Mischief Review - From the Designer of Arboretum
Transcript
hey everybody today I'm taking a look at a game called Mischief which is going to be launching on Kickstarter on the 1st of October 2024 now this is a two to four player card game that takes around 30 minutes to play designed by Dan casar who is most famously known for Designing arborium which is one of my favorite card games of all time now before I get started on my review of this prototype edition of Mischief I want to give a shout shout out to the show's sponsor kendra co.uk who are my goto online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order okay so before I go into the setup here please be aware that this is a prototype copy of the game uh the final version will come with a board instead of these cards and also some of the card Anatomy is going to be uh changed slightly to make the actual pertinent information a bit stronger and a bit clearer um as compared to this prototype version but this is what the setup is going to look like um depending on the player account you're going to have a number of these cards which depict these different kind of suits that are going to be uh in the game so each of these cards which represent these tables um come with two different types of cards associated to it like a light side and a dark side so you can see in this table we have the Centos and the saers um on the same table and in each suit there's
going to be a card numbered from 1 to 5 and also next to each table there's going to be a face down card from the main deck which are going to get revealed as the game progresses and on each one of these tables there's going to be three tokens um two of these protection tokens and one of these kind of prank tokens um of each type there's going to be an invitation row to the side um of the board which is going to be extended as the game goes on and these cards are revealed and also these other tokens are going to be important for endgame scoring so at the start of the game you're also going to get given 13 cards which is going to be your entire hand of cards through the entire game and some of those cards are going are going to get taken out of the game as well so that you do not have perfect information okay so let's talk about how the game works and naturally as you'd assume uh the objective of the game is to score as many points as you can by collecting these tokens but also by having influence over the final arrangement of the table so you can see here that the game works in a somewhat tug-of War style way where each table you are going to be splaying out the cards matching that particular type so you can see the saes at the moment have an influence of three as compared to the centor zero so again at the start of the game you're going to seed the board somewhat but that's going to get manipulated as the game goes on and as well as collecting these tokens as the game goes on which will give give you victory points and there will be some
endgame victory points that are going to be quite a significant factor in terms of the scoring so the way the game works is actually very simple where you are going to play a card from your hand mandatorily and then after that you can choose optionally to swap any card from your hand with a card from the Invitational row so there's only one at the moment um but you know that might extend as the game goes on as I'll explain so it's going to be difficult to um do this with their any kind of intelligent thinking because I'm just kind of winging this but let's just say I wanted to play this card here just because it's at the front so this is the four dwarf card so what I'm going to do is I'm going to have a look at the uh the four S where the dwarfs are and I'm going to play this card matching that spot so like this now this actually triggers one of the ways to gain a token because if you ever play a card or or have a card that's higher than the card you just played on that arrange so you're going to do what's called like a protection so the four is going to protect the five threes protect the fours the twos protect the threes and so on and if that ever happens you're going to gain that protection token so again I played the four which protects the five and therefore I'm going to gain this two pointer dwarf protection token now if I was to do that again say for example I played a three dwarf which um I'm not saying I do have but I might do I would flip this one over and lock it in place and until that happens uh that token is available to be stolen because my opponent might want to play a three
dwarf and they'll take that token from me but again if I do two in a row or you know two without being broken by another player then I'm going to lock it into place and those points are going to be secured for me now the importance of a card being protected comes down to the next mechanism which is when you play a card of a matching number of the other side so you know let's say the next player chose to play this four uh troll card I'm going to have a look if there's a four on the opposite side which there is if you remember the the four dwarf I've just played and I'm going to eliminate that card so that would be protected if the card had a lower number than it on there so if the three was there then the four couldn't be eliminated so in this example I couldn't actually eliminate this five card because it's protected by the four so you're kind of working from the lower number up in terms of eliminating them but in this example uh the player has played the four troll card therefore it would eliminate the unprotected four uh dwarf card from the game and if you ever do that of course you are weakening uh the the dwarf state of play but you're also going to take this prank token and much like those protection tokens if you ever play two of them in a row without being broken by another player then you are going to flip over to the lock side and secure those five points in place now if you ever play a value one or a value five card then you are going to add the card next to it to the invitation row so let's just say this player wanted to play this uh one valued card next to the the centors they're going to reveal this card and add it to that row again
