Feudum: Discussion
Transcript
everyone welcome to the discussion for udimm who two points ah I had a bit in my head that I was gonna do if I had lost but I wasn't gonna tell any of you and I was gonna like totally rage quit like at the very end if I had lost like I was legitimately gonna like act like I was Superman and walk out and then like I was hoping like I was getting so cat so she could like awkwardly do that wonderful whatever time it was in my head and I'll do it'll be so funny and everyone will think it's real because it it was it's probable but anyway then I was bad at the game this time well so I got well only because we did the regions incorrect last time the end game scoring four regions so not even in game scoring that epoch scoring four active regions we just kept doing uh-huh like every location that you had so uh you kind of played a first half of the game daelin and I played and Josh and cat played a full game the other day with a few rule mistakes and kinda I played a two-player game probably like the first two epochs we didn't finish a full game I let's sort of things we don't like combat I was like yeah um these monsters in this particular case I don't think the Dafydd made the defending player should win on a tie and it's mainly because like I can
understand not wanting one pawn to be able to take out one pointy but two pawns should always be able to take out one part right so that kind of ties into my complaint where it's like the game is called few them and it leads you to believe you want few times and I'm under the impression that you don't want them like in my opinion having a few dumb while yes it holds you get to the deal it gives you a if you want well gives you one guild obviously but you lost because of your few them well that was just a Lowell that was a slight oversight you had to and I mean there was only an oversight on my end if I did put a second pawn there like an idiot you would have lost eight points actually you would've lost technically more no you really lost four in the nine you would lost 13 when I went down somewhere else after what happened I mean potentially but there was no one else he probably could have done that where they like it works anywhere it happens I got level oh yeah I just like you just toss the servitor right face is one of those things where if you have a few them you have to work that much harder for right little to no payoff I mean yeah you're you're Noble or yeah yeah you're not you're Noble you're your church few time I mean they basically cured me a whole whole deal a lot of the points well I say well I was just running one poll on man I'll write it feed the one bond right kind of worked out for me for a while right so I
mean it holds you won it also it makes you a target more or less thing on who you're playing with
my attack be one it doesn't - defense like no and then if you have a so if you have a subject there that also increases your defense but also by the surf there it makes it a repelling surf and I can I think few domes are easier to attack honestly my draw one more attention right so that's what I mean that's what's my opinion um I think the risk is greater than the reward because you only get three points again and you have a potential now you have to really doesn't it collected the entire game you ever potentially lose 22 points don't attack anything luckily they do give you three ways to get on here either the way you did it start the people which does it but it scores you know points conquering upon scores you two points and goes on there and conquering a few them gives you four points and and put on here but you have to decide actually the reason why you couldn't even ever done this because you did the track you only ever have three three disks so you either have to decide you wanna go on an epic voyage review one at Concord that was me that was actually inevitable once he went on there and you can't pull that off so so yeah you guys don't have to go all war if you want few times or I don't know you think it balances now I think about it I think if you own a few you have to work much harder to maintain it but also since you're not scoring cuz three stars is a lot right I'm grant there are ways to outdo it if I had a Nobel on the Nobel damn it a monk and I had three outposts no you have to have
tiebreaker no no you have to have one of the primaries before you can give secondary I can't just have five outposts and own the guild if I have a pawn that was the monk in outpost would add to that gotcha so I think it does balance itself out for the fumes I think we were just not being as aggressive as we probably should have been yeah when looking at like the guilds and being ahead of a guild and stuff like that right because I mean looking at it it made a big difference in points I didn't really go for the guilds like I did last time which yeah and was like six to eight point difference plus you know the pushing and the pulling that you guys were able to do wait I just wasn't aggressive with it this time and I think that if I would have been more aggressive or gotten a few them right I would have been able to compete more on that right I mean he had a good set of them where he just kept doing this right the entire time and the way the Rose beats come out is you're essentially going to like you're always going to get max points I mean really like I don't think there's ever a time where you didn't get six points off of that which I mean I want to say it's unfair but it's really not like all I had to do was from this is just take these three and make seals and that's six points right from that all cat had to do was [ __ ] make vessels are better which I ended up doing for her to get
