Burning Banners QUICK Review
Transcript
Hey, Alex, if these are your top 10 games of all time, you should play Burning Banners. And he did it. So, we have this copy of Burning Banners. Here's a quick review of Burning Banners: Rage of the Witch Queen. Both of our thoughts will be in this video. Burning Banners is a fantasy war game of differing scenarios, but it's usually a simple objective to just destroy your enemy. No, there's no minis here, but tons of little chits with tons of art. Oh, also, this game was made entirely by one guy. Yes, he made the map and all the unit art, so that's awesome. So, if you like very traditional fantasy with your goblins and dwarves and orcs,
year 430 forced the empire to abandon its eastern provinces.
Perhaps if you're also into or familiar with War of the Ring, then here we go. It's a game that it's about 30 to 60 minutes plus per player and from two to six players. Also, we're not covering any rulebook pros or cons cuz this is a quick review. Disclaimer, the game does not come with these metal coins. It comes with these cardboard coins, but we're using the metal. Okay. How to play. You'll be given an objective off of your scenario. So in this scenario, the orcs are invading. So the orcs want to have control of six settlements and/or have them raised by the time the game ends. That is by three seasons or rounds of the game. The dwarves want to stop that. Everyone will have a bunch of units on the board, but you can never stack more than one per space. On your turn, each unit will get one move and one action. Move is equal to their movement value. Wilderness give you a penalty of requiring one more movement. Action is typically attacking an adjacent thing. Combat will get to soon.
or they can do a C action which is moving on water. Great. So now a unit versus unit combat. You look at your unit's dice and roll that many. Five pluses a hit and on a seven or eight on black dice that explodes. So you roll another white dice immediately. Matching hits cancel each other out and remaining does damage. If you kill the enemy you can advance into the space like taking a settlement for your windcon. Then your income goes up. You can loot the space for some immediate money. Yeah, simple stuff. That's it. That's a unit's turn. Then you it slightly to show it went. You can also pay for units on your turn to build them. If you build a settlement, it's ready to go. It can move and attack. Once you have cocked everything, it's time for your opponent to go if they haven't already. Once everyone has gone, it's the end of a season. Then you just reset everything. Quick pros. Wow, this game looks really good. There's so much art, art, art. There's six different factions with 10 plus pieces of unique art as they have units and their heroes. And uh wa look at the map. There's four of these boards. You can put them together for bigger maps. Oh, by the way, the art has all been done by MTG artist Christopher Mullen, who actually designed this game, too. As for component pros, we won't go into much detail, but this game is all just chits pretty much for the basic game. So, yeah, setup's not that bad considering how big this game is. And then the cardboard is also all great quality. Doing turns is not fiddly at all because you just move the thing and then you it slightly to show it's been used. That's it. These player boards organize the units well and you get these player aids which are all really useful and war game build explaining everything like the map terrain. Oh yeah, maps. They're not just a pretty face like the handsome orc leaders. Rather, the terrain really matters. There's intricacies like rivers that cross which slow you down, or a big
river which impedes more movement, or wait, there's a bridge, so this crossing doesn't impede movement. Or there's a road where if you do all of your movement in it, you get a movement bonus. And the world layout just makes sense. You have certain cities being fortresses that give defensive bonuses. Or this dwarven city has an extra settlement on its outskirts that is the first line of defense. because otherwise you have to spend an insane amount of effort to cross this major river and go into a swamp marsh that is five movement just to enter this hex. This all feeds into how positioning is the name of the game here. It's really easy to get mindset as you see the natural choke points of each map like oh yeah this bridge is really important or maybe your settlement is extra defended because it's protected by a bunch of rivers. So you get to roll one additional white dye in defending. This also helps you weight a decision of the ship move better cuz you can forego an attack and reposition through a river hex. Yes, you can move through rivers or you can attack to secure a port and then when you layered depart, you move six spaces. Moving on to the fantasy factions. Yes, you get six and they're very wonderfully asymmetric. Like you can immediately tell because of the units. So, let's actually take a detour in how units are distinct. They have health on whether or not they have a backside and have different movement and roll different dice. Then throw in keywords like flying ignores terrain or stealth memes you can first strike, but that only causes one damage max. Faction time. The dwarves are kind of vanilla. They have pretty good stats and can also summon a bunch of miners, which are beefy two health dudes that only cost one, but also all can be put to work to provide more money. It gets weirder from here. The ravaging orcs have amazingly stated units, but they don't have income at all, but rather mostly get their money by looting other players because they loot an extra money. Also, they literally lose the game if they have no
