy gaming. Take care.

Progress saved