Skip to main content
Loading video...

Trick taking (sort of) auction game: Goblin Vaults

Transcript 11:21

I received a complimentary review copy of goblin vaults from the publisher so thanks to thunderworks a trick taking sort of auction game sort of with Tableau building sort of and a fantasy setting sort of this is a small card game in thunderworks fantasy world of ulos the same universe as role player cartographers and Dawn of ulos though it shares very little in common with those games and that's the hook was there a hook in there I'm not sure this could be a problem I'm Adam Porter I design games and I review them on this channel with a focus on product design if you like what I do please subscribe comment and share the video Goblin vaults is a 2023 release designed by thunderworks founder Keith Matika and Eric schlapman it's playable by one to five players sort of and it's got a little more going on than your average trick taker so it's somewhere in that family plus category you're going to want to have a few simple card games under your belt before you take a stab at this one but it's certainly not complex in Goblin vaults players attempt to win different suits and values of cards displaying them in specific configurations to complete variable scoring objectives revealed at the start of each new game three cards are revealed from the deck and these are the cards over which the players will compete at the start of the game a fourth card dictates the Trump suit for the round in turn Order each player places a card from their hand beneath

one of the three cards in the display and places a token on it to show that they own it if your card is valued equal or lower than a card already in the column you've underbid and you must place a gear token on the current highest card in the column if your card matches the Trump suit it beats any card of another suit and if your card has an icon matching the icon on the trump card you can shift cards around in your own display or swap a card from your hand with one from the deck when all players have played a card the column are resolved the owner of the highest card takes the card from the top of the column and places it in their own Tableau their played card moves up into the display for the next round along with any gears placed on it each other player takes back their played cards and adds it to their Tableau each player's Tableau is called their vault and it contains four vertical Chambers and three horizontal tiers a card newly added to the Vault must be placed in any chamber in the lowest available tier when players are played all their cards they score their vaults gaining points for cards which have been positioned in the tier indicated on the card and for cards with a faction icon matching their own faction and for any gear tokens they've collected they also score points for fulfilling the three objectives chosen at the start of the game and these are different every time you might need to form sequences of ascending or descending numbers or gather together cards of matching suits or matching values like most trick-taking and auction games this game really only functions with three or more players but

goblin vaults does provide rules for two players and even solo mode whereby the missing players are substituted with a random card draw the automated opponent doesn't make intelligent moves but it blocks spaces and competes for cards giving a simulation of The Full Experience so let's kick off with the outward presentation of the product it's a small box with a big picture of a goblin playing cards and frankly the game could be set anywhere the theme is irrelevant and thunderworks do like to place all their games in the same roleplayer universe so why not Goblins the game would work just as well with plain old numbers and colors but how would it be distinguished from thousands of other abstract card games certainly this box cover will catch the eye a little bit more that said it's a pretty generic image and despite the quality of the Artistry it's still easy to overlook the next step in onboarding players is the rule book and this one is fine it gives a clear account of the system with very few ambiguities the rules are not complex but the strategies are layered and not immediately apparent it's not simply a case of playing a card to bid for a reward we need to think about under bidding to collect our own card but that's going to cost us cogs and there's a timing element too you might want a card for your Tableau but now is not the time because it would be in the wrong tier to score points playing an icon matching the icon on the trump card allows me to shift cards in my Tableau there's even a rule whereby the start player can swap the Trump suit at the start of each round each added layer

makes the game more interesting for strategic players but less accessible for casual gamers there's quite a learning curve here compared to other games in the genre and that issue is compounded a little bit by the terminology where every aspect of the game has a thematic name the central display is called the block your personal Tableau is your Vault rows and columns a tear and Chambers and the trump card is the warden thematic terms can really help players remember the rules in a complex thematic simulation but this game is totally abstract and the terminology sadly works against it just providing one more barrier to getting up and running I rate games using my own ladder engagement system I score games between zero and three points in five categories and each point scored climbs the game one rung score of 10 or above tops the ladder and indicates a real favorite with me thematic immersion as I've already indicated is a zero the presentation is lovely but it's irrelevant I I'm not going to labor this point meaningful interaction is the next category and this is an area where you would expect the game to excel trick taking games and auctions are both extremely interactive genres and that sfed Goblin promises underhand dealings and a competitive head-to-head but truthfully your focus in this game is entirely on your own Vault you have little concern for what your opponents are doing no way of influencing their Tableau and even the auction is lacking in drama it's very hard to know what your opponent has has in hand what card they're likely to play