settlements within their control after they've conquered their first, and they start with zero settlements. So, if they ever revert back to that, they just insta lose. but also they don't get rewarded for holding settlements because that doesn't give them income. So, they usually just want to raise and then go full on rampage mode. Or the weird army of the night, who we've seen also have pretty terrible map presence from the beginning, but they get to spawn these secret coins at enemy settlements, which let them build their disgusting spawns of rats or wolf packs or giant bats. These are feral units that can't take settlements, but they can still burn them to the ground. If you're playing the advanced mode, you can use the witchy woman to enslave other people's armies. Then there's the big Eastern Empire who in the scenarios we've seen start with a huge advantage like 15 plus income, but they're kind of like the Byzantine Empire in that their best days are behind them and they roll for a revolt at the end of every round. So they want to pay money to deal with that. Oh, there's also goblins and Vikings, but we don't have much time to cover them today. Uh, so the goblins have altered income and the Vikings have free ship movement. Okay, that's pretty cool. This is mostly without going deep into the advanced rules, spells, and blessings of which you can use a lot of because at the end of every turn, you'll usually draw back up to full in at least one category here. Then heroes can cast spells within a certain range, meaning that when you start understanding the game, you can really mind game and positioning your heroes in certain fights. Fainting, you have strong spells, and some of them are crazy, like a water spell to do damage to someone suddenly, or killing another player's hero. Here's some final things with unit positioning and why it's so good in this game. You can retreat units to your settlements to heal them back in full,
just at a discount. So, you get rewarded by retreating. But remember, looting an enemy settlement is too money. So, sometimes you just want to send and then just spawn more units with that. Or how when your units spawn in settlements, they get to go right away. But if you move them out, the settlement is now a lot weakened. So, you have to gauge whether or not your opponent can even hit it. Or how if you end your movement adjacent to an enemy settlement and not attack, you still prevent them from spawning units. It's considered besieged. Oh, and then your units can also go for a little side quest of their own to fight random monsters, which is a really nice worldbuing side story moment of seeing what's out there. You can fight a kraken in the sea, or you can fight some cobalts on the mountains. Huh, reminds me of those World of Warcraft raids. And then you can spawn units anytime in return. So, even before or after certain units move, and you have access to all these units and you can spawn them in any settlement. So, yeah, that's a lot. Do you want to get a bunch of small units on the map to just use them as a meat shield, but they're really cheap, but probably can't do any damage back to the opponent, or do you want to save up for a big unit because that's the only way you can override the opponent's enemy elite unit? Game also has an insane amount of replay-ability.
I mean, there's six different factions. You start with a really good tutorial and then the floodgates open as you go through the rest of this campaign book. You can no doubt play this game a hundred times and not play the same faction in the same scenario once. Oh, by the way, when we say campaign, what do we mean is that it's two chronological stories. It's not like you make decisions, nor do your factions get stronger based off what you do. So then the last pro is that there's so many storytelling moments when we just cram in all this fantasy together. Cuz remember, every single unit is so detailed and unique, then you smack on the unique hero on top. Or you can have simple but funny fights of say an ogre ambushing a minor. So then the minor just attacking the ogre's feet with like pickaxes, not doing anything. or just sweep across a lot of the map with a giant crow, but since it's only feral, it can only burn something to the ground, but who cares because it ignored all the mountains and enemies on the way. Neutral zones just get fought over a lot and it's funny to take them back and looting it cuz you need the money.
There's moments of big armies being thr crossings or a fragile siege engine finally gets pushed away to the perfect position cuz you only have one copy of these and this takes out the fortified conditions of cities. So now a nation's capital is really in the pits. Quick cons. Everything feels a little too small in this game, especially for more than two players. So, apparently, it's because the maps were painted to be in this specific size, but yeah, come on. Like twice as big would be greatly appreciated. Sometimes it's hard to see mountains because they blend in with the overall color or how rivers next to marshes can be sometimes forgotten. Or the crucial, and I mean crucial, bridges. The game feels a little too simplistic with components sometimes, like the control marker just hangs out on the hex so when your unit moves in, the small chit just got to be on top. Same thing with the raise marker. This is the worst for the heroes who just snack on top of the army it's with.