another option for me to swap a card from my hand with because if you remember the first thing you do is you play a card to one of these tables and then after that you have the option to swap a card from the Invitational row with one from your hand so you're going to keep on playing cards collecting tokens you know removing other cards from the opposite side with pranks until the board will look something like this where each player's collected a bunch of tokens and you've only got five cards remaining in your hand when you ever five cards left you are going to choose one of those cards to get rid of essentially just to dump out of the game so let's just say this person chose this one and this player chose this one to get rid of discarding them completely and then after that one at a time you're going to resolve these tables so first thing you'll do is you'll calculate the influence on them so you can see this one um the centors have a strength of 3 4 5 6 as compared to the saes strength of 789 so at the moment the saers are winning by a couple of influence points but this is where the cards remaining in your hand come into play because each player is going to have a look if they've got any cards matching that table and they're going to add that influence to those values so in this example um only this player has a card matching that table with the massive strength five card and these players this player doesn't have any at all so this is actually going to swing the winner of this table in favor of the
centors because now this has overtaken it with the adding of this strength five and if that happens or whoever's got a card matching that table and supporting the The Winning Side is going to get some of these Victory tokens and if the influence stayed the same as it was so say for example the saes won that won that influence B then you'd get the dancing side um as long as you had the lowest value in that particular card suit so you know if I had the one um saer strength I would guarantee myself these six points but because it flipped influence from the uh saers to these centors then you're going to get even more points um and i' get you know this 10o token like this because there's been a surprise um and that is going to come down to who's played the highest card to swing that infuence now in this example I was the only player to play um a card so and it was a five so I would get those 10 points but let's just say that my opponent had maybe the strength three card it's not quite as good as my five but they at least get a kind of um a runner up prize with these additional points so let's just resolve these remaining tables to get a help get a grip of how that rule works so this example you know the um the Goblins are looking strong compared to the Sprites no points at all but in this example this player has gone all in on the Sprites to try and swing the influence into their favor which they clearly have done now this probably wouldn't be an optimal decision to make but it shows you that and if you fli the favor from
the um from the Goblins all the way to the Sprites then this player because they've got the highest value card or in this example the only player with any cards of that suit they are going to get uh those bonus points again it's going to be a surprise so they're going to flip over and get those 10 points in this example there's no runner up either uh let's go to the dwarf and the troll table so in this example the dwarfs have a strength of eight compared to the uh the trolls 4 have we got any players that have the dwarf or the uh or the trolls no we don't at all so this table is not going to be rewarding any points at all and finally we'll go on to the Gnomes and the ogres so we got the Gnomes of a strength nine as compared to the strength eight of the ogres but in this example the this player has added was going to add another strength five to the Gnomes they've actually kept this one back just in case there's a backup as well um but still going to be stronger in favor of the Gnomes it's going to stay in control um yeah they're going to stay in control therefore they would only get the dance side of the token rather than the uh the prank side or the surprise side and that's how the game works really and now there is a slightly different rule where if you um get points based on that mechanism with the threes you get some bonus points for those threes as well um
because they're kind of in the middle of the uh of the suit um and at the end of the game you know once you've calculated all the scoring um you're going to calculate all of your points from your tokens as well well that's it really all your points from your tokens big and small and the player with the most victory points will be the winner Okay so share some thoughts on mischief and if you are familiar with arborium and you can probably tell that there is some crossover between these two games especially with that key idea of cards remaining in your hand being just as important as the cards that you are playing it adds a cool kind of Dimension Twist on the tug-of warar system where you can mislead your opponents into thinking that they're quite secure in um in making a certain character or a race of these fantasy characters um win the table where in reality you're holding on to those bigger cards and you can drastically swing uh the influence of that table especially if you are holding on to those four and five value cards but of course you could only ever have four left at the end of the game anyway so you got to be very careful about how you are using them and which cards you are collecting which cards you are spending but a really Dynamic and exciting endgame scoring system there now the hand Management in this game is very strong and particularly earlier in the game um you are somewhat overwhelmed with the decisions that you can make and how you are going to manage that hand of cards now which ones are you going to spend which ones are you going to swap when are you going to try and protect
these cards that you are invested in um to not only grab those tokens but also protect the suit that you are trying to help win at the table when is it worth trying to weaken your um or the other opponents or the other races Side by doing those pranks by playing those matching numbers do you want to it early and try and um eliminate the or make the other side weaker as early as possible but doing that might prevent you from pulling the wool over your opponent's Eyes by thinking make very clear that the uh the suit that you want to win and therefore they might want to try and piggyback off you and do the same thing so definitely lots of kind of clandestine lots of misleading and bluffing mechanisms going in to this one but I do like as the game draws to an end and bear in mind you are only playing uh eight cards through the entire game um you know your the clarity starts to become more and more clear and you know what you want to do and still the tension is really there because you're thinking know I've only got four cards I can keep back which ones do I want to play I want to keep them all but I can't um especially in two-player games when you have a quite a good idea about what other cards your opponent has and you can actually use that kind of deduction element of the game um to your favor but of course your opponent is doing the the same thing but without 100% Clarity or you know with the um with the elimination of some cards at the beginning of the game so lots of kind of synergizing um Dynamic decisions being thrown at you at all times always having