the six points and the three times from the feast and then all you had to do was pull over there and then it's just like I think the guilds are very ingeniously interconnected and I like it a lot because I was looking through forums today and a lot of people were saying that some gills are overpowered when they're not I don't think there's a single guild here that's overpowered in any way because all of them rely on resources all of them rely on each other right at some point it's like he couldn't do this anymore because he had no seals and he relied on me to push them over there the only thing that I would say that maybe needs to change if before not reading it incorrectly is on on the card here it mentions being on three six or nine scores or a sum of five eleven or seventeen this means it meets that they're higher I think then it should be exact because that gives well I think oh I'm saying in my opinion well you're saying if we're reading it incorrectly which right no what I'm saying is I think that it should be exact because that gives them to know to push and pull and do things right and otherwise you're just gonna keep pushing beads on you're always gonna get max points and that doesn't right I think if they did that and say that leads me to
my next complaint like I just said I really like the guild mechanism here a lot but it does have its downsides like you said it would promote okay you need exact well first of all you wouldn't be able to get exact three anyway because there's no there's no one's right so they don't have to tweak that but there is not enough in a four-player game anyway which is a lot of people definitely not and three definitely not into there is not enough pushing and pulling right within the guild is how with how integrated that is to this game like you have to like there's not enough Paul to go out to be able to constantly have a flow of guilt which I guess you can make the argument that that makes that creates variety and also is more instead of behalf kudos oh yeah it's like we'll find if no one's gonna frickin pull these and then I'll make a few them of that right um yeah I guess I guess that's true I don't know there I I think ultimately it comes down to it if a game ever needs an example of how to do balance to the in degree this is a good I think so there's really not a whole lot that's not properly balanced right I mean this game has a seven point seven out of ten on BoardGameGeek I I think it ended up being one of those games you either love it or you hate it there's no like in so so with but I mean I've
already said it's okay move on it but whenever you're looking at like a complete like balance of everything like I was sitting here my strategy and I still felt it whenever we played the last time I was like every time we started this game I've never had an idea like and that that was the same here like could you you were winging it for the most part I was playing a part I was like I want to be Nobles and just [ __ ] but religious that's who I'm gonna be that's all I am like [ __ ] that side I'm all about Jesus and and the church close family so it's gone yet exactly they're one in the same the Trinity had said um yeah and then I don't know what your strategy was okay so I cold place is going influence I guess influence yeah so like there are some secondary abilities that I either just I did I had wrong timing on but there are some abilities that like that's kind of shitty like my merchant like initially it sounds like a great idea Oh money is influence loan ruler I just pay a shilling and I take your spot immediately it's like influence nobody take it back it's like that was a wasted turn and a wasted chillin right you know so it was like okay maybe it just so
happens that every time I did that except once when I did it to Cap'n you guys did it maybe I just did wrong timing I could've done after you and but even then if you did it I wouldn't be able to take it because it wouldn't be a loan well I got like the merchants great if you want to spread it everywhere like say if they give people have distant colonies that they don't go to very often years coming as you keep moving go hop I did it again yeah that's true yeah that's a good point um no yeah that's a very good point actually because I can't argue against that like all I did was that or was stick around the place that you guys were sticking around and all the good nobility [ __ ] sucks well no wonder can you guys are hovering around your own areas we left this area completely blank which is different from last game where I spread that way I think there is second yeah and that's actually part of the advanced game like they have a basic game where you just ignore secondary abilities yeah which i think it would be we think this game totally suck yeah so I mean the primary is always going to be your merchant like oh okay well like I was moving around like I made I brought the knight in to actually try and take a sputum which which happens working I got some points from it well I mean it didn't matter you took a right back it sounds like oh well okay let's do this but see but now the places
that I had - could you have came in and put one and immediately taking it over with the merchant no you have to be a lone ruler okay so I couldn't come in and just up see whenever you have like a subject but then and like that makes an integrate like you can actually combo other abilities like I could have went there with a noble starve your person then like I say I'm with my merchants and then do his ability and then now you're you're alone which I didn't think of in the previous game so they they do have some combinations between cards which is very very smart make sure well so so that anyway so that brings it back to like my strategy this game like all I wanted to do was epic voyage I don't think there was a single turn there may have been one where I didn't move twice right and it hurt a lot to go that route because I last game I have funded some food like I all three of my pawns out and I was paying I was like cuz I own the merchant and I was able to move around and I just can't say I have a flow and I think I own the farm to the farmer yeah removing I was moving the park and I was like a like a farmer in here and I was just harvesting and you guys kept selling so I just kept pushing them to the merchant just kept buying food and then I had orchards which also also gave me food reminded one archery thing yeah so it's um so
