Die Macher Board Game Review - Still Worth It?
Transcript
hello welcome back to two ball games 4k a YouTube channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews playthroughs and we generally talk a lot of rubbish about tabletop games in a modern era today we're going to be looking at an ancient game there's been reprinted a few times currently being reprinted in its fourth edition and we're going to be looking at the game about German elections called D maka and in this game what you'll be doing you'll be playing it over the course five to seven rounds and will you'll be Charlotte there you'll be trying to influence the way that five to seven elections play out in the current and in the future and what you'll be doing you'll be trying to increase your party membership who'd be trying a increasing amount of meetings of your party get you'll be trying to crease the popularity and trends of your party and you'll be trying to match your party platform with both the state public opinion and the national public opinion and you'll be trying to control the media to try and influence voters in to vote for your pie so in this video we'll be giving you a very very brief overview the rules because this game has got a reputation for being a real complex based way so it would be giving you a very brief overview and the rules will be telling you what we do like what we don't like and then we'll come back and we'll tell you if democra is still worth playing today and in the future so if he knew aired in police consider subscribing to our Channel go and have a look at our playfulness we just recently done a full player play for this and leave a comment in the section down below and we'll see you after this
board games 4k so the market add your player we're not gonna we're not going to go into depth about it also it's going to give you a very brief overview of the rules because if you want to see how the games played we did a four tutorial before we played this a guide on the car play for Alice and and and that'll explain how to play to going it therefore so everyone takes control of one of the five main parties in Germany see well the Christian Democrats got a green pie you got the leftist party and all that sort of a super technical chopped get twenty five thousand euros to start with and you get one meet your marker in the relevant space and the board have divided up into various things so you've got the exchangeable wave that we put cars where you can exchange public opinion you've got the organisation bully with your pine membership you've got some discern victory people most of controlling maybe with certain elections and then you've got the national opinion which is gives you points at the end that game if you look at the main board you'll see that you've got an area where you got votes he got four different states they're gonna be available to influence any given time boy and this guy might be talking about a basic game they're not gonna be talking about a part so long that game it's emulation to the five elections and one of which is very much short say if you look at the board you got a spiced fear for your boats then you've got a spicy for your party meeting Marcus and you've got your trends which goes from negative 3 to plus free the main thing about this kind is that you'll be trying to match your pie platform cards with the state opinion cards and the national opinion cars and the way that you get votes is
you take the amount of media Marcus you got on a specific statement you'll add together the trend and the amount of policy platform cars that match the state opinion and then your your time set by the amount of media market again that's how many got should get an original the person with the most points will win the election they get certain amount of benefits based on winning the election like so might be the case sir you might go to swap out there's some opinion cards place opinion cards on a national election so this game takes place over certain certain amount arounds and they'll be a hit a certain amount of phases and you just go from phase number one all the way down phase number nine and then you repeat that four times and the fifth and actually it's just another score and thing--we so the first phase is that you will be determining who goes first or first player we do have a little auction whoever wins decides to use the first pathway so the second thing you're gonna do be doing is you're going to be performing your party platform conference and this gives you opportunity to swap cards out from your hand and you only have a certain amount of cards in your hand and change your pipe policy to maybe match of in a national opinion will the state opinion and you'll be able to swap them out and this in his face so next thing you'll be doing is you're going to be taking your Shadow Cabinet actions and everyone's got a hand of identical shadow cabinet cards and on this one you'll be able to play up to four and these shadow cabinet cards in your play you can play one in each active state these shadow cabinet cards have got costs you pay no cost and they range for 3,000 euros up to 25,000 and then they'll give you a benefit so you cannot have a move a media marker from one of these spaces on the state board or you can increase your party