and if you're out bid there's no opportunity to react of course this means that the random card draw of the automated players in the solo and two- player games does feel pretty authentic The Experience changes with increasing player counts because there are now more players vying for the same three cards the size of that Central display doesn't scale with the player count this leads me on to my third category stress and challenge with 1 to three players the game is a fairly Breezy Affair often you'll be able to claim the card you want from the display and you can focus on how to organize your Tableau low stress the tension cranks up with four or five players as you find yourself frequently outbid forcing yourself to adapt to tactics on each new turn some will prefer the higher player counts as a result but less competitive players might want to stick with one to three player games one area where Goblin vaults does well is feedback now now when I talk about feedback in games I'm referring to the various ways the player interacts with the game system and generates a response usually a reward or a punishment of some kind resulting from a player action now turns in Goblin vaults are short and after each player has taken a single turn rewards are handed out either a card from the display your own played card returned to you for your Tableau or potentially a gear token or two but playing an icon which matches the trump card also generates a special action swapping a card from your hand or changing the

location of the cards in your Vault it's a dynamic system and it's a real strength of the game now my final category is Meaningful decisions and Goblin vaults does okay here like the closely related family of trick-taking games you're limited by the cards you were dealt so luck does play a big role but there are a multitude of ways to use those cards and manipulate the game State and players are frequently prioritizing different goals so you rely feel like you're totally out of control and the variety of different scoring objectives in the Box means every game presents a slightly different Challenge from the last so the overall score of seven is fine it doesn't top the ladder but it's engaging enough to provide an enjoyable session and the gameplay is novel enough that it feels fresh while there's nothing here that's totally new this particular combination of trick-taking auctions Tableau and set collection is pleasingly offbeat moving on to my product design checklist is the game Innovative well I've just called it novel and then I went on to describe it as offbeat so does that equate to Innovative I'm not sure while the overall package does feel fresh each of the mechanisms within is familiar and very well worn there's nothing about the product which stands out in a very crowded Market is there a need for the product well through the lens of the game's Market as a whole the answer is no there are plenty of card games of comparable complaint complexity and similar genres a wealth of tried and tested titles to pick up before playing

Goblin vaults but there's presumably another consideration here for thunderworks and that's providing enjoyable new content for their committed followers fans of role player cartographers and other games set in the world of ulos if thunderworks was looking for a relatively simple card game that their fans could enjoy alongside the more well-known titles then this is a pretty satisfying little experience on my Matrix best selling titles combine a wonderful concept with outstanding execution occupying the orange red corner of the grid less commercially successful products tend to linger in the blue section struggling to turn a profit for their creators now as a game designer I can appreciate the Ingenuity of the mechanisms in Goblin vaults it's a really clever system building on several popular genres it makes for a fun game I think I'll be hanging on to this one but that doesn't necessarily equate to a strong commercial idea it concerns me that at the very outset of the video I was unable to identify a hook it's sort of a trick-taking game sort of an auction sort of set in a fantasy universe and it has a bit of a learning curve I mean how do you sell this stuff how do you get customers interested how do I persuade people to play it with me aside from asking them to just trust me you've just got to try it so I'm hesitant to place it too high on the idea axis and I think the execution is tricky too the game play is great welld designed and completely functional it's really fun in fact but it does have a few too many

layers of complexity which hinders its accessibility the terminology doesn't help and outside thunderworks built-in audience that Goblin setting is likely to turn off more players than it attracts ultimately the game sits in the middle of the Grid it's pretty good and if you think you've got a group for it I'd recommend picking it up but commercially I don't see it making a splash I do applaud thunderworks for their constant experimentation cartographers and role player are obvious highlights in their catalog but dawn of olos impressed me very much too despite being a little bit bizarre there's something to be said for treading your own path so if you enjoyed this review please go back and look at some of the others on my channel and I'll see you next time

Progress saved