it's interesting this one I was like okay I'm going to focus the epic voice this entire time but then I was hurting for food luckily I was able to I I moved a lot so I just kept filling up at pilfering uh let's see this is there's so much to talk about with mechanics of this game that I want to hit on everyone's opinion because unlike other games where is this like okay what do you think of combat what do you think of this there's a lot of integrated moving parts so what do you think of ease of play whoa mechanics the answer mechanics are rough yes they are that was a long like learning period yeah a lot of moving parts lot of [ __ ] going on so it's a heavy entry fee you know if you've got somebody that can explain rules simply which since sometimes does a good job of it sometimes goes untended oh yeah how do you think I did with this one it was okay I don't think you needed to necessarily read all of the cards like you did for me because that actually was too much okay but if you have somebody that could simply explain the rules and get you like a couple of turns and actually start playing I think that you catch on really really quickly you think like a dinosaur island kind of thing well a friend of mine with a game called dinosaur island tournament perfect now I did I was like why he plays a full round just something like a [ __ ] round that so I think in like and then they started over yeah yes he in my mind with ease of play okay
well first of all cat what do you think about he's a play that is a play once you get the hang of it it's fine but yeah there's a working order entry venturing to there's a lot to remember and later I this is my third time playing it um second time all the way through but I still had to ask questions right I was just like ah yeah it's one of those games that you can make the argument that it's like so I think what makes it easier at the same time you have to think it's to matically like me and they did a great job pulling theme into this game it's rich with theme because they actually made the rulebook it wasn't just oh you have another influence no they actually made its subjects surfing and ruler which made it somatically glow and everything almost makes them saltpeter for attack I don't understand that but everything else seems to really make sense loads maybe they use it for guns maybe but everything else is so interwoven together that whenever I'm trying to teach it is like if I try to do it simply I feel like you have a very unlike most games where it's a game figure I feel like you have a huge disadvantage if you don't understand the inner mechanisms of how all the guilds work and how your actions tie together because it's like hey pick four of these uh and most of them you're going to do over and over like guild action you're most likely going to do a lot and I mean defending conquer are very you know coincidental explorers also very sore neck once in a situational so that can
be a huge turnoff for this game is I like that so hard to get into it takes so long it's like hey I want to play this really new game give me an hour and a half to teach you like it's like a lot of people's like can we just play like five other games instead instead of T learning this game for an hour and a half and then playing it for an hour and a half or two hours probably more if you're rich really do people I wouldn't bring this out if I didn't know if you guys couldn't handle it right like if there was any like gateway gamers or you get like no way like I I'm mostly under the every game gun or exactly like I used to be under the impression you can teach anybody anything like gateway games for me I was like anything if it's our gateway game I can teach any of these this game broke that I cannot I can teach this no way any new player and you guys are gamers you figure it out so that can be a huge negative and I think that was it whose narrative and to be honest just actually seeing the card here and looking at both sides and have it a little bit of a point of reference to look at mmm makes it a million times easy absolutely you very first describe this game to me I was like oh [ __ ] I told me about it I hope like he plays it with somebody else and funny boy that's just yeah once
again we actually won't for you yeah so this is this does a really good job like one side you like I could teach the game then you can look at this like you made this very solid like you've almost won by two points just by kind of remembering a half game and then going off this I didn't have to like oh we're getting to you know nitty gritty on on you know the animation this does a very good job which thank God cuz any other to any other game would probably not give you one of these and then it's better there are some games that do this very well this is one yeah let's see so though ease of access I'm trying I'm trying to think of kind of where to go we talked about the guild mechanisms which are one of the heaviest parts what do you think of the actual like I guess I guess gameplay with the four actions and then the secondary actions on top of that do you think it works do you feel like like another argument you could make is that they did too much like it's like you didn't have to have the ruler subject surf you didn't have to add the [ __ ] you know little movement ways that you can even barely see anyway work it's Groot cat up one time I don't know most of the cards seem to have a very distinct purpose right the only one that doesn't is explore but
