Skip to main content
Loading video...

1492: The Year That Forged Spain | Designer Interview

Transcript 12:25

hey gamers this is liz davidson from beyond solitaire and i'm here from the reacting to the past game development conference with kyle lincoln he's a professor at southeastern oklahoma state university and he's the designer of a game that i played this morning called 1492 the forging of spain how you doing i'm well liz thanks for having me so we had an exciting morning uh why don't you tell the public at large what your game is generally about sure so the short version that i tell people in now elevator is that it's a game about resolving a conflict between the trustamara dynasty so fernando and isabelle on the one hand and muhammad the 12th the last sultan of granada that's what i tell people it's about what it's actually about is how to resolve a really deeply rooted conflict between religious groups while still also counterbalancing the kind of diplomatic needs that you have to have after a century of warfare is finally wrapped up um so it's it's got a couple of things going on but it's in a lot of ways about diplomacy about religious uh identity and about making deals at a time when it seems like a deal is impossible so so yeah i i know about that from experience now because i got to play fatima the dowager queen of granada i was really just trying to preserve my son's dignity at this point because we had lost the spaniards were coming in it was tough so what what feelings are you trying to create in students who are kind of on that losing side yeah so i think one of the things in in general that reactant does really well but that i really wanted to highlight here is that it's really easy

to see what happens historically and say that's what was supposed to happen right one of the things that reacting really does well in this regard is to play with contingency right that individuals are making choices that then shape the outcomes for the side that's losing right that's lost the war that's not the only objective right you can lose a war but be remembered as the guys that that you know put up a fight or preserve the dignity of your religion preserve the practice of your people um and could save face right so this is a classic example um that i i like to tell my students that i play if i play one-on-one against lebron james i will lose right unless he is in a coma i will lose there's no question about that it's lebron however if i lose a hundred to one i scored a poor point on lebron that's a moral victory for me at five foot seven and a half five foot nine if i'm leaving the right seven eleven there's enough of a moment where you can say like okay that was the kind of victory that was achievable and it was meaningful and so for the the students that are on the nostrids side it's a lot more about what constitutes moral victory right and in some ways it's making sure that the pyrrhic victory the trust amras the fernando and isabella team are are working for um it is really a pyrrhic victory right so they've lost so much in winning yeah that they're now neutralized as a threat um which for them i think is a big win and then for the international opinion characters it's obviously about keeping the war from breaking out again and creating a lasting peace which is

um right a little trickier for them than they think they know at the start indeed um and you know on the fernan the fernan isabella side things are a little difficult as well because you know you have people having to embody values that maybe aren't comfortable so isabella was notably anti-semitic there are religious primacy issues at hand how do you write a game like that that's going to teach students about the issues and have them work through it but in a way that's respectful yeah that's a really good question liz i i like to tell people that my goal is to introduce a version of religious prejudice to them that they have a strong reaction to but that generates the antibodies and antigens that they want from it right we want that we want that we're not the vaccine version of anti-semitism and islamophobia not um the live uh virus so to speak and so one of the challenges is how do we make sure that that religious prejudice is present and and potent without being overwhelming there are a couple of ways that we do that uh in this simulation in in the first place we try to replicate some of the population dynamics that is to say most of the characters in the game are are catholic or christian um and the next largest group is muslim and the third largest group is jewish which pretty closely replicates at least in terms of proportion the balance of the population the peninsula really um but at the same time instances of prejudice are off offstage right they don't happen voiced by characters um instead they

have certain abilities and powers that replicate the potency for contemporary audiences of really really harsh rhetoric right that is to say people responded to anti-semitism people responded to racism people responded to islamophobia in that period not because they were evil but because that that triggered their anxiety right they acted emotionally rather than intellectually they acted um emotionally rather than morally and so then the challenge is how do we make sure that the students can feel the impact of that rhetoric and understand that no in the 15th century those things were okay to say even if they were you know sort of fringer um there there's still powerful right so one of the ways i've done this is with a series of special powers all characters have some abilities some things they can do um and most notably students take a pre-game quiz because of course these are teaching names so we have to make them take a quiz um and whichever student gets the highest score gets um what i what i refer to as a cartesio a charter of prejudice a letter of prejudice that allows them to symbolically by holding up the the the form that they get the prize form that they get to embody using really harsh virulent rhetoric to trigger a response you know to sway people to their side to eliminate a certain prohibition in a tree or ceremony and really kind of replicate the impact while still keeping it far enough away so that if students have experienced islamophobia anti-semitism of their own um in their own lives then then that's far enough away to where you can say like ah so it made somebody do something right

