Skip to main content
Loading video...

An Outstretched Hand | Zenobia Finalists 2024

Transcript 23:01

hey Gamers this is Liz Davis from beon solit here and today I'm absolutely delighted to be interviewing Max bovim he is a game designer Zenobia finalist and he's going to be talking to us about his entry and outstretched hand so how you doing today Max I'm great thanks for having me excited to be here no I'm super happy to have you on um so uh for people who have not been following Zenobia uh just give us the summary what is an outstretched hand about uh an outstretched hand is about the sort of struggle uh for and over the Jews of Eastern Europe in uh the 19th century um so the players play as one of four four different factions at that time that was sort of struggling to sort of exert dominance control influence shape the destiny of the broad masses of Eastern European Jews um two of which are sort of national political and two of which are sort of ideological religious so uh what are the groups just for for their context oh yeah sure so one is the um sort of the zaris regime um which is sort of the prevailing power there one is the um sort of the poles and the the Polish faction a little bit of their character changes changes over time um one is the hosca movement which was um kind of considered the Jewish Enlightenment movement um sort of the more liberal um reforming movement um of that era and the other is the hidic movement um which is a religious

revivalist movement um that emerged um in the 18th century but became like much more broadly popular in Jews especially in that part of the world um over the course of the 19th century interesting I know very little about this topic I admit so um what kinds of tensions are in play between these groups and then how did you mechanically Express that in your game yeah sure so I think maybe just like to take a quick step back and explain sort of like a little bit of where this is all coming from um you know by the 18th century by the 1700s you know exact numbers hard to come by uh as they are in so many things but probably at least half and maybe even a large majority of all the Jews in the world were living in the um polish Lithuanian Commonwealth um which is which was a a really large State much larger than modern day Poland includes Modern Day Poland Lithuania um but also like most of what is today bellarus and Ukraine as well as some of the other neighboring countries um but that state didn't last it was partitioned over the course of the late 1700s um and by the time everything got wrapped up with Napoleon um all that mishas uh to use a culturally appropriate word um most of what was polish Pol Lithuania ended up in the hands of the Russian Empire um which previously had been a state um completely closed to Jews and now had probably the largest Jewish population in the world um so a lot of this are

about um sort of the different factions navigating sort of that kind of revolutionized environment um so the Zars faction deciding what to do with all of this these Jews suddenly within its newly expanded borders um the poles who were sort of struggling to um figure themselves out economically assert themselves nationally um in this new environment where they were suddenly um not really an independent country anymore um as well as these new movements kind of writing broader sort of religious cultural intellectual currence in Europe within a specifically Jewish context and sort of the way that the game mechanically expresses that um is fairly straightforward but tries to get at one thing that I thought was sort of key to that Dynamic which is that a lot of these factions um made as much an efforts to gain influence over each other as they did to gain influence directly over the Jews so as an example um the uh Zar Empire often found it um interesting and convenient to try and promote um the hcal LA the enlightenment uh movement in order to try and uh potentially see that as an Avenue to um bring the Jews into a state that was more favorable to assimilation into Russian society and in by contrast the hcal saw the you know the power and the resources that that the like ruling Russian regime had as its Avenue to spread its ideas right so they were both trying to like use each other as their

Channel um towards their ultimate goal of sort of bringing the Jews of Eastern Europe sort of into the into the place that they wanted them to be so mechanically the game is a little bit dudes on a map um there are nine rounds over which um The Players Place cubes um in nine different map spaces um sort of representing the geographical area um of the game um but un unlike some of these games where the goal is to directly sort of control the most spaces um The Players the factions accumulate points over the course of the game for controlling the spaces but the winner is not the player who has the most points necessarily but the players are also accumulating cubes of their own faction as well as the other factions in a secret area called their courts uh and the winner of the game is the player who has the most cubes in their Court of the player with the most points right um so it's a little bit of a bet on the winner mechanic as much as it is trying to actually directly get the most points on the board interesting and is this your very first game design or had you kind of poked around at the idea of being a game designer before um and and this is a just a project that struck you uh well I have a I have a Google drive folder um full of like drafts sketches half done ideas there's been a few times before where I've managed to put like a playable prototype like d on paper um

