Dune: Imperium Uprising Review - It's Just Straight Up Better
Transcript
Hey, I'm Alex Radcliffe from Board
90% Dune, maybe 85% Dune. But then it brings some things new to the table. Also, by the way, I finally finished watching the second Dune movie, uh which this also kind of draws upon the the progression within the Dune universe. So I am curious, is there a third core set coming after the next Dune movie? Or they're just going to go with the expansion, the new expansion that's been announced. I don't know which way they're going to go. That is neither here nor there. Point is, Dune Imperium Uprising is 85% the core mechanics of Dune. It is deck building, it is area control. You are without No, it's area control. It's deck building and worker placement, and you're trying to get to 10 points as you try to manage your asymmetric character, as you try to gather the cards the market, arise in the various factions over here in the various houses as you try to go ahead and gain spice and play with the little spice water to solari game of trying to figure out the correct currencies and growing your tableau and ultimately being the first person to get to 10 points while engaging in the constant battles each round. Each round you're going to have a conflict, and those are going to give you a variety of bonuses, but those will escalate starting off a little slow and then giving you more and more points until you reach the third round conflicts, which can sometimes give you two or even more points. And with the advantage, with the addition of sandworms, even more points you can get out of a conflict causing an increasing escalation to this. Now, Uprising is going to bring a few new things to the table. The main thing it's going to bring is first of all, there are small iterative changes to the board spaces here. So, most of this will look very familiar to you if you are already a Dune player, but there will be some small changes going on. Secondly, as far as core mechanics, we are going to have the sandworms.
Sandworms are a new element introduced in Dune Imperium Uprising. You're going to need to get your hands on these hooks over here by going to this location, going to the Sietch Tabr, uh getting your hands on a hook token, which will allow you to take control of the sandworms when you go to the Maga Basin or the Deep Desert. Uh when you go over there, the Maga Basin, you're going to get the Maga Basin. That's a That's a whole different kind of pit of worms to get into. The Maga Basin or the Deep Desert. You're going to go ahead and once you have the sand token, you can either take the spice or you can go ahead and utilize your your your hooks to take advantage of a sandworm placing it into the conflict, which will help you out. The sandworms are going to be worth three strength compared to your basic strength two, but that's not the main hook, pun intended, of trying to get them. The main reason you want them is it's going to double the rewards you get in any conflict that a sandworm takes part in. So, whether you get first place, second place, or third place, you double the rewards you get if your sandworms are present, which can be very compelling. Again, even second place bonuses doubled are huge, but getting first place bonuses doubled, especially in later rounds in the game, that is absolutely huge and game-breaking because you can get a ton of points from a single conflict if handled well. Now, the sandworms can't get into these three areas over here. This token blocks them from having access. So, certain conflicts, I probably have a few in this deck. Let me see. Certain conflicts over there. Go right there. The Battle for No, yeah, the Battle for Arrakis. If we are taking place over here, that's going to prohibit sandworms from taking part in that conflict unless we've broken the wall, which you can do for a variety of effects. This is going to be one of them, but there's other places you can break the wall as well. So, basically, sandworms introduce a new element in conflict uh trying to get your hands on
them both for the increased strength they provide as well as the increased bonuses. That's already a pretty big difference to the game, not necessarily to the rules overhead, but as far as how the game is going to play out. Then there's the spies. Spies are going to be another element to the game that add a huge element to it. Spies are tokens that can go onto various spots. Wherever you see this little area, you can place a spy. And it has two effects. The first effect is that if somebody is already in a location that you are trying to go to, you can recall your spy to go to that location as well. It gives you access to spots that are otherwise blocked. And in this game, if you're relying on certain spots for your strategy, having another player go there can break what you're trying to do. And so, it's incredibly important to have that access. You can place out spies through the espionage space, but a lot of other effects will allow you to place out spies from character abilities, from intrigue cards, from rewards in combat. There's going to be a lot of things that are going to allow you to place more spies onto the board. The second thing you can do with a spy is you can recall that spy in order to go ahead and draw a card before taking the rewards of that space.