but not you know causing a full-blown panic attack in a student so speaking of special powers there are also a lot of secret powers like one thing i really liked about this particular game is that there's a lot of skullduggery and like indirect communication a lot of use of kind of soft power and persuasion how do you convincingly build something like that into a classroom simulation and also is that typical of reacting games because i feel like in the other ones i've been looking at that's not present so i think there are definitely one of the things that you can easily plot in a reacting game is how you know sort of um how macro and micro it is right so um the the biggest macro games things like yalta um or um uh uh the rwanda simulation we have these huge international forces on the micro level you get things like greenwich village which is all you know in one neighborhood in new york um and then the other end of the spectrum are the the so-called great debate games um which are as as the name would suggest parliamentary legislative um on the other end the more social games they're a lot more about the kind of squishing in between space i've tried to make granada a little bit more on the macro end and a little bit more on the social end but there's still a very powerful great debate sort of in the middle and up like i guess um and so for soft power questions the real challenge is defining which characters have the hard power mechanisms and then saying okay how do you construct a way for somebody to wedge or nudge one way or the other and especially for for characters that historically wouldn't have had you know

the the ability to lead armies or or arrest people right that soft power is really important and so often one of the ways you do that is by limiting hard power pretty stridently and then limiting access in general right so that the students who have that soft power that access to go across factional lines to go between groups or committees um really have a little bit more leverage because people need them because the boundaries are more enforced right um the person who's in charge of a door you know isn't very important in an open field of grass but if you're in a big castle the guy that's in charge of the front door is kind of important right because they're controlling that access and so that's one of the ways that i really kind of made um a push point for what they're up to in that period right now uh so for people who don't get the joy that i had this morning of spending several hours arguing about how a ceremonial handing over of granada should take place because obviously that's politically very important and it was my job to make sure it wasn't too too christian and too shameful for me and for my son so if you're gonna go learn about the setting for 1492 and you can't play this game which is super fun what do you recommend that people out there read or look at in order to get like a good perspective on this it's not just columbus right so i mean in in the first place i think one of the there are some really good there's a really good series of books um by wiley blackwell which are um the wylie blackwell histories of spain and there's a really good volume in that set which i think is is either done by john williams not the composer um or taylor ruiz um

and those volumes are great i think one of the the most resonant portrayals for me is actually i forget if it's a tv quattro or if it's channel 5 series in spain which is actually a telenovela a soap opera but in the more game of thrones height um uh called isabel which is all about isabelle's pursuit of power and her role as queen and i think one of the things that we we mistake in this period and there's some great work on us for granada too by by all means there's some really good there's a great recent book by brian catlos called kingdoms of faith there's a really good chunk at the end sort of last chapters about granada it's a big history of islamic spain but i think there's a really good and really rich scholarly literature i think one of the challenges for first historians of spain for historians in medieval liberia is that we have great scholarship and then the popular stuff that comes out is garbage um or is transcendent and there's no in between right so you'll get you know books that are really evocative and really emotional but that you know dramatically misrepresent the scholarship in the sources or you'll get books that are really great um calluses kingdoms of faith is a great example where they're really like powerful reads but because they're not pushing on those emotional levers they don't get you know it's not the the stream of five star reviews about telling the truth to the woke professors and no come on that's nobody's like that um but but kingdoms of faith i think is a really great um book for me

medieval liberia in general it's a really good history of islamic spain um there are a couple of great books about the history of judaism which i'll post as a reply to this video as a little pinned uh bit because there's there's quite a lot of good out there um but you know the reason we spend a lifetime sifting through this stuff is because we're trying to sit through this stuff and so hopefully can save people a few bad books and and push them towards the better ones but absolutely kyle thank you so much for giving us some of your time if people have questions for you or know more about your game where can you be found online uh so i have an academia.edu profile that's mostly um where i do stuff and within the reacting community i'm pretty easy to find i'm not a twitter guy i was on twitter for all of a day and then just left um not not for me um but uh i'm i'm all over for the reacting um consortium i'm on the editorial board and the game development conference so if people are interested in bringing reactant in their classrooms um have suitcase will travel um and there are a lot of ways uh to find me through those outlets too so that's where i go fantastic if you're watching this channel you probably know i'm everywhere as beyond solitaire so please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming do

you

Progress saved