but this is Far and Away the furthest I've ever taken like actual like game design idea with like a full manual and a you know revised playable prototype like actually kind of like exposing it to other people um for their feedback in a more systematic way so this is this is definitely the by far and a way the longest um I've gone down that sort of game design Journey for which I'm really grateful to um the Zeno Zenobia 4 in terms of creating um both a lot of that scaffolding to help make that happen as well as just a lot of the moral support that's awesome so uh before you got started in the process what what made you decide uh to go in for Zenobia and how have you I guess handled the pressure of trying to design a game in such a short period of time uh well I you know I'd heard of the I you know kind of heard and followed a little bit the first zobia competition thought it was cool and awesome um and I think just like sort of like one of those stars align kind of thing that when they were doing the call for this one um I had just gotten really into this topic um and had been even just giving some thought cuz the way my brain works you know I have this nice big collection of games here is when I get into a topic like one of the ways I think about it is how would I model this topic as a board game you know like how would I explore the topic through that and so I'd already been like giving that some thought and then when they put out the call um I was like well you know like you know 90% of life is just showing up right um so uh I figured why not um and bit off substantially more

than I could chew uh probably but um it's been it's I mean it's been I think honestly it's been like a great experience because even though it has been a lot of pressure in terms of like doing a lot of work and like you know thinking through a lot of like really thoughtful um and constructive criticism but also you know definitely criticism um during the course of the process right like stuff that you actually have to take back and like rethink some of your ideas and be like am I doing this right is this the best way to do this am I succeeding in the thing I'm actually trying to do right um like doing all that um the environment has just been so supportive like you know with the judges the mentors but also the the contestants themselves people being really willing to share their own ideas like look at each other's materials play each other's games proofread each other's manuals like all that kind of stuff it's just been it's made it feel fun like 95 to5 in terms of like a lot of work or a lot of pressure stress that's really nice and it's sounds like um you know you've been receiving feedback I know that your final draft of this game is due uh in a few days so thanks for taking the time to talk to me but um how would you say that your game has evolved and changed uh since beginning it to now oh uh a lot um I in fact my initial proposal was for an entirely different kind of game um and sort of like as much my sort of entry into this topic was thinking about

more sort of the setting at a ground level as opposed to sort of like the high level of the Prototype I I just described right like something like think about everyday life and and what we're called the Shettles right like these little market towns all across Eastern Europe which were where most Jews lived especially up until like the early to mid 19th century I really wanted to try and create a game that sort of explored that environment and a lot more of like sort of that that human level um and that was sort of my original proposal was to design a game that sort of did that um and then I I could not make it work both like mechanically and also for a lot of I think what you'd call like representational reasons like there are a lot of ways to make that work as a as a game that was not like in some way like really problematic or sort of troubling in terms of how it actually like depicted that theme especially in um in a board game type setting right where you're putting a player in certain position and they have to like make certain decisions and pursue certain goals um so from there I kind of pivoted I had a couple other sketches of things that sort of and eventually I sort of worked my way up the scale of like sort of like the level of abstraction and also like the level of scope and zoom out um until I got to something closer than here and there were a couple other ideas earlier on I wanted to take more inspiration from a game called kitlock which was a sort of a 21 Blackjack style card game that was popular among Eastern European Jews in the 19th century and I wanted to work that more mechanically into the game um