membership put down state markers in it allows you to manipulate the elections and the thing about this is it's choosing when to play the appropriate Shadow Cabinet card and where to play it the next thing you're gonna do you're gonna be forming coalition's and you'll notice it on a shadow cabinet cards you a little telephone icon that allows you to place a coalition marker in that state and what you'll be doing in this one you if you've got a coalition marker in that state you and you share two party policies with another player you can ask them to go into coalition movie and it's up to them when I choose to accept and what you do if you got a coalition you'll be merging your votes together to get a more more chance of winning but your should you'll split the amount of featuring benefits and if you've got three things in common or if somebody else you can force them to cover to combination either so that's that's quite a nice little thing so you can ride on the coattails of somebody else right so the next thing you know you will be paying 4000 euros for to buy a media locker and the player who has the most media markers in in each state will get to exchange one public opinion card with a cart and Exchange Board and also they also immune in that state from the effects of any published polls which we talked about a bit so the next thing you're going to be doing you're going to be organizing your pub party meetings and this isn't this is why you get folks to be paying $1,000 each to part all party makeup meeting markers in each time just take the cues pay your money and talk a bit it looks it they're essential to getting votes like we said oh yeah so next thing you gonna be doing your gonna be put in one home card in each state and then you'll be auctioning off that pole carbine so you won't be
able to see what it is it's always in your interest to try and get control of these pole cards because they effects can be quite devastating oh it could have depending on where you come so you you will you do you you have a little auction you flip over and then you'll choose up to two of the criteria at the top if you want to publish a poll if you don't want to publish a poll you roll two dice and then you'll get how many party members and party members give you points at the end of the game the next thing you're gonna be done you're going to be stein at the last state and you'll be given the option of converting your party meeting markers in to votes and this is a sort of a way you could choose as many as you want and you'll use the equation that we talked about earlier and now people use a certain amount of I should be a lock down those votes early before the election takes place and you work your way around and then you'll come to the active state that you can evaluate it there and then you'll take all of the party meeting markers off the board and then your you'll calculate how many votes you're going to get so once you've determined who wins the election then you will score the election and we're almost done here the first thing you're gonna do you can be looking at a little card and you'll convert votes to seats and then you'll write that in the little box on a on your score sheet and it also gives you a certain amount of money at the end of the round so so votes as equal to seats and income you look at who's won the election and if it's a single party I get to put a media marker on one of the victory scored spices that they had to take one of the state public opinion cards and turn into a national opinion if there's a coalition then they both get to put out a media marker and a
national one and if a party wins by a nose which is sort of tie it rose on top then the person who lost by nose only gets to put a public opinion so it's always in your interests at one of a wimple coalition will win outright so then what you do you increase your pipe membership if you match your party policy with the national policy then you get your money and then you'll reset the board you just used it if you play the five I'm game you reset that and then you go again you just repeat these steps again and again again like I said it's a very brief overview and we'll also be listening for now if we I got us because it is a bit of a number but that's basically basically you play the Makah so what do we like about so the first thing we like about this game is the fact this one another one is massive epic games and the theme is it's very very original but it's I mean this game was designed by car honks me off in 1987 and it still hasn't lost any of this impact or penniless charm today and it's one of those especially if you play these seven round going as opposed to the 500k it is one of those going to takes five hours but you're you're constantly constantly constantly involved in the game and there are there are occasions where your brain does sort of get a bit it does switch off so it's one of them games is just like an endurance test as well as a test of skill and card and the card manipulation
so we love the fact that you are juggling all these factors in the present but also keeping an eye on the future elections because if you throw all your resources into the into the current election you're gonna leave yourself short for the elections in the future so you can't you can't do everything you you want to do at once so you've got a try and it's all juggle all these all these different factors you've got to try and control the media you've got to make sure you've got enough party meetings going on you've got to make sure that your trends are up you've got to make sure that you match not only the local public opinion people but make sure you match the national opinion and you've also got watch your opponents because they're there be the first like in real politics they'll be the first ones to come along and stab you in the back and slacking off to the media as soon as I win that public opinion poll so there's all these bullies bearing factors you've got concentrate on that now and in the future and you've gotta watch what you might sit there in either saw do so another thing that we really like about this one and it's it turned out for us at this game is no where near less complex or daunting as as we were led to believe I mean this guy's got a reputation of being one really complex untouchable beasts and you know we've played it before it's a lot shell but we dragged it out again because of a fourth edition but well no ever never look at democra and it's this time and it was it was it wasn't that bad it's a little bit we're trying to get your head around the thing but once you get the steps into your head you're just repeating such