they had to have some way to get us those cards yeah so I think that either but you get them in so many ways you get them from being a journeyman yeah if you're a journeyman and you pulled if you fulfill you get three points and in a car gotcha but so I something I was like [ __ ] we did not have been necessary but it was a good filler car playable yeah whatever so I think everything did its job like it should and nothing really after playing this like four times technically at first I thought they just may had it too much you could have streamlined this a little bit more the game is technically streamlined like everything works it's not like I know this is kind of weird everything flows really well and but I feel like they could have simplified it there are things that could have been taken out that like the the ferry it's like where you either need to have that just happen just have the best if you don't need you'll need a ferry there like there's a lot of things that actually mean it but then they don't make ships like the very good but it's like things like oh we can look like I like say if somebody were to bottleneck it that gives you a new option yeah I mean I know I know you were saying last time that you didn't care for the stagnant locations that wasn't as bad I think that is mostly to do with the way I was playing last last time you never really improve and that and yeah I
just stay away from that area this time because it's interesting whenever you because they cycle obviously it goes I'll post to farm to town to few them and then a few them has to be destroyed like you have to conquer for them to bring back to an outpost right and then it is cycles that way and I think that's what changes the game because it's like if someone keeps improving to crap I don't need towns like I need farm so I need to make my way over to those farms or yeah I'll try and take your outpost so I can get these Explorer carts or these rural wit cards is what they're called Rick whatever it's hard for me to say god that's the [ __ ] so there's a oh so talking about things that they could like I don't think in a single game I've played those monsters have mattered um I was supposed to kill one but would you like it so whenever you pull three or more influence you forfeit three to take control I feel like I'm taking it if you were taking your whole that you would you would put three wait and you would get three and you would take one now what they do is they I place one plus one yes they are plus one plus one so they help you attack they help you defend they add to your movement and they block pawns so like if I had been here you guys couldn't use those pawns
unless you attacked and indeed them so right now like you wouldn't be able to move it they kind of blocked you there and you don't have to feed them because they eat people the residents the it's not just us there's not just six people in the world and then he that he does the same thing but he sticks to the islands over here now I'd be interested to see how this game plays with the expansions one adds windmills which I think bringing another resource one adds monsters and one adds a explain well I will be the first volunteer to problem not the I hope that you forget to you feel that for players is still not enough no I think players I would I would like this to get I would to have you played it with to I think for to totally sizes it's either four or higher it's it's garbage at lower players because literally nothing is happening like you're just racking up a bunch of points because you're all your guild masters like it's like why would I go for that to be journeyman whenever I can just freaking push things around it was awful that's why I think we only made it yeah - yeah we were like I didn't [ __ ] this I think I got it I uh I would think that I would just love to see these guilds like the mechanism I would like to see it like actually like work like they're constantly just they're so like going around just that would be a huge scoring game - I also know the injury even more cutthroat I think I have a problem with games a lot
of people or maybe yeah two players should be more cutthroat with beutel's something should balance out I think we're talking about balance earlier well cuz it's normally cats definitely a Care Bear player I am more aggressive Devin Steffensen definitely aggressive you see flop I would probably pin you as more Care Bear aggressive I got some Rollo god damnit righto hook but yeah it was like inevitable her office is like oh yeah I'll try and take a sputum that seems pretty cool there's just spawn bhangra that we're like oh yeah we just kind of left it alone I will talk to you a second time do you have this much saltpeter like you son-of-a-bitch