So, again, whether it's more cards into your hand to be able to use for their effects or for their end-of-round effects, or alternatively to be able to guarantee access to a location, spies are important. They're also important because we have a new symbol on various cards. Uh these cards basically in Dune are going to do one of two things. You either place a worker along with a card, taking the effect over here, and these spots over here determine where that can work it can go, or if a card is in your end is in your hand at the end of the turn, you're going to get the bottom effects instead. And this spot over here allows you to place a worker where you have a spy. So again, getting spies out can allow you to guarantee access to a very variety of locations both even if somebody else went there, or alternatively just because you have cards that allow you to place your workers where your spies are currently at. And so having these various spy locations are incredibly key and it's going to be one of the big changes that Imperium Uprising brings to the table.
The other big change is going to be the Choam module, which you don't actually have to have in your first game. I think they recommend not utilizing your first game, but the Choam module effectively is these contracts that you can get from the dutiful service, you can get from accept contract, and again as always from a variety of other places. But when you go to these locations, you're going to take a contract, and that contract is fulfilled when you go to the matching location. So when you go to the specific location on this, the starter card in this case, you're going to be able to go ahead and recall an agent. You get the bonus on that contract, and then you flip it face down. There's a lot of effects in the game including cards that will get stronger the more completed contracts you have. So it's both good because it gives you an incentive to go somewhere and get a reward, but it's also good because it can power up other effects in the game. So that Choam module is going to give you another big change to the game. There's a lot of other smaller things going on, a lot of other small changes again to the board, to various cards, even to the basic cards that original Dune had like this wormhole card. I can't remember it's called, the card kind of let you go anywhere and discard it. Instead we have prepare the way, and we still have the spice must flow. So there's small changes to a lot of the basic constructs, but for the most part, those three main changes, the sandworms, the spies, and the Choam module are going to be the main impacts you're going to get if you're diving into this and kind of trying to figure out what are the main reasons to look at this versus regular Dune. Which brings me to my review.
It's better. I don't I don't have a ton to say about this. This is basically Dune, but better. Which granted a lot of people told me over the two years that I wasn't getting this game tabled, but I just hadn't gotten it tabled. I was totally content with the original Dune, and I heard this was, you know, solid, but like I don't know. Whatever. I just didn't get to it. Uh now that I've gone to it, I don't see a reason to play the original Dune. I just don't see any reason at all to play the original Dune. There's nothing This everything this game does is included in the original Dune and Dune Imperium. Uh but it's just better. Like the sandworms are an excellent addition to the game. I guess theoretically, you might not like the doubling of the bonuses. That can feel very, very strong. For me, it's just another thing that other players are vying for, and it gives you such a huge like push not just in the combat, but sometimes making sure that the person doesn't win a combat with a sandworm involved because they'll get too many points. So, you have to win, you have to really commit just to deny them those two points they're going to otherwise get. And so, the sandworms provide a nice degree of bump to the game. It doesn't shorten the game. It doesn't like Again, I don't I don't measure all my games, but from a feeling perspective, it doesn't feel like the game is shorter. I just feel like the game has an extra element of combat to be mindful of. The spies I love. I love the spies, the way you get to put that kind of guaranteed slot. Again, if your strategy relies on going to a certain location, having a person kind of ruin your game on that turn by going there, which is something you have to account for in regular Dune Imperium, but it's nice that they kind of have this get-out-of-jail-free card. You can kind of try to prep yourself by putting a spy somewhere. It guarantees you that spot when you need to go there. Again, it's a nice strategic bump, and if you don't need the benefit, you can still pull it back and draw a card. Meanwhile, there's a whole deck of cards that can lean
into. In fact, uh the Princess Irulan No, not her. She's not her. She's another character. There's another character I can't remember. There's the sister or whatever it is, who like relies entirely on spies uh for her placement. She can get a lot of benefit by placing other spies on the board. And so, you have to have characters that lean into these different new features. And so, overall, the spies are a very solid module. Again, a nice great way to add to the game. Similar with the CHOAM module. The CHOAM module, the game recommends not using utilizing it for your first game. I don't see it being that complicated. I don't know why it does that, honestly. It feels like the trauma module feels like it naturally fits into the game. It does so with minimal rules overhead. It's like two paragraphs of text, and it's very intuitive. I don't think it's complicated either mechanically or strategically. I don't know why the game recommends not using it. I would say especially if you're new especially if you're not new to Dune, there's no reason not to use it in your first game. And even if you are totally new to Dune for the first time, I would still recommend using it for your first game.