Okay, great. So, we have no idea what army is actually on the square. And even if you do remember, well, is it injured or not? Lots of hero gameplay involves checking what's underneath it for movement, too. It's also pretty hard to see their caster symbol. We're thinking the hero could just be a wooden marker that's screen printed with art so it can use verticality. Then, the box needs an insert. Luckily, we have a lot of plastic bags, but if you don't, well, good luck organizing all those unit pieces. The very last con, which is probably the most glaring issue with this game, is how it handles time. So, it's listed at an hour plus, which is, yeah, kind of true, but the thing is the play time is so insanely variable because of the win conditions. Like, one side could just get really lucky early on and just get a bunch of settlements and win the game. So, it's like 20 minutes or the game could go on for all the rounds. So, yeah, this game could easily be 30 minutes to 4 hours plus.
The second problem is downtime, where there's just too much waiting around when it's not your turn in three plus players. Think about how a lot of games nowadays have about one or two actions per player per turn most of the time or like four max. Not just the do every single thing then pass and do nothing because that's burning banners. So each unit's activation is rather streamlined, but you can have up to a dozen of them all across a giant board. If you're involved in getting attacked, sure, you're at least doing something and rolling dice to defend. Or if you're playing advance, you might have spells or treasures or blessings to wait to trigger. But then again, the map is so big that you might not be able to play them. It also starts scaling off how with more factions, the game is just more complicated. So even stuff like initial spawn is way more complicated. So yeah, a lot of the time 2v2 felt like it should be a two-headed 1v one or a 1v2. Luckily the game ended earlier before we got to season 6 cuz I heard on BG that one group's average round aka season is 2 hours. So yeah, their game was like what 8 to 10 plus hours. We were about 1 hour plus per season with each turn being 10 to 20 minutes. So it's four turns a season. So yeah, we were on pace to have probably a 5 to 6 hour plus game. Quick scoring recommener score 8 out of 10 for this. It is great.
Can you imagine this was all made by a single guy, Christopher Mullen. Wow, he has some passion for sure. And the game certainly feels like it was made by an old guy while playing in mostly a good way. For a game that came out in 2024, the inception of this game was probably much earlier. And it is old-fashioned fantasy fighting of orcs versus humans versus goblins versus monsters with dice chucking. And it's a lot of dice chucking because you do a ton of these rolls every turn. Now, while they're not that similar of games mechanically, I can't stop comparing this game to War of the Ring in my head. It's the fantasy thing. Like, this is a lot simpler, but it really gets those same fantasy juices flowing. And well, yeah, you're still fighting over settlements with armies. Heroes are like leaders. You can play cards from hand to change combat, although no turns have stacked armies or have the side hunt for the ring or have the action dice resolution system.
Burning Banners is certainly Tolken inspired in many ways like oh hello evil sorcerer tower that reminds us of Eisenard and the orcs spawn from the east all the time. Even the 2v2 kind of feels like war of the ring and that you shouldn't play 2v2 unless you want a lot of downtime. Just play 1 v one and two head to the game. Anyways, for 120 bucks, if this speaks for you, yeah, go for it. I mean, it's all pretty intuitive gameplay-wise and you get pretty much what it looks like, fantasy fights. Although the multiplayer systems aren't perfect, and I think where the simple action sequence really gets strained. Still, I could imagine multiplayer groups still going in deep, memorizing all the blessing cards for their factions, then keeping track of the spell discard to win. But also, this game doesn't take itself too seriously. I mean, you're creating off rolling seven or eights on black, so that encourages swingy combats, and you can just side quest for a monster to get some random OP treasure, or the monster defeats you and starts killing your army. Burning Banners is probably going to be the most commonly enjoyed by those playing it for theme above all else. If you get it, you'll likely be the one who loves reading the booklets of lore, getting in deep with a faction's personality, and just seeing all the amusing fantasy stories that arise, regardless of outcome, because you've been teleported back to some old but good '90s gaming.