she was a mess it was a loving yeah and that's it that's the other thing I was talking about they added too much but whenever they work like as we didn't do a feast of the last game right it was super fun like he made the game like they thought other ways that I guess my complaints I feel like I want to see the the push or pull happen you can do it another way there isn't just one way to get something done they have multiple ways which is really really smart let's see I like the fact that there's a bunch of ways to get points like this is definitely a point salad it's like your harvest and defense will get you one point upgrading will get you a bunch of points if you do it a lot you'll also get landscapes which landscapes are really cool I like that making this I'm yeah once again they added a bunch of stuff that doesn't come in a lot but I guess that you could argue that that creates variety right but I like that because that's four points or resources but you can become it can peel fur I wish you could take your own resources like if you're harvesting instead of doing a freakin like partial harvest like you can also collect your own [ __ ] resources it's almost like you could Bulldog right yeah you could bolster it with beans so that you can choose to steal from it oh yeah especially yeah and no one no one did this I'm surprised you didn't you didn't buy any of these like and then girl they did so what they do is they just increase your harvest like if you look
at the harvest card like let's say you have a five or you could have gotten close to the four you could have drawn six and keep three and if you got a farmer to do it you got to look at the three you wanted so that kind of so you don't get screwed out of food or that's not points I can push over yeah that's true you just make it to where it's empty or but if you do a partial harvest you lose your like your your rosary beads they turn into seals yeah and that's which is still a good thing you don't just lose it do you have to buy seals right there was one thing and I do not remember but here okay here's another complaint and this one's really finicky and I'll be surprised because maybe disagree the guild leadership the guild master in the journeyman how you calculate that wall simple is like a constant thing you have to do yeah I don't think we ever did it I rise this well I'm doing I don't actively order you okay good because I was not keeping you know oh that's why I'm over there yeah because if it was like yeah that's true it's like okay well crap are we tied like I guess none of us ever migrated off like I was really - okay because we all we put our people on and kept them this entire game it's an ER well if you lost one person because I don't know but you never put anything back on which I was surprised and it's like well with my derivative
for that that's yeah that's true and it's like cuz my grading and that's that's another thing is you could argue for the good of a few time is yeah you don't have to do that or where you could have done you like oh I don't have to have a monk anymore my freedoms taker and you could have put someone else on you could have put a knight on and then you would have been journeyman because you would have tied with me but if you had held a farm which you didn't do but if you could have you would have had a secondary point which would have put you over me so I think that's a lot of strategy that comes into moving your pawns you don't they're not just I don't think they're meant to be stagnant like they're they're probably meant to build the fumes and then pull off rain and you just constantly cycle and battle for you them but in the multiple games we've done we haven't done that right yeah you pulled people off you dumped back but yeah it's still a consoling every time someone comes on offer or things change you can't wait okay did anything change there I don't know if anything ever did in this game I don't think so right but it is a very that's probably the most finicky part of it there's no real way to keep trying instead of stopping the game every time someone loses influence or puts a pawn on right okay let's calculate secondary stuff on top of it and that can be that they can be kind of annoying just just release yourself whether the fact that or it could affect
other people yeah last thing I got is what do you guys think of the bro wait cards the way the Royal with things that I completely ignored the whole game yeah awesome it would be fun if why it's like alternative to some text any text yeah I mean there's not a whole lot and there's only eight eighteen twelve sixteen well that's still there's sixteen cards yeah I mean it kind of I mean think they do once you play enough you're like oh cuz I drew this one I was like Oh either need to in my gap or three in my barrel I get five or seven points but I think this can definitely be a game-changer like I I mean it was a like a seven point swing last game how much are they worth well it depends like a lot of that there are two types there's the mandates which are instant like one-time use like this one I could have spent a wood and a food and got seven shillings just I just play that there's others other charters which you need seals for which unfortunately [ __ ] you kept okay but I mean not gonna just bought these and then do a partial harvest and then just get one but this one was I needed this side to get points and then some like cat as a goal oh yeah if you kill the monster then you get seven points or if you control how many regions you control to top others in here are weapons like this one give a little dagger which gives you
a plus one but if you have an iron you can get the you can spend it to get a sword which is - there's once to get basically last game I got a ship for a wood and I just say if I was time to I did that's what got me up there I don't know why the hell was going away I think my entire bill I was like I'll see if epic voyage is worth it I somehow came back in one uh but then there's like a crossbow here or if I do this one if you have three stars in any of these guilds you can get three Goods three showings or both so if you go this route you journeyman a lot or you you do that like these can definitely just give you a swing manage where you don't really have to try right this is like okay I've seven shillings now the 7i service I have 14 I bolted by the resources one of my favorite things is this times two cars I love that and I love the fact how you know I'm trying right use of these months this time like that was an average oh you didn't you did not use it that matter that was a tactic I've used it his whole game and he used it quite a bit with his guilt it's it's just it's awesome like the fact of how beneficial it is cuz you're not stuck like you're not like I guess I'll just have a throwaway [ __ ] card you know it's like right I'll do another good action you can always do a good action so it can be beneficial so yeah I can't think of anything else you guys got any last minute tip its on anything