to know when to Pivot and switch from one side to the next and so on so yeah decision wise on the hand Management in this game is extremely strong as you'd expect from a designer of this pedigree despite being on the higher end in terms of its complexity level of card games of this nature maybe not necessarily in terms of rules overhead but at least in the crunchiness of the decision making the game does actually work at a very fast pace you're just smashing down cards they're going back and forth with those tokens and again you're only ever playing eight cards in this game because you start with 13 you end up with five so again your decision- making is um is coming thick and fast there's not really any scope to lose engagement and you know despite the decisions being there it does not drag its heels and it still feels like a filler game um do bear in mind that maybe the first learning game of this is going to be a little bit going to maybe the gears aren't going to flow so smoothly because some of the ideas here are a little bit different to some other games out there um but once you get the game flowing once you've got the a game or two under your belt it's going to flow quite nicely um and you're not going to have much issue remembering the rules Etc the player interaction is very solid in this game because again not only are you comp competing over these tokens going back and forth with those but also that final influence swing by keeping those cards in your hand and means you have to think about what your opponent might have and what they might want to do um additionally of course you are um
fighing over these communal cards and sometimes you might be discarding something that your opponent actually wanted so you have to be um considerate of that as well so all in all this game has a constant thread of play interaction throughout from a ction standpoint I think the game looks lovely you know I love the art style that has this kind of like fantasy oral aesthetic which I think is super Charming um again I have been completely reassured that the iconography will be a lot clearer in the final version with these um symbols being a lot bigger and again more easy to look at at a glance because you do need to know the race type quite easy because it's not easily to um to cross you cross reference the two and the numbers are fine but again the borders on the cars are also important because it shows whether it's going to be the you know the nighttime side or the daytime side of that particular battle but again with those small changes I don't see any issue at all again just make it a bit Bolder so you can look at the game at a glance again this box is going to be very different compared to the the final box again I will put the the final artwork on the on the screen now so you can see what the cover will look like um and again the final version will come with a board rather than these placement cards but all in all from a visual standpoint I think it looks super cool and unique okay so let's share some final thoughts on mischief and this is a very solid card game um I will put a strong caveat on it though that I do think this is the kind of game uh for
gamers you know this is a Gamers card game you're not going to have an easy time teaching this to very casual gamers or you know even people on the periphery of the hobby they got to find it quite jarring to understand all those different mechanisms with the protection mechanism um with the idea of swinging the influence whether it's going to be a surprise scoring or the standard dance scoring um you know it's a little bit jarring at times and it can be like you're um feel like you're pulling teeth in terms of drilling these rules um into other players heads but if you are playing this with more season Gamers I think it's going to flow relatively simply or easily um once you get going and once you get over that initial uh learning curve but this does again give me a similar feel to a game like arur but it does feel like distinct game in his own right especially with the back and forth battle over these tokens they protecting the cards and so on and I really do like all the moving parts of this one and the tight hand management only ever having eight turns through the entire game um is actually puts you on a on the spot and makes you or forces you to make very crunchy uh decisions from the get-go and sometimes you'll be mulling over your mistakes thinking I should have held on to that card or I shouldn't given that card up to the Invitational row where my opponent's just stolen it from me um and so on so everything you do in this game matters and it's very delicately balanced and based on how many cars or how many different um tables are in the um in play at any time and I really do actually like this game at two players I think it scales well but think two players is super cool because again you
can start bringing the deduction style of thing into play as well um because you have quite a good degree of accuracy on what your opponent might be holding on to and of course as more and more cards are playing that picture becomes even more clear but not 100% clear because there are some cards taken out at the beginning of the game but again this is a Gamers game if you have a big card game collection I think this one could fit in quite nicely um if you like arborium you're probably going to like this but it's not going to be quite as easy to table for those reasons but still it's a it's a solid design and I'm really grateful to have the opportunity to play an early kind of the game earlier than it has been released so um yeah I do I do recommend it give it a look if you um if you like these styles of card games but be aware that um you know it's not going to be the easiest game to teach to casuals or even people who play a lot of card games they might find that first game or two a little bit jarring in terms of how many rules are thrown at you and not not necessarily complex rules but maybe some rules that aren't so intuitive when you initially hear them especially when you throw in some of the terminology of the you know surprises of the dances um of the like side the dark side and the idea of doing things on the bounce and locking things into place and exceptions and so on but um still I don't want it to sound like it's a mess of the game because it's actually mechanically quite smooth just play a card um and swap a card if you wish to but again those decisions do come thick and fast in
Mischief so I'm hopefully you have enjoyed the video if you have please be sure to hit like And subscribe to the channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye all