Katana
Transcript
welcome to brains on games I'm dr. Brian McDonald and this episode we're going to be talking about a card game a two-player card game that's about dueling samurai called katana like I said this is a game for two players it can be played by kids aged 8 and up and it plays in about 15 to 30 minutes this is a game that was designed by Tracy Allen and I was lucky enough to speak with Tracy Allen yesterday about his game and and the thought that went into the design one of the things I mean you can see from the boxart one of the things that's interesting about this design is the style every choice that was made in creating this game is about creating an experience that immerses you in that culture of the samurai era of Japanese history so there's the there there are cultural elements to the game that you'll see when we look at the cards and there are some historical elements as well but they're not necessarily you know overt it's not a game that's teaching you something it's a game that's about the experience so let's take a look at the cards and we'll talk a little bit about the game and how it works so here you can see the various kinds of cards that you're going to be playing with in katana pretty stark minimalist kind of design mostly black and white with a little bit of red or a little bit of green but the idea is that one player is
going to be on the attack and might play an attack card where the other player can then play a card to defend and subtract that amount off of the the attack that's coming towards them so it goes back and forth but one of the things that create some tension in the game is that there's a hand management component you draw up to your full full hand of cards there's five cards in a hand so you only can draw up to your full hand at the beginning of your turn which means that whatever cards that you play during an attack you don't have those cards in your hand to defend with you see that each of the cards has an attack box and a defense box okay so you've got to think ahead about what cards you're going to need what cards you're going to need to defend yourself later on so you might be having a good time and have some good cards for an attack but you you also may be wanting to think ahead and hold back a little bit because you're going to need those cards later so if we're talking about holding back some in behavioral inhibition you might call that behavioral inhibition is an example of an executive functioning skill the skills that you need to be able to work towards a future goal those are executive functions and they include planning ahead which is another thing that you have to do in this game and behavioral inhibition let's look at a couple of other things about these cards
because each card has three different areas on it and there's three different things that you can use that same card for you can either attack if it's your turn to do that or defend like we said earlier after your attack though you put a card face down in front of you and that's called your stance so that's what's going to be your response to your opponent's counter-attack when it's their turn so you've got a facedown card in front of you this is the ability that it's going to give you your opponent doesn't know what that is when they're planning their attack okay so here you can see that you'll flip that over and your next attack will get a bonus on it because of that stance another well here you can shatter your opponent's armor you can reflect the attack back on your opponent so those are the examples of some of the different stances that you can use in the game to sort of give a surprise to your opponent so you're also saving cards for that stance if you play all of your cards and attack you don't have anything left to use because you can't draw up at the end of that turn now a couple of things here there's three different things that I just wanted to mention quickly about the game that that's really the Japanese culture and history portion of it and that is these these cards are called comi and the comi are the spirits that might help maybe they might get in the way but usually you're hoping that they're going to help your
samurai to win that battle so in this case you can see that the comi will allow you to draw your cards back up to your full hand at the end of your turn so this ability allows you to break that rule you don't have to be as careful about saving cards for defense if you have this ability and the active ability that you can use by purifying you play a purify card in order to activate the ability of your commie is that the enemy isn't allowed to draw cards so the enemy has to be extra careful when they're facing up against this current so the idea of purification or pollution and I'll talk more about that with Tracy when we get on the call purification and pollution are important elements of the game and there's certainly there's a spiritual context to those things that kind of brings you into that that Japanese cultural world if you play a card that purifies or pollutes the next thing you have to do is go to the shrine so you draw a card one of these shrine cards and they might give you a bonus but they aren't all good so you might wind up with the penalty so here you can see that you're going to lose some armor on that turn so that's not a great thing it's a risk to go to the temple but you but that's a requirement if you play one of these purify or pollute cards you might get a bonus like being able to see your enemy's cards so you'll know what's coming up against you so the it's a
gamble to go to the shrine you have to go there if you if you're purifying or if you're you're facing pollution here with the comi and that's just another part of the sort of spiritual element of the game of katana let's talk to Tracy Allen the designer of katana about the game and about how he linked this history and culture to a game that might otherwise just be a typical back and forth battling card game so Tracy you are a historian by trade really right tell me about your interest in history yeah so I studied history and graphic design and when I was doing that I was trying to think of ways to merge the two disciplines they're not really related very much and I've had some ideas like you know I could lay out history books I could do museum displays but I've always enjoyed games I used to work in the video game industry and it's taking a step back from that to go back to school and study history and design and kind of really enjoyed the the tabletop game design process and the depth that it has the possibility of depth particularly in terms of history and being able to explore historical experience and just
different stories that I think you can do with card games and board games and the gamers who love those those games in a way that's just different the relationship with with tabletop games is different than it is with video games and other types of media and so I am sort of taking it on as my mission to do games that aren't just historical in the sense that you learn facts and names and dates essentially trying to replicate the experience of reading a book I don't think that's the way to go I think there's a better way and I think it's focusing on the historical experience and trying to figure out ways to translate that into gameplay mechanics that then lead to a player experience that is in some way touching back on that historical previously lived past so for me that's what got me into history I was never I have a particular affinity for the ancient world distant past and so when I started learning about Greeks and Romans and Egyptians I was really saddened by how little information we have about ordinary people's lives or even people who existed somewhere in the middle of
society most of the information and most of the historical sort of discussion their new culture really tends to be focused on the elite the top the rulers and particularly politics politics is really the focus as much of history and it has only been in the last few decades really since about the 70s that people have in the historical world taken an interest in culture in the individual the ordinary things that previously were deemed unimportant because it didn't involve a king or a queen so my first game katana is does touch upon some politics and and and sort of traditional history in creating a backdrop but the gameplay is focused on the experience of any Japanese warrior of the medieval period it's about what it was like to actually be in their position of not only having to martially perform essentially go to battle and win but also the whole cultural set of dynamics related to religion that if you were to not include that in the game would be an oversight it would be missing this
essential component to that historical experience of being a medieval Japanese warrior in the same way that in our modern world you couldn't write a Canadian or an American history without talking about Christianity or Islam because they are part of the story they're not the full story and talking about them in no way is endorsing any particular religion or spirituality but is instead saying that it's part of the experience and that's what's important to me because I think and wrapping up my thought I think there's too often a fixation on nitty-gritty detail on trying to figure out what exactly happened in the past and what I'm more concerned about is our concept how we construct art an image of the past today that's what history is history isn't something that we dig up from the ground or a set of documents that we have to quote-unquote decipher in order to unlock the truth of the past instead it's subjective it's a story and the story that we tell is the story that we decide to build so the best stories are those that are based in evidence but also hint upon what the actual human
experience was so I think you know my games are always going to have that backdrop of academic hard historical you know humanistic study and evidence but really I want somebody to be able to play Kitana play any of my games and not need to know the language of the culture names and dates and still walk away and say chant make general statements about the experience and walk away saying yeah that culture is different than mine that that they do things in a different way and I could experience that through the way it was I was interacting with the game one of the biggest things do you think about katana that make it make it different in that way from other battle card games what what are the things that you feel players will walk away and and have that experience of having been sort of in touch with that historical Japanese culture so the first thing they would say in a lot of ways is detached from any specific culture and that is as a game is its first and foremost an action game which is unusual for a tabletop game right in fact tabletop games tend to be the opposite it tends to be not viewed as action-oriented tends to be more strategic take your time which you can do in in my game because it's turn-based
but there's this sort of pressure for you to make an action because of the context of being in this sword fight so from a design perspective I was really intent on minimizing the number of cards minimizing deck-building both is a way of keeping the focus on like make make decisions that are meaningful you don't need to have 20 different cards to have a meaningful gameplay interaction you can have just a handful and if they're really well designed you're gonna use them in different ways and that will be satisfying that also connects with a very strong Japanese aesthetic in terms of minimalism which is which really starts in the medieval era with Zen Buddhism coming to Japan and sort of promoting this idea of simplicity in all things and that's why you see early on a lot of interest in Japanese culture with design of aesthetics so the game in terms of combat mechanics and gameplay is definitely hitting on a lot of those themes but also when I look at a lot of other combat games there's a lot of customization of your there's a lot of deck-building or there are modifiers that the game ins you end up focusing on
those has options and you want to maximize your weapon or status attributes bonuses in order to win and I wanted to step away from that not because it's an invalid approach but because it's not it's not the lived experience of the medieval Japanese warrior they you know most of these were they had to buy their own equipment so for most of them they were fortunate if they had barber and if they had a sword they had one so the idea that they were going to you know sort of how I defeated an enemy I'm going to upgrade to a new sword was not really something that happened hearing regularly and so I wanted to create a combat system where it was like you are fighting with your skill not the weapon and so the cards are kept minimal you only have four different action cards you can't upgrade them to a better sword a better katana and so it really pushes the game although it's a working effectively because it's on a battlefield it's actually more psychological than it is about the physical sort of violence that would occur between these two warriors you beat your opponent not by the the individual card you play you beat them by outwitting them by the series of cards and maneuvers and choices you make mm-hmm well I will confess to you that
my son and I did sit for several seconds between turns staring at each other to try to try to spy what we're going to do next because we didn't know what that hidden stance card was or because we didn't know what Kurt or should we save cards to defend the Nexus so no I think you definitely accomplished that goal for sure you can't spend a lot of time with analysis paralysis in this game you've simplified it to that extent but there's still a lot of decisions to make and all your cards can do different things yeah I'm great it's great to hear that that was the experience of you and your son had because that's what I want I I want it to be difficult to make a decision in the sense that if you have three possible actions they're all valid and you can easily see how you would play them moving forward and so that's great because it means that it's easy to play because you can't make a wrong decision but it's sort of nerve-wracking because you're like I want to do all three and they're equal valid how do I choose you know and that's to go back to the question you're asking for us how is his uniquely Japanese culturally speaking Shinto is brought into this game Shinto is the sort of indigenous native religion I used the word religion loosely essentially focused on these deities called kami and comi are featured in