It's I just don't think the rules overhead is that high. Granted, I guess the one part I can't mentally put myself into is if you're not familiar with the locations, maybe that means you now have to spend too much time looking at the locations whenever you see one of these. Again, it's not it's not I don't think it's information overload, but I have the privilege of only encountering the trauma module after having played regular Dune Imperium a lot. So, maybe maybe there's an audience where that element is the the bridge too far. I just don't see it personally. But other than that, Dune Imperium Uprising is fantastic. The biggest downside of it is it kind of makes the original Dune to me at least a game that I don't see why I would ever recommend when I could recommend Uprising instead. That is the biggest downside of Dune Imperium. The games are not really cross-compatible. They're compatible with the various expansions. So, if you have Rise of Ix and Immortality, they all work with their respective Dune Imperium or Dune Imperium or with Dune Imperium Uprising. So, if you want a variety of experiences, you can I guess continue to play it. In fact, I'm curious. Let me know in the comments down below if you've played both and have both, do you still play Dune Imperium? Is do you find any reason to dive into it? Because for me personally, it's not that I feel Uprising is essential. I think if you have Dune Imperium, you are already playing an excellent game, especially if you're playing it with the Rise of Ix expansion. The biggest thing I'll say about Dune Imperium Uprising is I always felt that Dune Imperium strongly benefited from the Rise of Ix expansion.
I felt that it strongly added that extra element that the base game, while still being a top 100 game for me, it was kind of at the tail end of my top 100, and upright Rise of Ix bumped it up heavily for me. Whereas my first few games of Dune Imperium Uprising where the base game alone before adding any expansions and I felt the base game alone was enough. That's almost the biggest difference right there. The base game alone of Dune Imperium Uprising to me is almost comparable to the experience you get out of Dune Imperium plus Rise of X. And again, you can still add Rise of X to this. I've never I think I've reviewed Rise of X on the channel. I think it's phenomenal, highly recommended. Uh I don't believe I've reviewed Mentats officially, but my short two cents on the Mentats is to me it's take it or leave it. I don't mind playing with it but it's it's not an expansion that I feel is necessary and I play without it probably more often than I play with it. But it's still nice for the variety it brings. That's basically my two cents on Dune Imperium Uprising.
As far as final thoughts, Dune Imperium is a five out of five game for me and Dune Imperium Uprising is very much a five out of five game for me. This is an excellent addition to the genre. My biggest critique is it invalidates the previous game at least as far as my own opinion. I just wouldn't recommend Dune when I could recommend Uprising instead. That's basically it. I mentioned at the beginning of this video that All Play is a channel sponsor. If you go to allplay.com, you can find a variety of games both from All Play as well as their partner publishers. And if you're in the US, you can get them for $4 flat rate shipping for any number of different games. While you can't find things like Dune Imperium from Uprising from All Play themselves, you can find Wonderland's War from Juicy City Games if you're looking for a very different kind of area control game that is definitely for If you're a fan of Dune, you might enjoy the heaviness that Wonderland's War brings to your table. In any case, until next time, I'm Alex from Board Game Co.
Hope you found this video helpful and as always, I hope you have a good one.