alright uh skittle one the time oh [ __ ] oh really you didn't like it yeah no I mean it's your own like yeah I know it's which is why I'm getting into seven because that's what I said but I definitely don't want to play it anytime soon because now I know how to play it anymore but then after a break I can't honestly say that I just because the nature of the game but you know wasn't really even bored like I was engaged okay but real quick before you say one of the things I also love is the saltpeter and sulfur thing there's no reason for this token but that is a super beneficial to add another card or go play twice in a row so I'd give it an 8 and 8 yeah I mean there's just I would be happy to play it again there's just enough strategy in detriment to really kind of piqued my interest in I definitely want the expansion's I don't know that I would personally like cuz
like adding a sex player would be cool but finding six people to play this game itself because I know that each - Natasha notes on the play the monsters don't I don't think they'd make a big difference unless they were like had special abilities in which case what happens to adding a windmill like why add extra complication to a game that's already plenty complicated and has a lot - you can do so like none of the expansions really seem too relevant but I would definitely just give again I will mimic I don't you uh pretty well I like many facets I like the guild system just a lot going on yeah the injury it's pretty beautiful do you think this is more difficult than in a grenade I think in Akron he is probably the most difficult game that we've played other startup yeah it's a it's up there an Akron is definitely this one was very simple heavy as well and I still played through all this without understanding like those tiles what the [ __ ] are those I don't know that's right we do the whole game ignoring them that's true and you cut really really close all right I'm probably gonna give it an eight as well I thought about a nine but I think
over it's about the point of entry the point of entry is very difficult and I'm usually the one teaching it and after my how the play I'm [ __ ] brain-dead like it took me two hours to do that how to play but now it's become one of those games that we could sit down and easily play yeah and then it's always interesting because you want to try different things but at the same time there's a reason why it's not a nine because of that I'm worried that I'm good just gonna [ __ ] fail like if I try anything new now I know epic Boyd's does work but it could not it could easily just feel like okay it's only us I mean it's a 17-point sweet yeah that's it that's a lot of that's your action being used for move we're just moving not enough of doing anything else if anything was that's two cards that are not that are always taken yeah so potentially yeah two for always take notes and for six urns yeah yep and this game that's another thing actually a very good support this game yes this game is elegant and and uh and streamlined enough with a heavy I guess euro feel that requires a lot of people and it's shorter the more people you have yeah if you think about it find five people that's more people upgrading right as more people moving downhill slope yeah you start off slow and then all of a sudden you're at the phone yeah and but I love another game did the similar thing submerge where the players
kind of dictated the speed at the end we could have all chosen not to improve and the only thing that speaks of this game is this progress die which I love there's otherwise if no one did like improve they would just sit here writing again would be super long and then it would [ __ ] suck but the fact that they have this for it's like fine the game's gonna progress regardless if he wanted to or not but I love that tension where you're looking at it and it's like oh [ __ ] the game is almost over I do not have enough time to do what I want to do so you try and think I love that extra sense of pressure so yeah I'm glad you remembered to bring that up because I was a huge plus for me now I actually hate one 58.5 like I can think of another game that is also just as long to teach try I'm hearing to take six hours probably new cable no not to teach an hour hour and a half to teach same probably same length but the gameplay will last four to six hours even longer if you're playing with eight but yeah this they did a really really good job seven point seven total I know another reviewer did not like this game I don't know why and I was gonna now eight point five eight eight and seven let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time day is for you hey everyone thanks so much for watching this and if you like this video then click the subscribe button below to enjoy any video that I put out
and right next to that subscribe button is a little Bell click that so you get notified of whenever I actually upload these videos if you want to support the channel you can definitely visit my patreon page the link is in the description below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful with every time of day this for you