katana and they act as a vessel for powers that you can use in combat and this really makes the game very different not just because you have this God at your back other games have you know sort of complementary characters but it's the way that you activate their powers that is unique to Japanese culture and it's operates on this dynamic of pollution and purification so Shinto they believe that certain things in the world have a polluting effect shedding blood dying things a woman giving birth sometimes they're very random and other times it's easy to understand why blood may seem to be polluting in order to counteract any polluting effect you would purify yourself by presenting an offering to tuition to God Akane and these comi behave in ways that are analogous to like a Greek or Roman God in the sense that they will respond to petitioners but perhaps not in the way that the petitioner would like they might gain a favorable response or the comi might kill their family um it really sort of depends on the mood and so the game reflects that dynamic in terms of each comedy having a particular
affinity a personality a set of active and passive abilities and if that comi in the course of play is polluted because you shed your opponent's blood then you can't use those abilities so the game becomes a matter of not just trying to defeat your opponent and take away their health and armor but making a crap really kind of crass determination are you going to be the pious warrior and purify yourself to retain your commie or are you going to be a craven shogun and simply use the commie for what you need it for which is to win the battle and let it be polluted to oblivion and that to me is an interesting choice because when people realize that they're going that they have to make this decision you can see it in their face the first time they live because they realize like oh I might be icky for essentially using my god right it is is the commie has essentially been granting you all this favor been giving you all this power and some people don't want to you know balk at the idea that they would sort of use this this deity and and to me that is striking it tells me a couple things one that the cultural aspect is coming
through that this idea of pollution and purification is coming across in the game and that's exciting because that's what I want but that too in players understanding that they're understanding historical experience the game isn't just about swords in fact that's this that's sort of just dressing and in fact there's not really you know there's I think an icon of a sword for attack but you it's really not visually what the focus is on the focus is on that psychological narrative that each player has to have with themselves about how they are going to win and what is ethically acceptable in achieving that victory I really enjoyed the game and I thought I think you're it's great to talk to you about it because I I sort of felt decisions and the artwork and the graphics I think did speak to that culture but I'm so happy to be able to talk to you about how the historical context fits in a game that ostensibly if you just see it on the shelf is could it look like a sword fighting game yeah yeah I mean part of part of my approach is but I wanted it to be entertaining and not to be edutainment because I feel that is not appealing to white people it doesn't excite the games that are most successful and resonating with people
are not coming from the edutainment world so it's partly a marketing exercise but it also is there there is also you know research and thinking behind the aesthetics it's not hey that looks good let's do it black and white you know black and white looks great but you know part part of the thinking there was symbolism was incredibly important to Japanese culture and the time still is and painting in other arts very decidedly moved to the lack of color in the medieval period you see some use of very pale washes of color but a lot of black and white ink paintings and this was believed to be really important to prevent people from being distracted by the material world so they could achieve enlightenment in the next and so there it's his beautiful reason behind an artistic expression of an aesthetic mode that when when I was working with the illustrator on katanas you know tour we got to do this you know we got to figure out a way to to make this happen in a way that makes sense for a modern game and so that's why you see red there's it's a very tight color palette but but I feel very passionately about I love
history because I love learning these little things like I just described like who knew that black and white ink paintings had like this seriousness that had a real weight to them in this culture that's kind of interesting and when I tell people these tidbits they seem interested too the unfortunate reality is in order to learn some of these tidbits you have to sift through a lot you have to read a lot and so people would get turned off by history so I want to give them a way to access some of those little nuggets access you know the the experiential general cultural vibe that they can pull from from the past because I think people will enjoy it but if it if it's if it if it's too many gritty I mean I I love history but even sometimes I get bored with the stuff I have to read I get bored with some of the newer games that admittedly are technically superb but the barrier to entry is so high and so that's with with this game and other games moving forward it's about being inspired by art history but doing something new that's I just think that's cool I think that's what I want to do well I agree with you it is cool and it's a cool game and I thank you so much Tracy for talking to me today thank you dr.
Brian so that's an overview of katana a Dueling card game for two players that involves those executive functions of inhibition and planning to allow you to manage those hands of cards if you want to find out more about the game you can head over to katana card game comm so if you have any suggestions or questions you can reach me by email at Brian at brains on games dot CA brains on games dot CA is the website where you'll find all the episodes posted and you can find brains on games on Twitter on Instagram and on Facebook so hopefully you enjoyed this episode and if you did and you'd like to be notified of future episodes you can head on over to YouTube hit that subscribe button hopefully we'll see you next time