and that's still there in the current prototype but it's like much more for I think just sort of like theme and flavor not there as like like one of the original designs really was like kind of centered around like the players playing something more of more like this game and that sort of I couldn't find a way to make that like workable or fun either so kind of worked its way eventually towards the sort of the current mechanics oh that's interesting it actually it sounds like you've kind of told me to answer this question but in case there's more I'm gonna dig uh which is I was wondering um you know what what did you discover uh over the course of your research and design that you thought was really interesting but didn't quite make it into the game oh I mean a lot right like the current because like the current scope of the game you know it's a little I'm being a little ambiguous about the time frame but it takes place like over I think like something probably nailing down be like a 60e period over like most of the middle of the 19th century right um and over like a huge geographic area and it's like really smooth down like a goal I really wanted to have with this game was to make it approachable to people whose reason for getting to the game was maybe interest in the topic in the theme and not so much having like you know whatever 100 board games on their shelves right um so I really tried to make you know like there's only like one type of piece that you could put on the board right um the game is has a little bit of inspiration from the coin series but it's not like you know where you know there's different types of pieces that have different rules there's no as there's no like kind of like rule book based asymmetry between the actions

um so I think like there's a ton of things that I learned that were things that in some ways were some of the things that attracted me or motivated me to to think more about the topic but that like couldn't really get expressed in this format I think the things that I'm able to capture you know especially you know I'm hopeful that like as I continue to develop the game I'll be able to work in more like you know things like flavor text on the cards stuff like that um but a lot of like um you know I read one really interesting book um and the name of the author is escaping me it was entitled The Golden Age dadle I can I can look that up um before we before we get off the horn um but there's like a long um one of the long segments is just discussing sort of like how um basically a lot of the uh the Jewish Traders um were navigating um the sort of new world of like sort of Russian borders um and Russian trade restrictions um basically in a nutshell the zarus regime tried to crack down on uh trade like you know between its neighbors um a lot of which was disproportionately done um by Jewish Merchants um and the Jewish Merchants um basically just spent decades finding like increasingly creative and ingenious ways to get around those restrictions um either by evading Customs or subing Customs officials and you know all all these different ways of basically ensuring that they're they Aunt their there you know centuries of trade into these other

areas you know from like Austria Germany onwards um could continue and there was just so much colorful stuff about like the specific Goods they were bringing over like the ways that they would you know hide things from the Customs officials or get the Customs officials on their side like create entire cottage industries of like making Customs systems work for them um you know and that end up being something one that you can't really represent in a game that has like nine RS dudes on a map over you know that huge area right but also I think kind of points to a little bit of what I found challenging about some of those human level designs right because I think that you know when you there are certain things that I think if you portray in a certain context can be you know kind of like kind of neatly unpro problematic and then in other contexts can you know raise more questions about the sensitivity with which you portray them right like I own um Sheriff of Nottingham um a delightful game where you know the players are trying to smuggle things past each other they're you know know they're trying to you know be deceive each other you know um be a little cunning being a little conniving and sort of like that sort of like yield English setting has you know kind of like you know like no thematic interaction that sort of makes that problematic but then when you put it in a Jewish context right you like oh these Jewish people they are breaking laws and maybe you know telling lies in order to move Goods across borders and pursuit of money it's like are are you telling that story in a way that doesn't you know inadvertently you know f like negative stereotypes like that's like that's like

a harder thing to do um and one that was a honestly a bit of a daunting challenge for you know someone who's like new to game design like me and you know I was at some point had to decide how much I wanted to tell a certain Story versus how much I wanted to tell a story that I could be comfortable with putting out the world in the in the form that I was putting it out right yeah that that actually makes a whole lot of sense so on that note what are you hoping that people who play your game would Will Come Away with in terms of an understanding about the topic that you're presenting this way I had to really good question um you know something that I think you know as I have looked into this topic um and and done more research into it you know it's something where it's it is my background I'm of Eastern European Jewish descent um and I think it's something that a lot of people you know feel especially people for whom that is their background feel that they have some familiarity with right like people you know hear stories from their parents and their grandparents um they may have seen like a handful of prominent cultural representations of this era you know like Fiddler on the Roof comes to mind um but actually you know reading it I felt like it was in a period of history that is sort of ill understood or even misunderstood including and perhaps especially by the people whose history it is and it's not necessarily history he that folk that there's like kind of