I would give Burning Banners a 9 out of 10. I think it is excellent. Perhaps with some homebrew rule changes, it would be maybe even better. It's easily in my top 20 games, we'll say. The factions all feel very distinct and the map is simultaneously beautiful and also very functional. I think the theme of this game also comes through very well. I love the little lore snippets in the rule book. So, I think the gameplay of this board game is where it really shines. Its combat system is extremely elegant and it makes combined arm attacks feel very satisfying to pull off successfully. I really like the one unit per hex stacking rule because it kind of forces you to consider positioning and also different types of units are good in different types of situations versus just making one big death ball stack that you could just throw at your opponent. Oh, also Alex wanted to compare burning banners to bloodstones and that he likes that burning banners doesn't promote deathballing and that the art of burning banners is so much better. It carries a theme. I really enjoy the magic system in this game.
Spells and blessings add a huge amount of variety to every single game you play and a lot of tactical texture. They'll let you roll dice, you can add dice, you can do long range strikes, and you'll draw a tremendous number of spell cards over the course of the game. I mean, in a short game, you'll probably draw 20. In a really long game, you might draw over a hundred. So it rarely feels like you're being screwed over by bad luck because kind of the optimal way to play is by churning through your spells as fast as you can. So apart from usability, I don't like the amount of downtime in a multiplayer game very much. At two players, every game I played was very fast, furious, tense, lots of decision-m on both sides. At four players, the game was a slog. I barely did anything and my participation in the game was inconsequential to the victory of my team. Especially on that scenario felt like my faction was just an accretion. I would prefer the game if you have like three activations and on your activation you could move a unit and fight with it or you could build a unit um or you could cast a spell or use a hero's ability or something like that.
So even with those complaints, I love Burning Banners. It has a great setting. The rules are very slick. The asymmetry is super cool. I can't wait for whatever comes out for this setting next. I looked at the expansion and think the four new factions are all very neat. And I guess there's a video game adaptation of this coming out too. Game's great. Sorry. Game is game is excellent, not just great. My personal score is a 7 out of 10. I like it. I don't love it like I thought it would, but yeah, it's cool. I also I'm never playing multiplayer again. The 2v2 was way too much downtime. I literally started checking emails on my phone. I've never done that in a board game before. It's just h too much waiting. But yeah, this game is just so wonderful to look at and be around. This type of fantasy world will be enjoyed by me till the day I die. And piloting the orcs or dwarves or Eastern Empire all felt unique and satisfying. This game is really easy mentally to jump into, and it's fun to strategize around the map.
The combat feels good for the most part, although if I start playing many, many hours, I think I would enjoy another phase or nuance to combat, like stacking units maybe, but that's not what this game is. Now, I was expecting to like the spell system more, but I don't really like it as much as I thought it would because you have to just keep churning through spells, which leads to more story moments, but I find it to be way too much wacky spell being played by everyone cuz they're generic. It's like when casters are close to each other, anything can really happen. And again, I don't like how it's from the same deck. I'd rather have everyone have their own deck in addition to a blessing deck and have spells be more of a rarity. Probably more like how War of the Ring does it. Actually, speaking of War of the Ring, I've been thinking about that more since I haven't played it since I made all the videos for it many years ago. I will still rate A War of the Ring an 8 out of 10 today. It's just that I have currently no motivation to play it again because I've seen the stories it has to show. But Burning Banners has a lot more stories for me, even though I don't see the score ever changing from a 7 out of 10. I don't think I'd ever suggest to play Burning Banners, but if Alex wants to play 1 v one, then yeah, sure, why not? It's more fantasy to experience. Anyways, yeah, this is a nice way to game for me, and I'll probably be casually thinking about this in the future. Oh yeah, one last thing.
I suck at remembering to my units at a 45°ree angle after their turn. I know it just other games don't really do that. Usually it's a lot more intuitive. Like you you tap it sideways or you flip it face down or whatever. That's Yeah, that's burning banners.
That's That's Oh, wow.
Also, one hit.
What?
Yeah.
Oh my god. What are these?
You have one, two, three, four, five, six, seven, eight. I have to take back three.
Yeah.
So, this is impossible. Um, this is impossible. I think I'm pretty sure it's impossible.
I don't know what yet. Yeah.
Even if I had a three movement unit that I spawned here, which is my fastest unit, they would go one, two, wow,
three, four, five.
Your fastest movement is three. That's crazy slow. Wow.