Skip to main content
Loading video...

How to write better rules | Sen-Foong Lim

Transcript 8:55

a lot of times feeling outweighs mathematics in game design that you'll find you'll find this out if you're just starting game design you'll find this out pretty pretty shortly that yeah mathematical Perfection is a good place to start but it almost never ends there for all things it might end it for some things but for the really really important things that you want to have have great gravitas and magnitude to their gameplay experience you might need to swing a little wider than you know uh one two three cost maybe it's so 135 cost system now because that five just feels oh so much better to you know pay five and get this giant machine that you're gonna wreak havoc with or whatever your game is so yeah you know I think working with other people really does help to solidify your chops in terms of explaining games and justifying your decision so as a clinical therapist when I teach students that's my number one job is I have to teach them how to rationalize verbally rationalize or rationalize in writing your clinical decisions so that people who are you're working with understand why you're doing what you're doing um and the same thing happens in Game design it's like okay this is what I'd like to happen here's why and when you work by yourself you never have to explain the why and so you might

get caught down um roads that maybe shouldn't be followed but when you have somebody else has a check and balancing can you explain why and you can't maybe you shouldn't go that way or you know sometimes just a feeling might be good enough to say oh it's just the way I feel I think this would be better this way because and that goes to the kind of the statement that sometimes feelings outweigh the math of it all right that the perception of reality is often the feeling that you get from the game and we really are making games in my opinion as a boxed experience right it's a curated boxed experience that the designers want you to experience something very specific when they put it all in that box and sometimes math doesn't make the experience better it just kind of codifies it makes it into a hierarchy and then pushing that boundaries on that math now make the feelings much more visceral to the human who may not think in you know numbers as well as a machine does right yeah and then another thing I think you're bringing up here is something I've run into with having to write it down and having to explain it to another person in writing before you get to you know oh regarding the final rule book is so valuable because I can't tell you how many times I've created something that I thought was really cool but I could not put it into words I just

could not explain it in a way in writing that it made sense to enough people to say yes we're gonna we're gonna do this thing and knowing that early versus knowing that late is so so valuable and so I think there's so much you know to learn just right there yeah it's like planning it yeah go ahead if I can't teach it to a person in writing I don't put it in the game yeah I just cut it out like if it takes me and if it takes me more words in writing then it takes me in speaking to explain something to a person plus diagrams and arrows and things I usually try to cut it out of the game or design it so it's simple and it's like that's a problem we need to like simplify that uh because if it's confusing on paper to people who know how to play the game or to me who wrote the game or made the game it's going to become so much more confusing to people who are just picking this up for the first time right so we have to kind of stop assuming that people know how to play the game we have to maybe check our own Egos and say oh it's not because they're um they're not smart enough to understand the game it's because these rules are opaque uh or they're very convoluted or they're only necessarily necessary in like this very specific Edge case so how would I expect people to remember that I wouldn't remember that right so the idea

of empathy as being a huge design skill is really really important and one that I think is under valued if you are doing anything with design where somebody else is going to someday maybe interact with the thing that you designed whether it's a door or a game or a light bulb or whatever you have to have some empathy uh towards the end user right so this is why user experience ux is so important because your user experience may be different than somebody else's user experience but you should aim to understand how other users interact with your built product your designed product because that will by a large affect how they feel about it and their ratings of it and they're evangelizing of it or they're talking about it or selling it to other people right and you've seen examples of this just in in board games where you're like I don't know why this game is so popular and then people talk about it or explain it to you or you God forbid go play it and now you get it because it's the experience that matters not the mathematics of it that matter right or not the not the um nuts and bolts of it it's the holistic experience of it that make it so great so yeah there's there's definitely a lot to it about making things as approachable as possible having empathy to the players

for the players uh that it's not just this designer as this you know omnipotent figure handing down rules those rules have to be interpreted and understood and when they're not interpreted and understood in the way that they're intended to be things go poorly and my area of expertise is actually communication science right so um communication isn't just me talking to you right communication is when you Gabe have the same idea in your head that I intended you to have that's in my head that's communication we both agree that Gabe's shirt is very blue right do you agree I agree right then now we communicated right but when a designer is just writing rules we're assuming Communications happening but is it really it isn't if the reader doesn't have the same idea that you had in your head at the time for something like technical writing and rules writing that's very important for something like a novel not as important right because people can interpret words differently and that's allowed that's fine but if you expect your game to be played the way it's supposed to be played you need to make some real attempts at understanding how people on the other side of the rules will interpret those and understand those rules right so it's very important to test your rules that it's actually more important to test your rules than it is to test your game

right this is a situation where if you get something wrong in the rules potentially the entire experience is broken and it's not oh yeah the experience is very broken and that's the thing about these designer games these boutique games these games that have people's names on them etc etc they are intended with a purpose typically right there is some ethereal intent usually I know there's definitely pushback against that and mass Market games aren't necessarily like that and that's where most people have their first game experiences but they're simpler right but for sure I have an intention when I make a game and I have an intended experience that I'd like you to have when you play that game and if you don't that's not your fault that's actually my fault because I probably didn't communicate how to have that experience as strongly as I should have or as cleanly as clearly as I should have or could have and then maybe also I didn't design it well enough for you to have that experience because the design isn't just the game itself it's the whole package right it's a product now and we have to start thinking about product design it's supposed to just game design foreign

Progress saved