like a strong inclination to sort of look back into and try and like represent for a mass audience a little bit more like trying to like actually look back and and tell the story you know you know more with an eye towards like you know what we can say today based on the historical record and I think for me like wanting to like see like what was it really like then you know what what what was the world of my my ancestors but Al like what was you know I think in a broader World sense you know a part an important part of global history um trying to you know take a lot of the work that you know I think you know obviously like a lot of academics and researchers and other thinkers have done to try and like sort of rebuild a more robust historical record around that time and try and condense it into a more historical form that at least kind of brings people to be like oh maybe this the story here isn't the story that I thought it was or I never quite had the story in my mind that way and there's more to see and think about here um and to kind of like ignite some more interest in that like that would be if this game design could lead to any number of people having that thought and that experience I'd be really really happy all right that is a perfect place to end the serious questions so now you get a couple softy ones uh so um what games have you been playing recently that bring you some Joy oh um recently that bring me some Joy um well I play a lot of carcasson and Azul

always those are always two of the favorites um one game that I played recently that I found really interesting um was oh and now I can't remember the name of it but it was about the US presidential election of and now my history is just giving me either 1824 1828 no no it's 1824 1828 um the election with um the election with um uh Jackson and Adams and Calhoun and not Calhoun Henry Clay um and and Calhoun actually the and with the corrup bargain and I I cannot remember the name of this game I'm so sorry I can I can look it up and no no I'm looking now too that we're gonna look this up then I'm gonna edit it together because I need to know now but it was funny because um some some some friends of ours um recently got it as a gift to invite us to play it um and this was just like a few few weeks ago and it was like one of those weird things were like I'm in the middle of Designing this game and we're playing this game and I'm like oh this game is like weirdly similar to the game that I'm even though I'd never heard of it or played it before like not like that that similar but like similar enough in some ways that I was like like really like oh that's so funny and that's so interesting um it's a it's it's a clever design um because it's trying to simulate this this real four-way presidential election that happened and like the rules of the US president election presidential elections are that

um if no no candidate gets a majority electoral votes it goes to the house um which is you know rarely a like like a likely consideration like you know a two-way presidential election but in a four-way presidential election it's like much more likely so in the game you're basically trying to play for both like there's basically a two-step Victory thing where it's like first do you outright win the majority Electoral College if not it goes to the house and then do you win the election in the house so you're you're you're sort of like trying to play at both elections at once and you can't get to the second election unless you place in the top three of the first ones so it's like you're like you can't lose you can't come fourth in that first round um but so you need to try what are you playing for a long term is this corrupt bargain yes yeah I think that's what called 1824 presidential election from decision games got it yeah yeah and so I was I thought that was I was it was very Nifty um it was very fun like it was and it was like it was it was like I also like admired it because it like achieved I thought one of the goals I had with my game which is that like it wasn't like it was simple enough that you could teach like that like literally none of us really knew how to play it we managed to like teach ourselves from the manual and sit down and play it and like a relatively short amount of time it didn't take a lot of time to get it to the table and set up we could kind of just go with the flow and figure out a little bit as we went along um but still have fun playing it and still feel like we all had like our hat in the ring to actually try and win the game and the end kind of like surprised us and we all realize like oh like you know like if you don't think hard enough about this part early on the game then you know

it's like it it it had like a lot of like nice moments like that um so that was that was a fun one all right I gotta play this now uh and then if you um are online and want to be found by people where can that be uh yeah you can find me on Discord and my username is let me check Max Bento um max b n t o uh and my board game geek is just my name Max bentovim perfect Max thank you so much for coming on and talking to us about your game I'm super excited to see where it's going to go and I wish you all the best of luck congrats so much on being a Zenobia finalist thank you so much I'm really glad to be here and thanks again to Zenobia and everyone involved in it for making such an awesome experience all right everybody out there if you're looking for me I can be found anywhere online it's beyond solitire uh please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming

Progress saved