rinse wash would think so don't be afraid of democracy if you worried maybe throw a playlist because you think it are not for major elections copy us it's not like that at all wait it's a very very straightforward simple game and yes don't be don't be disheartened or poor for people to say it's too complex because it's nice it's actually quite hopeful go and we love that about it so what don't we like about them so the first thing that we really really don't know we don't know ever or not this has been rectified in the fourth edition we're hoping it is well because we don't really do this when I hate to talk about a fourth edition this is the third edition the one that's available at the moment and the one that's most readily available imagine because the fourth editions on Kickstarter but we don't like the dice rolling in this because you know if you choose not to publish a poll you school roll two dice and then you're gonna get that many party members and where that converts into income and points in the game that could decide the game so if you if you win the poll option real cheap and then you roll those dice and you get to fries you've been increase your party membership might be up to eighteen point zero eighteen thousand euros and that could be the difference between winning and losing at the end of the game so the fact that the game could hinge on a series of random barrels that's no good so hopefully a bit too far down the fourth edition so another thing that we probably don't like about it and it's if we act on it wouldn't be a problem but for us we're never going to play the seventh round game because it takes five hours plus hours and if you you're coming into
this from having not played it ever then you're not gonna really sort of understand the nuances of a game and on your first play your second play maybe even if I'd play my C this is one of them guys you need to play multiple times in trying to get a five plus our going to the table multiple times in a reasonable amount of time is probably impossible for us it might be possible for you but it's not impossible for us to do so it's a shame we'd love to sit down and play the seven round game of demócrata where sadly I don't feel that's ever going to happen so another thing we thought like about us and we know this has been rectified in fourth edition and that's affecting the Cavalia games edition the poll cards bar there there's no there's no public informational podcast you blind bidding on a card that you you don't know what it does and so what's the lack of information and poll cards maybe exciting because you're taking sort of a blonde punt I think you need to have at least some sort of partial information or now and I know they've met to avoid this because you've got you've got at least one of the criteria on the poll card I'm filled in in the new edition but in the third edition it is it doesn't give you any information so you've completed blonde bidding so that's a bit of a downer but yeah it still doesn't mean that the poll card auction isn't one of the most exciting parts of Skype so yes a bit of a 50/50 so to summarise is de maka still worth it is it still worth playing is it is it worth back in that kick-start Nozomi kind of a Sakura but
is it worth picking up the third edition or fourth edition we don't know much about a fourth edition sir is it was still worth playing today we're gonna have to say yes it's an in this is without doubt an enduring classic fail I mean if you look at this comply it in terms of today's games this still holds up if this was released that that it still be a solid game and I know there's a little bit of dye rolling in this one look I'm a random element and the fact that you essentially - when it comes down to the card matching game so you're trying to match the cards you've got in your hand and in the tablo to your local cards and the National cards but you're such one manipulate the cubes on board I say so this is one of the standout classic yacht games of all time and the fact that the fame is very very rare I mean what we put my thinking about the other games always something that maybe 860 making of a president that's about elections but it's not really a same game so D'Amato it's it's a it's a stone a classic it's absolutely worth playing this one's been a fact that this is getting a limited edition reprint is testament to the fact this is a timeless classic and there are a few rules that should be ironed out in this version like I've said the the blind bit non poll cards the random element when you're rolling dice to increase the amount of party members you've got and also the fact this is just sort of a basically just cut matching cards that you've got something to other people and also those own poll cards can be quite devastating if you if you don't get old of them yeah wholeheartedly recommend Amaka it's not
quite a five-star game for those very reasons might be the full edition is a fast our game we're gonna keep this for four stars I think maybe four and a half stars it's a timeless classic it's still worth playing today and coal point smell finger serving food later you've produced a Thomas classic that will never go away it's gonna continue to be reprinted again and again and again so that's the Amaka that's what going to German elections sounds really boring but it's actually one of the best games ever made and yeah let me said if you new here please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment about the Makah down below gonna have a look at our playthrough for the tutorial and all that sort of stuff and uh yeah we'll see you next time